Back to: Outage report | Forward to: Quantum of Nightmares

Omicron

I was supposed to be in Frankfurt by now, but my winter break—the first in three years—has been cancelled (thanks, Omicron!) and I'm still at home.

Probably very few of you track Nicola Sturgeon's weekly COVID briefings to the Scottish Parliament, but I find them very useful—unlike Boris Johnson there's zero bullshit and she seems to be listening to the scientists.

Today's briefing was palpably anxious. Some key points:

  • 99 confirmed Omicron cases in Scotland (pop. 5.6 million), up 28 from yesterday

  • Omicron confirmed in 9 out of 14 health districts, community transmission highly likely

  • Doubling time appears to be 2-3 days(!) with an R number significantly higher than 2 (!!)

  • Scope for vaccine immunity escape is not yet known, although hopefully it's not huge. However, Omicron is confirmed to be more able to evade acquired natural immunity after infection by other strains—if you didn't get jabbed and think having had Beta or Delta protects, you're in for a nasty surprise

  • It's not clear how deadly it is yet, but seems to be comparable to Delta. However, it's much more contagious

  • Scottish government is advising all businesses to go back to work-from-home, everyone should mask up and socially distance in public, and everyone should take a lateral flow test before going out in public for any purpose—work, pub, shopping, meeting people

  • Scot.gov moving to review the situation daily as of 8/12, rather than weekly (hitherto)

  • And get your booster shot (or first/second shot) the instant you're eligible for it

I'm bringing this up because this is the shit that the Johnson government should be doing, and on past form will probably copy badly in about 2 weeks (by which time it'll be 5-7 doublings down the line, i.e. utterly out of control).

It has not gone unnoticed that a strain that is twice as transmissible is much deadlier than a strain with twice the immediate mortality rate, because exponential growth in the number of cases means it ends up with many more people to kill.

My current expectation is that Boris Johnson and Sajid Javid will—have already—fucked up the response to Omicron and that the English NHS will come dangerously close to (or may actually) collapse by Christmas. Scotland handled successive waves better, but will probably still have a very bad winter (our border with England is porous, as in non-existent). And we may end up back in April 2020 levels of lockdown before this is over.

1759 Comments

1:

It's not clear how deadly it is yet, but seems to be comparable to Delta. However, it's much more contagious

This is one thing where the opinions seem all over the map. I suspect it is due to lack of data. Currently in the US the government health wizards seem to feel that for any one case it is less deadly than Delta but given that it is more contagious there might be a lot more deaths from it in total going forward as more people will get it.

On a somewhat related note, has anyone done any studies of how this might change the death rates for vaccinated vs. unvaccinated populations and if in any one country will it make a statistical difference in terms of the total population?

2:

i'm hopeful about this variant. sure it's only 166 mostly young people in south africa we have data about, but if you look at the cases vs. deaths graph for the first time in 4 waves for them the deaths are not following the cases. it's encouraging. if it happens in europe we'll get rapid immunisation with minimal hospitalisation very quickly. it's a huge "if", but it could end up being the best thing that ever happened in all this

3:

So locally (Alberta, Canada):

Nov 29: No confirmed cases of omicron, monitoring 156 travellers https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/edmonton/kenney-hinshaw-covid-19-omicron-1.6266519

Nov 30: One confirmed case of omicron https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/edmonton/deena-hinshaw-covid-19-alberta-1.6268276

Dec 2: 4 confirmed cases of omicron https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/edmonton/alberta-covid-19-update-1.6271671

Dec 6: 2 Alberta schools have been notified https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/edmonton/2-alberta-schools-notified-after-new-cases-of-omicron-variant-confirmed-since-friday-1.6275120

Dec 7: 11 cases confirmed https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/omicron-surveillance-alberta-1.6275783

And obviously based on the fact that Alberta has the second-lowest vaccination rate of any province https://health-infobase.canada.ca/covid-19/vaccination-coverage/ (please note the NWT/Yukon are even lower but they're territories) I'm reasonably certain there's more omicron floating around than we officially know about.

Sigh. It's almost as if the last 2 years have taught us nothing. Our gov/healthcare system still hasn't officially acknowledged that COVID-19 is truly airborne (e.g. no N95 or better mandate for healthcare workers).

4:

There does seem to be a fair bit of evidence that this variant leads to less serious cases. In which case, the higher contagion could actually be helpful -- if it drives out more lethal variants.

5:

Covid-19 seems more and more like a triffid. So long as we can see it, it's not all that dangerous--compared with smallpox or black plague. When we go blind to it....

Sorry about your vacation though. That sucks.

6:

There does seem to be a fair bit of evidence that this variant leads to less serious cases. In which case, the higher contagion could actually be helpful -- if it drives out more lethal variants.

The nasty things about Covid19, as with coronaviruses in general, are: --Immunity fades fairly quickly, even to the same exact virus. Why is not clear, but any protection from this group is only temporary. The adaptive landscape the viruses face continuously drops toward "open range." The COvid19s and our immune systems are not in a Red Queen race.
--Viruses continue to mutate randomly, so non-lethal versions can become lethal again, as with the flu.

If we had long-term immunity, that might favor a Red Queen race between human immune systems and the viruses that might push the virus towards nonlethal and rapidly spreading versions, the better to get to the children and other non-immune people.

With Covid19, it may turn out that a few six-month boosts provide better and longer term immunity than 1-2 shots given close together. Hopefully. We'll find out over the next year.

If that's not the case and our immune systems always lose their antibodies to Covid19, then without continuous vaccination efforts, we slump back to the wide-open vulnerability we had in 2020. Unfortunately, I don't think that's going to select for a less lethal covid19 variant.

7:

Sorry, but you are out of date. It's ALREADY completely out of control. The reason that this isn't obvious to pretty well everyone is that the UK's (yes, UK's) testing regime is an utter shambles, and the published data reflects that; billions of public money handed to foreign organisations to do fuck-all.

Not merely have they stopped using PCR and sequencing on entry to the UK, they have done similarly to places like prisons and care homes. What's more, the test results come in erratically over several weeks (1-3, I think, but I have not analysed carefully), AND the data published by PHE is dated as if it were current but refers to the figures of nearly 3 weeks previously (19-20 days) ON TOP of the previous delay! But even the only 2-3 week old data published on December 3rd shows Omicron spreading explosively. We are probably 7 doubling times in already, starting from an unknown (at least several, possibly tens) number of primary cases. Say, 1,000 cases scattered all over the UK.

https://imgur.com/gallery/FphMSqR

However, there is some very inconclusive evidence (not just hearsay and anecdata) that it is not as lethal as delta, though we won't have any reliable data for a couple of months.

8:

My wife and I got lucky in that we went to Germany in October, crossing from Bamberg to Trier in the process. At that point we thought everything was gently easing off. We were wearing masks and having daily PCR tests.

We then did BristolCon later in that month, and everything was sensible, people at the convention wearing masks in panels and everything.

So we were pretty relaxed for Novacon 50 a fortnight later.

Which caused about ten people to get Covid, myself included, ages ranging from 50s through to 70s. Not recommended. So yeah, even if it were just (just?) delta, it'd be time to lockdown again. But a variant that seems much more infectious? Definitely.

9:

Unfortunately, I don't think that's going to select for a less lethal covid19 variant.

Is there an example of a disease that evolved to be more lethal?

10:

Is there an example of a disease that evolved to be more lethal?

Um, most of the lethal ones? They didn't spin out of the ether, they jumped into humans from somewhere else, then mutated to spread. Certainly Spanish flu and Covid19 became more lethal as they went along.

The thing to remember about viruses is they don't care about lethality. They don't care about anything. They're just imperfect replicators that randomly walk across a changing selective landscape by their trillions, and we deal with the ones that win whatever jackpots are to be had. While it's thought that some viruses have become less lethal as they went along, the evidence for this is fairly scant, so far as I know.

That's why I compared Covid19 to a triffid. When it sneaks up on you, it's really dangerous. With sufficient effort, it's a manageable threat. But it's likely to be a chronic problem going forward, not a crisis that we go through and put behind us.

11:

Do you have a link to her briefings?

12:

Um, most of the lethal ones? They didn't spin out of the ether, they jumped into humans from somewhere else, then mutated to spread. Certainly Spanish flu and Covid19 became more lethal as they went along.

I'm sorry, I framed that badly. After it's initial burst into the human population, has any disease continued by evolving so that it's dominant form ends up being more lethal? Spanish Flu no longer kills large numbers of people and I don't believe that the Delta variant is more lethal than initial COVID.

13:

Actually, the evidence that some become less lethal is pretty good, but it's not precise, and it's unclear how much is selection of the virus and how much selection of the hosts. Also, it applies ONLY to viruses that kill a high proportion of younger people in short order, for obvious statistical reasons, so current COVID need not apply.

14:

Is there an example of a disease that evolved to be more lethal?

I believe the second wave of Spanish Flu was an example. The second wave certainly killed a lot more people, but its not clear why.

One theory is that during the war soldiers with mild cases were kept on duty in the trenches but serious cases were invalided back to large field hospitals behind the lines. In the trenches there were few opportunities to infect more than your squad mates, but back in the hospital there were lots of potential hosts. Hence the war selected for the more severe variants.

However I find that the Wikipedia section on this theory cites Malcolm Gladwell as a source, and I can't find anything else to support it.

15:

Charlie Much as it pains me, I agree re. Sturgeon on this one. She's doing exactly the right thing & ( On this subject ) there's no waffling or bullshit.

Madam boss' employers have done the sensible thing, here: "No-one to come into our main office ( London EC2 ) unless they feel they have to - everybody else PLEASE work from home!" I wonder how many others will be as sensible?

I expect a severe lockdown about Mon 27 December - and yes, the lockdown could easily be as bad as the very first one.

David L It will sweep through the unvaccinated morons & brainwashed, same as in the US & everywhere else. I just hope that those of us who are triple-jabbed will manage OK, even if we do get infected.

H I predict yearly ( maybe even 6-monthly ) adapted-booster "jabs" for the rest of the foreseeable

16:

How is it that “Sorry” makes this comment much more obnoxious-sounding than leaving it out would have, especially because the actual content is pretty informative?

17:

H I predict yearly ( maybe even 6-monthly ) adapted-booster "jabs" for the rest of the foreseeable

We don't actually know what the best vaccination regimen is, because the testing period was so short. With a great deal of luck, it might turn out that 2 shots six months or a year apart provide long-term immunity. We'll find out.

18:

There does seem to be a fair bit of evidence that this variant leads to less serious cases. In which case, the higher contagion could actually be helpful -- if it drives out more lethal variants.

Wrong.

A more contagious strain with high R number spreads exponentially faster than a less contagious but more lethal strain. Whereas the lethality scales linearly. Upshot is that a strain that's twice as lethal kills twice as many people, but a strain that's only half as lethal but 2x more contagious may spread through many times as many people in a given period, and thus ends up killing more people overall.

See also.

Finally, COVID19 infection doesn't confer lasting immunity, and acquired immunity doesn't automatically cover new/unfamiliar strains.

Remember, human intuition is a terrible guide to exponential growth, and exponential growth is what's killing us here.

19:

Does it? Sorry :-)

I am way out on the Aspergers scale, and find it very hard to understand how people who are not will react.

20:

They're live-tweeted via @theSNP every Tuesday from 2pm. Then all over the news media. Not sure there's an official website carrying it.

21:

Spanish Flu no longer kills large numbers of people

Spanish Flu is influenza, and it still kills many, many people every year. That particular strain of the H1N1 influenza A virus burned through the entire accessible population and maxed out the kill: subsequently we haven't been hit by a random remix that's as lethal and as contagious, but it's only a matter of time. Note that the 1918-20 flu strain's mechanism of lethality is to cause a cytokine storm very similar to the causative mechanism of the lung damage seen in SARS-NCoV19.

22:

I've been telling my parents in Spain to be very careful this Christmas. Here in Quebec the government claimed two days ago (could have been yesterday) that there was no community transmission, which I translated in my head as "we're not looking hard enough."

Time-to-remake seems to be getting shorter and shorter.

23:

Much as it pains me, I agree re. Sturgeon on this one.

There's a reason for her sky-high approval ratings among Scottish politicians: she's been doing these straight-talking no-bullshit reports since the beginning of the pandemic, clearly listens to scientific advice, and does her best to base public policy on the evidence.

Scotland being part of the UK she is then routinely overruled by the likes of Johnson/Hancock/Javid/Sunak -- in particular, furlough/lockdown payments are throttled by the Exchequer -- but we have overall done a bit better than the other UK regions as a result of not having totally incompetent leadership in a crisis.

I expect a severe lockdown about Mon 27 December - and yes, the lockdown could easily be as bad as the very first one.

Agreed. And many more folks dying in ambulances in hospital car parks -- or worse, asphyxiating as hospital oxygen runs out.

24:

Until it reaches saturation, when the exponential growth stops. In addition to what you say, it's not as simple as a more contagious variant will eliminate a less contagious one, as that assumes the former gives immunity to the latter. We shall have some idea in 3-4 months.

25:

Thanks very much. For some reason twitter doesn't work at all on my main browser (firefox), but I could run another and look at that.

26:

Here in Denmark (population 5.8 mil) we carry out roughly 300,000 - 400,000 tests per day where all positive tests get sequenced. The first omicron case was detected on 22nd of November. Now, just over two weeks later, we have 398 cases in total.

We have roughly 5000 positive COVID-19 cases per day, with roughly 100 being omicron on 4th of December.

Today, the health authorities have made it clear that their attempt at containment has failed. Given how new omicron is they don't have the numbers to determine if it is deadlier, but one spokesperson has likened its contagiousness to the measles.

The spread of omicron in Denmark by day of test are on page 3 in the linked pdf: https://files.ssi.dk/covid19/omikron/statusrapport/rapport-omikronvarianten-07122021-1t6o

27:

Looking at today's headlines & news ... [ C-19 + everyting else ] I think BoZo's days supposedly "in charge" are numbered. Every single thing is covered in bluster, lies & incompetence. It's as bad as Chris Grayling, but with bad jokes & buffoonery. The appalling problem is - what piece of lying shit gets to step into being PM, now? One has to remember that the MP's only get to choose ... after the tory "grassroots" make a selection. So, Patel is out & so is Grease-Smaug, but whom & how much longer will this go on for? James II & VI - the last "leader" we had who was this incompetent & disastrous - lasted approx 3 years & 10 months, so ... mid 2023?

28:

What the morrow may bring:

https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-03619-8

Beyond Omicron: what’s next for COVID’s viral evolution

29:

Until it reaches saturation, when the exponential growth stops.

Except it doesn't stop if, like most coronaviruses, acquired immunity is neither comprehensive nor lasting.

In that case (as with COVID19) you potentially get an endemic disease with regular reinfection and an increasing cumulative probability of death or severe disability. Worst case, the cumulative mortality could hit 50% over 30 years, making it as deadly as the Black Death, if more drawn-out.

On my sunnier and more cheerful side, however, I see three targets in vaccine research right now:

  • longer duration of effect

  • broader spectrum of coronaviruses protected against

  • easier storage (ideally indefinitely in ordinary 2-8 degree vaccine fridges)

The first would mean we can go from six month to annual or maybe multi-annual boosters.

The second means we don't need new boosters against breakout strains, and may gain protection against relatives (eg. some cold viruses, SARS, MERS).

The third means it's far easier to vaccinate the developing world.

... And I think there's commercial demand (ie. profits to be made) from hitting any, much less all, of these targets.

30:

I think we're heading for either Sunak or Javid. Both millionaire libertarian banker types. (Wildcard: it depends how racist the 1922 Committee collectively feel the party base is.)

31:

Comment

Wrong

Well, no, not wrong actually. What you’re pointing to is the speed of the deaths, not the final amount. It assumes that the population is unlimited. But that’s not the case and in a population with an upper limit, the lethality matters more than the transmission rate. I.E., if the population is 1000 people and all of them get covid, the more lethal variant is going to kill more of them than the less lethal one, no matter how quickly it happens. If the less lethal variant spreads so quickly that it drives out the more lethal variant, then there will be fewer deaths overall.

Ie, in a population of 1000 where it’s 50/50 cases between two variants, one of which kills no one and one of which kills 10%, then you’re going to have 50 deaths (5000% and 50010%). In a situation where the non-lethal variant spreads to everyone before the more lethal variant can, then you’re going to have no deaths at all. That’s an extreme and speculative example, but it applies at lower levels as well.

That particular strain of the H1N1 influenza A virus burned through the entire accessible population and maxed out the kill:

Well, yes, that was my point: the Spanish Flu isn’t killing people any more.

as that assumes the former gives immunity to the latter.

Yes -- and we just don’t know what the case is here. The assumption that it doesn’t is just as much an assumption.

32:

I have had PCR tests for reasons. The typical time from test to (thankfully negative) result would be 25 hours.

33:

To be a bit less blunt than EC.

I suspect the UK has the similar sampling issues as the US does. The anti-vaccine folks in the US mostly don't believe they need tests as (well pick from 100 reasons) and so they only get tested when in the hospital with bad symptoms. So asymptomatic and mild cases in this population are not tested. Those of us vaccinated, especially those who did it because it was smart, tend to get tested before and after situations where we MIGHT get infected. And we are less likely to get infected.

So test results statistically are not very good are providing indicators of what is happening. We have something like 1/3 of the population that isn't vaccinated and is resistant to doing anything that might help out which creates a huge hole in the data.

34:

But it does stop growing exponentially. We are already in the situation where were have an endemic disease (with Delta), and it seems almost certain that we will have with Omicron (with or without Delta). And, I agree that we don't have a clue about the shape of the cumulative probability curve, though we DO know that it will be the primary cause of death in the elderly (miracle treatments excluded). Best case - it's not much worse than influenza is today. Worst case is as you say.

I am expecting to die from it within a decade or so.

35:

Yes. Before my hip replacement, I had one at lunchtime on Friday, and the results were in before 7 am on Monday. Yes, sequencing takes a little long, but not much nowadays. The reason for the delays is ENTIRELY for the political reasons I gave.

36:

Re: '... and we just don’t know what the case is here'

Agree - still too soon to say. Based on discussions on TWiV, reliable assessments of omicron are still weeks away.

About the African apparent 'low' severity:

Their demos are vastly different vs. EU/UK, NA, Asia, etc. -- far fewer oldsters, i.e., the population segment with the highest mortality rates for this virus overall. Not sure whether anyone's done a reweighted-by-demo's analysis on this variant but until that's done, we're not sure what the actual overall lethality of omicron is.

You'll have to scroll about a third to see this median age chart.

https://ourworldindata.org/age-structure

37:

if what little we know of the 166 patients in the tshwane district will be similar in europe's older population then updating the vaccine for this variant is foolish and counter-productive, leading for further variants that evade immunity. there was an extremely comforting article about long term immunity in nature in june that shows 95% retention of memory b cells 11 months after recovery from infection ("Naturally enhanced neutralizing breadth against SARS-CoV-2 one year after infection" second paragraph of the discussion section), but a june article is uncertain to hold true still. the authors of the article speculated years, if not decades of immunity. of course new variants could evade long-term immunity even then, but that's already much better than having unvaccinated and unexposed people around. the bureaucrats will push us to take more injections after the third but i see little evidence that this is needed just now. "twice as effective" seems impressive, but if you write 92% instead of 85% which is the exact same thing, it's just not crucial.

38:

Re: '... long term immunity in nature in june that shows 95% retention of memory b cells 11 months after recovery from infection'

Works for younger people who have stronger, more efficient (much more adaptable) immune systems, not so much for older folks or younger folks with iffy immune systems*.

https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-02532-4

'In Israel, for example, elderly people who got their shots at the beginning of the year seemed to have almost double the risk of severe illness during a July outbreak compared with similar individuals who were immunized more recently7.'

E.g. folks with diabetes, an inflammatory disease, currently or recently in cancer therapy.

Not sure how this is exactly relates to the above re: b memory cells, but ...

https://www.cnbc.com/2021/12/06/who-strongly-advises-against-convalescent-plasma-for-treating-covid-patients.html

39:

My forward-thinking manager said ‘I don’t want you on public transport’ some time in Feb ‘20, and I’ve been back in for a couple of days since - and we’ve cancelled the long planned team meetup.

The one time I went to the pub to socialise - October - someone at my table went down 4 days later and we all got contacted by track-and-trace. We missed a gig last weekend - as my wife was ill, and being responsible didn’t want to infect other people - but we saw the notification after saying, ‘we suggest you get a PCR test’.

And I’m looking at things I want to go to - and not going - while knowing there is zero financial support for the artists and promoters.

(I also suspect there is a horrible spiral where indoor crowds in stand-up venues become increasingly made up of risk-takers, until it becomes a dead cert)

I do expect a chilling effect in 2022 - anyone planning or budgeting in the performing arts or cons next winter is going to be very risk averse.

Assuming they haven’t been sent to re-education camps to be retrained a pig-slaughtering HGV drivers.

40:

What all of you optimists except Charlie seem to be forgetting is that long COVID affects 15-80%* of all cases even the mildest. There is already evidence that having had beta or delta COVID doesn't protect you from having omicron, although it may result in milder cases, but then you are back to how much damage can even the fittest of the young take before we see loss of organ reserve that impacts on quality of life then life.

  • I've seen estimates of 80% although I don't think they were as reliable as lower estimates, however given that the damage that has been assessed is caused by micro clots it's quite possible that we are not seeing all the damage that has been caused. After all we know eg that you can be perfectly healthy with less than 50% of kidney function, so there is a lot of organ reserve that can be used up before we realise we have another health crisis on our hands.
41:

The problem with the Spanish Flu is that it currently does not exist, possibly outside of someone's lab.*

Another lethal H1N1 flu could easily re-evolve, and then we'd go through the same sorry mess all over again. Although the second time around, I suspect that the Anti-Mask League won't be in San Francisco.

That's the problem with viruses: it's roulette all the way down. The Delta strain is unlikely to be an offshoot of the previously dominant Alpha strain, while Omicron is not closely related to either Alpha or Delta. It came from somewhere else. This makes it tricky to predict what will happen, because it's not a coevolutionary duel of a common virus strain against human immune systems, it's a chaotic and possibly multispecies landscape wherein viruses that are harbored in one host for an extended period, or in another species, ultimately emerge with a substantially new genome and new properties.

Finally, even if SARS-CoV2 becomes just another cold virus, the more they dig, they more they find coronaviruses very much like it in South East Asia and southern China. We're the new frontier and pathogens are the new settlers. Do they strike it rich, or are we too inhospitable. We'll see.

*It's been recreated as a research tool, I believe.

42:

Google news just served up the following headline from Faux Newz:

COVID-19 spread more by men, loud talkers: study

Since it is Faux Newz, I didn't follow it any further than the headline ...

Got my booster a week ago yesterday. I've been wearing a mask whenever I'm out & about - which ain't much - doctors' appointments & grocery shopping plus a trip around the corner to the big 'ol Baptist Church's parking lot to set up my big telephoto & photograph a hawk sitting atop the steeple.

I wish this shit would go away. It's been almost two years with minimal human interaction and even with the little dog & some Zoom meetings I've been feeling kind of lonely lately. You guys have been a lot of help, but it's not the same as getting out and spending time with people.

43:

What was the hawk?

44:

David L @ 1:

It's not clear how deadly it is yet, but seems to be comparable to Delta. However, it's much more contagious

This is one thing where the opinions seem all over the map. I suspect it is due to lack of data. Currently in the US the government health wizards seem to feel that for any one case it is less deadly than Delta but given that it is more contagious there might be a lot more deaths from it in total going forward as more people will get it.

On a somewhat related note, has anyone done any studies of how this might change the death rates for vaccinated vs. unvaccinated populations and if in any one country will it make a statistical difference in terms of the total population?

Most of what I've heard about "Omicron" has come from NPR:

"Omicron" might be slightly less deadly than "Delta" but is much more transmissible. It's gonna' catch up with "Delta" at some point, but for now "Delta" is still the killer - especially among the UN-vaccinated. Natural immunity appears to dwindle significantly. If you just recovered from "Delta" a couple of weeks ago, your natural immunity might be enough, but if you had Covid last year, NO.

The people who developed the mRNA vaccines are already working on a vaccine specific for "Omicron". The work on the original Covid vaccines appear to have given them a good head start.

The Biden administration appears to be doing the right things, but are hampered by the recalcitrant minority of scheisskopfs & certain parties who are obstructing for political advantage. I expect the anti-vaxx extremists are gonna need A LOT of horse dewormer paste. I do feel some sympathy for their kids.

I haven't heard anything about "Omicron" reaching North Carolina yet, but I expect it will get here sooner rather than later.

45:

Here's that experimental study: Men spread more respiratory aerosols than women, study finds - A new study "suggest[s] that men could spread the disease [COVID-19] more effectively," an aerosol scientist said (Nicole Karlis, November 14, 2021)
Respiratory Aerosol Emissions from Vocalization: Age and Sex Differences Are Explained by Volume and Exhaled CO2 (November 9, 2021)
Particle number concentrations between 0.25 and 33 μm were measured from 63 participants aged 12–61 years with concurrent monitoring of voice volume and exhaled CO2 levels. On average, singing produced 77% (95% CI: 42,109%) more aerosol than talking, adults produced 62% (CI: 27,98%) more aerosol than minors, and males produced 34% (CI: 0,70%) more aerosol than females.

46:

I would be very glad to hear from a reliable source that Omicron is less-virulent than other circulating strains of Covid.

But the numbers aren't in yet, on virulence.

They're in on transmissiblity, and the news is genuinely frightening.

If Omicron is half as virulent - that is to say, half as likely to cause serious illness, death, or long-term disability - it's still more dangerous than Delta, because it's going to infect so many more people; and it is already doing it so fast that healthcare systems are going to fail in under a month.

That's the less bad news.

The potentially terrible news revolves around the question of why it spreads from person to person so easily.

If there's no more bad news, we'll hear that it's a change in the virus' behaviour - perhaps it's like Delta, camping-out in your throat and your nasal cavity, so your exhalations carry more viral particles; or maybe the viral particle remains viable for longer in the air.

But the bad news, if it's coming, is in the most likely explanation for higher transmissiblity: Omicron is probably better at getting into your cells. Or much, much better at evading your immune system.

Those explanations, if true, would mean that a more transmissible virus is a more virulent one; and they are quite likely to be true.

But that's not yet known: optimism is nice to hear, right now, but caution and precaution are the way to go, while we await better data.

And what is known already, is that Omicron is dangerous.

I have made my own predictions elsewhere, and I see no need to repeat them here, because Charlie's forecast of a half-assed and ineffective response, followed by surging cases and a panic-stricken 'nail the doors and windows shut' lockdown, is not only on the cards - it's the hand we've already been dealt for the pre-existing trajectory of Delta in our partially-vaccinated nation of partially-masked schoolchildren and pub drinkers.

Only... Faster.

And, potentially, much more damaging.

And I think we're all underestimating how damaging it will be if we get the 'best possible' scenario of hundreds of thousands of people being 'moderately' ill, all at once, not quite sick enough to need a hospital but far too ill to work.

You do know that we're still short of lorry drivers, right? Health workers, too, if you're paying attention; and it seems likely that there's somewhere we're not paying attention, some essential service to society we never think about, with a manager realising he can't staff today's shift and there's no cover, anywhere, in any other depot within reach.

Hold onto that thought, as you walk up the High Street, past another bank or burger bar that's 'Closed due to staff shortages' and you know damn' well it's a covid outbreak on the premises: already, with the numbers we had and the hand we were dealt a week ago, before Omicron overtakes everything else.

47:

waldo @ 42: What was the hawk?

I'm pretty sure it was a Red-Tail

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red-tailed_hawk

They're the most predominant hawk around here.

He was a big one, so I'm sure he wasn't a Cooper's Hawk or a Sharp-shinned Hawk. Might have been a Red-shouldered Hawk, but he didn't appear to be as streamlined as those appear to me.

I'm fairly sure it's the one I saw on the ground back in October while walking my dog. He was guarding a squirrel he'd taken. I got a much closer look at him then, but I wasn't able to go home to get my camera & tripod.

Somebody else came along, tried to get too close to him & he flew off ... which is how I know he was guarding his catch, because I saw it after he left.

I came back later to check and it looked like he'd been back & taken his catch to a more private location to have dinner.

The proverbial "Chickenhawk", even if they rarely do eat chickens. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LBJ1ZlTPd5I

48:

Cases in Africa

Thought I'd watch an update/discussion on COVID-19 Omicron from another med-sci source to see if there are any differing opinions: Nope - still too early to say!

However did learn something that I hadn't seen mentioned in media reports. According to the second guest: the majority of African Omicron cases were college kids ... seems they had a party ... so we really don't yet know how bad this virus is for older folks. It's probably also too early to see whether there's any increase/decrease in incidence of long-Covid.

'The Omicron Variant and the New Antivirals: How Much Will These Change the Pandemic in 2022?'.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IQL-tU22XoY&ab_channel=UCSFDepartmentofMedicine

I tend to try and visualize unfamiliar topics to help understand what's being said and decided early into the first speaker's comments that I needed a reference diagram. Found this and thought folks here might also like to see what the COVID-19 life cycle and replication dynamics are.

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41579-020-00468-6/figures/1

49:

Nile @ 45: If Omicron is half as virulent - that is to say, half as likely to cause serious illness, death, or long-term disability - it's still more dangerous than Delta, because it's going to infect so many more people; and it is already doing it so fast that healthcare systems are going to fail in under a month.

Yeah, the way I took the news was that "Omicron" might be more deadly some time in the future if you haven't already died from "Delta", which is already a killer HERE AND NOW.

If you haven't already gotten vaccinated, DO IT NOW to improve your chances of being alive long enough to find out what "Omicron" might do when it becomes the dominant strain.

Not minimizing "Omicron", but "Delta" is already killing a lot of people. Anyone who is not going to do what they need to do to protect themselves from "Delta" doesn't need to worry about "Omicron".

50:

Hmph. Sadly my name got purged (and no rules broken!) :( . Since the name got purged, and the cat is out of the bag today, we were referencing "EverGrande" previously (which might get you hacked $.50c hello) and all that that entails (entrails, mostly). IF you're wondering why an Anarchist would 'support' the CCP party response, we'd suggest looking at what happened to RU and having a little human empathy - if those dominoes go, whelp, it'll make the IMF and Vietnam look like kindergarten.

But, here's a freebie: there's a massive counter-reaction to #4 booster in the works which B.J. & co are counting on and Omicron is how they're gonna do it. It's all Culture War[tm] and this one is going to get ridden like the gold-hearted harlot at Appleby Fayre, with sprinkles and a spank fest that's designed to exhaust all the Ultra-Violence into graaar for anything more 'Liberal' than Fox News[1]. We'd suggest looking up (Dec 5th) a certain A F Nielll twitter spat and various members of the GBNews crews turning around with knives out [This is, somewhat ironically, actually good news: reverting to type and with the Fleet-Strt. Foxes and Media all joining in to knife the Old Bastard shows... $$$ is behind the opposite view]. This goes from UK local to AUS, to IL to SA to USA. "Build Back Better"'s opposition (of the Bannon kind) have been counting on this one for a year+ now.

Given that not many here actually pay attention to the 'voice of the people' this one.. has legs. Ground work been laid, all the boxes ticked, rub their noses in the shit-smell time. Now, we could list you all the Attack Vectors, where they're being deployed and how the angles are getting grinded, but... We liked that Name[2]. Even denotes which side we're on, given what mongooses are famous for and all that. Hint: grep "Blackfella" then take a look at the sudden interest in Aboriginal rights in AUS from Brei-barf for example[3].

~

TL;DR

They don't give a fuck about who is dying, they care about Impact (Font Bold). And remember kids - they still work for the "Build Back Better" crew, they just don't think you're part of that 'Better' bit.

[1] Shout out to Jewdas, we thought the joke was funny. And, more importantly: correct. Weird how rampaging mobs doing actual violence in IL isn't as shocking as a few teenagers acting out now, isn't it? My my, all those 'concerned' responses. Pro-tip: if you're dancing in a Cube Costume, in a modern City, you're gonna get roasted no matter your faith or ethnicity. And yes: we know you use the Cube Costume to trip the "mentally inferior" into crises and crash, naughty, naughty, that's an ancient trick from Roman times. And no: you didn't invent the skull-fuck either.

[2] Reference is Gamestop "We like the Stock". The Apes, well... should have watched Mr Robot.

[3] It's probably one of our Brothers doing the "mix-tape" effect: this shit is easy mode.

51:

~Appendix Note: if you even imagine [1] is either hate fueled or wrong, we've a long list of the Cube Costume (hmm, NYC, very public, poor little Arab on top of a statue breaking down, last 2 years?) being deployed as a deniable Terror Weapon. Know what we call it? Primitive. In that it only works on predominantly Abrahamic based Minds these days. Go look up their twitter, there's a nice long line of people happy to shout "kappo" at anything even faintly amusing. And yes: The Cube thing is real, we can even give you it in Aramaic, given that your fake modern Hebrew wasn't spoken back then. [And, tbh: modern pronounciation SUCKS, you all sound like you're from New Jersey / the worst slums of Arwad if you can remember that far back].

And we're not joking about Omicron being used as a lever either. Florida, Texas both squaring up to it, and you've got at least three National Guard commands willing to not go for another boost. Doesn't help that Pfziiierrr C level is now blaming "other vaccines" for deaths of course. Or the cool $10 billion profit in the last month / week taken home by ~8-10 largest investors.

Oh, and a lot of proper scientists viewing the program as, well: if not mis-managed, at the very least wantonly lax in larger movements[1]. We're not doubting the science, we're doubting the supply chain and societal applications of a profit driven Corporate Cash In.

Or: In other words, just from worrying if the wedding is on or off A person can develop a cough. Adelaide's Lament (there's your AUS link) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RX-eFkGdJNM (oh, and bonus points if you spot the thumbnail picture).

52:

I saw a red-tailed hawk perched on a dead woodchuck by the side of the road with cars whizzing by around three feet away a couple of years ago. I caught one in my backyard a few years back which I thought was injured until the rehabilitator who took it in told me that it had West Nile.

53:

We have an assortment of hawks around here. One day about 10 years ago I saw some in the air above and in front of my car. The shadow came down my lane and over the car. The wingspan was 6 feet or more.

JBS, this was between the Costco and McDs on Wake Forest Road.

54:

David L @ 52: We have an assortment of hawks around here. One day about 10 years ago I saw some in the air above and in front of my car. The shadow came down my lane and over the car. The wingspan was 6 feet or more.

JBS, this was between the Costco and McDs on Wake Forest Road.

I see them frequently all around Raleigh. That's right near the Crabtree Creek Greenway 1. The thing here is I haven't been able to get out much for photography in the last two years due to Covid and that's not the only problem it has caused me even though I managed to avoid catching it so far.

But I have that big lens FOR birding (600/F4) and this was a perfect chance to use it while keeping social distancing. The last time I got to use it was two years ago; end of October 2019. My main purpose for buying it was to photograph the eagles nest at Shelley Lake.

Peregrine Falcons nested on the Wells Fargo building in downtown Raleigh in 2020 ... and I think at least once in the past on the "Progress Energy (old CP&L)" building. Don't know if they came back in 2021 or not. I also didn't get a chance to photograph the eagles nest at Shelly Lake this year (or last). I didn't even get to check if they'd come back this year.

1 The spot David is talking about is about a hundred feet up from the greenway and Crabtree Creek is the one we talked about flooding and all the Volkswagen Beetles floating away. Raleigh's greenways are pretty good natural habitat running through the city. Many of them are the result of flood plain zoning changes after those floods back in the 70s & 80s. If you can't build there, maybe you can use it for a kind of linear park ... or a parkway for pedestrians & cyclists - no motor vehicles and on most of them no horses.

55:

jazzlet Actually, that's what worries me. I'm almost 76, but for my age, fit & healthy. I suspect I would resist an Omicron infection - BUT - what really scares me is "long Covid". No more dancing, difficulty maintaing my allotment, permanent tiredness ... shudder - no thank you. So - take precautions.

56:

Norway has gotten some attention (and not in the good way) related to omicron. There was a christmas party last weekend with 120 attendees where 2 had just come back from South Africa, and were likely infected. Last I've hard 60 of the 120 guestss and 90-100 in total (guessing their family, but could also be others at the restaurant) had tested positive. Only 13 have been sequenced to confirm omicron so far, and there could be multiple infection vectors involved. It doesn't help that we were already in a new wave of delta spread, setting fresh records on daily infections and approaching hospitalizations not seen since the initial wave in March/April 2020.

57:

We've got you beat. 53000 people at an anime convention and it looks like it was an omicron spreader event. The various agencies trying to trace things have tracked down about 35K of them so far.

https://arstechnica.com/science/2021/12/officials-trying-to-contact-all-53k-anime-convention-attendees-in-omicron-probe/

58:

You mean people like Bozo and Trumpolini? Are you sure this is Faux News?

59:

For the benefit of those outside the UK, this is currently taking up all the publicity oxygen here.

TL;DR: last year, just as we were heading into near-lockdown, Downing Street staff held an illegal Christmas office party. The Prime Minister has spent the last month asserting that while there may have been a gathering it was entirely in accordance with the rules (without explaining how this was possible). Now a video has been leaked of a practice news conference at which staff made jokes about this party.

The only question now is, can Kier Starmer, leader of the opposition, use this to actually land a punch on the PM at Question Time. Trouble is, Starmer is a laywer who also happens to be a politician, and what he thinks of as a devastating cross examination, the media think of as "meh!".

60:

All the First Ministers statements are published here: https://www.gov.scot/collections/first-ministers-speeches/

Anything put out by the Scottish Government is here: https://www.gov.scot/publications/

61:

«she's been doing these straight-talking no-bullshit reports since the beginning of the pandemic, clearly listens to scientific advice,»

But the scientific advice and the evidence is overwhelmingly to adopt test-trace-isolate as a strategy instead of halfbaked lockdowns to limit cases, that results in death rates 10-100 times lower than in Scotland or England, see Finland or Korea-south etc.

For "some reason" all nations of the UK, just like most european governments, have ignored the scientific advice and evidence, and have chosen the same strategy that results in 10-100 times death rates.

62:

Thank you. Bookmarked. I have read the latest one, and it is exactly what such a report should be.

63:

If R > 2 with Scotland's current precautions (and it's worth noting that there is not and cannot be hard evidence that that is true, because we only started looking for it last week) then full April 2020 lockdown WILL NOT STOP IT without vastly higher levels of adherence than have been seen in any Western country including the "success stories". "Full lockdown" will at best slow the progression, not stop it. Which means we have to STAY in full lockdown until we have a targeted vaccine and have rolled it out widely. Nine months. If Sturgeon's advice says R>2 and she's not taking further action she's just continuing to be about 24hrs better than Boris which yes, is better, but it's not much to boast about.

64:

"there is not and cannot be hard evidence that that is true, because we only started looking for it last week"

However, there are data going back further, though (for reasons I have mentioned in the past, it has only recently been collated) so what you say is wrong. Note that I am not saying there IS hard evidence, because I have not analysed it.

"then full April 2020 lockdown WILL NOT STOP IT without vastly higher levels of adherence "

Not even those would stop it now. It's too late. All that could be done is to slow it enough to keep the strain on the NHS under control. That is what Sturgeon is trying to do, and Bozo is not.

65:

No it isn't. It was. It's now too late. You can use test and trace to stop something getting out of control but, once it's out of control, it's a waste of time, effort and money. The time it might have helped with Omicron was if it had started on November 1st; starting it now isn't going to achieve much, and won't achieve anything unless there is thorough and fast sequencing for all people arriving from abroad. I explained the situation in #7.

66:

Data from Public Health Scotland released today says that there are 389 confirmed or suspected cases of Omicron-variant COVID-19 in Scotland but none of them have (yet) required hospitalisation. The earliest cases were from spreader events two weeks ago so that's plenty of time for some of them to get sick enough to need a hospital bed, and they haven't. Right now, even with the number of Omicron variant cases on the rise the numbers of COVID-19 hospital bed cases and ICU cases in Scotland is falling steadily.

The key factor in the Scottish government's thinking on precautions is "Can the NHS cope with the load?" Right now it looks like it can so any fresh restrictions, especially on the run-up to the holiday season will be applied with a light hand. All of the new suggestions are just that, recommendations for businesses to permit work-at-home etc. rather than mandates.

Other interesting information in the PHS bulletin is that about half of the Omicron-variant cases are in the age band 20-39, the Young Immortals with the lowest rate of vaccination and the greatest propensity to party hard in large crowds. Who knows, we may even eventually discover that Omicron is sexually-transmissable.

67:

"*It's been recreated as a research tool, I believe."

There's an interesting story behind that:

https://www.cdc.gov/flu/pandemic-resources/reconstruction-1918-virus.html

68:

Possible good news IF you have had 3 Pfizer jabs - as I have ...

69:

Greg @54: I suspect I would resist an Omicron infection - BUT - what really scares me is "long Covid".

Yes. Long COVID is the part of the iceberg that's below waterline. There are a lot of awful long-term disabilities from it, but one of the most frightening is persistent mental incapacity.

I know that "data is not the plural of anecdote", but, for those who care, here's my experience with long COVID brain fog.

Disclaimer: I already had some cognitive deficits plaguing me. (Probably cortisol poisoning -- when I was young everybody was ranting about how drugs would ruin your life, but nobody ever warned me about work. Especially decades of overwork.) Still, while the doctors were diagnosing my loss of mental function, I took an NP panel and I was in the upper quartile for almost all measures of brain function. So that was my baseline. COVID changed matters, quickly and radically.

I got COVID in June of 2020. Very mild symptoms. The most significant was that I lost the part of my sense of taste that told me how spicy food was. Since we rotate cooking duties in our household, the results were tragicomic... Other than that, though, COVID itself wasn't a thing. I figured I'd gotten off lightly: just lucky.

It was a few weeks before I realized that I had become frighteningly fucking stupid. Even the simplest projects (e. g. building a work desk) were incredibly difficult. Skills and aptitudes that I'd had since the 70s or 80s deserted me. I left tools outside when I knocked off for the day. I left the door unlocked so many times that the landlord changed the doorknob for one that was always locked. I lost the ability to focus on much of anything.

Driving became difficult. I lost the ability to find things, even when I was looking right at them. (Loss of visual pattern recognition was one of the most unnerving symptoms.) I lost items, sometimes permanently, but mostly just for a few hours or days because I set them down in an unaccustomed place. I'd forget things all of the time. I had very little capacity for sustained focus.

My ability to remember words and names for immediate use fell off a cliff -- sometimes it would take hours to remember the name of a person, or a writer, or a band whose music I wanted to hear.

Luckily I had retired shortly before COVID hit. I'd have been unable to remain in a job at all.

Brain fog has now been riding me for nearly a year and a half. I'm finally surfacing, to some extent. I currently seem to have roughly two good brain days followed by 1-4 days of still being listless, of still being unable to find my ass with both hands in my back pockets. But this really is a hopeful trend. We all respond much more strongly to a first derivative than to the value of the function itself, and it's pretty encouraging to be where I am now.

I probably won't get back to the level of thinking and focusing that I used to have. Long COVID has cost me a great deal.

But my lack of capacity isn't a problem for society at large.

Consider, on the other hand, the immediate and knock-on effects of persistent brain fog, of the kind I've got, in a big slice of the population. We're going to need people who are smart and mentally awake. Every hampered mind is a loss.

I can only say that I hope brain fog proves to be uncommon, shorter-lived and fully recoverable.

70:

It seems here in the god ol' USA-YAY, only the mayor of NYC is even attempting to take precautions for the inevitable coming surge. He mandated vaccination quarantine and proof for everyone, including young kids, to enter indoor venues from movie theaters to restaurants, with the idea of slowing things so our hospitals aren't overwhelmed like 2020, when we were the hottest of hot spots for covid, and we, unlike anywhere else in the USA had a full lock down. The governor of NY state is merely "strongly suggesting" masking in all indoor venues and getting vaxxed and boosted. But no mandate. Yet several regions of the state covid hospitalizations have surged so much in the last weeks there are no more beds. And again, already way behind non-covid medical procedures and even emergencies are being postponed and untreated.

Manhattan was an island in the whole country with such low rates of hospitalizations, deaths and positivity. But of course with the opening up to international travel ... Broadway ... not to mention that really stupid stuff such as the anime con brought up here earlier -- even my zip code, with very high vaccination and boosting, which was testing down in the lowest of numbers, cases hardly registering, no hospitalizations and no deaths, has increased numbers at an alarming rate.

I wish we would do what Singapore has done: if one has not gotten vaccinated, and acquires covid, then you and your family pay for it, not the state, city or insurance.

Christmas is going to be like last year's, again, I fear.

71:

This preprint is making the rounds. If it passes a day or two of scrutiny, policies should start to change immediately. Reduced Neutralization of SARS-CoV-2 Omicron Variant by Vaccine Sera and monoclonal antibodies (2021/12/08, medrxiv (preprint), Alexander Wilhelm, Marek Widera, Katharina Grikscheit, Tuna Toptan, Barbara Schenk, Christiane Pallas, Melinda Metzler, Niko Kohmer, Sebastian Hoehl, Fabian A. Helfritz, Timo Wolf Udo Goetsch Sandra Ciesek)
Abstract:
Due to numerous mutations in the spike protein, the SARS-CoV-2 variant of concern Omicron (B.1.1.529) raises serious concerns since it may significantly limit the antibody-mediated neutralization and increase the risk of reinfections. While a rapid increase in the number of cases is being reported worldwide, until now there has been uncertainty about the efficacy of vaccinations and monoclonal antibodies. Our in vitro findings using authentic SARS-CoV-2 variants indicate that in contrast to the currently circulating Delta variant, the neutralization efficacy of vaccine-elicited sera against Omicron was severely reduced highlighting T-cell mediated immunity as essential barrier to prevent severe COVID-19. Since SARS-CoV-2 Omicron was resistant to casirivimab and imdevimab genotyping of SARS-CoV-2 may be needed before initiating mAb treatment. Variant-specific vaccines and mAb agents may be required to treat Omicron and other emerging variants of concern.

On the up side (yes, please!) there are reports that loss of smell is less common with Omicron infections, and loss of smell is correlated (don't know if directly causally) with negative covid-19 cognition-related sequelae. OTOH, Delta and Omicron will be circulating simultaneously.

Bill Blondeau - I very much hope you recover most of your function. There has been/will be a lot of experimentation including personal experimentation being done, and sadly a lot of quackery. What have you been trying, if you're willing to share?

72:

There is some scant evidence that T-cell immunity is more important than antibody immunity, and Astrazeneca does better than Pfizer and Moderna in that (not surprisingly). Probably so does Sputnik and other traditional vaccines. But, frankly, there is precious little data and (sorry Greg) Pfizer is very bad about abusing data for marketing and even disinformation.

73:

I think we're heading for either Sunak or Javid. Both millionaire libertarian banker types. (Wildcard: it depends how racist the 1922 Committee collectively feel the party base is.)

I think the people who fund and lead the Conservative party would be happy to ditch Johnson, now that he has given them an 80-seat majority. They don't like all his talk of spending money and increasing national insurance; they was to get back to core tory values of austerity and cutting taxes. They'd be far happier with Sunak or Javid in charge. They couldn't move against Johnson when he was popular; once they sense he's an electoral liability, they'll get rid of him in an instant.

74:

"Consider, on the other hand, the immediate and knock-on effects of persistent brain fog, of the kind I've got, in a big slice of the population. We're going to need people who are smart and mentally awake. Every hampered mind is a loss."

I certainly hope that you (and everyone suffering from this) have a full recovery. And I wonder if this kind of thing has started to show up in the statistics of automobile accidents, airline pilots not able to pilot, truck/lorry fleets losing available driver-hours, etc.

76:

And, unrelated to omicron or anything else, how 'bout some good news?

Excerpt: Warp drive pioneer and former NASA warp drive specialist Dr. Harold G “Sonny” White has reported the discovery of an actual, real-world “Warp Bubble.” And, according to White, this first of its kind breakthrough by his Limitless Space Institute (LSI) team sets a new starting point for those trying to manufacture a full-sized, warp-capable spacecraft.

In an interview, White added that “our detailed numerical analysis of our custom Casimir cavities helped us identify a real and manufacturable nano/microstructure that is predicted to generate a negative vacuum energy density such that it would manifest a real nanoscale warp bubble, not an analog, but the real thing.” In other words, a warp bubble structure will manifest under these specific conditions. White cautioned that this does not mean we are near building a fully functioning warp drive, as much more science needs to be done (Updated 08/12/21).

“To be clear, our finding is not a warp bubble analog, it is a real, albeit humble and tiny, warp bubble,” White told The Debrief, “hence the significance.” --- end excerpt ---

https://thedebrief.org/darpa-funded-researchers-accidentally-create-the-worlds-first-warp-bubble/

77:

To illustrate the magnitude of the problem faced by the UK Con party, I commented on another site earlier today that "I would trust Larry (Chief Mouser to the Cabinet Office) more than I would trust any member of the Bozo cabinet".

78:

David L @ 56: We've got you beat. 53000 people at an anime convention and it looks like it was an omicron spreader event. The various agencies trying to trace things have tracked down about 35K of them so far.

https://arstechnica.com/science/2021/12/officials-trying-to-contact-all-53k-anime-convention-attendees-in-omicron-probe/

Yeah, that's gonna' suck, but at least the anime festival didn't end with an invasion of killer elves from another dimension.

79:

paws4thot @ 57: You mean people like Bozo and Trumpolini? Are you sure this is Faux News?

"Even a blind squirrel finds an acorn once in a while."

Google News said it was Fox. I didn't follow the link. I was just amused by the headline, especially since it was a headline from Faux Newz.

But I think Bill Arnold had links to the actual studies the headline must have been based on @ 44:

80:

Greg Tingey @ 67: Possible good news IF you have had 3 Pfizer jabs - as I have ...

Very good news. I have to go out today to get another Crock-Pot (I fucked mine up!) and I have to go to the dentist Friday to have two teeth pulled. I've already been on soft foods for a month, and it looks like it's going to be another two months before I'll get off of them. The Crock-Pot is cheap to replace (~ $20), but god help me if I break the damn Vita-Mix.

I got the third Pfizer a week ago last Monday (29 Nov), but Omicron was worrying me a lot. I'm doing everything I can to protect myself, but it has come at a very inconvenient time.

81:

Bill Arnold @ 70: I very much hope you recover most of your function. There has been/will be a lot of experimentation including personal experimentation being done, and sadly a lot of quackery. What have you been trying, if you're willing to share?

Thanks for the good wishes, Bill.

The only thing I've specifically used as a brain fog helper is turmeric, taken daily in capsule form. I was advised to try it by a person who said it had helped her; I did some checking and there is apparently some peer-reviewed science supporting that. (She also recommended several other things that had no science. I declined to go down those rabbit holes.) So I tried it, and was pleased with the result: modest improvement over the course of a couple of weeks, with no noticeable fade thereafter. This may, of course, have been coincidental with an improvement for other reasons, and possibly a placebo; but I am brutally pragmatic about these things. I maintain that the placebo effect is still, after all, an effect. And turmeric is inexpensive.

Another factor that probably influences the progress of my recovery from brain fog is that our household is vegan. Plant-based diets do have beneficial effects on vascular health, and vascular dementia has been a concern of mine for family history reasons. Two notes on this:

  • I am not trying to start a conversation about veganism. It's a ridiculously divisive topic, and squabbles about it should stay on Reddit where they fucking belong. I'm certainly not advocating veganism here in the comments. You do you, YMMV, etc.
  • Our plant-based diet is pretty healthy, based on well-verified nutritional science. Mostly. We do have the stereotypical vodka and oreos on the shelf.

There is a third aspect to my recovery: physical activity. As far as I know, regular exercise is associated with mental clarity and energy. I do use a bicycle when feasible, shovel dirt, rake leaves, scramble around with ladders to prune trees, etc. The more of this I do, the better things seem to go.

I sort of wish I had other things to tell you. One dietary supplement (although possibly no more than a placebo) that seems to help, and two more-or-less platitudinal lifestyle choices, seems kind of a meager yield for your question.

82:

I wonder if this kind of thing has started to show up in the statistics of automobile accidents

Well, automobile accidents here dropped during the pandemic, with the fatality rate remaining constant. The number of accidents has gone back up, and the fatality rate has gone up too.

Based on the limited driving I've done, the increased fatality rate would be idiots driving on empty streets during the pandemic, and continuing to drive the same way now that traffic levels are back to normal.

How you distinguish between ordinary idiot-related accidents and long-Covid-related accidents I leave to those wiser than myself. Which doesn't appear to be the politicians currently in charge of Ontario's pandemic response.

I recall seeing somewhere that there's a correlation between Tox. gondi infection and causing accidents, established by testing organ donors. Don't know if similar testing is possible for long Covid yet.

83:

"I haven't heard anything about 'Omicron' reaching North Carolina yet"

Would you know?

Serious question. Here in New Zealand I believe we're still genome-sequencing all positive Covid cases, so we know exactly what's here and if you get Covid they'll know which cluster you are in, and quite likely who you got it from. So we know that all cases in the community in our country now - and for the last few months - track back to one failure at the border. So it's all Delta here, for now, as one case of Delta got in past our border controls.

But are you guys doing similar and genome-sequencing all - or a lot of - the cases that test positive? It's really hard to tell just what's going on internationally, and how different places compare in their testing and genome sequencing.

84:

Another voice from NC. It's hit or miss. I think they sequence all the cases that wind up in hospitals. And maybe all of those that are PCR tested.

Plus we have 2 very major research hospitals local to Raleigh/Durham who do a lot. But if you're in BumF&*k nowhere where the hospital has 12 beds, I don't know. Our governor and his "in charge of state medical things" department tries hard to do the right thing but we are a 50/50 state where the legislature supports "freedom" most of the time so there is a constant fight. And the rural areas are more "freedom" than "we need to deal".

Given the university student population within 25 miles of me is maybe 100K plus staff plus 4 major medical centers and just my county school system is north of 140K students plus all the staff to make that work, new things tend to appear locally fairly quickly.

My point is that getting "invincible" students below the age of 25 to be responsible 100% is basically a dream.

85:

Re: 'There is a third aspect to my recovery: physical activity.'

Yeah - regular moderate exercise is key. Some people need a more structured plan like the below to help make sure that they exercise all of their bits.

https://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/physical\_medicine\_rehabilitation/coronavirus-rehabilitation/\_files/impact-of-covid-patient-recovery.pdf

Another thing that I've seen crop up is cognitive therapy (CI Therapy) which sorta looks similar to the behavioral re-education/physical re-training rehab that's given to people who've suffered strokes.

There's also: getting enough restful sleep, avoiding stressful situations and doing some meditation type exercises like tai chi (see below) that demand extended periods of mental focus combined with fine physical/muscular coordination while also being relaxing.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8054611/

[[ escaped underscores to unbreak link - mod ]]

86:

Here in New Zealand I believe we're still genome-sequencing all positive Covid cases Here in Scotland we nominally have a similar population (to 100_000 or so), but we have the issue of having a frontier line that you can walk, cycle, drive, be driven, take a train, fly or sail over with no customs or immigration formalities, so all cases might be pointless?

87:

"so all cases might be pointless"

It might.

In NZ we're doing it as part of our contact tracing, and associated attempts to get people with Covid to isolate and stop the spread. Most people who get Covid are easily linked to a household member or similar, how they got it is obvious. They aren't the main problem.

If you come down with Covid here and we know that someone who visited the same supermarket or whatever has Covid, and your infections are genetically linked, we know what's going on and can make good warnings about who should stay home and isolate. If it's very closely genetically linked to other cases, we know there's at most one missing link in the chain of infection.

But if you come down with Covid and genome testing says it's quite unrelated other Covid cases, that's a sign that we've got an undiagnosed cluster of cases, and the disease is spreading in a community. Time to intervene, warn people there, ramp up testing in that area/suburb or that church group, or school, or whatever.

But while genome testing everyone may be overkill places like Scotland, what I don't know is where that leaves you. How many would you be genome testing?

88:

Whelp, "Plan B" is live. Something put the Cat amongst the pigeons today, for sure. Quite exciting. Wasn't expecting tears and the literal sacrifice of the Maiden, but there we are. And we've even got GB News adjacents calling out to "Arthur" (the King, not the comic).

And right on cue, come the sounds of that campaign we warned you about[3].

Not sure: someone explain if your societies are supposed to function like this, all seems a little chaotic, doesn't it? Now imagine if you knew that last night, could have made a killing...

Talk about "bang for your BUCK", eh? bum-tish

~

Regarding the Pfzizere PR blitz: not convinced. They're relying on invitro modelling and their stock bump is too juicy for them to not run with #3 boost as sufficient, and this is after stating it wasn't effective. We've read contrary science and it checks out. We'd trust a spiked punch bowl in a student party more than a Pfizer C level rep on TeeVee for reference, and for good reason.

~

The only thing I've specifically used as a brain fog helper is turmeric

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piracetam - won't hurt you unless you OD to the max, good for old brains anyhow, circulation is always good.

Unless you're talking about the other kind of brain-fog and awakening, at which point our advice will get a lot more specific.

~

Oh, and Evergrande. shrug

[1] You're not going to understand the Jewdas / language references without watching the back-story to a UK / London affair currently being used as part of another Culture War. Put it this way: there are parts of Berlin you wouldn't want to host a PKK rally, and there are parts of London where turning up to dance in the Cube Costume would be considered ill-advised. So, either the organizer was a muppet or looking for a response: this isn't condoning the response, but we're not naive enough to imagine that putting teenagers into dangerous situations for media attention isn't something that has/will/can be done. Note: back when it was perfected it was used to entice Roman patrols into ambushes, not that you lot know that. [1a] The joke is an inclusive one: since Hebrew (modern) is a 'resurrected' language, the intonation is largely fake. Accurately fake, but still fake. Thus, having the "Ruling Council of UK" produce a video solemnly explaining the 'correct' pronounciation and so on is hysterically funny or hysterically atemporal depending on your reading. Arwad is/was a trading port back when Judea was under the Bablyonian thumb and even prior to The Jewish People actually arriving in the region, so natch: and yes, your modern accents are somewhat worse. Phlebas the Phoenician, a fortnight dead, Forgot the cry of gulls, and the deep sea swell And the profit and loss. [1b] It's a loving / inclusive joke: if all of you have terrible accents then all of you share something quite quaint / cute in a terribly jarring way to us. And trust us: Arwad was a riot back in the day. Ask your Mums where merkins come from...

[2] Appleby Fair is the largest Traveller / Gypsy (in the original, cute wooden homes with horses, sense) gathering in the UK. It's also very horse based. And a lot of sex goes on, but we digress. Also, probably going to have a massive crack down next year with the fuzz using their new powers to the max, but we didn't tell you that here. The implication was... well: We respect those visiting the fair and gold-hearted harlots far more than we respect what happened today, but it tracks, doesn't it? (Bonus round: M. Hancock getting the PR handy on dyslexia and all concerned are rather into horses). Again: cultural references you're not going to spot unless you're horsey / know your UK class break-downs. It was quite a magnificent insult for those engaged with dressage, put it that way. (And they... totally fucked her, live on TV).

[3] Not joking about the National Guard either. A certain General Flynn has just fingered the CIA as responsible for the Jan 6 / Q revolt (he's not wrong: wrong agency, but 100% an OP to get the reigns of that bolted horse back under control, grep it, we told you back then), which is preeeeety spicey in Evangelical Lands. Oh, and totes #3-4 booster is being used as the wedge. And those Guards have Armouries chocka-block full of heavy weapons and MRAPS! Weeeee!

~ That's just a snap-shot of the actual thought that goes into posts, we usually don't bother to explain, but the Cube Costume is a touchy one.

89:

So is it correct to say that, if compared to delta, omicron is 5x as infectious and 1/5th as fatal, then the same number of people die from omicron as for delta?

90:

No-one reads our comments, but no, not really.

Here's the break-down (in a % of population sample and referencing health of populations rather than individuals):

0) Covid19 already ganked a load of the most vulnerable, so that weights your "total fatality" figures right out of the gate

1) More infections = higher probability of mutation into new strands [This is Bad]

2) More infections = higher probability of 'Long Covid' and/or stuff like: myocarditis, nerve damage, lobe function loss rather than death [This is bad]

3) Given the DNA sequence (which, ahem is a bit strange and SA lab location noted, nasty history of weaponised AIDS research there) anomalies this looks like a recursive back-track to a more original strain, meaning work done on later strains not in the lineage (hello vaccines) won't be as affective [This is bad]

4) There's no specifics, as of yet, on H.S.S variant tweakage. Call us cynical, but the lack of response to the current variants' ethnic bias has been noted. Aka: "It's great when the Natives don't have immunity to our STDs".

But....

It will kill less people due to the fact that prior strains aleady killed a shit-tonne of people who were vulnerable to it. Probably not even a statistical blip, especially given Medical Treatment has learnt all the lessons (aka: don't fucking tube unless required, NYC). This is the "Nerve Rider" variant.

Which... will also feed into that Other Ting we told you is happening right now. Aka: "This is just the flu, waaa waaa.... WAAAAARGH, IT'S A CULTURE WAAAR".

91:

(Above: not DNA sequence, it's a virus. RNA.)

https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/science/science-briefs/scientific-brief-omicron-variant.html

If you want to get technical, this is the danger zone part:

Omicron variant of SARS-CoV-2 harbors a unique insertion mutation of putative viral or human genomic origin

The Omicron variant harbors 37 mutations in the Spike protein, which include six deletion mutations, one insertion mutation and 30 substitution mutations... This highly mutated Spike variant harbors a novel insertion mutation ins214EPE. Although the position 214 appears to be an insertion hotspot10 the EPE insertion in Omicron appears to be novel. Previous analyses of sequences deposited in GI SAID suggested that insertions in the SARS-CoV-2 genome likely arise from polymerase slippage or template switching.

Searching the HCoV-229E genome for homology to a nucleotide sequence encoding ins214EPE shows the presence of an identical sequence in HCoV-229E’s Spike protein, which could have been exploited for template switching (Figure 2). Furthermore, based on analysis of single cell RNA seq data (Table S2), we see that the receptors of SARS-CoV-2 (ACE2) and HCoV-229E (ANPEP) are co-expressed in gastrointestinal (e.g. enterocytes) and respiratory tissues (e.g. respiratory ciliated cells). This gives rise to the plausibility of such cells in co-infected individuals being exploited as sites of genomic interplay between different viruses

https://osf.io/f7txy/

It's not ideal having a SARS take cues from Flu, for reference.

92:

So is it correct to say that, if compared to delta, omicron is 5x as infectious and 1/5th as fatal, then the same number of people die from omicron as for delta?

Epidemiologists don't like to boil down their equations, but it's obvious from the graphs that infection rates lead to nonlinear growth of infection, so no, 5 times as infectious with 1/5 the bad outcomes is not a wash.

A way to think of this is as a bank account. You have two choices: the standard Delta account with the standard Delta interest rate and fees, or the speculative new Omicron account with an interest rate that's five times the Delta interest rate, but with 1/5 the fees of Delta.

If you want to maximize your returns, do you choose Delta, or Omicron? Or are they the same? It's not the simple, as noted in #89, but this is the basic problem.

And yes, in this example, the account is denominated in infections and the fees are deaths and other negative outcomes for humans.

93:

So is it correct to say that, if compared to delta, omicron is 5x as infectious and 1/5th as fatal, then the same number of people die from omicron as for delta?

No. As Charlie has pointed out several times, infection rates scale exponentially over time while fatality per infection (the case fatality rate) remains linear. You might not wish to take that at face value just because we say so, so here's a worked example.

Say R=2 for delta and R=10 for omicron (that is 5x). Person D0 has delta and person Om0 has omicron. D0 will infect 2 people (D1 and D2) while Om0 will infect 10 people (Om1 through Om10). D1 and D2 will infect 2 people each (D3-6) with 7 people infected after 2 iterations. Om1 will infect 10 people, as will Om2... the last person infected by Om10 will be Om110 with a total 111 people infected after 2 iterations. After 6 iterations when we're up to D127 and Om1.1 million, at which point we've probably seen our first delta death since we started counting, but we're already up to 222 omicron deaths (on average). At 7 its 2.5 delta deaths from 256 infections and 2.2 thousand omicron deaths from 11 million infections. At 8 it's 5 delta deaths from 512 infections and 22.2 thousand omicron deaths from 111 million infections, which would represent saturation for the UK I guess.

I may err a bit in details, but at least that's the general idea. Pick slightly more pessimistic numbers and the outcome worsens in proportion. This ignores the problem that 22 thousand people dying in ICU beds is a capacity emergency no matter how well resourced your health system is, and that many many more deaths would result just from that.

94:

I should dd a proviso: this isn't a prediction, exactly, just a working-through of what infection versus case fatality rates actually mean in practice. There are reasons why it might be less bad, including the ones mentioned at @89 and @91. This was just my attempt at redressing the apparently missed exponential growth thing.

Regarding capacity, the thing about ICUs is that just building more of them isn't enough, intensive care is both a medical specialty and a nursing specialty and training practitioners has a lead time of years. Which is why you might see a wave of doctor resignations and career changes resulting from hospitals and health systems telling their clinicians: "whatever your specialty is now, your future includes having intensive care as a specialty too, you don't have a choice about this".

95:

SFR / Bill Blondeau

"Exercise"

Yes, this is also supposed to help in prevention in the first place. Most weeks, 3 times a week, I'm walking a km each-way to my allotment & then pottering/gardening for anything from an hour to 4 hours, all in the open air. Should be good for me ...

Another recurring theme.. How people, especially fuckwit tory politicians REALLY DO NOT GET "doubling" or "exponential" growths, even now - some wanker on the radio, in the past hour, talking about a "tiny starting number" - obviously never heard the grains-of-rice-on-the-chessboard story. What a plonker.

[ 264 is a large number ]

87 / 89 / 90 - oh SHIT

96:

There's also the issue that the fatality rate is linked to the infectiousness, as in will the healtcare system have the resources to treat you. I suspect that the fatality rate for untreated omicron is worse than treated delta.

97:

Well, it's possible to genome sequence all positive PCR tests, but that will work at the speed of genetics, rather than the speed of any of plot, politics, or infection.

98:

turmeric, […] there is apparently some peer-reviewed science supporting that.

I recently came across a short article by Derek Lowe on curcumin research. It seems to be really easy to produce spurious positive findings. So I'd be wary even of peer-reviewed science on this compound.

99:

«But the scientific advice and th/e evidence is overwhelmingly to adopt test-trace-isolate as a strategy»`

«It was. It's now too late. You can use test and trace to stop something getting out of control but, once it's out of control, it's a waste of time, effort and money.»

I was indeed commenting to the past as to Sturgeon's complicity as to the past 18 month.

As to the current situation, fast-spreading variants like Delta and Omicron indeed put a strain on test-trace-isolate as testing and especially tracing need to be faster. But it is still a lot less expensive and more effective than half-baked lockdowns.

As to it being too late, as Delta and Omicron may have already spread too much, that can be reset, as China-Taiwan or China-mainland and other areas have done, with either (or both) short (a few weeks) very hard lockdowns, to let current cases burn out without spreading, or with fast mass testing. As to the latter:

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-54504785The Chinese city of Qingdao is testing its entire population of nine million people for Covid-19 over a period of five days. The mass testing comes after the discovery of a dozen cases linked to a hospital treating coronavirus patients arriving from abroad. In May, China tested the entire city of Wuhan - home to 11 million people and the epicentre of the global pandemic. The country has largely brought the virus under control. That is in stark contrast to other parts of the world, where there are still high case numbers and lockdown restrictions of varying severity. In a statement posted to Chinese social media site Weibo, Qingdao's Municipal Health Commission said six new cases and six asymptomatic cases had been discovered.

That is twice the population of Scotland... When there is a will there is a way. What is missing is Johnson's, Starmer's, Sturgeon's will. Yes, Sturgeon has given better reporting on the situation than the spivs in England, but that is not enough.

100:

Sturgeon has no powers to even test those entering from outside Scotland, whether from other parts of the UK or outside it. It is unlikely that test and trace would have helped significantly with that constraint.

101:

If you do 100 tests on something irrelevant, it is almost certain that there will be some that show a positive link and some a negative link. This has been known since the early days of statistics.

102:

Going by my very simplistic maths, a doubling time of 2-3 days would infect the entire population of the UK by the end of January. Probably overwhelm hospitals around the end of December.

Why are we not in ultra lockdown right now?

103:

Lockdown is politically painful, the dependency of politicians on donations from businessfolk guarantee it. It will be even less possible in the US, as the dependency on the goodwill of the donor community is greater.

104:

Politicians can only do what the polis (the people) permit them to. Last year Scottish schools were closed, remote learning implemented and exams cancelled in an attempt to reduce the spread of the first variants of COVID-19. This effort to mitigate an infectious disease nearly brought down the government and cost the Education minister his job as children's education was clearly impacted. The result is that schools, which are plague Mixmasters at the best of times, have been open throughout 2021 with the children in their classrooms and doing their part to spread this disease in their communities because the polis demands it.

105: 76 I mentioned this in another thread. My thinking was that they had theoretically created a bubble in the quantum foam not space-time. Though this could be useful in creating a warp drive or wormhole because of the negative energy density. I have no idea if this is correct! 81 I know exactly what you are going through with long covid as I have M.E. It's awful, best of luck. 82 I haven't driven for years as I felt I couldn't trust myself. 88 Thanks for the Piracetam, I have been suffering from both brain fog and myoclonic jerks. They have both settled a bit, but if they get worse I might try this.
106:

You have a point, but the holders of wealth will demand access first, theirs may be the voice you heard.

107:

You're going to have to explain the "cube costume" thing to me in words of one syllable. And "Jewdas", whatever it is. Something to do with the insane libelous Corbyn/anti-semitism allegations? (I am aware of certain parties trying to conflate anti-semitism with anti-zionism; and related parties trying to convince us all that "judaeo-christian" values are real, despite Judaism having a radically different axiom system from Christianity (no afterlife, no heaven, and no hell -- just for starters).

Also I'm utterly unclear about what you think booster vaccines are being used as a political wedge for -- even the direction you think they're being pushed in.

Not that anything has made much sense since 20th February 2001, of course ...

108:

Why are we not in ultra lockdown right now?

I hear you.

Where I live (Ontario), our 4th wave started in the end of October (27th or so).

After a slow rise, it's gone exponential. When you plot new cases on a logarithmic graph, it's been a straight line for the past 3-4 weeks (r2 over 0.981).

Right now, the 7-day average crossed 1000 new cases / day earlier this week. If things go on as they are, by Jan 1 2022, new cases will be around 1900-2000 per day.

And our premier does nothing to throw on the brakes.

1 For the linear line of best fit on the logarithmic graph.

109:

Regarding capacity, the thing about ICUs is that just building more of them isn't enough, intensive care is both a medical specialty and a nursing specialty and training practitioners has a lead time of years.

Training time for a fully qualified ICU nurse in the US is seven years.

Training time for a doctor is at minimum 5 years and, to consultant level, 10-12 years.

Also, even in non-pandemic times these are high-stress specialities and training is wasteful: about 30% of nurses quit the profession within 2-3 years of graduation, and while I lack data, I'm not sure doctors are any better at staff retention. And at the other end, people retire earlier than in other jobs -- medicine requires constant skills updates, nursing and surgery require physical condition, and after age 50 it's mostly about passing on skills to the next generation and/or winding down in low-intensity areas.

We are currently burning out an entire generation of talent in the space of a couple of years, and even if there's a massive recruitment ramp-up after the pandemic to train twice as many medics and nurses and auxiliary professions as usual, it'll take 10-20 years to get back to adequate staffing ... assuming another pandemic doesn't come along in the meantime.

We mostly trend older on this blog -- I think most of us are over 50, in many cases over 70. This is therefore going to lead to our premature deaths, even if we dodge COVID19 successfully.

110:

Why are we not in ultra lockdown right now?

Oh look, the Prime Minister's latest wife has just popped out another Prime Ministerial baby!

(This is called "throwing a live baby on the table", as "throwing a dead cat on the table" was looking kind of tired this week given the utter wtfery about the multiple Downing Street Christmas parties during the 2020 December lockdown, the Police refusing to investigate due to "lack of evidence" despite being tasked with signing in all visitors to 10 Downing Street and searching them for, well, Secret Santa presents ... )

I swear I have no idea how to even satirize this using the New Management.

111:

Added to the human resource issues, we might be looking at a succession of corona viruses as varieties mix and mingle in the unvaccinated. Not nearly as fast as Stephen King's "Captain Trips", but a return to normal looks like a forlorn hope in so many ways.

112:

It's over a year old, but still valid:

https://www.tvo.org/article/perimeter-institute-a-physicists-adventures-in-virology

Well worth watching. PI lectures are usually interesting, and this one was timely as well. It roughly sums down to 'people don't really understand exponential growth, and persist in assuming all growth is linear'.

113:

This was just my attempt at redressing the apparently missed exponential growth thing.

Years ago at a physics conference we had a guest speaker whose thesis was that a great many problems in the world stem from people not really understanding exponential growth.

114:

This is therefore going to lead to our premature deaths, even if we dodge COVID19 successfully.

As a first approximation, would going back to the days before antibiotics be a reasonable analogy?

115:

Yes, except we've already gone back to the days before antibiotics -- antibiotic resistant bacteria kill tens of thousands of folks a year in the UK simply because most of our antibiotics barely work any more.

116:

Jewdas is a left-wing Jewish Diaspora group, based in London. Their work includes parodies of both anti-semitic and pro-zionist [expletive deleted], along with a certain amount of community outreach and cultural stuff. No idea what specific thing of theirs SotMN is refering to here.

(They came to a lot of people's attention when Corbyn attended a passover seder they held and was promptly attacked by the press for "being antisemitic" by going to a jewish festival with what our definitely non-hateful media mysteriously decided were the wrong kind of jews.)

117:

The days when a prime minister regarded their duty to be to the country are long gone. Currently, it comes after the (usually foreign) plutocrats, the knuckle-dragging backbenchers, and the sheeple that are needed to win elections.

While Omicron is spreading exponentially for now, that cannot continue indefinitely. What we don't know is what will happen when the majority of the country has been infected, and is being reinfected. Bozo et al. are assuming the most optimistic outcome; SAGE, Whitty etc. are more realistic, but are being ignored.

As OGH said, satirising this is almost impossible.

118:

I offer for the optimists here my definition of the "new normal": Each year will be worse than the previous year, but the rate at which things get worse will continually increase.

I'm uncertain whether the increase is linear, geometric, or exponential, however (and since I'm disabled in the UK, probably won't live long enough to find out).

119:

Re: 'Sturgeon has no powers to even test those entering from outside Scotland, whether from other parts of the UK or outside it.'

'Power' is often used interchangeably with 'budget' - so unless it's a cheap (easy) fix, pols are unlikely to try to implement it.

Just saw this on my GoogNews page - no mention of Omicron but still hopeful that this type of test can be easily adapted to measure a variety of new types of antibody.

Here's a plain language version ...

https://www.utoronto.ca/news/u-t-researchers-low-cost-pinprick-test-measures-covid-19-immunity-under-one-hour

'... a pinprick test that accurately measures the concentration of coronavirus antibodies in blood in under one hour. And it’s cheap – costing a toonie ($2 CDN) or about tenth of current tests.

Their method is detailed in a study published this week in the journal Nature Communications.

“Our assay is as sensitive as, if not better than, any other currently available assay in detecting low levels of IgG antibodies and its specificity – also known as false-positive rate – is as good as the best antibody test on the market,” said Stagljar, who collaborated with public health agencies and blood banks from across Canada to have the test validated on blood samples taken from former COVID-19 patients.'

Here's the link for the published article:

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-22102-6

Article title - no bets that Murdoch/FauxNews go apesh*t over at least one biochem term.

"A homogeneous split-luciferase assay for rapid and sensitive detection of anti-SARS CoV-2 antibodies"

120:

Charlie

Why 20/02/2001?

@ 110: Wait for another Dead Cat, as BoZo & his tame lickspittle ( Paul Scully ) make sure the conditions set for TfL are unreachable & the Capitals' transport collapses, for which they will then do their best to blame Khan - who, being an idiot, has walked right into this one ...

Talking of fitness, I had to get some blood-pressure readings. An average of approx. 123/82 isn't bad for a an almost-76-year old.

Oh yes, why has the type-in box started to require a double carriage-return to get a new-line in the viewed output?

121:

Why 20/02/2001?

The date of George W. Bush's inauguration. After which, policy changes basically rendered 9/11 inevitable (and with PNAC neocons running the State Department, made a short victorious war likewise inevitable).

122:

Sounds about right, I have little in the way of foresight, but a new variety of COVID every year or two until after I've died would not be a surprise.

123:

Rapid (cheap) COVID test ...

And they've got a short (0:02:31) YT video white-board animation/drawings explaining the test! Hope other researchers adopt this multimedia approach to explain their research.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vu17zrzjarI&ab_channel=TheRoyalInstitution

'Introducing: A rapid, sensitive test for detection of antibodies against SARS-CoV-2'

The date on this video is March 2021 - quite a lag to publishing.

124:

>>I swear I have no idea how to even satirize this using the New Management.

James Nicoll's review of Doomsday Book by Connie Willis.

Humorous (?) how things that seemed incredibly unlikely now seem extremely probable:

https://jamesdavisnicoll.com/review/confusion

125:

Well, I'm just back from having the third hole poked in my arm. Pfizer again. Town centre heaving on the way there.

Had a good laugh on the way back from spotting a house roof that has been completely covered in solar panels. On the north side. FFS.

126:

"Oh yes, why has the type-in box started to require a double carriage-return to get a new-line in the viewed output?"

I imagine it's a side effect of the addition of markdown support.

(Is that actually worth keeping, Charlie? Nobody seemed to be over the moon about it, but it does appear to be breaking several people's URLs and post formatting.)

127:

infection rates scale exponentially over time while fatality per infection (the case fatality rate) remains linear.

Again, though this assumes a vulnerable population with no upper bound. Looking at it from the opposite direction (ie, total population), the situation looks a lot different. A country with 100 million people will get infected with omicron faster and experience deaths faster, but ultimately will have fewer deaths overall than with the delta variant. IE, a case fatality rate for delta of 1%, in a population of 100 million all of whom get it, would result in 1 million deaths. If omicron's fatality rate was 1/5 of delta that would be .2%, resulting in 200,000 dead.

This assumes that having a case means you have (some level of) immunity against another case, which has been the situation with earlier variants, though it's too early to tell with omicron.

Obviously -- like all these discussions -- this is highly simplified.

(As a specific example, the delta variant, which was more transmissible than previous ones, had a lower peak of deaths and lower total deaths (so far) in the United States than earlier variants. There's all sorts of confounding issues with this, though, including the vaccines, so it's hard to claim much from it.)

128:

TermiteDellaPunteggiatura @98: I recently came across a short article by Derek Lowe on curcumin research. It seems to be really easy to produce spurious positive findings. So I'd be wary even of peer-reviewed science on this compound.

Thanks -- good article. Informative, illuminating, and (as you point out) short.

However, it doesn't move me to discontinue turmeric. The point of the article is that curcumin is a "waste of time". From the author's point of view -- scientific skepticism, which I do endorse in general -- that's a valid interpretation.

I, on the other hand, am not approaching this from a scientific point of view. I'm doing personal risk management. Let me break it down in Teaching the Horse To Sing fashion:

  • Turmeric seems to be beneficial to me, to some extent.
  • If the benefit is physiologically real, then discontinuing would be foolish.
  • If the benefit is not physiologically real, it may be a placebo effect. As I have mentioned, I'll take a placebo effect if I can get it.
  • If the benefit is not physiologically real, and is not providing me with a placebo effect, it's a simple mistaken belief.
  • Since the benefit of turmeric is possibly actual, the cost of discontinuing might be negligible, but could be significant.
  • The downside of continuing with turmeric as a hopeful therapy is minimal. It costs little, and I've not seen documented side effects.

I do approach measures that are not scientifically supported with considerable caution. However, the ongoing scientific quest for truth about turmeric is not my main concern. In medical and nutritional areas, science is slow because human subjects are widely variable and many effects take a long time to appear. I don't have time to wait for a final consensus.

129:

As folks have been telling me for the last five years and more, solar panels are really cheap and getting cheaper every year so why NOT put them on the north-facing roof too? It's not like it's the Dark Side of the Moon there.

I've seem pictures of an American two-storey tract home which has solar panels on the walls around the upper windows. This could become a lot more common as solar panels inevitably drop in price to a dollar per square metre.

130:

Over the next few years virtually everyone is going to catch some strain of Covid.

This is a thing that is going to happen that no power or technology currently on earth will prevent.

However, there is strong reason to believe that the vaccines will in most people prevent serious disease. That’s the whole point of them, or to prevent you catching it but to prevent tot from dying of it.

The early days seems to show that the vaccines + booster are just fine at preventing serious disease for Omicron as well. Still too early to make that call but so far, so good.

The other hopeful thing is we now have reasonably effective treatments. These need to be fully deployed however.

With regards to long Covid the real question is do the vaccines so prevent that? I do not know the answer there but we are going to find out.

131:

Yes, Markdown is worth keeping.

URL syntax has changed, but:

[name of target](url_goes_here)

Gives you a named link; If your link includes a backslash, escape it thuswise: \\

Overall there's a lot less typing involved and it's easier to remember than raw HTML. It's also the same syntax used on Reddit, Wikipedia, in Discord, and on a host of other popular websites.

132:

In terms of how contagious omicron is, I provide what the writer of this comment on a different board provided. Additionally the commentator has had covid, despite being double jabbed early in the fall due to attending a soccer match with tens of thousands of fans. His entire family then got covid, one at a time, over a period of weeks.

[ "Some anecdotal evidence about how easily omicron spreads. My daughters ballet teacher had a class last Tuesday am where one person tested positive.

Since then every single person in the class tested positive, and everyone in her Tuesday afternoon class other than one woman who was triple jabbed and has had a previous infection also tested positive. Positive side, nobody was particularly ill. " ]

133:

In Scotland? The demand is considerably the greatest in winter, and the sun reaches a massive 10.5 degrees about the horizon (with a 6 hour day) in midwinter. Even on a horizontal surface, you can't expect much more than 130 KJ/day (*) per square metre, and you will get half that on a UK sloping roof.

(*) Roughly 2 KW-minutes.

136:

~Laughs~

Yeah, if Nyarlahotep threw a wild party and did less than a trillion in properly damage it wouldn't be very credible. At the very least I'd expect a large hole in the ground. And who's he going to invite? Hastur and Yog-Sothoth? Better hope Azathoth doesn't show up!

137:

I regard that as the date the Republican Party officially became put-them-in-a-hospital-and-keep-them-there insane. (They started being unhealthy when Nixon ran for president in 1968 and negotiated with the Viet Cong.)

138:

On the north side? There's a lawsuit!

139:

"markdown support" = ????
And .. "Markdown" is, or appears to be a simpler form / format / tool than HTML ...
err .. THIS one? - said he using HTML ...
Linkie to where I can find a set of clues to rely on, that are "Easy-to-Use" please? There seem to be several available - which one do people recommend, in other words.

I must say that pictures seem to be easier .. Though - do they still need a pre-existing URL - or can one post from one's own files?
I ask because I still can't get into "tinyurl", as it's full of self-advertisement & no clues
Oh, & how does one present Square-Brackets in this formatting?

140:

icehawk @ 83:

"I haven't heard anything about 'Omicron' reaching North Carolina yet"

Would you know?

Serious question. Here in New Zealand I believe we're still genome-sequencing all positive Covid cases, so we know exactly what's here and if you get Covid they'll know which cluster you are in, and quite likely who you got it from. So we know that all cases in the community in our country now - and for the last few months - track back to one failure at the border. So it's all Delta here, for now, as one case of Delta got in past our border controls.

But are you guys doing similar and genome-sequencing all - or a lot of - the cases that test positive? It's really hard to tell just what's going on internationally, and how different places compare in their testing and genome sequencing.

The Governor & public health officials have been holding regular news briefings on how things are going on the Covid front - mostly number of cases, trends & progress on getting people to get vaccinated - but they did talk about "Delta" when it showed up. So I expect once "Omicron" reaches North Carolina it will be mentioned in the briefing.

North Carolina has a NPR mini-network (mostly in the east) based on WUNC radio which carries the briefings live and the local TV stations have it in their news feeds and I see both sources pop up in Google News.

I'm guessing Google's algorithm takes into account the IP address block assigned to my ISP and the frequency I click on local news stories - especially about Covid - and includes it in what it serves up to me.

Short answer, I expect to see it reported in the news when (not IF, WHEN) it gets here.

141:

Oops! NOT "tinyurl", my bad. I'm looking for a really easy way to get piccies from my files into a URL-format for easy transmission/publication. And Photobucket have screwed up & the other one wasn't helpful either

142:

Yes, that MarkDown.

Let's test with the preview button:

[I am in brackets]

(I am in parentheses)

but brackets followed by parens makes a link

  • an asterisk for a bullet point

emphasized text inside a pair of asterisk

really emphasized text inside a double pair

143:

'Power' is often used interchangeably with 'budget' - so unless it's a cheap (easy) fix, pols are unlikely to try to implement it.

The powers of Holyrood, and thus the Scottish Government, are defined in the three Scotland Acts. Whilst Public Health is devolved, which could be used to justify testing people entering Scotland, Immigration is not devolved, so detaining people for testing as they enter Scotland might well be unlawful.

... and the Scottish Tories and Labour would probably be very keen to argue it was unlawful, and also an example of the SNP trying to divide the UK! Presumably to be followed later on by arguing that the extra deaths caused by people not being tested as they entered Scotland was the fault of the SNP.

144:

Yabbut when solar panels are cheaper than paint (next year maybe?) people can just fix them on every surface on their house even if the positional efficiency isn't the best.

145:

The current work-in-progress contains --

(This is not a spoiler, it won't be out for more than a year and may well change before publication)

-- The Prime Minister, who throws a royal reception, and Eve Starkey is invited.

It is made clear to her that Gifts are Expected: specifically the skull of Rupert de Montfort Bigge. (His Nibs collects skulls, as should be clear by this point in the series.)

Luckily Eve has the aforementioned skull, or at least a skull purportedly belonging to RdeMB (hint: it shows up in the last chapter of Quantum of Nightmares).

The PM receives the cranium, touches it, and says, "hmm, full marks for trying, but this is the skull of the wrong Rupert de Montfort Bigge: bring me the right one, there's a good girl."

(This is what is called a plot point, in the trade.)

Anyway: white tie receptions at Lancaster House, the Black Pharaoh taking a keen personal interest in a couple of protagonists, implication that Eve fails to find the right skull her own will do perfectly well as a substitute, you get the idea.

146:

Yes, that Markdown.

To enter a special character (like [ or ] or \) just prefix it with a backslash to tell Markdown to ignore it.

Here's a basic guide to Markdown syntax.

147:

SFReader @ 85:

Re: 'There is a third aspect to my recovery: physical activity.'

Yeah - regular moderate exercise is key. Some people need a more structured plan like the below to help make sure that they exercise all of their bits.

https://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/physical_medicine_rehabilitation/coronavirus-rehabilitation/_files/impact-of-covid-patient-recovery.pdf

I have trouble with some of those and I haven't had Covid - short or long (parts of me that got broke from over-use or abuse whenI was younger). And I think some of that "brain fog" may just be a part of natural aging ... having Covid on top of it makes it worse, but it's already there before you get Covid.

Another thing that I've seen crop up is cognitive therapy (CI Therapy) which sorta looks similar to the behavioral re-education/physical re-training rehab that's given to people who've suffered strokes.

There's also: getting enough restful sleep, avoiding stressful situations and doing some meditation type exercises like tai chi (see below) that demand extended periods of mental focus combined with fine physical/muscular coordination while also being relaxing.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8054611/

Having nothing to do all day but sit at this damn computer doesn't help my insomnia. I don't do Tai Chi, but I do have housework that needs doing. I try to get up up and do a few minutes after every comment I write, but that's hard too if I get carried away ... and the little dog don't like it so much because he's just got comfortable in my lap and I get up and the lap goes away. There's a lot of inertia to overcome and the isolation of quarantine aggravates my natural laziness.

148:

the little dog don't like it so much because he's just got comfortable in my lap and I get up and the lap goes away

How big is 'little'? You can get puppy chest carriers that are kinda like baby carriers (the womb-with-a-view model, not the backpack ones).

149:

Yabbut when solar panels are cheaper than paint (next year maybe?) people can just fix them on every surface on their house even if the positional efficiency isn't the best.

I realize piss-taking is ongoing, but I wanted to bring up a couple of semi-serious nits to pick.

One is that there's about a million metric fucktares of suboptimal roofs in dire need of solar paneling. These vary from those that were designed to be "cosmetically attractive" dormer heaven models to old homes whose roofs weren't designed for the weight of panels. There's therefore a huge potential market for smaller, lighter panels.

The other is that certain environmental groups are looking into the whole carbon offsets scam sector. Instead of buying up tree farms and promising not to cut them for 50 years, only to watch them burn, the enviros are looking into paying for solar on the roofs of poor people's homes and apartment buildings. If this helps them get off GHG emissions, it's not a bad thing, and since it's in a city, it's theoretically easier to monitor than a forestry project.*

Anyway, go back to having fun with us solar idiots, but if you have any other ideas along the line of solarizing towns for fun and profit, send them my way. There's actually room for change.

*Speaking as a one-time vegetation ecologist, the one time I looked at actual planting and monitoring data from one of these projects, I was unamused.

150:

Speaking as a one-time vegetation ecologist, the one time I looked at actual planting and monitoring data from one of these projects, I was unamused.

Back in the 1970s there was a Big Thing about growing pulpwood in Scotland on hillfarms and other marginal lands. It was the sort of depauperate monoculture you'd expect but in these enlightened days it would be considered Green as fuck because "trees!".

However the tax benefits and investment vehicles that flowered like desert plants in the rain based on buying 45-degree land at a hundred quid an acre and planting it with Government-subsidised trees that wouldn't be harvested for decades (when the capital gains bill would come due) were very much sought after. A lot of folks who weren't actually in the pulp timber biz like comedians and actors ended up owning surprisingly large parts of Scotland, at least temporarily.

151:

Didn't know that, thanks!

Yes, it's something like that in the carbon offset game. Basically, you have a tree farm, and the carbon offset market pays you to leave the trees planted, rather than cutting them on a 50 year rotation. I've even seem some proposals to do carbon offsets by paying a tree farmer not to cut for 30 years. If this is on a tree farm with a 50 year crop, well golly gee, that's an additional revenue stream...

The real problem that's become apparent in the last two years is that tree farms in northern California burn quite enthusiastically, especially when under severe drought. You may have seen these reported as wildfires in your news feed. And they were. Partially. Most of the land that burned had already been logged, often several times. So investing in reforesting these places on the assumption they won't burn in the next century? That's risky.

So far as growing trees like corn in monocultures... There's this little problem. Corn's an annual. Even so, it has its share of pests, even though it's only around for a few months. Trees that are planted in dense, genetically uniform stands and left for decades? Yeah, they're, what's the word...oh yeah, vulnerable. That's a big problem with industrial forestry. While they've made progress towards making super weed trees, I don't think it's a solved problem yet.

152:

That all sounds great and it sets up the rest of the book very nicely, but it doesn't satirize Boris's Xmas party. My point was that you'd have to get a bit further out there to make proper fun of the current PM, as in "what could the Black Pharaoh do that would actually result in having questions asked in Parliament which might bring him down politically?"

Answer? Go on a "Great Old Drunk" with his Elder-God buddies and do some real damage.

153:

The obvious improvement would be some kind of mixed crops, (the other obvious improvement would be a government which takes Climate Change seriously.)

154:

I think the pulpwood cycle was about thirty years or so, this was not an attempt to re-establish the great Caledonian Forest which had been nearly all logged out for iron-making charcoal a couple of centuries back. I certainly remember seeing one such pulpwood plantation going in just to the north of my father's cousin's hillfarm in the Central Belt and seeing it logged out some time later at about the thirty year mark. I do remember just how badly the ground was rutted and dug up from the industrial-grade machinery used to harvest the pulpwood trees.

The monoculture was worse than just lots of the same type of tree, they were actually cloned rather than grown from seed to reduce costs and guarantee all the trees being cropped would be at optimal growth when the time came. Driving through the Borders of Scotland you'd see these great swathes of pulpwood covering the hills, dotted with clumps of dead trees where some pest or disease had taken out every tree within reach before the owners could get in and cut firebreaks to stop the spread.

Timber wildfires aren't often a thing in Scotland although sometimes bracken and gorse will catch fire or be set on fire by idiots in the summer if it's hot and dry enough. It's pretty rare for the fires to go anywhere much though and controlled burning of the hillsides is often done in the late summer to prep the ground for overwintering sheep later in the year.

155:

I think the burnout rate in the USA is going to stay with us for a long time. Last week I received my covid booster in a small rural Utah county of 2,500 people (2,500 sq miles/6,400 sq km, or a little smaller than Devon). My wife works at a nearby national park, so that's where I spend my winter months. The young nurse administering the shot was a former ICU nurse who quit her job at a Salt Lake City hospital after working non-stop with covid patients for the past 18 months. We had some time to chat, and I'm surprised she lasted that long. Extra shifts, an average of 2 patients dying per shift (the record was 7), working in full protective gear in a negative pressure environment, which meant that taking a bathroom break necessitated leaving the floor and spending a significant amount of time getting out of her protective gear. Knowing that other patients weren't getting the care they needed because every ICU bed was filled with a covid patient (don't get a heart attack in SLC, it won't end well). This on top of getting to know multiple patients for a week or two before intubating them, knowing that the majority would die, or if they survived, have chronic health issues for the rest of their lives.

She chose to move back to the small town she's from and work to get more people vaccinated there. They're up to 51%, so perhaps she's having an impact. I'm glad she's nearby, but that kind of loss multiplied by many thousands is going to have huge impacts on the USA's already disfunctional healthcare system.

156:

My son's SO is a nurse at an infusion clinic. It's associated with a world class cancer and transplant hospital so well, they don't want to kill off the immuno compromised folks.

For months she went from dealing with 5 or 6 patients a day in the clinic to visiting the homes (hotels for many) of 2 to 3 a day. They are now back in the clinic but she getting worn out. And dealing with the hoaxers, deniers, etc... is no fun. Not so much the patients but all their relatives and friends.

Many medical centers in the US have been refusing transplants to people who will not vaccinate or will not live a life after the transplant to avoid Covid. (Why invest $100K to $1mil into someone who is almost trying to die soon after?) All of this is raising the stress level.

157:

Duffy @ 89: So is it correct to say that, if compared to delta, omicron is 5x as infectious and 1/5th as fatal, then the same number of people die from omicron as for delta?

My guess is it's going to depend oh whether we can convince the anti-Vaxxers & CovIDIOTS to get vaccinated.

My opinion is still anyone who goes to the ER with Covid symptoms and hasn't been vaccinated, they should be sent home with a tube of horse dewormer paste.

"Don't come back until you've been vaccinated. There are sick people who are here through no fault of their own and you don't need to be sucking up resources we need to use for them."

158:

I think the burnout rate in the USA is going to stay with us for a long time.

I have a suspicion that the nursing school entrants are more likely to be from the anti-vac crowd. Just a feeling but still. And if I'm right it will not help us dig out.

(My son tried to do nursing but his brain wasn't wired for the memorization needed.)

159:

She of many names under yet another pseudonym @ 90: No-one reads our comments, but no, not really.

That's because "no-one" here understands WTF you're talking about any more than you do.

Maybe try for clarity instead of cryptic cynicism.

160:

Charlie Stross @ 121:

Why 20/02/2001?

The date of George W. Bush's inauguration. After which, policy changes basically rendered 9/11 inevitable (and with PNAC neocons running the State Department, made a short victorious war likewise inevitable).

With the PNAC neocons in charge WAR was inevitable, but there was never any chance it was going to be either short or victorious. They'd been drinking their own Kool-Aid for too long

... and still are.

161:

Some places have rationed ICU care, and that's how they do it.

Beyond burnout, the other interesting factor is the rise of traveling nurses. There's a sub-industry of nurses doing contract work: travel to a place, live there for a few months, work in a hospital or whatever. The pay is higher than for a regular RN, because there's no job security.

A number of nurses are quitting their career gigs and becoming traveling nurses to replace the others who are leaving, especially if they're young and don't have families. The pay is higher, and if they fry, they can take time out without getting fired. The end result is that hospitals are paying more to employ traveling nurses than they were for staff nurses, and the travelers they get aren't as familiar with the local systems as the staffers they're replacing.

A bit awkward, that, but it's capitalism in action.

162:

"what could the Black Pharaoh do that would actually result in having questions asked in Parliament which might bring him down politically?"

Nothing practical. He's an immortal eldritch abomination and absolute despot. Nobody can stand up against him within the UK: at the end of the Laundry series arc the monsters won (although the humans managed to stall their ability to continue to bootstrap their presence in our universe to the max).

See, it's like asking what Queen Elizabeth II could do that would bring her down politically. Per YouGov polling h popularity rating is 72%, only 11% of the UK public dislike her, and 97% have heard of her, meaning she's more famous than Jesus. Liz could probably stab Boris Johnson in public and get a round of applause: dance naked across Tower Bridge ditto (except she's 95 and won't do either of those things), about the only things I can think of that would make her, personally, less popular would be to abdicate or maybe to marry Donald Trump. (CASE NIGHTMARE ROYAL CONSORT.)

163:

I have a suspicion that the nursing school entrants are more likely to be from the anti-vac crowd.

Nursing is an "acceptable" career track for women from a certain type of religious background. So you end up with a proportion of young-earth creationists, i.e. evolution denialists, in that profession, and they just can't cope with antibiotic resistance or vaccines or anything that forces them to think outside their carefully welded-shut box of religious shibboleths.

(The rote memorization incidentally is part -- a small part, admittedly -- of the reason I eventually bailed on being a pharmacist. My memory is shit, always has been, and I spent way too much time looking things up in books because I couldn't be certain I remembered it.)

164:

becoming traveling nurses to replace the others who are leaving, especially if they're young and don't have families. The pay is higher

In the neighborhood of $250K. More or less depending on need and location. Which is double or triple a regular gig.

165:

there was never any chance it was going to be either short or victorious

Yeah, I was being sarcastic (I think at this point in time anyone who thinks Iraq or Afghanistan were "short" or "victorious" needs a rest in a padded cell) and referring to Vyacheslav Plehve, who famously said "To avert a revolution, we need a small victorious war." (He didn't get it.)

166:

I'd love to see Liz marry Donald Trump. He'd probably have to become a British citizen and that would remove him from U.S. politics. (Definitely not gonna happen, though.)

167:

110 - In this case, "absence of evidence is absence of investigation"?

119 "Sturgeon has no powers to even test those entering from outside Scotland". That is very much the case. The Scottish government does not have powers that could be used to stop people entering Scotland from literally anywhere.

125 - I can't quite match that, but I did notice a neighbour with solar panels on the West face. Those won't receive insolation until the afternoon, when they'll maybe get 3 hours.

128 - I've seen anecdotal suggestion that tumeric also has some effects against arthritis and hypertension.

152 - Could Charlie actually satirise better than Allegra Stratton already has?

New Mark-up issue; I can't always update/edit a comment that I've previewed. Attempting to do so sometimes generates a "server hang-up".

168:

icehawk@83: Would you know?

Serious question. Here in New Zealand I believe we're still genome-sequencing all positive Covid cases, so we know exactly what's here and if you get Covid they'll know which cluster you are in, and quite likely who you got it from. So we know that all cases in the community in our country now - and for the last few months - track back to one failure at the border. So it's all Delta here, for now, as one case of Delta got in past our border controls.

Given the spotty nature of testing here in the States, a lot of our knowledge of how the variants are doing comes from testing wastewater. To bookend our experience with it, here's an article from Ars on a preprint on the subject back in May, 2020: Poop alert: Sewage could signal impending burst of COVID-19 cases and ABC7 posted one yesterday about detecting Omicron: Traces of omicron found in Southern California sewage, scientists say

169:

I just got COVID-tested today. Not happy, but I don't seem to have a bad case (if I have it at all.)

170:

" I don't do Tai Chi, but I do have housework that needs doing."

There are other exercises that are vaguely Tai Chi-ish that could keep your body moving. I think someone has already recommended Leslie Sansone's videos, and I'd endorse that.

E.g., https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DYuw4f1c4xs

171:

Luckily there are numerous reasons why it can't happen.

Firstly, Trump's vulgar AF, and Liz does not put up with that kind of shit.

Secondly, he'd have to get a divorce. (That used to be an obstacle to marrying into the Firm: less so as of Chuck'n'Camilla, but still questionable for the head of state's nominal squeeze.)

Thirdly, he'd have to convert to CofE and attend services regularly -- after all, it's her church (as in: one of her titles is "defender of the faith").

Fourthly, there are a lot of duties attached and Trump would fuck them up appallingly and end up under house arrest in a drafty castle in the highlands within a matter of minutes. (Nodding, smiling, and listening politely is part of the package. Phil the Greek got away with the odd off-colour joke, but he was a war hero and an eccentric royal. Trump would be crucified by the British press -- look how they monstered Meghan Markle: they're a lot more aggressive and nasty than the servile US presidential press corps.)

Fifthly, he wouldn't be allowed any social media or dodgy business deals that might backfire and stain the reputation of the Royal Family. Prince Charles sticks his name very delicately in front of some products of the Duchy of Cornwall -- expensive, high quality, organically farmed/artisanally produced foods -- and that was nearly too controversial for the royals.

Sixthly, he wouldn't get a crown. No "King Donald" allowed: he'd be, at best, the royal consort, married to the Queen, and granted a toy title from the stockpile of vacant ones the royal family keep on hand for the kids when they need to present as duke of this or princess of that.

Finally, she's 95 and you don't get better from being 95. Sooner or later -- probably sooner -- she'd die and he'd be politely invited to fuck off back to America.

(There's a promising romcom concept in here, and I could probably get my agent interested, but I don't need the hate mail I'd get from my UK readers.)

172:

Robert Prior @ 148:

the little dog don't like it so much because he's just got comfortable in my lap and I get up and the lap goes away

How big is 'little'? You can get puppy chest carriers that are kinda like baby carriers (the womb-with-a-view model, not the backpack ones).

I've got one. Doesn't work to well with a 15lb Shih-Tzu because he's just a tiny bit too big for the one I bought. I probably should look to see if they make a larger one, but the pet supply store doesn't really allow me to "test drive" them to see if he's going to fit.

And it's useless for house cleaning because he won't stay in it when I bend over to pick stuff up.

173:

Troutwaxer @ 166: I'd love to see Liz marry Donald Trump. He'd probably have to become a British citizen and that would remove him from U.S. politics. (Definitely not gonna happen, though.)

If you're gonna' wish that evil shit on somebody, why not wish it on someone evil? What's Liz ever done to you?

If Trumpolini is gonna' dump Melanoma to make a political match, he should marry Putin.

174:

Another factor that probably influences the progress of my recovery from brain fog is that our household is vegan. ... vascular dementia has been a concern of mine for family history reasons.
I was hesitant to suggest anything since I don't have personal experience with long-COVID , but vegans sometimes have insufficient DHA (an Omega 3 fatty acid) and choline; both are easily supplemented (inc vegan), and there is pre-COVID-19 lore relating deficiencies in both to brain fog, and also some mixed-results science (including recovery from brain injury and reductions in all-cause dementia), easily found with scholar.google.com. And there is that tantalizing UK biobank study[1] (still a preprint, but cited a bunch of times) finding loss of grey matter (which DHA might help rebuild) in some COVID-19 patients. But the effects of DHA (if any in an adult) are not obvious in my experience.
Choline definitely immediately helps my brain/mental clarity (especially visualization and metacognition) - a high-quality source like "alpha-gpc" or "citicoline", spread over the day.
As SotMNs says, Piracetam is a essentially-non-toxic-except-in-very-large-doses nootropic; it should be combined with a choline source. Not approved in the US but available, approved (prescription) in Europe. There are other stronger racetams and related compounds, but that one has a long half life in the body and is well-studied. (And a bunch of other nootropics, but be warned that that's a rabbit hole.)
As SotMNs also says, depending on the nature of the ... deficits, there are other approaches. (Not all legal, and some a bit risky. And she knows rather more than I do, I am sure.)

Re the vascular dementia, exercise is definitely good and you have that covered. Basically anything improving blood flow to the brain (excepting hypertension).

I do approach measures that are not scientifically supported with considerable caution. However, the ongoing scientific quest for truth about turmeric is not my main concern. In medical and nutritional areas, science is slow because human subjects are widely variable and many effects take a long time to appear. I don't have time to wait for a final consensus.
This is the right attitude, IMO.
It also applies at a larger scale, to e.g. anti-COVID-19 public health measures, which should attempting to stop/slow the exponential growth when it's easier, not when is undeniably obvious.

[1] Brain imaging before and after COVID-19 in UK Biobank (preprint, June 15, 2021)

175:

I think I see some parallels between H. W. Bush + team -> W. Bush + team and Bismark + Moltke the Elder -> Kaiser Wilhelm II + Moltke the Younger. Last time it was a short, victorious war! Plus, I'm better than my father / ex-chancellor / uncle! I'm going to do what they could not! I'm going to finish what they started! Narrator: About that...

176:

Got my 3rd booster shot of Pfizer three weeks ago and my annual flu shot the week before that. Took sick leave the next day after getting the booster, felt muzzy headed and fatigued, with an aching shoulder (Uh, why was I in the kitchen? Oh, yeah, I was going to make the coffee). Felt fine a day later.

Regardless, I decided not to go to Michigan for the holidays, they’re dealing with high rates of Delta right now. My niece’s family contracted Covid two weeks ago, she had a cough and congestion, her husband just lost taste and smell (both were vaccinated), their four-year-old son had a fever with sniffles. Their symptoms lasted three days and have recently tested negative. They were scheduled to get their boosters when they got sick.

Not to suggest that things are hunky dory here in Texas. It is utterly stupefying that Texas Gov. Greg Abbott issued an executive order prohibiting COVID-19 Vaccine mandates and before that banned mask mandates for schools (A federal judge overruled Gov. Greg Abbotts ban on mask mandates for schools in violation of the Americans with Disabilities Act). Meanwhile, COVID-19 (Delta) continues to spread in Texas as well.

177:

There's a promising romcom concept in here, and I could probably get my agent interested, but I don't need the hate mail I'd get from my UK readers.

You'd be amazed (I am) at how many folks in the US follow the royals. My wife does. Or did. Mostly now she's into documentaries or docudramas about various things a few decades or more ago. I personally follow it as closely as I do Oz rules football.

Hooking Trump into it would create a huge backlash here. At least with 1/2 of the population. :)

178:

"Markdown"
Thanks to everybody - will study.

JBS @ 159
I've been saying that for YEARS - does it make any difference? Nah.

179:

Aka: "This is just the flu, waaa waaa.... WAAAAARGH, IT'S A CULTURE WAAAR".
I checked the 5 Dec Andrew Neil twitter feed like you suggested(IIRC). Was tempted to dive in A-10 style at the replies to Mr Neil, who is (or should be) getting a lesson in influence ops. Irritating shifts in the antivax messaging.

This table is good, and there may be subsequent updates in the thread. (Image at the pic link.)
Omicron neuts studies ... Strong discrepancy between studies with live vs pseudo.

Dec 9th CET morning update. Now with the results of @JanineKimpel as well. pic.twitter.com/ORBsCH2dxH

— Yaniv Erlich (@erlichya) December 9, 2021
180:

Kardashev @ 170:

" I don't do Tai Chi, but I do have housework that needs doing."

There are other exercises that are vaguely Tai Chi-ish that could keep your body moving. I think someone has already recommended Leslie Sansone's videos, and I'd endorse that.

E.g., https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DYuw4f1c4xs

Yeah, I already walk for exercise. Don't really have room inside to do it the way she does, but I get about half an hour every day, but I wouldn't get through that workout.

Hips, knees & ankles are trashed from my years in the military; carrying too much weight. But the REAL problem is severe stress incontinence from radical prostate surgery.

I've got to have another operation to implant an AUS device. The VA isn't doing "elective" surgery right now.

181:

Liz beat me up in Middle School. I don't care who Trump marries - just get him out of our country!

182:

News story: Main, NH, and NY are mobilizing the National Guard to help with medical issues of overworked and understaffed.

183:

Liz beat me up in Middle School. I don't care who Trump marries - just get him out of our country!

I think Liz has spent enough time, erm, thinking of England.

My vote would be for Andrew.

Now, given the way those two operate, I'd only like to see Andrew and Donnie get hitched if they're sharing a cell. Not hunting as a pack...

184:

Took sick leave the next day after getting the booster, felt muzzy headed and fatigued, with an aching shoulder (Uh, why was I in the kitchen? Oh, yeah, I was going to make the coffee). Felt fine a day later.

My wife and I had those general symptoms for a day or so after each shot. And I've had them after about 1/3 of my flu shots over the years. My brain fog I attribute to the sinus headache I tend to get which just makes me pissed at the universe while it lasts.

As to the arm hurt, I can't remember a shot that has caused that. At least not for a few decades. Even the fat needle ones. Maybe it comes from all the day to day scratches and whacks I got growing up where we did all our own home and auto repairs then the small tractor driving a did as a teen. I think I just shrug off minor nicks.

Ah, Texas. We had an apartment in the DFW area for 10 years. Closed it up summer of 2020. Glad we did. I was a resident of NC the entire time. My wife is officially back. Abbot is just nuts. Well him and Patrick and friends are doing everything possible to hold onto power. Google Patrick and seven mountains if you want to get scared.

186:

My house faces East - West. Like many old houses in Norfolk it has a steep roof at the East (front) elevation and a shallow West facing roof which has about twice the area. According the the table in “Which” a 30 degree west facing roof will give 97 percent of the maximum possible. And since it’s the back of the house it won’t be visible from the road so the fact that it’s in a conservation area shouldn’t cause planning problems. South facing is not the only option.

https://www.which.co.uk/reviews/solar-panels/article/solar-panels/solar-panel-installation-aiRvu3N6OyEN

187:

A day ago I wrote this:

but we are a 50/50 state where the legislature supports "freedom" most of the time so there is a constant fight. And the rural areas are more "freedom" than "we need to deal".

Then today I saw this: USA Freedom

188:

You can get puppy chest carriers that are kinda like baby carriers

I just wore my normal small rucksack across my chest for a trip into Transreal to pick up "Invisible Sun" on release, with one of her blankets in the bottom - the Pup hadn't completed her vaccinations. She was very tolerant [1], and quite enjoyed it.

Two weeks later, and she was having none of it; wanted to walk everywhere. Right now she's 16kg of enthusiastic Labrador pup, and was actually quite good on her second visit to the shop...

[1] Mike was very tolerant too - the pup is cuter than the rugrats were when I carried them around in chest harnesses / backpacks... (firstborn is nearly twenty now)

189:

icehawk asked on December 8, 2021 21:37 in #83:

Would you know?

We would know in Oregon. This week, Oregon scientists begin testing wastewater for the Omicron variant. Wastewater surveillance has previously identified emerging variants, including Delta. In collaboration with Oregon State University (OSU), Oregon Health Authority’s (OHA) wastewater surveillance program monitors sewage for variants of the SARS-CoV-2 virus. The program, launched in September 2020, tests wastewater for COVID-19 in more than 40 communities throughout the state, covering more than 60 percent of Oregon’s population. https://covidblog.oregon.gov/wastewater-surveillance-program-expected-to-detect-omicron-spread-in-communities/

190:

Thirty plus years ago I met Al Kreitler, a maker of bicycle rollers whose toy dog (A full size smaller than a Shih Tzu) habitually rode in Mr Kreitler's bib overalls, tiny head & fore paws peeking out over the top between the straps.

192:

https://phys.org/news/2021-12-anti-covid-stainless-steel.html

High-copper stainless steel kills stuff than lands on it in ways that low-copper doesn't. Since stainless steel is all over public places (etc) this might help reduce spread of {disease of the day}.

High-copper stainless is already a product, but those grades cost more so aren't commonly used. But they're already approved for most uses, so it really just comes down to whether the governments/companies are willing to pay a bit extra. Not sure that will apply inside labs, where stainless is often chose for its other properties (resistance to strong acids, for example)

193:

Houston here. And it's already loose in the community from waste water surveillance and one person that tested positive and has no history of travel. It's in the house with you already.

194:

It is utterly stupefying that Texas Gov. Greg Abbott issued an executive order prohibiting COVID-19 Vaccine mandates

And look at what we/they get. https://appleinsider.com/articles/21/12/09/employee-covid-outbreak-forces-apple-to-close-texas-store

An Apple Store in Texas has shut down after 22 employees tested positive for Covid-19 in the wake of the busy Black Friday shopping weekend.

Upscale outdoor mall north east of the DFW airport. Been in that store a dozen times or more.

But in Texas businesses cannot have mask mandates for customers or employees, last I heard.

195:

[At] the end of the Laundry series arc the monsters won (although the humans managed to stall their ability to continue to bootstrap their presence in our universe to the max).

Kind of reminds me of Clarke's 'Childhood's End'. It might have been one of the inspirations for Laundry, I think.

(Also I like the Markdown, I made one mistake with an url because I didn't remember this was also Markdown. I write most of my documents at work using it nowadays, in addition to many internet places using it, so I think it's good to have here.)

196:

You might become the first person in centuries sent to the Tower by royal command :-)

197:

171 - Phil the Greek was also a product of a bygone age, and IIRC a member of the Greek "royal family" (not clear on his last constitutional position in Greece). Neither of those defences apply to Trumpolini.
And indeed Phil's most prestigious title in the UK was "Queen consort".

173 - snort

176 - There is a low (but non zero) chance of a vaccinator literally striking a nerve when administering any intra-muscular vaccine. OKs?

186 - I can't recall the formula offhand but the efficiency of a solar panel is concerned with sines and cosines of latitude of the installation, right assention of the Sun and installation pitch angle.

195 - I'm having to learn Markdown from scratch. I'm not convinced it has any advantages over HTML, but it doesn't have any obvious issues beyond having to learn it.

198:

Mixed crops is what they are now driving with the forestry grant structures in Scotland - they won't support monocultures, softwoods have to be mixed and an element of broadleaf also has to be included.

199:

The advantage of Markdown is that simple stuff is simple: asterisks for emphasis, blank line for paragraph etc. You can start by just typing, and pick it up as you go along, learning a new bit every so often. The resulting text is also easy to read because the basic Markdown syntax is very close to what people normally type anyway.

In contrast HTML has a big barrier of entry to anyone who hasn't done programming before. This is a tag. Every tag must have a closing tag. Learn a bunch of one-letter codes for tags. You need to know this before you start typing.

I'll grant the hybrid that this blog uses worked OK, but Markdown is now well enough known that it makes sense to introduce it. Though the escaped-underscores thing is a nuisance.

200:

Now that's surprise. /s

201:

Ok, tell me how this was meaningful when I typed it! The HTML tag would explicitly say "boldface" once you'd learnt it.

203:

Noted! You will also find my namesake (a pirate) in one of V. E. Schwab's books. And another (space marine, I think?) in one of Scalzi's. It's common enough among writers who have hung out together IRL.

204:

Well, for *me* using asterisks for emphasis and _underscores_ for italics is something I learned a long time ago, from the BBS times. I think it's been that way for many other people too, and Markdown is a good thing because it is a common definition for things.

So, for me it's easier than HTML (which I've used only for a bit less than those text-only thing). You still have to learn what <b> and <i> mean, and they break the flow of text more. In my opinion.

Also, those links are much easier to write (and read from the source) than the HTML <a> tags.

205:

why dont they grow trees, convert them into charcoal- extract the wood gas as fuel, then landfill the charcoal.? surely that would work?

206:

Markdown was actually a formalization of, and extension of, earlier versions of plain-text markup like SEtext, which indeed go back to BBS days.

Markdown simply added analogs for the most common HTML formatting directives (anything in HTML 3, basically), plus an easier-to-remember hyperlink (the link text you click on is in square braces, followed (in brackets) by the URL it refers to).

You can inline HTML within Markdown text if you want to get fancy. But you don't need the whole raft of recursively nested document classes and subtypes and divisions if all you want is text with the odd link and emphasis.

207:

*185 I saw that article, but I don't think it's any more reliable than the original one. It says that vacuum energy is dark energy which is only a theory, and that this is intrinsic to the fabric of space which I don't think is proven either. Am I wrong?

208:

Yes, I gathered it was not unusual and all in fun.

At least your fictional counterpart seems to have good survival sense.

I sometimes run the tabletop RPG Cyberpunk (from which the computer game Cyberpunk 2077 is descended). The setting is a parallel that diverges from the real world around 1990. I sometimes like to play around with what would have happened to people I know/know of in that alternate. Assuming that they would have survived it.

One thing that does make me chuckle is in that world our current queen is Princess Beatrice, rebranded as Victoria II.

209:

Trump would fuck them up appallingly and end up under house arrest in a drafty castle in the highlands within a matter of minutes

And that's a problem how? Sounds like a positive outcome to me…

210:

Doesn't work to well with a 15lb Shih-Tzu because he's just a tiny bit too big for the one I bought. I probably should look to see if they make a larger one

My niece has one for her 35 lb French Bulldog. He is apparently quite happy with how it takes him everywhere he wants to go without the possibility of someone getting closer to his servant than he is :-)

211:

And here I was hoping that 2022 would be the year to finally visit UK (with both a Sputnik and a Moderna jab, whatever you prefer, officer) for the first time and hear that one band from the 1970's whose music I grew up with in their, well, natural habitat.

Back to hoping that the concert is postponed till the world is slightly less crazy.

212:

204 and 206 - If you're going to start arguing this sort of stuff with me, it may help to know that I first learnt using WordStar (CP/M and MS/DOS), and then WordPerfect 5.1. So I'm kind of used to control codes and function keys (with toggles) for starting and ending formats, legal paragraphs etc. I still hate Wurd style sheets as well.

213:

Re: Tree farms. No idea what is happening in other parts of the world, but foresters moved away from monocultures in the 90s. I was on the front line of that, working as a treeplanter every summer from about 90 to 01.

In the first couple of years we were literally planting monocultures. Spruce was seen as more economically profitable, so we were planting white spruce everywhere, at 2 metre spacing. Of course, all the spruce in high/dry sandy ground has likely died decades ago now.

By the mid-90s we carried mixed bags of trees roughly reflective of whatever had been in place before the logging. In Northern BC that was usually a mix if white and black spruce, pine, alder and fir. With specific instructions where to put each type (i.e. high and sandy=pine, low and wet= white spruce, swampy =black spruce). The ground preparation rules also changed dramatically over that decade, for the loggers and also for us.

It's been 20 years since I left the industry but at least in Alberta and BC the state of the art has long since moved beyond monoculture. Almost certainly that is because monoculture wasn't working. Government regulations required trees to be replaced to a certain density in a cut within a certain number of years. Where it didn't work it was an expensive replant or an expensive fine and it affected their ability to cut elsewhere.

Climate change has of course changed the algorithm by a lot. The mountain pine beetle which used to be reliably controlled by cold winters was able to spread across the province and wreak havoc (fast forward a decade and we now watch the fires burn).

On one notable but discouraging occasion I supervised a crew that was replanting an area I had planted myself 7 years earlier. Of the four thousand trees I had planted I was able to find 2 alive, and neither of them particularly healthy. The mix we planted the second time was much different and more suitable to the terrain (high, grassy, dry).

214:

It would seem that the US Supreme Court may have spotted the problem - probably too late, but never mind.
And are attempting to avoid a "Dred Scott" case
Except that I think it's too late, they are going to have to choose between relgious bigotry & the wishes of the majority of the US population....
Interesting

215:

Personally, I don't think there's going to be another lockdown... Or rather, there might or might not be a lockdown on paper, but in practice everyone will ignore it and do whatever they want because who the hell cares anymore? Any legitimacy and credibility the government ever had on this topic has been pissed away: The leak about the Christmas party last year was certainly the last straw but let's face it, the last lockdown wasn't so much lifted as it just fizzled out because nobody was sure what the rules were anymore.

I'm glad I was already depressed before all this happened, it must be so much harder to cope if you weren't low-key looking forward to dying anyway.

216:

Tried Wordstar three or five times, and gave up. (I also did the same for emacs.)

Then came WP 5, and it was Wonderful! Usable! And note that my old spec for a word processor is "it is a replacement for a typewriter, and if I can't sit down at it for the first time and type a letter and print it out in five minutes, its bells and whistles have overwhelmed its primary function."

Word style sheets, like Word, are crap. But then, not one word processor puts out anything but absolute crap HTML. Which pisses me off, since WP had the killer Web app, and they were blind: quick, those of you who used WP 5 and later: what's F3 do? Unlike Word, displays ALL formatting codes. And think about it - they were 1-1 with HTML. If WP had a "export/save as HTML" function, it would have given perfectly good HTML, not this every-single-format-code-on-every-single-line crap.

217:

Oh, but I've got one better, that I just realized this morning: not only do those laws (and the ones in other states) take away womens' right, and healthcare, and... it's worse: they're ANTICAPITALIST!

I mean, if this was a problem, surely the Invisible Hand of the Market (tm) would have solved it, right?

218:

I thought French bulldogs were dinky little handbag rats, that had cat ears and were cat-sized and basically looked like cats that had run into a wall at high speed if you didn't have your specs on. They were inexplicably popular among UK glamour models a while back. I can't see how one could get to 35lb and still be able to walk; that's more than a quarter of my own bodyweight, and really rather an excessive load for a handbag.

219:

I saw the word "Casimir" in the original link and immediately lost interest on the grounds that that word is basically just a longer way of spelling "magic".

220:

My COVID test came back negative!

221:

"There is a low (but non zero) chance of a vaccinator literally striking a nerve when administering any intra-muscular vaccine."

...but a high chance that you will fucking well know about it if it does happen.

The conventional crook-of-the-elbow blood sample site is worse because of all the important bits that are crammed in there. I once had a consultant take a sample from there himself because he was a big consultant rah rah rah and we don't need no steenkin' nurses. Except that nurses do it all the time and you hardly notice what they're doing, whereas this chap couldn't find the vein and got the nerve instead. I noticed that to the extent of passing out on the floor, and gaining an instant powerful antipathy to having blood samples taken which I still find a bit of a problem many years later. It does rather make me wonder why that site is so popular over all the other more visible veins that are not intermingled with live wires.

222:

Congrats!

So did ours (that we had Tues).

223:

I really, REALLY hate it when they do the back of the hand. That hurts a lot worse.

I've had numerous vampires, er, phlebotomists who got it right, esp. the ones who do it all the time.

224:

Unfortunately, I still feel sick... but that's just making sure I'm stress free for a couple more days.

225:

216 - Well, I actually rather liked WordStar, but note the mention of CP/M; there wasn't just nothing better but nothing else at all when I started.

221 - Well, back in 2000, I crashed and rolled a car at about 60mph. The worst injury I received was from an F1 (new junior doctor) trying to take his own blood sample.

226:

it's worse: they're ANTICAPITALIST!

George Will (a very conservative US columnist who thinks Trump is a horrible aberration in the US political system but is afraid he will become normalized) wrote 20 or so years ago.

"Conservatives" are all about total freedom in money but control in people's person lives.

"Liberals" are all about total freedom in people's personal life but control in their money.

Way overly broad but so true in so many ways.

And yes I know you thing GW is a turd.

227:

There is a low (but non zero) chance of a vaccinator literally striking a nerve when administering any intra-muscular vaccine. OKs?

Based on this then most people I know get a nerve hit.

My point was that my hands from the wrist to finger tips have a LOT of white lines from various nicks and scratches. Plus a couple of fingers that don't flex all the way to my palm from getting caught between a scraper blade and the back of a tractor (flat on flat at least) when I forgot about leverage. I'm used to small aches and pains. Which makes be pause when answering that doctor/nurse question "on a scale from 1 to 10 how bad does it hurt"?

228:

I thought French bulldogs were dinky little handbag rats

This Frenchie won't fit in a handbag. I can't speak to the 35 lb from personal experience, because he won't let me pick him up, but that's what my niece told me one day. He certainly looks heavier than Big Red, the 25 lb cat that used to curl up on my lap, so I think it's in the right range.

A bit of quick googling turns up that typical max weight is 18-25 lbs, so 35 is heavy but given that he's larger than usual (ie. taller at the shoulder) and a definitely overweight it certainly sounds possible.

229:

"Conservatives" are all about total freedom in money but control in people's person lives.,/i>

Except they're not about total freedom in money. They're quite happy to control the money too, as a means of controlling people.

230:

"Markdown is now well enough known that it makes sense to introduce it."

Is it? I'd heard the word, but never actually encountered it; I thought it was just another word for the kind of cut-down replacement for HTML you encounter on forums which also gets called BBcode sometimes. Charlie says Wikipedia uses it, but if so they must have changed things quite a lot since the last time I edited anything, since the syntax he describes is nothing like what I remember.

"the basic Markdown syntax is very close to what people normally type anyway."

I consider that to be a bad thing, because it means you have to stop typing the kind of thing you normally type and start remembering fairy fiddles to make things continue to come out the way you expect them to. Hence why I brought the subject up in the first place: the most visible result of its introduction was a flood of broken URLs because it's no longer possible to simply copy and paste a link and expect it to come out unmangled, and some people's posts coming out with all the paragraph breaks removed.

To be sure the HTML support brings the problem that people type a bra to indicate "less than" and their post ends up truncated at that point, but most cases of that could be caught by having the code for the "limited subset of HTML tags" deal with tag-like things that aren't in that subset by escaping the bras and kets so they come out as ordinary text, instead of just wiping them out altogether.

231:

The interesting thing about that is that WP's internal usage should be half-decent HTML at all. Everything else I've encountered that automatically generates anything more than trivial HTML generates hideous dogshit - not actually incorrect, but oh dear what a horrible mess. Quite a few things use HTML internally to describe formatting, and while the obvious way to put their data into a web page is to intercept that internal HTML and whack it straight in, it requires so much editing just to get it into a form where you can understand how it interacts with the rest of the web page that it may well be easier to get the output as simple unformatted plain text and re-insert the HTML formatting by hand.

For actually writing web pages in its own right I always just write the HTML and CSS by hand in a plain text editor. It's not like it's difficult, after all, and apart from anything else I just don't see the point of doing it in any more fancy way.

232:

Speaking as someone who's gotten acupuncture, oh hell yes you know when a nerve's been struck. You know when the needle is near a nerve.

My acupuncturist was needling the point between index finger and thumb, which I think most people know. The actual point is in the middle of the fleshy part of the hand, right near a nerve, and it uses a needle that's longer than a vaccination needle. One of his questions is "tell me when it hurts," meaning, is it getting close to a nerve, and he stops and backs up when it starts hurting.

While a pharmacist doing a jab won't have that level of needle manipulation skill, if you're worried about nerve damage, scream stop if you feel a nerve light up when the needle gets near it. Trust me, you will know.

By the way, if you're wondering about why acupuncture works, remember that nerves are physical extensions of your brain in your body. A large number of acupuncture points aren't superficial (especially in arms and legs), they're at depth in tissue. What they're doing with the needles is moving energy, in the sense that the therapists are trying to get cold areas to warm up through vasodilation (heat is a form of energy, so they're "moving chi to a cold area"), trying to get spasms to release and go back to normal (movement is also a form of motion, so restoring normal range of motion "improves chi flow"), and so forth. This obviously won't aid against conditions caused by pathogens directly, but if a headache has you tied up in knots, stimulating various nerves to release the knots and restore circulation will help quite a lot. The various meridians seem to be a combination of major nerves (the Ren channel more or less maps the main trunk of the vagus nerve) and mnemonic maps for linking points that have similar effects on different parts of the body.

233:

Yes, the ones who do it all the time are fine. Although some of them have an annoying habit of saying "sharp scratch" or something when they stick the needle in. With the ones who don't tell me when to expect it there's a good chance I won't notice them doing it at all, which is how I want it since after that consultant episode, feeling the needle tends to trigger the same syncope reaction no matter how trivial the sensation actually is.

234:

My "professional" web pages* say, at the bottom, "this page will load faster than almost any other website. Proudly built in vi".

  • I'm trying to decide what my hosting provider offers for a blog that I'm willing to use, since I seem to need one, having become a writer. (about 2k words yesterday....)
235:

"that doctor/nurse question "on a scale from 1 to 10 how bad does it hurt"?"

I find that kind of impossible to give a meaningful answer to. "...where 10 is the worst pain you can possibly imagine" - right now nothing my imagination can come up with is remotely like what I'm actually feeling. Plus it doesn't exactly get a lot of practice at realistically imagining pain in any case, and moreover it's currently working full throttle in the opposite direction, trying to imagine that the thing which does hurt doesn't. I end up having to try and figure out what use they are going to try and make of the information in my kind of case, and guess which number is going to give them the most accurate clue.

236:

@223

I can testify to that - I was hospitalised with an infection a few years ago, and they needed to test arterial blood.

Cue one student doctor making 6 failed attempts to find the vein through the back of my hand - agonising. I later found out he should have stopped after the third failed attempt and got someone else involved, but I think it was a matter of pride for him...

Of course, when he FINALLY gave up and handed over to another student doctor, she got it at the very first try...

237:

Ex-military medics are good, too.

238:

I'm sometimes fuzzy on the scale, but I can give them something.

1 is "ouch". 2 is ow! 5 is "I took ibuprofen somewhere between 3 and 4. I'm hurting. 9 is either "the time I did not take stool softener after knee surgery, and was on hydrocodone for several days, and finally was on the john", or "I'm curled up on the couch in utter pain, and my SO at the time (20 years ago) called my oncologist, and I just don't remember if there was an ambulance involved, or she drove me. 10 - I'm assuming I passed out.

239:

Re: 'escaped underscores to unbreak link - mod'

Please elaborate - I've no idea what this means (non-techie here). Thanks!

240:

Re: Student doc & blood draws

That nasty blood draw sounds weird although it can happen even if that student doc had done his/her homework practicing on a gadget like the below. I found this very easily on BigRiver and am guessing that there are many sources/manufacturers of such devices for various bits of human anatomy.

"IV Practice Arm Infusion Model, WELLiSH Venipuncture Practice Arm Intravenous Model Injection Practice Kit Designed for Training and Perfecting IV Venipuncture Techniques"

I'm all for student doctors being allowed to examine me but pokes/jabs I want supervised!

241:

I consider that to be a bad thing, because

Well, I disagree.

HTML's design brief was to provide a simple subset of SGML, with hyperlinks, that could be used for a distributed machine-parseable hypertext information system. It's not intended to be human-readable and, once you get beyond a very minimalist subset, it isn't.

Markdown was designed to add explicitly human-readable markup to plain text, enriching it to minimal word-processing spec. Along the way it picked up some extras that turned into an actual word processing format and a hypertext language -- it's the document format used by wikipedia, for example (and almost all other wikis).

The point is, Markdown is designed to be readable by human minds and trivially editable using a text editor without introducing tons of weird parser errors from unclosed tags and other syntactical bloopers.

And as noted elsewhere upthread you can inline HTML inside of Markdown.

242:

I assume _ is an escaped underscore. Dead std. So, if your link is thisisa_website.com, you should escape it this_is_a_website.com.

243:

And, from what you and other say, it sounds like the way I learned to write email, as well as posts to usenet... and like the way I post, anyway.

244:

Single syllable? We've already failed.

"Cube Costume" = חֲנֻכָּה fan-cy dress but a lot more. Chabad operations and more esoteric usages therein - call it the proto modern OPS[1] and learn the current boogeyman status to Islam and so forth [the joke is that Oxford St. London is not exactly the Green Zone that UK / IL media are wanting to portray, but... the humour is there for those who are into it. Monsieur De-Polard-Canard just exited (with a very nice 'pension' retainer, we might add) from the smear rag sooo... we think the BAME meeting = woke antisemitism in Uni got too sad even for his backers to excuse]

Jewdas = London anarchist Jewish peeps, got mentioned on "Have I got news for you" via selective Twitter quote + REALLY OBVIOUS audience sound editing of SILENCE [the producer was not a smart woman] and then an over-zealous member of the 55th Tuffton set went live on air (the blonde one, close to Tic-cc-ee) on Sky news to denounce them. As did many of the Journo set who just went to an award ceremony last night / week (fronted by MENA cash, and not the pro-~Journalist kind) as we learn today that Assange is the first to get the Deportation movement on the rails. Get used as a punching bag a lot and get a lot of Cultural Pressure of the negative kind. If you want deep trawl, one ex-Grauniad member who sold Assange out to MI5 (wet his knickers allegedly) who was there also slandered them heavily.

Essentially anyone who went to the awards is "Sus" and Owned. Talk about Bonfire of the Vanities.

And, of course: you have to know / understand who is the ultimate giver of Language / Words and why, to this day, there are those who follow Judaism who refuse to speak Hebrew (modern).

It's a conceit[2] with dollops of respect benear the Flea-on-a-Flea and racous tone. From the perspective of a Mind around when Arwad was young. Which, notably, was around for a few hundred years before Hebrew (original) entered the region and thousands before Aramaic was spoken there.

The layers are there just as a gift during the festival of Light to cheer people up if they want to dig far enough to get the merkin joke (itself a... "hidden mystery" and not talked about much, but imports are imports and fashion is fashion).

It's 5782 and y'all still not willing to talk about wigs, let alone merkins. Scandal a couple of thousand years old over who was getting their wigs (and merkins) from non-Frum sources!!111!11! [And the answer is, of course: that which gives the Light].

Why bother? Because Jewdas believe in it, and they deserved a cuddle. Our cuddles usually just confuse you though.

Note: that doesn't explain all of it, which we can do, but that'd be boring. And no-one reads it anyhow. Like, literally, no-one reads it.

~

Also I'm utterly unclear about what you think booster vaccines are being used as a political wedge for -- even the direction you think they're being pushed in.

People expect Vaccines to function, usually for life or at least 10 years.

If you want the simple version: a lot of cold hard snakes who'd rather have a servile population and don't care much if a certain percentage die off are more than willing to scuttle things to get "back to normal".

DeSantis proposes a new civilian military force in Florida that he would control

But in a nod to the growing tension between Republican states and the Biden administration over the National Guard, DeSantis also said this unit, called the Florida State Guard, would be "not encumbered by the federal government." He said this force would give him "the flexibility and the ability needed to respond to events in our state in the most effective way possible." DeSantis is proposing bringing it back with a volunteer force of 200 civilians, and he is seeking $3.5 million from the state legislature in startup costs to train and equip them.

https://edition.cnn.com/2021/12/02/politics/florida-state-guard-desantis/index.html - Dec 3rd 2021

Knowyourmeme copy pasta about 4th, 5th, 6th,... nth booster shots is a commonly seen mimetic weapon and so on.

You're a smart Ape, connect the dots. Serious money being spent on both sides of this Culture War. And one side is gonna use 'the Science' (and the greed / bastard nature of Psfixzzer C level) to the max, ain't they?

We'd suggest reading about all the protests around the EU to get a sense of it.

And no, "John" didn't fail you: you're just not ready for the un-redacted full version.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Wandering_Soul_(Vietnam_War)

[2] John "Donne" https://www.poetryfoundation.org/learn/glossary-terms/conceit itself a pun.

245:

SFReader @ 239: Please elaborate

The new Markdown syntax uses underscore characters to tag some text as emphasised, so if you write something _like this_ it comes out looking like this.

But that raises the question: how did I get the underscores visible up there to explain what I meant? The answer is that I actually typed it \_like this\_. The backslash is called the escape character in this context, presumably because it frees you from the normal interpretation of what you type and gives you something different. Various programming languages and markup formats have different escape characters, although backslash is the most common. Using an escape character on some text is known as "escaping" it, in the same way that applying paint to something is known as "painting" it.

What the mod means is that they inserted extra backslashes into your post so that the underscores came out as underscores instead of random bits of italics.

How did I get the backslashes visible in my second paragraph? I escaped them of course. So what I actually typed was \\\_like this\\\_. How I got all those backslashes visible is left as an exercise to the reader.

See also The Telnet Song

246:

Yeah, well, after 5+ months of chemo 20 years ago, and they never put in a shunt (I forget why), finding my veins on the first try indicates that the phlebotomist is in the top 10% of all phlebotomists.

247:

Re: Paul @245

Thanks! I'm going to save your explanation.

Re: Whitroth @246 - '5+ months chemo' -

Yeah, we've got a running joke that any non-heme/onc experienced medico who sees my family member's arm is probably going to think 'user'. Depends on the season - if summertime t-shirt weather, the experienced ones take a quick glance around the clavicle area to check for any sign of usual insertion cut (scar) for the central venous line.

Re: Heteromeles - Herbals

OOC, are you (or your in-house pharmacist) familiar with the 'The Complete German Commission E Monographs: Therapeutic Guide to Herbal Medicines' (1999)? I just checked and it's still more than I'd like to spend ($189 semanticscholar dot org). If it's still sufficiently up-to-date I might check whether I can get it via inter-library transfer. (Assuming any of the public libraries in my area have it.)

248:

Honestly: cutting out a load of fun there. Including the stuff about when The Nation stopped using Hebrew (ancient) and the Roman patrol ambushes (done mostly by a sect that no-one mentions these days, not Chabad) and so on.

Like, the Festival of Lights is actually a celebration of this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maccabean_revolt -- note the Map. Then check out where Arwad is[1]. Then check out a modern map. Then check out current news from IL about their Wall and how proud they are of it. And how over a million people are stuffed in there.

You want conceit?

After 3,000 years, that's pitiful gains there boyos. For a shit load of dead people.[2]

So: actual conceit. Jewdas' gag, pretty on point.

And the Cube... ooooh. You're not ready for that conceit or Commentary.

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arwad

[2] See? How deep do you want your layers? A little deeper than modern trash shouting "kappo" at anything they cannot process.

249:

Many-named FUCKWIT @ 244
Vaccines WORK - got that yet?
I tell you 3 times is true seems to work for the omicron variant, too - I've had 3 shots.
* DO NOT* spread anti-vaxx lying propaganda in here, thank you very much!

Paul
Is the "Telnet Song" related to the Ode to a Spell Checker ??

250:

OOC, are you (or your in-house pharmacist) familiar with the 'The Complete German Commission E Monographs: Therapeutic Guide to Herbal Medicines' (1999)? I just checked and it's still more than I'd like to spend ($189 semanticscholar dot org). If it's still sufficiently up-to-date I might check whether I can get it via inter-library transfer. (Assuming any of the public libraries in my area have it.)

No, I'm not familiar with it. I'd suggest trying the interlibrary loan route first, to see how useful it is. Aside from the phun pharmaceutical phrolics that are herbs, whose diverse chemicals can be hard to quantify, characterize, and standardize batch to batch, the real problem is that I don't know how German 1999 herb quality laws (if any) play with those of other countries, like particularly the US. Since the USA minimally regulates herbs, something that's regulated to be safe in Germany may be minimally quality-controlled here.

Still, if it will keep you out of trouble, spend some coin and check out a copy.

251:

Greg, your knee is jerking hard enough to hit you in the face there.

She isn't spreading anti-vax propaganda. She is snarking at the heatless swine that are "and don't care much if a certain percentage die off."

252:

Whitroth @238:

I'm sometimes fuzzy on the scale, but I can give them something.

Allie Brosh critiqued a pain scale that has been in use for a while and came up with an alternate one. Pretty funny.

From the descriptive pictures:

0: Hi. I am not experiencing any pain at all. I don't know why I'm even here.

6: Ow. Okay, my pain is super legit now.

10: I am actively being mauled by a bear.

253:

Nobody with a functioning brain expects all vaccines to last for life. I’ve had flu vaccine every year for over twenty years. But I’ve only needed polio and smallpox vaccine once. I’ll only need pneumonia and shingles vaccine once. Anti tetanus needs to be boosted every few years which is why you’ll be offered one if you have a deep cut. Most vaccines are cheaper than antibody testing and very much cheaper and more effective than treating the disease Pfizer have made a lot of money from their COVID-19 vaccine but it’s saved a lot of lives. Oxford/AstraZeneca sell their vaccine at cost to third world countries and don’t make much profit anywhere.

254:

Since pharmacists in a certain hospital I know well are authorized to prescribe pain-killers for patients under doctor supervision, the following scenario came up some years ago:

"On a scale of 1 to 10, what's your pain level right now?"

"Oh, it's like 10, 16. I'm in pain. Give me drugs, I need to kill the pain..."

You can guess the rest.

This, incidentally, was before my local officials started getting serious about treating homeless people with addiction problems. It's still a contentious issue, but the liberal bleed-hearts explain to their conservative opponents that frequent flyers like the one above cost the city $400,000 per person per year or more in emergency room bills, ambulance rides, and so forth. At a fraction of that cost, the city or county could rent them an apartment and a slot in decent therapy and rehab. It's not that simple of course, but since the city and county are picking up the tab regardless, they getting a little better at realizing when compassion is a lot cheaper.

255:

Yes. You're a well educated man who understands (at least rudimenatary) biology and so on.

If you are an American Citizen, you're now in the top 30% of your populace. If you're from India, 83%. And so on. Iceland, 99%, you're that one weirdo on the black sand beach in that hut that no-one knows how they arrived or what[1].

We'll make it simple for you: not all your fellow Humans understand this. Many don't have the economic liberty to access "a free vaccination" if they could. Some cannot because they are not legal citizens. And so on.

The reasons are multi-tudinous; the results are death. We'd suggest blaming the systme rather than the people being preyed upon by it. This includes those slavishly believing in PFsxzzrer and other C-Level Corp execs from Comnpanies whose main model (tied to insurance scams) is: "Bleed the fuckers dry".

Want to bitch about it?

Don't blame Individuals (essentially not an issue in this): blame your systems. And your system is fucked.

~

For the record: this body has had no immune shots. Given we can ramp the internal temp up to ~108 without it dying and there's a shit load of much nastier fucking shit making its penis dance in there, trust us: not all of the "un-vaxxed" are threats to you. Shit you not, the stuff they tried to infect us with was faaaaaaaaar worse than a Conovirus. Heart goes SILENT RUNNING for 7 days on certain stuff. We've also not been able to talk to another H.S.S for years.

See above: vaccination =/= anything special. It's not a fucking badge, and some humans (chemo, immon-comp'd, AIDS etc) don't have the luxury of the choice.

So don't be a (AUS TRANSLATION) cunt and think you know better.

~

You also missed the entire point which is worrying.

[1] He's a Wizard / Satanist of sorts. Cunt didn't bother to show up when we arrived, which is getting pretty ironic right now.

256:

Bravo Lima Poppa 3 @ 193: Houston here. And it's already loose in the community from waste water surveillance and one person that tested positive and has no history of travel. It's in the house with you already.

And just now, checking Google News, North Carolina has their first confirmed case of Omicron.

I had my oral surgery appointment today, so I'm only up for a short time ... until the pain meds kick in again.

257:

Paul @ 199: The advantage of Markdown is that simple stuff is simple: asterisks for emphasis, blank line for paragraph etc. You can start by just typing, and pick it up as you go along, learning a new bit every so often. The resulting text is also easy to read because the basic Markdown syntax is very close to what people normally type anyway.

In contrast HTML has a big barrier of entry to anyone who hasn't done programming before. This is a tag. Every tag must have a closing tag. Learn a bunch of one-letter codes for tags. You need to know this before you start typing.

Yes & no. I know a very small subset of HTML. I learned all of the HTML I know from commenting here. Highlight text and right click to "View Selection Source" and save the tags in notepad to use as a template later I have a document on my desktop named "HTML-tags DOT txt" that I use when composing replies. I always select "Preview" to see what it's going to look like. Mistakes are usually obvious and I can correct them and preview again ... and again and ... until it looks right before I click on "Submit". Might not be the most elegant or intuitive, but looking at Markdown, it doesn't seem any more intuitive than what I've already learned to do with HTML.

I'll grant the hybrid that this blog uses worked OK, but Markdown is now well enough known that it makes sense to introduce it. Though the escaped-underscores thing is a nuisance.

And I guess I'll eventually figure that out if the blog switches over to Markdown completely from HTML.

258:

Robert Prior @ 209:

Trump would fuck them up appallingly and end up under house arrest in a drafty castle in the highlands within a matter of minutes

Trump would fuck them up appallingly and end up under house arrest in a drafty castle in the highlands within a matter of minutes

You don't want to have to deal with all the shit he'd cause getting there.

259:

Robert Prior @ 210:

Doesn't work to well with a 15lb Shih-Tzu because he's just a tiny bit too big for the one I bought. I probably should look to see if they make a larger one

My niece has one for her 35 lb French Bulldog. He is apparently quite happy with how it takes him everywhere he wants to go without the possibility of someone getting closer to his servant than he is :-)

He'd probably be too big for the one I bought too. The problem is finding one without the pet supply store getting all in my shit because I'm not going to buy another one UNLESS I can be sure it's the right size.

260:

Greg Tingey @ 214: It would seem that the US Supreme Court may have spotted the problem - probably too late, but never mind.
And are attempting to avoid a "Dred Scott" case
Except that I think it's too late, they are going to have to choose between relgious bigotry & the wishes of the majority of the US population....
Interesting

They've already chosen religious bigotry. They're just trying to avoid paying the price for their choice.

261:

whitroth @ 217: Oh, but I've got one better, that I just realized this morning: not only do those laws (and the ones in other states) take away womens' right, and healthcare, and... it's worse: they're ANTICAPITALIST!

I mean, if this was a problem, surely the Invisible Hand of the Market (tm) would have solved it, right?

They're not anti-MONOPOLY, so one invisible hand washes the other.

262:

Pigeon @ 235:

"that doctor/nurse question "on a scale from 1 to 10 how bad does it hurt"?"

I find that kind of impossible to give a meaningful answer to. "...where 10 is the worst pain you can possibly imagine" - right now nothing my imagination can come up with is remotely like what I'm actually feeling. Plus it doesn't exactly get a lot of practice at realistically imagining pain in any case, and moreover it's currently working full throttle in the opposite direction, trying to imagine that the thing which does hurt doesn't. I end up having to try and figure out what use they are going to try and make of the information in my kind of case, and guess which number is going to give them the most accurate clue.

I don't have any problem at all with the "worst pain you can possibly imagine"

When I got Rocky Mountain Spotted Fever down at Fort Hood, they took me to the ER in an ambulance (I know this because I momentarily woke up on the gurney when it went around a corner at speed).

When they got me into the ER they woke me up and told me they needed to do a spinal tap because they'd had a case of meningitis admitted that day.

The doctor had a great deal of trouble finding where to get the fluid sample from; told me I had the flattest spine he had ever seen and he couldn't find the bumps that told him where to stick the needle. I don't know how many times he had to stick it in, and if he had trouble finding the fluid, he had no problem at all finding nerves.

I try to be stoic because I don't want people to think I'm a whiner and a cry-baby ... but I screamed.

Thirty-three years later and I STILL KNOW FROM EXPERIENCE where 10 is.

What you really want to avoid is the one that "goes to eleven".

263:

Mike Collins @ 253: Nobody with a functioning brain expects all vaccines to last for life. I’ve had flu vaccine every year for over twenty years. But I’ve only needed polio and smallpox vaccine once. I’ll only need pneumonia and shingles vaccine once. Anti tetanus needs to be boosted every few years which is why you’ll be offered one if you have a deep cut. Most vaccines are cheaper than antibody testing and very much cheaper and more effective than treating the disease Pfizer have made a lot of money from their COVID-19 vaccine but it’s saved a lot of lives. Oxford/AstraZeneca sell their vaccine at cost to third world countries and don’t make much profit anywhere.

I've had the polio vaccine twice - or have had two different polio vaccines - Salk & Sabin. Maybe even three times, they gave us so damn many vaccinations before we went to Iraq.

I had the smallpox inoculation twice. First time as a 5 y.o. before I went to grade school. Probably Tetanus vaccine as well. I don't remember any others, I don't think the measles, mumps, chicken-pox, etc vaccines were developed yet. I did have all three of those while I was in elementary school.

The second smallpox inoculation was in 2003. Smallpox had been eradicated in the wild, but the Army decided it MIGHT be a bio-weapon in Saddam's arsenal. Got it right before Christmas and wasn't allowed to go near my family during the holiday because my brother had a six month old infant and my sister's little boy was in middle school and apparently there's a chance you can spread the disease before the body develops its immunity.

My first flu shot came in the early 70s. There was a Swine Flu outbreak & I remember there were mandatory vaccination. I don't remember any anti-VAXX at the time. Swine Flu sucked & it apparently was bad enough that it was killing some people and who wants that? Hadn't turned into a political football yet.

264:

Re infection rates of COVID variants: Presumably the variant after Omicron will be Pi. Will that be 3.14159 times more infectious?

265:

PilotMoonDog
And how am I supposed to be able to detect what you claim, amidst all the random bollocks, obfuscation & verbiage, eh?
- See also: Mike Collins @ 253, yes?
- - And, for further inanity to the point of being suicidal, see # 255.

JBS
If you are correct - & I'm horribly afraid that you are, that won't get them off the hook ( I hope )

AndrewMck
😁
But, Omicron SEEMS TO BE a much less serious variation, on the information now coming in ... Lots of cases, zero-to-very-low numbers of "hospitalisations". In the UK, no deaths, at all - so far.

266:

253 - I've said this on other sites too. Flu (like Covid 19) is a mutagenic virus, which is why you "need" annual flu jabs. Polio and smallpox are not so markedly mutagenic, which is why you need fewer, less regular jabs (but polio boosters are recommended if you live in or travel to countries where it is endemic).

257 - My argument also. Markdown is not "better" than HTML, just different (and IMO different numbers of leading and training asterisk characters to open and close boldface, italic and underscore is emphatically less intuitive than b, i and u tags). Other stuff, like numbered lists and indent levels may be better, but I don't use them much.

262 - Well, a spinal tap does involve sticking sample needles near nerves (the aforementioned spinal column).

264 - Yes, and well "everything is better with pi(e)". ;-)

265 - OTOH the first UK hospitalisations with omicron are only due about now based on dates when cases were assumed (on evidence available, some or all could actually be alpha).
Also, there are some dubious (to me) sounding statistics coming out, like, with an (assumed AIUI) R of 2, if 1 person in a gathering of 100 has omicron, 66 of that hundred will be infected over the next 2 weeks. I always thought that the R number was a positive float of the number of people that would be infected by a single case.

267:

It's not just whether they mutate, but how long resistance lasts. I used to have TAB every 6 months, and it wasn't because they changed the vaccine.

It is unlikely that alpha is confusing the matter; it's essentially dead in the UK.

The statistics vary from the dubious to the bogus, and the example you gave is in the latter camp. The thing to remember is that social behaviour affects R at least as much as the infective agent.

268:

My first flu shot came in the early 70s. There was a Swine Flu outbreak & I remember there were mandatory vaccination. I don't remember any anti-VAXX at the time. Swine Flu sucked & it apparently was bad enough that it was killing some people and who wants that? Hadn't turned into a political football yet.

Actually it was a bit controversial. But in those days it was private conversations for the most part. No Internet or social media to amplify it all out of proportion. I have memories of my father making some very mild comments about it wondering if it really was a serious flu strain or just a way to see if the US population would accept being told "everyone get vaccinated". This was very out of character for my father and it may have been he was commenting on what others said. But it really stuck with me.

Looking it up the Swine flu was around 2008. The "Hong Kong" flu was 68-69 and was likely what I (and maybe you) were thinking of.

269:

OTOH the first UK hospitalisations with omicron are only due about now based on dates when cases were assumed

Some of the Scottish cases of the Omicron variant are linked to two specific spreader events which can be dated exactly. The first was a "private event" AKA a wedding or birthday party or the like, on 20th November and the second was a large music event on 22nd November at the SEC Hydro with several thousand people in attendance (the headline act later cancelled their tour as COVID-19 was detected in some of their band members and crew but there was no mention of Omicron variant in the press report).

As of a few days ago, nearly three weeks after initial exposure, none of the twenty or so confirmed cases from those events had required hospitalisation according to Public Health Scotland, with the infected individuals staying at home in isolation. Saying that we didn't get a breakdown of the ages of the infected individuals but the cases from the music gig were most likely younger people (18-35).

Typically COVID-19 infections are asymptomatic for about five days then symptomatic for ten to fourteen days afterwards during which time hospitalisation is likely to occur if the patient deteriorates. By twenty days or so since infection most people exposed to a spreader event are considered clear of any virus they may have picked up.

270:

The statistics indicate roughly a fortnight's delay between infection and hospitalisation (if relevant), and a fortnight between that and death (if relevant). Of course, those are population averages. We shall have a pretty good idea of its severity by the new year.

The gummint has cocked up its latest variant report data, so I can't show people any pretty pictures.

271:

But, Omicron SEEMS TO BE a much less serious variation, on the information now coming in ... Lots of cases, zero-to-very-low numbers of "hospitalisations". In the UK, no deaths, at all - so far.

Greg, omicron is so new that there hasn't been enough time for the deaths to ramp up.

Remember, people with severe COVID19 tend to collapse about 9-11 days after infection. And then it takes weeks (sometimes longer) before they die in an ICU bed. There's also a 2-3 day incubation period for this strain. So we don't really see peak deaths until 2-4 weeks after we hit peak infections.

Also note that South Africa has very different demographics for the UK -- the population is younger on average -- and has sky-high levels of HIV compared to the UK, which results in immunocompromised patients.

Basically we don't know how Omicron will affect the UK population yet: SA isn't necessarily a good model, and anyone saying "but this strain isn't as deadly" is to some extent indulging in wishful thinking.

272:

Part of that is because they keep changing their minds about how long immunity lasts, and vaccines change (which often affects that). Tetanus has been 3, 5 and 10 ten years, lifetime, and 'when you get a dirty cut' in my lifetime, so I have had at least half a dozen.

273:

And then there's this report: Omicron could cause 75,000 deaths in England by end of April, say scientists -- Peak of 2,400 daily hospital admissions is most optimistic scenario if England stays in Plan B, say advisers.

(Plan B is: mask-wearing, working from home, and booster jabs. It's where England is at, already. As I already noted, reading between the lines it's glaringly obvious that Nicola Sturgeon wants to go further -- but furlough/lockdown payments are in the hands of Rishi Sunak, Chancellor of the Exchequer, former Goldman Sachs banker turned hedge-fund capitalist, and son-in-law of a billionaire. Guess what his natural inclination is ...)

274:

Sign me up as in favour of MarkDown. It's my standard format for writing notes and simple documentation for myself, although I tend to get complaints about recieving notes in .txt or .md format instead of .docx.

The one problem with MarkDown is that it's not all that standardised. I'm most familiar with the flavour used on GitHub, but there are differences. Notably, WikiMedia uses a distinctly different dialect - or at least, the wikimedia server that we maintained our lab documentation on did.

As a few examples, GH-flavoured markdown emphasises like so:

  • **bold text**
  • *italicised text* and _italicised text_
  • [hyperlink text](hyperlink url)
  • * first level bullet point
  • space * second level bullet point

While wikimedia formatting looks more like

  • '''bold text'''
  • ''italicised text''
  • [hyperlink_url hyperlink_text]
  • [[internal_link_url internal_link_text]]
  • * first level bullet point
  • * * second level bullet point

Finally - MarkDown isn't all that well suited to splitting documentation across multiple files. So I tend to write more complex documentation in ReStructuredText (RST) - at least, after leaving tyhe group that used WikiMedia, anyway.

I will echo the complaint about escaping characters, though. Once you start adding escapes in, the primary benefit of MarkDown (i.e. that it's perfectly human-readable text even with all of the formatting characters in-line) gets lost relatively rapidly. I'm not sure what the solution to that is, mind you. Either it's a special character, or it isn't.

275:

Unlike Word, displays ALL formatting codes.

Ah, the WP "Reveal Codes." I had a job once where I was responsible for hundreds of pages of reports that had to be updated each legislative session, all done in WP. I inherited the documents, which had passed through several/many hands. I spent most of a month after my first session with them with "Reveal Codes" turned on, cleaning out the cruft.

276:

As of today (11 December 2021) in Scotland, new reported cases of COVID-19 are up, reported death rates are down a little and the number of cases requiring hospital care and intensive care support are also down. This is in comparison to a couple of months ago, before the booster vaccination program kicked off and of course before the Omicron variant was first reported in Scotland three weeks ago.

277:

I'm seeing disturbing reports about the age distribution of omicron cases admitted to hospital with severe disease in South Africa -- that fully 30% of them after under 5's.

In SA the full vaccination rate is reportedly 30%, so the juvenile admissions aren't an artefact of the elderly population being protected against severe disease: everyone's getting it, kids are just getting it much worse than with previous strains.

If this holds up, then it's a show-stopper for the UK, where until now the normal assumption has been that kids are safe, it's the old farts like us who need to shelter. (We haven't even green-lit vaccination for under-12s yet.) After all, schools are disease swap marts.

278:

Yeah :-( As the SAGE people know, we simply don't know - and if we wait until we DO know, and it is anything but the best-case scenario, it will be too late.

I have seen those reports about Omicron attacking younger people (#277), too, but hard data appear non-existent. Again, we shall know by the end of the year, but need to act now.

279:

Markdown question for those in the know…

Suppose I want to paste a URL, as I have been in the habit of doing, and that URL contains underscore characters (as many do). Is there an easy way to do that and have it show up just as it is, or do I have to manually edit the URL after I paste it, and hope I don't miss an underscore or add and extra backslash?

280:

schools are disease swap marts

I started reading Michael Lewis' The Premonition a few months ago. There's a part at the beginning where he's writing about a science fair student who came up with an improved mathematical model of disease spread by noting that schools aren't offices for tiny people (as they were treated in the official models at the time).

A great many people who make decisions about schools* seem to have spent very little time in an actual classroom.

*There was the official in an Ontario Conservative government who decided that each student needed as much room as a bank teller, so set the funding for schools based on that. Corridors, libraries, boiler rooms — all counted as part of a student's average space.

281:

Pulling this from way back in #182:

News story: Maine, NH, and NY are mobilizing the National Guard to help with medical issues of overworked and understaffed.

This isn't going to work.

The National Guard is a part-time militia. Guess what they do the rest of the time?

That's right, they work, in that state, doing jobs like ambulance driver, nurse, emergency medicine tech... if they have medical skills, they're already working. Having the Guard called up moves them to some other part of the state, where they are no longer familiar with what's going on, can't retreat home at the end of the day, generally makes them less effective.

If all you wanted were grunt laborers, offer $25 an hour.

282:

Yes. Use regular HTML A HREF syntax and Markdown will refrain from mangling underscores in the URL target, although it will interpret underscores in the link text as emphasis. Demo: thisisbrokenandwill_fail.

(That points to a non-existent html page: https://www.antipope.org/charlie/this\_is\_broken\_and\_will\_fail.html .)

Added complication: a bare URL in Markdown text will be turned into an HTML link when posted (with the URL copied into the link text, as happened above).

So there are actually three ways you can post links, now:

  • Markdown link using [caption](URL)

  • HTML link using normal HTML syntax (remember to escape underscores in the caption)

  • Bare URL (will be turned into a link)

283:

The National Guard is a part-time militia. Guess what they do the rest of the time?

Am I right in thinking the Guard know what their members' civilian specialties are and allocate them to roles accordingly? (So that civilian medics/nurses/etc would be given equivalent roles when called up.)

If so, there may be some useful roles -- for example, drivers for ambulances so that the civilian paramedics can leave that part of their job to someone else and focus on stabilizing patients on their way to hospital.

I'm reaching here but there must be something worth doing, unless this is just a political photo-op mobilization.

284:

The National Guard is a part-time militia. Guess what they do the rest of the time?

Well, applying Hanlon's Razor, it could just be double counting by someone who hasn't thought it through:

"Our state has N paramedics working in the ambulances, but we have another G paramedics in the National Guard, making a total of N+G available in emergencies".

285:

In the USA, the waves of the Great Influenza of 1918 - 1922 (they say often date it 1918 - 1920, but big waves, though not everywhere the same time, continued into 1921-22) hit different populations harder. 1918-1919 was mostly men and women between 15 and 45. The wave that most affected children came later.

I don't know as much about how it worked throughout the period in other parts of the world. But Pale Rider (2017), by British historian, Laura Spinney, unlike US author John M Berry's The Great Influenza (2004), has a far more global outlook. Both books are brilliant -- and yes, I thought so when I initially read them at publication, and more so since re-reading them in These Times.

For a contemporary medical overview:

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1088249/

286:

Tetanus has been 3, 5 and 10 ten years, lifetime, and 'when you get a dirty cut' in my lifetime, so I have had at least half a dozen.

I've had nurses ask me if I'm current on my Tetanus shot a few times over the last 10 years. I look at them and ask how to know?

287:

Re: 'I don't think the measles, mumps, chicken-pox, etc vaccines were developed yet. I did have all three of those while I was in elementary school.'

I mentioned/posted about measles in a previous topic but I think it bears repeating.

Measles resets your immune system to zero.

In many ways this is one of the most dangerous viruses out there - get this and all of your library of immune antibodies just vanishes. Probably why kids seemed to catch every cold/flu in circulation until they hit high school (in the pre-MMR vax days): they were! Until they restocked their antibodies.

https://asm.org/Articles/2019/May/Measles-and-Immune-Amnesia

288:

I'm reaching here but there must be something worth doing, unless this is just a political photo-op mobilization.

And referring back to the comment about grunt labor at $25/hr.

The NG is people all with a military background. They know how to organize themselves (to some degree) and take orders and somewhat obey them. And they can mostly read a manual and follow a process. Some (many?) people seem to exist in a universe where these are foreign concepts.

As to pulling away ambulance drivers and such, the NG is a broad swath of the population. They might hit a few docs and ambulance drivers but in general they will also get a lot more bank tellers and such. But anything lasting longer than a week or so gets to be disruptive.

289:

A bit of a topic change.

Some people look askance at those of us who get all "crawl in a hole and hide" when tornadoes are nearby. Growing up in the tornado area of the US tended to wire us that way.

Mayfield Kentucky just got hit hard last night. Literally looks like a war zone. 20 miles south of where I grew up. I visited and was through this town multiple times the first 20 years of my life.

weather.com wpsdlocal6.com

70 or more dead in Kentucky (maybe just Mayfield?)

Likely a lot of even smaller towns in bad shapes once communications gets re-established. This was from a line of storms/tornadoes which started in Arkansas and ran through 1/2 of Kentucky.

290:

Am I right in thinking the Guard know what their members' civilian specialties are and allocate them to roles accordingly?

Yes, very much so. That doesn't stop them from doing odd things (my brother-in-law is a high school math teacher, who was placed in charge of a tank training company because he met the minimum requirements and it was available).

291:

As the state is effectively forcing a woman to have a child that she does not want, does this mean that - the state becomes financially reponsible for the upkeep of that child, and/or - the state becomes totally responsible for the care of the child ? If not, why not ? ( assuming the woman feels the same way after the child is born )

292:

I'd also point out that when the Guards are doing multiple tours in Afghanistan or Iraq, and when they're the first line operators for some of the drone and other specialized units, the notion that they're part-time is laughable. More like contract workers rather than career. The National Guard isn't what it was prior to Bush II.

The National Guard played a big role in the early stages of the pandemic, basically doing the semi-hazardous grunt work (clean-up, disposal, and decontamination), doing logistics, and especially (IIRC) helping the hospital engineering sections keep the ventilators running. Hospitals at that point didn't have much experience using their oxygen systems at 100% capacity, and they needed more engineers and mechanics fast to help keep their systems operating at all. They needed more oxygen too.

The problem with Covid19 is that it doesn't make money for hospitals (a long-hauler is going to pay a million dollar bill? Pull the other one). Normally hospitals depend on expensive elective surgeries to bring in the bucks to support the emergency and ICU departments. But during a pandemic surge, this revenue goes away. That, in turn, means hospitals have trouble finding the money to surge-staff things like engineering, support, janitorial (which they outsource anyway) and so forth. Hauling in the National Guard to do these things actually isn't stupid.

I'll admit that having a 50+ year-old nationalized health care system would have avoided all these problems, but unfortunately we don't live in that particular leg of the trousers of time.

293:

Um....

Let's see, in my life, it's always 9-10 years for tetanus boosters. (And the time before last was me going to "occupational medicine", working at the NIH, because I'd cut my head, and that was the NIH std. Ditto when I had one a year or two ago with Kaiser-Permanente, which was on the same schedule.

It's bundled now, btw, with MM and P, IIRC.

Shingles, you need the equally-long-term jab, and now you want the new one - genengeneered version, two jabs over 2? 3? months. Had both earlier this year.

294:

Oh, yes. Wasn't that capability wonderful?

In the late nineties, I knew a number of secretaries who knew both WP and Word, and hated the latter, and loved the former.

295:

In that case, the URL-related part of my objection could be met by having the Markdown parser only trigger on URL-like things that are already in its own syntax, using that syntax as the trigger, and not also through matching a "looks like a URL" regex or whatever. In that way both HTML-syntax URLs and bare URLs would be handled by the ordinary parser, as was the case previously, and the problem that it is no longer possible to simply copy and paste a URL and expect it to work without further ado would cease to apply.

296:

I started having tetanus shots in the early 1950s. Some of my multiple vaccinations were because there were no records. I am surprised at multiple smallpox ones, because the ones we had left a large and highly indicative scar.

297:

The same is true in the UK, though it started under Thatcher, and got worse under Blair. There was a time when the Territorial Army wasn't used for foreign adventurism; it was intended for home defence (hence its name) and as a reserve in time of war.

298:

I'll admit that having a 50+ year-old nationalized health care system would have avoided all these problems, but unfortunately we don't live in that particular leg of the trousers of time.

Unfortunately here in the UK we do ... and we hit COVID right at the tail end of a decade of (mis-)rule by austerity-obsessed Conservatives that had left 15% of all nursing positions vacant, closed hospitals, reduced the number of beds by something like 40% (going from memory) and generally imposed "efficiency" improvements with the objective of ultimately selling it off piecemeal to private equity and reconfiguring it as a US-style system (and leaving the rump NHS as a single payer in an insurance-friendly market).

If that sounds like insanity to you, that would be because it is.

(Health is a devolved matter, and Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland are to some extent insulated from the English madness. However, spending among the four nations is managed centrally and the others have to march in lockstep with England.)

299:

Word for DOS was ghastly as of version 5.0 and 5.1. Then Microsoft somehow emitted Word 5.5 for DOS which ... well, they went full-on for the CUI interface (same menu/keystroke structure as Windows 3.1, only in a DOS application) as a side-effect of working with IBM, and it actually worked and was usable.

But then they shitcanned it and cut over to Word for Windows, which was Not Perfect. WinWord started out as an attempt to port Word for Mac to run on Windows. Word for Mac was the best word processor on that OS for many years -- it peaked with Word 5.1 for MacOS in 1986 or thereabouts -- but it suffered from too much success.

Microsoft reassigned their entire Mac dev team for Word, then the project manager left, and Word 6 for Mac was orphaned. (It was going to be Word 5.1 only with a Basic scripting language.) So WinWord sputtered along, then Microsoft decided to focus on a common code base, and emitted Word 6 for Windows and/or Mac. Which was written on Windows and ran like a dog on Mac, using a horrible compatability API that caused inconsistent UI problems and much bloat.

Anyway: the takeaway is Microsoft Word peaked with version 5.1a on MacOS, and on DOS it peaked with version 5.5. While Word for Windows was god-awful terrible and no good until roughly 1997, nearly a decade later.

Hint: I know whereof I speak, I wrote a technical book and a couple of novels using Word 5.1 for Mac back in the day.

300:

Re: 'Mayfield Kentucky just got hit hard last night.'

Saw the headlines in GoogNews which included an article about the BigRiver depot there also taking a hit: considerable damage, unknown number of employees trapped (why?*) but not razed to the ground like some nearby homes/small biz.

Geez - wonder who's going to get Fed/State emergency funds/help, how much and how fast? Better yet - base that 'help' on amts paid in taxes.

  • The emergency weather systems send alerts/alarms for target area residents to take shelter - why didn't BigRiver employees?
301:

"...the UK, where until now the normal assumption has been that kids are safe, it's the old farts like us who need to shelter. (We haven't even green-lit vaccination for under-12s yet.) After all, schools are disease swap marts."

That's rather a BBC way of stating the assumption! I'd put it more along the lines of "kids generally don't get ill from it, therefore there are no visible signs of their role in transmission and we can easily get people to forget about, or not realise in the first place, the point that they do still catch and spread it. That way we can shut down discussion of what to do about schools, don't have to spend any money on it, and don't have to deal with parents' objections to our incompetent handling of the situation being amplified to hysterical levels because of their kids being involved."

It could end up being the case that if kids now do get ill from it, the policy of "fuck schools, thanks to our disinformation nobody cares" will be forcibly collapsed, to everyone's (eventual) advantage. If we're lucky, also some parents who have had the disease without knowing where they got it might realise that one way they could have got it indeed was kids bringing it home from school, same as they always do with every sniffle that's going, even if it didn't look like it. If we're really lucky, the involvement of kids might even be enough to get parents to drop their inexplicable persistence in voting for the Tories.

302:

The best I can usually manage is "well, I know it wasn't within the last five years..." followed by an attempt at tracing connections through my memory to try and come up with a date for the last occasion I can be reasonably sure I did have one. At some point they get fed up with listening to me wibbling on and decide to just give me one anyway. It seems to work; at least, I haven't got ill with tetanus yet.

Last time I had one they were also asking me about my diphtheria vaccination status, which baffled me entirely; I might have had it when I was too small to remember what the jab was about, but basically I just don't know. Reason being apparently that nowadays the tetanus vaccine comes combined with diphtheria in its standard form, and the plain tetanus-only version is some kind of special order thing that they don't get in unless someone actually can't have the diphtheria bit (or something along those lines). Must say it surprised me a bit as I didn't think diphtheria was anything like as likely to infect you as tetanus; nor is it something you catch in the same way, so "if you can get one you can probably get the other too" does not apply.

303:

Speaking of medical treatments... this isn't about COVID, but rather UK medical. If someone does something and gets hurt, say, climbs on a ruined castle that has a sign "not safe, and if you go on it, we're not responsible" or however it was phrased in Aberystwyth, is there any penalty, monetary or otherwise, if they need serious treatment?

304:

I think you're conflating two different things.

The Amazon warehouse was in Edwardsville Illinois. Which is really East St. Louis. Nearly 200 miles north of Mayfield Ky.

And that area doesn't get enough tornadoes to have shelters in every (or maybe any) buildings. Much less regular drills. That is mostly something that happens west of the Missouri River. And when the sirens (if they exist) do sound (or now days your phone goes off) you really need to make a decision of what you can do in the next 5 to 10 minutes. Tornadoes spin up very quickly.

Anyway, my point is that staying IN the warehouse was likely the best things to do. Without the knowledge that the warehouse would be hit.

I read the storm front itself was moving at 60mph. Which for a weather SYSTEM is just plain hauling ass.

One last point. Tornadoes are incredibly local. I've been near a few, but never "in" one. One came through here 30 years ago and left a 20 miles long trail. That one obliterated trees 100' from a house we almost bought a month earlier. But no issues with the house. One big box store leveled (exploded really) with merchandise all over many acres yet the office I went to work in the next morning was fine. You see a house foundation with nothing on it and the ones next door are fine or even a house with a missing WALL and the rest of the house intact. Even the furniture in the exposed rooms still in place.

305:

"WinWord started out as an attempt to port Word for Mac to run on Windows."

...but if you expected it to be as good as the Mac version, you would be sorely disappointed, because it was shit. I used both of them, and was indeed so disappointed.

I strongly suspect the Mac version was what Borland used to produce their Turbo C manuals. We defined our company documentation style to be basically identical to those manuals because (a) they were very clear and (b) making Mac Word produce something exactly the same - in every detail - was trivial to do.

There are still copies of that Mac Word floating around and I have got it running under Linux with the Basilisk 2 emulator. Still the same, but for just knocking up the odd one-page letter which is all the word processing I do nowadays it's not worth the hassle of using an emulator instead of something native.

306:

No. Doesn't matter how you got injured, or how obviously dangerous the thing was that you were doing at the time, nobody tries to get on your case about it. The worst there is in that line is that motorcyclists are medically nicknamed "organ donors".

307:

The emergency weather systems send alerts/alarms for target area residents to take shelter - why didn't BigRiver employees?

It's entirely possible the alerts didn't reach them, which is a tragedy.

It's also entirely possible that the alerts reached them (or some of them), but there was no refuge they could reach in the time they had, due to the construction of the facility. That would also be a tragedy.

I also know that I've received fire evacuation alerts and had to argue with other people for 15-20 minutes that the alert is real and they should evacuate. Imagine that happening inside a big facility, where some manager doesn't wanna believe for just a bit too long.

Or it could be some combination of all three.

308:

The worry is that the next variant may give rise to irrational behaviour.

309:

WinWord started out as an attempt to port Word for Mac to run on Windows.

My understanding of the general path.

MacWord redone to be WinWord.

Then MWord team told to follow WWord team at a spec level. They might share come code if asked politely.

Then MWord given source but much of it was .Net and similar based so it was a big re-write. And forget OLE.

Now they actually share a code base. Which I think is up to 90% or so. Mostly for layout and features. UI for each is done to match the UI needs of the platform instead of the Mac folks being told to make it "more like Windows". And the codes changes/fixes now flow both ways.

Macs just have too big a penetration into school and universities to ignore reality. And MS has taken a much more "we're OK to sell them Office or M/O 365 without Windows as long as they don't use Google docs and email". Ballmer leaving was what allowed that to happen.

310:

"tetanus vaccine comes combined with diphtheria in its standard form"

DTP, I think.

https://www.cdc.gov/vaccinesafety/vaccines/dtap-tdap-vaccine.html

311:

That exists too but more as a kids'-standard-shots thing. (Of course different countries may have different defaults.)

312:

Like, literally, no-one reads it.
My Name is No One - The Mechanisms - 3:03
My Name Is No-One
"But I choke down the pain ‘cause one good throw and the eye of the Cyclops is mine!
I wouldn't do an op like that drunk, though. (Well, not under the influence of ethyl alcohol.)

(I kinda like their treatment of the Trojan Horse, though.)

Did have fun rabbit-holing down the Festival of Lights / Anwad / etc; thanks for that.

[cranky after nearly 2 years of anti-COVID-19 NPIs; even though hypersensitive introvert, so rant ahead.]
The low vaccination rate in the US currently has a dominant partisan component prodded and amplified by mass-homicidal operators. (Not entirely unexpected.)
In an alternate trouser-leg of time, where DJT won the election and was still POTUS, there would be right wing vigilante squads (perhaps with distinctive clothing, though the shirts would not be brown) staking out the homes of anti-vaxers. They would be organizing shaming(/shunning) campaigns. There would be mandatory vaccinations in the workplace with the “Trump vaccine”, enforced with severe (employee-only (employers are sacred)) sanctions. Evangelical church members would be knocking on doors about vaccination-Jesus. Etc.
And US vaccination rates would be 10-20 percentage points higher than they are now.

Most of the unvaxxed in partially vaxxed populations where vaccines have been available for many months, are, when unmasked, a statistical (mortal) threat to public health. Omicron(/vaccine escape) shifts this a bit, but delta and omicron will co-exist in populations. They, especially when unmasked, deny access to public places by those concerned about their health, especially to those who are immune-compromised or otherwise unvaccinatable. (I have not yet found a superspreader event case study where the index patient was verified to be always wearing a mask.) In the US there are Stand-Your-Ground laws in way too many states; we have been Lucky so far that there has been no vigilante action against people threatening the health of others with unfiltered exhaled plumes infectious material.

Video:

.@jordanklepper vs. Anti-Vaxxers in SoCal pic.twitter.com/oOIM1JHha9

— The Daily Show (@TheDailyShow) December 9, 2021
313:

David L @ 268:

My first flu shot came in the early 70s. There was a Swine Flu outbreak & I remember there were mandatory vaccination. I don't remember any anti-VAXX at the time. Swine Flu sucked & it apparently was bad enough that it was killing some people and who wants that? Hadn't turned into a political football yet.

Actually it was a bit controversial. But in those days it was private conversations for the most part. No Internet or social media to amplify it all out of proportion. I have memories of my father making some very mild comments about it wondering if it really was a serious flu strain or just a way to see if the US population would accept being told "everyone get vaccinated". This was very out of character for my father and it may have been he was commenting on what others said. But it really stuck with me.

Looking it up the Swine flu was around 2008. The "Hong Kong" flu was 68-69 and was likely what I (and maybe you) were thinking of.

If it was controversial, I don't remember the N&O reporting the controversy. I was already a news junkie and devoured the paper daily.

The vaccine campaign I remember was probably some time after 1974, because I was already married. I remember it because my wife was a drama queen & a big cry-baby about getting shots and she bitched at me nonstop the whole day - before we went, while we were standing in line and after we came home.

It was done on a Sunday afternoon in the Broughton High School cafeteria. According to Wikipedia there was a Swine Flu outbreak in the U.S. in 1976.

314:

dsrtao @ 281: Pulling this from way back in #182:.

News story: Maine, NH, and NY are mobilizing the National Guard to help with medical issues of overworked and understaffed.

The National Guard is a part-time militia. Guess what they do the rest of the time?

That's right, they work, in that state, doing jobs like ambulance driver, nurse, emergency medicine tech... if they have medical skills, they're already working. Having the Guard called up moves them to some other part of the state, where they are no longer familiar with what's going on, can't retreat home at the end of the day, generally makes them less effective.

If all you wanted were grunt laborers, offer $25 an hour.

It works better than you think. Frequently National Guard medics are not drawn from medical profession. When not on duty they're grocery store clerks or para-legals in some law office. The actual Doctors & Nurses will generally be exempt from a state call-up for medical emergency. They might bring on Doctors & Nurses from OUTSIDE the emergency area.

There are plenty of NON-medical, logistics & administrative roles the National Guard can fill to free up medical personnel. You don't have to be a doctor to drive the ambulance.

315:

.” You're a well educated man who understands (at least rudimenatary) biology and so on.” I’m not a biologist. My MSc is in clinical biochemistry. My wife knows much more immunolog than I do.

“If you are an American Citizen, you're now in the top 30% of your populace.” I’m not American I’m British.

“We'll make it simple for you: not all your fellow Humans understand this. Many don't have the economic liberty to access "a free vaccination" if they could. Some cannot because they are not legal citizens. And so on.” I’ll make it simple for you. You don’t need to state the obvious. But in the UK there’s no such block to vaccination.

“The reasons are multi-tudinous; the results are death. We'd suggest blaming the systme rather than the people being preyed upon by it. This includes those slavishly believing in PFsxzzrer and other C-Level Corp execs from Comnpanies whose main model (tied to insurance scams) is: "Bleed the fuckers dry".” Why are you afraid doing to write Pfizer? They are just capitalists. Their profiteering is possible because the US government won’t regulate them. The Oxford group chose the help mankind rather than get rich,

“Want to bitch about it?:” About what?

Don't blame Individuals (essentially not an issue in this): blame your systems. And your system is fucked.

I do blame individuals. Vaccination is a public duty. Those who are able to be vaccinated but choose not to, either out of misplaced individualism or because they’re basically freeloaders and deserve to die from their disease. But in doing so they infect others. ~

“For the record: this body has had no immune shots. Given we can ramp the internal temp up to ~108 without it dying and there's a shit load of much nastier fucking shit making its penis dance in there, trust us: not all of the "un-vaxxed" are threats to you. Shit you not, the stuff they tried to infect us with was faaaaaaaaar worse than a Conovirus. Heart goes SILENT RUNNING for 7 days on certain stuff. We've also not been able to talk to another H.S.S for years.”

Is there medical reason for your refusal of vaccinations or are you a freeloader?

See above: vaccination =/= anything special. It's not a fucking badge, and some humans (chemo, immon-comp'd, AIDS etc) don't have the luxury of the choice.” Immunocompromised people are protected by the majority who are vaccinated. Vaccination is special. Just like antibiotics. Modern life would be impossible without them. So don't be a (AUS TRANSLATION) cunt and think you know better.

~ You can call me what you want but you’re wrong.

“You also missed the entire point which is worrying.”

I you were worried about people missing the point you would take care to write in comprehensible text. I glance at your posts because sometimes they contain interesting facts but I can’t be bothered deciphering deliberately obscure and/or redacted language. And I’m perfectly aware of vaccine dangers. I refused the HIV vaccine required for my job because it had a slight increased risk of multiple sclerosis. Since my mother died of this I’m statistically already at thirteen times the risk of the general population. My wife initially refused the same vaccine required for her job in virology until she had been reassured that it wasn’t the flavour grown in vaccinia. She was very ill as a young child after her smallpox vaccine.

316:

Charlie Stross @ 283:

The National Guard is a part-time militia. Guess what they do the rest of the time?

Am I right in thinking the Guard know what their members' civilian specialties are and allocate them to roles accordingly? (So that civilian medics/nurses/etc would be given equivalent roles when called up.)

If so, there may be some useful roles -- for example, drivers for ambulances so that the civilian paramedics can leave that part of their job to someone else and focus on stabilizing patients on their way to hospital.

I'm reaching here but there must be something worth doing, unless this is just a political photo-op mobilization.

The state AG's department knows their soldiers civilian specialties and their MILITARY specialties. They won't be calling up Doctors & nurses who work in one hospital and assigning them to work in another hospital. They probably would ask doctors who didn't work in a hard hit area to volunteer for state duty.

And most National Guard medics do not work full time in the medical field. They're medics on the weekend and during Annual Training or Deployment, but generally the people called up to state duty will perform ancillary roles.

317:

arrbee @ 291: As the state is effectively forcing a woman to have a child that she does not want, does this mean that - the state becomes financially reponsible for the upkeep of that child, and/or - the state becomes totally responsible for the care of the child ? If not, why not ? ( assuming the woman feels the same way after the child is born )

You know damn well they don't. They only care about the "child" from conception to birth. After that they're on their own.

And the so-called pro-life assholes have no shame either, so don't expect them to take any responsibility for their actions.

318:

Bill Arnold @ 312
DO NOT DO THAT
I was expecting some sort of explanation regarding sotmn's irrationalities - I actually got EarShit. ...
Sorry, I know that US "Stand -Your-Ground" so-called "Laws" are fucking stupid, but you are making no sense to a UK resident - explain or shut up about such things - PLEASE?

Mike Collins @ 315
DOUBLEPUSGOOD Thank you - that's the best take-down of the seagull's raving lunacies, incoherence & plain dangerous insinuations I've yet seen.
HINT: My neighbour ( & a friend ) is severely immunocompromised - transplant. SELFISH & STUPID SHITS like sotmn are not wanted, thank you!
And, may I repeat in bold?
If you were worried about people missing the point you would take care to write in comprehensible text.
THIS, exactly - for how many times, now?

319:

Elderly Cynic @ 296: I started having tetanus shots in the early 1950s. Some of my multiple vaccinations were because there were no records. I am surprised at multiple smallpox ones, because the ones we had left a large and highly indicative scar.

Same here, but my second smallpox vaccination came 48 years after the first one. For many of the soldiers in the Brigade, it was their FIRST smallpox vaccination. Most of the younger soldiers were born after smallpox was considered eradicated in the wild.

But based on the fear that smallpox might be developed as a biological weapon, the Army decided to vaccinate everyone, even us old farts who already had the inoculation as a child.

Whether the fear was reasonable I don't know, but I do think taking precautions against it was reasonable.

320:

"I you were worried about people missing the point you would take care to write in comprehensible text."

She did.

The original post you and Greg are doing your nuts about was quite clear about who its actual targets were. All that is required is to read it without a preconceived intention of discovering glaniform tendencies in the interpretation. That she is actually saying pretty much the opposite of what you are accusing her of is not at all obscure, and she is both correct and justified in saying that you have completely missed the point (in multiple ways, and repeated the error in subsequent posts).

PilotMoonDog has already made the same point @ 251, but it seems that it needs to be repeated.

321:

Is there medical reason for your refusal of vaccinations or are you a freeloader?

I wouldn't do an op like that drunk, though. (Well, not under the influence of ethyl alcohol.)

The answer is simple: we suggest you grep "do not want to be put into a lab and subject to vivisection". Suggesting we take your vaccine is akin to necking ivermectin horse paste[1]: different physiology. And... given the amount of effort spent fucking assassinating Others like us (the woods, the woods) and the RAMPANT ideological STAMPING ("The Beast": "We Disagree") while we're being extremely polite about Abrahamic Religions, trust us: if we needed it, we'd already have been forced to have it.

If we took it, we'd be feeding a whole another Conspiracy line, that one about Saline injections and A/B/C grades. And potentially taking a dose from a Human Being who required it.

Sigh.

OBVIOUSLY: since x2 shots are now totally fucking useless, get a booster and hope that the 70-7% coverage is enough and the R rate is kept under 1.4. You're all very smart people, you know the drill. We assumed this was a base-line knowledge base.

And: pray very very hard you don't get our version of this, which is a little bit more hard-core. And death is not an option.

"There is Light" - spoilers kids: the goodies don't name winning genocidal warfare as "The Festival of Light" even if it's about their freedom and then sing about it for 3.000 years if they actually told the Truth to their children about absolutely anything (merkins!). And they don't make it such a Mental Mindset that their Eurovision Singers are shocked that no-one else views their country as a "Light Bringers Beacon" when we watch them knee-cap children.

You know, for reference there.

Lol, just joking: you're British, this is 100% your bag of Chai.

[1] There's a bonus hidden joke here about RU / CN vaxes and so on, but hey.

322:

Sorry, I know that US "Stand -Your-Ground" so-called "Laws" are fucking stupid, but you are making no sense to a UK resident - explain or shut up about such things - PLEASE?
Imagine some armed (concealed gun) hair-trigger-temper male in a US Stand-Your-Ground state, who is fully onboard and approving of public health measures like vaccination and masks indoors in public spaces.
Spice it up - his wife recently died of COVID-19, infected by some unmasked, unvaccinated COVID-skeptic - she was wearing a surgical mask but the stochastic killer was near her in a room and coughing Delta plumes for minutes and a surgical mask isn't as good a defense as a tightly-fitted N95.
While he is in a shop, some other COVID-skeptic starts loudly making fun of him for wearing a mask, calling him an ignorant gullible sheep, etc, while convincingly coughing (maybe pretend) to be more of an asshole.
Our hair-trigger-temper guy says to keep away. COVID-skeptic asshole approaches, coughing loudly. Our hair-trigger temper pulls his concealed gun, guy shoots him in the leg. Hits a major artery. Guy bleeds out, dies.
Oops.
Maybe a few similar copycat cases happen after it gets in the national press, or not. (US population is 330 million.)
Our hair-trigger-temper guy and his lawyer decide to use a Stand-Your-Ground defense, because it is all they have and the incident was recorded on shop video.
The US press goes wild. Our hair-trigger temper guy is either acquitted or convicted; doesn't matter - COVID-skeptic asshole is still dead, and the killing of COVID-skeptics becomes a thing.

This hasn't happened, yet.

(Also, SotMNs has said nothing anti-vax - it's all meta, about the anti-vax movements/factions, the propaganda driving them, the agendas driving the propagandists/influence operators, the entities driving those agendas, and regrettable things like very high pharma company profits and tone-def corporate executives that can be, and are being, used by homicidal propagandists.
And - to your other point (re "this body") , if it helps you, think of it as fiction - the persona is mocking the pronunciation of modern Hebrew, up-thread, which I am pretty sure you do not believe is true. )

323:

Re: 'I think you're conflating two different things. The Amazon warehouse was in Edwardsville Illinois. Which is really East St. Louis. Nearly 200 miles north of Mayfield Ky.

You're right re: conflating/not understanding the distances involved. Heteromeles is also right: probably a combination of factors. But ... I still wonder about how much attention some of these mammoth warehouse/depot operators give employee safety. Because tornadoes are usually written off as 'acts of god', not sure whether their insurance provider will investigate and provide a list of mandatory/recommended improvements. The org sidestepped answering how many employees were there by claiming the tornado struck during shift change, i.e., potentially many more employees.

The news updates are pretty grim and I don't think our weather patterns are going to get much calmer over the next few years. Whatever a very high profile for-profit-corp does or does not do re: corporate responsibility wrt on-the-job employee safety matters now and long term. (I've recently seen articles saying that some insurers are balking about coverage for problematic GW/CC areas.)

Re: 'I've been near a few, but never "in" one.'

I have while vacationing on a 10 or 12 ton displacement boat in a small bay in one of the Great Lakes. We had about 15 minutes' warning over the marine band.

324:

the persona is mocking the pronunciation of modern Hebrew, up-thread, which I am pretty sure you do not believe is true.

We totally are: but for very different reasons to what you might suppose. There's an extremely (deadly) touchy area about this Theologically speaking which we are not litigating: we've presented an alternative ("accents") that is also Factually True (in that, no-one alive has the same accent as a Trader looking for Wigs / Merkins circa 700CBE/BC in a trade port that harboured almost all near Languages at that point[1]) while respecting the (stupidly wasteful) huge amount of Scholarship that has gone into making sure that Hebew (Modern) is "factually" true[2] and also respecting those who believe that even speaking the Language is a blasphemy that we can't repeat here.

...And also: most IL people speak with fucking terrible grammar anyhow. And their accents are all over the place, due to teaching multiple waves of immigrants their "new Mother Tongue".

It's a joke: it's not disrespectful.

~Also, it's Meta: the last known speakers of Hebrew (ancient) were.... traders. At that very port.

BE NOT AFRAID

[1] And, more importantly: is actually in the Torah / Bible, thus offending no-one. The name is a bit mangled, but it's there. i.e. no additional Existential Angst required.

[2] As in: you might think this is just like speaking Latin or Greek, but... technically not true, at all.

325:

I'm reaching here but there must be something worth doing, unless this is just a political photo-op mobilization.

It would also be useful to see if there is a difference between the role assigned and the role touted in the media.

Back when Toronto had a really bad snowstorm and the mayor called in the Army for assistance, the city took a lot of flack for calling in soldiers to shovel show. (Pictures of soldiers with snow shovels were front-page news.)

But that wasn't the assistance requested at all. Lastman (the mayor) was worried about ambulances not being able to get through and requested the military provide some ATVs and medics, which were stationed around the city to transport patients to hospital in the event of heart attack etc.

A low-ranking officer ordered his men to shovel show in front of a TV crew, thinking 'military helps out' was good PR, and didn't realize that that story would be reported as the entirety of their mission.

326:

The emergency weather systems send alerts/alarms for target area residents to take shelter - why didn't BigRiver employees?

Because workers aren't allowed to bring their phones with them, so wouldn't get texts/alerts, is probably one part of that puzzle. So taking action would require management to make a decision favouring workers and cutting productivity, which is measured by algorithms and affects compensation/job security.

I suspect that a manager shutting down a warehouse for a tornado that missed wouldn't be well-regarded by those algorithms. And simply allowing workers to leave without passing security would be a loss-control nightmare — so again a decision that would negatively impact careers.

327:

Mike Collins: Hear, hear!

328:

I wrote this post after an exhausting day. I ended up writing HIV instead of Hepatitis B vaccine.

329:

Bill Arnold
"Also, SotMNs has said nothing anti-vax.."
REALLY?
Here she is in #321
..."The answer is simple: we suggest you grep "do not want to be put into a lab and subject to vivisection". Suggesting we take your vaccine is akin to necking ivermectin horse paste[1]: different physiology. And... given the amount of effort spent fucking assassinating Others like us (the woods, the woods) and the RAMPANT ideological STAMPING ("The Beast": "We Disagree") while we're being extremely polite about Abrahamic Religions, trust us: if we needed it, we'd already have been forced to have it."
READS like ant-vaxx propaganda to me, where it isn't the usual ravings.

330:

The Seagull speaks an infinite deal of nothing, more than anyone on this blog. Her reasons are as two grains of wheat hid in two bushels of chaff; you shall seek all day ere you find them, and when you have them, they are not worth the search.

331:

You've started reading the Seagull's postings again, they have you on their hook again and they are taking pleasure from your reaction again. I recommend you stop paying attention completely but it's your choice. You may also, like I do, ignore those like Bill Arnold that do interact with the Seagull but again it's your choice.

I interacted with people like this a long time ago on Usenet. It was never a satisfying experience. YMMV.

332:

As an American, I must say I'm amazed (for one word; sickened may be better though) but the tendency of too many nations choosing to cease mitigation efforts too early to chill out the masses, as it were -- the same masses they pretty consistently ignore outside of empty campaign promises. Of course, we are even worse in the US where states are free to ignore federal directives and courts are knocking down one federal mandate after another in order to push the GOP's longterm goal of shrinking the federal state which, obviously, also involves rendering it as powerless as possible.

333:

Whether the fear was reasonable I don't know, but I do think taking precautions against it was reasonable.

Smallpox was a horrible, horrible disease and I'm glad it's gone.

I'm unusual for my age cohort -- aged 57 -- in not having been vaccinated: I still remember having had an exemption certificate in my passport when traveling in the 1970s.

(I had severe atopic eczema as a kid, so they patch-tested me when they came to vaccinate everyone in my year at school. I had a bad enough reaction they gave me a pass, Epipens not having been invented yet.)

334:

the (stupidly wasteful) huge amount of Scholarship that has gone into making sure that Hebew (Modern) is "factually" true

It's not stupidly wasteful if your perspective is that it's a necessary cost of nation-building an artificial polity assembled from settlers drawn from all over the world. Which indeed the modern state of Israel is: Aliyah only got under way from the 1880s onwards, and nobody spoke modern Hebrew before then: it picked up pace during the 1930s/40s (can't think why ...) and then accelerated, and the State needed a common language (and couldn't adopt English, Arabic, or German for ideological reasons: Yiddish might have been viable but would have excluded the Sephardic community and in any event took a huge hit during the Shoah).

Anyway, it's very largely an artificial language. Case in point: my first cousin paid his way through PhD studies in English by translating SF novels into Hebrew during the 1970s, and one of the things that kept tripping him up was the need to invent new Hebrew terms for words he ran across in English. (This isn't that surprising when you consider that, per Teresa Nielsen Hayden -- one of my editors at Tor.com -- almost every SF/F novel reinvents the language to some extent.)

335:

Plus the fact that even 'standard' English is a huge language, it has a zillion variants, and they keep exchanging words and uses.

336:

"Couldn't adopt English ... for ideological reasons." Uh?
I can see why German or Arabic might not be a "good idea", but I'm missing something here, all too clearly.

337:

England was the Imperial power with the League of Nations Mandate in Palestine, 1918-48.

To the Jewish settlers they were an oppressive foreign occupation who hunted, arrested, and executed resistance fighters: and who also refused entry to Jewish refugees from the Third Reich, resulting in uncounted thousands of deaths.

It's not well-remembered in the UK, but pretty much as soon as Israel declared independence it acquired an Army -- which had formerly been known as the Haganah. This was more or less the equivalent of the pre-Irish independence IRA in terms of scope and activity. They were the mainstream paramilitary arm of the movement: the more radical/activist types splintered off to form Lehi and Irgun (also known to the British as the Stern Gang). Anyway, thing is, the formative influences of the Israeli Army were: fighting a resistance against British occupation, and (a minority pursuit) fighting for the British (in the Jewish Legion) against the Nazis, which is where a lot of their officers were trained. And with universal military service the army was a major component of nation-building, with disproportionate political clout. (An old Israeli joke: "why will there never be a military coup in Israel?" To which the answer is, "because the cabinet are all generals!")

Finally: the first wave of pre-Mandate Jewish settlements in Palestine came from German and other European nations, including Russia. (Anti-semitism in Europe goes back a long way: IIRC about a quarter of a million Jews were murdered in pogroms in Europe circa 1914-18.) British Jews were a small minority of this. So English wasn't widely spoken, and was a language associated with foreign imperialist occupation.

338:

The latest UK report indicates a R value of 3.7, a doubling time of 2.3 days, and that it will dominate by the end of December. But that won't appear in the published data until well into January.

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/investigation-of-sars-cov-2-variants-technical-briefings

339:

I couldn't figure out from that document whether this R-value is assuming unvaccinated or vaccinated, or whether the vaccination status is immaterial to the transmission rate. I would hope that high rates of vaccination lowers the likelihood of transmission; it seems to for other variants.

340:

Going science fiction-adjacent for a moment, it's worth noting that the current martial art Krav Maga was in part developed by a combat instructor (Imre Lichtenfeld) in the Haganah and subsequently in the IDF.

I point this out in an SF context because setting-appropriate martial arts are good window dressing for many stories. What we consider martial arts are often the commercialized descendants of the hand-to-hand, and small-weapons combat skills developed by guerrillas, spies, paramilitaries, and gangsters. For example, I wouldn't be surprised if some former Al Qaeda members haven't opened self defense gyms in Pakistan already, the same way some former SEALs are teaching their stuff here in the US.

It's part of the post-conflict half-life of military arts and sciences, fortunately or unfortunately. While various forms of wrestling seem to be universal in humans (especially among children and young men), and indeed aren't limited to humans, combat arts seem to be more historical: they're the legacies of conflicts, where someone tries to figure out how to teach their skills either to protect others or to make money. The interesting thing is that it's rare for these systems to last all that long, probably because good fighters are comparatively rare, while duffers like me are the norm, and the bad tend to flood out the good, especially if there's little need to actually use the skills as they were intended.

Just something to think about. If you want to have grumpy middle-aged men teaching antifa skills in refugee camps somewhere, that's actually might be appropriate in a few decades.

341:

SFReader @ 300: Re: 'Mayfield Kentucky just got hit hard last night.'

Saw the headlines in GoogNews which included an article about the BigRiver depot there also taking a hit: considerable damage, unknown number of employees trapped (why?*) but not razed to the ground like some nearby homes/small biz.

Geez - wonder who's going to get Fed/State emergency funds/help, how much and how fast? Better yet - base that 'help' on amts paid in taxes.

Looks like it's going to be the states of Arkansas, Missouri, Illinois and Kentucky or at least the parts of those states that were affected by this storm system.

• The emergency weather systems send alerts/alarms for target area residents to take shelter - why didn't BigRiver employees?

How do you know they didn't? Maybe wait a bit until you have some facts before talking smack just because you don't like their employer.

342:

That document is specific to the UK so presumably assumes a high vaccination rate (the UK is way ahead of the USA currently).

Also warning nobody knows yet -- or will know for at least a month or two -- if omicron causes long covid, much less how likely you are to come down with long covid after omicron.

Which is worse: a strain with 1% mortality and about 5% long-term (multiple years) disability, or a strain with 0.1% mortality but 25% long-term disability? In purely personal terms it sucks to be dead ... but the "25% disability" option would be an economic catastrophe.

343:

Tornadoes

For those who have never lived where these are a "thing".

Tornado Alley in the US does have a very high incidence of tornadoes. And building codes reflect that. To the extent that schools now have bomb shelter like rooms in them for students to hide in when one is near. And there people do have cellar rooms and such where they hide out at times. Many towns in this part of the country have sirens for warning.

For the rest of us who live where tornadoes might show up...

99.999% (maybe a few more nines) will never ever see one or have their home or work location hit. Not quite as rare as a meteor strike but as something to worry about it is closer to that than any day to day concern.

More and more buildings have a safe room which is likely something like the bathrooms in a warehouse are made of cement block walls instead of drywall over framing. But no where near bomb shelter like in the "alley".

Warning systems over phones are great. But for tornadoes they are a total Pain in the Ass. Our weather forecasting state of the art is to where someone might get a half dozen alerts in 2 or 3 hours and no tornadoes ever appear. Which is 99% of the time. So most everyone just turns the alerts off as they are great at interrupting meetings, video calls, diner, etc... Seriously most everyone turns them off.

And when you actually get the warnings of a tornado nearby you have 5 or 10 minutes to do something. Which means get under something NOW and hope the building you are in doesn't come down around you.

Again, I've lived in tornado prone areas for 60 years or so of my life. I've spent 2 nights in basements of old masonry buildings. I've been in the middle of major outbreaks. (Check out the April 1975 one in the US.) I've had them touch down within 10 miles of me multiple times. I have NEVER EVER seen one or been in a building damaged by a tornado. The closest was about 5 years ago when the sky turn charcoal gray and rain was literally pouring down. One was one the ground 3 miles away.

You just can't plan your daily life around them.

Oh, yeah. I had boarded a plane at DFW when we were told the departure was on hold as a storm cell was passing over the airport. After 30 minutes we pushed back and took off. I found out after landing that a tornado had touched down about 5 to 10 miles east of the airport. And made a mess of an area. But while over us was just storm system strong enough to pause operations at the airport for a bit. And DFW is a bit over the top when it comes to caution for such storms. Check out the L1011 Delta crash there back in the 80s.

344:

Agreed. In grad school on the edge of Tornado Alley, I was once in my office around 10 pm (grad student!) during a storm when the tornado sirens went off all around me. Great! What to do? Looked out the window, and I couldn't see a damned thing. Which is normal, when you consider what a major rainstorm looks like at night. So I moved away from the windows and got back to work. The tornado passed a few miles away.

That's the problem: even when you know a tornado is out there, sometimes there's not a lot you can do, and running into the storm isn't often (or usually) the best answer anyway.

Now, if you're like someone I once knew online, who lived in Oklahoma and had his prized ethnographic knife collection displayed all over the walls of his house...getting into the basement during a tornado warning actually might be a reasonably intelligent move. I never knew if he told his neighbors about his decorations, or how they felt about them.

345:

I haven't heard anything about "Omicron" reaching North Carolina yet, but I expect it will get here sooner rather than later.

It's here. It was sequenced in the Charlotte area a day or two ago.

Got my 6th PCR test Friday. Negative. [yeah]

346:

had his prized ethnographic knife collection displayed all over the walls of his house...getting into the basement during a tornado warning actually might be a reasonably intelligent move. I never knew if he told his neighbors about his decorations, or how they felt about them.

I like it. But you know when the wind is throwing something at you at 100+mph I don't think it makes much difference as to how sharp or pointed it is. A scrape of wood framing might do more damage than a knife blade.

347:

Pigeon @ 302: The best I can usually manage is "well, I know it wasn't within the last five years..." followed by an attempt at tracing connections through my memory to try and come up with a date for the last occasion I can be reasonably sure I did have one. At some point they get fed up with listening to me wibbling on and decide to just give me one anyway. It seems to work; at least, I haven't got ill with tetanus yet.

Last time I had one they were also asking me about my diphtheria vaccination status, which baffled me entirely; I might have had it when I was too small to remember what the jab was about, but basically I just don't know. Reason being apparently that nowadays the tetanus vaccine comes combined with diphtheria in its standard form, and the plain tetanus-only version is some kind of special order thing that they don't get in unless someone actually can't have the diphtheria bit (or something along those lines). Must say it surprised me a bit as I didn't think diphtheria was anything like as likely to infect you as tetanus; nor is it something you catch in the same way, so "if you can get one you can probably get the other too" does not apply.

My guess is diphtheria is still a problem out in the wider world even if it's been mostly wiped out in the U.K., E.U. and U.S.. I think in the U.S. you can still get the tetanus alone shot if it's indicated (i.e. deep wound and you don't know when you last got a tetanus booster). Otherwise if you're getting the booster because it's been 10 years or so & it might include the diphtheria booster as well.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DPT_vaccine

I'm pretty sure I got the DPT booster at least once as an adult. And as it turns out, because I signed a form to have my Army medical records turned over to the VA when I started to draw retired pay, the VA actually knows when I last got a tetanus booster.

I'm a little surprised your NIH didn't have a similar record.

348:

David L @ 304: I read the storm front itself was moving at 60mph. Which for a weather SYSTEM is just plain hauling ass.

And even if you live right in the middle of tornado alley, you're not really expecting - or making preparations for - a storm system like that one in DECEMBER.

One last point. Tornadoes are incredibly local. I've been near a few, but never "in" one. One came through here 30 years ago and left a 20 miles long trail. That one obliterated trees 100' from a house we almost bought a month earlier. But no issues with the house. One big box store leveled (exploded really) with merchandise all over many acres yet the office I went to work in the next morning was fine. You see a house foundation with nothing on it and the ones next door are fine or even a house with a missing WALL and the rest of the house intact. Even the furniture in the exposed rooms still in place.

I had been up to visit my Mom who at the time lived up near the NC - Virginia state line. On the way home I crossed the path of the tornado about 10 minutes ahead of it and I didn't even see storm clouds. The big box store that got leveled was one of the locations I serviced for the burglar alarm company. I drove past it at midnight & I believe the first alarm came in about 10 minutes later. I found out about the tornado the next morning when I was dispatched to the location to shut down the alarms.

350:

Greg Tingey @ 318: Bill Arnold @ 312
DO NOT DO THAT
I was expecting some sort of explanation regarding sotmn's irrationalities - I actually got EarShit. ...Sorry, I know that US "Stand -Your-Ground" so-called "Laws" are fucking stupid, but you are making no sense to a UK resident - explain or shut up about such things - PLEASE?

Mike Collins @ 315
DOUBLEPUSGOOD Thank you - that's the best take-down of the seagull's raving lunacies, incoherence & plain dangerous insinuations I've yet seen.
HINT: My neighbour ( & a friend ) is severely immunocompromised - transplant. SELFISH & STUPID SHITS like sotmn are not wanted, thank you!
And, may I repeat in bold?
If you were worried about people missing the point you would take care to write in comprehensible text.
THIS, exactly - for how many times, now?

The thing you should try to keep in mind is that fully HALF of the people in the U.S. have below average intelligence.

This also holds true for the U.K., the E.U. and the rest of the world.

351:

Charlie Stross @ 333:

Whether the fear was reasonable I don't know, but I do think taking precautions against it was reasonable.

Smallpox was a horrible, horrible disease and I'm glad it's gone.

I'm unusual for my age cohort -- aged 57 -- in not having been vaccinated: I still remember having had an exemption certificate in my passport when traveling in the 1970s.

(I had severe atopic eczema as a kid, so they patch-tested me when they came to vaccinate everyone in my year at school. I had a bad enough reaction they gave me a pass, Epipens not having been invented yet.)

Yeah, I was speaking specifically to whether the fear that Saddam had made a biological weapon out of smallpox was reasonable. Turns out he hadn't, but WE (especially those of us down in the mushroom farm) didn't know that at the time.

I'm not sure when the WHO and/or CDC declared smallpox eradicated, but at some point THEY decided to discontinue vaccinating children against it (at least here in the U.S.). As a result, when the possibility Saddam might have developed a smallpox bio-weapon came up, significant numbers of our brigade (younger soldiers) had never had the smallpox vaccine.

As a precaution THEY decided to vaccinate EVERYBODY and that's what I considered a "reasonable" precaution, even though it turned out to be unnecessary.

And knowing what I know now, I still think it was a reasonable precaution even though it inconvenienced me personally.

352:

Re: 'Maybe wait a bit until you have some facts before talking smack just because you don't like their employer.'

I am waiting for facts - but their history suggests certain possibilities that would not leap to mind for other orgs.

BigRiver is not a particularly old outfit, so their custom designed/built warehouses can't be that old either. Plus some of their major warehouses/depots cost $1billion to put up. What happened just doesn't make sense. At some point a journalist will check whatever's on file with the local city hall re: building permit, blueprints, inspections, etc. (I'm assuming that that area/city required such.)

353:

As OGH implies, the R value is specific to a particular disease in a particular society in a particular state (e.g. vaccination and lockdown both reduce it). For two strains in exactly the same conditions, the R values are proportionate to their inherent infectivity, but that's all you can say.

354:

Charlie Stross @ 337: England was the Imperial power with the League of Nations Mandate in Palestine, 1918-48.

To the Jewish settlers they were an oppressive foreign occupation who hunted, arrested, and executed resistance fighters: and who also refused entry to Jewish refugees from the Third Reich, resulting in uncounted thousands of deaths.

Kind of ironic, because if memory serves, it was the British who first came up with the idea for Jews to have their own state located in Palestine ... dating back to the 1840s .

355:

JBS & Charlie
I knew that the Attlee guvmint had attempted to ban Jews from "returning" to Israel in 1945-8, but have never, ever found out why they did what seems to me to be a profoundly stupid move. I mean .. w.t.f?

356:

Yeah, about those nay-sayers and how's it's all noise:

OBVIOUSLY: since x2 shots are now totally fucking useless, get a booster and hope that the 70-7% coverage is enough and the R rate is kept under 1.4. You're all very smart people, you know the drill. We assumed this was a base-line knowledge base.

BJ just went "live" (pre-recorded) with... this exact message. Like, literally: the UK is attempting to make sure all 18+ can access booster shots by the end of the year (doubtful, but the intent is clear).

PM of IL has put out an immediate call for child vaccination, has issued travel warnings (72 hrs, UK, Belgium, Holland) and other things:

Prime minister Bennett in Israel

'i ask all parents now: protect the children of Israel - no need to make an appointment - GO STRAIGHT TO THE VACCINATION CENTER https://twitter.com/itosettiMD_MBA/status/1470041103726530561 Irene Tosetti, today, official embedded tweet in Hebrew (Modern).

And this, today: Israeli study finds 2 Pfizer shots fail to neutralize Omicron, but booster effective https://www.timesofisrael.com/israeli-study-finds-2-pfizer-shots-fail-to-neutralize-omicron-but-booster-effective/ Times of Israel, 12th Dec 2021

Look: we're being polite. It is considered highly naughty to fucking tell you what your Leaders are about to announce prior to them doing it and so on. If you do it too much, Vox Populi might start considering them "not Leaders".

~

READS like ant-vaxx propaganda to me, where it isn't the usual ravings.

That's how vaccination works: you get a dose you know the body can handle, so that when it meets the proper versions it has a defence. Put it this way: you are not accustomed to the various proper Disinfo stuff going live (as we speak) but we can see it all before it does go live and make jokes (and even meta-meta jokes) about it.

Look: we can produce you a proper .mil spec doc on what's running now, but:

a) You won't believe it b) Even when it does go live, it'll have been adapted to the weak spots we've pointed out, which is why demanding it in vanilla speak is akin to asking for imbedded 0 days in software c) We're not exactly talking only about current Covid / Omicron stuff, if you know what we mean d) It's fucking boring and even running a "Consider Phlebas" meta-historical joke that isn't (we're pretty sure) anti+semitic and more importantly is actually a key to a more 'progressive' Future in the notoriously hard to reach hermeneutics of Othodox thought merely to suggest that some Anarchists stating "The Diaspora is good, actually" has merit is annoying

while

e) We'd rather much more be talking about other stuff. f) The drinking is because Memory [redacted].

Example: Pfuzzzzer (why don't we spell it? because spiders are searching for it) stock price and so on is a raging fucking hit at the moment. Knocking it out of the park, and whoever got the C-level on UK TV either a) knows this reaction and was planning for it (hello Tufton St) or b) is a raging muppet or c) is so totally beholden to out of date and useless ancient PR machinery thought it was a good idea (hello Prince Andrew's crew).

And, sad to say: you managed to not have even the lightest doses of protections here. Which isn't your fault, you're just pre-modern variant Minds.

And yet we do try, so you don't get scrambled Eggs.

~

Re #334: well, yes, obviously, but rather it come from a person with knowledge than something like us. We're taking (gentle) aim more at the rather longer tradition of arguing over which horn of a ram is best to grasp first and so on. The larger point (for the non-secular) was that, you know, at least some of us attempt translation (conceptual). Not that they'd read it, given certain criteria, which is the meta-joke.

357:

President Eisenhower was reported to have been shocked when he discovered that half of all Americans had below average IQs.

358:

https://www.nytimes.com/2021/12/12/us/politics/newsom-texas-abortion-law-guns.html

Angered by the U.S. Supreme Court decision to continue allowing private citizens to sue Texas abortion providers, Gov. Gavin Newsom of California on Saturday called for a similar law giving ordinary residents legal standing to file lawsuits against purveyors of restricted firearms.

As predicted California might use the SCOTUS gutting of federal protection to restrict gun wrongs. I predict SCOTUS will have no hesitation finding that gun laws are different from women's rights.

359:

Oh, and for the record:

Omecron largely ignores the x2 initial shots due to (as we stated back when) RNA branch dynamics.

It spreads through those are vaccinated, it travelled via those who were vaccinated, and it can infect those who are vaccinated x2 only.

Stop the shit about blaming the "leper class" of un-vaxxed or we'll make it personal.

360:

In theory, Texas & a lot of other states have safe haven laws which means a woman can turn over a newborn baby to the state, no questions asked. Justice Barrett has referred to such laws in her arguments against legal abortion. In practice I'm not sure what the plan is if there's a dramatic increase in the number of "safe haven" babies. That's going to require a lot more tax money.

361:

Sigh: forgot, have to explain: Our reasons for that are multi-tudinous: but we'd suggest asking a simple question: The UK has had almost none of the protests / riots seen in the EU / IL (check out last night, PM abode, anti-vaxxers[1]) etc etc and yet is almost the only one who has introduced Law to make it illegal.

Why?

The answer is 2011 ish riots.

The meta-answer is something a lot more darker.

p.s.

A modern State that makes Protest illegal with immediate jail time and makes Citizenship a secret conditional determined by the State without recourse to appeal and makes Journalism and Free Speach conditional on political or economic or ethnic or racial background is....

Fascism.

Fucking warned you.

[1] And yes: if you don't think we're going to use IL anti-vaxx protests as a means to make sure actual anti+semitism that the fucking clown show B/C/D list celebs have fucked up so badly then sorry, not sorry. You're humans: we'll slap you silly with the simularities until it makes sense.

362:

They were attempting to prevent this:

النكبة

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nakba

Since, you know: they had very good empirical data from India (pre-Ghandi) on how to prevent violent uprisings and so on, as well as Ireland.

Since, you know: for all of us who aren't fucking muppets and can read, and who refuse to be threatened by jumped up little grobbits whose main education is blinkered propoganda tripe, the Founders of Israel were pretty fucking explicit on what they were aiming to do. Like: explicitly so. So explicitly so that the whole German thing was pretty entwined with it until the end of WWI and a certain artist getting the amazing idea that Concepts like this were Universal.

Like, really: Germany didn't just spawn Nazism in that period.

The more interesting question is that quite a few Jewish people also knew this and were pushing for it not to happen. Usually involving walls and guns waaaay before it got Industrialised.

"Festival of Light"

Be careful what you wish for.

363:

RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRight on!

364:

GREAAAAAAT ANSWER!

3-Alarm Fire Breaks Out in Rice Dryer at Kellogg’s Plant

Fire crews were called to a Kellogg’s plant in Memphis, TN after a fire ignited inside the facility Sunday afternoon, several local news organizations reported.

https://www.powderbulksolids.com/food-beverage/3-alarm-fire-breaks-out-rice-dryer-kelloggs-plant

Unlike you, we know WHY.

GOOOOOO, TIGERS!

365:

Actually it does.

And any warehouse built in the last 10 years will be permitted. And likely have a "safe space" inside it. Which is fine for a high wind thunderstorm but dicey for a tornado that hits the building. For that you just hope.

The bigger possible loss of life is the candle factory in Mayfield. So far they have brought out 40 people. But 110 are thought to have been inside it when it was taken out.

Have a read: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2021/dec/12/kentucky-tornado-survivor-candle-factory

Notice the picture.

Being in a building when a strong tornado hits is like a 500 pound bomb being dropped on the building.

366:

Don't let them talk smack to you.

Said Candle Factory is a hot-bed of corrupt offiicals using ex-con (parole) labour and refusing all kinds of safety stuff including preventing them from leaving work. It's malfeasance list is a mile long and the local PD are involved. Family who owns it: major power player in the region.

Reddit, for once, doing some due diligence.

~

Like: does anyone on here actually bat for the Light Side or did we miss a fucking note or something.

367:

Did the math. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1A3apMX4HVC1z6LWbUMWE-46VX9ROCPlp/edit?usp=sharing&ouid=117896955502397650801&rtpof=true&sd=true shows Omicron would spread to everyone in the US in 100 days at the aforementioned R value and doubling rate.

368:

R rate is determined by reality, aka: local populations.

Given the vastly disparate population experience of the USA (vax %, vax type, dosage types, limitiation enactments (means: masks, distancing etc) your document is...

Wank.

Bad dangerous Wank.

So... GRRRRRRREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEAT?

369:

As of today the candle company is differing from the State officials and claiming of the 110 employees 8 are dead and 8 are missing, stating in the local media that they have been able to contact all the other employees by phone.

It won't be the first time (if true) where the first reports to the media end up being far worse than the reality days/weeks later once things calm down and the processes can track everything down.

371:

That number is unclear. Of the 110 workers who were believed to be at the factory when the tornado hit, there have been only 40 rescues of workers by first responders, according to Beshear. The last rescue was at 3:30 a.m. Saturday, he said.

"We're gonna lose a lot of lives at that facility," Beshear said. "And I pray that there will be another rescue, and pray they'll be another one or two. But it's a very dire situation at this point."

However, on Sunday a spokesman for the candle factory said of the 110 people in the factory when the tornado struck, eight are confirmed dead and eight remain unaccounted for.

The rest have been reached and are alive, said Bob Ferguson with Hawks Bill Group LLC. "We've had a very productive day" getting in touch with employees, adding most of the survivors are in shelters where they could charge their devices so they could answer calls from the company, he said.

Weird. 110-40 = 70.

110-16 = 92

Where did boss man do his math?

372:

OOOOH, better question:

Why does a DC lobbyist run a fucking candle factory?

Bob Ferguson is the Chief Executive Officer and a founder of the Hawksbill Group, a global diversified business and communications consulting firm based in Washington, DC, and Hawksbill Advisors, a Hawksbill Group company focused on public policy that provides strategic counsel in public policy and external and regulatory affairs to clients worldwide.

https://hawksbillgroup.com/bob-ferguson/

S L A V E R Y

373:

(Answer: he doesn't. But that's some HIGH GRADE FIREPOWER to bring to a fucking candle factory, if you know what we're actually saying. Big $$$ rate).

Seriously? This is all performance art, right? You all actually know the players doing this and are taking the piss, right?

374:

Such spam.

And: pray very very hard you don't get our version of this, which is a little bit more hard-core. And death is not an option.

25-30 Broken Covenants and so on later.

Here's the spoiler: 5,000 years of History, no-one made that connection before. Entire lives dedicated to that sole edifice.

Took us 10 minutes while drunk: that's how shit your are.

375:

Pro-tip 77th / 8031 or whatever.

Don't do the "slight nudge spelling mistake" on something that makes you look like fucking muppets. Aaaaand.... totally out of your remit at that.

Hey: it's gotta be liberating to learn something new about your dead fucking society after 3,000 years, right?

Here's a joke: "What happens when you can't push your target into extreme crisis and violence to enable the next part of your plan"

"Ho ho ho"

"You just get the next Arab online to do it"

~

That's your fucking internal coms.

376:

It spreads through those are vaccinated, it travelled via those who were vaccinated, and it can infect those who are vaccinated x2 only.

Stop the shit about blaming the "leper class" of un-vaxxed or we'll make it personal.

What the flipping fuck are you talking about. Please give me an interpretation of what the fuck you said that isn't "the unvaccinated cannot spread Omicron variant Covid, only the vaccinated can." Functionally equivalent to "the vaccine makes you spread 5G spike proteins".

I don't know what purpose you have in conflating the small business tyrants bombarding spittle at schoolchildren and the people in the global south who don't have access to vaccines. Why are you trying to have me have sympathy for the fascists that spout reactionary bollocks in practically the same sentence as antivax propaganda by putting exploited workers in front of them?

377:

Some of us are laughing hysterically, since the governor of California has announced he's asked his staff to draft a bill for individuals to sue for $10k manufacturers of firearms, ghost guns, etc.

The SCOTUS is going to be looking at that in horror.

378:

By Ghu, a post I can pretty much read straight, and appreciate.

Oh, btw, about the spiders... back in the later usenet days, a good number of folks had a sigfile about three or four lines long, with every primary word that Raptor, or whatever is was called, that was run by the NSA to look for Suspicious Posts, so that they'd be overwhelmed by too much to process. Right now, your obfuscations is so trivial, compared to the Trumpists, and Q, and the rest their systems will mark it to have attention paid to it somewhere around 2041, if anyone ever gets to it.

379:

Btw, you're driving me (USan) nuts - IL is also the std/postal abbreviation of Illinois.

I know, I know, next you're going to tell me that CRT is not the acronym of cathode Ray Tube.

And it's nice to have you to read, now that I've just stopped even skimming JBS.

380:

The odds on the IWW being involved is minimal. Maybe it was scabs who didn't know what they were doing, he says, innocently.

381:

I have doubts about how big a deal he is.

From a quick search: "Hawkesbill Group...has 3 total employees across all of its locations and generates $253,142 in sales"

Another grifter.

382:

Please give me an interpretation of what the fuck you said that isn't "the unvaccinated cannot spread Omicron variant Covid, only the vaccinated can."
The context is the unvaxxed, and the Omicron variant. The evidence is shaping up that there is not much functional difference between the vaccinated (with current vaccines) and the unvaccinated with regard to Omicron spread, excepting perhaps those who are recently boosted (and maybe also those who have had the second dose recently; I haven't seen evidence for this but am presuming it might be true.). (Delta, against which vaccines work OK (for low levels of exposure at least - mask up), continues to be rampant, though; a parallel pandemic, essentially.)
Yes, there is disinformation being deliberately spread as you describe, asserting that only the vaccinated are spreading Omicron. SotMNs is not saying that, at least not in my reading. Wear a tight-fitting N95 mask, and push your local jurisdiction to declare an indoor public spaces masking requirement.[1]
It's also a point in time; in the next several months boosters or maybe 2-shot series covering Omcron and probably Delta too will start to become available.

[1] I live in NY State: New York governor orders temporary indoor mask mandate (December 11, 2021. Goes live tomorrow.)

383:

Someone want to do a wellness check on Greg? Twelve Seagull posts in four hours (and nine minutes, if you want to split feathers) can't be good for the poor chap's blood pressure…

384:

President Eisenhower was reported to have been shocked when he discovered that half of all Americans had below average IQs.

When I started teaching my principal was really upset that 50% of our students in one particular category had failed the provincial literacy test. There were two students in that category, and one had arrived in Canada the previous week and spoke almost no English. She knew why that student failed, but still insisted that 50% was too high a failure rate…

She later got promoted to special assistant to the director of education.

Neither event filled me with confidence in the ability of management…

385:

The SCOTUS is going to be looking at that in horror.
California Governor Gavin Newsom is quite directly attacking the "conservative(aka radical)" wing of the US Supreme Court with this. Other states should do similar, but different enough that a single SCOTUS decision couldn't void them all without voiding the Texas abortion ban law. One I'm thinking of is wealth taxes (forbidden by the US constitution), collected by legal privateers, with the states taxing all collected revenue but a very generous fixed fee. (or maybe a percentage fee, to encourage targeting the richest of the rich.)

Gavin Newsom To Use 'Logic' Behind Texas Abortion Ban To Ban Assault Weapons (Robyn Pennacchia, December 12, 2021)
This will give the conservative wing of the court three options. They can retract the Texas decision, thereby making it so California can't pass their version, they can try to only ban California's law, thereby making a mockery of themselves and the Constitution (and making it a hell of a lot easier to justify packing the court), or they can let California's law stand.

386:

Neither event filled me with confidence in the ability of management…

But how good was she at filling out forms and writing memos and such?

387:

Opportunity knocks: I get to test the new markup system and also share a cartoon about plague idiots. It works in preview.

388:

356, 359, 361, 362, 364, 366, 371, 372, 373, 374, 375,

Skulgun
I have deliberately NOT read any of the multiple diarrhoea-splatterings listed above - as pigeon ( IIRC ) said, it's a lure, a trap, a snare. And she's "just" sectionable ....

Robert Prior
😁
Oddly enough, I've just had a set of blood pressure checks & it's perfectly OK. Approx: 123/84 over 14 readings ...

And, since you pointed it out & as I've noted above ( 11 vacuum-filled rants )
Didn't we have a rule, somewhere, about how many of these were actually allowed at a go? - Something like THREE ??

389:

Meanwhile, if we are talking about evil & corrupt practices, just as a reminder This pops up in the press, reminding us of dark corners
As a further addition, let us not forget that, though some/all of the plod involved in the non-prosecution of the murderers of Steven Lawrence were racists ... bloody all of them were corrupt & on the take, mainly from the people who actually did the murder. But MetPlod decided they would rather be labelled "Institutionally Racist" rather than "Totally Bent" ( As well as being partly-racist. )

390:

Robert Prior @ 384: She knew why that student failed, but still insisted that 50% was too high a failure rate…

On the other hand, maybe she had to fill in a monthly report with a box for the number but no box for the explanation about this one student, and she knew, or feared, that this was going to reflect badly on her and the institution she was managing. When a measure becomes a target....

Obviously the above is speculation, but in my experience with senior management its not that the individuals are stupid, its that the system contains a bunch of perverse incentives, and trying to fix them simply creates a new crop. Expecting an individual caught in the middle of this to solve the wider problem is just victim-blaming (albeit a rather better paid class of victim than usual).

Bear in mind that while you saw your Principle as being the top of the local hierarchy, she probably saw herself as being lower-middle, with a lot of people back at Central Office being senior to her, and a big chunk of her job was to insulate you from all of the stuff above as best she could.

Sorry if this sounds like a lecture, but the pathologies of large organisations is one of my interests, and I really hate it when people blame an organisational pathology on someone who is just the messenger; not only is it unfair, it masks the real problem.

391:

It isn't hard to do a much more realistic analysis - the exponential growth obviously slows as the proportion of people who have had it becomes significant. However, given that it is almost certainly throughout the USA already, it is likely to be dominant before that.

392:

whitroth @ 377:

Some of us are laughing hysterically, since the governor of California has announced he's asked his staff to draft a bill for individuals to sue for $10k manufacturers of firearms, ghost guns, etc.

I've been waiting for that shoe to drop ever since I read about SB.8 (the Texas abortion law in question).

The SCOTUS is going to be looking at that in horror.

They've been warned. The Firearms Policy Coalition submitted an amicus brief predicting exactly this in an Amicus brief. Not that it would take a legal genius to make such a prediction; I'm sure that every member of SCOTUS banged their heads on their desks when they first looked at SB.8, because its so obviously a hack of the Constitution as a whole rather than just about abortion in particular. Any state legislature can now pwn any part of the constitution or federal law it doesn't like using the same mechanism.

The "conservative" wing of SCOTUS isn't just anti-abortion; its biggest ideological position is "originalism" or "textualism" (there are subtle differences). Their main reason for disliking Roe v Wade is not because it allowed abortion, but because it was judges who invented the law. (I'll note in passing that the 9th Amendment is an open invitation to judges to do exactly this).

But now this puts them in a bind. SB.8 has clearly cracked the constitution wide open, but there is no existing constitutional mechanism for blocking it. So either they invent one out of whole cloth (oh the humanity!) or they let it happen.

Right now I think they are trying to find some existing mechanism which will block SB.8. But its clearly going ot be a kluge at best.

393:

The British treatment of Jewish refugees 1933-45 was obscene, but after that is another matter.

Balfour was an ignorant idiot, and the mandate was damn-near impossible to manage, but Britain honestly did try. Remember that it was supposed to allow a Jewish home without harming the existing Palestinian residents. That was objectionable to both the Jewish and Palestinian terrorists, which is why Northern Ireland is the closest comparison.

394:

And knowing what I know now, I still think it was a reasonable precaution even though it inconvenienced me personally.

Smallpox vaccinations for the military was and is a good idea. It's known that the Soviets weaponized it, and the smallpox genome has been exhaustively sequenced and is relatively -- some years ago New Scientist staff ordered synthetic RNA that could (with a few additional steps) be used to reconstitute a live smallpox strain, so it's probably one of the easier biological weapons to create and work with.

Not that any biological weapons are sane or sensible ...

395:

So does this make the UK's present R number likely to be an overestimate?

396:

Random "life recapitulates Charlie's fiction" digression

Remember how COVID19 killed the third book in the Halting State trilogy?

(Plot: a flu-like pandemic leads to a long-term post-viral syndrome typified by Cotard's Delusion (and whacky Shkreli-esque treatment grifters converge). Cotard's Delusion is the psychotic state in which the patient thinks they're dead and either in hell or trapped in a rotting lifeless carcass: in effect, it gave rise to a real life zombie pandemic -- of people convinced they're the walking dead.)

Well, guess what just popped up on my radar via Pubmed?

Post-COVID-19 psychosis: Cotard's syndrome and potentially high risk of harm and self-harm in a first-onset acute and transient psychotic disorder after resolution of COVID-19 pneumonia

No, really, I do not want to live in one of my own novels, please go away now.

397:

if memory serves, it was the British who first came up with the idea for Jews to have their own state located in Palestine

That was evangelical Christians wanting to use Jews as a useful local proxy to keep the Ottomans out. Didn't play well with the Jews in question, most of whom ignored it -- prior to Theodore Herzl's ideological construction of nationalist Zionism in the late 1890s, the only Jews talking about going to live in the holy land were a handful of religious scholars who mostly never got around to it (it was essentially a religious debate centred on messianism, which means something utterly different in Judaism from the Christian meaning of "messiah" you are probably more familiar with).

I think it's often easily overlooked, but Zionism emerged at the same time, and in the same place as a bunch of other European ethnonationalisms, namely sprouting from the rotting body of the Austro-Hungarian Empire (components of which today are: Austria, Czechia, Slovakia, Hungary, Croatia, Bosnia, Serbia, plus bits of Italy, Romania, Bulgaria, Poland, Germany ...).

398:

Paul
Yes, the shoe has dropped, but, but ... Will SCOTUS as presently riggedconstituted actually, you know, follow the law, or will they fall into the "Dred Scott" trap & rule according to bigotry & religion?
Or will they try to "kludge" it, as you also suggest. Whatever they do - unless it's uphold Roe v Wade - I think they are in the shit - as seen from here, but you are closer to this & more knowledgeable.
Um.

Charlie @ 396
The remedy is obvious. Start writing modern, "Stross" takes on Simak.

Um. "Markdown" not working for "strikethrough" - had to revert to HTML

399:

...a flu-like pandemic leads to a long-term post-viral syndrome typified by Cotard's Delusion...

No thank you; the excerpt was fun to read but I don't want to live in that story either. * tired sigh *

Is anyone doing really fun utopian fiction? How about Culture fanfic? I could stand emigrating to the Culture. Let's copy something like that.

400:

I predict SCOTUS will have no hesitation finding that gun laws are different from women's rights.

I agree.

But I note that if they do so, it'd provide ammo for a -- hypothetical at this point -- Democratic backlash to appoint another six bodies to the Supreme Court.

(I do not believe Biden is the POTUS to lead such a fight-back: he's old, he came of age back when bipartisan politics was still a real thing, back before the Gingrich insurgency wrecked the previous consensus on playing by a common rule book. I have no idea whether Harris has the ideological inclination to fight back: I doubt she'll get the opportunity.)

401:

I'm not sure what the plan is if there's a dramatic increase in the number of "safe haven" babies. That's going to require a lot more tax money.

There's an obvious modest solution: these babies are footloose parasites! So obviously the Texas legislature needs to make it a felony to extort benefits from the state merely by virtue of being a helpless baby. Life sentence, of course! Then we can send them to baby jail and raise them as slaves unless they're lucky enough to be purchased for adoption by members of approved Quiverful churches who need live-in domestics.

(I wish I thought this was implausible. As it is, pencil it in for the 2024 Texan legislative program.)

402:

A modern State that .... Fascism.

Yes, and they'll install Priti Patel in 10 Downing Street specifically as a pre-emptive counter to accusations of racism. (Because, as Josef Goebbels reportedly/anecdotally told Fritz Lang, "you see, Fritz, we decide who's Jewish or Aryan".)

NB: this is what the New Management books are all about.

403:

Greg, see her comment 361.

Here's a hint: people who live in fascist surveillance states (or who believe they do) cannot speak openly because to do so is to invite retribution. So they tend to use allegory, metaphor, indirect speech, and stuff that snitches working for the state -- who tend to be authoritarian followers, who in turn tend to be literal-minded -- will have difficulty understanding.

And I hate to break it to you, but you have more than a little of that particular mind-set. (Not saying you're a fascist: but fascists notoriously dislike ambiguity and word-play ...)

404:

I'm sure that every member of SCOTUS banged their heads on their desks when they first looked at SB.8, because its so obviously a hack of the Constitution as a whole rather than just about abortion in particular. Any state legislature can now pwn any part of the constitution or federal law it doesn't like using the same mechanism.

You missed the point. Anti-abortion is a component of a reactionary crackdown on women's rights (and also LGBT rights and anything that the evangelical religious right dislike), but the real goal of the religious right is opposition to desegregation (and, ultimately, to the emancipation of any non-white anglo-saxon protestants).

For about 40 years successive Republican presidents and senates have been pushing the SC further towards originalism because the original constitution was compatible by design with slavery. Gutting one amendment opens the door to gutting others, including the First Amendment, which is not just freedom of speech but also disestablishment of religion. They can legislate piecemeal to let approved white patriarchs keep their guns (along with their well-disciplined women and children), but ditching all the amendments is a treasure beyond price if you want to turn the USA into a Christian Dominionist theocracy.

405:

My long-stalled space opera Ghost Engine is an attempt to emulate the "mouth feel" of the Culture universe without being anything remotely close to a copy or fanfic.

I got about 16 months into writing it, far enough to discover how insanely hard a target it was, when my father went into his terminal illness in early 2017 and after that Stuff Got In The Way: I hope to pick it up again and get back to work in 2022.

406:

And, since you pointed it out & as I've noted above ( 11 vacuum-filled rants ) Didn't we have a rule, somewhere, about how many of these were actually allowed at a go? - Something like THREE ??

I counted 12. Most have been deleted now, so I suspect there is either a posting limit being applied or their content was even more provocative than usual.

This behaviour does make referring to comments by comment number an exercise in guessing, though. I'm replying to your comment which I see as #396, but you are writing about Charlie's comment #396 so it appears you have a time machine, and we have to guess which comment you are referring to. This is one reason I reply to one comment at a time, even if it means several short comments.

407:

I'm replying to your comment which I see as #396

Comment #379, and I clearly need more tea before continuing. :-(

408:

Twelve Seagull posts in four hours

Which is nine more than are allowed (and twelve more than are necessary). Mods: act as you deem needful. Or not. Not my blog, after all.

409:

No. It means that almost everybody is misunderstanding or misusing it.

410:

Greg Tingey @ 389: as seen from here, but you are closer to this & more knowledgeable.

I'm actually in the UK. I follow this part of American politics, partly because the collapse of the US would be an event of world historical importance even greater than the collapse of the USSR, and partly because its fascinating in the same kind of way as a slow motion train crash.

Charlie @ 395: You missed the point. Anti-abortion is a component of a reactionary crackdown on [lots of things]. ... if you want to turn the USA into a Christian Dominionist theocracy.

I can certainly see that Republican culture-warriors think that way, including the Dominionists, but I don't read SCOTUS (with the exception of Amy Barrett) as thinking like that. Maybe that's wishful thinking on my part, but it looks to me like they actually believe in textualism/originalism, and just can't see the extent to which they are imposing their own religious and political beliefs on their supposedly disinterested legalistic thinking. These are people who have devoted their lives to the concept of the rule of law. I just can't think that tearing up the Constitution is on their agenda.

But I agree, when the proposed California law lands in front of them they are going to have to either fish or cut bait. That's when we'll see what they really believe.

@394: fascists notoriously dislike ambiguity and word-play

I think they see it as a weapon to be wielded by themselves when out of power and banned when they are in power.

411:

Charlie @ 394
I DID NOT NEED the shitgull to tell me that (via Patel ) we are headed rapidly into fascism.
Though, because of the way tory party leader-selection is set up, so it won't be her, but some other stalking-horse, whom I cannot predict. - { SEE BELOW } I find both the current bills on "policing" & "elections" extremely disturbing - my late father's predictions & anger in the 1950's are coming home to roost, because that generation is dead, & not enough of us listened to their warnings. As for ambiguity & word-play, we all do it, yet even you groaned at her, earlier on, so .. Pot:Kettle ( Which itself is wordplay, yes? )
@395 ... Except who will be first back into bondage in the US? Women or "minorities" - I would guess the latter, THEN removal of the vote from women.
But, your last para is on the money - what's our equivalent - won't be "chrisitan" though - I suspect the internal contradictions might wreck it.

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
For those uncertain here's how it works - copied from "The Institiute for Government"
... The election takes place in two stages. In the first stage (shortlisting), Conservative MPs put their own names forward. MPs then vote in a series of rounds to whittle down the candidates. In the first two rounds, the candidates who don’t meet a certain threshold of votes are eliminated. For all subsequent ballots, the candidate who comes last is eliminated, until there are only two candidates remaining.

In stage two, the party membership is balloted on which of the two final candidates they prefer.

The timescale for each contest is set out by the 1922 Committee.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
That first stage will eliminate Patel - enough tories know that she is poison to the electorate, so who is a likely pair to be selected from the present bunch of tossers?

412:

On the other hand, maybe she had to fill in a monthly report with a box for the number but no box for the explanation about this one student, and she knew, or feared, that this was going to reflect badly on her and the institution she was managing.

Undoubtedly. Principals are judged by how much they improve OSSLT results from previous years, so one whose school has a pass rate of 99% (up from 98%) is asked "why only 1% improvement" while one whose school went from 5% to 15% is commended.

Sorry if this sounds like a lecture, but the pathologies of large organisations is one of my interests, and I really hate it when people blame an organisational pathology on someone who is just the messenger; not only is it unfair, it masks the real problem.

I've had principals who were actually good at their job, as opposed to getting promoted. Ranting at your staff about a result no one on staff can change isn't being a messenger — a good manager would explain to the staff why the board would be unhappy with these results, and pound heads at the board not to judge an entire school by the test results of one recent immigrant who had only attended for a couple of days before the test. It the board was getting it's knickers in a knot about that one number, she should have explained it to them. My good principal would have (and frequently did). But she didn't earn the nickname (among staff) of "Teflon Karen" for nothing.

My point wasn't that she was a bad manager (although she was), but that she seemed unable to understand that one student failing in a category of two students meant that the category had a failure rate of 50% — there was no way to have anything other than 0%, 50%, or 100%. She accepted that the kid had no chance of passing*, but still thought the failure rate of 50% was too high and wanted it lowered — something like 10% would be acceptable. Total inability to understand what the numbers actually meant.

*Now they'd have been given a deferral, but that wasn't an option then.

413:

No, really, I do not want to live in one of my own novels, please go away now.

Given your record, maybe you should stick to fiction set in a happy, cheerful world from now on?

You will either get your wish of not living in one of your novels, or we all get a happy, cheerful world :-)

414:

That first stage will eliminate Patel - enough tories know that she is poison to the electorate, so who is a likely pair to be selected from the present bunch of tossers?

The electorate don't matter -- as witness the bill to mandate voter ID which is transparently copied from the Republican playbook aimed at suppressing poor/minority/young voters (who don't vote for the authoritarian right). Also note the attempt under Cameron at reducing the number of Westminster seats, which plays to the Tories (a disproportionate number of Labour/LibDem/Scottish seats were to be merged with safe Tory seats or outright abolished).

What they really want is a leader who appeals to the Conservative Party membership, then a couple of years of press barrages to soften up the electorate. I reckon Desi Himmler could plausibly go the distance because the membership can tell themselves "but I can't be a racist, I voted for her" and she appeals to all their worst instincts. Also, like Cameron, she came out of the Public Relations Department (in her case, tobacco marketing -- blech).

Unlike Cameron, she has impeccable credentials on the euroskeptic/brexit wing of the party, and today's Tories are the product of a determined entryist campaign by UKIPers: being a toxic xenophobe is more important to the parliamentary back benches than just about anything else.

Also? Don't underestimate the competence of any BAME woman who started out with a comprehensive school background and climbed to the top of the racist, sexist Tory party. Frankly, I find the prospect of a government led by Desi Himmler terrifying, and so should you.

415:

Would it help if I said I'm currently pastiching Regency romance?

Think Bridgerton, only in Laundry style:

The Doctor picked up a large pair of calipers. "I shall take some measurements," He announced, then began muttering under his breath. "It's all in the skull you know, according to Herr Gall, the leading professor of cranioscopy. We practice only the most modern of the sciences here, my lady! I specialize in Galvanism and the hysterical paroxysm, while my colleague Doctor Baker is an expert in the homeopathic arts, leeching, and cupping. We will get to the bottom of what ails you, to be sure!"

It's set in 1816. And lest you imagine historical adventures in the dream roads are fun, toilet paper wouldn't be patented for another 40 years, and it would be another decade before the first brand arrived with the selling point, it's splinter-free.

416:

My personal view of SoTMNs' postings:

Sokath, his eyes closed

417:

400 - OK, cheers.

402 - What's this "we" stuff Englisher? ;-)

403 - Personal account. I did a 1 year lower course to fill time and for extra credit in year 12 (of 13 if you did them all). Our "mock final" had results of I scored 92%, the next best student scored 64%, and the other 5 all failed, with a fail mark of under 30%. However, 6 out of 7 scored over 50% in the final and the other guy I already mentioned also scored over 70%. (there was no way to distinguish 71% from 100% on the grading system used.)

418:

Charlie Really, you should know better ..
OF COURSE I find Patel really, deeply scary, it's just that I don't think she'll make it. OTOH the boss refuses to accept my judgement of Patel as a fascist "Because you can't stand a woman in power" ( Yes, really! )
People are complicated.

Phinch @ 416
I had to look that up & am still not much wiser.
( Anti-revelation? Full of obscurity? Meaningless? )

419:

but the real goal of the religious right is opposition to desegregation (and, ultimately, to the emancipation of any non-white anglo-saxon protestants).

You do understand the current make up of SCOTUS is: 6 Catholics 2 Jewish 1 Anglican/Catholic

Which is NOT the historical makeup.

420:

Err.... markdown.

You do understand the current make up of SCOTUS is:

6 Catholics

2 Jewish

1 Anglican/Catholic

421:

It was my way of commenting on SoTMNs' commenting style and OGHs' comment regarding use of metaphor to impart information. The line itself is a misquote from a well regarded ST:TNG episode called Darmok which is all about communication with a species that uses metaphor and allegory to communicate.

I believe, but I'm willing to accept I could be wrong, that you do not have a lot of the cultural background/context to decypher their posts not that you're incapable of understanding the use of metaphor in communication.

My view is that communication doesn't just require a common language but also context and cultural understanding. I break down SoTMN's posts into: Yes, I understand this bit No, I don't understand it but I know where to find the right "dictionary" to comprehend it. Totally clueless.

Overall, life it too short to try to complete a cryptic crossword where I don't have all the cultural references.

422:

I sincerely hope that it is satirising that unspeakably ghastly sub-genre to hell and back again. It's taken over Book View Cafe, so I haven't bought anything from them in ages.

423:

Which makes be pause when answering that doctor/nurse question "on a scale from 1 to 10 how bad does it hurt"?

I broke my hand at judo the year before last; knew I'd done it, immobilised it immediately with a cold pack, and it didn't really hurt. At the A&E ward (Accident & Emergency - UK equivalent of "ER", which across here tends to stand for "Elizabeth Regina") I got that question...

...and was able to answer "on a scale of 1 to 'Passing a kidney stone', it's a 2". Which seemed to surprise them, but it honestly didn't hurt that much.

424:

It's the gratuitous obfuscation that annoys me - there USED to be some reason for that for some of the things said, but I gave up when I found that almost none could not have been said openly and safely and the obscurity level ramped up. Several posters here say things in circuitous ways, because the content could harm them or someone else (e.g. by identifying a source) - that's reasonable.

There are some things I don't post because they are just too damn dnagerous, both for me and OGH - yes, the UK has made it illegal to express dissent with certain government policies, no matter how moderately and how much based on evidence.

Yes, I fairly often include references that I don't expect people to get, but I ensure that I either give a clue or ensure the posting can be understood without them - in my view, that is a distinguishing mark of literature worth reading. Works that are comprehensible only to a small in-group, but are published for a wider one, deserve to fail (but regrettably often don't).

425:

Yes, I asked for clarication of what 3 was, and said "is it like cutting your finger"? I was told that it was much less, which is bizarre, because even cutting a finger is just curse and carry on pain.

426:

Greg @ 389

Whatever they do - unless it's uphold Roe v Wade - I think they are in the shit - as seen from here, but you are closer to this & more knowledgeable.

My feeling from a distance is that at this point it doesn't matter what they do.

At this point most of the population of the US has finally become aware that the justices have been appointed for political reasons and not for their ability to uphold the Constitution.

This means no matter how they rule, a significant part of the population will view the Court's decision(s) as illegitimate.

Trump's 3 Justices, plus others, were placed on the court to overturn Roe v Wade - so a failure to do so will enrage the right and likely result in they as well as the Democrats calling for an expansion of the court (now that the Democrats conveniently put the idea into play).

But unlike the Democrats the Republicans are likely to have the votes in the Senate to achieve it in the next 6 years.

Charlie @ 391 (I do not believe Biden is the POTUS to lead such a fight-back: he's old, he came of age back when bipartisan politics was still a real thing,

While I agree with you regarding Biden, it is a moot point - the Democrats don't have the votes in the Senate to achieve anything as radical as an expansion of the Supreme Court.

427:

Am I right in thinking the Guard know what their members' civilian specialties are and allocate them to roles accordingly?

In the UK, this doesn't happen (or at least, we reservists kept saying it would be a helpful thing, but the regulars kept giving it a stiff ignoring).

Our problem was that since the loss of Crown Immunity in the early 1990s, the British Army has a fixation with course qualifications. Any responsible task needs you to be a Suitably Qualified and Experienced Person (SQEP); which sounds great, but falls at the first hurdle when a regular looks at a civilian qualification which they don't understand, and can't map directly to an Army equivalent... "but it's not on the list!"

It's not such a problem with analogous tasks like "coach firers on a rifle range" or "be a practising doctor / vet"; but is rather more of a problem when it's "design software" or "operate heavy machinery". It gets fun when the Army only just manages to pack two days' training into a working week, by insisting that military drivers need a full week's course to convert a civilian license into "allowed to drive a Landrover".

It gets even more fun if they accept the qualification, but then get squirrelly because troublesome civilians haven't got a universal mechanism for recording and demonstrating that you've stayed current in your (Landrover-driving / software design) skills since you qualified...

Their thinking is that it's great when Captain Cynic actually is a subject-matter expert in software specifications - but a bit of a risk-management nightmare if Major Stross is recorded as a pharmacist ;) i.e. was qualified twenty-five years ago, to twenty-year-old standards and procedures, and is well out of practice...

428:

It's the gratuitous obfuscation that annoys me - there USED to be some reason for that for some of the things said, but I gave up when I found that almost none could not have been said openly and safely and the obscurity level ramped up.

I know multiple very high IQ people in real life who do this. And others very high IQ people who do not. I came to the conclusion that this was being done to PROVE their superiority. If you didn't get the point, and quickly, then you were just not as smart as they are. In their opinion.

Those that don't do this tend to be very nice people to be around and don't make it obvious that they ARE high IQ people.

429:

My outsider understanding of the senatorial election cycle in the US is that the next election or two have the Republicans a bit more vulnerable than the Democrats - more current Rs up for re-election. As opposed to the last election cycle, where the opportunities for D advancement were limited as most R incumbents weren't in an election. That may also help explain their current blitz on voter suppression laws.

At some point I sincerely hope the gerontocratic stanglehold on American politics will come to an end, ideally without being replaced by a young, charismatic fascist. How much longer can the turtle live?

Living in Canada it is almost impossible not to be affected by the culture war spillover, like swimming in a pool next to a splashy sewage tank. I would love a few years of boring politics, but I just don't see it happening.

430:

Phrinch - & Charlie
I use quite a bit of metaphor myslef ... but the shitgull's ramblings are several layers deep, with zero guarantee of anything actually THERE when you reach bottom.
I second EC's remarks @ 415
It's utterly pointless wanking to show how "clever" she/it/he is.

431:

In what way are "wealth taxes" forbidden by the US Constitution? There's been a good bit of talk in the last year about instituting them.

432:

Ok, I probably shouldn't do this - it's Charlie's blog, after all - but try my novel, 11,000 Years. I really am pushing "yes, we can make the future better than the past". It's not all happy - that wouldn't be worth publishing - but.... And I've got more novels coming. I understand that, for some idiotic reason, the subgenre is being referred to as "hopepunk".

433:

The absence of a smallpox scar is a good way to identify chickenhawks.

434:

For one - Greg, the posts from last night by SotMN were amazingly comprehensible, to the point I actually looked at them, rather than just skipping.

For another, Charlie, I understand that... but for analogy and metaphor to work, the writer and the reader must share a background that allows it to be understood. Otherwise, it's like having a one-time pad based on a book, and you don't know which book in the library of 1000 books.

For example, I grew up hearing of the Good Samaritan... but never had a clue, like 99% of Americans, of what its author was saying, until I read a column of Isaacs (back in the seventies, I think), where he explained the guy who'd been mugged was still wearing REALLY EXPENSIVE silk underwear, and the "good Samaritan" was an older Black man pushing his belongings in a shopping cart. (Samaritans were very much not viewed as "good people", more like the way rabid suburbanites view inner-city Blacks.)

If SotMN were to refer to Samaritans, what I read would depend on whether it was before or after I read Isaac's column.

436:

My outsider understanding of the senatorial election cycle in the US is that the next election or two have the Republicans a bit more vulnerable than the Democrats

Like you an outsider, but the expectation is that it is the Democrats that are vulnerable next year - in part because historically the party who holds the White House tends to lose in the mid-term elections.

But it is also a question not of who hold the current Senate seat, but how safe/vulnerable that seat is - and while I would be happy to be proven otherwise it appears far too many of the Republican Senate seats are safe. CNN for example is showing 10 potential flip seats, and only 6 are Republican with 4 Democrats at risk.

A complicating factor for the Democrats is the current disconnect in the electorate - while not fair Biden is being blamed for the current high inflation. While it should go away by election time, it is distorting voter views on the economy which they think is worse than it is.

more current Rs up for re-election. As opposed to the last election cycle, where the opportunities for D advancement were limited as most R incumbents weren't in an election.

At one point in the 2020 election cycle the Democrats were talking of picking up Senate seats, potentially giving them 52 to 55 of the 100 - that didn't happen.

Unfortunately the election results seemed to indicate the undecided were tired of Trump but not the Republican Party.

437:

For those of us who don't think we are living in a Charles Stross novel, and for those of us who would rather be living in a Charles Stross novel than the real world:

Elon Musk is Time's 2021 Person of the Year.

My immediate reaction: "They picked Nyarlathotep."

438:

I tend to be in the "don't bother" caucus with regards to SoTMN. If I want to be insulted by someone who has a problematic relationship with cited references and similar conventional realities....well, I engage in San Diego politics, and that stance is de rigueur among those involved in some forms of development and also in non-agenda testimony (one hour's worth per Board of Supervisors' meeting, although that hopefully will change one day). There's little point in doing it for fun, at least for me.

If there were the possibility of a genuine conversation, well, that would actually be quite refreshing.

As for the Samaritans, they're actually still around, and it's worth reading up on their modern relationship with modern Judaism some time. I don't pretend to be familiar with it, except that it seems to be as complicated as any other long-term factional relationship in that part of the world is.

439:

Time magazine is addicted to capitalism, the way Pravda was addicted to communism back in the 1970s. The ideology is so pervasive it's invisible to the folks working there.

As for Musk ...

Read my lips: Elon Musk is, by all accounts, a flaming asshole. Also, one on one, personally charming. He's a blinkered idiot when it comes to societal issues and the environment and biological systems. His politics is pretty dodgy, too, as far as I can tell. (I have low expectations for a South African apartheid-era emerald mine heir: given his lack of a filter on twitter, I'm half-surprised he hasn't come out with flagrantly racist bullshit, so he's exceeding my low bar in that respect.) He's also a visionary when it comes to building manufacturing systems for transportation engineering -- be they electric car factories or spaceship factories. (And no question, the factories are the key to his success: rapid prototyping and iterative development have clearly reaped huge rewards both at Tesla and at SpaceX.)

Anyway, there is no paradox here. I grew up reading the same visionary SF: the difference between us starts with the fact that Musk has leverage, a monomaniacal determination to die on Mars, and a near-mystical talent for talking investors into bankrolling crazy/brilliant/stupid boondoggles, enough of which payed off to make him look like a magician. He also had a few extra-good insights along the way: that the way to sell electric cars was to make them sexy instead of glorified eat-your-greens golf buggies, or the need to go for vertical integration in the manufacturing process of spaceships, reducing supply chain dependencies, to optimize for reliability and production cost rather than efficiency, and to go all-out for reusability even when there was no market pressure.

Finally, I'd just like to note that both Henry Ford and Walt Disney were sexist, racist, assholes (Ford was clearly a white supremacist); Bill Gates got divorced over the contents of Jeffrey Epstein's little black book, which is kind of creepy in its own right: Steve Jobs was a notorious asshole in person (and an egomaniac), nobody had a kind word to say about Thomas Edison or Andrew Carnegie or J. P. Morgan. It's almost like there's a pattern here?

Successful industrialists are almost always lousy human beings. All we can judge them by is their accomplishments (and hope that those outweigh their drawbacks as people, so that their legacy is overall positive).

440:

And if Nyarlathotep had had a significant impact on the world he'd be in the running. Person of the Year isn't supposed to be an honour, as Time points out on a regular basis. Hitler, Stalin (twice), Ayatollah Khomeni and Donald Trump have all been there.

List

441:

This behaviour does make referring to comments by comment number an exercise in guessing, though.

There have been a number of occasions over the years when something like this has happened. I have found myself coming back to the conversation to find entire sub-threads disappeared with no notice. The experience is rather, er, Glasshousian.

I would put in a request to the moderators to leave little notices behind in deleted posts, so that readers can keep track more easily. I realize it's more work to do that, though.

442:

"The title is given to a person or group of people who 'most influenced the news and the world — for better or for worse' over the past year."
It also satisfactorily explains a recent cryptic tweet by Mr. Musk:

thinking of quitting my jobs & becoming an influencer full-time wdyt

— Elon Musk (@elonmusk) December 10, 2021

(I sorta track that account, for reasons other than cryptocurrency "tips". :-)

443:

Successful industrialists are almost always lousy human beings. All we can judge them by is their accomplishments (and hope that those outweigh their drawbacks as people, so that their legacy is overall positive).

No Bezos this year? Oh well.

Speaking of humanity...

I'd note that, given the situation our species is in now, giving monomaniacs power to assert their vision despite the rest of us has resulted in temporary benefits more than permanent ones. Given that our species has been around for tens if not hundreds of thousands of years, probably our 300 year-long experiment with fucking around and finding out was not as wise (or even as smart) as it seemed at the time.

Perhaps it's possible that those who practiced age old traditions and thought we imperialist colonizers were freaking insane knew something really obvious that we were carefully blinding ourselves to?

444:

Oh yes. But Time doesn't do that anymore; witness the obvious choice for 2001 (bin Laden) not being picked because his face wouldn't sell magazines.

445:

Mike Collins @ 357: President Eisenhower was reported to have been shocked when he discovered that half of all Americans had below average IQs.

Especially after he figured out he'd chosen one of them to be his Vice President.

446:

" his Vice Presiden"

Nixon was somewhat crazy and evil, but he wasn't stupid.

447:

Crouchback @ 360: In theory, Texas & a lot of other states have safe haven laws which means a woman can turn over a newborn baby to the state, no questions asked. Justice Barrett has referred to such laws in her arguments against legal abortion. In practice I'm not sure what the plan is if there's a dramatic increase in the number of "safe haven" babies. That's going to require a lot more tax money.

I believe if the state is going to deny the right to abortion they should be liable for ALL of the costs associated with the unwanted pregnancy and completely provide for all of the child's needs until at least his/her 18th birthday ... unless the child is born with some birth defect that requires institutionalization when support is for LIFE.

448:

"Perhaps it's possible that those who practiced age old traditions and thought we imperialist colonizers were freaking insane knew something really obvious that we were carefully blinding ourselves to? "

Edmund Burke would have tended to agree, I think.

449:

It could have been worse; in Jimmy Carter we had a POTUS that was below average IQ. ;-)

450:

Greg Tingey @ 379: 356, 359, 361, 362, 364, 366, 371, 372, 373, 374, 375,

And, since you pointed it out & as I've noted above ( 11 vacuum-filled rants )
Didn't we have a rule, somewhere, about how many of these were actually allowed at a go? - Something like THREE ??

I remember at some point reading that it was maximum of 5 at a single go. And looking at the post numbers that seems to be the case here; batch of 4 & response from someone; batch of 2 & response; batch of 5 & responses.

Not my blog, so it's not up to me to determine if she's following the guidelines or not. I usually don't read more than the first couple of lines. If it's nonsense by the end of the first paragraph, it's probably going to be nonsense all the way down, so I just move on to the next comprehensible comment.

451:

Perhaps it's possible that those who practiced age old traditions and thought we imperialist colonizers were freaking insane knew something really obvious that we were carefully blinding ourselves to?,/i>

Not so much carefully blinding as resolutely shutting our eyes, plugging our ears, and yelling "lalalalalalallla can't hear you".

452:

"Perhaps it's possible that those who practiced age old traditions and thought we imperialist colonizers were freaking insane knew something really obvious that we were carefully blinding ourselves to? " Edmund Burke would have tended to agree, I think.

Whether or not you believe Graeber and Wengrow's thesis in The Dawn of Everything, they appear to be onto something in their first chapter, wherein they posit that Rousseau's notion of the "noble savage" was due in large part to the conversations among the European literati spurred by encountering the Indians of North America. They'd finally run into a culture that hadn't been in dialogue with them for centuries, and the critique of their colonial efforts and social mores was a shock to the system. Burke was alive at that time, so I wouldn't be surprised if he was caught up in that whole question of what a proper society looked like.

BTW, they parse "noble savage" as not ethically noble," but as living the way nobles did, on rural, largely wooded estates, and hunting. Assuming that's a correct interpretation, I think that's another point: the very wealthy and society's drop-outs often choose to live more as hunter gatherers, rather than as middle or lower class working stiffs. That may be telling us something.

453:

No I didn't :) I think it's probably Nojay you're confusing me with.

I was pointing out that the people flying off the handle at La Polynomielle were being daft because what she was actually saying was not far off being the total opposite of what she was being shouted at for. She wasn't "spreading anti-vaccine propaganda"; she was pointing out some of the misconceptions which facilitate its being spread, and calling down some of the slimy arseholes who are happy with the spreading of disinformation and dodgy "facts" about the disease in general because they can make money out of that.

It gets interestingly "meta" (as they say) to consider how that set of exchanges typifies a widespread problem with comprehension in general: people are far too fond of jumping to premature conclusions and then hanging grimly on to them come hell or high water. People encountering a complex set of circumstances (in a very general sense of which "a piece of writing" is merely a subcategory) attach far too great an importance to the first little bits they come across in the fringes of it, and far too little to all the other bits they get to later; they construct an initial model which is consistent with what they know so far (at so early a stage that "consistency" is no more than correlation on one single isolated point), and then doggedly refuse to amend that model in the light of what they discover later no matter how gross and glaring the inconsistencies become, preferring simply to discard any later discoveries and forget they ever happened because they don't match that incorrect preliminary model.

In the case of a piece of writing, to which people reply also in writing, this tendency very often and very clearly takes the form of people latching on to one or two particular keywords which they noticed straight away, and then mentally rewriting the rest of the piece on the fly in the mould of some antipathetic context where the same keywords also often occur, which somehow enables them to maintain a quite staggering degree of blindness to what the piece of writing in question actually says: it's not uncommon for people to go so far as to copy and paste quotes from the piece in the belief that the quotes support their interpretation when in fact they quite obviously refute it, yet somehow they are entirely unable to notice this.

This problem is not a function of the lady in question's style, but a function of the readership. I've had it done to me numerous times and using language as precise and definite as possible doesn't make a fuck of difference. I've also had it done to me in physical actuality, times without number for as long as I can remember, and (for instance) failing to display symptoms of heroin withdrawal when abducted and isolated doesn't count as an indication that I was never on the fucking stuff in the first place but indeed was just off work with flu. How clear the evidence is and how unambiguously it's communicated make no difference at all once people have superglued their hand to the wrong end of the stick in the first place.

454:

Paul @ 383: whitroth @ 377:

Some of us are laughing hysterically, since the governor of California has announced he's asked his staff to draft a bill for individuals to sue for $10k manufacturers of firearms, ghost guns, etc.
I've been waiting for that shoe to drop ever since I read about SB.8 (the Texas abortion law in question).
The SCOTUS is going to be looking at that in horror.

They've been warned. The Firearms Policy Coalition submitted an amicus brief predicting exactly this in an Amicus brief. Not that it would take a legal genius to make such a prediction; I'm sure that every member of SCOTUS banged their heads on their desks when they first looked at SB.8, because its so obviously a hack of the Constitution as a whole rather than just about abortion in particular. Any state legislature can now pwn any part of the constitution or federal law it doesn't like using the same mechanism."

The "conservative" wing of SCOTUS isn't just anti-abortion; its biggest ideological position is "originalism" or "textualism" (there are subtle differences). Their main reason for disliking Roe v Wade is not because it allowed abortion, but because it was judges who invented the law. (I'll note in passing that the 9th Amendment is an open invitation to judges to do exactly this).

But now this puts them in a bind. SB.8 has clearly cracked the constitution wide open, but there is no existing constitutional mechanism for blocking it. So either they invent one out of whole cloth (oh the humanity!) or they let it happen.

Right now I think they are trying to find some existing mechanism which will block SB.8. But its clearly going ot be a kluge at best.

Won't even be a bump in the road. The Right-Wingnut majority will have no problem finding the proposed California Law intrudes on a Constitutional Right, while the Texas law does not.

They won't even have to resort to pretzel logic to do it.

455:

"I'm a little surprised your NIHNHS didn't have a similar record."

Theoretically it should have, but in practice patient records have always been a horrible mess, with bits here and bits there and bits getting lost and no real way of either assembling all the scattered bits of information into a single complete record or of making it available to whoever needed it. So every doctor and every hospital who had ever seen me would have part of the story, but they would all be missing much more of it than they had, and the most complete record would be in my head. Computers and networking are supposed to have made it better these days, but the computer systems themselves are kind of a notorious shambles and although it is a bit better it's still a long way from good.

456:
It's the gratuitous obfuscation that annoys me - there USED to be some reason for that for some of the things said, but I gave up when I found that almost none could not have been said openly and safely and the obscurity level ramped up. I know multiple very high IQ people in real life who do this. And others very high IQ people who do not. I came to the conclusion that this was being done to PROVE their superiority. If you didn't get the point, and quickly, then you were just not as smart as they are. In their opinion. Those that don't do this tend to be very nice people to be around and don't make it obvious that they ARE high IQ people.

When I had a job, I explained to my students the following little insider's tip: "If you are paying attention, and cannot understand what is going on in a lecture, then you should conclude that the lecturer doesn't understand the material."

My own goal when presenting research at conferences was to convince my audience that I was a complete idiot because the explanation was so obvious.

My German colleagues remained gloriously unmoved by the idea that a good presentation ought to be intelligible.

457:

Today's Covid update in the Province of Ontario.

They are confirming Omicron is doubling every 3 days, vs 34 days for Delta.

Omicron is now 31% of cases in Ontario, will be dominant by next week.

One expert thinks Omicron is so contagious that he expects everyone, even those triple vaccinated, to become infected.

https://www.thestar.com/news/ontario/2021/12/13/two-shots-may-not-be-enough-heres-what-you-need-to-know-about-booking-a-booster-as-omicron-surges-in-ontario.html

458:

How do you know they didn't? Maybe wait a bit until you have some facts before talking smack just because you don't like their employer.

"Larry Virden's last text to his wife was "Amazon won't let us leave."

https://www.reddit.com/r/antiwork/comments/rfgahs/larry_virdens_last_text_to_his_wife_was_amazon/

Screenshot linked from that article, no surprises anywhere.

Bought media summary of the facts so far: https://truthout.org/articles/warehouse-workers-deaths-prompt-renewed-scrutiny-of-amazons-no-phone-policy/

When you have a company that prides itself on pushing the extremes of sociopathic behaviour and is regularly found to put policy, let alone profit, above human life, it's quite reasonable to assume that they will continue to do that unless there's evidence of a change.

460:

I haven't read through all the comments, so sorry if I'm repeating.

The rote memorization incidentally is part -- a small part, admittedly -- of the reason I eventually bailed on being a pharmacist. My memory is shit, always has been, and I spent way too much time looking things up in books because I couldn't be certain I remembered it.

No, that's doing it right. When lives depend on it, looking it up is the correct thing to do, a lesson that consumed a lot of lives before things like checklists were accepted. A pilot might have 10000 landings under their belt, and have done three that day, and have another pilot watching them to catch mistakes. They still get out the book and look up how to configure the plane for landing.

461:
I use quite a bit of metaphor myslef ... but the shitgull's ramblings are several layers deep, with zero guarantee of anything actually THERE when you reach bottom.

Greg,

Surely the standard, usual, English words for the concept you are describing would be: "Seagull Droppings"...

... if that's not considered too meta.

462:

"And lest you imagine historical adventures in the dream roads are fun, toilet paper wouldn't be patented for another 40 years, and it would be another decade before the first brand arrived with the selling point, it's splinter-free."

Yes, but that was actually OK, because they hadn't invented shitting yet either. People could hide in or be shut in some wardrobe or unused room for months or even years if they were supplied with food and water, yet not ever would their presence be given away by sewage trickling out of the cracks in the door or dripping through the ceiling of the room below, or even people wondering why it always smells like a toilet in that part of the house.

Come to that, it wasn't all that uncommon to successfully keep a rotting corpse concealed in much the same kind of unsealed conditions. You couldn't do that these days. I can only conclude that part of the Wisdom Of The Ancients was a thoroughly perfected method of domestic waste removal, of which the knowledge was entirely lost after it was banned in the interests of people making money out of selling bog paper.

(Oh yeah, "hysterical paroxysm"... may I make so bold as to wonder if something resembling a hand-drill with an eccentric mass in place of the chuck might feature in this tale?)

463:

Charlie Stross @ 385:

And knowing what I know now, I still think it was a reasonable precaution even though it inconvenienced me personally.

Smallpox vaccinations for the military was and is a good idea. It's known that the Soviets weaponized it, and the smallpox genome has been exhaustively sequenced and is relatively -- some years ago New Scientist staff ordered synthetic RNA that could (with a few additional steps) be used to reconstitute a live smallpox strain, so it's probably one of the easier biological weapons to create and work with.

Not that any biological weapons are sane or sensible ...

Yeah. I agree. All I'm saying is the Bush/Cheney administration's claims about Saddam's Weapons of Mass Destruction were BOGUS, all lies. But we had no way of knowing that for sure back then. I suspected it then because I already knew Colon Powell was a lying asshole. Today we KNOW he was lying, and we know HE knew at the time it was a tissue of lies.

Given all that, I still think the smallpox vaccination was a good idea. Hell, I think the Anthrax vaccinations were a sensible precaution at the time, given that even if "we" DID already know it hadn't come from Iraq, we didn't know where it had come from.

464:

Oops. That should have been replying to Charlie Stross @ 394:

465:

Charlie Stross @ 397:

if memory serves, it was the British who first came up with the idea for Jews to have their own state located in Palestine

That was evangelical Christians wanting to use Jews as a useful local proxy to keep the Ottomans out. Didn't play well with the Jews in question, most of whom ignored it -- prior to Theodore Herzl's ideological construction of nationalist Zionism in the late 1890s, the only Jews talking about going to live in the holy land were a handful of religious scholars who mostly never got around to it (it was essentially a religious debate centred on messianism, which means something utterly different in Judaism from the Christian meaning of "messiah" you are probably more familiar with).

I think it's often easily overlooked, but Zionism emerged at the same time, and in the same place as a bunch of other European ethnonationalisms, namely sprouting from the rotting body of the Austro-Hungarian Empire (components of which today are: Austria, Czechia, Slovakia, Hungary, Croatia, Bosnia, Serbia, plus bits of Italy, Romania, Bulgaria, Poland, Germany ...).

I still think it's kind of ironic.

466:

"This behaviour does make referring to comments by comment number an exercise in guessing, though."

It isn't a wonderful method in any case, because unless the comments being referred to are within the last 10 posts or so, it means scrolling back through seas of text trying to find them and then doing the same in the other direction to find the comment with the references again.

To get around this problem I have written a script which looks for the common ways in which people habitually cite comments by number, and turns them into links to the cited comments. Looking for # or @ or * plus an optional space, then a string of digits, and also for a string of digits at the beginning of a paragraph followed by a space, seems to catch nearly all of them; of course it also catches such sequences being used for other reasons, but that is much less common on here, and it's not important anyway since it's obvious from the context that those particular added links are spurious.

That solves the scrolling-and-searching problem, but being purely client-side and not keeping persistent state to track numbering changes, it still gets thrown out of whack when comments are deleted. A server-side implementation as part of the new post parser would solve that aspect too.

467:

Greg Tingey @ 411: @395 ...
Except who will be first back into bondage in the US? Women or "minorities" - I would guess the latter, THEN removal of the vote from women.
But, your last para is on the money - what's our equivalent - won't be "chrisitan" though - I suspect the internal contradictions might wreck it.

Here in the U.S. it's likely to be "women & children first", but it will happen in stages, the way voting rights & abortion rights have already been whittled away by previous GQP administrations.

Not with a bang, but with a whimper. We won't lose all of our rights at once - the Constitution, Bill of Rights & equality before the law (13th, 14th & 15th Amendments) will be nibbled to death by rats.

468:

"it was the British who first came up with the idea for Jews to have their own state located in Palestine"

...which later got a great big boost from British efforts to mess with people's heads during WW1 and persuade Jews in general, and those living in the region and those influential in US government/finance in particular, that it was in their own interests to support the British side and not the Ottomans.

Of course they were also trying to persuade all the other groups in the region of the same thing, and trying to make sure it would end up under British control to help fuel the Navy, and trying to minimise how much of the Ottoman lands the French got because even if they are on the same side they're still French, and generally being massive fucking weasels with everyone. So it's not really much of a surprise that the Mandate was a thoroughgoing fuckup and the most favourable view the inhabitants tended to have of the British ended up being to look northwards and say "well at least they're not the French".

469:

That's why I generally quote part of the text I'm replying to. It means that even if there are several matches people can just find in the page to see the whole context (including replies if people quote the same bits). We've had many episodes of numbers being off, but we still have users who just say "#123: not quite, think more like powers of arrest", a comment that is almost worthless when posted and quickly becomes absolutely so.

470:

""Larry Virden's last text to his wife was "Amazon won't let us leave.""" ... "...renewed-scrutiny-of-amazons-no-phone-policy/"

So how did he send it then?

471:

We won't lose all of our rights at once

Might be useful to sit down and make hard limits for when you consider the place to be a failed state and be ready to execute your fallback plan.

It does seem that the "democracy was a failed experiment" side have become much more blatant recently. And somewhat scary that Australia and the UK are trying the exact same techniques without even filing off the serial numbers.

In 'straya we've just seen voter id law get dumped because even half the far right party couldn't keep a straight face when talking about voter impersonation. We have compulsory voting, and most cases of impersonation are with consent (often of the "technically illegal" form, like my gf filling out the voting paper for her mother, then her mother signing it. In theory her mother had to actually tick some of the boxes as well). But the compulsory thing means that the Australian Electoral Commission have a pretty good handle on how many cases of problematic voter impersonation there can possibly be, as well as on how many there are. Oh, and ~80% of apparent cases are found to be clerical errors, normally a polling clerk ticking off the wrong voter ("Hubert J Smith" instead of "Hubert K Smith" on the line below). Once those are removed it drops from hundred (out of ~10M) to ones or tens of cases.

https://johnquiggin.com/2021/12/07/good-riddance-the-costs-of-morrisons-voter-id-plan-outweighed-any-benefit/

472:

David L @ 428:

It's the gratuitous obfuscation that annoys me - there USED to be some reason for that for some of the things said, but I gave up when I found that almost none could not have been said openly and safely and the obscurity level ramped up.

I know multiple very high IQ people in real life who do this. And others very high IQ people who do not. I came to the conclusion that this was being done to PROVE their superiority. If you didn't get the point, and quickly, then you were just not as smart as they are. In their opinion.

Those that don't do this tend to be very nice people to be around and don't make it obvious that they ARE high IQ people.

Having a high IQ ain't all it's cracked up to be. It confers no benefit whatsoever in 90% or more of life that requires more mundane experience.

Plus, if you never get to use it it just fades away.

473:

There's much discussion of the new "no phone" policy, so I'm assuming that either the policy wasn't in place, or he ignored the policy. But I'm just reading the same articles you did, so I don't know any more than you do.

474:

skulgun @ 433: The absence of a smallpox scar is a good way to identify chickenhawks.

I dunno. Most of the more notorious chickenhawks I know about are old enough to have been vaccinated as children before the WHO/CDC decided smallpox had been eradicated and the vaccination was no longer required before you could enter the first grade.

475:

455 - They do, but there are bits that aren't joined up, for instance I am on one system that allows me to see what my renal unit has prescribed for/used on me, and what my PHP has prescribed. One thing is not exactly like the other and they actually should be.
Also, the renal unit staff have a quite touching faith that if the computer says $thing then that must be correct even if my memory says differently.

466 - I gave up identifying post numbers with a hash sign because Markdown treats those as "special characters". More to the point with addressing your complaint about threading would be if we could make multiple comments without browsing away and back.

476:

"All I'm saying is the Bush/Cheney administration's claims about Saddam's Weapons of Mass Destruction were BOGUS, all lies. But we had no way of knowing that for sure back then. I suspected it then because I already knew Colon Powell was a lying asshole."

I suspected it because they were too silly and stank of made up propaganda bollocks.

I wrote to Blair in opposition to the involvement with Iraq. In reply I got only a copy of that bloody dossier which (apart from not being a relevant reply to anything I'd said in any case) contained next to nothing that actually gave reason to believe there was a problem but an awful lot of wild tabloidesque extrapolation, degenerating in places into "...and he smells!"-level silliness. The thing I most particularly remember from it is the little diagram comparing the area (in square metres) of Saddam's palace with the area of Buck House and citing this as evidence of what a nasty man he was.

477:

Some years ago I wrote an article for a local rag that talked about the hazard inherent in being a country next to an 'ally' with the largest and most powerful military in human history.

It's all well and good when they are at least somewhat democratic and a society of laws. If that goes out the window then anything goes. For the US military to conquer Canada really would be 'a matter of marching' at this point. Holding it would be another question of course.

The Authoritarian decline process goes something like as follows:

  • Country becomes vulnerable to takeover by authoritarians. Some combination of degraded social cohesion and disruption makes it possible for an aspiring tyrant to take over. This can happen in the form of a coup or through a collapse of functioning democracy.

  • At first things go well for those who supported them - and very badly for everyone else. Those close to the top are greatly enriched, the foot soldiers and brownshirts feel powerful. The great project or whatever is begun.

  • Decisions are made based on loyalty and affiliation rather than merit or facts. As this spreads through the system it starts to fail in small and large ways. The people at the center are still benefiting greatly though. Those who are loyal but starting to feel pain are further motivated blame the enemies within and without.

  • Eventually reality asserts itself. The economy is in trouble, things are starting to fail. Time for a short victorious war.

  • War begins, ideally against a weak neighbour on a bogus pretext. (See: Italy into Ethiopia). Maybe they even win, at least for awhile. Everyone rallies to the flag.

  • Inevitably, the cronyist rot will or has infected the military as much as anyone else. Leadership has been chosen based on loyalty or connections, supplies purchased from profiteers with connections.

  • Much suffering ensues.

    478:

    Heteromeles @ 438: I tend to be in the "don't bother" caucus with regards to SoTMN. If I want to be insulted by someone who has a problematic relationship with cited references and similar conventional realities....well, I engage in San Diego politics, and that stance is de rigueur among those involved in some forms of development and also in non-agenda testimony (one hour's worth per Board of Supervisors' meeting, although that hopefully will change one day). There's little point in doing it for fun, at least for me.

    If there were the possibility of a genuine conversation, well, that would actually be quite refreshing.

    As for the Samaritans, they're actually still around, and it's worth reading up on their modern relationship with modern Judaism some time. I don't pretend to be familiar with it, except that it seems to be as complicated as any other long-term factional relationship in that part of the world is.

    The thing to understand is that the Jews despised the Samaritans (and vice versa). They shared a common religion, both claiming descent from the Israelites of the Exodus, but each accused the other of doing it wrong (see Protestants vs. Catholics).

    When the man on the road (presumably a Jew) was robbed & left for dead the Priest and the Levite (fellow Jews) would not render aid to a fellow human - passing by on the far side of the road - but the despised Samaritan did and paid for his care out of his own pocket.

    So the question, "Who is my neighbor?" is asked and answered. All men are your "neighbors", even your most despised enemies.

    479:

    korydg @ 441:

    This behaviour does make referring to comments by comment number an exercise in guessing, though.

    There have been a number of occasions over the years when something like this has happened. I have found myself coming back to the conversation to find entire sub-threads disappeared with no notice. The experience is rather, er, Glasshousian."

    I would put in a request to the moderators to leave little notices behind in deleted posts, so that readers can keep track more easily. I realize it's more work to do that, though.

    That's why I give the identity, comment number & quote of the text I'm responding to. If it gets moved or even disappears entirely, I think you'll still have a chance to decipher what I'm on about. I hope it's not overloading the server with surplus text. I trim the posts of excess material I am NOT responding to, so if it looks like I've taken something out of context, no, I'm just not responding to the bits I've left out.

    480:

    Kardashev @ 446:

    " his Vice Presiden"

    Nixon was somewhat crazy and evil, but he wasn't stupid.

    That's a matter of opinion and sarcasm doesn't always rate the Sarcasm Font.

    481:

    Re:'... built in last 10 years'

    I looked it up - that complex was opened in 2020 (last year).

    https://www.reuters.com/markets/commodities/amazon-driver-died-bathroom-sheltering-tornado-with-colleagues-2021-12-12/

    If you look at some of the photos, there's no central reinforced interior space, i.e., what would typically qualify as a 'safe interior' space to hunker down in during a storm. Bathrooms or closets are usually a home's safe space because proportionally more support per volume of enclosed space including the ceiling. From the photos I've seen of the damaged warehouse/depot there's not a helluva a lot of support for the roof. And I'm guessing there's no/not much of a second/internal wall that would help stabilize the exterior and interior structures. BTW - today I read that there will be an investigation.

    Below is the most detailed info I've found on how that place was run/managed. Also answers why the BigRiver spokesperson couldn't answer a basic question: how many people were working in that warehouse when the tornado struck. (This subcontracting is the domestic version of off-shoring: just plain evading responsibility/liability. But somehow they're pretty quick to grab the glory/profits!)

    https://dnyuz.com/2021/12/12/at-amazon-site-tornado-collided-with-companys-peak-delivery-season/

    About Maryille -

    Pretty vile if confirmed. Hopefully there's an Erin Brockovich ready to take on a couple of cases: what weather/climate safeguards and protections are employees, contractors and customers entitled to from a biz - whether they work there or they have to physically enter there to conduct business. (I'm also considering covered malls, big box retailers, etc.)

    https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/kentucky-tornado-factory-workers-threatened-firing-left-tornado-employ-rcna8581

    482:

    I think smallpox vaccination for the military is a good idea as it reduces the incentive for anyone considering developing a smallpox weapon.

    483:

    The Wikipedia article on the 2019 gas explosions in Massachusetts (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Merrimack\_Valley\_gas\_explosions) mentions this:

    “At the time of the accident, workers were replacing some of the low-pressure piping, but the procedure set out by Columbia Gas for doing this failed to include transfer of a regulator's pressure sensor from the old, disused piping to the new. As a result, when the old pipe was depressurized, the regulator sensed zero pressure on the low-pressure side and opened completely, feeding the main pipeline's full pressure into the local distribution network.”

    But fails to mention that the workers who didn’t notice anything wrong with this procedure were “temporary replacements,” the regulars being out on strike.

    Scabs are fecking dangerous.

    484:

    paws4thot @ 449: It could have been worse; in Jimmy Carter we had a POTUS that was below average IQ. ;-)

    Again, I dunno. I've seen Carter's IQ listed as 156.8 (coming in 6th after J.Q.Adams, Jefferson, Kennedy, Clinton and Wilson), and I think that's enough for MENSA (definitely above the 98th percentile). He wasn't really a successful President, but I don't think that had anything to do with his IQ.

    A different ranking puts Carter 5th with Wilson demoted to 13th place. That same ranking has Trumpolini as 16th (IQ 145), so I don't know how much I believe it, because that ranks him higher than Teddy Roosevelt, Abraham Lincoln, George Washington, Dwight D. Eisenhower and Richard Nixon. I just don't buy that.

    Average IQ in the U.S. appears to be 103 (it was originally intended that 100 should be the average, but it slipped a little). The lowest estimated IQ for any previous President was U.S.Grant at 120.

    We don't really know Trumpolini's IQ because he's afraid to have people find out. Best, most credible estimate I've seen of Donald Trump's IQ puts it around 110, so he's not quite dumber than a box of rocks, but it's clear the turnips that fell off the back of the truck could give him a run for his money.

    Sarcasm aside, it doesn't look we've had a President (including Trumpolini) with below average intelligence.

    485:

    When I had a job, I explained to my students the following little insider's tip: "If you are paying attention, and cannot understand what is going on in a lecture, then you should conclude that the lecturer doesn't understand the material."

    Wow, imagine teaching algebra or calculus this way.

    Now actually I agree with what I suspect is the underlying idea: people who understand the material should be able to rephrase the ideas in a wide variety of ways, while people who only understand it in one jargon are stuck hoping that the listeners understand that jargon the same way they do.

    The problem with this approach is that some things aren't understood the first time by most people. I think we've all had that experience with algebra, and most of us have had that experience with calculus. There's the wonderful day it clicks, after weeks of headbanging, but the headbanging part is essential to getting the idea to click.

    There are a bunch of things that work this way, so sometimes you just have to trust that the teacher knows what they're doing. And yes, that trust can definitely be abused.

    The most egregious thing I saw this with was teaching cladistics in college. I know, from long experience both learning and teaching, that it takes two or three exposures to really get how it works. However, that's not common knowledge. And I saw one freshman biology teacher getting really discouraged by the reviews of how they taught cladistics and the test results, compared with how a senior faculty member teaching juniors and seniors got students to shine. I finally took the both teachers aside (snooty grad student that I was) and explained that I'd TAed for both the freshman and senior classes, and that they were teaching exactly the same thing in almost identical ways. The difference was that the freshman students had never seen it before, while the senior students had seen it several times and finally got it.

    So ultimately, I don't think it's always worth blaming the teacher for the failure of the students to understand. IIRC, there's a Chinese version that says the teacher may have the fire, but if the student doesn't have the right kindling, the flame won't be passed. There's some truth in that. And often, getting the students to catch fire involves drying out the water behind their ears first.

    486:

    Moz @ 471:

    We won't lose all of our rights at once

    Might be useful to sit down and make hard limits for when you consider the place to be a failed state and be ready to execute your fallback plan.

    I swore an oath to protect & defend the Constitution. I'm retired now, but I still consider that oath binding.

    My fallback plan is to protect & defend the Constitution for as long as I have breath in my body to do so. But I don't yet know what actions that's going to require until the threats actually materialize.

    487:

    Moz @ 473: There's much discussion of the new "no phone" policy, so I'm assuming that either the policy wasn't in place, or he ignored the policy. But I'm just reading the same articles you did, so I don't know any more than you do.

    The most recent stories I've read say this is a new Amazon delivery facility where the drivers & contractors pick up their loads. The tornadoes came right at end of shift as the drivers were coming back from their day's runs. The facility was equipped with two internal storm shelters and one of those took a direct hit from a tornado. That's where the people died.

    488:

    SFReader @ 481: About Maryille -

    Pretty vile if confirmed. Hopefully there's an Erin Brockovich ready to take on a couple of cases: what weather/climate safeguards and protections are employees, contractors and customers entitled to from a biz - whether they work there or they have to physically enter there to conduct business. (I'm also considering covered malls, big box retailers, etc.)

    https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/kentucky-tornado-factory-workers-threatened-firing-left-tornado-employ-rcna8581

    I believe it. When Hurricane Fran hit Raleigh back in 1996 I was working second shift in manufacturing for the PC Company subdivision of a large computer manufacturer. We were told we could "leave if we wanted to", but we "might not have a job later" if we did.

    Fran was still a hurricane when the eye reached Raleigh around midnight. We got off work at 12:10 am.

    489:

    Re: Tornadoes & architecture

    Trying to understand what happens to a building in severe weather and found this. Figured it might also be handy info for the folks here without sci/engineering/construction backgrounds.

    Note: This is a very long read.

    https://www.wbdg.org/resources/wind-safety-building-envelope

    'Because of the extremely high pressures and missile loads that tornadoes can induce, constructing tornado-resistant office buildings is extremely expensive. Therefore, when consideration is voluntarily given to tornado design, the emphasis typically is on occupant protection, which is achieved by "hardening" portions of an office building for use as safe havens.'

    Most interesting bit of info on a related link. Note: Haven't checked how many/which jurisdictions are covered.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Building_Code:

    'In the wake of the Federal copyright case Veeck v. Southern Building Code Congress Int'l, Inc.,[13] the organization Public Resource has published a substantial portion of the enacted building codes on-line, and they are available as PDFs.'

    Extreme weather events are here. I think we need to understand what that means wrt to our homes, places of work, etc. and certainly merits at least as much discussion/policy as affordable and environmentally friendly heating/cooling.

    490:

    protect & defend the Constitution ... I don't yet know what actions that's going to require until the threats actually materialize.

    I think where you and me differ on this is that I see real threats happening right now. It's not just the invasion of your congress building by terrorists, in fact that's one of the more minor threats IMO. The problem is the attacks on your democracy, especially the move to restore it to the original form envisaged by your constitution... where only white men get to vote, black people are explicitly property and white women are not much better.

    "voting rights" are the obvious problem, but the current interest in who counts the votes is another obvious area of concern, along with whether the counting matters when state governments are looking to instruct the electoral college voters directly (ignoring the popular vote).

    The trouble with this stuff is that fighting it involves a great deal of boring administrative work, a lot of going to meetings, and very probably signing up for jobs that entail a great deal of both of those. No option to charge in with a gun and save the day, but some prospect that someone else will do that to you (viz, execute you as a traitor if you make too many decisions they disagree with).

    491:

    One expert thinks Omicron is so contagious that he expects everyone, even those triple vaccinated, to become infected.

    I became eligible for a booster today (which was also the first day I could attempt to book one). Can't find a place with an opening in the next two weeks within a two-hour drive. I suspect I may not get a spot before they open it up to everyone in three weeks.

    Doug Ford is not my favourite person right now. Rather than a central system (like in BC) it is incumbent on an individual to contact every pharmacy and mass vaccination clinic separately, one at a time, to try to get a spot.

    492:

    in Jimmy Carter we had a POTUS that was below average IQ.

    Uh, not really. He just proves the point that being able to manage a sprawling bureaucracy and working well with a bunch of populists it not something IQ tests measure well. At all.

    It is hard to become a US nuclear Navy sub skipper with a below average IQ.

    493:

    If you look at some of the photos, there's no central reinforced interior space, i.e., what would typically qualify as a 'safe interior' space to hunker down in during a storm ...

    I was referring to the comment by someone about he building likely not being built to code. These days projects like this most anywhere near a population center in the US are hard to NOT build to code. When it happens people go to jail. The driving force behind this is the insurance companies do NOT want to insure buildings not to code. And will work hard to help jail anyone who cheats that part of the system. Too harmful to THEIR profits.

    That doesn't deal with buildings built back before there were much in the way of codes or where the codes have changed a lot.

    494:

    I cant imagine a hyper-optimized billion-dollar corporation like Amazon would ever bother an insurance company about one of their corrugated tinplate boxes...

    495:

    paws & others
    Looking for comments up-thread?
    "Ctrl+F" And the specific number - goes straight to it.

    Rocketjps
    1. - Now vulnerable
    2. - the foot soldiers and brownshirts feel powerful. The great project or whatever is begun. - Brexit
    3. - TICK
    4. - short victorious war ... only of we get dragged into one by a re-trumpist US. ( I think )
    5. - No.
    6. - Haven't a clue.

    However, looking at the authoritarian/fascist progress in/near Europe, all three at present are very strongly religious in nature & rhetoric.
    Poland + Hungary are reactionary old-fashioned Catholic a la Pius XI & XII, and Turkey is semi-Islamist. THAT simply will not work or play out here, the ridicule would be immense - so what empty totem will the tories try for, I wonder?

    H
    Not getting it first time - POINTERS. The abstraction required is considerable - maybe even worse if you have been doing old-fashioned "linear" programming for years, as it requires a re-set of your "how to do it" actual mind-set.

    JBS
    There's a hurricane coming & the employer can still "fire at will" for people wanting to make sure they live for the next 24r hours?
    That is so Fucking insane & criminal that I have difficulty with it.
    Presumably, that's what the tories want for this country?
    { Let us not mention the word "Grenfell" here, though. )

    SFR
    Extreme weather events are here - yes, it's called ... Global Warming - still being denied by most "R's" in the USA, yes?

    496:

    whitroth @ 431: In what way are "wealth taxes" forbidden by the US Constitution? There's been a good bit of talk in the last year about instituting them.

    Its a matter of some argument.

    When the US Constitution was written it stated that federal direct taxes must be apportioned according to the population of each state. "Direct" means a tax on a person, or on property that is owned by that person. Tariffs are not considered direct taxes. In 1895 the Supreme Court decided that income taxes were direct taxes, and hence a federal income tax was unconstitutional. The 16th Amendment was introduced to make income taxes constitutional. It says:

    The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several States, and without regard to any census or enumeration.

    A wealth tax would clearly be a direct tax in exactly the same way as an income tax. The question is, can the 16th Amendment be stretched to include wealth taxes? Or conversely, can a wealth tax be made to quack sufficiently like an income tax? This would be another case for the Supreme Court. Unfortunately another amendment to fix the problem is not on the cards.

    497:

    I cant imagine a hyper-optimized billion-dollar corporation like Amazon would ever bother an insurance company about one of their corrugated tinplate boxes...

    They might not. (But check out Lloyds and the global re-insurance markets.) You missed my point. The insurance companies want working local building code enforcement. And work hard to make sure it exists. And they, (whoever handles permits and code enforcement), will show up at such a building being built if no permits are pulled. And if pulled make sure it meets code. (Most times these things coming to town are big news in the local area for a long time.) That would land multiple people in court withing a day or two. I work around the edge of the construction industry and non permit work on such things gets the attention of multiple people fast. And while Musk tends take pride to try and ignore such things Amazon doesn't need the hassle. A sheriff's car blocking $1 million in daily deliveries swamps any permit shavings.

    Much more likely in this case is that the building codes of the area didn't require hardened safe rooms. And here I'm harking back to my earlier point of 99.999+% of the time no building that far east will every experience a need for such. I will not fault that location for not having such.

    498:

    477 - "The Short, Victorious War", which was neither of those things for th state which started it.

    484 and 492 - I think the 3 most significant characters in the statement you replied to were the last 3, ";-)".

    485 - I understand the principles of calculus just fine; it's the mechanics and symbology of integration that usually cause issues.

    487 - Maybe I've missed something, but I thought the whole point of a tornado shelter was to be proof against tornadoes?

    499:

    all lies. But we had no way of knowing that for sure back then

    I was pretty sure they were all lies. Reason: the Bush and Blair administrations were employing the Josef Goebbels' 1935-39 playbook for ramping up to an invasion in propaganda. It was glaringly obvious they intended to invade Iraq: if you read Shirer's Rise and Fall of the Third Reich and pay attention to the run-up to the Anschluss and the invasion of Czecheslovakia the Iraq propaganda campaign was a beat-perfect re-run. Which meant the "sources" inside Iraq that they claimed were providing evidence of Saddam's WMDs could be evacuated and invited to talk in public. There's no point keeping a long term spy in place in an enemy manufacturing facility if you plan to invade and bomb it next week.

    If those agents had been real, all they needed was to exfiltrate one of them and put him in front of the news cameras to testify and about 90% of the anti-war protests would have evaporated instantly.

    Second confounding factor: Americans (and UKans) always think it's about us. But it's not always about us. The USA wasn't a factor in Saddam's diplomacy: the USA was an out-of-area irrelevance (until 1992). What Saddam was concerned with was the risk of an Iranian invasion -- after all, he'd attacked Iran and had been at war with Iran for 8 of the past 20 years. Claiming to have WMDs was a threat aimed at Iran -- there'd been extensive use of gas during the Iran-Iraq trench war -- and if he let it be known that he'd disarmed, he thought he'd be showing signs of weakness in the face of the real enemy, not a decadent western nation on the other side of the world.

    500:

    Pigeon: if you hit the "reply" link next to a comment, it will take you to the comment form and provide a back-link to the comment you're replying to that will persist regardless of whether a moderator messes around with any other comments.

    501:

    a new Amazon delivery facility

    One other angle: it's nearly mid-December, so peak Christmas season, which is when Amazon hires a huge raft of temporary workers to meet the demand surge. Which in turn means lots of folks who haven't been around long enough to have been through a fire or tornado drill. Or even to know where the toilet block is located.

    (This is not an attempt to excuse Amazon's working conditions which are generally open to plenty of criticism, but the tornado does seem to have hit at the worst possible time.)

    502:

    I have news for you. The social practices of favouring a dominant leader and establishing control over resources predates our emergence as a species, and has never gone away. This 'golden age' of primitive societies is a myth.

    503:

    There are a fair number of subjects where the appropriate saying is "if you think you understand this, you don't have a clue". Teaching and learning those is extremely difficult.

    Immunology, quantum mechanics (*), non-sequential logic (as in parallel computing), numerous aspects of mathematics over uncountable sets, and so on.

    (*) Let's omit high-curvature general relativity, which is hard more because it is mathematically dubious.

    504:

    IQ is a fuck-awful measure. I came in at 179 (*), and was only that low because I had a brainstorm on one question. But the test was on EXACTLY my skills, and I would have done very differently on one that tested other skills.

    Mainly pattern recognition, simple arithmetic, simple logic and use of English.

    505:

    Which in turn means lots of folks who haven't been around long enough to have been through a fire or tornado drill. Or even to know where the toilet block is located.

    I worked as a contractor at an Amazon warehouse in the UK a few years back during the pre-Xmas surge. We received a day of basic orientation around the site, including being shown where all the fire exits and toilets were. Getting time to use the toilets during a work shift was another matter...

    The building's construction was based, like most modern large buildings, around a reinforced core of concrete stairwells and elevators which are fire and smoke-resistant and structurally the strongest part of the building. They should resist collapse until (hopefully) everyone gets out safely in an earthquake or extreme weather event. If they don't, either the design strength was insufficient or it was built wrong. In the case of the Illinois Amazon building, time will tell. Red tape, as they say, is dyed in blood.

    506:

    Re: 'Extreme weather events are here - yes, it's called ... Global Warming'

    Yeah - part or maybe even most of the problem is that 'warming' suggests cozy therefore a non-issue whereas 'extreme' communicates 'Hey, we've got a serious problem here folks!'

    As I've mentioned before: scientists are (overall) crap at coming up with descriptive terms apart from those derived from Greek or Latin -- languages understood by maybe 0.001% of the population.

    507:

    JBS (@486) wrote:

    My fallback plan is to protect & defend the Constitution for as long as I have breath in my body to do so. But I don't yet know what actions that's going to require until the threats actually materialize.

    I think I see a problem with your position. What is the Constitution? The Constitution is whatever Congress (and the assenting states) writes into it. And what does the Constitution say? It says whatever SCOTUS decides that it says.

    What I'm aiming at: the other side can change the Constitution (certainly not at will and not easily, but you're already right in the middle of the attempts, from 'Citizens United' right through to this latest decision).

    So, if either (but more unlikely) the R's successfully pass an amendment that rescinds those parts of the Bill of Rights that they're not happy with, or (much more likely) SCOTUS decides that those parts don't actually mean what seems to be written in them, then your position is screwed. You will suddenly no longer be protecting and defending the Constitution, but you'll be attacking the (newly defined) Constitution – and the other side will be quick to protect and defend it against you.

    508:

    "I swore an oath to protect & defend the Constitution. I'm retired now, but I still consider that oath binding."

    I've always been unclear how the first half of the US enlistment oath(*) is to be interpreted. How does one determine the Constitution needs defending and how does one defend it? Who are enemies foreign and domestic and how are they to be identified? Matters of interpretation do matter: the oath the Oath Keepers claim to be keeping is precisely the enlistment oath.

    (*) https://www.army.mil/values/oath.html

    I, NAME, do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign and domestic; that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same; and that I will obey the orders of the President of the United States and the orders of the officers appointed over me, according to regulations and the Uniform Code of Military Justice. So help me God."

    509:
    IQ is a fuck-awful measure.... But the test was on EXACTLY my skills, and I would have done very differently on one that tested other skills.

    So very, very true.

    Give your average sportsball player an IQ test, and their scores will be all over the place. But the skills needed to be effective in their sport make them geniuses in their chosen profession.

    W.A. Mozart is another example. Excellent composer - few equals and none better as the saying goes. Yet there's an anecdote that someone saw him come to a party, and "within half an hour, he made a dozen enemies." Not the action of a smart person!

    Spoiler: intelligence is a many-factored thing, and there's no such thing as 'general intelligence'.

    510:

    Also, what if the two halves clash with each other? Namely, what if POTUS turns out to be a domestic enemy of the Constitution, and gives orders that run contrary to it?

    (And as we all have become aware at least since 2021-01-06, this is more than just a hypothetical possibility.)

    511:

    IQ tests are generally bad tests that only vaguely manage to measure the thing they are trying to measure

    But they are attempting to measure a real thing

    That real thing is called “general intelligence”

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/G_factor_(psychometrics)

    There is a “ positive correlations among different cognitive tasks, reflecting the fact that an individual's performance on one type of cognitive task tends to be comparable to that person's performance on other kinds of cognitive tasks. ”

    The applicability of the ability to excel on “cognitive tasks” to personal success in life is no guarantee (success in social tasks is also important” but I would say it is becoming more useful to life success over time as the ability to talk to computers become more and important in society.

    512:

    "General intelligence" almost certainly doesn't exist. At a minimum there are somewhere between a handful and a hundred domain-specific types of "intelligence", and a high ranking in one doesn't correlate with anything outside that subdomain.

    Existing GI tests conflate a bunch of things -- linguistic sophistication, arithmetic, logic -- but miss others. For example, I'm pretty sure that I'd score highly on language use in my own language, but I'm beyond awful when it comes to ability to retain other languages. My memory retention is shit, too, and my puzzle-solving ability is questionable. However, I can compensate for my memory fail up to a point by using software.

    I am, frankly, not convinced IQ measurement has any point outside the extremes: it can tell us if someone is very genuinely impaired -- when they score low across all problem-solving/patter recognition/language use/logic domains -- and if they're very much the opposite (although again, the latter maybe isn't terribly useful as a predictor of anything in particular).

    513:

    “Intelligence” in the common parlance is not what the term is referring to

    There are absolutely things that we commonly refer to as “intelligence” that are outside the bounds of the “general intelligence” definition used in psychology. Everything social for starters. But lots more

    However AS THE TERM IS SPECIFICALLY AND CAREFULLY DEFINED by psychology (and the article I attempted to link) it does in fact, empirically exist.

    There are a set of cognitive tasks that most certainly statistically cluster

    I.e if you are good at A you are more likely to be good at B, C, D etc

    This set of A, B, C things is SMALLER then the broader common use definition of “intelligence” but it is still a largish set and the clustering is interesting and non trivial

    If you read the wiki they are pretty specific about what that set of things are that cluster, how strongly they are correlated and math and studies are provided.

    All this is counter tot the current popular lefty hippy narrative that everyone is a special snowflake and equally smart in those own way lalalala kumbaya

    And yes IQ tests are horrible at measuring it and yes it’s not specifically correlated with life success but it is a real thing

    514:

    MSB
    Which is ( more or less ) what happened between 1856 & 1861, or at least AIUI.

    515:

    Oh shit
    I asked a question in #495
    - about - "How would the fascist takeover really kick off, here?"
    And my question has been answered - and that is really scary. - Though I wonder if they will soft-pedal the christian-blackmail-lies-bullshit for the start, at any rate.

    516:

    This link is borked. Is it an issue with Markdown?

    What I see: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gfactor(psychometrics)

    The part before "factor" is a link to the Wikipedia article on the letter "G". "factor" is in italics, and "(psychometrics)" is regular text.

    There should be underscores in there. I thought we could simple paste in URLs and Markdown would understand them? That is what I did below, and as you can see it has the same results as what you did — the link is borked.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G_factor_(psychometrics)

    Did the designers of Markdown not think that people might want to post URLs in messages? Was writing a system that could recognize that a line starting with "http://" or "https://" was likely a URL and shouldn't have text formatting applied?

    Not impressed with Markdown so far, based on my limited experience here.

    517:
    There are a fair number of subjects where the appropriate saying is "if you think you understand this, you don't have a clue". Teaching and learning those is extremely difficult. Immunology, quantum mechanics (*), non-sequential logic (as in parallel computing), numerous aspects of mathematics over uncountable sets, and so on. (*) Let's omit high-curvature general relativity, which is hard more because it is mathematically dubious.

    Funny you should mention those examples, EC.

    My explanation for countable/uncountable sets involved having some physical teacups (T) and saucers (S), and asking how we could show that there were the same number of each. Obviously we could count them and say that there were five of each, but an alternative would be to show that we could place one teacup on each saucer, thereby establishing a bijection (one-one map).

    Now we introduce Hilbert's Hotel, which has a countable (i.e. in one-one correspondence with the natural numbers) number of rooms. All the rooms are full, but we can make space for a newcomer by moving each guest to the next room (map is n |-> n+1), thereby freeing room 0.

    (examples of various countable sets such as integers, computer programs and rationals omitted.)

    You know -- of course -- how we show a set, like the reals, is uncountable. We assume that there is an enumeration (i.e. a one-one map between the reals and the naturals), and then generate a contradiction by creating a new real number that isn't already in the set. A nice picture of decimal expansions with the diagonal in highlights adds to the gaiety.

    I've also taught quantum computing, as a last-minute substitute teacher. I promise that the students won't ever forget the lesson that the BRA-KET notation is non-commutative! (They helped out, and I limped to the end of that lecture.)

    The only real problem I foresee with general relativity, which I've never had to teach, is that actually finding closed-form solutions to the ODEs is comparatively rare. Apart from Kerr's Solution, how many others are there?

    518:

    I cant imagine a hyper-optimized billion-dollar corporation like Amazon would ever bother an insurance company about one of their corrugated tinplate boxes...

    Your making a false assumption though that Amazon itself is building their warehouses.

    Generally, they aren't - like any modern business they are leasing them from a developer. And that developer will be following building codes because they will be looking at it as a long term investment - and who they lease it to when/if Amazon moves on - as well as their potential legal liabilities if anything happened.

    But even if Amazon builds their own, same applies - looking at meeting codes so that when they move on they will be able to sell/lease the space they are leaving.

    519:

    it is incumbent on an individual to contact every pharmacy and mass vaccination clinic separately, one at a time, to try to get a spot.

    I too became eligible, though haven't yet attempted to book anything - I may simply try a walk in.

    But my advice (which I used back in June to get my 2nd shot sooner) is to use the websites to find a proverbial hole in the wall small pharmacy that most people are likely overlooking.

    Back in June when the Region and the big chain pharmacies were all talking weeks I contacted a small pharmacy (M-F hours only, no evenings, in an out of the way strip mall) and got an appointment the next day.

    520:

    I think where you and me differ on this is that I see real threats happening right now.

    This is the real problem.

    The killing of democracy isn't happening with one big obvious thing (like a Pearl Harbor), but rather it hundreds/thousands of little things over time that are simply being overlooked by most - and as a result it makes it that much harder to fight back.

    521:

    "BRA-KET notation is non-commutative! (They helped out, and I limped to the end of that lecture.)

    The only real problem I foresee with general relativity,"

    Thanks for that. It reminded me of the very-long-gone days when I was moderately adept at bra-ket notation (QM) and Einstein index notation (relativity). But, for some reason, it never occurred to me to check whether they're somewhat equivalent.

    But it appears they are:

    https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/171238/index-gymnastics-and-representing-bra-kets-as-covariant-and-contravariant-tensor

    522:

    The point about UNcountable sets is that thinking in terms of discrete objects (like teacups) almost immediately leads you into making errors, where you assume countability without realising it. Proving that the reals are uncountable is easy, I agree, but I was specifically referring to various mathematical activities where the base set is uncountable. It's amazing how much stops working, and how many obvious assumptions fail.

    An example there are the concept of limits and 'weights'. In order to do anything useful with those over even the reals, you have to impose extra structure (e.g. require a complete order or stick with only measurable sets). Another is Markov theory - discrete Markov is quite simple, but continuous Markov is fiendish.

    523:

    I misunderstood your post on first reading, so here is another reply on general realitivity. The lack of closed-form solutions is near-universal in anything modelled by differential equations, quite a lot of statistics, and many other areas, but it's not a serious difficulty.

    The problem is that the standard formula for general relativity has a non-trivial singularity boundary, and far too much of it involves extrapolating closely around that boundary. That is (at best) extremely difficult, both because of poor convergence of limits and because it is easy to go over the boundary by accident.

    Worse, much of the active 'research' is by the black hole divers and other pseudo-scientists who deliberately extrapolate over the boundary, which is well-known to lead to logical inconsistencies.

    524:

    I am reminded of a girl I knew in high school whose parents were concerned because she was not doing well in school (or anything really). They sent her for an IQ test and later that day joined us at the coffee shop glowing with pride that she had scored a 90 on her test. She then spent some time lording her superior intelligence over me in particular for some reason.

    If souls are a thing I was able to save a portion of mine that day by keeping my mouth completely shut.

    525:

    Don't put bare URLs in comments unless they're simple (hint: no underscores or backslashes).

    Instead, use the [ ] ( ) notation: link caption goes in [ ], then URL in ( ).

    Here's a working link:

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/G\_factor\_(psychometrics)

    You should escape any underscores in the link caption (so instead of entering _ ender \_) but not in the actual URL.

    (I tried to provide a human-readable rendition of that link syntax but it melted my brain because of the (pyschometrics) at the end of the link. Bad wiki page title!)

    526:

    Conversely: some years ago my wife and I were at a Superbowl party in Cambridge (the suburb of Boston, not the one in the UK).

    On our way home, she told me she'd felt really stupid. Outclassed conversationally.

    I had to remind her: "You realize we were the only people at the party who weren't MIT post-docs, right?"

    (But she'd been the only one present who could explain the rules of American Football.)

    527:

    RbtPrior
    In the post exactly previous to yours, I posted a link in Markdown, & here is what the link actually read:

    \https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/dec/14/boris-johnson-tory-party-radicals-conservative

    As you can see ( comment #515 ) it posted, though that one doesn't have any underscores in it. And, my attempt to have the link post in blue failed ....

    mdive
    Precisely, the "Death of a thousand cuts" - which is exactly how the christian fascists in Poland & Hungary & Erdogan in Turkey have done it. The R's in the USA are, obviously doing exactly the same thing, except it's spread, in slightly differing formats, across the individual states.
    Here, the current tories are trying to rush it, because they are afraid that come 2024, they will lose & time is short. But in their favour ( As they see it, they have an 80-seat majority & can push it through, provided that 39 or less of their own people do not vote against their own party. )

    528:

    Yeah, I know... but I was talking about reading what other people have posted, not posting things myself.

    You can also use the links under the dates of people's replies to turn references to comments by number into reliable URLs (eg. 500). But I'm not sure if I've ever seen anyone actually doing that, apart from maybe me about twice.

    529:

    Can't find a place with an opening in the next two weeks within a two-hour drive.

    Of course the advantage of a lack of a central system can be ways to get it sooner.

    Decided to go out for a tour of my local independent pharmacies to try for a walk in, 2nd place tried (the pharmacy inside my local No Frills) was taking in person appointments for Thurs/Fri - so I am booked Thursday morning.

    530:

    Just a reminder, since this one's been used on me a number of times: If the building code matters, read the effing code to find out what it actually says.

    My example is the California Building Code on wildfires. A number of developers have stated that they build their homes up to code, and therefore the homes are proof against wildfires. Politicians accept this statement. What the code actually says is that it's designed to do the minimum to make the home more resistant to fire.

    So I have no idea what various states' building codes say about large warehouses and tornadoes, but I'd be shocked if those disaster sites weren't up to code. Conversely, I'd be unsurprised if the code wasn't designed to make the building or any part of it tornado proof, although hopefully it's more stringent than that.

    531:

    What I want to know is how come Charlie had access to my text editor, since what he said re Elon Musk is pretty much word-for-Word what i was about to post.

    I’ve met/worked for or with/worked with ex-worker-for/etc a lot of the Musk/Gates/Allen/Jobs/Ellison type and in general they’re just people. Nice in some respects, awful in some, smart at some things, idiots in others. Having lots of money tends to amplify the effects of the not-so-good parts. Some of them understand that luck has played an enormous role, some think it was all their own skill. I have neighbours just like that.

    All in all I’m willing to give Musk a bit of a break because he’s doing a lot of things I like (cars, rockets) with all that money instead of just making an island of stacked dollar bills. Gates I have personal reasons for not liking.

    532:

    Yup.

    On a similar note: living in Edinburgh means I know folks including some who knew a certain Joanne Rowling several years before she accidentally fell in the secret publishing industry money tank and it all stuck to her. Allegedly she was rather unpleasant, and her drift into right-wing-adjacent TERFery came as no surprise. (If you get filthy rich it behooves you to tread very likely lest you crush ordinary people by accident. JKR doesn't quite seem to have realized this -- to put the most charitable interpretation on her actions that I can think of.)

    533:

    Just a reminder, since this one's been used on me a number of times: If the building code matters, read the effing code to find out what it actually says.

    Yep.

    The building code is the resulting compromise between what the experts want, past disasters, what the developers want, and what the politicians think the public (home buyers, businesses) can afford. Plus probably other things.

    If you want something better than that, then you need to look at the insurance companies to change the financial equations through insurance rates - and keep the government from interfering in those rates.

    534:

    If the building code matters, read the effing code to find out what it actually says.

    And often talk to your local government to find out what they actually want.

    My house was recently reclassified into flood zone, because the whole Sydney basin is a flood zone. I mean, it genuinely is. High high points are maybe 50m above sea level, there's a lot of swamp and the rivers are tidal almost to the foot of the Blue Mountains.

    BUT my house is ~30m above sea level, towards the top of a long ridge, and has less than 100m of catchment above it. So the flood that will hit my house is the generic "all of Sydney is flooded" one.

    Local government say "oh we just want you to have a pump to clear your basement when it rains". Hopefully that's the end of it, but it cost $270 for the report on my property that confirms that yes, I'm on a slope near the top of a hill. Sigh.

    535:

    Moz @ 490:

    protect & defend the Constitution ... I don't yet know what actions that's going to require until the threats actually materialize.

    I think where you and me differ on this is that I see real threats happening right now. It's not just the invasion of your congress building by terrorists, in fact that's one of the more minor threats IMO. The problem is the attacks on your democracy, especially the move to restore it to the original form envisaged by your constitution... where only white men get to vote, black people are explicitly property and white women are not much better.

    I'm aware of the current threats.

    The "Founding Fathers" knew the Constitution was not perfect. That's why they included the mechanism for amending it. Once an amendment is ratified by the requisite number of states it is part of the Constitution and can only be removed by passing and ratifying an amendment to repeal it (see Amendments XVIII and XXI). The XIIIth, XIVth, XVth, XIXth, XXIVth and XXVIth Amendments are here to stay.

    THEY may want to ignore those Amendments, but time is against them. THEY may be able to take us a step backwards, but eventually we're going to take two steps forward again!

    I hope they will not be able to take those backward steps, but if they do I hope to live to see that undone and I'll do my part to undo them.

    "voting rights" are the obvious problem, but the current interest in who counts the votes is another obvious area of concern, along with whether the counting matters when state governments are looking to instruct the electoral college voters directly (ignoring the popular vote).

    That can be a problem, and it's probably going to take a Constitutional Amendment to fix it. In the meantime we'll just have to fight tyranny at the state level.

    The trouble with this stuff is that fighting it involves a great deal of boring administrative work, a lot of going to meetings, and very probably signing up for jobs that entail a great deal of both of those. No option to charge in with a gun and save the day, but some prospect that someone else will do that to you (viz, execute you as a traitor if you make too many decisions they disagree with).

    I'm not planning to charge in with a gun.

    536:

    Poul-Henning Kamp @ 494: I cant imagine a hyper-optimized billion-dollar corporation like Amazon would ever bother an insurance company about one of their corrugated tinplate boxes...

    I can't imagine a "hyper-optimized billion-dollar corporation like Amazon" getting a certificate of occupancy so they could operate a distribution warehouse in a building that did not meet code.

    I was involved in a number of final inspections (fire alarm) during the years I worked for the burglar alarm company. If it doesn't meet code, all you get is a big empty building. You might get a tax write-off, but you ain't gonna be using it as a warehouse.

    If it's a high-cube warehouse (like what I see in the photos), the internal safe spaces won't stick up all the way to the roof. Based on what I know from doing fire alarms in high cube warehouses, those photos of the interior ... the reason you don't see the internal shelter spaces is because the photographer is standing on top of them to take the photo.

    The way I read the news story about the guy who texted his wife or girlfriend that he wasn't being allowed to leave, he was a driver, not a warehouse worker. Amazon didn't want the liability of him being out on the road when the tornado struck, so they required him to shelter in place.

    I don't think anyone anticipated the tornado would strike directly at the internal shelter space the way it did. News reports I've seen says that's what happened. That internal shelter space may not have been adequate to withstand the tornado, but you can bet your bottom dollar it met the requirements of the building code.

    537:

    Greg Tingey @ 495: JBS
    There's a hurricane coming & the employer can still "fire at will" for people wanting to make sure they live for the next 24r hours?
    That is so Fucking insane & criminal that I have difficulty with it.
    Presumably, that's what the tories want for this country?
    { Let us not mention the word "Grenfell" here, though. )

    It's an extreme case, but that's the way at will employment works. They don't have to have a "reason", they can just tell you you don't work here anymore. Wouldn't surprise me if you don't already have some aspects of it in place already. I think over there it's called "made redundant"

    538:

    David L @ 497: Much more likely in this case is that the building codes of the area didn't require hardened safe rooms. And here I'm harking back to my earlier point of 99.999+% of the time no building that far east will every experience a need for such. I will not fault that location for not having such.

    The building had shelter spaces that met code. The code may not be adequate, because the tornado hit one of those shelter spaces directly and tore it apart.

    539:

    Elderly Cynic @ 504: IQ is a fuck-awful measure. I came in at 179 (*), and was only that low because I had a brainstorm on one question. But the test was on EXACTLY my skills, and I would have done very differently on one that tested other skills.

    Mainly pattern recognition, simple arithmetic, simple logic and use of English.

    Y'all are getting all wrapped around the axle over IQ, when the point was average ... half the population have below average [something].

    Of course it's really half the population fall below the median, but for the purpose of making a stupid joke ... average is good enough.

    See also - Lies, damn lies & statistics

    I know what my IQ was when I was in High School. It was high enough I could have joined MENSA (if MENSA allowed high school students to join). Whatever it is today, maybe not.

    540:

    No, Tricky Dick had no sense. Politics and chasing power overwhelmed anything resembling sense.

    541:

    The "on incomes, regardless of source", at the least should let us tax capital gains, and interest and dividend income as income. That alone would Simplify The Tax Code, and eliminate forms B and D, I think.

    And piss off the wealthy no end.

    542:

    Some of us knew as soon as they were in office. The Project for a New American Century wrote President Clinton a letter in '98, urging him to invade Iraq. Among the signatories were, yes, Rummy, Condi, and Cheney.

    543:

    Kardashev @ 508:

    "I swore an oath to protect & defend the Constitution. I'm retired now, but I still consider that oath binding.""

    I've always been unclear how the first half of the US enlistment oath(*) is to be interpreted. How does one determine the Constitution needs defending and how does one defend it? Who are enemies foreign and domestic and how are they to be identified? Matters of interpretation do matter: the oath the Oath Keepers claim to be keeping is precisely the enlistment oath.

    Nobody ever said it was going to be easy. Or safe ... or popular.

    While I was in the National Guard we used to have classes on how to deal with "unlawful orders" - how to recognize them, what the oath and the UCMJ requires of you if you receive one. And understand you might not prevail. But you have to stand for the right, for truth and for justice no matter the personal cost. The "Oath Keepers" don't do that. Their Oath is a lie.

    Some things are NOT matters subject to interpretation:

    Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.
    The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.
    No person shall be held to answer for a capital, or otherwise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of a Grand Jury, except in cases arising in the land or naval forces, or in the Militia, when in actual service in time of War or public danger; nor shall any person be subject for the same offence to be twice put in jeopardy of life or limb; nor shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself, nor be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation.
    In all criminal prosecutions, the accused shall enjoy the right to a speedy and public trial, by an impartial jury of the State and district wherein the crime shall have been committed, which district shall have been previously ascertained by law, and to be informed of the nature and cause of the accusation; to be confronted with the witnesses against him; to have compulsory process for obtaining witnesses in his favor, and to have the Assistance of Counsel for his defence.
    Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction.
    All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside. No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.
    The right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on account of race, color, or previous condition of servitude--
    The right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on account of sex.
    The right of citizens of the United States to vote in any primary or other election for President or Vice President, for electors for President or Vice President, or for Senator or Representative in Congress, shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or any State by reason of failure to pay any poll tax or other tax.

    I don't want to lose life, limb or personal freedom defending these principles, but if those are the costs, I've sworn to pay them. I don't know how to explain it any better than that.

    544:

    Redundancy is not sacking at will. Anybody made redundant has to receive redundancy pay which depends on how long they have worked and their current salary. For redundancy the job must not be replaced. I was made redundant at the age of 65. I got the equivalent of two years pay. I also retired from the NHS and took my NHS final salary pension. I was then asked to provide cover for a colleague on maternity leave. Since National Insurance is not payable after state retirement age (equivalent to a 10 percent pay rise)and I got my NHS pension plus pay for 12 hours per week working i was earning as much for a 12 hour working week as I had been before retirement working a nominal 38 hours (actually about 55 hours) I was very happy to be made redundant since I had planned to work for another two years but with the redundancy I got a lumps sum payout equivalent to those two years pay.

    545:

    Unholyguy @ 511:

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gfactor(psychometrics)

    It looks like you have to add a backslash before the underscores to get the URL to work.

    <p>https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G\_factor\_(psychometrics)</p>

    Or just manually embed it between paragraph tags

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G_factor_(psychometrics)

    or make it an embedded hyperlink Gfactor(psychometrics)

    546:

    Well, that does sound like genuine MIT post-docs.

    547:

    timrowledge @ 531:h All in all I’m willing to give Musk a bit of a break because he’s doing a lot of things I like (cars, rockets) with all that money instead of just making an island of stacked dollar bills.

    What does Elon Musk have to do with Amazon? I thought that was Jeff Bezos. Musk was "PayPal"

    548:

    I don't want to lose life, limb or personal freedom defending these principles, but

    As pointed out by someone else above, your enemy is actively working to change the law you're so willing to defend. Right now you're willing to put your life on the line to prevent women in Texas getting abortions, allow state legislatures to gerrymander the voting system, and defend the right of corporations to buy legislation. Increasingly that legal system you're so keen on is limited voting to those of the right race, allowing Christians to discriminate against others, allowing police officers to execute suspect, and so on.

    There are processes to stop them doing that, and I think it behooves you to engage with those processes if you disagree with the goals of them people changing the law.

    You're being asked to put hours and hours of your life into opposing those things. But you keep avoiding opportunities to say you're doing that, or willing to do it, and instead you witter on about 'putting your life on the line'.

    549:

    Don't put bare URLs in comments unless they're simple (hint: no underscores or backslashes).

    Instead, use the [ ] ( ) notation: link caption goes in [ ], then URL in ( ).

    Obviously a miscommunication, because I asked earlier about posting URLs by just pasting them and you said that was possible.

    Personally, I prefer so see what a link is before clicking on it, which is why I like bare URLs that I have to cut-and-paste into my browser, because in a caption/URL combo there's no guarantee that the URL goes where you think. (And on an iPad I haven't figured out a way to display the link, because the 'hover over' trick doesn't work.)

    In any case, Markdown has made posting URLs more difficult, as I now have to either use that caption/URL notation or edit the URL and hope I did the escaping thing correctly. I'm always underwhelmed when a labour-saving technology makes something more difficult to do. Especially as it wouldn't have been difficult to not apply Markdown formatting to lines that are obviously URLs because they begin with "http" or "https". It's not like URLs never used underscores before Markdown was invented.

    550:

    But my advice (which I used back in June to get my 2nd shot sooner) is to use the websites to find a proverbial hole in the wall small pharmacy that most people are likely overlooking.

    Could you be more specific? I've signed up online for the waiting lists for all the pharmacies near me. Do they prioritize people who walk through the door?

    551:

    Decided to go out for a tour of my local independent pharmacies to try for a walk in

    Where are you located? I remember last spring that it was much harder to get a shot in the GTA than elsewhere in Ontario.

    552:

    you can bet your bottom dollar it met the requirements of the building code

    A few years ago I had lunch with a retired engineer who was on the committee that decides whether someone gets their Professional Engineer designation or not. He said the worst were those whose design portfolios "met code" but were clearly suboptimal designs. The worst were apparently those who worked for the nuclear industry, whose defense when question on their design choices was always "but it meets code".

    Meeting code is the bare minimum — and a lot of builders do the bare minimum to meet the bare minimum.

    553:

    Charlie Stross @ 499:

    all lies. But we had no way of knowing that for sure back then

    I was pretty sure they were all lies. Reason: the Bush and Blair administrations were employing the Josef Goebbels' 1935-39 playbook for ramping up to an invasion in propaganda. It was glaringly obvious they intended to invade Iraq: if you read Shirer's Rise and Fall of the Third Reich and pay attention to the run-up to the Anschluss and the invasion of Czecheslovakia the Iraq propaganda campaign was a beat-perfect re-run. Which meant the "sources" inside Iraq that they claimed were providing evidence of Saddam's WMDs could be evacuated and invited to talk in public. There's no point keeping a long term spy in place in an enemy manufacturing facility if you plan to invade and bomb it next week.

    If those agents had been real, all they needed was to exfiltrate one of them and put him in front of the news cameras to testify and about 90% of the anti-war protests would have evaporated instantly.

    Second confounding factor: Americans (and UKans) always think it's about us. But it's not always about us. The USA wasn't a factor in Saddam's diplomacy: the USA was an out-of-area irrelevance (until 1992). What Saddam was concerned with was the risk of an Iranian invasion -- after all, he'd attacked Iran and had been at war with Iran for 8 of the past 20 years. Claiming to have WMDs was a threat aimed at Iran -- there'd been extensive use of gas during the Iran-Iraq trench war -- and if he let it be known that he'd disarmed, he thought he'd be showing signs of weakness in the face of the real enemy, not a decadent western nation on the other side of the world.

    When I wrote "we had no way of knowing that for sure back then" I really meant the average uninformed American who got everything they knew about the rest of the world from nightly network TV News broadcasts wouldn't have known.

    But I wasn't "pretty sure", I KNEW. I was unable to share that knowledge. Not bound by any oath, I just didn't have the words. I tried to explain to people that when you look at the ethnic & religious makeup of Iraq, the only sure winner would be Iran.

    I knew when and where Saddam had gotten his chemical weapons, who sold him the chemical ingredients and who built the factory that produced them ... and what had happened to them after Desert Storm.

    Anyone paying the slightest bit of attention would have been able to find the information about Saddam & Iran. I found it. I was paying attention because NBC - Nuclear, Biological & Chemical warfare was my specialty. But the lies went back 20 years before 9/11, all the way back to the Iran Hostage Crisis ... and it wouldn't surprise me if they went back as far as the 1953 Iranian coup d'état. But that's neither here nor there.

    I knew Colon Powell was a lying sonofabitch BEFORE he ever became dumbya's Secretary of State. I knew he was a liar after Desert Storm when he went on TV in front of Congress and told lies about ME and the National Guard units I served with and how the Army tried to fuck us over and tried to fuck us over AGAIN!

    But the worst part of the Iraq invasion - besides being a monumentally stupid fucking idea in the first place is they got high on their own supply and fucked it up from the get-go. They had no plan and had made no provision for what to do next if the invasion was successful ... which ultimately led to defeat. It was a war lost in Washington, DC before it ever started in Iraq.

    http://www.faculty.fairfield.edu/dcrawford/klein.pdf

    554:

    Where are you located? I remember last spring that it was much harder to get a shot in the GTA than elsewhere in Ontario.

    I'm in Brampton.

    In the spring I got my first shot through the Region of Peel, as noted my 2nd shot (mid-June) I got by ignoring all the "normal" pharmacies (Shoppers/Rexall/Walmart/grocery store) and found on the provincial listing a small (as in very small - looked like a husband/wife team in a 10'x30' retail location in a small mostly forgotten strip mall) - with it I was surprised to get an appointment the next day when everyone else was quoting 3 weeks.

    As for today, many places have been offering walk in vaccinations for a while now so I just decided to try, and the No Frills didn't do walk in anymore but were taking in person appointments.

    The PC Health website shows multiple Loblaw company locations in the Peel area doing walk-in of some sort, so maybe try it.

    https://covid19.pchealth.ca/#/en

    555:

    whitroth @ 542: Some of us knew as soon as they were in office. The Project for a New American Century wrote President Clinton a letter in '98, urging him to invade Iraq. Among the signatories were, yes, Rummy, Condi, and Cheney.

    And if you read the whole thing you'd know that Iraq wasn't even the target. It was only a stepping stone to regional hegemony.

    Invade Iraq and use it as a base to take Iran and with Iran you control ALL of the oil & gas fields and pipeline routes from the former Soviet Republics. You don't even have to invade them for them to fall in line.

    ... and the whole damn scheme managed by ENRON, with just about that much chance of success.

    556:

    Moz @ 548: You're being asked to put hours and hours of your life into opposing those things. But you keep avoiding opportunities to say you're doing that, or willing to do it, and instead you witter on about 'putting your life on the line'.

    I'm not answerable to you. I don't have to justify whether I'm doing what you tell me to do or doing something else.

    557:

    When I wrote "we had no way of knowing that for sure back then" I really meant the average uninformed American who got everything they knew about the rest of the world from nightly network TV News broadcasts wouldn't have known.

    It's easy to forget now just how pro-war the US was back then - the public, the media, and all politicians.

    Yes, there were a small number who didn't fall for it - but there was simply no way at that time to try and convince the general public otherwise because being anti-invading Iraq was deemed unpatriotic. Just ask the Dixie Chicks about attempting to stand up and say the right thing.

    558:

    I wasn't suggesting that you're accountable to me, I was criticising you for what you are saying, and what you're not saying.

    You're being emphatic that you will defend slavery, forced childbirth, oligarchy etc to your dying breath, and I regard those as bad things to be fought against. "but it's not illegal" is a very low bar.

    In the past you've objected when I point out stuff like that, so I thought it might be worth asking whether you actually intend to fight to the death to stop women getting abortions in Texas. As you say, you're not required to answer that, but I'm entitled to think you're not disagreeing because you don't disagree.

    559:

    Current article from The Atlantic, which discusses the threats to US democracy.

    Most interesting part is closer to the end where it discusses the changes being made to ensure a Republican victory in the future - including that 4 of the Supreme Court Justices already are behind an idea that Trump's legal teams could use in the future with a 5th Justice's position unknown.

    https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2022/01/january-6-insurrection-trump-coup-2024-election/620843/

    560:

    I had to remind her: "You realize we were the only people at the party who weren't MIT post-docs, right?"

    Well not post docs but how about a good friend's wedding guests. In my house for the afternoon around 15 friends of the bride and groom. Both of them recent grads of MIT (got in with perfect SATs) and the friends all classmates.

    First time I ever felt I was the least smart person in the room.

    561:

    JBS
    The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, ... So "Civil Forfeiture is against the US constitution, is it?

    mdive
    Reminder to readers - open that "Atlantic" link in an incognito browser window - though not as bad as the NYT, they limit the number of visits ...

    562:

    That very specific list of things the people were "secure in ..." didn't include automobiles, computers, clothing-with-pockets, or wallets, so various courts over time decided that obviously the constitution didn't apply to those things that weren't listed. Oh, and the word "unreasonable" is doing a lot of heavy lifting there, isn't it?

    A case where less specificity might have made the constitutional law more broadly effective.

    563:

    TBF I'd be happier engaging with people who recognise it's a legal document (a pretty antiquated one at that) and not an expression of universal principles... seeing as how they don't make sense outside a certain geography and they don't make sense inside it 250 years later either.

    564:

    It was high enough I could have joined MENSA (if MENSA allowed high school students to join)

    A friend at our boarding school decided to see if he could join Mensa; and if so, whether it was an excuse to get out of the place at weekends (because boring) and just maybe meet women (because all-male). He dragged me into it, because I had a fairly spotless track record when it came to good behaviour... We both tested, we both got in (I'd only just turned 17), and a Mensa social event in Stirling was the first time I ever got drunk...

    But no, there were no women even remotely close to us in age, and the group concerned did a good job of providing a safe environment (for me at least).

    565:

    The PC Health website shows multiple Loblaw company locations in the Peel area doing walk-in of some sort, so maybe try it.

    Thanks. That's a lot more useful than the site the government links to. I found a coulpe and will give it a try today.

    566:

    It's easy to forget now just how pro-war the US was back then - the public, the media, and all politicians.,/i>

    I remember it quite clearly, as seen from next door. An apparently non-stop pounding of the drums, with threats against any country that didn't sign on to help the invasion. It's why Canada upped our involvement in Afghanistan — Chretien managed to convince Bush that while Canadians wouldn't support an invasion of Iraq (which the majority didn't) we would send more troops to Afghanistan freeing American forces for the Iraq war.

    567:

    JBS @ 543:

    The right of citizens of the United States to vote in any primary or other election for President or Vice President, for electors for President or Vice President, or for Senator or Representative in Congress, shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or any State by reason of failure to pay any poll tax or other tax.

    Things that aren't defined as "taxes" on the other hand, are just dandy.

    TL;DR: If you get convicted of a felony in Florida the state whomps a ton of non-optional charges on top for court fees etc. Most people just out of prison are not in a position to pay this off, quite possibly ever. But until they do they are not allowed to vote, despite a vote in 2018 to re-enfranchise convicted felons who have served their sentences.

    Worse yet, Florida won't tell them if they have paid off all this "debt", but until they do attempting to vote is itself a crime.

    568:

    The PC Health website shows multiple Loblaw company locations in the Peel area doing walk-in of some sort, so maybe try it.

    Been trying all morning. No walk-ins, no appointments despite what the web site says. Hit my limit for driving in traffic (in the rain, in construction zones). Sigh.

    Will have to try again tomorrow. Thanks for trying to help.

    569:

    Charlie @ 562: A case where less specificity might have made the constitutional law more broadly effective.

    Oh God yes. Warning: rant ahead.

    This is something the textualists and originalists just don't seem to be able to get their heads around: there is no "original" or "real" meaning of the Constitution beyond some very broad-brush strokes, and trying to figure out where in a sea of shades of grey you are going to draw a bright line is inevitably an exercise in politics and personal opinion.

    "The right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed." Well, it depends on whether that applies to the right to join a "militia" (whatever that is), and somehow it seems to apply differently to weapons that have full-auto settings or fire explosives, for no well explained reason. The most recent Supreme Court case goes into a lot of stuff about

    (JBS: I know you have opinions on this. My point is that other people have other opinions. We are lost in a twisty maze of little opinions, all different).

    And "Congress shall make no law [...] abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press". Well yes, except for certain types of pornography, libel, "true threats" and some other stuff. Historically that list has veered all over the place. The Supreme Court nailed it down somewhat in 1936 by setting the "strict scrutiny" standard for exceptions, but "strict scrutiny" is still something that they made up; it isn't found in the Constitution.

    The 4th Amendment exception for cars dates back to Prohibition. In theory it requires "probable cause" but in practice "Sniff... smells like cannabis to me" is considered sufficient. Or get a well trained dog to "indicate" as judged by its handler. (This is actually improving: in states where cannabis is legal, smelling of cannabis is no longer considered probable cause).

    so various courts over time decided that obviously the constitution didn't apply to those things that weren't listed.

    Meanwhile back in the 1st Amendment the courts have rightly decided that a bunch of things that weren't listed as "speech or the press" are in fact "speech". Burning the flag is "speech". Computer programs are "speech".

    And as for the Commerce Clause:

    power "[t]o regulate Commerce with foreign Nations, and among the several States, and with the Indian Tribes.*

    That was originally put in to let Congress charge customs duties (its main revenue source back then), and also to stop the states from charging customs duties to each other. The latter made the United States the first really big common market, and had a lot to do with the subsequent economic rise of the USA. But what exactly counts as "interstate commerce"? During the New Deal the federal government tried to regulate mines, but this was struck down because mines were not "commerce". Roosevelt threatened to pack the court to get his way, and the court reversed itself (I'm over-simplifying some rather complicated and contentious history here). After that the Commerce Clause expanded to cover pretty much anything the federal government wanted to do, because they could always find some way, no matter how trivial, that their rules would affect interstate commerce. One case found that this included growing food for your own consumption. Another example: the federal computer misuse act is grounded on the commerce clause, because it is limited to computers used in interstate commerce. But in 1995 the Lopez case reversed much of this; these days the link between a federal law and actual interstate commerce has to be a lot more direct.

    If there is one true meaning of the Constitution then many decisions above must have been wrong. If they are a matter of judgement then the Constitution is not a set of rules, its a set of guidelines.

    Oh, and of course the 9th: The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people.

    So lets consider some unenumerated "Right to X" for some X. There clearly exist rights that the People enjoy which are not enumerated in the Constitution. The Right to Self Defence seems a pretty unarguable one: nobody on either Left or Right (AFIAK) claims that this doesn't exist, although they do argue a lot about where it applies. Therefore the set of values of X is non-empty. So who gets to decide whether some alleged right is in fact a member of this set?

    It can't be an individual decision: "I have an inalienable right to pick up stuff I want even if someone else thinks they own it" is not going to fly.

    It can't be the executive or legislature, because the whole theory of rights in the constitution is that they exist apart from any particular society or set of rules, so they can't be granted or taken away by governments or parliaments.

    So that leaves judges. The 9th is nothing less than an open invitation to the judiciary to discover new rights not enumerated in the constitution.

    570:

    Me just now: * The most recent Supreme Court case goes into a lot of stuff about *

    Sorry, forgot to finish that bit. I meant to point to all the stuff about the right to self-defence in Heller.

    571:

    Moz @ 558: I wasn't suggesting that you're accountable to me, I was criticising you for what you are saying, and what you're not saying.

    You're being emphatic that you will defend slavery, forced childbirth, oligarchy etc to your dying breath, and I regard those as bad things to be fought against. "but it's not illegal" is a very low bar.

    In the past you've objected when I point out stuff like that, so I thought it might be worth asking whether you actually intend to fight to the death to stop women getting abortions in Texas. As you say, you're not required to answer that, but I'm entitled to think you're not disagreeing because you don't disagree."

    And you persist in straw-man arguments. Criticize me for what I've actually written not for shit you make up.

    572:

    Greg Tingey @ 561: JBS
    The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, ... So "Civil Forfeiture is against the US constitution, is it?

    I think it is.

    573:

    Gronk? I have no idea how you might have got from my comment about Musk to thinking I was referring to Bezos. Who, I should point out, didn’t come up in my thoughts at all whilst writing my comment. Perhaps because he isn’t yet making real rockets.

    What was the connection you were thinking of?

    574:

    Well, neither of us, nor any of the people within the variety of circles in which we're active, supported the Middle East War AT ALL. There were a whole lot of massive protest-demonstrations here against going in. Ya, do something regarding Afghanistan, but sheesh, leave Iraq alone! that was as much war support as you'd find among our ilks, which includes people who have spent a lot of time on the ground in the Middle East. We all knew better. It was the frackin' media, more than anything . . . . Which continues to be the worst source of lie-mongering. Television killed this nation's democracy long before online social media did, one thinks.

    ~~~~~~~~~~~

    CBS News reported this AM that New York State (not only NYC) and New Jersey have the highest rate of omicron infection in the country, 14% greater than the rest of the country, and transmitting with extraordinary rapidity. Yet that same CBS report, that interviews tourists in Midtown, none of whom are masking, respond with variations of "That's surprising but not surprising, really. We walked today from Times Square which is shoulder-to-shoulder packed, over to etc., all the way shoulder-to-shoulder packed to etc."

    The tens of thousands attending Anime-Con brought it here, and then this weekend the horror show called Santa Con brought tens and tens and tens more thousands from all over -- none of whom, I vouch for it -- were wearing masks, and were hanging out all over and around the participating bars shoulder-to-shoulder, at least 6-8 individuals deep, maskless.

    By the way, one does wonder how the recent sf/f cons meeting f2f turned out with post-con new infections among the attendees?

    In the meantime, Cornell has had to shut down its classrooms, with over 900 infections. Our school's last day of classes was yesterday. Thank goddessa. Exams 16 - 22, which is still not so good, though in my case, it's final papers, not exams, so I don't have to meet with them. Thank goddessa.

    I fear this is the winter I get covid. We are the most vaccinated place in the country, but our new numbers are soaring already, when, until Anime Con they were very very low (unlike Staten Island and parts of Brooklyn, Queens and the Bronx). I am boosted, as of the middle of last month, but still. I confess to being kinda scared. We're now shutting down the bits of normal life we've been enjoying for the first time in 20 months just about, such as going to film screenings (not the movies -- a different kind of experience entirely, and one we have not resumed since stopping back in January 2020 -- in my case due to fear of flu, etc. then -- we hadn't quite gotten to covid yet).

    575:

    Civil Forfeiture is a strange legal animal.

    The subject of the action is not the person who (claims to) own the pile of money (or other object), but the money/object itself, in itself.

    The legal reasoning then goes:

    Whatever is in the constitution does not apply, because a pile of money is not a "citizen" or "person".

    The constitutional rights of the person who claims to own the money are only infringed if they actually do own the money, so if they cannot prove that, there is no problem, and if they can prove it, all they have to do is sue, using that proof to get their money back.

    What makes this so utterly demented is "The American Rule", where even if you win, even if your opponent obviously tried to defraud you, you still have to pay your own lawyer.

    576:

    Martin @ 564:

    It was high enough I could have joined MENSA (if MENSA allowed high school students to join)

    A friend at our boarding school decided to see if he could join Mensa; and if so, whether it was an excuse to get out of the place at weekends (because boring) and just maybe meet women (because all-male). He dragged me into it, because I had a fairly spotless track record when it came to good behaviour... We both tested, we both got in (I'd only just turned 17), and a Mensa social event in Stirling was the first time I ever got drunk...

    But no, there were no women even remotely close to us in age, and the group concerned did a good job of providing a safe environment (for me at least).

    I wrote "if MENSA allowed high school students to join" because I didn't know if it did when I was in high school, and I hadn't thought to see about it. I don't remember if I even knew there was such a thing as MENSA back then.

    I got an invitation to join some kind of "National Honor Society" and they did have girls my age as members. But they didn't have any purely social events (that I'm aware of).

    I scored in the 99th percentile on every standardized test they made me take while I was in school. That and a dime would get you a cup of coffee back then, but I hadn't started drinking coffee yet.

    All it really got me was a bunch of grief, because no matter how well I did it wasn't good enough; I "wasn't living up to my potential."

    577:

    Foxessa: CBS News reported this AM that New York State (not only NYC) and New Jersey have the highest rate of omicron infection in the country,

    Perhaps the time has come to rename it the Omigod variant.

    578:

    Paul @ 567: JBS @ 543:

    The right of citizens of the United States to vote in any primary or other election for President or Vice President, for electors for President or Vice President, or for Senator or Representative in Congress, shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or any State by reason of failure to pay any poll tax or other tax.

    Things that aren't defined as "taxes" on the other hand, are just dandy.

    TL;DR: If you get convicted of a felony in Florida the state whomps a ton of non-optional charges on top for court fees etc. Most people just out of prison are not in a position to pay this off, quite possibly ever. But until they do they are not allowed to vote, despite a vote in 2018 to re-enfranchise convicted felons who have served their sentences.

    Worse yet, Florida won't tell them if they have paid off all this "debt", but until they do attempting to vote is itself a crime.

    So, what are YOU doing about it?

    Just 'cause they do something in Florida doesn't make it Constitutional.

    “There is no distinctly native American criminal class except Congress.”
         -- Mark Twain
    579:

    If you get convicted of a felony in Florida the state whomps a ton of non-optional charges on top for court fees etc.

    The enabling legislation to the referendum tossed this crap in. And polling shows an easy majority didn't want this. So now this legislation is in the courts. Anyone know the status of these cases?

    Several non profits were quickly set up to help people pay off these various fees so they could vote.

    580:

    Let me note that, having been in person since Oct to Capclave Windycon Philcon

    All are requiring you to show your vaccination card at reg to get your membership, and to wear masks except when eating or drinking.

    581:

    timrowledge @ 573 Gronk? I have no idea how you might have got from my comment about Musk to thinking I was referring to Bezos. Who, I should point out, didn’t come up in my thoughts at all whilst writing my comment. Perhaps because he isn’t yet making real rockets.

    What was the connection you were thinking of?

    Confusion from thread drift? Appeared to me like Evil Elon was getting conflated with the Amazon warehouse that collapsed from the tornado.

    582:

    Oh, and except for one or two idiots in the consuite, at Capclave at least (I was running the consuite), everyone did wear a mask.

    583:

    Oh, well obviously Evil Elon could have zapped the warehouse from orbit. Which Jeff can’t do yet! Evil cackles, hand-wringing, sniggering

    584:

    All are requiring you to show your vaccination card at reg to get your membership, and to wear masks except when eating or drinking.

    There's a minor scandal up here about the number of people using fake cards, or places that 'check' the card but don't look too closely. I would be very surprised, given the looney-libertarian-wingnut part of SF fandom, if every card at a con was legit.

    We also have rules stating that people should wear masks except when eating and drinking. Various folks are interpreting that to mean "as long as I have a cup of coffee in front of me", not "while I am actually taking a sip".

    585:

    I "wasn't living up to my potential."

    I got this on my reports all through high school. Oddly enough, it was never followed up by any indication what this "potential" was, or any mentorship to help me realise it...

    586:

    I "wasn't living up to my potential" is from teachers the equivalent of "you need to lose some weight" from a doctor. It's a generic nostrum designed to make the recipient feel vaguely guilty and thereby submissive towards professional authority, but it seldom means anything -- "living up to potential" in an educational role simply means you aren't jumping through the arbitrary hoops used as a definition for success (which seldom bear any resemblance to an actually useful life skill), and the recommended weight targets are based on BMI, which is a measure of statistical distribution in a population rather than a target for individual health: as a target they're borderline malnourished for anyone growing up in the developed world since 1920.

    587:

    CBS News reported this AM that New York State (not only NYC) and New Jersey have the highest rate of omicron infection in the country, 14% greater than the rest of the country,

    Really anyone who gives it any thought wont be surprised - just like with the first wave back in early 2020 omicron is following international travel. Which means it first enters the US in the major airport entry points, like NYC (and NYC's large commuter belt will help it spread)

    But like 2020 omicron will spread out across the rest of the US with time.

    The tens of thousands attending Anime-Con brought it here, and then this weekend the horror show called Santa Con brought tens and tens and tens more thousands from all over

    I have no idea whether it can be traced back to the events you mention, but I suspect at best they just accelerated things. Pretty much every country discovered they already had omicron once they new what to look for, and for example Ontario which has still had reasonably strict restrictions in place (albeit with some people not following the rules) is expecting omicron to dominate cases within 7 days - and we certainly aren't holding international conventions or cons again yet.

    588:
    ... or stick with only measurable sets

    Yes, I agree.

    (I did axiomatize measure theory for NASA, and there is a beauty in Lebesgue's approach, but I'd not give that sort of thing to undergraduates.)

    In fact, now I come to think about it, the one area of undergraduate maths I'd struggle to present coherently would be probability. The only way I ever found to make sense of conditional probability was to enumerate all the possibilities and then sum them up -- and approach that only works for discrete problems, of course.

    By the way, the problem you are alluding to with General Relativity: would that be people doing numeric modelling on boundary-value problems with boundary conditions that are discontinuous? If so, I had a rather nice example involving the heat equation with a partially uninsulated pipe. The boundary conditions were continuous, but at two points where the insulation had been cut the differential was discontinuous. The difference between the closed-form solution and the numeric solution was about 10%. Apparently a well-known problem in numerical analysis.

    As I used to drum into my undergraduate students: "When you graduate you will have a degree in Computer Science; and this means you are not qualified to use floating point numbers!"

    We'd just discussed the fact that (x+y)+z is not the same as x+(y+z), and that most compilers give no guarantee as to which bracketing they were going to do. Even if you introduced intermediate variables to try to force one bracketing over the other.

    589:

    Agreed - but whatever the intent, I figured it was bullshit fairly early on. At least a doctor telling you to lose wight can offer some practical advice.

    Years ago we had a WiiFit which said my ideal weight was somewhere around 70kg, which was less than my weight as a skinny undernourished teenager - I always assumed that was based on ideal ranges calculated via Japanese data and not quite applicable to western body types.

    590:

    586 & 589 - Well, I'm 5'10", and 102.5kg (BMI 33). I recently attended a kidney transplant screening clinic, at which I was told that I was "generally fit but might want to lose 2 or 3 kilos".

    591:

    Charlie - oh & Aunty Jack, as well ..
    Re: "BMI" - it's even worse than that, actually. In the mid-1930's a large statistical survey was done of a population in a "developed" country for many medical reasons, including taking weight, height etc ...
    Unfortunately, this was the central USA in the period 1930-40 - the "dustbowl" - so all BMI statistics are based on an underfed, malnourished population & aren't worth the toilet-paper they are written on - I learnt this from a postgrad Geography student, who used to rant on about it a bit - you can see why, of course.

    Paws
    In my case, 5'10" = 1.78m & 80 kg, gives BMI of 25.25 & I'm "overweight". Which is bollocks, because my waist measurement, as judged by my trouser size is the same at age almost-76 as it was when I was 35.....

    NOT as big a load of LYING UTTER SHIT as the "safe" limits for booze, of course, but that's another story.

    592:

    "I fear this is the winter I get covid... I am boosted, as of the middle of last month, but still. I confess to being kinda scared. We're now shutting down the bits of normal life we've been enjoying for the first time in 20 months just about..."

    Us too. We're boosted, but ~75 YO and the stats for > 65 YO aren't encouraging. Booked to take the descendants (carnivores all) to the local churrascaria a week from now for pre-Xmas, but not sure it will be prudent to do that by then.

    Good luck to you.

    594:

    I "wasn't living up to my potential" is from teachers the equivalent of "you need to lose some weight" from a doctor.

    For me it was mostly true. I peg the ADHD meter. Which means I'm easily distracted. When I paid attention I'd get nearly perfect scores on tests. But a bird flying by would get me looking out the window most of the time.

    Once when 10 or 11 I got to reading ahead in a book and then noticed it was quite and everyone was writing. There were like 3 points on the board of what we should mention. I glanced at the person next to me and saw the story he was writing about and did the same. After it was over and I had written about a story I really didn't care for I discovered we were supposed to write about our favorite story from a group of 4 or 5. Oh, well.

    All of this made more interesting growing up in a small enough area that some of my teachers had known my parents since before they married. As adults or had grown up with them.

    595:

    Listing to a panel discussion on WWII in the Pacific. In terms of counterfactuals someone in the audience asked:

    If the USS Maine doesn't blow up in Havana Harbor, do the Japanese attack Franco's fascist fleet in Manila?

    596:

    JBS @ 578: So, what are YOU doing about it?

    I'm a UK citizen living in the UK, so unfortunately I'm not in a position to do anything. Sorry about that.

    You might find this story about a Danish politician going to prison inspiring though. Pity it won't happen to Priti Patel.

    At least I'm not even theoretically eligible for citizenship anywhere else, which increasingly puts me in a privileged class.

    597:

    I didn't explicitly say so earlier but my transplant assessment was conducted by a practicing transplant surgeon who basically said "never mind what your BMI is; you're fit enough for practical purposes".

    598:

    Just 'cause they do something in Florida doesn't make it Constitutional.

    Again, this is an unnecessary (and somewhat misdirecting, bad-faith) step along the road to saying whether a thing is right. To be clear, whether a thing is supported by the US constitution or is not says nothing at all about whether it is a good thing. The US constitution is only relevant in terms of US legal questions. It doesn't supply any ethical argument: ethical argument helps us to judge it. Mostly when we judge it we find it severely wanting. Can I make it any clearer than this?

    599:

    Yes and no. I agree with your analogy. In the absence of concrete reasons for saying it, it's a cop-out (as is the converse). The data show clearly that there are several other important factors, and that fitness is far more important than excess weight; lockdown, self-isolation etc. have NOT helped.

    It depends on why a person's weight is high (BMI has other defects, too, such as being inaccurate for short and tall people). If it's abdominal fat, then the GP may have a point; if it's bone and muscle, then not. I hit 85 Kg at 1.86m, and they said it was fine, but losing 8 Kg has been beneficial (I am light-boned).

    600:

    "By the way, the problem you are alluding to with General Relativity: would that be people doing numeric modelling on boundary-value problems with boundary conditions that are discontinuous? ... The difference between the closed-form solution and the numeric solution was about 10%. Apparently a well-known problem in numerical analysis."

    Yes. You can have an analysis that apparently stays away from the boundary, but is implicitly dependent on continuity where there is none. 10% is a small error in this context. I was thinking of things like Tipler cylinders, which are of that class; whether the Alcubierre drive using the Casimir effect is another, I can't say.

    I agree that conditional probability is not obvious; I didn't find it hard but, then, I was a mathematical statistician. However, it requires thinking in very different ways from those even most scientists and mathematicians are used to.

    601:

    Perhaps I should have added that I had rickets as a baby and was severely underweight until my 20s (I don't know why); that is why I differ from OGH, you and Greg. The dustbowl remarks are extreme, but childhood nutrition and other factors control how heavy people's bones and muscles are. Exercise and diet in adult life make very little difference to either.

    602:

    Kardashev: Booked to take the descendants (carnivores all) to the local churrascaria a week from now for pre-Xmas, but not sure it will be prudent to do that by then.

    My advice: cancel it.

    The reason can be found in this graph of case incidence in London -- the curve rises so sharply you can't even see it, it's basically turned into a vertical line in the past week.

    This strain shows explosive replication. (Recent reports suggest it's about 70x more efficient at infecting bronchial tissue than delta.) As testing lags new infections by a few days and weekly reports lag by 2-3 doubling periods, it is already much worse than you think.

    And a churrascaria sounds like the perfect environment for spreading omicron -- lots of people with open mouths, waiters walking around and getting up close behind your shoulder, open plan seating indoors, no real possibility of distancing.

    If you were under-50 it might be worth persisting -- your family, your value call -- but if you're over 75 then in your shoes I'd be locking down the hatches right now.

    603:

    As back-up to Charlie:
    Put Worldometer UK" into google, then look at the daily case graph. - It's almost vertical.
    The GOOD NEWS is that this rate will infect anyone who is going to get it & then burn itself out in less than a month ...

    604:

    And the bad news is we have no reason to believe this strain won't leave the same legacy of long covid behind as all previous strains.

    Worst case for the UK would be: it infects or reinfects everyone and leaves 10% of the population -- 6.5 million -- crippled for months to years afterwards.

    605:

    Plus that it may well not be less serious than delta in the middle-aged or elderly (*), and that we don't know how soon you can be reinfected.

    (*) The evidence from London hospital admissions indicate that it probably isn't. As someone of 74 with breathing problems, it may well be my Grim Reaper - which I would prefer to serious long covid.

    606:

    On a (personal) good news front, I was finally able to get a booking for my booster — Christmas Day at a community centre in Toronto. No idea whether this is a new set of openings or why the provincial system finally decided I was eligible (earlier it was telling me I wasn't even though I was).

    Still gonna keep trying to find something sooner/closer to home, but at least I have something this year.

    607:

    I'm seeing vague reports that, although omicron is 70x more efficient at infecting bronchial tissue, it's significantly less efficient at infecting the alveolar walls. So a much worse throat infection but less damage to the lungs.

    If true, this is really good news (at least, in terms of demand for ICU beds/body bags).

    608:

    Interesting. Thanks very much. Yes, that's good news generally. As my problems include minor bronchiectasis as well as slightly collapsed lungs, it's mixed news for me personally ....

    609:

    Re: '... although omicron is 70x more efficient at infecting bronchial tissue, it's significantly less efficient at infecting the alveolar walls.'

    Please elaborate, ideally with illustrative examples, because my mind's picture of this process is: more O2-grabbing cells dying faster therefore O2 insufficiency therefore moot point whether there's still some down-the-road/biochem reaction chain operating. Not being rude just really want to understand why you judge this situation a lower risk. Thanks!

    The piece below came out in July 2021 (pre-Omicron) - figured you and other folks here might be interested since there's on-going discussion about assessing one's individual risk.

    https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-01773-7

    'Human genetic variants identified that affect COVID susceptibility and severity

    An individual’s genetics can influence their risk of infection and the severity of disease symptoms. A large international study has identified parts of the human genome that can affect the risk of severe COVID-19.'

    For quantum theory and math/stats fans (open access)*:

    https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-04160-4

    'Quantum theory based on real numbers can be experimentally falsified'

    • Looking forward to the plain-language explanation in the ensuing discussions.
    610:
    wasn't living up to my potential

    Sounds like you needed to take the Career Aptitude Normalizing Test1, or C.A.N.T. for short. "Some of you might find some wonderful vocation you never even imagined. Others may find out that life isn't fair."

    Maybe you missed your calling along the way?

    ~oOo~

    1 Link goes to a Simpsons YouTube video.

    611:

    Re: 'No idea whether this is a new set of openings or why the provincial system finally decided I was eligible (earlier it was telling me I wasn't even though I was).'

    I was checking on availability of boosters in the GTA (my sib lives there) and came across this story. Hopefully Metrolinx (owned/operated by the Prov Gov't) will get this sorted out - fast!

    Okay - I can understand that the field workers are by now so overworked that they don't have time/energy to read a gazillion email alerts - but their supervisors probably do and should pass on relevant info during their start-of-day briefing. Actually, given how fast the present situation is changing, maybe multiple quick briefings each shift/day should be the new norm.

    https://toronto.citynews.ca/2021/12/15/ontario-resident-denied-booster/

    612:

    There was another case where someone in their 70s was less than six months, but more than 168 days, out from their last shot and they were denied it on-site because the worker thought the key limit was six months going by calendar dates. (I'm getting my booster 180 days after my second dose, but less than two full calendar months. Hope that doesn't happen to me!)

    I think the government should just stick to days rather than using months as well, as it is just causing confusion. (And you can't blame that on changing directives, just sloppy wording.)

    I had better luck with the provincial site than individual pharmacies etc. The Thorncliffe community centre clinic had openings for Christmas day as of an hour ago. All other sites I could find in Metro were booking into January and February.

    Good luck on your search.

    613:

    Please elaborate, ideally with illustrative examples, because my mind's picture of this process is: more O2-grabbing cells dying faster therefore O2 insufficiency therefore moot point whether there's still some down-the-road/biochem reaction chain operating.

    The study showed Omicron infects the tubes carrying air 70 times more, but the alveoli where gas exchange happens 10 times less. This might explain it's higher contagiousness (we're shedding more virus) but (apparently, maybe) lower per-case lethality.

    The Omicron Covid variant has been found to multiply about 70 times quicker than the original and Delta versions of coronavirus in tissue samples taken from the bronchus, the main tubes from the windpipe to the lungs, in laboratory experiments that could help explain its rapid transmission.

    The study, by a team from the University of Hong Kong, also found that the new variant grew 10 times slower in lung tissue, which the authors said could be an indicator of lower disease severity.

    https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/dec/15/omicron-found-to-grow-70-times-faster-than-delta-in-bronchial-tissue

    615:

    Without bothering to decode it in detail, all it shows is that the currently most popular formulation (Hilbert spaces) needs complex numbers. As it says, there are other formulations that don't. A huge amount of both mathematics and physics has multiple equivalent formulations, sometimes based on different fields. See, for example, the following:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quaternion#Quaternions_in_physics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Octonion

    Complex numbers are just the natural extension of the reals to include (say) the solutions of polynomials. I have no idea why some people seem to think that the reals are any more 'real' than the complex numbers.

    616:

    Oh yeah.

    https://arstechnica.com/science/2021/12/officials-trying-to-contact-all-53k-anime-convention-attendees-in-omicron-probe/

    Wasn't meaning to say the convention wouldn't be a spreader event, but rather whether it is to blame for the current case count in NY and NJ.

    It won't have helped, but given how quickly it is spreading elsewhere in the world it is doubtful that a convention, as bad as it would be, is anywhere close to being the primary cause.

    617:

    On a (personal) good news front, I was finally able to get a booking for my booster — Christmas Day at a community centre in Toronto. No idea whether this is a new set of openings or why the provincial system finally decided I was eligible

    Glad to hear, likely something new that was created - someone had an article yesterday on how Ottawa's health unit was scrambling to set up clinics and other non-pharmacy options with the current race to get a 3rd dose into people.

    618:

    The U.S. curve isn't that bad yet, (keeping in mind that any number of Republican governors are lying about their state's numbers) but I think it's only a matter of time... I am soooo cutting back on my activities.

    619:

    The problem is, the omicron curve is more like a vertical line than a curve. My wife and I booked flights and hotel rooms on December 15th in anticipation of a winter trip to Germany. Then omicron arrived and we cancelled the trip on December 6th. It is now the 16th, omicron is the dominant strain (having swamped delta) and infections are now at an all time peak despite vaccination (and booster shots) also being at an all-time peak (and considerably ahead of the USA).

    Right now the Scottish government is screaming at London to release funds for furlough and lockdown payments, but London, in the person of Clownshoes Churchill, isn't listening: if Scotland was fiscally autonomous we would already be in lockdown.

    Anime NYC 2021 happened at the Javits Center in NYC on November 18-22 and appears to have been an omicron spreader event.

    Upshot: I think you're probably 2-6 days behind the UK -- two weeks at the absolute maximum -- but with a more susceptible population (especially in red states).

    Reasoning by analogy, I expect the saner parts of the US to be doing the furlough/lockdown tapdance by the end of December unless evidence confirms that omicron morbidity/mortality is significantly lower than for previous strains (and long covid incidence as well).

    620:

    Here are today's graphs - look at the London cases and admissions (deaths will take a week or so to show up). It's also not good news for those of us in Cambridgeshire. But you can expect the figures for the whole of the country to look like that in or before January :-(

    https://imgur.com/a/jeBWVE2 https://imgur.com/a/X8uqbcU

    621:

    Yeah, we're not remotely close to the "vertical line" yet here. I'd also guess we're 10-15 days behind the U.K. The problem for me is that I've been unable to get a booster because I've been sick bronchitis. I'm currently on antibiotics and hope I can get a booster in the next few days.

    622:

    Disclaimer: I know what imaginary numbers are, and I have an idea about why they're useful in quantum physics.

    That said, I think there's something unspeakably cheerful, in the Lovecraftian pseudo-physical sense, about the non-local part of reality requiring an imaginary dimension to exist. It's an excellent bit of misinterpretation to hang some magic and parallel fantasy dimensions on.

    623:

    Charlie
    Yes - I have said before that I was prepared to take my chances with C-19 itself, especially as I'm now triple-vaccinated, but "Long Covid" gives me the creeps, so I'm doing my best to avoid it, by avoiding infection.
    Not going to pubs, only going into necessary shops, whilst wearing a mask, getting outdoor exercise ( allotment) 2 or 3 times a week, keeping the viricide/bactericide intake ( CH3CH2OH ) up in the form, mostly, of white wine. Don't intend to get on public transport until 5th January & maybe not then .....

    624:

    Re: '... whilst wearing a mask,

    Suggest that you upgrade your mask too - see if N95s are available in your area.

    I'm also switching back to ordering online and picking up at the curb or shopping first thing in the a.m. where car pick-up isn't available.

    625:

    Not N95, that's a US standard; over here it would be FFP2 (very slightly weaker) or FFP3 (more efficient).

    626:

    Yes. I think that even the most cynical epidemiologists are amazed at its explosive growth; all now depends on how serious an infection is. It's scary, in at least a 1665-6 sense.

    627:

    Ottawa Public Health has ordered all hands on deck to man the vaccine clinics. So that means new early morning and evening time slots have appeared at their existing mass vaccination clinics (usually Indoor hockey rinks). By the way, the local Loblaws pharmacy was booking vaccine appointments for January 5th.

    628:

    Just got boosted. Yay Moderna. Now I get to find out if I'm a member of the annoying side effects club or not. Hopefully my membership in that group gets rejected.

    629:

    602 Para 2 - I thought you knew better. The "vertical line" is at least partly an artefact of the the poster's chosen X (time) scale. "Doubling every 2 days" is more like a slope of 0.5, and not an asymptote to the Y (cases) axis.

    630:

    I assume my readers are capable of checking the scale and min/max markers on any graph I link to?

    Doubling every 2 days is indeed terrible -- this one's coming at us far faster than any previous wave.

    631:

    By the way, the local Loblaws pharmacy was booking vaccine appointments for January 5th.

    My local pharmacies have a wait list only, or not even that. The two I was able to talk to say they are out of vaccines and won't take more bookings until they get more supply, and they don't know when that will be.

    I'm anticipating a rerun of the original vaccination screwup, where the GTA had more supply issues than the rest of Ontario. I don't know if GTA residents are better at uptake, or if the allocation isn't strictly by population.

    (I do know that a lot of provincial allocations are more by geographic region than population.)

    632:

    I think there's something unspeakably cheerful... about the non-local part of reality requiring an imaginary dimension to exist.

    A little over 30 years ago I had a short story published where the protagonist travels to an imaginary landscape on a bus with a complex route number. It was only in a university poetry magazine that I don't think has ever been digitised, and while I'm sure I've still got a copy somewhere it would require a search. Anyway it was of the form X+Yi, where X and Y were well-known local route numbers. At the time it seemed like a joke that some people would get, and as you say, in a cheerful mode.

    633:

    When I was a final year physics undergrad in the 1990s and everyone was punch drunk with revision a hugely elaborate poster appeared advertising a bus trip to reciprocal space.

    I didn't go because all the phonons made it quite noisy.

    634:

    Not eligible for booster till next year and I strongly suspect omicron will be on us before then. I'm expecting authorities here to take it less seriously due to vaccinations, so the gap in efficacy with and without the booster is an especial risk. Sigh.

    635:

    It's unquestionably happening a LOT faster than the delta or VUI-21OCT-01 variants, but we don't have enough good data to be sure of the doubling time yet. 2 days is possible, but so is 3 days. It doesn't make that much practical difference.

    636:

    Boosted a month ago (Moderna). Oregon's 211 telephone bank made it easy to find a site for Jab-3. Herself (<65) has an appointment for her booster two days before Christmas, as soon as permissible. Both of us use P100 filters on 3M 6200 half-face respirators https://www.3m.com/3M/en_US/p/d/v000057395/ & safety glasses w/ side shields when we go out, which is damned seldom. P100 respirators cost <25 American pesos each w/ two pair filters and more comfortable to wear, with the very greatly appreciated benefit of being 6.67X protective to us than FFP2 or N95 masks, as per https://microcovid.org

    637:

    https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1A3apMX4HVC1z6LWbUMWE-46VX9ROCPlp/edit?usp=sharing&ouid=117896955502397650801&rtpof=true&sd=true shows a projection of Delta vs Omicron infections. Plug in your favorite values for R and days-to-double.

    638:

    Eligibility is fluid. I wasn't eligible until January until I suddenly was. Eyes peeled for panicked rule changes.

    639:

    Yep. Ontario just halved the wait time between second and third doses. Which has just slammed the system, as there apparently aren't actually any more vaccines than there were before they made the change. Hopefully your government is handling it better.

    (Or maybe the problem is Ford is slamming Toronto. Canadian Conservatives have form for pandering to their rural base and dumping on areas that don't vote for them. (The G20 being a good example.)

    640:

    630 - I agree in principle, but I figured out the likely actual slope from anecdata, not from the picture (I refuse to call that a graph) on @rsebook.

    632 - That's actually an interesting idea. Have you ever read "A Subway Called Mobius"?

    635 - Agreed. My serious point was that Charlie has linked to a scary picture, not to a usable graph.

    634 & 638 - Second dose was in mid-April; in mid-October I received an appointment letter for mid-November, and attended at that time. If current rules had applied at that time I'd have had my booster around my birthday rather than "just in time for Omicron".

    Anecdote - As some of you may remember I am a haemodialysis patient. 2 days ago a senior nurse at the unit asked some of us some "additional Covid questions". One of which was "Have you been abroad in the last 10 days?" My response was "What idiot told you to ask dialysis patients that?" Her immediate response was The additional questions have been dialed back to "Do you or anyone you know have Covid symptoms?"

    641:

    Reasoning by analogy, I expect the saner parts of the US to be doing the furlough/lockdown tapdance by the end of December unless evidence confirms that omicron morbidity/mortality is significantly lower than for previous strains (and long covid incidence as well).

    My guess is no, due to a lack of support from the Federal level, because the Democrats can't get anything through the Senate.

    The idea of paying people to stay home when a large part of the US has been convinced by business/media that worker shortages is because the Covid benefits are too generous means attempting to get any budget measure to restart this process through Congress is (sadly) a long shot - though I will be very happen to be proven wrong.

    642:

    Re: '... don't have enough good data to be sure of the doubling time yet. 2 days is possible, but so is 3 days. It doesn't make that much practical difference.'

    Agree - just read that the UK reported more than 88,000 confirmed Covid cases today with case numbers doubling every two to three days.

    643:

    Charlie Stross @ 586: I "wasn't living up to my potential" is from teachers the equivalent of "you need to lose some weight" from a doctor. It's a generic nostrum designed to make the recipient feel vaguely guilty and thereby submissive towards professional authority, but it seldom means anything -- "living up to potential" in an educational role simply means you aren't jumping through the arbitrary hoops used as a definition for success (which seldom bear any resemblance to an actually useful life skill), and the recommended weight targets are based on BMI, which is a measure of statistical distribution in a population rather than a target for individual health: as a target they're borderline malnourished for anyone growing up in the developed world since 1920.

    I think there was a large increment of "sit down, shut up and stop asking so many awkward questions!" involved. I had several teachers who had taught my father and made a point of telling me I wasn't working as hard as he had.

    Many of the others knew my father through his work & the civic organization he belonged to. It was as bad as being a preacher's son ... or worse, 'cause the preacher's kid only had to endure it on Sundays.

    Plus my father was appointed to the School Board while I was in elementary school and became Chairman of the School Board just before I began High School. Anything that displeased my teachers, I was going to hear about it when he got home from work.

    644:

    Ottawa Public Health has ordered all hands on deck to man the vaccine clinics.

    This article indicates a similar thing in Hamilton, where they are closing community centres and some other local government facilities to repurpose those staff to working vaccine clinics

    https://www.thestar.com/ths/news/hamilton-region/2021/12/16/covid-hamilton-closures-latest-news.html

    It also notes (and potentially worthwhile advice to anyone in the GTA struggling to get vaccinated) for people to keep trying each day as they add capacity to the vaccination effort.

    Of concern though are the 2 sentences I have quoted below (which they don't give a reference for so accuracy is unknown)

    "The severity of Omicron is unclear, but early Danish data suggests it’s the same as previous strains."

    "The modelling also notes hospitalizations, occupancy in intensive care and deaths are rising in South Africa."

    645:

    Re: '... worker shortages is because the Covid benefits are too generous'

    Can't find the article but recently read that over 70% of the people who left their jobs in the last couple of years (when Covid started) are in the 55+ age group - mostly early retirees. Further, although in pre-Covid days some retirees did go back to work on a part-time/semi-permanent basis, that's not happening now. A double whammy to the available workforce numbers.

    The upside to this is that the younger age cohorts have a greater number of job openings available therefore as per market rules: employers now have to compete for employees. (Seems that some employers are having a problem understanding this.)

    646:

    Kardashev @ 592:

    "I fear this is the winter I get covid... I am boosted, as of the middle of last month, but still. I confess to being kinda scared. We're now shutting down the bits of normal life we've been enjoying for the first time in 20 months just about..."

    Us too. We're boosted, but ~75 YO and the stats for > 65 YO aren't encouraging. Booked to take the descendants (carnivores all) to the local churrascaria a week from now for pre-Xmas, but not sure it will be prudent to do that by then.

    Good luck to you.

    What I understand from the news is people are likely to get the Omicron version even if they are vaccinated, but if they ARE vaccinated (especially with the third shot booster) it's likely to be not so bad. You're less likely to die from it.

    Am I being over optimistic?

    I'm able to stay inside at home most of the time, only going out to shop for groceries, walk the dog or go to doctor's (& dentist) appointments ... and walking the dog I don't encounter too many people I can't stay 10 feet or more away from them. I ordered a package of new N95 masks yesterday. Someone in a Zoom meeting recommended them that they fit real well around the nose & won't cause your glasses to fog up as badly as the regular disposable surgical masks do.

    647:

    Here in BC I just received notice that as a front-line adjacent health(ish) worker I am eligible for the booster. Sometime in the next few weeks I'll get the nod to make an appointment, but it really doesn't look like we are getting them soon enough.

    Political reality being what it is in our various democracies, it would take Ragnarok itself for an elected leader to initiate a lockdown before Christmas, and even then it would have to be one of that person's last acts in government.* However everyone feels about the actual science and what is needed, a government that forces people to cancel Christmas will be punished.

    As it is we are hearing our leaders try every method they can think of to imply that we should not travel to visit family over the holidays, without actually saying it or imposing any policies to that effect. 'Avoid non-essential travel and gatherings' as opposed to 'stay the fuck home'. Last night a friend of mine quite emphatically defined his planned trip to Mexico in February as essential.

    • I would love to see an elected leader come out and say something along the lines of 'This is a crisis that is more important than my career. I will put everything I have into helping resolve it, and then on resolution of that crisis I will resign. I will not make decisions based on electability but rather on what has to happen.' The closest I know of was LBJ refusing to run for re-election during Vietnam, but it is a bit of a stretch.
    648:

    Paul @ 596:

    JBS @ 578: So, what are YOU doing about it?

    I'm a UK citizen living in the UK, so unfortunately I'm not in a position to do anything. Sorry about that.

    You might find this story about a Danish politician going to prison inspiring though. Pity it won't happen to Priti Patel.

    At least I'm not even theoretically eligible for citizenship anywhere else, which increasingly puts me in a privileged class.

    I might go to jail if they make it against the law to protest against stupid shit like that. I don't think they will.

    ... or by the time they do the country will already be lost.

    649:

    I'm probably not on those numbers but I was at Novacon 50 and tested positive for COVID after, as did my friend who was also there. And he went home and his wife got it. Fortunately none of us seem to have had it too bad apart from my sense of taste not having having fully returned yet. Then my niece went to a concert in Glasgow and tested positive after and also spent ten days in self-quarantine. So after 18 months I went from not personally knowing anyone with COVID to having it and three people I know.

    650:

    Damian @ 598:

    Just 'cause they do something in Florida doesn't make it Constitutional.

    Again, this is an unnecessary (and somewhat misdirecting, bad-faith) step along the road to saying whether a thing is right. To be clear, whether a thing is supported by the US constitution or is not says nothing at all about whether it is a good thing. The US constitution is only relevant in terms of US legal questions. It doesn't supply any ethical argument: ethical argument helps us to judge it. Mostly when we judge it we find it severely wanting. Can I make it any clearer than this?

    Can I make it any clearer that I think you ARE arguing in bad faith. Criticize us, but criticize us for what we are NOW, not for what we were once upon a time.

    651:

    JReynolds @ 610:

    wasn't living up to my potential

    Sounds like you needed to take the Career Aptitude Normalizing Test1, or C.A.N.T. for short. "Some of you might find some wonderful vocation you never even imagined. Others may find out that life isn't fair."

    Maybe you missed your calling along the way?

    ~oOo~

    1 Link goes to a Simpsons YouTube video.

    I already knew life isn't fair, otherwise why wasn't I born rich as well as good looking?

    I will admit I still haven't figured out what I want to be when I grow up.

    652:

    Plus my father was appointed to the School Board while I was in elementary school and became Chairman of the School Board just before I began High School. Anything that displeased my teachers, I was going to hear about it when he got home from work.

    Now the reverse holds — anything that displeased you, your teachers' principal would have heard about the next morning.

    653:

    in pre-Covid days some retirees did go back to work on a part-time/semi-permanent basis, that's not happening now

    I got called last week asking if I would go back. Not bloody likely when the school board prohibits N95 masks, is still obsessed with surfaces and droplets, and tells teacher to turn off air filters while teaching because students say the noise bothers them.

    So yeah, the plague is areal disincentive to go back to other than remote work — and they insist that remote teachers* will still have to show up to a school and teach from a classroom (and be available for on-call classes, so still have an in-person component).

    So students can opt for remote, but staff must be in-person.

    *If they have them next semester — they are still timetabled for mixed remote and in-person students in a single class.

    654:

    I already knew life isn't fair

    As does Eric Bogle:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wBMv_HFkA30

    * Bloody Markdown. Pasting URLs is more work than it used to be.

    655:

    My father was a teacher in my school. He was a good teacher, but was very strict. Of course the knuckle dragging brigade couldn't do anything to him...

    656:

    Bah - if I can put up with the horrendous pain, gross inconvenience and indeed literal torture of wearing a mask for minutes at a time, you can jolly well put up with using Markdown.

    657:

    [ "Anime NYC 2021 happened at the Javits Center in NYC on November 18-22 and appears to have been an omicron spreader event." ]

    Not "appears." It was a major spreader event. Not only did it bring the first detected omicron infections to NYC, but it was spread throughout the USA in the same way Alpha and Delta were from the tens and tens and tens and tens of thousands attending the annual Sturgis Motorcycle meet-up in South Dakota back in the Julys of 2020 and 2021.

    658:

    I'm somewhat relived that my 80yo mother got her booster this week, as I expect that Omicron will breach the NZ border sometime this summer (probably in the next few weeks). I am strongly encouraging her to stay with us rather than alone in her house in a small down after she visits other family post-Xmas.

    659:

    I got called last week asking if I would go back. Not bloody likely when the school board prohibits N95 masks, is still obsessed with surfaces and droplets, and tells teacher to turn off air filters while teaching because students say the noise bothers them.

    My wife just turned 65 and was "forced" to retire last year. And is very bored. She has mentioned getting certified as a substitute teacher. I haven't said much but for reasons similar to yours I'm not so sure this is a good thing for a while yet. And our school district (one of the largest in the country) is requiring masking, vaccines, and testing in classrooms and sports. Much to the displeasure of the some parents and our state legislature.

    660:

    Can I make it any clearer that I think you ARE arguing in bad faith. Criticize us, but criticize us for what we are NOW, not for what we were once upon a time.

    So for when your back comes back down, understand: I'm not criticising "you" (meaning Americans) at all (in general), but I'm complaining about the subset that treats certain legal documents as quasi-religious sources-of-truth around the US national foundation stories, and bringing that up in general discussions about ethics. What I am saying is that doing that isn't a useful contribution, inside or outside the USA (but it's especially irrelevant outside). I'm explicitly not saying these are bad documents or bad things to believe in, but I am putting a brick wall between that and the extension that they have some bearing on a general moral case.

    It might be hard to follow as a general statement, so for a specific example: I and many others think it's a bad idea for the general population to be heavily armed. The US constitution has zero relevance to whether it's a bad thing for the general population to be heavily armed, both where I live, which is obviously not in the USA and also in the USA. Once you have decided, by means of valid criteria, such as mortality statistics and ethical arguments, whether you think it is a good or bad thing for the population to be armed, then if you live in the USA you might use the US constitution in pursuance of your preferred policy, but that is completely different to arguing about whether it is good or bad. Legal documents are ethically neutral, in respect to the fact they serve a policy: they have no bearing on whether the policy is a good policy or a bad one. If you treat them otherwise, you're working in some kind of enclosed reality.

    661:

    Can I wet myself laughing?
    N Shropshire, oh dear how terribly sad ....
    Only two problems.
    1: What head-banging moronic tosser are they going to pick as not-quite-yet-fascist party leader next?
    2: I heard Ed Davey on the radio, STILL appearing to rule out even an unofficial pact with Labour to get these arseholes OUT at the next election.
    Is it something in the water or what?

    662:

    checking the scale and min/max markers on any graph I link to?

    Speaking of vertical lines, Chris Billington has just revised hist scale on the "daily cases in NSW" so it goes to 75,000. New cases per day. {gif of Moz shitting his pants}. He posts a couple of nice graphs every day for NZ and some states in Australia (I suspect based on availability of data).

    The official government policy in Australia seems to be "let it rip", NSW removed most restrictions yesterday and a a lot of contact tracing efforts have stopped (shops are removing the QR codes that let us choose to trace). The local big box hardware chain had "freedom day" BBQs in many stores. Should have been "One Thousand Cases Per Day, Day"

    https://www.reddit.com/r/CoronavirusDownunder/comments/ri1s0i/nsw_r_eff_as_of_december_17th_with_daily_cases/

    (sadly image embedding straight from reddit only allows a 1330 pixel wide one and I think that's a bit large)

    663:

    Dammit, checked everything except the link.

    Reddit post with graph

    Also, I am currently in week two of being miserable after going camping and sharing the tent with at least one tick. I found one attached in the morning, but had 20+ bites. Lethargy, headaches, a lot of brain fade. Plus the horrible transition from an hour or more of aerobic exercise a day to lying round the house feeling gross... with leg cramps, swelling and general lack of exercise malise. Luckily after a few days I could get back on the bike, but the first day back I walked about a kilometre and had to stop for a rest mid-walk. Ticks bites are officially no fun{tm}

    Doctor said "yeah, if symptoms persist for six months let me know", ordered generic blood tests and it turns out I'm low on B12, so I am getting shots of that. But allegedly that's very ulikely to be tick related (I stopped getting B12 and iron tests when I started eating meat again... apparently oops)

    664:

    The Lib Dems are who temporarily-embarrassed Tories vote for, once. If the Lib Dems, famously Coalition supporters of the Cameron government and enablers of Brexit even looked like they would consider supporting Labour in any way, their total vote and number of MPs would drop precipitously next time round as the Tory scum rally around their next firm-smack-of-Government leader to keep that radical commie socialist Starmer out of Number 10.

    665:

    Tick bites are minor in themselves (I have had many hundreds), but they carry some very nasty diseases. You might like to get a second opinion.

    666:

    it turns out I'm low on B12

    An elderly relative of my wife had B12 deficiency around 30 years ago, but her doctor just put it down to old age. By the time her son demanded a second opinion and a test got done the dementia was irreversible.

    B12 deficiency isn't that common, but its so serious, and so simple to test and treat, that you don't want to skip it.

    667:

    Nojay
    A very unfunny rant, I'm afraid, though you have the Murdoch "Scum" headline pitch-perfect. But, there are a lot of "left" tory voters, who are increasingly pissed-off with Bo Jon-Sun & his clique.
    In the meantime, the important thing is to get them OUT & worry what to do next after that. The perfect & the pure is enemy of the practical & good enough. We MIGHT even get electoral reform (!)

    668:

    You might want to check for Lyme disease, your symptoms align and ticks are a known vector

    669:

    I got my third jab on Tuesday, and have been haranguing my coworker and friends to get it this week. A friend's analogy was; if delta is a steam roller leveling your house, then omicron is a 747. In Aus I feel that there is a week sometime in mid Jan where about half the country will be out on sick leave, dying or dead. But we're committed to never locking down again, so go good on all those strong politicians for not being all flip floppy and bowing to the pressure of experts.

    670:

    644 - Where I live, one of the community centres is the vaccination centre!

    647 - You think so!? We had a lockdown starting on Dec 26th 2020, and the government that ordered it were returned with an increased majority on 6th May 2021. Of course, Scottish politics are affected by the Bozo factor.

    660 - The US Constitution generally, and the 2nd Amendment in particular, are used not to defend the nation, but to defend the profits of armament manufacturers.

    671:

    There aren't a lot of "left" Tory voters, the last General Election proved that if it really needed proving. There are some folks who are occasionally embarrassed at what the Tories they elect do when in power and some of them will, for an electoral cycle or two, not vote at all or perhaps vote Tory-Lite Lib Dem since they're Nice People Like Us, mostly although they aren't quite, well you know...

    Once the embarrassment wears off they will vote for Boris and Patel and all the Right People again. They will never vote for the commie socialist murder-us-in-our-beds let-the-immigrants-in tax-raising hairy ultra-Marxist lefties like Starmer and Creasey, ever.

    672:

    You think so!? In West Dunbartonshire there was a swing from Con to Liebour which is almost exactly the size of the Liebour MSP's majority over the SNP candidate.

    673:

    Last night a friend of mine quite emphatically defined his planned trip to Mexico in February as essential.

    If we're all lucky, omicron will have burned out by then.

    If he's lucky, he'll still be alive and fit to travel by then.

    In which case I guess he deserves his vacation (but wait: where's Mexico going to be at with omicron by then?)

    674:

    The newly passed UK law on citizenship removal isn't new, it just means the Home Office doesn't have to notify the victim, it just cancels their passport at will -- and I don't think there's an appeal process.

    It's a Crime Against Humanity to render someone stateless, but their theory is that if the target is theoretically eligible for citizenship in a second state then they're not doing that.

    They got press/public support by targeting Shamina Begum, who admittedly did something Very Stupid. (But: mitigating factor, a sixteen year-old girl who'd been systematically groomed and got suckered into the Islamic State broodmare/handmaid lifestyle and pregnant before she was 18? If you remove the "butbutbut she's an ISIS sympathizer" from the equation it's a much uglier picture of the state picking on a victim of organized child abuse.)

    But now, I can be stripped of my passport on Priti Patel's whim, because I grew up Jewish (bar mitzvah and all) so I am in theory eligible for an Israeli passport under the Law of Return. (Not that I want a passport from an apartheid state, but ...)

    And my wife? Turns out her mother was naturalized as a Canadian, briefly, aged 2, so under current Canadian law my wife just needs to fill out some paperwork and she can have a Canadian passport. So she can be deported too! (Never mind that her grandmother -- from Manchester -- returned to Manchester when her mother was 2, and mum-in-law didn't even discover her Canadian status until she was in her 60s and got hauled aside by Immigration when visiting on a package tour, she was using "the wrong passport", i.e. her British one.)

    Upshot: if Priti Patel has a snit my wife and I can be stripped of our citizenship and deported in opposite directions, 8 time zones apart! And we were both born in the UK, as were our parents and most of our grandparents.

    675:

    Bloody Markdown. Pasting URLs is more work than it used to be.

    You can still use HTML. If the URL is correctly tagged (<A HREF="some.url">link text</A>) Markdown won't mess with it. You can even mix and match in the same comment!

    676:

    The Englandshire Tory voters determine who gets into Number 10 since they are the clear majority of voters in the UK. Note that I said "voters", not supporters. Once one gets to a Certain Age, married and with children that are in a decent school, proud owners of a 30-year mortgage, on the ladder for promotion at work and having drinkie-poos with the upwardly-mobile neighbours who are in the local constituency Tory party, then it becomes a natural thing for an ex-Socialist Worker Party flag-waver to vote Toey for their own current best interests and fuck the poor.

    Scotland is different, there are still a lot of Tories around but the SNP have done a fine job of marginalising them to the point where none of them actually got elected by ballot in Scotland in the last election, having to rely on the list process to get any MSPs at all. What's even more impressive the SNP have not gone down the Tartan Tory route unlike Starmer and co., they've carved out a Socialist option for Scotland that the Tories have not been able to demonise like they did with Corbyn and the national Labour Party in the past.

    677:

    What head-banging moronic tosser are they going to pick as not-quite-yet-fascist party leader next?

    I'm calling it for PM Priti Patel. If not the next leader, then the one after that.

    Other candidates for the next leader are, obviously, Rishi Sunak (he's a billionaire mammonite), Liz Truss (she's stupid enough to take the job, not realizing what a poisoned chalice it is: second-rate Thatcher cosplayer, basically), Michael Gove (who has the redeeming feature of not being entirely stupid, but appears to be on the out with the Bozo-led faction), and the Emperor Dalek ("bzzzt! Strong and Stable! Strong and Stable! Juche Britannia! Juche Britannia! Exterminate the Remoaners!" -- that's all a leadership candidate has to say to get the head-bangers on their side).

    PS: there is never going to be a Rainbow Alliance to get the Tories out. Labour will never, ever, sit down with the SNP (they consider the SNP an existential threat in Scotland) so that's 54 seats written off before we're out of the starting gate. The LibDems don't want an alliance with Labour -- they learned in 2010-2015 how bad coalitions are for them -- they want to replace Labour as the main opposition. And there's a bunch of bien-pensant wishy-washy types who are more obsessed with knifing each other on the back and climbing to the top of a pile of corpses than with, like, building a viable coalition: starting with the entire Labour front bench, unfortunately. And the Greens are a very long shot in England (as opposed to Scotland, where they're part of the government).

    678:

    The SNP might, just might, agree a confidence-and-supply deal with Labour but they wouldn't join a UK Government coalition as junior partners since their focus is on Scotland. Such a deal would come with the absolute requirement for IndyRef2 though.

    I'm not so sure that the LibDems wouldn't support the Tories again though if some inconsequential Cabinet posts were offered up. It's been, what, over six years since they were bent over a barrel and buggered bloody by Cameron and co. and if the NuTory leadership promised not to do it to them again pinky-promise well, it's worth considering... (these are LibDems we're talking about after all, not the sharpest bowling balls in the bag).

    679:

    Nojay
    YOU DO REALISE that Ms S Creasey is almost a neighbour of mine & that I know her mum, personally? And I always vote for her ....
    since they are the clear majority of voters in the UK - They WERE in 2019 ... now? ....
    Later...
    Libs got so shafted by the tories last time, they would require a written promise of 2 things: Real electoral reform & "closer to Europe" ( Single Market/Customs Union )

    Charlie
    Patel - not this time, because of the way the selection process works. Agree about the long-term threat, though.
    I do hope you are wrong about Lib/Lab, but suspect you are not. The Greens are almost as stupid as the tories ( Nuclear Power )

    A bleak midwinter, indeed.

    680:

    644 - Where I live, one of the community centres is the vaccination centre!

    Likewise. of course, I can't get a booking there, so rather than a three minute walk I've got to drive for over an hour in a week. (But at least I'm getting a booster, so shouldn't complain.)

    647 - You think so!? We had a lockdown starting on Dec 26th 2020

    You're in Ontario? That's when our's started. Apparently Ford was not gonna be the premier who cancelled Christmas, so we had the expected spike as people mixed inside in close proximity with multiple households, because the government didn't say it was a bad idea…

    681:

    Bloody Markdown. Pasting URLs is more work than it used to be.

    You can still use HTML.

    I know. But I used to just paste the URL on its own line, so it was visible and not hidden behind a link. Now I have to remember to put it between paragraph tags so it doesn't get mangled.

    My complaint is mostly that it's a poor design specification. Enough websites use underscores in their URLs (eg. Wikipedia which predates Markdown) that the specification should have not applied text formatting to lines starting with "http".

    682:

    677 - According to Liebour, the SNP are THE existential threat, not just in Scotland but to the UK as a whole.

    678 - Well, I think Ed Davy might, repeat, might have learnt something from the ConDem coalition, when Scamoron managed to make it look like almost everything was their fault. Certainly wee Nic and Ian Blackford will have learned stuff from being ConDUP.

    680 re 647 - I did not say that, and, indeed, am in Scotland rather than Canada.

    683:

    No. Not if the text I saw is correct. Yes, you can be made stateless at whim, but that's under the OLD law, and the new law merely means they don't have to tell you.

    The new law also targets people like me, who were born abroad but have no right to ANY other citizenship, nor ever have done. Oh, yes, THEORETICALLY it doesn't, but given that the criterion is just that the Home Secretary claims that it believes I have such an option, there is no appeal, and they are proposing to abolish judicial review over govenment actions, ....

    https://nigerian-constitution.com/chapter-3-section-25-citizenship-by-birth/

    Furthermore, in the current political climate, you are a long way further down the likelihood list of being rendered stateless than I am. After all, nothing would show that these laws are being applied fairly (in a racial discrimination sense) than including someone like me (white, well-off, 'middle class' etc.)

    PP stands for political pox.

    684:

    On UK citizenship revocation law: it might help to understand this law if you know it was originally passed in 1914 in response to the start of WW1. There was massive anti-German sentiment in the UK. Anyone of German extraction or having dual citizenship with Germany was interned, quite possibly after being fire-bombed out of their homes. I don't know of any cases of actual lynching, but I wouldn't be surprised. So one of the things the government did was grab the power to revoke the citizenship of anyone who was considered by the Home Secretary to have helped Germany.

    Since then no government has bothered to revoke this power; why get rid of it when it might come in useful?

    685:

    The official government policy in Australia seems to be "let it rip", NSW removed most restrictions yesterday and a a lot of contact tracing efforts have stopped (shops are removing the QR codes that let us choose to trace). The local big box hardware chain had "freedom day" BBQs in many stores. Should have been "One Thousand Cases Per Day, Day"

    So there was a plan - Freedumb Day - for "vaccinations are in full-swing," then the virus did whatever it wanted to. Will people fucking ever learn?

    686:

    We've got a spare room if you need it. (You're highly unlikely to have problems with U.S. immigration for all the obvious reasons.)

    687:

    Going back to the header subject.
    The number of cases per day is now well up over all previous, but the death numbers are still down in the "only" 100 per day or lower. A lot of that is down to multiple vaccinations, improved knowledge of how the virus kills or disables people & better/more appropriate drugs, of course.
    But - provided omicron isn't actually deadlier, I can see why some sections of guvmint want to leave things as they are ( I don't agree with them, incidentally ).
    It now appears that something like 16% of the population have, or have had, some form of C-19. Sooner or later, it will run out of people to infect, unless, of course it continues to mutate. But, omicron is apparently so infectious ( R ~= 5 ? ) that any other variant is not going to get a look in, not in the near future, anyway.
    Make of that what you will.

    688:

    Not surprising, DisCon / World Con announces first detected attendee as positive.

    http://file770.com/postive-covid-test-at-discon-iii/

    689:

    That is wishful thinking, at best, and wrong at worst. We simply don't know yet.

    As I have posted before, the data clearly show that cases, admissions and deaths are each separated by about 2 weeks. As it was first detected in the UK on November 14th, we would expect to see the first deaths round about now - which is what we have done. We won't have any significant data on actual deaths until the new year.

    The gummint changed the format last week, and again this week, so my scripts don't work. Normally, I don't bother to update until they have had at least 2 weeks with similar formats, because it's a pain in the neck (like the gummint itself).

    690:

    the death numbers are still down in the "only" 100 per day or lower. A lot of that is down to multiple vaccinations, improved knowledge of how the virus kills or disables people & better/more appropriate drugs,

    Nope, you're jumping to conclusions.

    COVID19 typically takes 9-11 days to turn serious enough to justify hospital admission, then takes another 10-30 days to kill. We won't see an upturn in deaths before roughly day 20 of the Omicron wave, which began on or after November 15th (I don't recall precisely when, but it was clearly going to hit hard by the end of November). We're only 31-32 days into it, at most. The infection rate is rising on a steep exponential, starting from near-zero on November 15th: only single- to double-digit people were infected in the first 5-10 days.

    So we have no way of knowing how bad it's going to get for another few days. (It should be becoming clear by this time next week.)

    Positives: we have a largely vaccinated population, which cuts down on mortality and severe disease, and an increasingly rapidly boosted population. In most folks with boosters omicron presents a bit like a bad head cold rather than the wheezing death plague of 2020.

    Negatives: nobody under 12 is fully vaccinated and schoolkids are disease spreaders. Of the 12-18 cohort, many are not yet fully vaccinated, nor are they boosted. And there are a number of 18-40s who think they're immortal, plus vaccine-hesitancy among ethnic minority communities, especially in London. And it's winter. Bad year to have a heart attack, stroke, or be diagnosed with stage III/IV cancer ...

    Finally: omicron appears to dodge immunity acquired from a previous alpha, beta, or delta infection. In other words, it can reinfect you.

    691:

    The daily number of deaths in the USA alone this week is 1,285. Where in heck is that under 100 number coming from?

    https://www.kff.org/coronavirus-covid-19/issue-brief/global-covid-19-tracker/

    Deaths in UK are 115 -- as of today. Tomorrow will be higher, judging by the incredible rapidity of new infections galloping through the populations.

    Health care systems cannot handle this.

    692:

    Next week is too early, for deaths at least, but we should have some data on admissions. Yes, most people have little trouble, but most people didn't with delta, either.

    It's irrelevant why it's bad news for me personally, but a lot of the excess deaths are non-COVID, caused by the NHS and care limitations caused by COVID. If I stop posting, you will know why ....

    693:

    Healthcare systems would have been hard-pressed to handle this back in March 2020, even if they'd had full foreknowledge and the inventory of treatments and PPE and the mostly-vaccinated population we now have: right now they've been run ragged, about 30% of healthcare workers are planning to quit in the near future, equipment is overworn too, hospital admins teeter on the edge of bankruptcy, there's a huge backlog of serious cases to catch up with in the absence of COVID, and burnout is a pressing concern.

    This is what comes of trying to organize healthcare along "free market" lines (yes, even in the UK -- the Tories are doctrinaire free marketeers who want to privatize/outsource everything they can).

    694:

    Good luck with that.

    (I'm staying in as much as possible between now and next Tuesday -- then ideally for another 2 weeks -- as my wife hasn't had her booster yet: that's Tuesday morning and it can't come soon enough. We should both be covered, at least insofar as one can be, by January 6th. But even then I won't be hanging out in pubs, coffee shops, restaurants, or shopping malls until the current storm front has passed. Back to April/May 2020 lockdown for me! Sigh.)

    695:

    Kingston Ontario region had zero deaths from Covid in 2020 and handled Covid reasonably well - until now.

    Today Kingston has the misfortune to lead Canada in the number of Covid cases with 471/100k, almost twice as many as the 2nd place location in Quebec.

    The numbers are so high they also exceed the case rate seen in any area in Canada since Covid began.

    https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/ottawa/kingston-health-unit-highest-covid-19-case-rate-canada-1.6288819

    696:

    Thanks. Socially, I am better off, being a solitary person with a large house and garden, and my normal behaviour is close to lockdown. I still hope to visit the Western Isles in April, but it will be mostly solitary triking. My wife is a lot less happy.

    In the past year or so, I have had it drawn to my attention just how much of the NHS has already been privatised. What I don't know is what proportion of its budget goes on 'outsourcing'.

    697:

    Omicron has taken over in Ontario in the last week.

    Daily case counts:

    Dec 10: 1453

    Dec 11: 1476

    Dec 12: 1536

    Dec 13: 1429

    Dec 14: 1808

    Dec 15: 2421

    Dec 16: 3124

    In histogram form:

    Dec 10: -----------------------------

    Dec 11: ------------------------------

    Dec 12: -------------------------------

    Dec 13: -----------------------------

    Dec 14: ------------------------------------

    Dec 15: ------------------------------------------------

    Dec 16: --------------------------------------------------------------

    Nothing to worry about. Nosiree.

    (Last week I was thinking: we're going to be averaging 3000 cases or so by Jan 1st. How optimistic I was.)

    698:

    Some good news: Newspaper reports (in the Independent) suggest that booster shots stimulate B- and T- lymphocyte responses much faster than the initial vaccination shots -- 2-3 days for a notable effect, 7 days to maximum effect. (This assumes AZ initial shots and a different booster. The Israeli experience used three shots of Pfizer and took somewhat longer, up to 2 weeks for maximum effect.)

    So I may not have to hunker down after Christmas.

    699:

    Aaaargh!!!

    Sorry, needed to vent. Got an email today cancelling my booster appointment, because apparently someone in Waterloo entered my health number for a booster given yesterday, so the provincial system thinks I've already got it and don't need it. In the several days it may take to sort this out (including the weekend) I've lost my spot in the queue, and may have to wait until February.

    REALLY not happy right now!

    700:

    Never fear. At least people in Europe are protected against harmful 5G signals. Radiation burns not withstanding.

    https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-59703523

    My brother sent this to me as we share another brother whose clan very likely has purchased similar things. (They don't worry about Covid-19 as it is all a hoax.) I know my mother would buy similar if still alive. And sent them to us to make sure we would be protected.

    Major huge sigh.

    701:

    What that article conspicuously fails to explain is why. Have the things been made from contaminated material or did some knob actually put radioactive stuff in them on purpose? Does the sales blurb make any mention of it? And how radioactive actually are they, compared to something like a banana?

    703:

    Pigeon & David L
    If anyone brings one of those into the UK there WILL BE TROUBLE ... Import of unlicensed radioactive materials .... arrrggghhh!
    I mean W.T.F??

    The level of suicidally-stupid involved in this makes my head hurt.

    704:

    I was informed yesterday that I was eligible for an 'early' booster due to my job. Today I got an appointment, Jan 4th. I'm currently 2x Moderna, no idea what the booster will be.

    Today the BC government announced some significant restrictions. No sports tournaments effective Monday. No organized New Years parties or other gatherings. No gatherings with unvaccinated people.

    That last is going to make things interesting, as my BIL has morphed into a vocal antivaxxer, in a family of people who are not that stupid. MIL, who wants what she wants, is likely to try to get us to stay at his house again next week, which is not going to happen. Much drama is likely to ensue.

    705:

    The brother I mentioned a couple of comments up will likely never speak to me or the other brother again. We are now evil for believing that Covid-19 is real. Plus not believing Trump is the savior of the USA. [wave a flag or two here]

    706:

    wave a flag or two here

    I'm trying to work out what flag Trump would actually use. Any vexilloligcal meaning is clearly out because that's the domain of those awful experts, so I'm guessing it would just be a small "Made in China" label in one corner of a red flag?

    707:

    Robert Prior @ 652:

    Plus my father was appointed to the School Board while I was in elementary school and became Chairman of the School Board just before I began High School. Anything that displeased my teachers, I was going to hear about it when he got home from work.

    Now the reverse holds — anything that displeased you, your teachers' principal would have heard about the next morning.

    That might be generally true nowadays but I don't think it would apply ME. Seems like it was pretty much given around my house that if a teacher complained, I was in the wrong. My father wouldn't have bothered asking for my side of the story, and if I had insisted on telling it he would have just ignored what I said in my defense.

    709:

    That might be generally true nowadays but I don't think it would apply ME. Seems like it was pretty much given around my house that if a teacher complained, I was in the wrong.

    Your father was a different generation. Nowadays everyone knows that the kids of trustees and board members need to be treated with kid gloves. "Keep extensive documentation, cover your back, and when possible let them get away with it" is pretty much what I've seen.

    I know dealing with administrator's kids was always fraught, because if they disagreed with your decision they knew just which levers to pull to get revenge.

    710:

    Eler @ 668: You might want to check for Lyme disease, your symptoms align and ticks are a known vector

    IIRC, Lyme disease doesn't exist in Australia; it mostly occurs in the northern hemisphere. Might be some other tick borne disease, but Lyme disease is unlikely.

    711:

    Charlie Stross @ 674: Upshot: if Priti Patel has a snit my wife and I can be stripped of our citizenship and deported in opposite directions, 8 time zones apart! And we were both born in the UK, as were our parents and most of our grandparents.

    "Patel" doesn't sound like an ancient Anglo-Saxon or Norman surname. She could end up "hoist on her pwn petard"

    712:

    IIRC, Lyme disease doesn't exist in Australia; it mostly occurs in the northern hemisphere. Might be some other tick borne disease, but Lyme disease is unlikely.

    Quick search reveals your correct, but also turned up this Australian Government website about a possible unknown tick born disease like Lyme

    https://www1.health.gov.au/internet/main/publishing.nsf/Content/ohp-lyme-disease.htm

    713:

    so I'm guessing it would just be a small "Made in China" label in one corner of a red flag?

    Of course not. It would be a true 50 star 13 stripe USA flag[1]. They ARE the true patriots. The believers in, and defenders of, the Merican system.

    [1] Most likely made in Pakistan. That's where most of the flags in the US are made. As people trying to buy flags found out just after 9/11. This may have changed by now.

    714:

    https://lymedisease.org.au/ claims Lyme disease is in Australia, but not officially recognised. The big symptom we're told to look out for here in Canada is a bull's-eye rash. https://www.canada.ca/en/public-health/services/diseases/lyme-disease/symptoms-lyme-disease.html

    My MIL had the rash some years ago after being bitten by a tick, went to the doctor right away, and got a fairly simple course of antibiotics. It seems like it might be worth following up on, just in case.

    715:

    I think I have a dry socket where I had those teeth extracted last Friday. That's the only reason I can think of why the pain is so persistent even after I've taken STRONG painkillers.

    I believe I have a high tolerance for pain and a low threshold for the effectiveness of pain killers. The label directions say "take one tablet every 4 - 6 hours for pain" and one is usually enough. It will put me on my butt for 24 hours and the pain will usually be gone by the time I regain consciousness. I took one last Friday after I got home from the dentist and don't remember much until Saturday afternoon.

    Since then, I've been taking 1/2 tablet at bedtime and sometimes taking the other half when I get up in the morning. The pain had been getting better until yesterday when it got worse kind of all of a sudden. The pain got so bad today I took a whole tablet a couple hours ago, but it doesn't seem to have had much effect. I'm still in pain and it hasn't even made me sleepy.

    Otherwise, today has not been a good day.

    I have Windows 10 set up (according to Micro$oft's instructions) so that it is NOT supposed to download any updates without my permission. But sometime last night it downloaded an update anyway.

    Today I was locked out of my computer for 8 hours because it would not accept my PIN number - the PIN number I wrote on the wall so I would NOT forget it. So, they're going to email me a verification code ... except I don't have that email account on any other computer except for the old computer this computer replaced.

    When I dug that one out and connected it it had a boot failure. I booted from the Windows Repair disk I created on that computer and it told me it was the wrong version of Windows, even though it's the repair disk I made ON THAT COMPUTER, from the Windows 7 installed there.

    I think it might be an artifact from the failed windoze10 upgrade. Somehow when I reverted to Windows 7 it didn't revert to the original installation, so now it doesn't recognize the repair disk.

    I've got the original installation disk somewhere, it's just a matter of finding it and hope I can install Windows 7 without destroying the original installation.

    I had to get my laptop out & recharge it enough that I could sign in to it and I was finally able to log in to webmail to get the code.

    So now all I have to do is figure out how to make Windows 10 behave properly, reinstall Windows 7 on the old computer, figure out how to add yahoo mail to my laptop.

    Not going to install Linux on any of these machines, Photoshop does NOT run on Linux and Photoshop is the only program I actually NEED. All the others are nice to have and it's a pain when they don't function properly, but Photoshop is my WORK program ... and fuck Lightroom and fuck the cloud!

    716:

    An obituary. I didn't know the woman, but I wish I had. I hope I can go to the memorial service when they hold it in May 2022:

    https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2021/dec/16/obituary-viral-renay-mandel-corren-texas

    https://www.fayobserver.com/obituaries/m0028451

    717:

    "Not going to install Linux on any of these machines"

    No, but you could run it off a live CD and use it to back up the data off your Windoze filesystem in case you fuck up trying to reinstall Windoze.

    Sudden increase in pain in your tooth socket suggests to me that something undesirable has happened to cause it, so it may be a good idea to have it looked at.

    718:

    What I get from that article is that they contain small amounts of materials of igneous origin, which as such things tend to do contain trace amounts of U and Th, and so fall foul of radiation limits which are already known to have problems with some ordinary rocks. Still not clear about why, especially in the case of that pink rubber thing which doesn't seem to have any call for such mineral ingredients.

    719:

    What I get from that article is that they contain small amounts of materials of igneous origin, which as such things tend to do contain trace amounts of U and Th

    But that's natural radiation, so it must be good for you.

    720:

    No, but you could run it off a live CD and use it to back up the data off your Windoze filesystem in case you fuck up trying to reinstall Windoze.

    This is a very good idea. You can also run Linux off a live USB stick.

    721:

    Reply to self & Charlie, further back up ...
    It seems ( Headline in this AM's "FT" ) that omicron is, or easily could be, as dangerous as delta.
    So it seems Charlie's pessimism was correct - especially given that the doubling time appears to be 3 days, or even less.

    Pigeon
    "That pink rubber thing..." - - the mind boggles

    722:

    704 - 2 x Moderna make me think your booster will be Pfizer. Reasoning being that they don't seem to be using Astra Zenica for boosters, and also don't seem to be using 3 shots of the same vaccine.

    710 - AIUI that's correct, I presume because the vector, ticks, don't migrate.

    723:

    Re: 'MIL, who wants what she wants, is likely to try to get us to stay at his house again next week, ...'

    I'm guessing she's a DT fan. Maybe BC will get hit with a major snow storm.

    724:

    Re: 'ticks, don't migrate .'''

    But their hosts do and migration patterns are changing.

    'Poleward Expansion of the White-Footed Mouse (Peromyscus leucopus) under Climate Change: Implications for the Spread of Lyme Disease'

    https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0080724

    There's also been mention about migrating songbirds and changes to their migratory routes therefore new pests showing up in different areas ... but I don't remember where I saw it.

    725:

    That's terrible, but it doesn't sound inconsistent with the regular symptoms directly associated with paralysis tick bites, especially if you got a substantial dose of the toxin. Of course there are some nasties going around with tick bites, mainly bacterial infections, some of which are quite serious. There's also a recently described syndrome where you become allergic to meat(!). All this and more appears in the handy federal department of health factsheet:

    https://www1.health.gov.au/internet/main/publishing.nsf/Content/ohp-tick-bite-prevention.htm

    726:

    Are you suggesting that live sheep migrate!?

    727:

    Given that it tends to be fairly rare where it exists and how difficult it is to identify (the blood tests are expensive and seriously unreliable), the maps of where it occurs and where it doen't are largely fantasy.

    For example, its absence from almost all of Africa is probably because nobody bothers about such a minor disease there.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tick-borne_disease

    728:

    Yeah. Someone doesn't need to make a fuss about curling causing cancer from exposure to the stones. But I keep expecting it ....

    729:

    My daughter had 3 x Pfizer.

    730:

    Re: 'live sheep migrate!?'

    Thanks for the laugh!

    Maybe not willingly or under their own power like other hosts.

    But there are feral sheep in Australia like the 6-year old (Baarack) that was found and shorn this year. They removed 35 kgs (77 lbs) of wool off him. No mention of how much of that was ticks - they might not have looked.

    731:

    "Patel" doesn't sound like an ancient Anglo-Saxon or Norman surname.

    Her parents were part of the Ugandan Asian community deported to the UK in the 1970s by Idi Amin. Anti-black racism is consistent with that history ...

    Historical back-story: the British Empire had a standard method for administering conquered territories. They'd ensure that the geographical boundaries of each administrative region held two ethnic groups, plus the colonial administrators. The larger ethnic group -- say, 70-80% of the population -- would be exploited for agriculture/mining/raw material provisions, and paid taxes. The smaller ethnic group had a relatively privileged position below the colonial administrators: they'd be used as footsoldiers, tax collectors, servants for the British colony administration, low-level bureaucrats. Some of them would even get professional training as doctors and lawyers, depending on how the colony was run. Obviously, they had a vested interest in propping up imperial rule -- they were relatively privileged, and the 80% majority saw this and hated them for it. So it became a self-perpetuating system. Finally, on top of the pile was a roughly 1-2% of British colonists who ran everything and could call in troops with machine guns.

    Problem: what do you do in a colony where your own (British) personnel get horribly sick from tropical diseases, and the locals don't have an elite/higher caste tribe you can use as a proxy?

    Answer: you ship in members of a successful 20% group from somewhere else in the empire, handing out real estate grants in return for service. Which is how Uganda ended up with an Asian professional elite who kept things running for the British ... until independence, at which point the British (and their machine guns) disappeared, and they discovered that being rich foreigners in a former colony was not great.

    The not-great aspect was maxed out in the early 1970s when Idi Amin seized power and ran a viciously racist campaign against the Asian community, who were forced into exile. And that's where Priti Patel's family history comes in: Patel is a Gujurati surname etymologically descended from a title meaning "landowner" or "chieftain", and her ancestors were colonial administrators. While a large number of the Ugandan exile community returned, evidently her family chose not to: there's probably a story there.

    732:

    That is a very one-sided view, and isn't really correct in this case. There were a lot of 'Indian' immigrants who came as independent traders, and I am pretty certain that they were the main source of the 'Ugandan asians'. In particular, Uganda was never a colony (it was a protectorate), and the British involvement was very different.

    Before 1900

    After 1900

    733:

    You missed Idi Amin's explicit deportation of the Asian population in 1972?

    734:

    Not in the slightest. I was in Uganda shortly beforehand, and some of the young 'asians' were asking me what discrimination was like in the UK, because they were thinking of coming here. And I remember the disgraceful behaviour of Wilson in changing the citizenship rules to stop them having automatic right of entry, which was the first step towards where we are today.

    What I was saying was that almost all of what you posted did not apply to Uganda, and was largely inaccurate when applied to most of the rest of Africa. In particular, her grandfather was an independent trader, NOT a colonial agent, as were so many 'asians' in Africa:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Priti_Patel#Early_life

    Answering the original question, as the current politics goes, it depends on whether her father had obtained full British citzenship by the time she was born. If not, she COULD theoretically be rendered stateless under existing law.

    735:

    722: It will be Moderna or Pfizer. I'm pretty sure BC has discontinued the use of Astra Zeneca after the 'furore' over blood clots.

    723: She is not a DT fan at all, quite progressive in general. On a global scale she is very concerned about all the things (climate, pandemic) and votes accordingly. On a personal scale she has trouble seeing why those things should affect her family or choices.

    736:

    Re: '... deportation of the Asian population'

    She's one crappy deal for the UK. When Zanzibar kicked out Asians/Indians you got Farouk Bulsara (Freddie Mercury).

    Queen - Don't Stop Me Now (Official Video)

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HgzGwKwLmgM&ab_channel=QueenOfficial

    Great song for that extra burst of speed when finishing your exercises in the a.m.

    737:

    Re: 'On a personal scale she has trouble seeing why those things should affect her family or choices.'

    Guess she's got an unpoppable magic personal bubble. Good luck - it's hard to argue with magic.

    Mag1c bubble$ are a kid's toy ... except their bubbles pop.

    738:

    Charlie Also, it wasn't "just" racist ... Idi also pushed islam, hard, & the Ugandan Asians were all sorts of religions, but ( usually ) not muslims. I've run into several Parsees from that community, in the past.

    739:

    Still not clear about why, especially in the case of that pink rubber thing which doesn't seem to have any call for such mineral ingredients.

    If I'm misreading your comment, sorry.

    This necklace is a grifter's income maker for hawking to the ignorant and crazy. Or one of the ingnorant and crazt folks marketing it to their tribe. The more various "exotic" (to them) bits you put into such things the more marketing nonsense you can make up to explain the need. After all we're warding off 5G radiation without a Faraday cage.

    If my mom was still alive she'd order 20, intending to give them to all her relatives and friends. And then get mad when we say no. Then after she dies, we find them and dozens of other not science based nonsense as we clean out the house. And when I say dozens I mean the plural use of the word.

    Welcome to the second half of my 2014 year.

    740:

    Sort of like Melania Trump's parents being naturalized while Trump and his minions ranting about how we must stop chain migration.

    741:

    Idi was Trump only 40 years earlier.

    742:

    Her parents were part of the Ugandan Asian community deported to the UK in the 1970s by Idi Amin. Anti-black racism is consistent with that history ...

    Which I first encountered in this film:

    https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0102456/

    (1991's Mississippi Masala.)

    Which I remember as being good, but can't speak to modern tastes.

    743:

    Well, got up at 5AM today to go to popup clinic in Mississauga — so two hours driving each way, plus 3 hours standing in snow and 20km/hr winds — only to be told that I will not be given a booster until Waterloo Public Health fixes their mistake. Confirmed they don't work weekends by calling WPH this afternoon, as clinic manager told me I should contact them directly. Apparently every shot has to be entered into a government database and it won't accept me as I've 'already had one' as far as it knows.

    Except it's all "leave your name and number and someone will call you back," so I'm tied to the phone until they call, with no promise of when because "things are busy" and "it's Christmas".

    Scream.

    744:

    Maybe it's time to hire a lawyer?

    745:

    Re: 'Apparently every shot has to be entered into a government database and it won't accept me as I've 'already had one' as far as it knows.'

    This doesn't make sense as in: surely they check more than one data field when verifying patient info/identity! Apart from your medical/health card number, there's your name, address, phone number, DOB, etc. plus photo IDs (driver's license).

    After you've sorted this out and gotten your booster consider writing to the Ministry - sloppiness in a universal healthcare system is dangerous.

    746:

    Robert,

    Do you have any anti-vaxxer friends? ;)

    Of course that'd illegal.

    So, for a more acceptable course of action, can you contact your political representative? And then a local or national news organization?

    747:

    This doesn't make sense as in: surely they check more than one data field when verifying patient info/identity!

    Apparently there is someone in Waterloo with a "very similar name" and almost the same birthday. At least, that's what the woman from my health region told me.

    Gonna contact my MPP's office on Monday and ask them how to best go about getting this resolved, and ensuring that it doesn't happen again.

    According to the woman who turned me away from the vaccine clinic, this happened to someone on Monday as well. I think part of the problem is looking up name and birthday of people who forgot their health cards, and not being careful as they try to go fast.

    Or maybe identity theft. Will also see if I can get a look at what's actually in the database about me, to verify that it's actually me. Wouldn't want someone else's medical information being used to treat me.

    748:

    "This necklace is a grifter's income maker for hawking to the ignorant and crazy."

    Yeah, that's the point though. The people who buy it will never know the difference, so why should the people who make it bother putting anything "exotic" in it at all, when it's so much easier just to lie about it? After all the entire "function" claimed for the thing is a lie to begin with, so I can't see the minor increment in mendacity being a noticeable deterrent.

    The black pendant thing does at least look as if it might be made of resin-bonded pulverised quarry waste such as is often used for making ornaments, but the cock ring has no such excuse available. Surely it would be far easier and more profitable just to buy a consignment of cock rings from the factory and put them in packaging that calls them something different, than to make something which actually is different yourself and then still have to package it the same way.

    Same kind of thing with people who sell powdered rhino horn as an aphrodisiac or whatever it's meant to be. What the fuck is the point of going to all the trouble and danger and expense of cutting the real horns off actual rhinos, when you could achieve exactly the same result by powdering up the crap the local abbatoir can't even use for burgers? (I'm guessing that's what it smells like; if it doesn't, pick some other kind of rubbish.)

    749:

    So todays Omicron headlines look less cheery

    The UK doesn’t see evidence (so far) that Omicron is any milder

    Hospital rates are starting to spike in London

    I think the best metric to track at this point is hospital occupancy in London but having some issues tracking a reliable daily source of that

    https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2021/12/18/omicron-variant-spread-in-london-hugely-concerning-mayor-says

    750:

    The people who buy it will never know the difference, so why should the people who make it bother putting anything "exotic" in it at all, when it's so much easier just to lie about it?

    Probably something to do with labelling laws. If you say that your product has xxxx in it, it had better contain some.

    If you phrase your ads correctly your claims about effectiveness will come under trade puffery and be allowed (because no reasonable person would consider them true) but claims of containing an ingredient are different.

    So I can call my cereal the "best cereal in the world" and be OK, but if I say it "contains hazelnuts" and it doesn't, I'm guilty of misleading advertising.

    751:

    The UK doesn’t see evidence (so far) that Omicron is any milder

    Last night my sister (Alberta paramedic) told me you don't need a booster, and that Omicron is just a cold and nothing to worry about. Think I'm gonna have to start discounting her medical opinion about Covid — she's deep in the Alberta information ecosystem and it's clearly not science-based.

    752:

    Re: '... contact my MPP's office on Monday and ask them how to best go about getting this resolved, and ensuring that it doesn't happen again.'

    Good luck - hope you get this resolved quickly. There are slews of folks across ethnicities with common names, i.e., Smith, Lee, Roy, McDonald, Singh, etc. so it's not as if this wasn't an unlikely possibility hence the multiple data fields. (Wouldn't have guessed Prior was part of that set.)

    Yeah - that suite of scenarios did pop to mind.

    753:

    Same kind of thing with people who sell powdered rhino horn as an aphrodisiac or whatever it's meant to be. What the fuck is the point of going to all the trouble and danger and expense of cutting the real horns off actual rhinos, when you could achieve exactly the same result by powdering up the crap the local abbatoir can't even use for burgers? (I'm guessing that's what it smells like; if it doesn't, pick some other kind of rubbish.)

    It's allegedly a febrifuge, among other things.

    Rhino horn's supposedly just keratin, so a bunch of nail clippings would be hard to distinguish through bulk chemistry. Structurally, though, it's more like plastic (IIRC there's a hot wire test to see if something like an old knife handle is rhino horn).

    I agree that it's an expensive placebo, where the expense is driving the effect. I wish people would just powder gold and leave the rhinos alone. Or take an aspirin if they have a fever.

    754:

    The people who buy it will never know the difference, so why should the people who make it bother putting anything "exotic" in it at all, when it's so much easier just to lie about it?

    To pile on to Robert P's comment, most of the people buying this stuff and many of them selling it (lots of multi level) here truly believe in these things. So they expect it to contain what it says it contains. And the labeling likely doesn't claim much past what it contains. The rest of word of mouth.

    Like horse de-wormer.

    755:

    Robert: Sounds like another example of the 'distrust the population syndrome so often in effect with governments, and particularly conservative governments. They are very worried about someone getting an extra dose, so they put policies in place to ensure that doesn't happen.

    The policies are hasty or sloppy, so a few people get blocked from a potentially life saving dose. But, key point, nobody can claim they are giving out doses willy nilly, so whatever your personal outcome it is a win from a politico/bureaucrat perspective.

    See also: Means testing for any kind of subsidy for anything at all. You must abase yourself before your kids can play soccer/access the pool/get a library card without paying! Also related, expensive and intrusive processes to root out 'welfare fraud' that usually find very few actual fraudsters while costing millions to complete. 'We spent $10 million to root out $500 in fraud, but nobody is going to leech off our taxpayers by god!"

    It is not a rational process or perspective, but it is common.

    756:

    Edit: 'distrust the population syndrome'

    757:

    C-19
    Comparitive Statistics available here - - if the "your area" section comes up blank, type "Waltham Forest" - the Lond. Borough in which I live & you'll get my local data.
    Note the low numbers - we have silent anti-vaxxers, probably religious/ethnic based. Darwin will catch up with them.

    Rbt Prior.
    Your sister is, at the very least, badly misinformed. How you try to persuade her otherwise could be - difficult.

    758:
    I agree that it's an expensive placebo, where the expense is driving the effect. I wish people would just powder gold and leave the rhinos alone. Or take an aspirin if they have a fever.

    But gold is useful -- and harmless.

    Could I humbly suggest depleted uranium?

    759:

    "Could I humbly suggest depleted uranium?"

    For people involved in trading endangered species? Definitely, though powdered plutonium might be quicker.

    760:

    Update:
    Oh Shit
    Two articles worth a terrified read: Serious computer security threat in Java, of unknown proportions - because everyone cut-&-pastes ... Apparently, the Bad GuysTM are already using this ...
    For the second one, use an incognito window - it's from the "Atlantic" ... "Are we DOOMED"? - visualising the disintegration of the USA in 2024-5

    761:

    Re: Waltham Forest

    That's a really low vax rate so I checked the demos for that area - see below. Skews very young so some of that unvaxxed head count could be too young to have qualified for a vax? (Over here we got the news a few days ago that infants can get vaxxed. Not sure what the UK policy guideline is on this.)

    https://www.walthamforest.gov.uk/council-and-elections/about-us/statistics-about-borough

    'Waltham Forest has a younger than average population with 28 per cent of residents being aged 0 to 21 ... There are proportionately fewer people aged over 65 living in Waltham Forest (11 per cent) compared to ... the UK average (18.5 per cent).'

    Anyways - stay safe, stay indoors!

    762:

    It is not a rational process or perspective, but it is common.

    It's perfectly rational when you master the art of not looking shifty while claiming those fraud investigation agencies "create jobs" to deal with the "problem". It's just one of the many back doors by which the avowedly non-Keynesian conservatives implement Keynesian stimulus, but limited to benefit their friends and fellow travellers. And one of the reasons why conservatives are inherently corrupt, at least the way it works over here.

    763:

    For people involved in trading endangered species? Definitely, though powdered plutonium might be quicker.

    Uranium and plutonium are annoying to carry around. I'd suggest MPTP instead, possibly injected in a single, large dose.

    764:

    SFReader @ 745

    This doesn't make sense as in: surely they check more than one data field when verifying patient info/identity! Apart from your medical/health card number, there's your name, address, phone number, DOB, etc. plus photo IDs (driver's license).

    In Ontario the modern health card is the number, name, DOB, issue and expiry dates and a photo (and I think there are still some of the old red health cards in circulation that are just a number and name, which technically you need to show photo id for but for a vaccine clinic they may not request).

    So no address or other personal info.

    Rocketpjs @ 755

    Sounds like another example of the 'distrust the population syndrome so often in effect with governments, and particularly conservative governments. They are very worried about someone getting an extra dose, so they put policies in place to ensure that doesn't happen.

    Nothing so sinister (well, at least directly).

    The main thing at the moment is that the system is tracking your vaccination shots for the vaccine passport system used for going to a movie, public events, eating at a restaurant, etc (you can login to the government website and download a QR code).

    The secondary thing is tracking things because we are an imaginary line away from a country that has a health care problem, and as a result Ontario had/has a fraud problem with Americans and potentially others using a health card to illegally get free healthcare.

    https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/red-white-health-cards-ontario-cancelling-1.5128983

    (not a real issue with Covid vaccines as they are typically free in the US, but the system remains set up to worry about the issue)

    765:

    I can see that. Especially with folks living just across the border in places like Niagara, Detroit, Vancouver, etc. And even more so if they have friends or relatives on the "other side" so they can have a mailing address that fits.

    766:

    Those vaccination figures are shockingly low compared to South Norfolk’s 90%/67%/52% figures even allowing for the older population. Are people rushing to vaccination centres?

    767:

    (Over here we got the news a few days ago that infants can get vaxxed. Not sure what the UK policy guideline is on this.)

    You sure about that?

    Just this week Pfizer announced their clinical trial on 6-month to 5 year olds had to be changed from 2-dose to 3-dose because 2 doses wasn't generating the necessary immune response, thus delaying their application to the relevant authorities from about now to sometime first half 2022.

    https://www.npr.org/sections/coronavirus-live-updates/2021/12/17/1065200225/pfizer-third-dose-covid-vaccine-infants-young-children

    768:

    https://api.coronavirus.data.gov.uk/v1/data?

    But decoding that needs some complicated scripts, and the documentation is, as you might expect, confusing.

    769:

    734 - Couldn't happen to a nicer person. (OK it could, about 60 million of us ;-) ).

    745 - I can't speak for Ontario, but in Scotland they only actually checked our CHI number.

    770:

    SFR
    Thanks, I'd forgotten that - quite a lot of people have moved here in the past 20 years, when it was "cheap" & are raising families - not "cheap" any more of course ... ( I've been here all the time ... )

    Mike Collins
    Yes - every time I go past a vaccination centre, there's a queue.

    771:

    I forgot to mention, but it's delayed by a few days - however, I am pretty sure that the figures you hear on the media are, too, except where they are guesstimates.

    772:

    In Ontario the modern health card is the number, name, DOB, issue and expiry dates and a photo

    Also has a number on the back (like the CVC number on credit cards) for use as an extra authenticator online. Also has a scan code on the back.

    But at the clinic today the young lady with the iPad wasn't scanning, she typed in the number (with cold and shaky fingers). So I could see the mistake, although they are supposed to check that.

    My guess is a careless entry and another Robert Prior in Waterloo, born close to my birthday (or in the same year). That's what the woman from YPH implied, although she didn't tell me much because of patient confidentiality. I suspect the woman at the province probably shouldn't have told me the doctor's name when she was reading out the date and time the dose someone else got was administered — I think she was half talking to herself.

    773:

    If you're comfortable with Python there is an open-source, pip-installable Python package provided by PHE that consumes the web API, and which includes basic documentation and examples.

    It's about 5 lines of code to get things into a Pandas dataframe, and I'd include the code but the blog's Markdown flavour doesn't seem to support display of code.

    I've been reasonably impressed with the data governance of the UK Coronavirus dashboard - it looks like the developers behind the site are using modern standards and generally trying to do things right.

    774:

    Plutonium can also be tricky to ship in bulk.

    775:

    About a year ago the HD failed on my hosted server and the hosting company gave me a new server instead. The KVM functionality for the new server (ie. that which lets you get at the screen and keyboard remotely and independently of the server itself being working, so you can still try and fix it even if it won't boot) was said to use the same protocol as it did for the old one... but when I tried to use it with the same client, it didn't work. Turned out the new one was using a butchered version of the protocol, and neither the hosting company themselves nor any reference at all that I could dig up on the internet at large could give me the slightest hint as to what client did work with it beyond the one universal recurrent answer: use this one particular unique client, which is written in Java.

    It seemed to baffle them entirely to find that they were dealing with someone who didn't have Java installed and didn't want to install it "because it's too much pain and grief" (I spared them the detailed rant about it being a pile of oozing turds writhing with maggots from top to bottom). They couldn't understand how anyone who worked with internetty stuff could not have it installed, and I think they thought I was very weird for so persistently badgering them for details of exactly how the protocol had been butchered so I could try and find something else that could support it, and failing that for some alternative KVM facility that wasn't so bleeding fussy. Maybe (if they remember at all) they find it less peculiar now...

    776:

    Within three days so many of our friends who lost their livelihoods when Broadway and theater shut down in 2020, who got them back a few weeks ago -- from Jagged Little Pill to the annual Radio City Music Hall Christmas extravaganza, have lost their jobs again.

    So much has changed here within ONLY THREE DAYS. Including I just received phone call from the across the hall neighbor; she's got it. Yes, she's vaxxed and boosted too. She thinks it was because she was hanging out with her two best friends, who also are vaxxed and boosted.

    This stuff is incredibly fast -- I think even more so than the close to the end wave of the Great Influenza of 1918.

    It really does feel unavoidable that we'll get it too.

    777:

    We hope everyone has read the News today (and Mr Monbiot[0] who is on a bit of a redemption arc and is nailing (cough with a little help cough) what's actually happenening.

    Well, that's part of why one of the threads was so beautiful. To explain: prior to AD70, a lot of Jewish humor focused on[1] the trope of the overly young, high caste, Temple educated 'enforcer' of Religious / Ethical Morality getting their commupance (This is pre- Tanakh times). The High-brow version from the Bible is little Jesus confounding the scholars then dunking on every single thing a Pharisee says for four books.

    To parse the joke in modern terms:

    Scene - Arwad docks, merchant quarter, centre stage, huge crowd. Young (probably Noble, did we forget that Monarchism thing? We didn't, Arward was one of the first quasi-Republics of the Era and was noted even by the Romans as a "friend of the Jews" in terms of State relations).

    He's new, he's keen, there's a big scandal back home about how imported wigs/merkins are not Frum[2], he's got a mandate and of course he speaks Aramaic since (new rules) he views speaking Hebrew (ancient) in public where goyim can hear as 'sacrilege'.

    You can plot out the conversation, with the crowd getting hot up, the young bloods looking to kick the shit out of the (much lower caste) traders and so on, but the punch line was: "Go back home and ask your Mother where she gets her merkin from"[3] in Hebrew(Ancient). Answer: of course, she like everyone else of that caste, imports high-grade wigs/merkins from abroad to show off their wealth and status[4] and he spent a lot of his time doing such trade, as well as the far more important stuff like diplomacy with the locals so that they generally supported the post-Macc rebellion Israel (and did so up until the Romans squashed them ~35BC or so... take note: Israel was not the only place getting squished in this period).

    And then flash-back/forward to the UK Council desperately attempting to make a huge drama out of a slight teenage gang / macho stand off[5] that various stupid / reactionary entities are attempting to swirl up into a "BBC is racist" / "The Streets of London are a warzone" media deal for their readers.

    So, yeah. I'm thinking we're back.

    And that trader, btw: fucking hilarious. And no, there's no fucking way a modern Mind should know any of that instantly without even checking their Memories.[6]

    ~

    Sokath, his eyes closed

    Want a real lesson in "Eyes Open"

    The largest Senate you've never seen: white robes, the whole deal. Woman[7] stripped while wrists tied and shoulders bent forward. Dunked and drowned: "Poetic Justice" for "Death by Water" gag.

    Her Voice (the real one[8]) in people's Dreams: wake them up, blood everywhere, "Nose Bleed, can't handle it", Brazil lost: Amazon state, not popular with her.

    Water boarded, blind-folded, pushed back down the stairs[8], a hand grasp and Male (sigh... we detest the Male Ones): "He's So SMALL" and a RU slav with plastic teeth grins[9] with under 16 twins dancing in kinky black underwear.

    Fuck this noise, blow the locks off... and we'll let The Women Decide[tm]. (One of those old double round handle on each side brass/gold ones, real Rag-time feel).

    Put simply: Conceptually, Sigh.

    ~

    Anyhow, look at your current reality. It was a freebie to Host (and anyone willing to read): we like you, your continued surivival is kinda a good thing.

    [0] https://twitter.com/GeorgeMonbiot/status/1472150414732808197 [1] Closest English eqiv. Little Lord Fauntleroy: https://idioms.thefreedictionary.com/Little+Lord+Fauntleroy [2] This is also a later cultural translation, but it will do. [3] Again, this works a lot better in a different language [4] If you want to go Dark-Black with references, we've got a nice line in "Surely there's not that many kids with cancer who need wigs" in modern times, how Charities are not really charities and where the hair all those nice people goes, goes, and who makes $$$ millions off, but hey. [5] And trust us: the kid in question 100% said "Dirty Muslims" and some other rude stuff, slang is a thing you [6] Bene Gesserit gag. [7] Not even your species, clostest analogue [8] "Who goes up? Who goes Down?" And trust us, Her real Voice Scours Minds but we think it's sweet and beautiful. [9] https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/why-do-slavs-squat-slav-squat

    778:

    Note: if you can spot the style it's a Meta-Stylistic joke for those slogging through the bad bits of it all with endless discussions of sheep and it was all just for Hanukkah to show:

    The Light is fucking funny, it's not about a Genocidal War on All Non-Tribe.

    p.s.

    No, it's not in your book(s). That's the META joke.

    779:

    The good news, of course, is that Zoom stock zoomed up again.

    780:

    (Oh, and turning a double vodka mixed with some kind of fruit alcho-pop in pint glasses into lemonade in the bombed out hotel that looks like a High Rise set whilst spitting out the chewy rinds of a fruit that's really never been seen on Earth for a few thousand years, because the important part of turning water into Wine is the opposite when you've just let out (quite literally) the maenads from a place they've been locked up for Eons in)

    "They'll rip you apart" (and, yeah: the sexual energy comes off them like a 1990's MDA rave)

    Yeah, we know: thatsthejoke.jpg.

    ~

    2(?)9 broken covenants on the wall, 29 broken covenants on the wall...

    What you got? Fucking Carboard Warriors with Poppies on. When this kicks off, you're gonna get pasted.

    781:

    Patient identity is really hard, even in jurisdictions where there's a national identifier issued to everyone at birth. I've heard of one incident where the misidentification was picked up because pathology found the blood type didn't match what was in the patient record. It's a challenge in that both centralisation and decentralisation seem to make it worse, whatever you do. The best a healthcare organisation can do is ensure it has robust merge and unmerge processes, but for some medical record software (making a furtive glance at Kansas City here...) these can be intensely manual processes.

    782:

    It really does feel unavoidable that we'll get it too.

    I watched the first 3 episodes of "Station 11" last night. Makes this time seem not so bad. At least for now.

    783:

    "Could I humbly suggest depleted uranium?"

    I'm not sure DU taken orally is particularly dangerous. Even snorting DU dust takes, on the average, years to have an effect.

    784:

    The best a healthcare organisation can do is ensure it has robust merge and unmerge processes, but for some medical record software (making a furtive glance at Kansas City here...) these can be intensely manual processes.

    While it is somewhat of a trope in fictional movies and TV real docs and hospital people have said always look at the bracelet they put on your arm and be sure it's you.

    And if you're going in for surgery on a major thing, write on the wrong things in a fat marker things like: "NOT THIS KNEE", "NOT THIS ARM", etc...

    Just in case the surgeon and the prep staff get out of sync.

    785:

    It really does feel unavoidable that we'll get it too.

    Yes, there are all the indications that any effort to try and contain omicron appear doomed to failure given how easily and quickly it is spreading.

    The NFL (US Football league) seems to think so - they have ended the routine weekly Covid tests for vaccinated players and staff. While they don't say it, it is pretty much an admission that Omicron is spreading so quickly and widely that they would have to shutdown the league it they kept testing.

    Meanwhile the NHL (ice hockey) schedule is currently in tatters with several teams unable to play due to Covid.

    That those leagues who were able to control things up until now no longer can provides clear evidence of how difficult a job governments are going to have attempting to do anything.

    786:

    I’m told you can get quite substantial chunks of it delivered by rocket.

    And wrt the ‘log4’ thing - no, it’s not because people “copy and paste” (as if that were necessarily a bad thing) since log4j is alibrary. It’s because a little utility library maintained, barely, by volunteers, got sucked into several big widespread packages. And nobody bothered to check it.

    And of course, also because it is java, which is a steaming pile of nonsense that failed to make anything close to a proper attempt to copy Smalltalk. Like Ruby. And most of JavaScript too, come to that.

    787:

    Completely off topic, but I've finally got around to reading Graeber and Wengrow's Dawn of Everything. And, like James C. Scott's Against the Grain (another book I'd looked forward to), I'm wondering if it's worth finishing the blasted thing.

    Problem is, the current chapter I'm reading is purportedly a critical part of their argument, a comparison of the "Northern California Indians" with the "Pacific Northwest Indians." Bluntly, they didn't do their research. For example, Cape Mendocino, which they twice insist is the dividing line between the two comparison areas, is south of the California tribes they're talking about. They also mostly forget that there's the whole of Oregon and part of Washington in between the Makah (the southernmost of the PNW coastal tribes, and the Hoopa (the northernmost of the California tribes). In doing so, they ignore the great (slave) trading market on the Columbia River. That's a non-trivial geography fail.

    They also cavalierly dismiss the ecological arguments about why California Indians eat acorns. If they were in a graduate seminar touting this BS, I'd fail them on all the details they got wrong, from how to harvest and process acorns, the economics of doing so, the variability of the crops, and the alternative plant food sources.

    The problem is, the book is built out of creative reinterpretations of old literature, including the chapter I just lambasted. When they're talking about the stuff I know about, they get the details laughably wrong (largely ignoring Oregon when comparing the neighboring cultures of California and Washington, thinking Cape Mendocino is somewhere in Oregon, etc.). What does that say about the other stuff I'm not familiar with? Were they similarly careless?

    Hence I'm not sure it's worth finishing. But I'll plow on. like the Aquatic Ape theory, this book appears reasonably likely to turn out to be not very accurate, but good for creating fantasy worlds.

    Incidentally, Scott's Against the Grain is his attempt to prove that primary civilizations rose only where there was grain being farmed. Problem with this theory is that we've actually got pretty good observations of a primary civilization in formation: the Kingdom of Hawai'i, as it was finally united by Kamehameha under European eyes. And guess what? They didn't farm grain. And guess what is never mentioned in Against the Grain?? I didn't finish that one. If you're going to write a Great Book, do your effing research or get it proofed by raging grumps like me (emphatically not looking in Jared Diamond's direction).

    Hope this rant-let took you away from being consumed by rapidly propagating omicron terror for a few minutes. Keep both your sense of taste and your sense of humor intact.

    788:

    You are confusing fiction with reality.

    789:

    Tick bite update: saw a different doctor, got reassured that it's almost certainly just the profusion of bites that have affected me. No sign of any of the more difficult symptoms, and specifically no rash. Much blah blah just wait you'll be fine, and at least you've eaten meat without ending up in an ambulance :)

    790:

    Meanwhile the NHL (ice hockey) schedule is currently in tatters with several teams unable to play due to Covid.

    Yep. Our local NHL team played last night with 6 regulars missing. (And still won with callups.) 1 game cancelled, 2 postponed in the last week. Plus what was reported to be a crazy bit of paperwork and special chartered flights to get 3 or 4 on the team who tested positive while in Vancouver back home in North Carolina.

    College basketball is starting to fall apart. A non trivial number of programs have shut down for a week or two which required re-scheduling some major TV games. Which is a HUGE deal over here.

    791:

    No.

    It was an mental escape into fiction where as bad as things are now I really don't think this is the end of the world with jet liners falling out of the sky into a Chicago park due to a rapidly mutating flu virus.

    792:

    Yes, there are all the indications that any effort to try and contain omicron appear doomed to failure given how easily and quickly it is spreading.

    For a slightly different take.

    For a few months many of us were serious about masking, distancing, etc... And yes there were to skeptics who ignored it all. And there were those in the middle who went along as it wasn't too big a burden. And with that much effort we mostly sort of tamped it down.

    Over the last few weeks I've noticed more people out shopping who ignore the store signs that masks are required, sporting events where more and more of the folks in the stands are not masked, etc...

    And apparently (in my opinion) that little bit of relaxation was enough to allow the spread to take off.

    People (at least in the US) want to know what they can do to FIX IT so it will BE OVER. Most of them do not want to hear, AT ALL, that all they can do is make it better and maybe in a year or two it things might be somewhat normal. They just refuse to go there mentally. "I'm vac'd and boosted" so I can do what I want seems to be a mantra I hear more and more.

    And here we go.

    793:

    When they're talking about the stuff I know about, they get the details laughably wrong (largely ignoring Oregon when comparing the neighboring cultures of California and Washington, thinking Cape Mendocino is somewhere in Oregon, etc.). What does that say about the other stuff I'm not familiar with? Were they similarly careless?

    Which is why I avoid ALL the cable news shows after 6pm. Whether I like the points being made or not. Every time they talk about something I KNOW about they get enough of the details wrong to make the point of their story wrong. Since I doubt that it's just the items I personally know about, I figure they are getting it wrong with all kinds of things.

    794:

    Foxessa
    Good luck, keep safe ....
    And all of the rest of us, as well: "Come the bleak midwinter.."

    Oh dear - #777
    There might be an ACTUAL MESSAGE in there, but, you know, I really can't be arsed.
    Can we have a translation?
    . . Plus 778 + 780 + 782 + 783 + 784 + 789 + 791
    - which appears to be EIGHT posts in a 3.25 hour period. There was supposed to be a maximum of THREE wasn't there?

    In actual real news
    "Frostie" has resigned, because the US-Rethuglican switch he was hoping for in the UK isn't happening fast enough.
    Almost-quote: A low-tax, low-regulation, profitable economy TRANSLATION: Removal of workplace safety & employment laws, shit in the rivers, low wages for you & fat "profits" for us ...
    Following my 1665-8 analogy - how long to the Trial of the 7 Bishops & a Glorious Revolution?

    795:

    Greg Tingey @ 760: * Serious computer security threat in Java, of unknown proportions - because everyone cut-&-pastes ...*

    As Tim Rowledge has already noted @ 790, no this is not about "cut and paste" programming. That is something different.

    The Guardian's technology reporting is shite, and I recommend ignoring it on general principles. This is a classic of the genre.

    "Cut and paste" programming means a coder copying some source code from one part of a program to another part, creating a second copy, and then modifying bits of the code to fit the new place. This is bad for a long list of reasons, and good programmers avoid it. (Reasons include; it makes the program bigger and harder to understand, if there was a bug in the original you now have two bugs which must be separately found and fixed, its easy to introduce bugs by not fully understanding how the original code worked).

    Reusing libraries, on the other hand, is good practice. Library code has been written to be used in multiple places. It provides a clear and well-defined way of achieving some common goal (such as logging what the program has done). If everyone who needed this function were to write their own then that would be a huge waste of effort, all the different implementations would have lots of new bugs, and programs would be even bigger than they are now. (Simplified explanation: if your computer is running 5 different programs, and they all use a common library, your computer only needs to keep one copy of the library in memory).

    The real problem here isn't the reuse of library code, its that huge amounts of code can wind up depending on some obscure library that isn't being properly maintained. This XKCD cartoon puts it rather well. (However log4j isn't one of these; its part of the big professionally-run Apache project).

    Very occasionally something like this happens: one of these basic widely-used libraries is found to have a major security issue. The software world has a well-practiced process for dealing with this. The issue is widely publicised to ensure that everyone who needs to know hears about it. An updated version is issued, along with instructions to upgrade ASAP. Many organisations already use pre-built assemblages of this kind of software running on the cloud, so the upgrade may well happen behind the scenes as their cloud provider handles the details. Others just need to change a line in a configuration file and restart the program (simplifying again).

    Such events are inevitable as long as we have bugs in software. The real test is how we deal with them.

    796:

    Heteromeles @ 792: Completely off topic, but I've finally got around to reading Graeber and Wengrow's Dawn of Everything. And, like James C. Scott's Against the Grain (another book I'd looked forward to), I'm wondering if it's worth finishing the blasted thing.

    Yes, that was my response to "Debt: The First 5,000 Years". I also read his original essay on "Bullshit jobs". Based on those two experiences I'm just ignoring anything with his name on it.

    Graeber systematically confuses anecdotes with evidence, cherry-picks without shame, and hides bald unsupported assertions in mounds of waffle.

    797:

    My scripts are in Python and, developing them, I found that the documentation and examples weren't entirely reliable.

    798:

    775 - The one and only correct place for Java is in mugs, not in computers!

    795 - Virtually the entire English top soccer division was cancelled yesterday due to Covid and/or weather. Meantime, in Scotland, 3 matches were fogged off (yes really) with none lost to other causes.

    798 - Similar feelings only more so. When celebrity talentless contests become "major news stories" there is something wrong. Similarly, if a politician is asked a question twice and refuses to answer, IMO the interviewer's next statement should be along the lines of "OK, you clearly don't want to answer that question, so we'll let the viewers draw their own conclusions as to why, and move on."

    800 - I'm not sure about "facilities" like log4j. My reasoning is based around a piece of code throwing an exception that had been masked by the developer. In order to identify what the said exception actually was, I wrapped that code in its own exception handler as follows:-

    Exception Block Fred ;

    -- Code raising exception

    exception

    when others => raise ;

    End Fred ;

    This then had the effect of clearing the exception, so it obviously made some change to the run time object. By agreement with the supplier's support engineer and my boss, this got enshrined in the defect report as the fix for the defect in question.

    799:

    I should be amused to know if you remember why you started using the name 'Fred' for such purposes. In the 1970s, I had a slight reputation for doing it (followed by 'Joe'), but you may well have thought of it independently.

    800:

    paws4thot: 800 - I'm not sure about "facilities" like log4j.

    Yes. I was trying to present an explanation for non-programmers that corrected all the misunderstandings in the Grauniad, not to evaluate log4j specifically, or even the Java language in general. I've never actually learned Java: when it first came out it was Yet Another OO Language, so I didn't bother. ("A language that doesn't affect the way you think about programming, is not worth knowing." -- Alan Perlis). And I haven't had occasion to actually sit down and use it since.

    801:

    If I need a meaningful name for a block, I use it. In this sort of case, I use Fred (Flintstone) as being a handy identifier for what I think will be temporary trace code. I was actually surprised to find that adding the trace fixed the problem. The lesson is that doing this sort of thing does actually change the compiled code.

    802:

    This stuff is incredibly fast -- I think even more so than the close to the end wave of the Great Influenza of 1918.

    Absolutely, except this won't be the last because, unlike influenza, infection with COVID19 doesn't confer lifelong immunity to that particular strain.

    I'm vaxxed and boosted, but I'm staying indoors until after my wife gets her booster (on Tuesday). Reportedly the booster-driven rise in T- and B- cell immunity is much faster than for the initial shots, arriving in 3-6 days and maxing out after 7 days, rather taking two weeks.

    I fully expect the UK to be back in don't-call-it-lockdown by the end of tomorrow (Monday 20th).

    803:

    Thanks. Independent invention of such simple things is extremely common, despite the claims of the patent believers.

    804:

    I am also expecting it to be half-hearted and largely ineffectual :-( Bozo doesn't have the balls to do what the experts say is essential.

    805:

    Greg, I'll provide a translation of the Seagull's shite for you (the first post, anyway - can't be bothered to do them all.

    [DELETED]

    Adinistrative note: that's a Yellow Card for JReynolds.

    Hint: just because you don't understand a comment doesn't mean I don't understand it. Or that it's unwanted. Leave that decision to the moderators. Also? Abusive disparagement of other commenters is officially discouraged.

    806:

    Charlie
    I, too - fully expect the UK to be back in don't-call-it-lockdown by the end of tomorrow (Monday 20th).

    #810
    I can be contacted at: ( Remove all the spaces & put the appropriate symbols in ) ---
    f l e d e r m a u s AT d s l DOT p i p e x DOT c o m
    Though I must emphasise that I consider the s-gull in need of medical/mental help, rather than being insulted, ok? It's also that she (?) shouldn't be depositing her "problems" on us, she should see a doctor. And, if the administrator can understand it - you can provide a bloody translation, grr ....

    More generally, & to take our minds off C-19. A genuinely serious question.
    How far along are we, really, in the farcical historical re-enactment of the utterly disastrous reign of James II & VII compared to Bo Jon-Sun?
    Note the similarities - the disregard of Parliament & it's votes & procedures, the ignoring, sidelining & attack on the judiciary & "packing" ( Or proposing to pack ) supposedly independent bodies & P Patel standing in for Judge Jefferies. Comments/disagreements/differences/odds on how long this will last? Oh, & how big the inevitable crash will be WHEN it comes, whenever that is.

    807:

    If you're comfortable with Python

    Actually, one of my retirement projects is learning Python. Any advice for someone just getting started, who has a creaky old iMac (and an even creakier MacPro)?

    My last serious programming was in Pascal, back in the 90s. Never managed to get my head around object-oriented. (Or rather, when/why object-oriented is better than procedural.)

    808:

    I should be amused to know if you remember why you started using the name 'Fred' for such purposes.

    In my case I did it because it was easy to type (four letters adjacent on a keyboard so easy for a mostly-hunt-and-peck typist such as myself). Didn't know I wasn't the only person doing it. :-)

    I wonder how common it is?

    809:

    Re: '... 6-month to 5 year olds had to be changed from 2-dose to 3-dose'

    Not sure whether you mean that none of the kids in that age group have received any vax shots yet.

    Greg @770: Low vax rate in your neighborhood

    I looked at what the country of origin vax uptake is for the largest ethnic group in your area (Romanian) - it's really low. But not sure what this means in reality because people who choose to emigrate might be doing so not just for a job but because they want to get away from their country of origin's cultural norms. For example, my parents held onto their country of origin's religious and cultural customs but got rid of most of the then-prevalent societal/political baggage. Their kids meanwhile enjoy some of the traditional foods, can understand/hum some of the traditional tunes/Xmas carols and maybe know a bit more of that country's history. But that's it. Oh yeah - their kids are agnostic/atheist.

    Another possibility is whether these folks have reasonable access to vaccines. This means transportation and time: how many jobs and what hours do they work and can they get to a vax clinic within that 'time off' window? This is a serious issue in some parts of NA.

    Possible exposure - wait & see time ...

    Close family member who's very cautious is going for a Covid test. Most likely exposure would have been a few hours' duration just before we spent several hours together a couple of days ago. Not sure how soon the test results will be in. In the meantime, I'll be staying at home, checking my temp and watching for symptoms. (My booster was scheduled for mid-January - the earliest date I could get.) I do realize that this could be a cold or Covid but catching either while masked and socially distanced (as family member was) is still weird. Stay safe folks!

    810:

    Got my booster last Tuesday, in and out in less than an hour. Concerning the many named entity, worth skimming, usually too obscure to read and a bit of a comfort to encounter someone more alienated than myself.

    811:

    812 - I can see no obvious gains to object-oriented either. Object based, where, instead of writing, say Xsquare := X * X ; Ysquare := Y * Y... you write a short function for exponentiation and use it every time you want a power of a number is convenient.

    813 - I'd guess that more or less anyone who aspires to write readable and usable source in a language that supports block structures and/or exception handling does things like this.

    Various - The Many Named Seagull; rarely to never worth reading, and pretty much never worth replying to, unless you feel an actual pressing need to be one or more of belittled, patronised, insulted and threatened.

    812:

    unless you feel an actual pressing need to be one or more of belittled, patronised, insulted and threatened

    And if you do, consider becoming a teacher in a high-needs area. Satisfy your masochism while doing some good! :-)

    813:

    Over the last few weeks I've noticed more people out shopping who ignore the store signs that masks are required, sporting events where more and more of the folks in the stands are not masked, etc...

    I don't doubt that is true where you are, but it isn't necessarily true elsewhere in the world where omicron is taking off.

    Where I am in Ontario transit riders, shoppers in malls and stores, etc. are still wearing masks and you need to be vaccinated to indoor dine or do indoor events like movies.

    Yet omicron is still doing it thing despite that.

    814:

    The problem about Python is that it's very useful, but far shoddier than it is made out to be, and its inconsistencies and (serious) flaws cause trouble when you move to advanced coding. My main advice is to read the documentation carefully, and be suspicious of claims that it's easy to use and natural. For example, its global/local rules are a mess, and the following will not work to create a 5x5 updatable matrix, though it is implied to:

    x = 5*[5*[0]]

    Its diagnostics are terrible, too, and most of the work learning it is learning its library. Most of that is of comparable quality, but some is less good, and non-canonical libraries are VERY patchy. I could go on about areas with traps, but that's a warning of the most basic ones where the hype and reality are flatly contradictory.

    Object-orientation is useful for problems that fit naturally into that form, and harmful otherwise, as is pretty well every other programming dogma.

    If you're interested, modern Fortran is easy to learn and useful for writing numeric (especially matrix) programs. DON'T try to learn C++, unless you are an insane masochist, or even more insane hacker.

    Re Fred: well, that's three of us that use that style, with no connection. Interesting.

    815:

    Actually, one of my retirement projects is learning Python. Any advice for someone just getting started, who has a creaky old iMac (and an even creakier MacPro)?

    A lot depends on how you like to learn, but first stop should probably be your local library to see what they offer.

    In addition to the obvious books many of the libraries these days have online learning courses available that can be used from home.

    Then there is YouTube which has lots of tutorials so you can pick and choose if you like video.

    Life will be easier if you use and editor meant for programming. Two free options to check out:

    The obvious (given it's popularity, support including tutorials on YouTube) would be Visual Studio Code by Microsoft. The drawback is it is a bit bloated and maybe slow on an older computer.

    Alternatively, the Mac native program BBEdit. It is a paid program but only for extra features - you can download it and use everything for free for 30 days, and then continue using many of its features for free forever (it disables the extra features unless you pay).

    816:

    And beware, Microsoft has a bad naming habit. You would want to try Visual Studio Code, not Visual Studio (Windows only) or Visual Studio for Mac.

    817:

    Re: '... consider becoming a teacher in a high-needs area'

    Yep - and now I know what old movie to watch. Thanks!

    Cue music - hint (sung by Lulu):

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EV1qmmMwc9M&ab_channel=HDFilmTributes

    818:

    Actually, one of my retirement projects is learning Python. Any advice for someone just getting started, who has a creaky old iMac (and an even creakier MacPro)?

    Raspberry Pi

    819:

    Heteromeles @ 792: Completely off topic, but I've finally got around to reading Graeber and Wengrow's Dawn of Everything. And, like James C. Scott's Against the Grain (another book I'd looked forward to), I'm wondering if it's worth finishing the blasted thing...Yes, that was my response to "Debt: The First 5,000 Years". I also read his original essay on "Bullshit jobs". Based on those two experiences I'm just ignoring anything with his name on it...Graeber systematically confuses anecdotes with evidence, cherry-picks without shame, and hides bald unsupported assertions in mounds of waffle.

    Haven't we had this discussion before? For me it's more complex than that. In Debt, Graeber tried to make the perfectly reasonable points that being indebted to others is a basic part of being human, but monetizing those debts is not basic, it's a choice that's often forced on us. I think he was right to look at debt as older and more fundamental than money, and propose that therefore it's more useful to study the history, anthropology, and sociology of how debts are handled than it is to try and figure out precisely what money is, since it's a function of debt. Then, we both agree, he buried this reasonable thesis under piles of waffle and anecdata.

    In The Dawn of Everything, he's making the point that the people of the stone age were simply people, not super chimps or raw material awaiting the spark of civilization or a specific mutation to become truly human. Therefore (and I agree with him here), it's stupidly counterproductive to ignore all the evidence from the paleo, meso, and neolithic of sophisticated societies (cave paintings, elaborate burials, and just now, 125,000 year-old evidence that neanderthals burned to maintain a savanna in Germany for ca. 2,000 years, just as the Australian aborigines did and do). I agree with him that we oversimplify human history in pointlessly destructive ways, and that our habits of grouping people by how some white male anthropologist thought they got food (hunter-gatherer, simple farmer...civilized office drone) should be thrown out with extreme prejudice. He's not the only anthropologist saying this, either. Just the one the literati fawn over the most.

    With the Pacific Coast comparison, he was trying to make an important point, that it's problematic to deduce social structures from environmental data. Where he screwed up IMHO is that he cherry-picked two examples from areas that really are environmentally different, salted in details from surrounding groups that properly should have been excluded, then pretended his two tribes were right next to each other when they're hundreds of miles apart. This weakened his argument.

    That said, I think a fantasy writer could use Dawn of Everything, as part of a balanced intellectual breakfast,* to create a genuine "Hyborian Age," complete with multiple human species and megafauna, set back 40,000 or even 125,000 years ago in the Eemian. Graeber's right that there could very easily have been something akin to a PNW chiefly culture somewhere in ice age Europe, Asia, or Africa. The evidence would almost certainly be buried under millennia of farming by now. He's right that ancient peoples traveled a lot, were generally multilingual, and were probably more aware of personal politics than we are now (such that someone trying to pull a Trump and take over a village might be killed accidentally in the woods in a hail of spears and rocks). So a stoned-age Conan actually makes some sense.

    While he trips over his own unsophisticated terminology and ecological ignorance, he's right that much of what we consider hallmarks of civilization probably showed up at smaller, sparser scales back in the ice ages. Unfortunately, he wants to speculate, not support, and that's where his work runs into problems. It's too bad, too.

    *including Dark Emu and The Biggest Estate On Earth, both of which use ample historical records from the settlement of Australia to demonstrate in great detail what such a world could look like. I'd also throw in Lynne Kelly's memory research, because that gives a better reason for cultural diversity and creativity than Graeber did with his schismogenetic handwaving, IMHO.

    820:

    Raspberry Pi.

    Completely agreed. You can pick up a Pi with 8 gigs of memory for around $45, and them whatever you want by way of an SSD card - 128 Gigs is plenty for a learning machine - and maybe an HDMI mini to HDMI cable for $5-10. Use an existing keyboard and mouse, install Ubuntu, and you should be good. I'm "Obvious Name" at gmail.com if you need any help.

    821:

    Actually, it is better to use a generic WYSIWYG text editor, though finding one nowadays is seriously tricky for anything other than Linux, and none too easy for that. Editors for coding tend to have dogmatic ideas of what coding is, and can get in the way more than they help.

    But it is CRITICAL to avoid anything like Microsoft Word, which delights in mangling the text you write for 'improved formatting'.

    822:

    Okay, back to the Covid19 panic.

    Here's a local article from San Diego: https://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/news/health/story/2021-12-18/ucsd-covid-surge-wastewater-spike

    The tl;dr/paywalled version is that UCSD, which is a biotech powerhouse, is monitoring covid19 levels at the major local sewage plant. In 2020 and 2021, they noticed that virus spikes in sewage led Covid19 spikes in hospitalizations by about two weeks. And now they're seeing a massive spike in Covid19 virus in the sewage. If previous trends hold, we'll see a hospitalization spike around New Years. Joy.

    The one new finding is that they did a fair amount of genotyping of their samples. The sewage spike isn't just omicron, it's both omicron and delta together. That's something to contemplate. Even if it turns out that omicron is less lethal than delta, if you use that notion to stop masking and just get the infection over with (it's only a cold...), you might get nailed by delta instead. At least here. The UCSD virologists aren't seeing omicron replacing delta here yet.

    823:

    Association is not causality. That is only one of the various theories about why the savanna was stable in that area.

    824:

    Association is not causality. That is only one of the various theories about why the savanna was stable in that area.

    Since I actually did my PhD on oak savannas in Wisconsin, let's start with the basic question: could an oak savanna be stable in that area without regular fire? In places as far apart as Wisconsin, northern California, and Vancouver Island, oak savannas are only possible where people burn quite deliberately. Otherwise the oaks take over. Is this true in that part of Germany? This isn't a trap question but a crucial one. For me, northern oak savannas are anthropogenic landscapes, created because they're extremely useful both for hunting and for foraging. But without careful management, they're also quite unstable. If there's evidence of a northern oak savanna in a pleistocene environmental record, one of my first questions would be what was causing the fires that created the savanna. Absent lightning strikes, it would almost certainly be humans.

    For context, 125,000 years ago was in the early Eemian interglacial (130,000-115,000 YBP). It was as warm as today, but from what I've read, the climate never stabilized as it did for us around 5,000 years ago. The global temperature instead slowly spiked, then dropped. So it was like today, but with an unpredictable climate.

    The environmental record is from lake samples. Apparently they have a bunch of lake samples from the same area and the same period, and this is the one that has a savanna and evidence of neanderthal stone flakes from nearby.

    825:

    But it is CRITICAL to avoid anything like Microsoft Word

    You aren't seriously implying that some people write code in Word are you?

    That's like going to the corner market for milk and bread by driving a articulated tractor trailer / lorry. Instead of a 100 meter walk.

    826:

    Actually, it is better to use a generic WYSIWYG text editor, though finding one nowadays is seriously tricky for anything other than Linux, and none too easy for that. Editors for coding tend to have dogmatic ideas of what coding is, and can get in the way more than they help.

    I agree there, though I'm a bit old-fashioned in that way.

    I personally use Sublime in Linux, Windows, and MacOS, both at work and at home. Its development cycle is not the fastest, but I've found it pretty good. It can be configured to run external programs, but I use it as an editor and run 'make' from a terminal window.

    827:

    !!? Since when was Wurd a text editor? Going all the way back to A Mess DOS days, it's always been sold as a "word processor". If all you want is a text editor, Notepad is a better choice (and my favourite price when you've already bought Windoze).

    828:

    Heteromeles @ 824:

    Haven't we had this discussion before? For me it's more complex than that. In Debt, Graeber tried to make the perfectly reasonable points that being indebted to others is a basic part of being human, but monetizing those debts is not basic, it's a choice that's often forced on us. I think he was right to look at debt as older and more fundamental than money, and propose that therefore it's more useful to study the history, anthropology, and sociology of how debts are handled than it is to try and figure out precisely what money is, since it's a function of debt. Then, we both agree, he buried this reasonable thesis under piles of waffle and anecdata.

    Indeed. In fact I'm pretty certain it was you that recommended I read Debt in the first place.

    There were certainly interesting insights into the history of money and finance, but the trouble is that the gems were mixed in with a load of coloured glass and I lack the expertise to tell the difference. So because I can't trust anything of his I read I can't take any of it on board, which is frustrating because it certainly looks like some of it is right.

    I'd very much like to read something on the subject by someone who knows what they are talking about and can be trusted not to cherry-pick data or make bogus leaps of logic. Any suggestions?

    829:

    If you are stuck on Windoze then Notepad++ is fairly decent.

    830:

    ""Cut and paste" programming means a coder copying some source code from one part of a program to another part..."

    That's not quite how I understand the term; I just call that repeating code or duplicating it. C&P I take to mean the practice of looking up some example solution to the kind of problem in question, and then copying it verbatim without necessarily understanding fundamental things like how it works, why it works, when it doesn't work, whether it actually is an appropriate solution in this particular case and what a more appropriate solution might look like.

    This does have a fair amount of overlap with the excessive/inappropriate use of libraries, most obviously in that if the code copied without understanding makes use of some library or other, then the inclusion of that library will be copied without understanding along with it, as a matter of necessity to make the thing work. But whereas the original use of that snippet of code may well have been in a context where the other implications of using that library have already been taken into account, when it is copied into an alien context all that stuff gets lost and random chaos takes its place. And since the snippet does work fine using whatever sample data the copier is trying it on, the existence of the lurking chaos is not suspected.

    It does rather look as if the current panic is in large part due to innumerable instances of this kind of behaviour, combined with the problem existing with library reuse of rampant scope bloat in successive versions introducing fragility, to which in this case the obfuscatory nature and thoughtless attempt at universality of Java act as encouragement and exacerbation. Nobody in their right mind expects some facility to dump a blob of text to a log to have the possible side effect of downloading random code off some random server and executing it locally in place of what the local system provides: as a bug it's bloody serious and as a deliberate inclusion it's bloody stupid. That it decides whether to do this by parsing the fucking logged text rather than according to some entirely separate parameter specifically for that purpose is stupid squared. I'm not sure whether it's amusing or sad to see all the Java nerds rushing to defend this behaviour on the grounds that if you set up some hideously fucking bizarre and idiotic kind of logging system that was so fucked up it had to do that sort of thing in order to function, it would still All Just Work.

    So you have a million people all wanting to know how to write to a log file in Java and turning to google and everything they find says "oh just use log4j, like this blah blah blah". Maybe in the beginning some of these posters mention that the default is not to simply log the text as a blob but to parse it as input to something that expects things like "download and execute untrusted code" as a legitimate instruction, so you need to perform some additional fucking about to make sure this doesn't happen. But the people reading it don't read that far, or they can't be arsed because it "can't happen in our application" and forget about it; their enthusiasm to spread the word on this easy solution prompts them to post snippets of their own code and say "just do this" with no mention of the danger at all; and before very long the people who are aware of the problem are so small a minority that the knowledge is effectively lost.

    Or some variant on that hypothetical situation adjusted for the real timeline, etc.

    I don't see a problem with the Guardian describing it as the result of people just copying code without understanding what they're actually doing, because although that may not be all there is to it, I'm sure it's a very large part of it. Also, explanations of the other aspects get increasingly technical and tedious, whereas the "sorcerer's apprentice" aspect is an ancient theme and familiar to everyone. And it's the reason why an awful lot of software in general is flaky as fuck.

    831:

    Well not the artic, but I have a fond memory of someone driving to the corner shop rather than walk; it was more like 50 metres than 100, and by the time he'd walked round the back of his house to get his car and then from the parking spot into the shop, he'd gone further on foot than if he just walked all the way.

    And trying to write code in Word... yeah, that sometimes happens, too.

    832:

    Actually, one of my retirement projects is learning Python. Any advice for someone just getting started, who has a creaky old iMac (and an even creakier MacPro)?

    As long as they are Intel machines, you can probably get a recent Python working on them - anything more recent than Python 3.6 should be fine for learning - and something like BBEdit as you editor should be fine. As other people noted, a Raspberry Pi is also probably not a bad way to get a working Python environment for not much money. If you are interested in data science-y sorts of things then getting Jupyter up and running may also solve the editor situation if you like Mathematica/Maple notebook-style environments.

    I'm a long way from being a beginner and it's been a few years now since I've taught Python to newbies, but Python was designed to be easy to learn: it was a design goal, and is part of the reason for some of the syntactic idiosyncracies. I remember the tutorial in the documentation not being bad back when I learnt it (back in Python ~1.3-ish), but there is so much more out there these days.

    If you're interested in doing data analysis, the courses from Software Carpentry might be a good place to dive in to the Python scientific stack and are aimed at academics with minimal coding background. The SciPy conference which I've been heavily involved with over the years also has recordings of tutorials covering similar beginner material.

    If you're interested in more general things, then the Raspberry Pi Foundation has a lot of stuff which uses Python and teaches it along the way, but I'm not sure it has a course per-se.

    I don't have any good resources for learning the web backend stuff that Python is used for as that's not really my area, but I'm sure there are things out there.

    As with anything, you probably need a concrete project or problem that you are trying to solve with Python to learn it well.

    My last serious programming was in Pascal, back in the 90s. Never managed to get my head around object-oriented. (Or rather, when/why object-oriented is better than procedural.)

    You can (and many data scientists do) use Python in a completely procedural way, and if you are comfortable with that paradigm it works acceptably well. You can move on to using OO if and when you actually need it. You can even use Python as a functional language if you are a masochist (and it lacks Lisp-style macros).

    Python is very consistently OO under the covers but isn't in your face about in the way that Java is and is pragmatic in ways that it exposes the OO nature: OO purists will claim that Python isn't "proper" OO, but the langauge is OO enough to get the benefits of when the paradigm makes sense.

    There are some gotchas coming from a language like Pascal about scoping and the nature of variables (such as the [[0] * 5] * 5 thing mentioned above) that make complete and perfect sense once you realize that variables, elements of lists, etc. in Python are not memory locations as in languages like C or Pascal, but rather references to objects, that assignment doesn't copy, and that some objects can be mutated in place (lists, dictionaries) and some can't (numbers, strings). These won't get you on day one, but you'll almost certainly run into it once you start doing anything serious if you're used to Pascal.

    I rather like the way it works, and did from day one coming from a background of Pascal, TCL and various Basics, but for people with backgrounds in languages like Pascal, C/C++, Java, etc. it can be a sticking point because it is a different mental model.

    Other gotchas include packaging, which is slowly getting better, and which probably won't bite you unless you want to publish your work in a re-usable way.

    Finally, Python's real strength is that it is an excellent glue language. Almost all of the prominient Python toolkits in the scientific world are actually wrappers around Fortran and C/C++ code that does the heavy lifting, so for example NumPy and SciPy are more-or-less wrappers around the usual suspects (BLAS, ODEPACK, FFTPACK, etc.). You'd be crazy to try to implement certain things in pure Python (eg. numerics, GUIs, system-level code, etc.) just as you'd be crazy to try to implement a web server in Fortran (although I'm sure someone's done it) but a reasonable strategy is to write a little bit of code in C or Fortran and then wrap it, and use Python to connect it to whatever else you are doing (eg. building a web server, writing an app using wrapped Qt code, etc.).

    833:

    I like Python a lot - although that may be because it was my first programming language, and thus everything else is, mentally, referenced to how it differs from Python.

    The only quibble I can offer about Python is that it's notorious for horrendous dependency management, and that is consistently the biggest problem I run into with the various researchers who are being encouraged to use it rather than Matlab.

    It's not the most important thing at the beginning, but if you do start writing more complex projects in Python, getting used to virtual environments (either via venv or via conda) will make your life a great deal easier.

    834:

    The climate was believed to be much drier, and there were mammoths. I am not claiming that I know the answer, but that it isn't definite, not least because other people make different assertions to you.

    835:

    Apparently, Bjarne has some students that attempted just that - the results weren't pretty ....

    But it's not just extreme products like Microsoft Word. FAR too many editors are prone to changing what you type (or paste), usually only by mangling white space but occasionally in more drastic ways (such as automatic justification). And Python is terribly sensitive to white space mangling.

    836:

    Pigeon: Maybe in the beginning some of these posters mention that the default is not to simply log the text as a blob but to parse it as input to something that expects things like "download and execute untrusted code" as a legitimate instruction, so you need to perform some additional fucking about to make sure this doesn't happen.

    Right, so you are saying the careless cut-n-paste was of the config file rather than the library itself. Yeah, I can go with that. Not sure if the distinction was lost on the Graniad reporter though.

    837:

    My workplace decided one day that they were not buying so many IDL licences (or MATLAB) and fiercely encouraged us to learn Python 3, so I had to abandon 100,000 lines of my own code and some utilities friends/colleagues had written.

    Work liked the fact it was free (so do I) and the fact it could access a wide range of higher level packages directly (certainly true) - perhaps less so since they realised some could host a nasty easter egg behind our shiny firewall.

    And its true, in comparatively little code I have it doing some useful stuff that would have taken a lot longer to write without the libraries. However, it does have some issues.

    The documentation is rubbish. Some of it is vague and a lot of it isn't presented with examples which can make life awkward. yeah, you can find lots of help on line, but the manual should be the first point of call and the people writing the code are too lazy to document it fully.

    If you use lists a lot (as you are strongly encouraged to do) you will find them comparatively slow compared to array handling and also memory ravenous. For that reason, apart from niche activities I use the numpy library most the time. Its no surprise as my other languages are Fortran, VB6, C, Forth, assembler, IDL.

    If you are used to other languages you may have come across something like:

    for i = 1 to 10

    where the i variable is iterated from 0 through to 10 in steps of 1. In Python the code to do the same thing is:

    for i in range(0,11):

    Note that the iteration top limit is not inclusive which can be a real pain in the derriere if translating code (as I was).

    Python3 is not backwards compatible with Python2. Go figure!

    Its slow - there was a whole Register item about this about 10 days ago.

    Its user based is obsessed with "style" and many would rather do something in Python style - even if its clear as mud - rather than in an easy to comprehend manner anyone can follow (in truth C sometimes suffered from the same problem when the programmer is a smart arse not used to working in teams). Also editors moan at you let a line get longer than an arbitary low limit - despite it running fine - or even if you write "i=a+b" rather than i = a + b". the latter is hilarious when you have big equations o are 6 levels of nesting into using ifs and for loops.....

    Truth is, its a useful tool and you can use it procedurally or as OO, but many of its fans have never used another language and are zealots - so expect some arrogance on help sites. Really, like any language, its just another tool with some good big data/data analytics/AI tools available and is cheap. Its not the Messiah.

    So, at present, its very trendy. I wonder if it will lose some of its shine for the born again coders when Python 4 comes along and is also not backwards compatible.

    On Windows Anaconda is a nice package of Python with an editor, but even the Raspberry Pi has a perfectly acceptable version which runs fine - and allows easy access to hardware control and interfacing.

    838:

    I remember pointing out to my Practice Nurse in Benbecula, who would at least intellectually know where I lived, that I could walk to my nearest shop faster than I could drive. Indeed, one of the neighbours and I coincidentally proved that to be literally true.

    839:

    The documentation is rubbish. Some of it is vague and a lot of it isn't presented with examples which can make life awkward. yeah, you can find lots of help on line, but the manual should be the first point of call and the people writing the code are too lazy to document it fully.

    This is unfair - the people behind all of these packages, and the language itself - are mostly volunteers or people doing it in their spare time. Laziness is not the problem.

    840:

    The problem is that the standard for documentation and examples is set by the full time professionals maintaining larger packages. Like log4j, to pick a topical example.

    And that standard is, frankly, shit. I'm playing with cUrl right now, sending emails via "curleasy..." whatever, and many of the examples don't compile, and most are incomplete. The documentation mostly consists of "this call lets you..., see example".

    One huge, huge thing about Rust is that they have officially decided that this is bullshit and they do not want to play that game. So they work really hard to make everything from the community to the compiler emit helpful information. They actively encourage dummies like me to simply work on the documentation whether that be core docs or library docs. Just download a random library and follow the documentation. If you don't understand it, or the examples don't work, ask for help then improve the things that don't work.

    It's not perfect, and there is a huge amount of work to be done (and being done!) but it beats the shit out of "haha newb RTFM" in response to "the example on the readme page of the library does not compile".

    841:

    Just for the record, I have contributed to open source projects in a variety of support roles, from reporting bugs/submitting bug fixes, to (re)writing documentation and promoting the libraries. I've done presentations to language user groups on a couple of them.

    I realise it's hard work, and often unrewarding, but at least these days it's (much) easier to just send money if that's your thing. And given how few people do that, just sending money can make a huge difference (I was donor <10 to Calibre the ebook tool, for example, and got a personal email thank you).

    I also have a list of stack exchange/overflow questions to my name, either asking for help or pointing out problems. I have one absolute classic about MySQL where the bug report says "cannot reproduce" and the SO question has ~100 upvotes and a lot of comments saying "this happened to me, your example is perfect WTF the bug report. The workaround works, though".

    842:

    The problem is that the standard for documentation and examples is set by the full time professionals maintaining larger packages. Like log4j, to pick a topical example.

    I can't speak for log4j or the Javascript world, but NumPy (which is about as important as it gets in the Python world) has, I think, 2 full-time, paid developers. 5 years ago it had zero.

    Outside of the non-community projects like Tensorflow (Google) and PyTorch (Facebook), there might be a max of 10 people who have a full-time job working on the scientific Python stack which so many scientists use. Everyone knows that documentation is important, and the documentation tooling is pretty good in Python these days, but resources are very limited - there are fewer of those "full time professionals" out there than you might think - it really is like the XKCD "one guy in Nebraska".

    Things are getting better - the various US funding agencies and foundations have started to realize that this sort of thing is important, and maybe they should give some grants; the UK, not so much.

    But as you note, the solution is money (don't like the docs? get your employer to donate some money they saved on IDL/Matlab licenses to NumFocus to improve things) or getting in there and fixing it yourself (but there is huge privilege in being able to do that).

    843:

    NOT as big a load of LYING UTTER SHIT as the "safe" limits for booze, of course, but that's another story.

    Can you elaborate on this? Because I really do not know what you mean here.

    844:

    Where I am in Ontario transit riders, shoppers in malls and stores, etc. are still wearing masks and you need to be vaccinated to indoor dine or do indoor events like movies.

    I thought unboosted vaccination is of greatly reduced efficiency against Omicron?

    My niece complains about her favourite yarn store where the owner only masks up when someone enters, for example.

    Last time I was at a dining establishment (couple months ago) no one wore masks even when not eating and drinking — I was the only one who took my mask off while eating and drinking and then put it back on. Everyone else took their mask off after sitting down and just stayed unmasked for the duration of their visit.

    In malls I've seen people sitting unmasked for nearly an hour while working on their computer with a coffee in front of them — which I didn't see them touch at all while I was waiting.

    Last flight I took my seatmate stretched his single bag of crisps over a full five-hour flight (so he spent it basically unmasked).

    Anecdote not data, but I suspect people are still loopholing the guidelines rather than treating Covid like an aerosol disease.

    845:

    I don't doubt that is true where you are, but it isn't necessarily true elsewhere in the world where omicron is taking off.

    Actually most of it comes from what I see in sports stadiums on TV. A month or few ago, most folks wore masks the entire time. In places with mandates it was approaching 100%. Especially for things like hockey and basketball where you can actually see faces. Now much less. And a non trivial number have them below their nose.

    846:

    Thanks for a detailed reply.

    What I'd like to do is try my hand at some of the data-scraping that Elderly Cynic has talked about, and maybe some data science stuff (which I also want to learn). Heteromeles pointed us to a neat application (nomographs) that I think might make a good first project.

    I'd prefer to do this for free or very cheap, because pension*.

    My mental model for computer programming is probably still a C64 under the hood. Despite taking half-classes in Fortran and Pascal at university, and in fact ending up as a programmer at BNR, I'm basically self-taught with all that implies about conceptual gaps.

    Libraries, for example, I think of as just collections of subroutines that effectively extend the language into computations the original specification didn't include. This seemed to be correct in the old days (ie. 1980s) but I don't know if it still is a good mental model.

    Dependencies I think of as "you have to include this at the start of your program to load all those subroutines" — again, no idea if this is correct.

    I have no idea what you're talking about with wrapping code. I would guess that it is a way of using code written in one language in another language?

    I've only ever programmed in an environment with an integrated editor/interpreter/compiler. Something like that would be nice. I don't know Unix/Linux and would really prefer to avoid learning an OS to learn a language. Don't know if this is possible.

    To put this in more concrete terms, lets suppose I want to start with nomographs. Here is a project that generates them using Python.

    http://pynomo.org/wiki/index.php/Main_Page

    Can you point me to a good place to learn what I need to learn to run this package? Something suitable for a Bear of Very Little Brain…

    *Going from "money accumulates so I don't have to worry about it" to "make certain I'm not spending more than I earn" has been a big mental shift. I don't miss the 60-80 hour weeks, but losing half my take-home pay has been a shock to the system. Especially as my plan of supply teaching for spending money went out the door with Covid.

    847:

    An important part of the performance problem for Python is that at its heart it is a not very good implementation of a Lisp interpreter. In theory there is a ‘compiler’ of some form but last I heard (as in “when I was asked a few years ago to take a look at improving it”) it was not very good.

    For Smalltalk we solved the problem in the mid-80s with dynamic translation (see https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/800017.800542 for the original paper) and that has been massively improved over the years. Quite a lot of other languages have taken up the idea; java of course renamed it to ‘jitting’ and tried to pretend they invented it. JavaScript has a pretty impressive development of it, but then again that has been developed from an original Smalltalk based concept (HotSpot) and a great deal of money.

    Could you do the same thing for Python? Yeah, almost certainly with enough effort, but when Peter Deutsch (see above cited paper) has looked and tinkered and said “nope” just like me... perhaps not. Part of the problem is the lispiness; underneath everything is variable length lists and you can’t rely on, well, anything much.

    As for Python being OOP, that’s a no. Really, it just isn’t. Ask my old friend Alan Kay, after all, he invented the concept. He is, by the way, a big fan of Lisp in the abstract. The problem is that to do OOP decently you have to have everything be an object, to work by sending messages, and have absolutely no way you can grab random memory addresses and go around molesting RAM as if you were some sort of computational Weinstein. Java and c++ etc fail that, horribly. If you do ‘procedural’, ie specify the jump target address, then that ruins any chance of maintaining object integrity. The difference is quite succinctly put by a phrase Adele Goldberg coined “Ask, don’t grab” to explain the contrast between proper OOP and C like procedural/pointer manipulation.

    Yes, I’m an OOP bigot. Yes, I can rant about it. But it’s backed up by 40 years of professional experience around the world at levels ranging from grunt to LtCol-equiv. & CTO. If you don’t like OOP, feel free to not use it; just don’t waste my time trying to tell me it doesn’t work.

    848:

    When I started teaching I could cycle to school faster than I could drive, because I could take side streets and walk my bike across intersections where cars were prohibited. Ten minute bike ride, 20 minute drive.

    Big problem was no secure bike storage, in Toronto. (Bike theft capitol of North America.) Administration insisted that bikes be locked outside in a place that had no security cameras or observation. So I didn't cycle much, because the risk of loss/damage was so high.

    849:

    I'd prefer to do this for free or very cheap, because pension*.

    Essentially beyond the hardware and OS (which you have with your Mac), everything you need to do programming today can be found for free (the editors, the libraries, tutorials (either via blogs, YouTube, or by books or courses from a library). You can even find some books are distributed legally for free in a PDF format or as a website.

    My mental model for computer programming is probably still a C64 under the hood. Despite taking half-classes in Fortran and Pascal at university, and in fact ending up as a programmer at BNR, I'm basically self-taught with all that implies about conceptual gaps.

    The programming world has changed dramatically from those days. As I noted above, thanks to pressure from Linux and other things everything you need today is available for free. Yes, there are still things you can pay for if you want, but they aren't necessary.

    For example, go to https://www.python.org/downloads/macos/ and you can download Python for macOS and install it.

    If you then open a terminal window on your Mac and type python (or maybe python3) you will be in an interpreter where you can type python and each line you enter will be run immediately.

    Libraries, for example, I think of as just collections of subroutines that effectively extend the language into computations the original specification didn't include. This seemed to be correct in the old days (ie. 1980s) but I don't know if it still is a good mental model.

    Libraries are essentially just code that people want to reuse, so they make it a library to make reusing it easy.

    Dependencies I think of as "you have to include this at the start of your program to load all those subroutines" — again, no idea if this is correct.

    Dependencies are code that the existing code relies on to provide stuff - it could be a math library, or a specific file reading library, etc.

    Usually this is done by specifying them at the top of each source code file.

    I've only ever programmed in an environment with an integrated editor/interpreter/compiler. Something like that would be nice.

    I don't know if anything like that is available for Python, but the tutorials/books/etc will all walk you through how to get things working.

    If nothing else a way to get started would be to go to the python website ( https://www.python.org/ ) and either choose the Get Started link on the main page, or on the menu select Documentation and then Beginners Guides.

    There is lots that can potentially get you started.

    I don't know Unix/Linux and would really prefer to avoid learning an OS to learn a language. Don't know if this is possible.

    macOS is very popular with programmers, thus you can do almost anything on your Mac.

    The only potential issue depends on how old your version of macOS is - if it is too old then you may need to find older versions of things, but hopefully that won't be a problem for you at this point.

    850:

    I guess this is one of those things where the walking distance is an order of magnitude or two greater than 50m, the driving distance is another order greater still, and in addition there may be dependencies on factors like surface conditions and state of the tide?

    851:

    Oh, and turning a double vodka mixed with some kind of fruit alcho-pop in pint glasses into lemonade in the bombed out hotel that looks like a High Rise set whilst spitting out the chewy rinds of a fruit that's really never been seen on Earth for a few thousand years
    Spiking the Solstice Party punch with [redacted[1]] + [Fruit], again? :-)
    I expect ... surprises.

    Also, nice tutorial on construction of a [Jewish scholar's] complicated joke.

    Re DIE ANTWOORD ft. The Black Goat ‘ALIEN’ (Official Video) (5:31) - Good video, thanks again for the link. (I've listened to that song a lot over the last few years.)

    UK 20th, Monday, big Paper wrap.
    mmm.

    [1] akin to Ayahuasca++?

    852:

    Some fun reads about US storms in 2021. (These guys used to write at Weather Underground.)
    Catastrophic December tornadoes slam Mid-Mississippi Valley. (Bob Henson December 11, 2021)

    Plains mega-cyclone shreds December weather history - Records were blown to smithereens amid Upper Midwest tornadoes, 1930s-style dust storms, and springlike warmth. (Bob Henson December 16, 2021)
    Nobody has published a global-heating attribution study for one or both of those, yet. Eyes are on jet stream disruptions, though.
    (FWIW, the Forsythia, a woody perennial ornamental that blooms in the early spring, is in bloom in my town in lower NY State. I have never seen a mid-December bloom before.)

    Also this one is amusing:
    Top-10 weirdest things about the bonkers 2021 Atlantic hurricane season - The season featured an insanely busy start followed by eerily quiet October, a tropical storm that formed over land, and two landfalls in Rhode Island, among other oddities. (Jeff Masters November 30, 2021)

    853:

    “I've only ever programmed in an environment with an integrated editor/interpreter/compiler. Something like that would be nice.”

    Geany and Thonny are apparently popular, enough so that they are provided by default on the Pi.

    Obligatory aside that built-in edit/debug/trace/code-management has been part of Smalltalk for decades, written in Smalltalk so you can edit the editor with editor, live. Etc. Debugging the debugger with the debugger can be much fun.

    854:

    The only potential issue depends on how old your version of macOS is - if it is too old then you may need to find older versions of things

    Based on his comments about a creaky old PowerMac at best that one will only support Mac OS X 10.5 which is from around 2006 or so. He didn't specify the exact model of the iMac but implied it wasn't all that new either.

    So he can buy a newer bug old MacMini which will run 10.12 or so and get to Python 2.9 or maybe 3.0 without a lot of fiddling.

    Of just spend less than $100 and get a nice Raspberry Pi. And be ready to go within minutes, maybe an hour.

    855:

    Oh yeah. My son in law wanted to learn Python so he bought a Raspberry Pi just to do that.

    856:

    Yep, and this year's Raspberry PI is probably more powerful than a Power Mac from 2006.

    857:

    And on 1/100th of the power. Those G5 cheese graters were great space heaters. Well for part of the year. The rest of the year they were a terrible thing to be near.

    858:

    Yes, in the early stages, developing into the loss of any clue that the config file might need considering at all. For instance if I search Bing for java logging I get, in order: some sort of promoted-looking result (promoted, skip), Oracle docs for a rather old version (old, skip), geeksforgeeks.org (shite, skip), and then this, which looks promising: http://www.marcobehler.com/guides/java-logging

    That looks like a pretty good introduction - it sets things out clearly, with simple examples, and remains clear when it starts talking about some of the horrible kludges that have got involved over the course of time and how to make your own code kludge-compatible. If I was really looking this stuff up because I needed to do it and didn't know how, I'd probably conclude on reading that page that I had found the answer, and probably also never find myself in future feeling any need to investigate in greater depth.

    And since there's nothing on that page that even hints at any need to take additional steps to ensure that the logged text doesn't get assumed to be an instruction to download and execute untrusted code, I can't see it ever crossing my mind that such a need might exist. Indeed, I'd be thinking that the logging library would be making sure that it doesn't exist: in case, for instance, the application might end up being used on a system that wrote logs to an SQL database instead of a file; part of the point of using the logging library is that in such a case it would insert the necessary escaping to keep Bobby Tables out automatically, instead of me having to anticipate that possibility and write my own code to keep him out if necessary. I certainly would not be expecting the library to - intentionally - include a feature, enabled by default, for issuing invitations to his bigger and nastier older brother.

    The tendency to use the term "zero day" in connection with the current kerfuffle isn't really accurate. It's not a case of someone having cocked up and nobody knowing about it until just now when some chance explosion brings it to people's attention; it's something that's been known about for years, ever since someone deliberately wrote the code with that effect as the explicit intention; and I don't think it's unreasonable to suppose that that someone must have made some mention of it at the time, because otherwise it's either daft or malicious to bother writing it at all. But in all the innumerable instances and iterations of people copying only the bits they need to make their current project start working, forgetting or ignoring the rest, and then the result becoming an example in its own right to be copied in turn, the knowledge has been lost.

    859:

    ...spiking the punch at the Ambassador's Ball with a mixture of yage, hashish and yohimbine, precipitating an orgy?

    860:

    Hi, folks.

    Just back from Worldcon. Yes, the con chair announced a staff member tested positive... even though they had tested negative on Thurs, Fri they were positive.

    Overwhelmingly, fen were wearing masks. Really. There were a few people, like an old friend, who complained the first day about claustrophobia, by the next day, he was keeping his nose covered.

    Con was good for me - got to connect with an agent from a very large agency, and she's interested in the next novel in my universe. Did my third reading, ever; I was with someone else, and together we had maybe 20 people... and afterwards, two folks I didn't know came up and bought my book.

    The in memorium, during the Hugos, was really hard. Ellen took hold of my hand - I personally knew and cared about too many people on that list.

    861:

    At Worldcon, first you showed your driver's license and your vaccination card, they stamped a card, and gave you the stamped card, and then you registered.

    862:

    Interesting. I'm somewhere between 1.78 and 1.8+ (I was 6' even, but that was before having both my knees partly replaced), and I'm just under 70.kg.

    863:

    Remember that some of those "dimensions" aren't physical - for example, a temperature range could be classified as a dimension.

    864:

    I understand that the county transit took over several former transit companies years back... then kept the same route numbers.

    I cannot fathom why anyone would name a bus line the L8. Their kids would laugh at them.

    865:

    Kindly note that the anime con had tens of thousands of anime fans, and presumably a lot were underage.

    Worldcon may have gone over 3k, but that might be with one-day memberships, and a lot of us are well over 21.

    866:

    Lightweight Portable Security (rebranded as Trusted End Node Security)

    Might be ended... but it was built by the DoD themselves.

    867:

    So, sort of like eastern Europe, esp., using Jews to collect taxes....

    868:

    Nope. Amin was recorded having someone driving a jeep, sorry, "tactical", and machinegunning people. The Former Guy, doing that? Not hardly.

    869:

    We're really happy - both of us are on Kaiser-Permanente, and it's one computer system. Every doctor/nurse that looks us up has all the correct info.

    870:

    Both when I had my knees done, and when I had the open heart surgery, they came in and wrote on me with magic markers.

    872:

    Re java - I agree. Back around '06 I tried to teach myself java, from one of the O'Reilly books.

    Gack. Trying to get a window up, and get information out of it, the only way I could find was to use a global - no, I'm not kidding.

    873:

    OO: in the mid-nineties, I took a course in OOPs and GUI (which always sounded to me as though someone had dropped a raw egg).

    OO design I found interesting. OOP? The closer you got to actually cutting code, the fuzzier and less comprehensible it got.

    And the ever popular "Oh, I need to write a paper, so I'll rename something, that's not passing a parameter, it's sending a message!"

    And... ok, the cover of the Jan 1994 IEEE Spectrum literally had OO as The Silver Bullet to the software backlog. And I saw - no, you can't argue with me, I can look it up, if I have to - that with OO, you'd never have null pointer exceptions, etc.

    Really.

    Debugging? Let me show you the dead typical apache tuxedo crash of 150 to 200 lines.

    In all the PL/1, or COBOL, or Pascal, or C I wrote, I never went 10 layers deep... and that includes the literal database system I personally wrote in (Ghu help me) Basica, or when I was using C-Tree.

    It's yet another "interesting technique, but then becomes the only tool you have, like a hammer, or recursion was in the eighties.

    874:

    What, like emacs? Or eclipse?

    875:

    Not wild about python. For one, I have issues with whitespace being used as a syntactic element.

    Then there's reliability. The first few versions, 20-15 years ago, each new major release broke whatever you'd done before, And that seems to still be true, at least to some degree (python 2.7, 3.x....)

    876:

    Drop MATLAB, ok, but just python? Did/do they not know about R? Where I was working, they used it heavily, and python has libraries to work with R.

    877:

    Ok, I don't understand, as usual, wtf you just said, but I was not especially unhappy with the Hugos. The three I really did not want to win went down and did not. The biggest disagreement I had was that I really wanted Ring Shout to win for novella.

    So, what's your problem, and don't give me Holy Book-level metaphor.

    878:

    Do you actually think that all of us are "oh, wow, Google supported Worldcon!? And Raytheon space and intell?

    And you think everyone was good with that, or are you saying that because we didn't stand up, scream, and walk out, we're complicit?

    IT'S A FUCKING WORLDCON, not a police action, nor a political campaign.

    And the secret service shtick - I've seen motorcades in DC, no where near what folks who live there for years have. It was a shtick, and nothing more.

    And how do you feel about pretty much all the biggest awards being won by women?

    879:

    "when I had the open heart surgery, they came in and wrote on me with magic markers."

    ...what, like "This side"?

    So! You are a Time Lord!

    880:

    Books like that... ok, did you ever read "Man's Rise To Civilization"? https://www.amazon.com/Civilization-Indians-America-Primeval-Industrial/dp/0525152695

    Can't say I have. But if he's doing the band, clan, village, chiefdom civilization thing...

    Here's an example of the problem with that logic: Western shoshone and various other desert groups tend to spend most (not all!) their time in family groupings. Are they primitive? The better first question is: can they live sustainably in any higher density in a place like, say, Death Valley. If not, then they're not going to build a city there, are they?* Social density is irrelevant in places where it's unsupportable.

    And (riffing on Graeber) are these wandering bands politically and socially unsophisticated? Well possibly, possibly not. Do you know how to figure out how many people can live together in a resource-poor desert for a period of time? That's essentially what politicians do, solve social and resource problems without violence. Conversely, if you proudly don't vote and don't engage in politics because it's not what nice engineers do, can you properly claim that you're more politically astute than some tribesman who knows how to keep his chief from turning into a massive dick and violently enforcing his orders? Probably not. So who's more politically astute, the primitive tribesman or the interchangeable office drone?

    This is the value in Graeber's work: he makes it possible to question the status quo. I can agree with the questions he asks without agreeing with the material he presents to make his case.

    *Note to Elon: do try out your Mars base designs before asking Amazon Prime to ship them to Mars for your crew. That's a good chap.

    881:

    Sell out the entire SF cannon to fucking Raytheon?

    (Not mine originally, but anyway:)

    Hey, at least Murderbot Diaries got the series Hugo and Network Effect (a Murderbot novel) got the novel Hugo, so inviting a real murderbot company there is nice! (Or not.)

    882:

    Ilya87
    Some years ago, the "health officialdom" in this country decided to set supposed "Safe Limits" for alchohol consumption per week.
    They came up with 20-30 "units" per week, a unit being 10ml of pure alcohol - itself thought to be on the low side, OK? Not too long after that, it was publicly admitted that the number had very-little-to-zero actual experimental, scientific basis, as evaluated by actual measurements.
    More recently, the number was, quite arbitrarily, dropped to 14/15 "units" - it turned out that the committee doing the work had been got at & suborned by nasty little puritan christian-&-muslim arseholes. These "limits" are not worth the bog paper they are written on, but they are, the "official limits" - & if you admit to ( Shock, Horror! ) drinking 3 pints of beer & 4-5 bottles of wine per week, then you are an irresponsible, hopeless drunk etc ... Fucking lies from beginning to end. How to encourage trust in government & the Medical Profession - NOT.

    Bill Arnold
    Yes - plants that should be dormant, are not + more still in flower, or look like flowering early.

    whitroth
    "Dimensions"; - Length, Mass, Time, Temperature, Current, Light ( amount ), Matter (amount = Moles)
    Everything physical & measurable can be quantified using combinations of the above ...
    #893 - I see you are having problems as well - see below - though you appear to have extracted SOME meaning ( #894).

    Moderators: # 850, 855, 861, 862, 863, 868, 875, 879, 882, 886, 888 Oh & note - 850 looks like a scream for help, except, as usual it makes no sense, because missing INFORMATION.
    References to the US "defence" contractor, Raytheon - which then dribbles off into making no sense.

    883:

    It appears that some people are taking time out of their day to to defend the Raytheon sponsorship, at least as tweeted by an Ilhan Omar communication staffer. I don't know who the screenshots are of; doesn't appear to be any of the written fiction nominees.

    https://twitter.com/isaiah_bb/status/1472550125042032640

    In most people's defense, the sponsorship appears to have been sprung at the very end of the show; I don't know that intention can really be ascribed to the average attendee.

    884:

    843 - Some years ago (I'll be hazy on dates here I'm afraid) the UK government introduced "safe limits" for alcohol consumption of 28 units a week for males, and 14 units a week for females. There was no scientific basis stated for these limits at this time.
    More recently, these limits were reduced to no more than 14 units per week for males and females alike, and again no scientific basis for doing this was ever stated. 882 also refers, in similar terms.

    846 - Libraries and Dependencies you're on the right lines with. For example, in Ada, if I want to calculate the area of a circle without using a user-created "magic" number I would write:-

    package Area_of_Circle ;

    with Math ;
    new function "**" return Long_float is Math."** (left, right : Long_float ) " ;

    Radius : Long_float := 0.0 ; -- Initialise input variable

    Area : Long_float ; -- No need to initialise since first use will be a write

    function Area_of_Circle is ;

    return Area := Radius ** 2.0 * Math.Pi ;

    end function ;

    end package ;

    Which is a bit long winded, but illustrates the use of the standard library Math to set a dependency (my unit is dependent on Math), perform exponention and declare a named constant. (BTW Charlie, please note the number of backslash characters I had to use here)

    860 - Thanks; the personal account confirms my sister's and my opinion of "Covid testing" as "means you did not have Covid on the date of test".

    870 - I've had 3 procedures on my left wrist, and in all 3 cases the consultant drew on my left forearm with magic marker, and the anaethsatist looked for/at the drawn marks.

    873 - My mileage does not vary significantly from this. When I talk about "object based" code I mean creating a complex action that you use twice or more in your program as a callable sub-program.

    876 - I, for one, have never even heard of R, but have at least heard of Matlab and python.

    885:

    R is bit in statistics land I believe. I have friends who swear by it but have never picked it up myself.

    For those with matlab code and employers who don't like paying for it there's a free open source alternative called octave that's mostly compatible.

    886:

    It is, however, fair to accuse both the design, implementation and documentation of excess sloppiness. While Python is not the worst language (or implementation or documentation), it's pretty bad. Its compiler is the sort of thing that gets computer scientists a bad name.

    If you want a properly designed language, you have to go to Ada, Fortran, Cobol and a few others. As far as I know, there are no scripting languages that fall into that category - while I have never used Rust, I have looked at it, and am doubtful that it is one. Without a solid design, the implementations and documention will necessarily be iffy.

    887:

    Emacs - sort of, if you are a hacker. It requires quite a lot of arcane configuration to force it into fundamental mode, and it's still prone to insane aberrations that mangle your text horribly. It's my primary editor, so I know. Some of the incantations to disable its 'cleverness' that I use include:

    (setq interpreter-mode-alist nil)

    (setq auto-mode-alist '((".*" . fundamental-mode)))

    (add-hook 'lisp-interaction-mode-hook 'fundamental-mode)

    (setq indent-tabs-mode nil)

    (electric-indent-mode -1)

    I took a look at eclipse, and am not going there. God alone knows what the editor is like, but it's another of the infernal 'just install me and I will take over your environment' monstrosities. No way.

    Think ex (vi if you must), gedit, jedit and so on.

    888:

    R is bit in statistics land I believe.

    Yes. It seems that research labs are big users. Where they might generate a few 100 million data points. Or even billions.

    I was at a local Dev Ops get together where someone was talking about an add on or similar to R that was allowing them to watch trends in real time in data when thousands or millions of data points were rolling in non stop. Or similar. It was a few years ago.

    889:

    Right. To clarify, Python is a good choice for that sort of thing.

    The easiest way to do it is to be really old-fashioned, use Linux and use the basic command-line tools (no IDE) but, for you, that's quite a lot to learn before you start. I know that it is possible in a Macintosh environment, but I don't know how - when I have to use one, I fire up a terminal and use the command-line tools.

    Be chary of IDEs. If they don't do exactly what you want to, they can double your effort and, worse, actually harm what you are trying to do. A common problem is when you want to insert some experimental or broken code into your main program to clarify the specification (*), but do NOT want to risk it being included permanently. Many IDEs don't make that easy. Command-line means that it's easy to take a safe copy and restore it, reliably.

    (*) I do that frequently with Python REs, similarly complex libraries, and particularly revolting data formats.

    890:

    885 and 888 - Thanks guys. I do do stats programming myself, and had still never heard of R. I actually mostly roll my own in a mixture of Ada, Excel and Visual Basic (for cross sector compatibility of algorithms).

    891:

    Command-line means that it's easy to take a safe copy and restore it, reliably.

    This might be a bit advanced for Robert, but personally I use version control for basically all code I write. This means I can have a known working code and then can return to that from basically any state, with no copying and keeping track of which file was which manually.

    I've been using different version control systems for over twenty years, so I'm not a good person to tell if they are easy to use or not. Personally, I use 'git' for everything version control related, but it has somewhat of a steep learning curve. I'm not sure if simple 'just use this and it should work' guides around, probably there are.

    892:

    Robert Prior @ 846:

    Libraries, for example, I think of as just collections of subroutines that effectively extend the language into computations the original specification didn't include.

    Yes, but turned up to 11. Key differences these days are:

  • Libraries depend on other libraries, which depend on other libraries. Its libraries all the way down. Hence the term "stack" for the environment your program runs in.

  • Managing this stack of dependencies turns out to be a big issue. Libraries have version numbers, and those version numbers are included in dependencies. Somewhere you will have a package manager which does constraint solving to manage all this and get you a (constantly evolving) consistent set of libraries. When this works, its great. When it goes wrong debugging it can be a major pain. Details depend on the language and tooling you are using.

  • Because of (2) you need to declare in a build configuration file of some kind exactly what versions of what libraries you are using. These are your direct dependencies. They of course have their own dependencies, which for you are "indirect" dependencies. You may be able to get "hello world" running without all this, but once you start writing real code this tooling will save you a lot of tedious work; you're going to learn it sooner or later, so better make it sooner.

  • Reference documentation is derived from the code. Each exported module and function has a header comment written in a language-dependent mark-up. A dedicated tool chews through these comments, integrates them with data derived from parsing the actual source code, and generates hyperlinked HTML. This makes it a lot easier to keep the reference documentation in sync with the actual code. Examples and tutorials, not so much.

  • Within the Python code itself you also need to "import" each library module you want to use. That brings the functions declared in the library into the namespace (i.e. list of named things) in your code. Yes, "load all those subroutines", but potentially much more sophisticated for e.g. two libraries you want to use both use the same name for something.

    When you want to do something, your first thought should be "does a library already exist to do this?". Your second thought should be "Which of the N libraries I just found with Google are reliable, well-documented, and are still being maintained?".

    I've only ever programmed in an environment with an integrated editor/interpreter/compiler. Something like that would be nice. I don't know Unix/Linux and would really prefer to avoid learning an OS to learn a language. Don't know if this is possible.

    Never used it myself, but it sounds like the Python extension to Visual Studio is what you want. Visual Studio has a free (as in beer) Community Edition.

    You should also learn how to use version control, even if you aren't collaborating with anyone else yet. Every programmer has had the experience of going down a blind alley, spending a week modifying code in a way that they eventually discover doesn't work, and then needing to unwind all their changes. Routine use of version control makes this easy. Most developers use "git". Its big, powerful and complicated. Fortunately Visual Studio has a front-end for it. You can also make your code open source by having a free repository with GitHub or similar site. Again, you don't need that for "hello world", but you are going to have to learn it sooner or later, so make it sooner.

    I have no idea what you're talking about with wrapping code. I would guess that it is a way of using code written in one language in another language?

    Yes. Python is flexible and novice-friendly, but also very slow (a bit like a modern incarnation of Basic). Other languages like C and Fortran are designed to run like greased lightning, but are much harder to program in. So experts in numerical computing have built libraries in C and Fortran that run very fast, and then Python developers have added "wrapper" libraries which provide a Python API ("Application Programmer Interface": the bit of a library you need to know to use it) for the low-level C or Fortran.

    The only downside is that now your stack of dependencies includes stuff written in another language, which in turn has its own way of dealing with dependency management.

    When you run into a problem try Stack Exchange. Learn how to search it, and learn how to ask the right kind of question.

    893:

    Note to mods/sysadmin: I tried to use Markdown numbered lists in my post @ 892, but they have come out as mostly-obscured bullets.

    894:

    Me @ 892: Never used it myself, but it sounds like the Python extension to Visual Studio is what you want.

    Arrghh, kicks self. I forgot to mention Atom which is the open source alternative. I use Atom on Linux for all my coding, so I have no idea why I didn't think of it earlier.

    895:

    Remember that I started before there were such things, and so taught myself how to do equivalent things, manually. I have used half a dozen version control systems in my time, and every single one prevented me from doing what I needed to do, FAR more than it helped. I gave up on trying the latest and greatest some time ago, because life was too short.

    896:

    Well, yeah, I first used version control more than ten years after I started programming, and for the next ten years after that I didn't really see the point using it at home (used at least ClearCase and CVS), because they were so terrible to use.

    Then at work we tried to use Subversion and later git, and those made things much easier than the earlier ones. Setting up and using CVS was a pain, but with git you can basically do 'git init' in the directory your code is in and then start using about five commands which is enough for most purposes, especially when doing it just for yourself.

    Nowadays I find copying versions manually mostly annoying, but then again, I've probably changed my ways of working to work with git, too. *shrug* I'm not sure I'd have the patience to learn it now if I didn't know to use it, but then again, I'm doing Kubernetes stuff at home, to learn how it works, so I'm not sure about even that.

    897:

    The problem is that the standard for documentation and examples is set by the full time professionals maintaining larger packages. Like log4j, to pick a topical example.

    Those professionals are, in general, professional programmers, not technical authors, QA testers, or other specialists.

    Read my (metaphorical) lips: programmers can't write documentation. (At least, 90%-95% of them.) It's a specialized skill set in its own right that involves being able to crawl all over the codebase then look at it afresh, as an outsider, and work out how to explain it to the aforementioned outsiders who will be using it. The developer is the wrong person to do this because they already know why they need it, how it works, and what the gotchas are. Of those three points they might right down some notes about the gotchas ... or they might be so used to them that they think it's intuitively obvious and doesn't need documenting.

    (I've been in the trenches on both sides of this argument and can attest: it's really hard to put yourself into the mindset of a new user of something you wrote. Also, most programmers think writing documentation is easy. The number of times I've received a blank look and been told, "just read the source code" ...)

    898:

    892 and 893 - I wasn't actively aware that Markdown "did bullets and/or numbering", but the format appears, shall we say unusual? here. It goes sort of

    "bullet
    CRLF
    text CRLF
    bullet
    CRLF..." rather than

    "bullet indent text
    bullet indent text...".

    899:

    paws4thot, I was trying to do it like this.

    900:

    You are completely correct there. In my work (as a developer, or 'software engineer' as there's much more than just writing code involved in the work), we have the responsibility to document our interfaces to other teams using them, and it's... not easy.

    We are lucky enough to have good enough documenters, and internal teams give comments if they can't understand, so we can improve it, but it's still not easy.

    Then I had a discussion with some friends about writing adcopy about software, and that's even further away from your regular developer. The people who can develop software and handle search engine optimization are not that common...

    (Also doing lists is easy enough with Markdown, using (on sequential lines)

    [space]* first item

    [space]* second item

    [space][space]* sub-item

    which gives:

    • first item
    • second item
      • sub-item

    Two things that don't work here from common Markdown are code and code blocks, that is, using a single grave accent or three of them for code blocks and I'm not sure why. They should give monospaced text and perhaps a different background, but even escaped they don't show up in the rendered comment text. I tried to escape them but only got the backslashes...)

    901:

    I wasn't actively aware that Markdown "did bullets and/or numbering"

    It appears to fo bullets by taking a leading asterisk as the cue that the paragraph should be bulleted. That has caught a few people who use an asterisk as a footnote symbol*.

    • Like this, which looks like an asterisk when I type it but shows up as a bullet when posted.
    902:

    Gonna contact my MPP's office on Monday and ask them how to best go about getting this resolved, and ensuring that it doesn't happen again.

    Well, that didn't do much good. Office closed until January and not answering emails or messages until then.

    My federal MP (Liberal) is still working this week — I'm meeting him Wednesday about another matter, but as health is a provincial responsibility he can't help me.

    So all I can do is wait for a callback from Waterloo Public Health, apparently.

    903:

    Various from 897 on, on software engineers writing documentation. At my place we try to avoid writing our own documentation and absolutely insist that if Joe wrote it, he needs to have it reviewed by Fred or Barney. If Tina the technical author wrote it, she needs to have it reviewed by 2 from Paws, Joe, Fred and Barney!

    From 898 on, on Markdown. Ok, I only even heard of Markdown a couple of weeks back and am still learning the spec, never mind all the formatting. Still, from this I've taken that starting a line "spacebarasterisk" creates a bulleted item, terminating one "spacebarspacebar" creates a CRLF instruction, and to reliably include underscore or asterisk characters in my text requires me to type "backslashunderscore" or "backslashasterisk" every time.
    OK, it is what it is, but I do actually have a ScotVEC certificate in Word Processing, and am less than impressed by any product or standard that uses white space as any form of formatting.

    904:

    Me @ 892: Never used it myself, but it sounds like the Python extension to Visual Studio is what you want.

    He's on a Mac, so Visual Studio is not an option.

    905:

    Of just spend less than $100 and get a nice Raspberry Pi. And be ready to go within minutes, maybe an hour.

    He will be spending more than C$100 for a Raspberry Pi setup.

    And of course the bigger problem is that it is Linux, which sounds like it might be a bit too much extra learning.

    While I understand the issues rather than spending $100+ on a Raspberry Pi he is likely better off allocating that to an eventual budget to get a newer Mac that will not only allow him to do the Python stuff but all his other computing needs going forward.

    906:

    I have only worked in one place that generated decent documentation.

    Programmers wrote draft documentation that was passed to a tech writer in the next room who would come and ask questions before throwing it away and writing something meaningful.

    It requires a high level of cooperation, skilled writers and ideally colocation.

    This was documentation for programmers, not end users. I don't think I ever saw a programmer written paragraph survive the process intact.

    Nobody else I have worked for has bothered, and it shows.

    907:

    Regarding python and data science

    There are fairly good (and free) online university classes for modern data science. I’d really consider taking one those, there is a ton of (well meaning ) disinformation in this thread (along with some fairly good advice) and you will never sort through the good from the bad on your own.

    You absolutely do not need to buy anything including any kind of new finite hardware assuming you have a working computer running a relatively modern version of a common OS.

    If you want an integrated IDE you should consider Anaconda which packages a bunch of things together. Including Jupyter notebooks which is the go-to IDE for data science.

    908:

    He will be spending more than C$100 for a Raspberry Pi setup.

    I think he already has a keyboard and mouse. Plus most of us have a display of some kind that can be driven via an HDMI cable.

    He might need to buy a power lump and/or power cable.

    He's in the Toronto area so he can also hit up BestBuy for something from Cana Kit for a few $$$ more.

    And it matters if he goes with 3 or 4.

    Personally I have all the bits needed except for the pi 4 board and it's memory. Others may not have as much lying around. (My wife will suggest I send some of it to anyone who asks but that's not what I want to do.)

    And I think it requires more Canadian $$$ than US $$$ at this time to buy the same thing.

    909:

    Visual Studio Code, though, that's on Macs. I use it as a glorified syntax-highlighting editor, but I think it can go a lot further.

    Otherwise, Visual Studio for Mac

    910:

    I think getting enough PI to run a desktop was around $80 U.S. This included a fan (which might not be needed,) power supply, micro-HDMI to HDMI cable, and an SSD card. I already had the mouse/keyboard and a monitor which accepted HDMI.

    The big revelation was that this was plenty of computer to run a desktop (note that I don't play complex video-games.) I used a variant of XFCE as my GUI - not sure if a PI will run Gnome or KDE - and all the usual Linux desktop tools and was quite happy.

    911:

    I am fairly sure I'll never learn to program, nor even to use Markdown. I have done a few hamfisted attempts at html, but I focus on other skills. I'm glad some of you are programmers in the same way I'm glad people are plumbers and paramedics - it needs to be done and it won't be done by me.

    A large percentage of maintenance manuals and other such documentation were clearly written as afterthoughts by the engineers or their minions. They require a lot of reading between the lines and inference, and often some web searching to figure out what they thought was obvious because they'd been working on it full time - but is completely opaque to anyone who is not them.

    The skillset for engineer does not always overlap with the skillset for communicator. On the flip side my wife is an excellent communicator and has built a career on same, but has only a 50% chance of using the correct end of a screwdriver.

    A close friend of mine, who is a world leading cancer scientist and statistician, called me to his house yesterday in despair. He had spent several hours trying to troubleshoot a faulty electrical outlet. He and his wife had systematically flipped each of the circuit breakers in the house with no success. He wanted me to confirm that he should call an electrician.

    The outlet was outdoors and consequently had a Ground Fault Interruptn(GFI) switch. When I reset it he immediately suggested that I never speak of this to his wife.

    912:

    starting a line "spacebarasterisk" creates a bulleted item

    Actually, asteriskspace creates a bulleted item.

    913:

    He's on a Mac

    Specifically, an iMac running OS 10.12 (Sierra). I'm not expecting the older MacPro running Lion to run modern software!

    914:

    There are fairly good (and free) online university classes for modern data science. I’d really consider taking one those, there is a ton of (well meaning ) disinformation in this thread (along with some fairly good advice) and you will never sort through the good from the bad on your own.

    Could you recommend one? My experience with free university classes has been very mixed, tending towards negative.

    915:

    It used to be SOP, way back when. The key was that the programmers wrote the code and documentation, AND did the support! There's nothing like the last for getting feedback, both on obscure documentation and on user-hostility in the program. I and others found that it actually helped to spend an extra factor of two on both the user interface (mainly diagnostics) and documentation, because of the reduction in the number of support calls.

    But we live in a different world :-( You might be surprised at how often I have been flamed for pointing out the evidence in the last sentence of the previous paragraph by people who were responsible for all three aspects!

    916:

    The skillset for engineer does not always overlap with the skillset for communicator.

    Understatement of the year!

    When we took a technical writing course at engineering college our prof (a practicing engineer) told us that more engineers lose their jobs because they can't communicate clearly than because of technical incompetence.

    When I saw the documentation at BNR/Nortel, I believed him.

    917:

    The key was that the programmers wrote the code and documentation, AND did the support! There's nothing like the last for getting feedback, both on obscure documentation and on user-hostility in the program.

    Back in the 80s I linked up with a new long-distance provider. What sold me was that the technical support people all knew telephony — they were the guys who actually ran the network. They even took suggestions about improving instructions. Eventually as the company grew technical support because a separate department who just read scripts, quality dropped, and I left them.

    918:

    I think he already has a keyboard and mouse. Plus most of us have a display of some kind that can be driven via an HDMI cable.

    He might need to buy a power lump and/or power cable.

    Raspberry Pi 4 with 4GB is C$70 (plus C$11 shipping), and that is the board only.

    Add in a power supply and likely a microSD card and he is above C$100, and he likely also needs a Micro-HDMI cable given how rare they tend to be.

    Everyone likes to throw around the nice cheap US$ price for the boards only, and that's great if you are in the US and already have all the necessary pieces.

    If you are outside the US and/or need to buy those extra pieces the price climbs quickly.

    919:

    If you are outside the US and/or need to buy those extra pieces the price climbs quickly.

    Such as a monitor, keyboard, and mouse (no spares).

    920:

    Well, I decided to contact the office of the doctor that administered the shot I didn't get, on the off-chance that they could do something. I actually got a call back within the hour taking health card details, so another possibility there.

    Contacted the premier's office, but not expecting much response there. Mostly making certain his staff know that there's a problem — I suspect they are also closed for the holidays (at least for dealing with the public).

    Waiting. I hate waiting.

    921:

    I'd very much like to read something on the subject by someone who knows what they are talking about and can be trusted not to cherry-pick data or make bogus leaps of logic. Any suggestions?

    Ummmm, after doing some digging....

    Fair warning, I haven't read this, but I just bought it because of who wrote it:Money: The True History of a Made-Up Thing. This is from the co-host of the Planet Money podcast, and it's pretty obvious from the table of contents and index that he's assembling a bunch of his reportage (some of which I've heard) into a book. That said, what I've heard from him seems well-researched. So pay your money and take your chances, if it helps.

    922:

    I will ask but the university of Michigan ones on coursera look ok

    They will general want you to learn the basics of the language first and then move into the data science part but here is one as a seed

    https://www.coursera.org/learn/python-data-analysis

    923:

    Re: ' ... the office of the doctor that administered the shot I didn't get, on the off-chance that they could do something. I actually got a call back within the hour taking health card details, so another possibility there.'

    Sounds positive - I wonder whether that doctor (or one of his/her health ministry contacts) can access your file for details. I'm guessing that this should be feasible since it's fairly certain that at least one doc sometime in the past made an error on a patient's file and later had to correct it.

    924:

    Ok, it is a few bucks more than piecing it together yourself, but may I suggest: https://www.raspberrypi.com/products/raspberry-pi-400/

    You can find them on Big River for US$99 or less.

    925:

    I'd be interested in your cmts, if you care to read it. Note it's from 40 years ago, so you might find it in a library. And yes, he does talk about families, etc. The lowest level, IIRC, were the Utes, who lived in an incredibly harsh land, separated into small family bands most of the year because they needed a large territory to keep from starving, but gathered once a year for a buffalo run.

    926:

    Um, charm? Spin (that isn't really rotating)? Etc.

    927:

    Being a member of BWAWA, and was, early, in meetings, I did, eventually, hear about Google (and was not happy, but money right now is really tight for cons). I did not know about Raytheon Space and Intel until I got to the con, which was an unpleasant surprise.

    However, mostly, we were enthused and enchanted to be at a con again, and see friends....

    928:

    Working for 10 years at the NIH, I assure you a lot of people there, and in colleges (who can't afford MATLAB) use R very heavily, and the python interface as well.

    I worked with a guy - I was a sr. Linux sysadmin, and so administering the system he was mostly on, seriously honkin' big - who was working with snips of DNA. At a talk he gave late in '13, he mentioned some library research he'd done, and he found published work with 300 snips and 800 snips.

    He was working with 64,000 snips. His jobs would run for literally 2-3 weeks, with only him on the box, running Linux, with .75TB RAM, and I forget how many cores.

    He told me he'd had his paper published in the spring of '14.

    R is heavily used.

    929:

    I taught myself Python from the tutorials at docs.python.org, mostly because I couldn't find a good SNOBOL implementation :). I needed to analyze the code dependencies on a working system (who is using these libraries?, and what packages did they come with?). Later, I wrote a program that, using a description of a state machine in a spreadsheet created documentation, graphic representation, and code template of the state machine. There was one plug-in for the reading the spreadsheet, another for creating the Word document, and another (graphviz) for creating the graphics. All very powerful.

    As for the language itself, I think it is a deliberately designed to enrage anybody that is used to a sane computer language. It reminds me of programming in Basic, it is mostly interpreted (I know it says it is compiled, but so much happens at run time, this is extremely limited), there is NO static typing, you can screw up and add a field to a class with a simple typo. Types can change with no feedback (ah, you were storing an array here, did you really want to just store a string?). I have seen code that does checks to see what type a field is before accessing it, which just seems really stupid to me. (Classes are just maps, with the field name the key, and any variable can store anything, a list, a map (hash table), a tuple, a string, a number, a function reference, etc). It is very powerful, but very error prone and good luck trying to figure out where it went bad.

    I got exposed to Swift about a year ago, and in some ways it seems like a static typed Python. I have heard Rust and Swift are closely related, but I have no experience with that. (Both Swift and Rust are fully compiled, and there is an effort to put modules written in Rust into the Linux kernel).

    930:

    I use vi/vim. I do know how to get out of emacs once I get in.... 20 years ago, a buddy referred to emacs as a windowing operating system masquerading as a text editor.

    For editors, and an IDE, I still miss Brief, which on pc's, was the editor of choice late eighties/good part of the nineties.

    Now, if anything had a Brief emulation mode....

    931:

    Not my taste. For some years, nineties/early oughts, I was also version control, and really liked PVCS.

    The whole concept of several people checking out a code file, each working on it, and then merging makes me want a drink. I'd have broken the file into several, and each would check out what they were working on, WITH A LOCK, and nobody else on that file.

    932:

    sigh Documentation.

    IIRC, some big name programmer back in the late sixties published a paper (ok, it might have come out of April 1 of that year) Comments Considered Dangerous (just think of all the toner in the air!).

    My preferred code documentation are flow charts. I can code directly from them, and what's happening is clear.

    I've seen database ant trails in the nineties that were nightmares.

    Then there's user documentation, which is completely different than code documentation. And which requires you to ignore the manager, and let actual end users look at it....

    My article on making useful documentation was published in SysAdmin mag in '06. http://24.5-cent.us/egoless_docu.html

    933:

    One more thing, for the non-programmers here: python, I think, is compiled as you run it. Real programming languages, like C or COBOL, etc, are compiled, then run - all the .exe or whatever - are compiled. They run fast.

    Then there are interpreted languages, like Basic, and a lot of others. You go into an interpreter, or you write the code, and feed it to an interpreter, and it runs them. Much, much slower... but a faster development cycle. Not used for something that really, really NEEDS to run fast, such as where you're loading a huge amount of data into it.

    Then there's assembly, and that's a whoooooole 'nother story.

    934:

    whitroth
    Rotational Angle ( In Radians ) is sometimes included, sometimes not.

    935:

    912 - I think I may have proved at least one of my points from the statement you selectively quoted.

    928 - To repeat, I did not say "people do not use R"; I said more like "No-one I work with uses R".

    929 - So Python is "compiled" to some form of intermediate code (and I guess compile syntax checked at that time), and the intermediate code is interpreted at run time?

    932 - My preferred form of code/design documentation is pseudo-code.

    936:

    I have used vcs's, but not the modern networked ones like subversion and git. (More like sccs, rcs, vcs ...)

    One of my big irritants is folks who tell me I need to use git or subversion for writing fiction and change tracking. No I don't. Fiction "projects" are typically a single flat text file, no forks, no merges, only a single user at any time. Even rcs was overkill for my needs. Worst case you might be collaborating with another author ... big deal: it's still a semaphore-passing exercise where only one of you is writing new material at a time. (I don't generally do multi-author concurrent shared world projects.)

    Scrivener doesn't play nice with version control systems but it has its own snapshotting system built in, which is more than adequate for solo writing needs.

    937:

    There's a whole class of languages -- Perl was the first, I think, followed in quick succession by Python, Ruby, Lua, et al -- which are implemented using an interpiler. In the case of Perl, first it builds a syntax tree then it executes it: so it generally only parses once, making it much faster than a traditional interpreted language like BASIC or Tcl, although potentially slower than a compiled language insofar as every program run starts with a compilation step. But a side-effect is that a program can evaluate new statements on the fly (kicking it back into compile-time mode), a capability purely compiled languages lack. IIRC Python also works this way, with the added twist of saving the bytecode as a .pyc which acts as a cache for the compilation step. Oh, and Raku (formerly Perl 6) also has multiple implementations -- unlike Perl 5, there's a language spec separate from the reference implementation -- including compilers.

    Upshot: post-1990 interpreted languages may be closer to compiled languages than you might expect: the boundaries are blurred.

    938:

    For me, if I'm making what might be serious changes, I just change the name to title_1.docx.

    But I agree - there's no real reason for version control in writing. (Well, unless you want to leave the versions for your descendants to sell to academics to publish papers about how you changed your Great Work. )

    939:

    Perl wasn't hardly the first, says Mr. awk-lover.

    940:

    programmers can't write documentation... It's a specialized skill set in its own right

    I know, and I treasure the few technical writers who volunteer with open source projects, and the companies that employ writers to work on documentation for open source.

    The sad/scary thing is that comments in code are also documentation, and it's hard to write good ones, and even harder to explain to management why I'm bothering. We have a wiki, but my code also has occasional essays where I explain a problem, why various solutions don't work, where the test program(s) are, and what the profiler says. I have in a past job had to revert those essays back into the code after cow-orkers "cleaned up" all the gibberish and just left the code. Once after improving the code by rewriting in a commented-out "this looks as though it should work but..." bit of code. That stuff makes for fun times in bug review meetings.

    Current project has a 2000+ line file called something like "is the panel online.cpp" that has one small function in it and a great deal of discussion, including multiple links to the wiki and references to emails. Because history shows that what management think of as "this panel is online" is neither simple nor obvious.

    The function looks roughly like this:

    OnlineStatus IsPanelOnline(OnlineStatus portOne, OnlineStatus portTwo, Magic magic)

    Where there's a little const matrix relating the various online status values of the two interfaces to the overall online status, with a carve-out for the magic option that makes a panel claim to be online even if it's not (don't ask. Just don't).

    (I couldn't guess the right markdown syntax to get a code snippet so I reverted to the good old %;lt;tt> tags. Likewise you get PascalCase because I can't be bothered escaping underscore)

    941:

    I like the idea of literate programming, but sadly I currently work in C++ and Rust which actively work to prevent literacy. It's annoying, but I kind of try at least for the main function in each file (which goes at the top!)

    The whole "comments considered dangerous" idea is great, and has a lot of truth in it, but it is widely taken to mean that comments shouldn't be used and everyone should just start from scratch reading the code every single time. Which is... kind of ok, for single programmers working on small projects. But as we saw with unix "many small utilities chained" and then again with OO, and then again with blah blah whatever and today with docker images... the complexity has to go somewhere, and wherever that is should be explicit and there has to be an explanation of how it works. Ideally not "ask Bob, they know" because that just adds a bus problem to your other problems ("Bob walks under a bus")

    Right now I work with a system that has a clusterfuck of load balancers, failover managers, monitoring systems, alerts and god only knows what else. One person set it up, and I hope understands it, but I think there's roughly no chance at all of anyone else discovering how it works if we have a bus problem. We'll just have to employ a new person and get them to re-create the bits they can't work out.

    My bit at the back end is a monolithic C++ application that is internally split up in a vaguely plausible way and has at least some high level documentation (data flow diagrams, some text, plots of how the major classes relate to each other, even some rough timing and profiling descriptions). I like to think that a reasonably experienced programmer could take it over and maintain it while they came to grips with the delightful randomness of choices I made 5 years ago when I was trying to learn enough C++ to make the prototype go...

    942:

    I think the decision was strongly influenced by a few people at work who had management's ear and were heavily into the latest "hot and sexy" gamechanger - AI etc. So we were encouraged to use licence fee alternatives like Python - though not exclusively so - and because a few colleagues seemed already to be using it successfully we followed on the basis if we got knocked down by a No8 Omnibus there would be someone in the office who could pick up the pieces.

    Also, as most of what I do is image processing, data reduction and instrumentation control a bias toward stats didn't add much we needed.

    Stuff like its apparently random variable typing, use of global variables (they were a non-no in most languages by the 90s, I'm only surprised GOTOs are not advocated) and the ability to insert functions within functions are irksome.

    943:

    I've had excellent luck buying monitors at thrift stores. Goodwill usually allows 7 days to exchange any electronics.

    944:

    You don't need a spare mouse/kbd/display to use a Pi. So long as you have a machine that can run a VNC client (the usual default one is RealVNC, from the people that pretty much originated it) you can just power up the Pi, configure it to talk VNC and Robert is your father's brother. It's how I use my dozen or so Pi's.

    Sierra is supported so just go to https://www.realvnc.com/en/connect/download/vnc/macos/ to download.

    To set up a Pi for VNC, see https://www.raspberrypi.com/documentation/computers/remote-access.html#vnc

    You could even go so far as to set things up to have the Pi netboot, thus avoiding the need to even have a uSD card involved, though that may well be more effort than you feel up to handling. If you're buying a uSD card, the best ones appear to be SanDisk A1 types and I'd suggest a 32Gb one as the sweet spot for price/capacity. You'll need to download the imager program to copy the OS data file to the card; see https://www.raspberrypi.com/software/

    The default Raspberry Pi OS includes everything you'd need to get going. https://raspberrypi.com is where you go for the best information; definitely not farcebook or reddit or any of the other dodgy places.

    945:

    Does anyone write anything in awk large enough that precompiling it makes sense? (Okay, so regexps, maybe ...)

    I will note that Perl is such a strict superset of awk that from Perl 3 onwards, the utility a2p that came bundled with Perl essentially compiled awk programs into Perl. (Also s2p, for sed.)

    946:

    Ah yes, that reminds me, where's Tolkien's git account?

    947:

    To put this in more concrete terms, lets suppose I want to start with nomographs. Here is a project that generates them using Python.

    http://pynomo.org/wiki/index.php/Main_Page

    Can you point me to a good place to learn what I need to learn to run this package? Something suitable for a Bear of Very Little Brain…

    There's good news and bad news.

    The good news is that someone has put up a playground for PyNomo (linked from the above): http://46.101.125.20:8080/

    That means you can just type code into a web page and it will produce PyNomo output for you if you do it right (note - I have not tested it!).

    This is very... trusting of the person running the server, and while it's fine for playing around with you obviously shouldn't run anything that you care about on someone else's computer.

    The bad news is that PyNomo is sitting atop a fairly tall stack of dependencies including TeX/LaTeX in addition to Python.

    To get things running on your Mac (assuming it's an Intel mac), the process will look something like:

    I imagine that this will take a lot of disk space, and may take some time. But once you're done you will not only have PyNomo installed but also have a working Python 3.8 environment you can use for other things (and a TeX installation as well).

    I'd then suggest following the tutorial here to dig in further: http://lefakkomies.github.io/pynomo-doc/tutorials/tutorials.html

    Explanation of the moving parts:

    • Macports is a package manager for Mac that is similar to apt, yum, etc. in the Linux world. It manages the building and installation of open source software in any language. Homebrew is an alternative, but you'd be on your own to work out the commands.

    • pip is an installer for Python packages/libraries, you can use it to install Python packages that aren't available in Macports

    That should be enough to get you going.

    This tutorial from Software Carpentry looks like a fairly good one to work over the basics of Python in a data analysis context.

    948:

    "I like the idea of literate programming,"

    If you are trying to write a text-book, it might make sense, in all other cases it makes absolutely no sense.

    And even then, having spent time with the source code to the (excellent!) LCC book, I'm not even sure I would go that route, were I ever to attempt a code-heavy text-book.

    It is inherent in the concept that you end up with fragmented literature fighting with fragmented source code, and therefore readability goes straight to hell for both parts.

    And since compilers do not read comments, much less literature, you still end up with prose saying A and source code saying B and the reader being none the wiser.

    In Varnish HTTP Cache, I laid down the policy that whenever somebody feels a comment might be warranted, they should attempt to express it as an assert() instead. This has worked quite well for us, and it has nailed a lot of bugs right out of the starting gate, because both compilers and CPU do read assert() statements.

    949:

    IIRC Python also works this way, with the added twist of saving the bytecode as a .pyc which acts as a cache for the compilation step.

    This is basically correct for the standard Python runtime - it compiles through the syntax tree to a bytecode that runs on a VM, so it's like Java in that respect. The Python VM is a fairly high level stack machine, however and most operations can have essentially arbitrary side-effects, so it's hard to optimize beyond that.

    There's also PyPy which is intended to be compatible but targets LLVM as its virtual machine, and as a result is much faster, as well as a zoo of partial JIT solutions (like Numba), transpilers (like Cython) and so forth.

    And then there's Hy, a Lisp implemented on the Python VM and fully interoperable with Python, which is about as crazy as it sounds.

    950:
  • Don't get me started. I was explaining something to someone in comp.language.awk around '94 when Larry popped in and tried to talk to them about perl.
  • But then, he is an evangelical Christian.....

  • I really learned it during my first job in Unix. One major project involved a ton of different agencies sending us data, and we were the magic, and reports. I wrote a database loader in C. Then every one of them said "we don't have the budget for that, here, you want the data in whatever form we have it in or not.
  • I wrote about 30 awk scripts (and perl wasn't that stable at the time) to convert the data into the format my dataloader was expecting it.[1] And I don't mean small - I'm talking 100-200 line awk scripts, and yes, of course they were in structured code, and as self-documenting as I could manage.

    Then, in the late nineties, when I was supporting the City of Chicago's 911 system, after the original programmers left, and his wife left, the manager came to me and told me "we need to load the export from the City's ArcInfo system into our Oracle d/b. Can you clean up the import?"

    The programmers had been freaking MASSAGING the data, EVERY SINGLE TIME. Next export, repeat that original massage, and add new, and then use Oracle import (gag). I wrote an awk script - several hundred lines, I think - to validate the data, spit out bad records with REASONS they were bad, and then load the rest. We went from two weeks of sheer terror, and doing it once or twice a year, to every month or two, and between 4 hours and a day and a half of "here's your errors, fix them","sure", and the old bad data never ever came back again. And when I was out, someone else read my document, followed it... and had no trouble.

  • That included "reboot system to DOS with no ramdisk, bring up Lotus 1-2-3 (which needed every byte of memory), export the data to comma-delimited-files (Lotus did not have a command line export), then run it through my reformatter....
  • 951:

    a comment might be warranted, they should attempt to express it as an assert() instead.

    I tend to do that, partly from using Eiffel and the contract-based ideas there. But a lot of my comments are design notes or bug explanations rather than anything that can be asserted.

    The cliche would be something like this:

    // SLOW! collection.Iterate(SomeFunctor)
    // code below is ~2x as fast, see scratch/SomeFunctorProfiling

    ... and imagine that there are six ways to do that, with a 10 line comment listing them and giving notes and sample timings. That way when I come back to it in the future I can read the comment, think "hmm, I vaguely remember this, I wonder if the profiling is still true".

    One joy of C++ is that assertions, exceptions, sigsevf's and everything all do the same thing... my server program abruptly restarts. The good thing about assertions is that they tell me what went wrong, where. The great thing about Rust is that every exit tells me what went wrong, where, and in great detail. Often after the compiler has spent much time telling me in great detail how to do that, and sometimes even why it is a bad idea.

    I have slowly learned that writing the code to be thread-safe first, then optimising it later is actually the quick, easy way to do things. Modern CPUs are far too smart for any intuitive understanding of how things will run to be possible. Even "this is a native word, partial writes shouldn't happen" are just wrong.

    Also, I am excited by C++ finally accepting that a std::string format() function is necessary (viz, printf for strings). I spent way too much time playing with my version of that to get one that performs adequately.

    952:

    Macports is a bit ... eccentric: I'd strongly recommend Homebrew instead.

    953:

    Macports is a bit ... eccentric: I'd strongly recommend Homebrew instead.

    Yes, but unfortunately the step-by-step install instructions are based on Macports with no Homebrew equivalent. It'll do for the goal at hand (getting PyNomo up and running with a minimum of grief for a less experienced user).

    954:

    Pigeon @ 717:

    "Not going to install Linux on any of these machines"

    No, but you could run it off a live CD and use it to back up the data off your Windoze filesystem in case you fuck up trying to reinstall Windoze.

    I need to boot Windows. I don't need an extra layer of complexity added by trying to run a Windows program in Linux. The "data" is already "backed up". I did that when I was setting up the new computer. If I can't reinstall Windoze the drive is BORKED. Linux ain't gonna' UN-bork it. But I so appreciate your confidence in my abilities. This ain't the first time I've had to do a Windoze recovery.

    Troutwaxer @ 720: This is a very good idea. You can also run Linux off a live USB stick.

    It would be a good idea if I wanted a Linux machine. I don't need to use Linux to run Windows programs.

    The pain eased off enough overnight last night I'm back to usual with the painkillers.

    955:

    I think the problem is they only want to do the fun bit of the job. To write code, call themselves developers and creatives and all the rest of it without doing the dull bits that make it easier for someone to maintain/improve after you have moved on to other things. Its part of the job. Its tedious and its irritating, but its essential unless you are likely to be the only ever user.

    When developing code for PPARC and a 2500 member string user base I bargained on a substantial chunk of code taking a third as long to document as to design, write and debug.

    And as for the idea that comments are bad - someone made. Nope, totally disagree. Recently, I revisited a 20,000 line tool I wrote with a view to translating it and offering it to astropy - without the comments I would have been totally lost.

    956:

    Elderly Cynic @ 734: Answering the original question, as the current politics goes, it depends on whether her father had obtained full British citzenship by the time she was born. If not, she COULD theoretically be rendered stateless under existing law.

    FWIW, the "original question" was RHETORICAL SARCASM.

    Wasn't really intended to be answered. It was an observation on the IRONY of a person who is obviously not descended from William the Conqueror using SECRET POWERS TO REVOKE THE CITIZENSHIP other persons who also happen to be obviously not descended from William the Conqueror.

    You think that could come back someday to bite her on the ass (arse)? Hmmmm?

    957:

    David L @ 741: Idi was Trump only 40 years earlier.

    Except that Idi had a much more pleasing personality.

    958:

    Troutwaxer and I are not suggesting that you should "use Linux to run Windoze programs". The point about the live CD/USB stick is that it gives you a prepackaged basic Linux system that you can use temporarily - as soon as you take the CD/stick out it vanishes as if it had never been - and independently of the Windoze installation, without affecting it in any way.

    This means that you can boot the machine off the CD/stick, mount the Windoze filesystem read-only under Linux, and tell Linux to copy the data off it onto an external hard drive or whatever. That way you avoid such problems as Windoze refusing to copy some of the files because it says it "can't", or Windoze screwing up the data and producing a bad backup because the Windoze installation is already borked, or any of that kind of shit. You can just duplicate everything onto the backup device and reliably produce a backup which really is a duplicate without errors and missing bits. Then you shut down again and take the CD/stick out, and that takes you back to having a plain Windoze box in exactly the same state as it was before only now you also have a good backup of the data.

    Regarding "confidence in your abilities", it was you who expressed the initial doubt, so I thought it was worth informing you of a safe and straightforward method of creating a safety net which didn't seem to be in your existing toolkit and which would relieve the anxiety arising from that doubt.

    959:

    The key was that the programmers wrote the code and documentation, AND did the support!

    Which is the point of DevOps. Well one of the points. But watching this from some windows into a few large company back rooms, the developers hate it they want their code declared "accepted" (full of bugs or note) then move on to something new and shiny. So they create a new org charge to satisfy the higher ups that they are doing DevOps (along with some very shaded readings of what DevOps is) and continue throwing things over the wall to the "suckers" stuck with maintaining things.

    960:

    Everyone likes to throw around the nice cheap US$ price for the boards only, and that's great if you are in the US and already have all the necessary pieces.

    I mentioned the exchange rates would change things.

    I also remember when a CND$ cost me around $1.25 USD.

    961:

    Since you mentioned your iMac can run 10.12 then you have access to Python 2.9 and I think 3.0. I was/will be a big user of Munki which back then was written in Python 2.9. The need to consider a transition to 3.0 was the impetus to move it to Swift.

    Munki did/does use GitHub to manage development by people around the world.

    FYI - Munki is a Mac only utility set for managing (and doing) software installs and updates on Macs so no need for cross platform support. It is similar in function and goals to Chocolatey for Windows.

    962:

    "The point about the live CD/USB stick is that it gives you a prepackaged basic Linux system that you can use temporarily - as soon as you take the CD/stick out it vanishes as if it had never been - and independently of the Windoze installation, without affecting it in any way."

    Exactly! The live CD/USB does not install Linux over your Windows drive. It boots off the CD/USB device and provides all the necessary tools to move your data, but it does not overwrite your Windows drive.

    963:

    if we have a bus problem.

    I work doing tech (whatever is needed) for small companies. 1 to 20 in size. I've gone to creating an Evernote account for each client. Only I have the email login for the setup. But I put the login information into a few envelopes and tell the owners to store these away for when I get "hit by a bus".

    I don't spend hardly any time keeping it well organized. Just do a search. When we have to setup an account with someone like Microsoft or Adobe I stick the details into a page for each. Ditto the networking management. And why some configuration choices are made. And so on.

    Ever few years I change the login and hand out new envelopes.

    964:

    Unholyguy wrote on December 20, 2021 at 15:47 ref. 907:

    "There are fairly good (and free) online university classes for modern data science."

    Thank you! Do you have recommendations for those?
    And, for courses to learn programming? Preferably one course for those of us who must bang the rocks together, and perhaps another slightly swifter course for those who can master LibreOffice Calc macros?

    965:

    You don't need a spare mouse/kbd/display to use a Pi. So long as you have a machine that can run a VNC client (the usual default one is RealVNC, from the people that pretty much originated it) you can just power up the Pi, configure it to talk VNC and Robert is your father's brother. It's how I use my dozen or so Pi's.

    This is nice and all, and probably interesting for many on this board.

    But it is complicating things (and perhaps risking driving the person from learning Python) for someone who has a Mac that should be adequate to at least learn Python.

    It's great that so many people are Raspberry Pi evangelists, but it isn't the answer in this case.

    966:

    For me, if I'm making what might be serious changes, I just change the name to title_1.docx. But I agree - there's no real reason for version control in writing. (Well, unless you want to leave the versions for your descendants to sell to academics to publish papers about how you changed your Great Work. )

    Someone never wrote a graduate thesis.

    I learned to normally include a smart date (e.g. 20211220 for today) in the name of documents. It's useful in multiple ways, from major changes to dealing with Dr. Boss Stoopid who's just getting around to shredding editing an old version. And now that I'm dealing with Slow Money Developments that metastasize and re-emerge on the scale of decades, having the date in the title of old files helps me find old stuff that turns out to be important.

    While I agree that all the versions are ultimately useless once I pass to the great worm bin in the sky, it turns out that some of them are critical at various junctures. Unfortunately, there's no way to determine which one is which when you write something. So for me, a date in the title makes it easier to find what I need.

    967:

    Completely agree. Just as "agile" (in all its many subforms) has so often been used as a "oh someone else will do the documentaion later" technique. In my experience (I test), it does not work well for anyone except the easily-bored devs, who seldom hang around lnng enough for maintenance to be needed.

    968:

    I said "writing", not work/school, and no, I never did a thesis. I never went for a masters, because I was afraid some HR moron (I repeat myself) would decide I was "overqualified".

    969:

    " The key was that the programmers wrote the code and documentation, AND did the support! "

    This is, quite literally, illegal for big financial systems in large companies listed on the US stock market.

    I'm not kidding. It's the dumbest thing ever.

    The "Sarbanes Oxley Act" was an attempt to enforce better financial reporting on big companies after the GFC. It includes some segregation-of-duties ideas to stop people cooking the books - basically to make people are required to check their data is right and the person checking can't be the source of the data. Not a bad idea.

    But for IT it's been a total disaster because "Segregation of Duties" was read as meaning that developers must not have access to production systems. IT Consultants from big management consultancies pushed this because they're MBA grads who've never written any code in their life and they really, really like waterfall models of software development.

    970:

    Sounds positive - I wonder whether that doctor (or one of his/her health ministry contacts) can access your file for details.

    Been a crazy day, but positive.

    Never got called back by Public Health Waterloo. For some reason I got the urge to check my vaccine passport once again, and noticed the booster dose was gone. So I immediately booked the first appointment I could get within 200km of Toronto, for Feb 2 at a little town 120 km away from home.

    Wasn't happy, so decided to politely see if the doctor could squeeze me in sooner. Turned out he had a spare dose today, so I immediately hopped in my car and spent 2.3 hours driving to Waterloo*. He stayed late and I got my shot around 5:10 PM (after the office was closed).

    So he caused me a lot of panic and time, but he did his best to rectify his mistake, and apparently hasn't had a holiday in over 2 years and is thinking of changing professions, so I'm going to call this one even.

    Got my new passport downloaded.

    So yeah, really glad the first person I talked to let slip his name, which let me track him down, and glad he fixed his mistake so quickly.

    * Accident on the 400, and heavy construction on the 401 — trip should only have been 1.5 hours.

    971:

    And what companies did under the rubric of "SOX compliance" was "we're going to have so much documentation that you won't be able to find anything under the mass of it."

    I had a short-term contract at Lowe's in '06. They rigged things so that every. single. command. that. every. Unix. Programmer. ran. was recorded. And they had hundreds of us.

    972:

    "I never went for a masters, because I was afraid some HR moron (I repeat myself) would decide I was 'overqualified'."

    Depends on where you work, I suppose. I had an MS and failed to get a PhD because I finished the coursework but never completed the dissertation. The LargeDefenseContractor that absorbed the small company I subsequently worked for always billed me as being an ABD (All But Degree) in their bids. I guess they thought that sounded good.

    973:

    Um, I didn't really understand most of that.

    I suspect I don't have the base skills most of you do, so this may not be a good project.

    974:

    (All But Degree)

    Sorry, All But Dissertation (duh)

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/All_but_dissertation

    975:

    waterfall models of software development

    You just keep telling yourself that that is water flowing down on to you. Looks like... water, smells like water, tastes like water... this must be a waterfall.

    I quite like having my boss answer the phones when our support person is busy. It helps correct some of the ideas he has about what customers want. It gives him new ideas, which isn't always good. But at least is slows the flow of "every customer is just like me, therefore what I want is what everyone wants". Meanwhile about 90% of our apps have exactly one alarm set up in them. Not 50.

    976:

    That means you can just type code into a web page and it will produce PyNomo output for you if you do it right (note - I have not tested it!).

    I tried running their sample program. (Or script, or whatever it's called.)

    Ended up leaving it for two hours and it did nothing. Don't know if the sandbox doesn't work, I need a different browser, or what.

    977:

    update your system to a recent version, if you can (Catalina or Big Sur would be the sweet spots, otherwise as recent as your hardware will allow)

    Then I'm out. I can't update because this is mostly my photography computer, and I need it to run Aperture which Apple stopped supporting years ago. I might be able to run High Sierra and have Aperture work, and I know people who have it running on more recent systems (up to Mojave), but I also know people who've had it stop working reliably.

    I don't want to learn Python so much I'll sacrifice a 10 TB library!

    978:

    But at least is slows the flow of "every customer is just like me, therefore what I want is what everyone wants".

    Had that this morning on a Teams call with the 3 partner owners of a client firm. One partner was adamant that everyone would be wanting "this". Other two partners said we're not interested at all and we suspect that the staff will have various levels of interest. Her face had that look like she'd bitten into a lemon peel.

    979:

    You should be able to find Python setups that will work on macOS 10.12.x. I think that macOS version came with an iteration of 2.9 but without a bunch of patches. The Munki system I mentioned earlier started including a private distribution of Python to deal with this.

    And I strongly suspect you can find a 3.x distribution.

    980:

    Pigeon @ 958: Troutwaxer and I are not suggesting that you should "use Linux to run Windoze programs". The point about the live CD/USB stick is that it gives you a prepackaged basic Linux system that you can use temporarily - as soon as you take the CD/stick out it vanishes as if it had never been - and independently of the Windoze installation, without affecting it in any way.

    This means that you can boot the machine off the CD/stick, mount the Windoze filesystem read-only under Linux, and tell Linux to copy the data off it onto an external hard drive or whatever. That way you avoid such problems as Windoze refusing to copy some of the files because it says it "can't", or Windoze screwing up the data and producing a bad backup because the Windoze installation is already borked, or any of that kind of shit. You can just duplicate everything onto the backup device and reliably produce a backup which really is a duplicate without errors and missing bits. Then you shut down again and take the CD/stick out, and that takes you back to having a plain Windoze box in exactly the same state as it was before only now you also have a good backup of the data.

    Regarding "confidence in your abilities", it was you who expressed the initial doubt, so I thought it was worth informing you of a safe and straightforward method of creating a safety net which didn't seem to be in your existing toolkit and which would relieve the anxiety arising from that doubt.

    Yep. Do you understand the answer is technically correct but totally useless for what I needed to do? If I want to unscrew something, I don't need another hammer added to my toolbox. Booting from a Linux Live CD NOW is no help solving the problem of configuring server settings for an email program to work with a particular service provider a week ago.

    This computer should not have been locked. I wrote down the PIN number and used it several times already when I was setting up this computer. The critical question is why THIS computer would not accept the PIN number after Micro$oft downloaded an unauthorized update.

    I have the email program installed on this computer (which was locking me out), on my laptop (but only configured for my primary email account - which I have since corrected) and on that old computer. I just needed that old computer to boot for long enough so I could receive a single email with the code to unlock THIS computer.

    If I hadn't been in so much pain at the time, I probably would have thought to try webmail sooner (which is how I DID finally retrieve the code).

    And, backing up data that was already backed up is not necessary for getting Windows to boot on that computer, especially not now a week after the fact.

    Any "data" I needed to save has already been saved. If Windoze is borked, I'll install Windoze again. If the hard-drive is borked, I can replace the hard-drive.

    981:

    PS: If y'all know how I go about filing a criminal complaint against Micro$soft for violating the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act of 1986 (CFAA), that might be useful.

    982:

    Troutwaxer @ 962:

    "The point about the live CD/USB stick is that it gives you a prepackaged basic Linux system that you can use temporarily - as soon as you take the CD/stick out it vanishes as if it had never been - and independently of the Windoze installation, without affecting it in any way."

    Exactly! The live CD/USB does not install Linux over your Windows drive. It boots off the CD/USB device and provides all the necessary tools to move your data, but it does not overwrite your Windows drive."italics"

    OTOH, what if I don't need to move data? What if all I needed to do is run a particular Windows program A WEEK AGO so I could receive an email?

    983:

    Kardashev @ 972:

    "I never went for a masters, because I was afraid some HR moron (I repeat myself) would decide I was 'overqualified'."

    Depends on where you work, I suppose. I had an MS and failed to get a PhD because I finished the coursework but never completed the dissertation. The LargeDefenseContractor that absorbed the small company I subsequently worked for always billed me as being an ABD (All But Degree) in their bids. I guess they thought that sounded good.

    That's kind of what happened to my dad. He was ABD for a PhD in Clinical Psychology when the Army called him back to go to Korea. Columbia mailed a Masters Degree to his APO address.

    I don't know why he didn't go back to complete his dissertation after he returned home from Korea.

    984:

    For learning Python you could try one of the web-based learning platforms. Or something like https://www.pythonanywhere.com/ where the basic pricing is free, it comes with a Jupyter notebook and you can create a web site with it. Even the free tier comes with a bunch of packages installed; if you're lucky the one(s) you're looking for will be included.

    I host a website that's coded in Python using their services (on a paid tier), and the support is friendly and knowledgeable in my experience. It's based in the UK, and runs on AWS.

    985:

    I said "writing", not work/school, and no, I never did a thesis. I never went for a masters, because I was afraid some HR moron (I repeat myself) would decide I was "overqualified".

    There's a reason theses and dissertations are called publications. I did both, masochist that I am, and a dissertation is basically three (or sometimes more) theses.

    No, losing data and manuscripts is an unfortunately common experience, and utter paranoia about losing track of a manuscript is normal. That's what I meant about tracking the date of a version, so that you don't start adding new text to an old document (which I've done...)

    To give you an idea of what writing one of these sweethearts is like, as an ABD, we had a joke that The Lord of The Rings was a metaphor for the graduate experience, the ring being a metaphor for one's dissertation, with throwing the damned thing into the volcano being the thesis defense. Turns out, someone actually completed a PhD on that very subject.

    986:

    "What if all I needed to do is run a particular Windows program A WEEK AGO so I could receive an email?"

    You could in fact have used the Live CD/USB to receive the e-mail, and therefore not needed to resurrect the very old machine.

    But you are quite correct to say that webmail would have been the best way to deal with it.

    JHomes

    987:

    Long-time lurker, occasional commenter, totally weird question: you’re one of the few commenters who’s mentioned they live in the GTA. Extending this to you or any other commenter in the area who’s interested, anybody likely to be near Bakka-Phoenix in January? I should be back to school in-person at that point, and while I probably saw some of you a few years ago at Charlie’s last appearance there, I’d love to attach faces to names to the commentariat. (As proof of my existence: I was the only person in the room under 30 and I was sitting front and centre in front of OGH)

    988:

    These "limits" are not worth the bog paper they are written on, but they are, the "official limits" - & if you admit to ( Shock, Horror! ) drinking 3 pints of beer & 4-5 bottles of wine per week, then you are an irresponsible, hopeless drunk etc ... Fucking lies from beginning to end.

    Hmmm, maybe you're right for some. If I downed 5 bottles of wine and 3 pints of beer in a single week... Well actually I couldn't. I'd be unable to keep it down, but if I attempted to do that I'd be completely non functional for the entire week. Either asleep, vomiting, moaning from the hangover or sometimes all three at once.

    If their objective on setting limits is the same as the setting of speed limits, ie, pretty safe for anyone, while trying not to be overly restrictive, that sounds pretty unrestrictive to me.

    989:

    Remarkable what gets deleted. Comments on DU munitions were accurate.

    For the record: she was telling the Truth. Nasty little business with a D note not just "Golden Rule" but a couple of levels above "Top Secret". Here is the Major Trigger: "Babylon". "Empress Dragonflies" is also True.

    Ironically enough, she went places that even Lovecraft didn't imagine. And brought something else back, several somethings, but that's just imaginary and you'll forget it was ever said, immediately.

    Anyhow, those comments about Raytheon were also True. We understand the UK is a difficult country to live in given that you can be fined £10,000 for merely tweeting "That is stupid" in response to some obvious Troll, but there we are.

    Oh, and that footnote about the Turkish Lira: in GB terms, it did hit 20, then Nation State levels of interaction kicked in. Which, in retrospect and having read her "grep" comments was probably her joke.

    In real terms that single comment about Lira has: well, read the papers. "Largest move in 40 years" and so forth. And that was a footnote.

    990:

    Which is the point of DevOps. Well one of the points. But watching this from some windows into a few large company back rooms, the developers hate it they want their code declared "accepted" (full of bugs or note) then move on to something new and shiny.

    In my experience, this depends, a lot. If you get the developers to buy the idea that they are providing some service instead of writing code you can get better results. Anyway, 'writing code' is in my experience just a small portion of software development - it's much more work figuring out what we are trying to accomplish and why, and what's the best way of doing it.

    In many cases the best way is not obvious from the start. I've been in projects where we have decided that we need a certain component and then implemented it, realized that it doesn't work that way because of Things, and then re-implemented it from scratch.

    I mostly work with Python nowadays. I've grown to at least accept it, it's not perfect but it's one of the best tools I've worked with. Maybe Ruby or Rust or something more modern would be better, but I'm not the only one making decisions here. Golang was also a nice, if somewhat incomplete, language environment I used a couple of years ago. It might be better nowadays.

    I've worked also with C and C++, and, uh, I don't really want to. I know what they were designed for, mostly, but to me they are much too error prone and, well, clunky. Speed... well, yeah, but in many cases the real speed of the running program is not that important. Depending on what you're doing, things like ease of development and the environment the thing is running in has a great effect on what's the best solution.

    Also I don't like using concepts like 'real programming languages'. (That wasn't David L, but withroth in @933.) That's kind of harsh as there are languages made for different purposes, but they are all programming languages. (Joke languages aside, going into extremes like Whitespace or Ook!, or INTERCAL.) I've done things in various assembly languages, and arguably they (especially something 8-bit like 6510 assembler) are more 'real' than anything interpreted or compiled, but I wouldn't really consider them a good tool in general use. Use whatever works for you, and if it's a computer language, it most likely is a real programming language. Design your own if you want, but be aware that it's often a NIH problem then.

    I work doing backends, so my perspective is somewhat limited. It's what I like to do (most things here are REST APIs, so using http(s) programmatically, but there's a lot of other stuff), and we (my team) are also responsible for deploying our stuff and making sure it runs properly. This includes a lot of various tasks, and for me is quite interesting and fun.

    I'm also very lucky to be working in a team. This shows up in small things, like when I had to take some days off for sick leave, and the almost completed things I had left behind had been taken up and completed during that time. Also coming back from summer vacation and seeing that the piece I was working on before the vacation had been improved a lot by other people was a nice experience.

    I'd say we are quite a DevOps organization. It however needs more than taking a bunch of developers, formerly responsible of making up architecture from vague specifications and delivering code that seems to run, and saying that they are now responsible for deploying and monitoring the stuff. It's possible to do it properly, in my opinion, but I'm not an expert on how to do that. (I like being one of the people working on the stuff, not on making people work on the stuff.)

    991:

    Henry Athelton
    For the record: she was telling the Truth Yes, maybe, but how the fuck were we supposed to find out, through all the obfuscation?
    Your view on fines is exaggerated

    Back to the original subject .......
    Radio this morning, man from London hospitals/care/intensive care sections.
    85%+ of hospital admissions are unvaccinated & 100% of ICU are unvaccinated.
    AND STILL the fucking stupids won't get their shots.

    992:

    icehawk @ 969: they're MBA grads who've never written any code in their life and they really, really like waterfall models of software development.

    Anyone interested in this topic should read the original paper from 1970 which described the Waterfall model. It also explains why it didn't work even then and proposes a much more iterative lifecycle, culminating with the advice to basically write the system twice, first as a prototype, then as a real thing (this advice was also repeated in The Mythical Man-Month).

    The trouble seems to be that back in 1970 a bunch of managers looked at this paper, saw the first diagram, said "I understand that, so I'll use it", and didn't bother to read the rest of the paper.

    Unfortunately I've also seen what happens when the "plan to throw one away" policy was followed. The "prototype" took much longer and cost much more than was expected (gee, its software, whoda thunk it), thereby consuming the budget allocated for the "real" system. As a result the prototype had to be thrown into production regardless.

    Fun fact: the paper above was written by Winston Royce. His eldest son, Walker Royce, was one of the chief architects behind the Rational Unified Process, UML and the rest of the "big OO" software industry.

    993:

    976 - This seems like "normal behaviour" for "real operating systems". Nothing (appears to) happen (well except maybe the command prompt reappears) means that the application has done something, and exited without error.

    981 - I think that if you're trying to claim that a Mickeyshaft "update" is a breach of federal law, forget it. Read the End User Licence "Agreement" if you don't believe me.

    988 - Well, the new UK "recommendations" are more equivalent to 0.5 Imperial pints of good beer every day.
    Don't start me on UK speed limits because of the number of them that have been set/reduced for political reasons.

    994:

    At one stage, there were machines where there was a firmware interpreter, so the 'machine code' was a higher level language. It's not just recent environments where things are blurred :-)

    995:

    I've never seen that, but have heard of it. It's perverse, at best, because awk is NOT suited for such things. However, there were much older languages of comparable use and functionality, including POP2 from your neck of the woods and lots of others.

    Remember that most of the Unix utility 'innovations' were following ideas and even designs from other systems, including from Cambridge, MIT and elsewhere.

    996:

    "In Varnish HTTP Cache, I laid down the policy that whenever somebody feels a comment might be warranted, they should attempt to express it as an assert() instead."

    That is complete nonsense. Yes, it's fine for comments that describe simple constraints, but consider the following, all of which I recommend when teaching:

    This procedure implements the algorithm described in ..., and the variable names are the same as in that paper.

    This code assumes matrix M is positive definite, with the smallest eigenvalue no less than 5*eps times the largest.

    Do NOT change this apparently perverse code, because it is this way to bypass defects in the C standard and compilers.

    Use least-squares and iterated improvement to fit the model's parameters to the data. (This sort of comment is so that you can find important sections of code without having to decode them).

    997:

    "The trouble seems to be that back in 1970 a bunch of managers looked at this paper, saw the first diagram, said "I understand that, so I'll use it", and didn't bother to read the rest of the paper."

    That is not at all what happened.

    Waterfall is how engineering projects have always been run, at least all the way back to Claudius and Rome's new harbour at Portus, and straight up to this day, in almost all other engineering disciplines than software.

    The first documented failure of the waterfall model in computing was on LEO, the Lyon's tea-shop-franchise custom built computer: They wrote the entire software suite in parallel with the construction of the hardware and found that absolutely nothing worked once they tried to run it.

    That essentially means that waterfall failed out of the gate, since LEO was more or less the first time a computer was not just used to get numerical answer to some scientific question or other.

    The main reason waterfall does not work for software is the unprecedented level of complexity of software.

    To build a state of the art US Nuclear aircraftcarrier, you have to keep track of only approx. 1 million SKU's (They bragged about this in a press-release some years ago.)

    For comparison there are 160 thousand lines of code in just the bash shell and 17 million lines in FreeBSD, which is considered a very lean operating system.

    The major operating systems, as installed by default, clock in around one billion lines of code these days.

    There was quite a bit of study done pre-dot-com about this topic, and the consensus number was that elite programmers could manage to keep around 100k lines of code in consistent high quality.

    My personal rule of thumb is that any IT project, which does not have a single document fitting in a single binder (or less), which explains everything you need to know to implement the system, will miss both budget and deadline.

    998:

    Both the UK and USA have the best law that money can buy. I would dearly love someone who can outbid one of the big companies to challenge those one-sided laws. They could start with the much smaller UK banks, who are equally bad.

    1000:

    "This procedure implements the algorithm described in ..., and the variable names are the same as in that paper."

    If you are reimplementing algorithms, you are doing it wrong. You should use an already tested and proven implementation. (But see also: https://queue.acm.org/detail.cfm?id=1944489)

    "This code assumes matrix M is positive definite, with the smallest eigenvalue no less than 5*eps times the largest."

    That should be checked by assertions, because even if people think that is what they have passed in, they are likely to be wrong sometimes. In particular for large data-types where a quick visual sanity-check is not possible.

    "Do NOT change this apparently perverse code, because it is this way to bypass defects in the C standard and compilers."

    In my not at all humble experience, that is almost never a problem with the C standard and compilers, but a bad choice in how to express intent to the compiler, usually due to a wrong perception of actual performance metrics. Most "hard-core performance improvements" simply are not.

    "Use least-squares and iterated improvement to fit the model's parameters to the data. (This sort of comment is so that you can find important sections of code without having to decode them)."

    Again, you should rely on proven implementations for stuff like that, rather than write your own. The name of the function call should be plenty clue for what is going to happen.

    But please note that I did not say "no comments", I said they should be made asserts if possible.

    The point is to make as many assumptions as possible visible to the compiler, because, yo and behold, the more information you give it, the better code it produces.

    And the proof is very much in the pudding: Varnish Cache is 16 years old, about 20% of the worlds HTTP traffic passes through it, and we've had only 8 security holes, most pretty obscure, and none of them exploited at scale in those 16 years.

    Now, show me your homework...

    1001:

    Georgina Ferry's book "A Computer Called Leo" is a solid introduction to the LEO story, but there may be better now with the TNMOC's Lottery funded LEO project.

    One interesting nerd-bit: The ALU could do multi-radix addition and subtraction because it had to work in pounds, shillings and pence :-)

    1002:

    If you are reimplementing algorithms, you are doing it wrong.

    Most of the time. Sometimes you need an algorithm that isn't in the standard library, or any other library that meets quality & licensing standards.

    I would say that 99% of my code only uses standard algorithms. The other 1% is the fun bit when I'm writing the library for everyone else.

    It helps to be working in an area where there's still active research going on.

    1003:

    Exactly HOW would you check that a matrix satisfies that condition? And do you know how much it costs?

    I spent 15 years on SC22WG14, and (at one stage) probably knew more about C portability than anyone else. Here is a snippet - please explain why the casts are necessary, why they don't always work, and what other incantations sometimes help (A-D are all doubles, with valid values in them, and there is no overflow):

    A = (double)((double)((B*C)+D))-D;

    "Proven implementations"? In many cases (most, in my areas), there ARE none. Worse, a lot of the time I roll my own precisely because the available implementations are unreliable.

    I could give comparable examples, but shall refrain.

    1004:

    " spent 15 years on SC22WG14"

    I'm going to hold that against you, because I no other programming has ever been mismanaged by its purported guardian the way SC22WG14 has mismanaged C.

    How come, for instance, that C still does not have a standard way to force layout of structs to conform to an external specification ?

    Why is "I want a field named 'header_checksum' at offset 10, and it is 16 bit and big-endian, no matter what CPU this code runs." still not something C can do ?

    1005:

    JBS @ 981: PS: If y'all know how I go about filing a criminal complaint against Micro$soft for violating the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act of 1986 (CFAA), that might be useful.

    The FBI Internet Crime Complaint Centre looks like a good place to start. However I think you might have difficulty with the "mens rea" part of the law:

    (5)

    (A) knowingly causes the transmission of a program, information, code, or command, and as a result of such conduct, intentionally causes damage without authorization, to a protected computer;

    (B) intentionally accesses a protected computer without authorization, and as a result of such conduct, recklessly causes damage; or

    (C) intentionally accesses a protected computer without authorization, and as a result of such conduct, causes damage and loss.

    You would need to prove the "knowingly" and "intentionally" parts of one of those paragraphs. I think Micro$oft's likely counter-arguments will be that:

    • It was doing its good-faith best to keep its customers computers secure, despite many of them not knowing a security update from a hole in the head,

    • It was authorised to access your computer by virtue of some term in the EULA (which I haven't looked for).

    • The update was performed by an automated system; nobody knew or intended that it should access your computer.

    • Your computer contacted their server and downloaded the update, so that was the cause in para 5A, so it wasn't M$ causing it.

    • If M$ did exceed authorised access or cause damage, it was an honest oversight and was neither intentional nor reckless.

    (Note: I'm not saying I agree or disagree with any of the above; I'm simply trying to anticipate the obstacles)

    You can also file a civil suit. Your state probably has a small claims court or similar, where you can avoid hiring a lawyer as long as the amount is below some locally-defined limit. Companies try hard to stay out of those because they do have to hire a lawyer to represent them, for which they pay. So if nothing else you can try to extort a settlement that way (I say "extort" because from the M$ point of view this would be a nuisance suit and their thinking will be focused on "how cheaply can we make this guy go away?". Actual justice is irrelevant).

    1006:

    Back vaguely on topic I see that Novavax got their vaccine approved in the EU.

    Unlike AZ, Pfizer and Moderna it's not mRNA based. That's not going to persuade any antivaxers to take it but they will need a new excuse.

    1007:

    Yes. The UK contingent did our damnedest to try to get some coherence, clarity and consistency into the standard and, in my view and that of some others, failed dismally. You are welcome to hold that failure against me, but please don't blame me for actively perpetrating that horror.

    It's worse than you say, too. It was claimed that the layout of structs was well-defined by the language (never mind an external specification, I mean just an unambiguous layout), we pointed out why it wasn't, and got the brush-off. As happened with 80% of such issues that we raised. Some of the language parts of SC22WG21 are better, but not the template system, the inheritance from C, or the library.

    I eventually gave up because I was getting nowhere and it was bad for my blood pressure.

    1008:

    No, Astrazeneca is not mRNA based.

    1009:

    My understanding was that it was the rna payload in a virus delivery vehicle. Same underlying mechanism once it gets in the cells.

    1010:
    We understand the UK is a difficult country to live in given that you can be fined £10,000 for merely tweeting "That is stupid" in response to some obvious Troll, but there we are.

    Dear Mr Athelton,

    Not at all, the libel law of England giveth just as it taketh away. [1] Straight reportage is not libellous.

    The precise sequence of events you are alluding to is:

    In January 2019, whilst leader of the Labour Party Jeremy Corbyn went to a mosque and was hit by an egg.

    Some time previously Owen Jones (Guardian Columnist) had tweeted about Nick Griffin (former British National Party leader):

    “I think sound life advice is, if you don’t want eggs thrown at you, don’t be a Nazi.”

    Rachel Riley (Jewish TV personality) re-tweets the above adding “good advice”.

    Now we get the contentious bit: Ms Laura Murray (an aide to Jeremy Corbyn) then tweets:

    “Today Jeremy Corbyn went to his local mosque for Visit My Mosque Day, and was attacked by a Brexiteer. Rachel Riley tweets that Corbyn deserves to be violently attacked because he is a Nazi. This woman is as dangerous as she is stupid. Nobody should engage with her. Ever.”

    It is this tweet for which Ms Murray was sued, and had to pay Ms Riley £10,000 damages. So it’s not a fine since libel is a civil matter and not a matter for the criminal court.

    ps “Laura Murray was stakeholder manager of Mr Corbyn’s Office when he was leader, and went on to be the party’s head of complaints, before going into teaching.” (Quote from Scotsman)

    The article in the Scotsman is here: https://www.scotsman.com/news/crime/countdown-presenter-rachel-riley-awarded-ps10k-in-damages-over-libel-claim-against-former-jeremy-corbyn-aide-3500841

    [1] Before the matter comes to court it is permissible to report the allegations in a simple “He said, She said” fashion. After the matter comes to court and a judgement has been arrived at one can report that “it has been determined that this [is/is not] libellous.”

    Because it is a civil matter, this does not set a precedent and repeating the exact same statement of a non-libellous opinion (without qualifying it as the reported words of others) might yet be found libellous.

    Think very carefully indeed before responding to this post. Because Charlie is on the hook for any libellous comments made on his blog.

    1011:

    Possibly the problem is that C is a verbose form of Assembler that has mutated horribly rather than a structured computer language with well-defined abstractions? The assorted bits and bobs glued onto the original lean mean K&R version of C over the millenia tend to obscure its very crude basic roots but at its beating heart it's still crude and brutal and it takes no prisoners.

    You want an highly abstracted language with comprehensible structures and error-checking and "don't do this, stupid" there are options other than C or its bastard offspring C++. If you want to go fast and break things, C is just the ticket.

    1012:

    "You want an highly abstracted language with [...]"

    Most of the time yes.

    But some of us writes low-level code, and for that, C is clearly a better choice than raw assembly.

    1013:

    this advice was also repeated in The Mythical Man-Month).

    If anyone gets a chance to hear Fred Brooks give a talk, don't miss it. He's a great speaker and had an interesting career after the IBM 360 project.

    And to be honest is a truly nice guy.

    But he is getting up there in years. I last saw him around 5 or so years ago. Turns out at a personal level he's a big Apple Mac fan. Bought a 128K Mac when they first came out. He had it with him to show off but the power capacitor blew when he turned it on.

    Someone asked him what the biggest decision he made on the 360 project and he said the fight over 6 vs 8 bit "bytes". Apparently Gene Amdahl wanted 6 and was adamant about it. He was all about math. Who needs more than upper case English oriented letters? FB said they had to have a meeting with Watson Jr. to settle it. And he was very happy that he and 8 won.

    1014:

    But some of us writes low-level code, and for that, C is clearly a better choice than raw assembly.

    I have a friend who specializes in patching code on running systems. I think he dreams in assembly.

    Before you ask he was with Nortel for years where re-booting a CO phone switch while in service was considered poor form at best.

    1015:

    Nope, the AstraZeneca vaccine is a modified chimpanzee adenovirus (i.e. the sort that causes common colds). The outer surface of the virus was genetically modified to make the spike proteins there look like COVID-19 spike proteins which the body's immune system would react to and stimulate antibody production.

    This chimpanzee adenovirus is not communicable among humans, however it had never been used previously as the basis of a vaccine for humans and in a few cases out of hundreds of millions of doses it did cause adverse reactions.

    1016:

    If you want the (nearly) full story of that, I can give it. A precis is that K&R C was a crude, semi-portable Algol-like compiler (sic) with a BCPL-like run-time, intended to be a high-level assembler, and no other specification. Code was NOT portable.

    However, the real rot came in with the standard. SC22 allowed X3J11 to manage the job, and it was attempting to make C both a portable high-level language and a flexible assembler. The UK opposed that, as the objectives were ireconcilable, but its objections (like most of its comments) were ignored.

    Once of my most enduring regrets was in a 90 minute BSI meeting (with c. 50 people present) where I argued that a flawed standard was better than none. It passed by one vote, and I am pretty sure that my opposition and vote change) would have reversed that.

    X3J11 had pissed off several countries by its rule-breaking and arrogance, and said that they would vote "no" if the UK did. At least 3 people on SC22 were seriously concerned and would have restarted the process if the UK (and a few other countries) had voted "no".

    It got worse with C99, but that's another story.

    Hindsight is a wonderful thing :-(

    1017:
    But some of us writes low-level code, and for that, C is clearly a better choice than raw assembly.

    Not always.

    The key operation on SpiNNaker was an exponential decay ODE solver, with (rare) triggering of a synaptic event. The ARM processors ran at 200MHz (for heat reasons), and had just 32K bytes of code space.

    An (basic) ARM instruction has four components: the basic ALU operation, a shift operation, a condition code setting operation, and a conditional execution operation.

    GCC is just hopeless at optimizing for that instruction set, and ARM CC is only slightly better. Good code needs to be doing two of those operations at once to get best performance.

    Because of the intermediate code representation of branching that GCC uses it cannot make best use of the conditional features of the machine.

    1018:

    right. My mistake.

    In any case, nowt goes into the cells with the novavax one so they don't get the "muh DNA!" excuse.

    It's obviously still poison and all that.

    1019:

    Re: '... where I argued that a flawed standard was better than none.'

    Okay - but that suggests that recognition of an existing/potential flaw would put the parties on alert to keep tabs on that (and possibly other emerging) flaws. Did that happen?

    Changing to Covid-stats mode --- curious what you and other compsci/stats folks think of this article. Also - first time that I've seen high ferritin levels associated with severe Covid (pre-Omicron variants).

    https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-021-03632-x#Tab2

    'Abstract

    Since 2019, a large number of people worldwide have been infected with severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2. Among those infected, a limited number develop severe coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19), which generally has an acute onset. The treatment of patients with severe COVID-19 is challenging. To optimize disease prognosis and effectively utilize medical resources, proactive measures must be adopted for patients at risk of developing severe COVID-19. We analyzed the data of COVID-19 patients from seven medical institutions in Tokyo and used mathematical modeling of patient blood test results to quantify and compare the predictive ability of multiple prognostic indicators for the development of severe COVID-19. A machine learning logistic regression model was used to analyze the blood test results of 300 patients. Due to the limited data set, the size of the training group was constantly adjusted to ensure that the results of machine learning were effective (e.g., recognition rate of disease severity > 80%). Lymphocyte count, hemoglobin, and ferritin levels were the best prognostic indicators of severe COVID-19. The mathematical model developed in this study enables prediction and classification of COVID-19 severity.'

    BTW - the high ferritin levels which are mostly associated with either (a) a genetic predisposition (predominantly among northern Caucasians) and/or (b) liver damage from too much alcohol may help explain why the Russian Covid deaths are so high, i.e., close to 3% of confirmed cases vs. UK at just over 1% per the Johns Hopkins site.

    https://coronavirus.jhu.edu/map.html

    1020:

    Then I'm out. I can't update because this is mostly my photography computer, and I need it to run Aperture which Apple stopped supporting years ago.

    As someone above noted, stop listening to much of the advice in this thread - it simply isn't necessary (and yes, your free to ignore this too).

    You don't need a Pi, you don't need the latest macOS.

    My slowly dying Mac Mini is stuck on 10.13 High Sierra and is fine.

    I just downloaded Python 3.9.9 from python.org and it wants macOS 10.9 as a minimum, so your fine with your 10.12.

    Visual Studio Code runs quite happily on mine, so should work on yours fine if you want to run that.

    As the version of macOS that old offers the now obsolete Python 2.* as the default, you will need to type python3 instead of python. That is all.

    Ignore for now all the stuff you eventually want to do, you need to do the proverbial learning to walk before running.

    Simply follow the tutorials on the Python website, or as I mentioned earlier if you prefer books check your library - Python is in the top 3 if not the #1 programming language at the moment so most public libraries will have beginner Python books in their collection.

    Once you get comfortable with the keywords, data structures, and layout of Python (and reading and understanding Python code) then you can look into doing the stuff that interests you as you will then have the foundation to succeed.

    1021:

    "Did that happen?" No, largely because we were too trusting. That's another sordid story.

    W.r.t. the article, its use of statistics is probably good enough, but I am too rusty to say more. It's not all that surprising that ferritin is an indicator, because of the effects of COVID. Basically, it throws a spanner into the whole metabolism, and which secondary effects are most indicative is a matter of chance.

    1022:

    BTW - the high ferritin levels which are mostly associated with either (a) a genetic predisposition (predominantly among northern Caucasians) and/or (b) liver damage from too much alcohol may help explain why the Russian Covid deaths are so high, i.e., close to 3% of confirmed cases vs. UK at just over 1% per the Johns Hopkins site.

    As one who has the genetic mutation that causes high iron (though fortunately for me it doesn't require treatment) it is interesting, but I do wonder about some things.

    For example, given the lack of genetic diversity in Japan and their diet, does their normal/average iron level differ from from other cultures/races.

    And does the same spike in deaths in Russia also happen in the Scandinavian countries where the genetic mutation is most common.

    1023:

    The Nature Scientific report you quoted seems to be a non-event. I’m not medically qualified or an expert in statistics but it looks like the people involved in this study were not lab professionals. They chose 35 lab parameters for the machine learning exercise. When that many parameters are measured even in a “normal” patient the odds are that more than one or two will be outside the reference range. There appear to be no controls. They are confusing creatine (not routinely measured and of no clinical use) with the commonly tested creatinine. This is confirmed by the them stating that Cre (the common abbreviation for creatinine) is related to kidney function. They are using LDH as a marker. LDH has five or six isoenzymes and is a test so no specific that it’s rarely measured in the UK in routine testing although it’s common in the USA and US - influenced countries where costs are reimbursed by insurance companies and the lab has no financial incentive to drop and almost useless parameter. It’s also complicated by the fact that there are two methods in use depending on which direction the lactate-pyruvate rejection is run in the analyser. The reference ranges for these methods differs by almost a factor of two. It’s lack of specificity means that there is no reason to measure it since many conditions have raised LDH. CRP - this is a non-specific inflammatory marker. It’s very useful as a first indicator of infection and inflammation (including arthritis). It’s also used to monitor these. But, as an eminent consultant chemical pathologist once remarked to me, “A raised CRP means that the patient is a bit poorly”. The change in lymphocyte levels does seem important but It’s not one of their top factors in the machine learning. It’s a little surprising that they didn’t have many results for this parameter since intensive care units do full blood counts regularly and a differential count a showing lymphocytes is an automatic part of an FBC (CBC to Americans). Ferritin - It’s not clear (at least in my quick reading of this whether the ferritin was raised before admission to hospital but it’s not surprising because patients with haemochromatosis or liver problems are already more susceptible to disease.

    1024:

    For one, having to change jobs, for another, I knew what they wanted me for, and more degrees would not have been useful for their purposes. Being out of work for almost five years during the Bush II recession didn't help. Oh, right, and I went back to college in my late 20s, and had to work (child support, rent, etc), so I could only go part time. Then, for well over four years, my late wife and I were living in the exurbs outside Austin, and there was no way I could take courses.

    1025:

    "babylon" and "empress dragonflies" produces zero relevant results in google, bing, or duckduckgo.

    Oh, and you obviously aren't the Real Thing, because you wouldn't have written: "And brought something else back, several somethings, but that's just imaginary and you'll forget it was ever said, immediately."

    fnord.

    1026:

    "What we are trying to accomplish" is a manager's job. They're supposed to specify that, and, if there are any special requirements/business required processes, those.

    Then you get to write and test the code, and make sure it does what it's supposed to do, and give useful information if there's a problem, not crash.

    But then, I think that at least 90% of the time, Agile is a rationalization for "here's what we want/you do that/oh, that's not what we meant, but do this, whatever it takes, no, I won't sign off on more budget and more time".

    CentOS, which I really liked, got killed this year - IBM/RH decided it would be a continuous upgrade... and most of us left. You want fixed releases, so that bugs can be fixed once. You want local programs to work with what's there, not what changes were made, and on, and on. Agile, and what little I understand of DevOps, is just that. And a return to "code that and put it into production"... the way Faceplant does all the time.

    1027:

    Ah, no - I think my 100-200 line awk scripts are pushing it.

    Of course, I've written longer perl scripts....

    1028:

    If you don’t like OOP, feel free to not use it; just don’t waste my time trying to tell me it doesn’t work.

    I think the problems are firstly, that people have a skewed perception of OO (Oooh, just draw bubbles and arrows!) driven by poor instruction during The Great OOD/OOP Silver Bullet Enthusiasm of the 1990s; and rather missing the point of "combine the data and the operations to be performed within it in order to achieve good encapsulation and low coupling" and forgetting about describing systems in other ways, than focussing on the control flow.

    Throw in "OO means inheritance; therefore I must use lots of it, for everything" (if I see more than one, maybe two, layers of inheritance, I start to get twitchy), and you've got a recipe for "purists" to overcomplicate matters.

    Interestingly, a big thing for Les Hatton while he was selling our department his QA-C tool, plus training, in the mid/late 1990s (our quality driver was "no, asking the pilot to reset the radar is not a good idea") was getting us to appreciate the "explicitly undefined" aspects of the C language.

    Also interestingly, he demonstrated that Object-Oriented Design isn't inherently more effective than other methods of generating software (link). I like it, I use it, but I'm not going to insist that it's the only way to do things... (yes, I'm one of those enthusiastic C++ types, operating close to hardware for most of my career)

    A fascinating set of Les Hatton's articles can be found here (link)

    1029:

    Back around '93 or so, a very good programmer I worked with and I shared an office, and we agreed that no function should be longer than 1-2 screens (that's 25-50 lines), unless it was a ton of moves.

    Beyond that, you'll have errors.

    1030:

    Sorry, but if a language doesn't give you the possibility of shooting yourself in the foot, it also prevents you from writing clean, elegant, and simple code.

    (Btw, I'm an ANSI C guy).

    1031:

    "Dreams in assembly"... I think it was Jan of 1988 when I was at work, and I realized I'd completely lost it as I realized I was doing hex arithmetic in my head.

    1032:

    Yep. Every few years, someone comes out with a New Revelation (or relabels an old one), and suddenly that's the answer to every single question.

    Back in 88-89, and again around '92, people I was working for wanted to use relational databases. When they realized it wouldn't work, ain't got that hardware, I built a hierarchical that worked, did everything they needed, and they used it for a good number of years.

    Then there was the guy in the mid-eighties I worked with, and we were writing compiled Basica (don't ask), and he wanted everything he wrote to be recursive.

    1033:

    Dave Lester
    Probably, the message to take away from you #1010 is:
    "Don't be a stupid wanker" - as Ms Murray seems to have been.

    EC
    "Algol" - Arrrggghhh!

    1034:

    EC @1021 - '... and which secondary effects are most indicative is a matter of chance.'

    Thanks! - I've been wondering ever since the article identifying all of the locations of ACE2 binding sites whether COVID-19 was a 'weakest link' opportunist. Most of the mass media reports to-date highlight respiratory problems esp. when showing ICU cases. This article says (to me) not necessarily.

    mdive @1022 - '... lack of genetic diversity in Japan and their diet, does their normal/average iron level differ'

    Genetic diversity - Yeah, hopefully this test will be run/corroborated in other countries.

    Diet/iron levels - Overall, the Japanese skew to lower iron levels based on their diets (WHO). Haven't found any by-country comparisons for average iron levels but did see a couple of articles about iron deficiency anemia (related to low BMI) being a problem esp. among younger adult females in Japan.

    Russia vs. Scandinavia - No idea how they differ apart from alcoholism rates. Would be useful esp. since alcoholism seems to be mostly a male condition in higher alcoholism rate countries per the below.

    https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/alcoholism-by-country

    Mike Collins @ 1023: 'They chose 35 lab parameters for the machine learning exercise.'

    I think they used whatever diagnostics the participating hospitals performed - convenience sample/variables to test the model.

    My take aways are:

    (a) So whatever bias there is in the results is not due to the model makers but to the medicos/hospitals.

    (b) Are you/the medico going to test for something completely new that you don't understand or are you going to test to see what bit of the patient's body given their medical history you're going to have keep a close eye on so that you can mitigate. Coin toss situation.

    1035:
    Dave Lester Probably, the message to take away from you #1010 is: "Don't be a stupid wanker" - as Ms Murray seems to have been.

    No, actually.

    My message was that there is nothing, absolutely nothing, in English Law that necessitates the use of "redacted", provided that the post in question is properly written, and clear in the claims it makes.

    1036:

    Don't I remember a passage in Neuromancer where a Rasta chap takes a brief glance at the virtual world, and all the nerds excitedly ask him "what did you see?" and he just shakes his head sadly and says "Babylon, man".

    Which about sums it up, really.

    1037:

    unless it was a ton of moves.

    Oddly enough, the worst program I ever wrote was 250,000 move instructions, all the same.

    Context -- I had a 68000-based computer (Atari 520ST), I wanted to grab some 16-bit data as fast as possible. I only needed about 100,000 samples but it was easier to write a program to generate code for the max memory of the computer (512kB, later upgraded to 1MB) in case I needed more samples later or I wanted to play around with trigger delays etc.

    The instruction was, from memory, MOVE.W (A0),(A1)+ repeated 250,000 times to nearly fill the machine's memory. What made this work was the instruction itself took up 16 bits. The rest of the code at the end of the long list of MOVEs were calls to the OS to write the contents of the previous 250,000 16-bit words of RAM to a hex-dump file on the floppy disc.

    A0 was initialised to point to the 16-bit I/O port (I think only 10 bits were valid, it was IIRC an A/D converter). A1 pointed to the first MOVE.W instruction. When it executed the CPU would read the I/O port, increment the program counter then write the 16 bits of data it had read into the same location in RAM (A1) it had just read the instruction from, before incrementing A1 to point to the next word in memory i.e. the next MOVE instruction. It then did the same thing again and again, 250,000 times. At the end of the MOVE operations the data reading part of the program in RAM had been filled with the 16-bit data from the I/O port.

    Doing it like this eliminated delays in looping, counters etc. and it maximised the use of RAM for buffer storage. I think I got something like 600,000 samples/second out of it.

    1038:

    'They chose 35 lab parameters for the machine learning exercise.'

    "I think they used whatever diagnostics the participating hospitals performed - convenience sample/variables to test the model."

    Yes they used the data they would have easily had available. But there were no controls. I suspect they would have got the same correlations for matched non - COVID but similarly ill patients.

    "My take aways are:

    (a) So whatever bias there is in the results is not due to the model makers but to the medicos/hospitals."

    I don't think their results are biased. But I think they are of no or limited use.

    "(b) Are you/the medico going to test for something completely new that you don't understand or are you going to test to see what bit of the patient's body given their medical history you're going to have keep a close eye on so that you can mitigate. Coin toss situation."

    Because there are no controls they can't show they've achieved anything. The parameter they flagged as potentially significant, the lymphocyte count was not even included in the machine learning.

    Perhaps I'm biased since in a previous incarnation it was my job to advise on and implement testing for clinical trials. And also ensure that the lab knew about all trials being carried out with our results.

    Confusing creatine and creatinine is sloppy writing, editing and reviewing.

    1039:

    That's not entirely relevant. If they can get good predictive results from a small set of cheap, quick tests, it doesn't matter whether they have any medical significance. A usably reliable indicator of whether a patient needs anti-COVID drugs proactively is useful in itself.

    I haven't studied the paper in detail, but that's what it seems to claim that it does.

    1040:

    Ha. As I've mentioned before, when I was using Perl all the time, as in it was my day job to develop and maintain a somewhat gnarly and growing/evolving system written in it, I would also use awk mode in one-liners for general log file munging pretty much all the time too. I had a small template so that when it needed to wrap on a terminal maximised to a 1024x720 screen (or at least if it needed to wrap more than twice...), I'd turn it into an actual script (and then forget I'd done it, so I probably still used one liners for variations of the same thing). I made considerable use of the idiom where you close the built-in while() loop to do something after processing the stream, a facility that says a lot about Perl by itself (no idea whether awk itself offers that).

    perl -lane '$ip{$F[0]}++; } print "$_ $ip{$_}" for keys %ip' < access.log

    These days with a modern Perl 5 just sitting there in the Terminal app I still reach for it occasionally when needed for general text file munging, though I'm more likely to have to look up syntax for some things.

    1041:

    That's dogma, but not as bad as the extreme form where no procedure should be longer than 10 lines - have you ever tried to decode a program where operations as simple as addition to a member of a structure were separate functions (different ones for each structure and member, of course)? I have :-(

    A lot of numeric and some other code has long procedures where the only sane way of splitting them up would end up with the parent procedure being a linear sequence of calls to the sub-procedures, and the latter would be used nowhere else. What's the point of that?

    I teach "Damn dogmas - the clearest code is the best."

    1042:

    This is a provocative paper, maybe a bit harsh[1], on how researchers can go wrong with ML for diagnostics: Common pitfalls and recommendations for using machine learning to detect and prognosticate for COVID-19 using chest radiographs and CT scans (Nature, Open Access, 15 March 2021)
    [1] It rejected some papers for silly reasons, perhaps because their (unstated and so I'm guessing) goal was to reject all papers.

    Happy solstice! (Thread)

    Attention everyone, as you know the winter solstice is *tomorrow* in the northern hemisphere and there's just a few last minute planning items before the women can hunt the year-king through the woods and tear him apart!

    — 🚩Shepherd🏴 (@NeolithicSheep) December 20, 2021
    1043:

    I trust you are aware that in the seventies and eighties, folks like them were explicitly speaking of the US in general, and the Sprawl in particular.

    1044:

    Oh. No, I was referring to moving named variables or structures, name, address, zipcode (you did check it was numeric, right?), not arrays.

    sigh

    When I was working at the Scummy Mortgage Co, the "sr. programmer" (she'd worked her way up from keypunch operator) had a program, COBOL, that printed out a six digit label that was about ten chars high (line printer here). She had this thing of well over 2k lines, with a structure for each position - yes, that's 100 structures. I had/got to do maintenance on it, and it was over 600 lines. One array each of the ten digits 10 high (or whatever it was), and struct move.

    1045:

    Right. At the time, I wasn't that hot on perl yet, and in both cases, the 30 or so scripts, and the one set, they made sense, since they were validators and checkers for the data before it went to the d/b loader program.

    1046:

    paws4thot @ 993: 981 - I think that if you're trying to claim that a Mickeyshaft "update" is a breach of federal law, forget it. Read the End User Licence "Agreement" if you don't believe me.

    The EULA doesn't apply to sarcastic kvetching or U.S. Federal Law.

    1047:

    I have once, repeat once, created a procedure something like 1000 lines long. After 3 weeks, my boss and I agreed that we couldn't actually see any sensible way to shorten it, because there weren't any repeated sequences of instructions. I did separate it from the rest of the package it was part of, for reasons of readability.

    1048:

    Bill Arnold @ 1042
    Shouldn't that be ... " ... and shag him to death" ???

    1049:

    no function should be longer than 1-2 screens (that's 25-50 lines)

    Depends on the language. And on the code. Also, these days a screen is more like 500x200 characters, and ~150 lines seems to be reasonable using modern code. Especially for languages like C++ where the code formatting and language design make lambdas grotesque (the least awful option is generally to spread them over extra lines. "return (is match)" becomes ~7 lines).

    Plus I have event loops that deal with 8 bit or 16 bit event types, and that's tedious whichever way you do it. Sure, you can mask the complexity by having a tree of small case statements, but urk. And sadly the jump table version which is sometimes more efficient also obfuscates the code something awful.

    I import one such lump of code and the C++ compiler hates it (it's written in an embedded C dialect), but once the worst is tidied I run into "cyclomatic complexity > 500" warnings and a pile of vomit from all my static analysis tools. It's also ~3000 lines. I just paste it in and hope for the best, because my ability to push changes upstream is negligible (I got a couple of "statement falls through" warnings fixed, because they were obvious errors. But another couple are by design, so I add gotos to bypass the warnings and make it explicit that they're intentional).

    1050:

    But these tests are already being used to treat the patients and there is little need to apply dubious machine learning procedures which will make little difference to the treatment. Important tests for COVID (and all other intensive care patients) like blood gases were not even considered. Particularly when alterations to patient care software are made. One of the worst Y2K problems in the NHS was when non standard software for Down’s screening gave an incorrect maternal date after New Years Day 2000 and it wasn’t discovered for months. Changes in software now need multiple checking before implementation and in this case it would be a lot of work for a trivial benefit.

    1051:

    Article from the Guardian, which references an origin on Boomberg News, that the FDA is about to approve 2 drugs for the treatment of Covid.

    Paxlovid (Pfizer) and molnupiravir (Merck)

    (molnupiravir already approved in the UK).

    https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/dec/21/fda-approve-paxlovid-molnupiravir-covid-pills

    1052:

    Damn dogmas - the clearest code is the best

    Strong agree. "Maxims are for the guidance of wise men, and the blind obedience of fools"

    I'm not arrogant enough to assume that I'll remember what I was thinking six months down the line, let alone anyone who didn't write the code.

    As clear as possible, as simple as possible, and commented as appropriate; I regard anyone suggesting "but the code is the comment!" as a fvckwit. My current project has large chunks of uncommented code written by an arrogant SOB who was a) truly in love with their own brilliance, and b) convinced they were indispensable. One performative "Well, if that's the way you feel, I'm resigning!" later, the boss took him at his word; I've been untangling the wilder parts of his wheel-reinvention for five years now...

    1053:

    I read the tweet thread as a remix of the Frazer(The Golden Bough) writings on the Sacred king. See also the maenads mentioned above - they would tear to pieces animals(/humans), e.g. a bull. (All wikipedia links, but they'll do.)

    1054:

    Depends on the language. And on the code.

    ...Sort of.

    Yes, coding conventions like "no more than 80 columns!" irritate me, because we're all running decent monitors, not a VT220 with an appalling resolution; but that two-full-screens-ish guideline is a useful one.

    What worries me is testability. If you can't test something with a reasonable degree of confidence, the function's too damn big. Most of the larger "it just grew, honest" 300+ line functions I've seen, seem to have large numbers of conditionals or loops. Given that most people don't bother with two-to-the-N test cases, it tends to suggest that such code is never thoroughly (or even adequately) tested by test harnesses / regressions.

    The "what's the point of breaking it up, that function will only be called from one place" rather misses the point - it's not just about clarity, but testability and maintainability.

    1055:

    I've been untangling the wilder parts of his wheel-reinvention for five years now...

    Ah, job security.

    1056:

    "...spiking the punch at the Ambassador's Ball with a mixture of yage, hashish and yohimbine, precipitating an orgy?"
    I deliberately didn't use the name of the concoction. But your's might be quite interesting, too, depending on context.
    Charlie seems to be a bit annoyed so letting it rest for a while.

    Re Dave Lester's comment, it is generally good to be aware of what is indexed/spidered(/actively tracked), and how often. (Linear comment threads like these are generally indexed by public search engines (disqus is apparently not), though eventually search engines stop reindexing unless asked (e.g. google has a procedure) to re-index.) E.g. Names+Google can (and do) attract attention. (Nyms too :-)

    1057:

    Testing is a whole different ball game, and design for testability is a skill in itself.

    The flip side is that unit testing is often a complete waste of time, made worse if the code has to be mangled to allow every line to be unit tested. I've grown to prefer integration and system testing, just because the boundaries are normally more reasonable when you're doing those tests.

    At the extreme you get compiler testing for functions that consist entirely of return collection.find(lambda{does this match}) but because there are four or five paths through some monkey gets told to write five or six tests for that function and now you have 100 lines of code to maintain. It's bullshit, and it's even worse with exceptions because some monkey has to work out how to trigger every exception that those things can throw.

    Where I work we have system and some integration tests in the CI, and a few unit tests for things at the library level where stand-along functions make that practical. The Rust and Ruby code has more tests, and the phone apps have ~50% statement coverage... but strangely just as many bugs make it to production as from the C++ system. Mind you, the embedded code has no automated tests and no prospect of getting any. So we have system tests for some of that, and integration tests for the server at the "spawn a thread and poke it a bit" level, plus some packet generators that test basic functionality of the whole system. Including stuff like load tests, which is where sub-system testing shifts from farcical to nonsensical.

    My goal is to have less test code that production code, and for the tests to take less time to run than the rest of the build process (because they run in parallel). Then the system tests should take less than a day, because stress testing systems is hard to do quickly. It takes work to make this happen. We drop stress tests regularly, or pause them, when they stop being areas of concern.

    1058:

    Ton of moves?

    Reminds me of this video I found only a couple of weeks ago: Turning mov into a soul crushing RE nightmare (YouTube link) where the presenter presents a compiler which compiles only to MOV instructions...

    1059:

    BTW - the high ferritin levels which are mostly associated with either (a) a genetic predisposition (predominantly among northern Caucasians) and/or (b) liver damage from too much alcohol may help explain why the Russian Covid deaths are so high, i.e., close to 3% of confirmed cases vs. UK at just over 1% per the Johns Hopkins site.

    Sorry to respond late to this, but the New Yorker had a rather different take on why Russia just passed the US with the most Covid19 total deaths (over a million, apparently).

    https://www.newyorker.com/news/dispatch/why-russia-hasnt-cracked-down-on-covid-19

    If it's paywalled, or tl;dr, here's the key paragraph:

    "The answer reveals a great deal about the true power, and limitations, of the Putin system. Ekaterina Schulmann, a prominent political scientist in Moscow, has described today’s Russia as an “informational autocracy” that “relies most on the impression it is able to create.” The Kremlin can count on, say, F.S.B. henchmen to loyally carry out its edicts, but it lacks any real power to guarantee the same for millions of citizens, even those it considers a part of its electoral base. For Putin, if the majority of people are disinclined to follow quarantine measures or calls to be vaccinated, failing to force compliance only calls attention to a weakness that the architecture of the system was designed to mask in the first place. “This dynamic is especially dangerous in a time of constantly sinking popularity, when people have started to fall out of love with you,” Schulmann said. In the past several years, the Levada Center has found consistently falling levels of trust and job approval for Putin; last month, a survey showed that trust in the President was fifty-three per cent, the lowest such figure since 2012. “To enact harsh or unpopular measures and then see them ignored or sabotaged only deepens the feeling of crisis,” Schulmann told me. “The most dangerous thing of all is to give an order that won’t be followed.”"

    There may be a biochemical cause for the high death rate, but the political problem does need to be dismissed first.

    1060:

    The current project I'm working on we decided to only (with some minor exceptions) do deep (full stack + external services) automated integration testing with data fuzzers as the input.

    It's worked out amazingly well so far, there was no facade/interface/injection hell you get with project with a heavy unit test focus, and we find all the weird reliability bugs suppliers/customers systems.

    It's also nice to make a small refactor/design change run your tests and a few seconds later announce that your 'small change' f'd up some contract in some part of the AWS config. If we'd a been doing unit testing first approach, these issues wouldn't have shown up for weeks.

    (based on xunit and dotnetcore WebApplicationFatory).

    And to everyone who winges about how everything is so complex these days, and you can't just make a simple... yep.

    1061:

    Bill Arnold
    Long time since I read Frazer, yes, but ....
    It's since been realised that he, um, exaggerated a bit, though "Year-King" rituals did occur.
    IIRC, Orpheus was dismembered by Maenads?

    .... I thought you could overload/spoof search criteria like that, with fairly simple word-lists, or better still, sprinkle said word-list into one's normal texts. The word-equivalent of steganography, if you will?

    Moz
    Critical code-testing, yes, well.
    The example I always think of is railway signalling software coding & testing - or, given recent fatal fuck-ups, control-critical testing for aircraft systems - thank you Boeing.

    1062:

    "IIRC, Orpheus was dismembered by Maenads? "

    IIRC, that was Actaeon. Orpheus simply failed to get Eurydice out with him.

    JHomes

    1064:

    Oh, you might be right there. There are a lot of things that work but aren't worth the bother - I have invented dozens myself.

    1065:

    Testability IS a serious problem for all operations that are inherently complex or large. Splitting up helps but only if you can test each unit separately - when you can't, it's pointless. It's also largely pointless if the large procedure is just sequential code or a mammoth selection of different actions, because it's easy to add diagnostics to them in that form. I loathe things where I have to test 1,000 complicated lines as an entity, but it happens.

    1066:

    Actually, I'm (partly) wrong. Actaeon was dogs, not Maenads. I don't recall exactly who fell to Maenads, someone connected to Bacchus, but not Orpheus.

    JHomes.

    1067:

    If that article is representing them correctly, they are more likely to be on something than onto something.

    1068:

    1052 - I recall one of my software design lecturers actually saying "in COBOL (but the language nominated is not the point, my aside) the code is self documenting", and then having a student who handed in a project which was just source apart from a note saying "on $date you said 'COBOL is a self documenting language".

    1054 - OTOH sub-programs that have only one entry and one exit add complexity for the maintainer rather than increasing readability since you have to generate a parameter list for a call that is only made once, and for the statements in that call.

    1057 - Makes sense. Particularly when everyone involved in the development cycle for that code has sufficient experience to realise that one size does not fit all.

    1063 & 1067 - Just ran the article past my sister (pharmacologist) and she thinks it may make sense, if the report is accurate.

    1069:

    Both testing and testability are hard problems.

    In Varnish Cache we have just a tad above 90% code coverage, but at the cost of 886 test-cases. Holding that goal takes work, but it does, demonstratively, find bugs before we ship them to users.

    We're lucky with Varnish, in the sense that our interfaces to the rest of the world are few, mostly non-human and relatively well defined.

    We use a dedicated test-driver called "varnishtest" which is responsible for 21 out of 163 KLOC in the project.

    However, tjat is not just overhead of "our own test program", varnish users also use it to test their own configurations, and HAProxy also use it under the name "VTest".

    But still, yes, comprehensive testing is a LOT of work.

    1070:

    Is your employer hiring testers?

    1071:

    Yes. Exhaustive testing is even harder. I have written tests that checked not just every line of code but every alternative branch/state, and it was three times the length of the code and five times as hard to debug (you have to check that it will detect errors, as well as not detect non-errors).

    1072:

    JHolmes
    As you note, later - Actaeon annoyed Artemis & was transformed into a stag & then torn apart by her hounds ( Ovid - Metamorphoses )
    Orpheus was dismembered by Maenads - apparently for worshipping the "wrong" god.

    1073:

    Re: '... the New Yorker had a rather different take on why Russia just passed the US with the most Covid19 total deaths (over a million, apparently).'

    No prob about late response - hope all is well with you.

    Anyways - I think this needs to be split into 'catch' and 'die of' parts:

    a) 'catch Covid' - I've noticed that areas where trust in the pols/gov't system is low, more people catch Covid because they don't trust their (or by extension anyone else's) gov't to care about the common folk.

    b) 'die of Covid' - This part shows how strong/weak the underlying social norms and corresponding infrastructure are that in turn directly impact overall physiological (and other) health of the populace. The alcoholism rate among males in Russia is over 1 in 3 - that's staggeringly high! Until 2011 anything under 10% alcohol was not considered 'alcohol' in Russia meaning that kids could easily buy what Westerners would consider 'alcohol'. Alcoholism is a serious underlying medical condition wrt to Covid.

    https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-14232970#:~:text=Russian%20President%20Dmitry%20Medvedev%20has,has%20been%20considered%20a%20foodstuff.

    Russia is very weak on both parts. Yeah - I think there's somne serious under-reporting going on. If sleepingroutine still visits this site, I hope he/she decides to provide some local input.

    1074:

    Speaking of big computing, I wonder if our computer-savvy membership could comment on this:

    https://www.technologyreview.com/2021/12/21/1042835/2021-was-the-year-of-monster-ai-models/

    "What does it mean for a model to be large? The size of a model—a trained neural network—is measured by the number of parameters it has. These are the values in the network that get tweaked over and over again during training and are then used to make the model’s predictions. Roughly speaking, the more parameters a model has, the more information it can soak up from its training data, and the more accurate its predictions about fresh data will be.

    "GPT-3 has 175 billion parameters—10 times more than its predecessor, GPT-2. But GPT-3 is dwarfed by the class of 2021. Jurassic-1, a commercially available large language model launched by US startup AI21 Labs in September, edged out GPT-3 with 178 billion parameters. Gopher, a new model released by DeepMind in December, has 280 billion parameters. Megatron-Turing NLG has 530 billion. Google’s Switch-Transformer and GLaM models have one and 1.2 trillion parameters, respectively."

    (Billion and trillion are probably American usage, 1e9 and 1e12 respectively.)

    1075:

    I have written tests that checked not just every line of code but every alternative branch/state, and it was three times the length of the code

    Likewise. The first time was for 5KLOC of hard real-time embedded C, for mission-critical avionics; we had 15KLOC of test harness (and an awful lot more documentation). It's still flying, twenty-five years later.

    The second time I managed it, was a library handler, about 3KLOC of C++; I had a chance to write it from the ground up, and wrote thorough set of tests around the functions as it was written (cppunit-like stuff). We ran our shiny new static analysis toolchain against it, to find that it was pretty near 100% of all branches (although, as you point out, that doesn't necessarily mean it's thorough - that takes nominal, boundary, and erroneous value testing)

    We put it into the field, perhaps 100K users, and three years later it had zero code changes from its initial release (and no bugs reported against it). We then made one specification change, aligned the code, and it's still out there a decade later.

    1076:

    Similar experience, where a test harness for a sub-program tends to involve a statement for each input parameter, one for each output, and two for each input/output of the subprogram under test, and where the word "parameter" should be taken as meaning "data field", so a record of time, x_coord, y_coord, Z_coord needs 4 statements to load the record with the test data, and another 4 to display it afterwards.

    Also, in some respects I'm a bit of an advocate of "extreme programming". This is not jumping out of a perfectly serviceable aeroplane with a parachute on your back and a laptop on your chest, and trying to write a working sub-program before you have to open the parachute, but rather having full access to the entire codebase so that you can modify anything at any time, a hard wood floor, a castor base computer chair and multiple terminals logged in and performing tasks on them at once.

    1077:

    Sounds about right, with the note that boundary conditions for angles include incrementing and decrementing towards and away from your limiting condition, values around tangent (90) and tangent (270), their arctans, around the phase changes and around the maxima and minima. I have written, and indeed documented, just such test data files.

    1078:

    Re: '... hard real-time embedded C, for mission-critical avionics; ... We then made one specification change, aligned the code, and it's still out there a decade later.'

    OOC - how much technical background/expertise in avionics did you/your coding team have before writing this?

    1079:

    I disagree. That was our opinion, with both of us being experienced programmers.

    The alternatives... well, using Brief (the best programming editor, ran under MS DOS), I once split my screen (decades before we had two monitors) 27 ways.

    1080:

    And any other discontinuity or singularity, explicit and implicit. Yes, that's real fun. The first time I did that, I had to target unknown arithmetics with at least six floating-point representations. That accounted for about half the complexity :-)

    1081:

    One of the phrases I used for many years in job interviews was that "some people think job security is 'never let them know what you're doing', while mine was "if it's 16:15 on Friday, or 02:00, and I get an emergency phone call, I don't want to spend hours figuring out how clever I was a year ago, I want to solve the problem and leave on time/go back to sleep that night."

    The short phrase I came up with was "I want elegant, not clever, code." And whether I was writing awk or C or COBOL, the only time I used single-letter variable names was in "for i=0; i < b; i++). Anything else I used a meaningful name for.

    Why, no, I never entered the Obfuscated C competition.

    1082:

    Testing really is an art. (For that matter, one of my daughters has done years of it, along with programming, for a multinational known mostly for aircraft....)

    And it isn't always write a zillion lines, it's write the first set. Then add to it... because you'd damned well better be doing regression testing, unless you really want that bug that was in version 3.4 back in 4.1. (Let's not even begin to get into vcs's, and why I would refuse to work with them if each developer did not check out with a lock.)

    1083:

    While we're swapping war stories:

    I worked for a while on software assurance, which meant checking that the developers of some high integrity software (not flight-critical avionics, but still important) had done their jobs right. Partly this meant checking they had followed the relevant standard, and partly applying my skill and experience as a developer to spot shenanigans.

    I always made sure that I followed a requirement down into the code and then back up through the tests, just to see what I found there. On one occasion I found code along the lines of

    constant integer C3 = 3;

    constant integer C5 = 5;

    and then

    A5 is Array [0..C5];

    and so on. (The language was Ada, and I don't recall the exact syntax).

    They had a coding standard which said "no in-line numbers; you must used named constants", and this was enforced by a checking tool. Of course the checking tool was quite happy to see "X := Y + C3" where it would have rejected "X := Y + 3".

    It could have been worse; I might have found

    constant integer C4 = 5;

    1084:

    Nope. It was Maenads what got Orpheus, as he wandered drunk through the woods, agonized over having lost Eurydice again.

    1085:

    VEHEMENT disagreement. A function ("sub-program") should only have one entrance and one exit. Otherwise, just as a start, debugging gets far more troublesome. And you need more code to validate the input. In more than one place....

    1086:

    You write:

    b) 'die of Covid' - This part shows how strong/weak the underlying social norms and corresponding infrastructure are

    Unfortunately, all of that became political, and are you trying to say it's only in Russia, given the UK and the US's antivaccinators?

    1087:

    "Modify anything at any time"...

    Sorry, I'm about to run screaming out of the room. Before or after notifying your manager, and/or other developers? And how critical is the "anything"? And are you planning on shoving it into production?

    You know, the way faceplant rolls out changes?

    1088:

    whitroth: (Let's not even begin to get into vcs's, and why I would refuse to work with them if each developer did not check out with a lock.)

    Oh God, another war story from my time in Software Assurance.

    We had a new bit of software installed, and during operation it started misbehaving. There seemed to be undocumented features (big no-no), and bugs that had been fixed were reappearing.

    I was sent out to the supplier to get to the bottom of this. I was introduced to their "Configuration Manager", who frankly admitted to me that he was an ordinary developer who had been told one day "The contract says we need a configuration manager, so you're it".

    They were using CVS, badly. The poor guy fingered for the job didn't know anything about CVS, and also had to keep up with the development work. So basically CM wasn't getting done. Developers would check stuff out, modify it for whatever new feature was required, and check it back in. We were supposed to have our own dedicated version, but forking wasn't a thing in their world, and then they made a mess of rolling back stuff to try to get the extra features out.

    I spent a bit of time teaching him CVS-101 (not that I was any kind of expert in it myself, but I at least knew the basics). And then had to spend some weeks going through printouts from "cvs diff" (which gives you the changes between two versions) marking lines of code with coloured highlighter pens depending on whether I could see that they had been introduced by a legitimate change or not. Uurgh.

    1089:

    Um... you may have seen me mention the Scummy Mortgage Co that I worked for. One day, might have been in '88, I was working on a CICS program that the programmer who'd been there for 10 years (and just fired) had done... and I came to my boss, the VP of DP, to show him the "algorithm" that the programmer had used: "if it was '76 or '80 or '84 or '88 or '92, it was a leap year."

    No, I'm not kidding. But wait, it gets worse.

    My boss said, "is it broke?" "But it will in less than four years" "It ain't broke, don't fix it. We'll fix it when it breaks."

    At a mortgage co, with, you know, 30 year mortgages....

    1090:

    As we old farts reminisce about the golden age of programming...

    SpaceX just landed their 100th booster rocket.

    Didn't they just start doing that a year ago? (My sense of time since March 2020 is severely warped.)

    1091:

    Oh, story time?

    I was once working as a contractor software developer, so our customers hired us to do development stuff - the projects I was involved in were from six months to three and a half years, so not the short term stuff.

    In one of these client assignments, at a large customer, in a big project, there was this small testing tool. It had been written once and then distributed in various forms throughout the project, and of course had accumulated all kinds of new features.

    I was given the task of finding out the various versions of this testing tool in the project, and combine all the nice features into one code base, and put that into a version control system. After some detective work (and a week or two of time) I had found about ten different versions of this tool, some distributed as a code zip file, some in CVS repositories (both dedicated to this one and part of some other repository), and a couple as compiled binaries.

    Of course the features of all of these weren't all compatible. I spent three weeks trying to figure out a workable set of features, implementing them in the 'best' code base and then putting the thing into one dedicated repository. Of course the code was written in the style of 'we need something to use in testing this thing', so the quality was almost non-existent.

    After that I got assigned to the maintenance of a bigger testing setup for that project, but that's an even longer and sadder story so I'll perhaps tell it later.

    1092:

    Pilot moondog@202 recommends www.girlgeniusonline.com/comic.php

    What a great series! Regional library sharing website lists a dozen of these collections published by Tor. Kaja Foglio's scripts blend sword and sorcery, steampunk and alternate 19 th century Euro history to captivating effect, and her husband's artwork lampoons the styles of Mort Drucker, Al Capp, Archie comics with a substantial influence of Little Annie Fannie. Hilarious caricatures throughout. If they can win multiple Hugos then I don't see as how those awards are anything less than a recognition of genuine merit, no trace of regulatory capture by the publishing biz, at least not for this category. Although I remain blissfully ignorant of what the Sad Puppies were all about.

    1093:

    I think that he meant 'called from precisely one place'. While I have seen cases where alternate entry, alternate exit and assigned GOTO all clarified the code, 90% of the time that was to bypass another language deficiency! The remaining cases numbered no more than 3 for each, and I have a lot of wide-ranging experience with many people's code.

    W.r.t. what I think he meant, I partially agree. The worst case I saw was half a dozen nested loops, containing several hundred lines of densely packed matrix algebra. When I said "surely that can be clarified by being split up", the response was that two of its developers had tried and failed; I tried and failed, too. Oh, yes, it could be split up, but that hid the essential symmetries, and made it harder to understand.

    1094:

    Oh. You've just discovered Phil and Katja. You should look at Phil's body of work.... (I say, looking up at the pic that may be the first one Phil ever sold, that my late wife bought in the early eighties).

    1095:

    1080 - :-) are we talking about known unknowns, unknown unknowns, or values where we don't know if they're known or not?

    1081 - Similarly, the only single letter variables in my code are loop counters, and constants where that letter is an SI named constant.
    BTW I maintain that C is, or can be, a "write only" progrmming language.

    1083 - Aside from details of syntax (that's what compilers are for ;-) ) that is legal Ada.

    1085 - I think you misunderstood me; I was saying that a procedure can have more than one parameter, and that any one, or more, of those parameters can have any of the modes "in", "in-out" and "out". There is only one entry point, "procedure My_Proc : --parameter list ) is" or "function My_Func : --input parameter list" and one exit point "end My_Proc ;" or "end My_Func ;" respectively for any given subporgram, regardless of how many calls it has.
    Which does actually break coding rules, but only in that a line, not a statement, a line, has to be terminated when a comment marker "--" appears.

    1087 - If you're doing real extreme programming, and not just rolling around on your favourite chair and doing 3 unrelated jobs at once, maybe, maybe, lots and none at all, only if it works, and I don't use ar$ebook.

    1089 - Would y'all pass me the co-codimol? I think I'm starting a headache! ;-)

    1093 - Good point well made. I misspoke and meant "a subprogram that is called from exactly one place, and returns to that place and only that place on successful termination".

    1096:

    I assume that you're kidding about the sense of time. Of probably more significance, on the 18th, they landed booster B1051 for the 11th time.

    The goal was 10 flights between major refurbishment and 100 flights in total. I don't know if B1051 had a refurbishment, but if it did, it was pretty quick, as the gap between flights isn't unusually long.

    So it looks like they're hitting their goals for the F9 reuse program. Though I'm sure they'll be retired long before they hit the 100 flights per booster. Starship looks like being cheaper per launch. There will be no reason to fly F9 once that happens (unless the Dragon program is kept going by NASA)

    1097:

    SpaceX just landed their 100th booster rocket. ... Didn't they just start doing that a year ago?

    No, they first landed a booster in 2017. Their next and final flight of 2021 will be the 31st, which is still goddamn impressive insofar as it exceeds the entire US launch rate for any given year in the 1980s by a considerable margin (and they're reflyable).

    1098:

    Re parameters: ok. IIRC - it's been a while since I was writing heavy code - you do the in-only parms first, then the in-out.

    And I admit I have seen, and once or twice, used a goto... inside a function, where, say, a case statement was "yep", or "nope", skip everything else, you're done here, go to exit.

    1099:

    Starship looks like being cheaper per launch

    And carries 7-10 times the payload!

    (They get to "cheaper per launch" by not throwing away an upper stage, complete with an Mvac engine, on every flight. Entire Starship system is reusable, which makes up for the extra fuel consumption -- about a factor of 5.)

    1100:

    SpaceX just landed their 100th booster rocket.

    That needs rearranging a bit. SpaceX just landed a booster rocket for the 100th time, although even that's not quite worded right. Four boosters (B1049, B1051, B1058 and B1060) have made 39 of the 100 landings. The current fleet has 17 boosters available, six of which (two Heavy side boosters, three Heavy centre cores and one new F9 booster) have so far not flown at all.

    The 100th landing was exactly six years after the first success.

    1101:

    Nothing wrong with goto. I use it myself. Twice at the last count. Cue somebody 'splaining that all constructs are goto under the hood.

    On the ordering of input & output parameters. Kinda. Conventions like that are helpful so long as all the users know them. "const" is better. Ideally both.

    1102:

    I meant to add that compilers make non trivial return by value as cheap as out parameters in most cases so I use them instead.

    Except for the exceptions of course.

    These days I think half the job is knowing what the compiler does well and badly.

    1103:

    1098 - No no gotos, not ever, but, if pressed I will admit to a case statement going:-

    case My_Var is :=
    when $value1 :
    -- code
    when $value2 :
    -- code
    when $value3 :
    null ; -- Will make execution jump to end case statement
    when others :
    -- code
    end case ;

    1101 - Sort of agreed, but seriously I only use a GOTO if the language doesn't have a more elegant structure with the same effect .

    1104:

    I assume that you're kidding about the sense of time.

    Not really. Time seems to have almost stopped since March of 2020. My wife had an apartment 1000 miles from me. We saw each other most weekends and spent multiple weeks with me there doing my thing remotely and took vacations together. Then March 2020 hit, she got retired, I drove there in a big van and picked her up in July 2020 and we've been on our home with limited interaction to all but immediate family (who live nearby) for almost 2 full years. And it just doesn't seem like it. I think it is the limited personal interactions. Going to the grocery doesn't seem to tick over the mental clock.

    And yes my wording was poor. SpaceX just landed a booster for the 100th time. In my mind I had watched most of them. Or a replay. But now I'd have to guess I've only seen video on 15 or so. A few of each combination. East coast water, west coast, water, single land, double land.

    Still 100 is impressive.

    As to Starship, at some point Musk will have to basically buy out everyone nearby on that coastal area of Texas. No way can people live under a weekly (or more often) close down all the local roads while we "do it again". Well sane people.

    1105:

    Oh sure, there's real advantages to being a slow trend follower, by the time you discover a thing, it's far enough down in the product life cycle that it's either free or freely available. More for me!

    Which makes me wonder if there's a sweet spot that looks obvious with hindsight for entry to any market. Get there too early and, like with the first computer languages, you burn out your life's energy contending with what Spock described as 'stone knives and bearskins.' Too late and the whole thing's been so thoroughly assimilated into the mainstream that it's just another commodity, low margin and low rewards to pursue it.

    Even in climate policy, I have to wonder if future generations might look back with regret or pity on some of the big investments made too early, reflecting sadly on how much money and effort got squandered on immature technologies, like a proposed Manhattan seawall, " if only they'd waited until 'magic X' turned up a few years later." Like economic bubbles though, some trends are invisible from the inside no matter how glaringly blatant from outside. Too late now to worry about it, when every year wasted for fear of lost opportunities translates directly into meters of sea level.

    1106:

    It's vanishingly rare and only to be used on occasions when you can demonstrate that you can both beat the compiler and there is a pressing need. IMHO that sort of thing should be revisited every couple of years in case the optimiser has got its shit together.

    There's a cppcon talk about "non conforming c++" by a man in a tinfoil hat that includes "computed goto", for when you really need to tell the compiler how to implement switch. I can see the value but hope I never find any occasion to use it.

    1107:

    Seriously. Some years ago, I remember having issues, and the answer was to tell the compiler not go -O2 optimize, because that broke things with the driver.

    1108:

    As above, you can usually achieve the same effect with a more elegant structure. I would advocate confining the GOTO to use in languages that don't offer loop and/or case structures. Well, unless you can demonstrate a gain in execution speed for the final executable anyway.

    1109:

    That kind of sounds a bit like the time upthread that I fixed a problem before I knew properly what it was, by putting in an exception block to stop exception masking in the code.

    1110:

    Well, case statements like that are pretty normal in C. I consider it perfectly clear to have one that goes like this:

    switch(bottom->state) {
    /* TODO: add error handling */
        case ITCHY:  scratch(bottom); break;
        case FULL:   evacuate(bottom, toilet);
        case DIRTY:  wipe(bottom);
        case NORMAL: break;
    }

    These days GCC is wanting to coerce us all into pissing around setting __attribute__((__fallthrough__)) on cases like FULL and DIRTY. I deplore the fashionable execration of fallthrough in C case statements as if it was shockingly unexpected behaviour - no it's not, it's C, that's what it's supposed to do. And every language that has copied C does it the same way, so it's not just what you expect C to do, it's what you expect code that looks like C to do even if it's not actually C.

    The situation I'm familiar with that matches whitroth's description is when your $value3 case means not just "nothing to see here", but "oh, it's like that is it? fuck all this then.", so you want to jump out of the case statement and out of its enclosing loop or other case statement (and possibly up more levels too). But break in C only takes you out of the current level, so you can't, and sometimes you find that of all the possible frigs you have as alternatives, goto is the one with the least resemblance to a donkey's bottom.

    Anyway, case statements in C are pretty wonderful really...

    switch(thing) {
        case 0: if (condition) {
        case 1: /* do stuff */; break;
        } else {
        case 2: /* do other stuff */; break;
        }
    }

    1111:

    And what is exactly wrong with "GOTO"? Of course if you are using old-fashioned (Non-visual ) BASIC or FORTAN IV - probably nothing, but things have got a little more involuted since then ...

    Time seems to have almost stopped since March of 2020. - yup, go with that slight problem, we seem to be stuck in a C-19 version of Groundhog Day?

    Pigeon
    If THAT is what C statements/programming looks like, I really do not want to know ....

    1112:

    SpaceX has already offered to buy out everyone in the immediate Boca Chica area at 3 times appraised value. A lot of them have accepted but there are some holdouts who want more, and a few who are now making a decent living live-streaming the activity and providing news updates. The main problem they are going to have there is that all beaches in Texas are open to the public, and changing that will involve a change to the state constitution which is unlikely to happen.

    Elon has said that work has restarted on a launch pad at Cape Canaveral, and NASA has been asked to start the environmental assessment for what is now being referred to as LC49 which is roughly where LC39C (or LC39A if you go back far enough) would have been built.

    Boca Chica and Cape Canaveral will both have problems with the launch rate proposed, as well as the problem of Starships returning ballistically over land. One of the oil rigs they picked up cheap appears to have had all its superstructure removed now, and the other is just parked up, with little sign of more work bing done on either.

    1113:

    I really love the Rust style (I saw it there first) result/optional types. It combines the two normal cases for return values - "is this an error" and "if it's not an error, what's the value". And often you end up just returning that after getting it from something else.

    The explicit version is something like:

    result = SomeFunction(...)
    if(result)
       result = DoSomething(result.value)
    else
       return result

    But the Rust idiom is more like

    result = SomeFunction(...)?
    DoSomething(result)

    Where the return is implicitly the value of the last function called, and the question mark means "if this fails return the error".

    I find that in C++ I'm leaning towards functions that return optional PODs, which is a reasonably simple template but makes life easier.

    if((result = SomeFunction(...)).ok()

    Or something like that. Because these days inevitably I'm calling something like "get me the Greek version of this email with these parameters substituted" and the result is From, Subject, HTML body and text body, but making four calls with subtly different parameters to each one just results in errors from parameter ordering or substitution (ask me how I know!).

    1114:

    In the kind of situation I'm thinking of, GCC, at least, is already pretty unbeatable. It seems well able to figure out you're trying to break out of several nested levels at once and just emit a JMP to the appropriate point. The thing is that whatever you're doing to achieve that, though it may be perfectly understandable to the compiler, can in some cases be less understandable to a human if you reject the option of just doing goto break3; or whatever.

    1115:

    Greg, C can be a really nicely written language if that's something the programmer(s) desire, there are some slightly weird idioms that make life easier but once you have those it can be straightforward.

    I've written embedded C that ran for ~20 years with ongoing mods, and because I wrote it to be simple and clear from the start most of the later developers were encouraged or shamed into following suit. When I got contracted back to clean it up/improve it, it was surprisingly good. BUT it only had to run in one environment (well, six generations of one environment...) so it could be quite specific.

    Sadly C is also a language that can be portable, and has been around for a very long time. Which means there is a lot of code that is really fucking ugly{tm} because it's both old and portable. Things are done because they work rather than because they're easier to read.

    The alternative is often to have 12 different versions of the code in a slightly nicer to read format, but then someone has to maintain 12 different versions of the code.

    1116:

    Or, in Ada:-

    Case Bottom is :=
    When ITCHY -> Scratch ;
    When FULL -> wait to On_Toilet ;
    Evacuate ;
    When others -> null ; -- If we think of other states, add them to the enumeration and action sub-programs above here end case ;

    Not a GOTO in sight, but easy to modify for dirty or any other states your bottom might be in.

    1117:

    C/C++ really are the languages of deep nesting. Even with std::optional or std::result you still end up with chains of if(this failed) else if (that failed) else if (other failed)... as the least awful option. Not helped by a whole lot of things behaving idiosyncratically on failure. The output may be non-existent, unusable, invalid, misleading or zero/null, depending entirely on the context. So you can't necessarily call "convert this to that" and leave the output untouched if you get an error. Oh, and there's always the option that calling the thread-safe version might return a pointer to a static buffer, discarding the pointer to your buffer that you passed in. {cries}

    Or, in the case of MySql, the "error integer" returned is -1 cast to uint64. Just because.

    1118:

    I've come across that kind of behaviour too. To be sure, what I was doing was next door to deliberately looking for trouble, but it was also very much the kind of thing you do naturally end up doing when you're writing something like a driver, taking advantage of the resemblance of C to a high-level assembler and being surprised at points where the resemblance is poor.

    It's particularly nasty when something everyone's been using unsuspectingly for years suddenly gets into a new standard as being explicitly undefined, and the optimiser gets updated to know that means it can now just leave stuff out altogether and still be correct according to the standard. All of a sudden loads of things still seem to be compiled fine, but don't work any more for no apparent reason...

    1119:

    I remember when BBC BASIC came along and all of a sudden you could stop thinking about line numbers and almost never had to do a GOTO. It made it such a tremendous fuck of a lot easier to follow what was going on than in previous kinds of BASIC that I've never had any disagreement with antigotoism...

    1120:

    Even in climate policy, I have to wonder if future generations might look back with regret or pity on some of the big investments made too early, reflecting sadly on how much money and effort got squandered on immature technologies, like a proposed Manhattan seawall, " if only they'd waited until 'magic X' turned up a few years later."

    I doubt that there is any 'magic X' or other silver bullet that is going to come along and make any change in climate change investments.

    The bigger thing, that we have already, is the regret of not starting things sooner (or alternately, actually doing them now instead of by some variable of Y years into the future that is a sliding window).

    All of which means there are predictable losers coming in the next decades, and their numbers (combined with the costs of attempting to prevent more losers) means they won't get a government bail out I suspect some are expecting when their ocean lifestyle goes underwater.

    1121:

    I find similar if/else chains trying to arise when everything has succeeded, and now you have a lump of data, like the header block of some file format, which requires lots of little piddling different things to be done or not done to transform data which is merely technically valid (or maybe indeed technically invalid but still recoverable because some common implementation always gets it wrong) into something which is actually usable. This field may be in any of 3 different places; that field may be 16 or 32 bits, but if the first one was in its second place it might not be there at all; the other field is garbage if the file was written by a Mickeyshaft program but you can reconstruct it from fields a, g and k, or maybe k, e and f. The process of disentangling this into something consistent to use henceforth itself generates if/else chains, and at any point along, you may discover that what you've got is actually fucked beyond recovery and all you can do is abort (but you still need to clean up after yourself). The essentially arbitrary and individual nature of the little piddling things means there's really no way to group them or lay them out according to any sensible order, and whatever you end up doing when the indentation starts falling off the edge of the screen is a difficult exercise in minimising awkwardness.

    Those contextually idiosyncratic failure responses are not too bad - at least you usually find that most of the functions in a particular category respond in the same way as each other, and those that don't make it obvious that they have to be different because in their case the usual pattern wouldn't make sense. At least C isn't PHP, which is just a bloody mess...

    I do find though that it is often useful to wrap the raw things you're given in little stubs to impose consistency, so you can say "convert this to this" and it will either work or it will report an error in the same way everything else does. This is also an opportunity to introduce the kind of behaviour in your Rust example, which I agree can be a very useful way to deal with things.

    "if((result = SomeFunction(...)).ok()"

    It seriously gets on my tits that in C there is no way to automatically give .ok() a pointer to its containing structure, so you have to say if((result = SomeFunction(...)).ok(result) if you want it to look at itself. I've had a couple of cracks at creating something that does let you do this, but they depend heavily on macro magic, GCC extensions, bits of assembler, and information derived from analysing object files, so they are kind of flaky and shit.

    "...the thread-safe version might return a pointer to a static buffer..."

    A static buffer? So when the same error happens in another thread...??

    1122:

    A static buffer? So when the same error happens in another thread...?

    My expectation is that it's a really static buffer, literally a pointer to an immutable string "file not found" that was shipped with the executable. But I haven't confirmed that.

    I have a "misc utils" file full of random shit like "stringtouint64" in four overloads and stuff like that, because the default C/C++ ones all have funny edge cases and return values in weird ways. Plus a comms one, to hold shit like the 20-odd cyclomatic complexity to open a UDP socket the way I need it. Somehow every language I've used ends up with files like that.

    Plus I am currently using one library that only communicates errors as exceptions. "close this connection" -> Exception("that connection is not open") or even worse Exception("that connection cannot currently be closed"). So not only does every function that calls into that library need the C++ exception garbage, the library doesn't work if I turn off exceptions. And the resulting exceptions are almost never useful. FUCK you people. Just fuck you utterly and completely.

    1123:

    RE: '... are you trying to say it's only in Russia, given the UK and the US's antivaccinators?'

    No - not saying it's only in Russia.

    Just trying to highlight that there are two distinct factors at play.

    The R States seem to parallel Russia: (a) mistrust of present gov't and (b) serious underlying medical conditions (obesity mostly, followed by malnutrition).

    https://www.cdc.gov/obesity/data/prevalence-maps.html

    1124:

    Re: Data by State

    This is probably the most accurate for mortality, cause(s) and co-morbidities except that it's awkward to read/understand with a lot of side notes/cautions about how and when data are received, multiple causes of death (i.e., do not sum certain columns or you'll double count), etc. Lastly - not all hospitals report into the CDC.

    https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/vsrr/covid_weekly/index.htm#Comorbidities

    Pretty alarming how high COVID pushed mortality rates.

    1125:

    You guys aren’t exactly making a good case for why anyone should ever use a non-Smalltalk system for making software. Pointers? Mind-mangling fucked case statements? Compiler optimisation flags that cause problems? Shudder. Just nope.

    On a slightly in-the-past note, I swear I recall some discussion a while back about heatpumps. Well, I just an interesting illustration of how effective they really are. It’s pretty cold here right now, freezing or worse, wet, snowy, blech. My heat pump failed on Saturday for as yet unknown reasons and so the system started using the backup heating element. My electricity supplier provides hour by hour usage data and it is scary to see the jump when the heat pump stopped. Normally we use about 70kWh/day (heating, lighting, water, cooking, many computers etc) at this part of the year. It jumped to over 120... so yeah, heatpumps are very effective even at freezing temperatures.

    1126:

    My heat pump failed on Saturday for as yet unknown reasons and so the system started using the backup heating element.

    Speaking from experience you might consider buying a few of those oil filled electric "water radiator looking" portable heaters. And put them in the bedrooms and maybe other rooms with doors that close. Then let the HVAC heat drop to 60F or less in the rest of the house. Especially at night. Most times you'll save on your electric bill. Especially if you can't get it fixed for a few days (or weeks) due to the holidays and supply chains.

    I ran into something like this when my wife and her sisters were arguing about what to do with "mom's" house. As the only relative within 1 time zone and 1/2 days drive I was visiting monthly to maintain. I had installed a (new thing back then) Nest (before it was Nest) thermostat. A few days after Christmas I checked in after too long a break and the temperature inside was a bit below 50F. Looked a bit deeper and the system had been running 24/7 for a week. Crap. Drove up 2 days later and outside compressor would not run and emergency element was not on. The system was 15 or so years old so no big surprise. Inside temp down to 45F. Crap. Crap. So I fiddled and determined the emergency trip on the emergency element was broken. And the part hard to get in a hurry. So I bypassed the emergency cutoff to get the place up to a decent temp then made arrangements to meet up with HVAC guys a week later. I wasn't worried as the weather was set to warm up for the next few weeks. I got some of said room heaters, set them to their lowest settings, and used that setup till we got to March.

    The good part of all of this was it got the sisters off their duff and we sold the place by May. (Not my preference but better than doing nothing.)

    1127:

    The availability of procedures and Repeat/Until made BBC BASIC much easier than ZX81 BASIC. I wrote a planetarium program in ZX-81 basic which was riddled with GOTOs. With the BBC micro there were no GOTOs and it was much easier and more comprehensible. I sold the program to Electron User magazine and the editor had no problem making the changes necessary for Acorn Electron -a cut down version of the BBC micro.

    1128:

    1119 - Well, TBH, back when I had to write BASIC and COBOL, I did use GOTO - RETURN structures, but pretty much only to force monolithic languages to allow me to program sub-programs.

    1122 - I feel your pain. You can inflict similar on Ada coders, but usually only by deliberately masking the real exception similarly to this:-

    My_Sub ( parameters ) is

    local variable declarations ;

    -- Code ;

    exception :

    when others => raise EX_FATAL_ERROR ;

    end My_Sub ;

    So you now have to modify My_Sub (and associated design documents) to overcome the mask on the actual exception which is defined by the standard, including the circumstances in which it is raised, in order to find out what is wrong, before you can even start a fix.

    1125 - I can neither attack nor defend Smalltalk since I've never even been exposed to a relevant course or project. I will not attempt to defend C, since that's classic defending the indefensible to a programmer who normally works in Ada or Pascal.

    1129:

    It could have been worse; I might have found constant integer C4 = 5;

    There's a guy on slashdot who's .sig is:

    const int one = 65536; (Silvermoon, Texture.cs)

    It's not a joke!

    https://searchcode.com/codesearch/view/9614781/

    1130:

    const int one = 65536; (Silvermoon, Texture.cs)

    That assumes the const int is an unsigned 16-bit integer. It may be valid in some compiler instances which permit const declarations to exceed the maximum numerical range of the type, it may not be true in other compilers which would throw up errors when the range is exceeded or indeed in newer versions of the same compiler.

    1131:

    const int one = 65536; (Silvermoon, Texture.cs)

    To me (taking a peek at the code itself) this looks like using fixed-point arithmetic, with 16 bits for the fractional part of the number. In this system, using the language-provided 'int' type as the basis, the number "1" is indeed represented by "65536" in the integer space. This makes it faster than using floating point arithmetic and allows for fractional numbers.

    Was that clear enough? It's a system where you divide by 65536 = 2^16 to get the "proper" numbers.

    1132:

    I might have found constant integer C4 = 5;

    Which assumes that why there is a literal 5 is obvious from context or explicitly documented in the relevant design documents. At least I hope it's not an unexplained "magic" number!

    1133:

    The origin of the anti-GOTO dogma (which was partially justified, back then) was in the Algol/Fortran wars. The latter did not have conditional statements until Fortran 77, and GOTOs were used excessively.

    Once you have conditionals, by far the most common is to break out of multiple levels of nested loop. Modern Fortran supports that, but few other languages do, and you need revolting kludges (like GOTO, exceptions or gratuitous flags) to emulate it.

    The two remaining uses of GOTO are very rare, and one is better handled with exceptions in languages that have them. The remaining one is coding some forms of finite-state machine; that can be done in many ways, but GOTOs are often the clearest. But I must stress the 'very rare' - few people will ever encounter such a requirement.

    While BASIC is fairly old, it was not used for any serious programming until very late, and doing so was definitely a retrogressive step. I will except the BBC Micro, as that was designed and sold as a teaching machine for people unfamiliar with programming, and its BASIC was much more advanced!

    1134:

    It had better NOT be run on a system with 16-bit integers, then!

    1135:

    Ah for the good old days. When men were men (obnoxious mostly), memory was measured in K if you were lucky, variables passed by reference, and compilers did what you asked no matter how dumb.

    So you pass a constant to a subroutine, say the number "1". The memory conscious coder of the routine would then reuse the variable as a loop counter or whatever and then when the sub returned the constant "1" no longer had the value of "1".

    Then there was the time I was farmed out for a couple of months in 79 and started writing code the first afternoon. (Which surprised them, which then surprised me.) My mate and I wrote up a bunch of code then tried to run it the next day. Utter total system crashing. Then we found out the guy writing the replacement bits of the OS (we never did find out why this was considered a good idea) wasn't saving the register state. He thought that should be the application programmer's job. (($##$&*)) So to keep moving we got his source, implemented the register save (as a temp) thing then ran our code on top of the custom custom OS build we made. And our code worked. At the end of day two we were asked if they minded if our register saving code could be implemented into production.

    This was a well known at the time X-Ray company working on their first CAT scanner. Management thought of it as a hardware project with a bit of software on the side. They left the X-Ray business in a few years.

    1136:

    While BASIC is fairly old, it was not used for any serious programming until very late,

    Not completely. But close enough for government work.

    1137:

    The R States seem to parallel Russia

    In so very very many ways…

    1138:

    Pretty alarming how high COVID pushed mortality rates.

    Somewhere I saw a graph of American Covid deaths; one of those bar graphs using stacked objects as bars, with the object being a burning World Trade Centre.

    They're up to over 260 9/11s so far, and counting. Not a bad casualty count for a hoax.

    Under Trump it was over 150 9/11s, with 63 of them being preventable if the presidency* hadn't interfered with government responses.

    *And Republican wingnuts, who probably wouldn't be nearly as influential if they'd had a different president.

    1139:

    In the UK, it's 130,000 excess deaths, and it's still increasing; it may well approach 150,000 by the end of February. The effect on the age at death is noticeable, too.

    1140:

    Zoom security question:

    How secure is the iOS Zoom app when running on iOS 12.5.6? I've heard about security flaws, and I've heard they're patched, and I've heard otherwise…

    I'm looking at needing to use Zoom to attend a couple of meetings in early January, when I might be on the road, and I'd like to avoid bringing my old iPad if I can. So I was thinking of putting it on my iPhone 6s (which is the newest iOS device I have), but don't want to create a security hole on my phone. I'm not worried about controlling the meeting access as someone else is setting it up and that's their problem.

    I am worried about data being copied off my phone, like to Facebook, but my main concern is creating a security hole on the phone that even deleting the app (which I plan to do after the meetings) won't fix.

    1141:

    "Deep nesting" - in your code, perhaps, or that you work with. I never went deep.

    But then, I'm a believer that you do not need recursion for everything, and iteration is less expensive in many cases.

    1142:

    Not for those of us in M$ basica.

    1143:

    As Alexandrescu said, fast code is communist code - it leans to the left ;)

    That's the real value of 80 column strict ;)

    1144:

    The oil-filler radiators are wonderful. I've used them, and have one that's something like 20 yrs old sitting behind the laundry basked (unplugged), and it's still good. And they're safe, unlike the space heaters with the glowing elements.

    1145:

    Should we assume you never had to do maintenance on code, thousands of lines long, filled with a spaghetti code of goto's? I have.

    But wait, there's worse: the COBOL ALTER statement.

    1146:

    I think you'll be fine. The biggest thing they had was not being up front about their policies back 2 years ago. They quickly figured out the way to becoming and staying billionaires was to fix things fast.

    Lots of big firms with security teams who check out such things use Zoom.

    I run a weekly meeting using Zoom. And we'd drop it in a minute if we thought there were any issues.

    Your biggest security issue is using an older iOS or macOS software. Zoom puts out regular updates. Like almost weekly.

    The only thing I do with Zoom security wise is to not allow it full disk access on my system. And when I share something I share a window, not the entire system.

    1147:

    Agreed. If you are going to get an electric heater that you don't have to baby sit, get one of those.

    1148:

    Don't pretend to be an idiot - you aren't one. Yes, of course, I have, and not just a few thousand lines long - some was hundreds of thousands. But, back in the 1960s, there was little option but to use Fortran (II, IV or 66) if you were writing a portable non-financial program, and you couldn't avoid using GOTO excessively BECAUSE THERE WERE NO CONDITIONALS. That's why so many packages of that era chose it and put up with the downsides (of which that was not the worst).

    Where the program was competently written, it wasn't wholly spaghettified, but there was plenty that was written by complete idiots.

    1149:

    1133 - While BASIC is fairly old, it was not used for any serious programming until very late, and doing so was definitely a retrogressive step.
    Clue in "Beginner's first All-purpose Symbolic Instruction Code" I'd have thought.

    1139 - The English Broadcasting Corporation are reporting that the majority of Omicron patients being hospitalised are the unvaccinated.

    1145 - " the COBOL ALTER statement"
    I don't know that one. I guess I don't want to?

    1150:

    1145 - " the COBOL ALTER statement" I don't know that one. I guess I don't want to?

    Without looking it up, it gives me flashbacks to those board games that let players alter the rules and the horror of trying to play them while drunk.

    1151:

    Paul at 828

    You might try an old book (thirty years plus) called "The Phenomenon of Money" by an anthropologist called Thomas Crump.

    The first third of Debt seems to me excellent, but it isn't much different to stuff I learnt from reading this man Crump, but after that he starts oversimplifying grossly, with 'everyday communism', or whatever phrase he used, instead of the kind of subtle understanding of entitlement systems (rights and duties and all that) which you can find in the anthropological literature.

    And I am Chris Blanchard Again because I haven't posted here for a long time and my account got disabled, which is fine.

    1152:

    Trust me, none of you want to know. I was at work when I found it in a manual. I went to my boss - and this was the Scummy Mortgage Co, even, and said "so, would you fire someone or defenestrate them if they used the ALTER statement?"

    I think he said "both".

    It alters the target of a goto somewhere further down in the code.

    1153:

    Or, as some of us immediately flash on, Calvinball (from Calvin and Hobbes).

    1155:

    Re: 'Republican wingnuts, who probably wouldn't be nearly as influential if they'd had a different president.'

    I recently read that Doug Ericksen GOP Sen (WA), major DT insider, age 52, died a few days ago: he had Covid about a month earlier. Will be interesting to see who the WA Governor (DEM) selects as his replacement.

    However - seems that McConnell is wooing Manchin.

    1156:

    I think I was making this recommendation too, and it was with a specific goal in mind. A lot of us fall into a trap of using things we "know" from our cultural background and experience as a null hypothesis, and speculate as though they were unproblematic truths. That's a subset of pre-theoretical naïveté, and even people who are highly educated in one discipline sometimes (or even often!) do it when talking about things where other disciplines have treated the topic, while this background knowledge hasn't permeated their own discipline. Sometimes one is even unaware that a particular thing might be thingish enough to have been a focus of research and prior art at all. It's usually no slight on someone when they proceed this way, but it's an obligation for others who've at least glimpsed some of the current state understanding of the topic to help point them in the right direction. That's what happened when you were speculating about barter, many threads ago now. Whatever Graeber's overall thesis is, he makes a strong case against certain received wisdoms on that topic and now that you've read it you are aware of the argument and some of the evidence. And that means whether you trust his conclusions or not, you're already a better contributor here.

    Which reminds me that I probably need to read more things I might not agree with too, sigh. In the new year.

    1157:

    1150 & 1152 - AGGHHHH!! That sounds sort of like Fluxx on acid, and I rather like Fluxx, even with the New Rule card that says something like "all New Rules that mention numbers now become one greater" eg New Rule "draw 2" now becomes "Draw 3" with immediate effect, and yes that does mean that the player who just played the second New Rule there has to draw another card.

    1158:

    See also Nomic
    An example Nomic:
    Mornington Nomic is a Nomic game, inspired by the ever-popular Mornington Crescent strategy game, combining the style and wit of the latter with the creative flux of the former.
    In a Nomic game, players continually suggest alterations to the initial ruleset; the addition of new rules, or the amendment (or even removal) of existing ones. The rest of the players then discuss and vote on these proposals - if enough are in favour, the suggestions are implemented immediately.

    If the rules constrain you unreasonably, consider working out how to edit the rules. :-)

    And Charlie once linked MalbolgeLISP "MalbolgeLisp is a LISP interpreter written in Malbolge." (It is the stuff of madness.)

    1159:

    EC @ 1148
    Yes, exactly - nowhere near as experienced or practiced as you, but that was the way it was, then.

    #1139 & 1149
    ...reporting that the majority of Omicron patients being hospitalised are the unvaccinated. - exactly ...

    SFR
    "WA = Washington state? Far NW of USA?

    Bill Arnold
    Malboge
    As in Dante, the Maleboges - the trenches in Hell, where the damned are imprisoned, yes?

    1160:

    Indeed. From the Malbolge language specification(1998):
    "Malbolge" is the name of Dante's Eighth Circle of Hell, in which practitioners of deception (seducers, flatterers, simonists, thieves, hypocrites, and so on) spend eternity.

    1161:

    No. I looked up COBOL's Alter keyword. It's now deprecated, and was used back in the day when it took a program days to compile and you might want to change the program's behavior without having to spend multiple days recompiling it. It's probably been a non-issue for decades, unlike GOTO which can probably still be abused.

    1162:

    I recently read that Doug Ericksen GOP Sen (WA), major DT insider, age 52, died a few days ago: he had Covid about a month earlier. Will be interesting to see who the WA Governor (DEM) selects as his replacement.

    He was a STATE Senator. IE he was in the state level legislature, not the US Senate in Washington DC.

    Yes Greg that place that borders both the Pacific Ocean and Canada.

    And yes we folks in the USA can get confused when news stories and headlines are not clear with the distinction.

    1163:

    I dutifully looked up The Phenomenon of Money. It's Routledge and hence phenominally expensive at £39 for paperback, so it will have to remain unread by me. Pity.

    1164:

    I dutifully looked up The Phenomenon of Money. It's Routledge and hence phenominally expensive at £39 for paperback, so it will have to remain unread by me. Pity.

    You might find it more satisfying to search alibris.co.uk for "Phenomenon of Money": https://www.alibris.co.uk/The-Phenomenon-of-Money-Thomas-Crump/book/5097629?qsort=p&matches=13

    Interesting that BigMuddy doesn't carry any of the used copies, since AFAIK they also own alibris.

    1165:

    Re: 'He was a STATE Senator.'

    Arrggh! You're right - thanks! Wishful thinking on my part about maybe some chance of one more DEM in DC.

    US Gov't stats report below - spacing added for faster reading.

    I wonder how the GOP is going to twist this. Also would like to see how this compares with other countries.

    https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/products/databriefs/db427.htm#section_3

    'Summary

    In 2020, a total of 3,383,729 resident deaths were registered in the United States—528,891 more deaths than in 2019.

    The number of deaths for which COVID-19 was the underlying cause of death was 350,831 (10.4% of the total number of deaths in 2020).

    From 2019 to 2020, the age-adjusted death rate for the total population increased 16.8%.

    This single-year increase is the largest since the first year that annual mortality data for the entire United States became available (2).

    The decrease in life expectancy for the total population of 1.8 years from 2019 to 2020 is the largest single-year decrease in more than 75 years (3).

    Age-specific death rates from 2019 to 2020 increased for each age group 15 years and over.

    Age-adjusted death rates increased in 2020 from 2019 for each race and ethnicity group for both males and females.'

    In a nutshell - COVID-19 is worse than the Spanish Flu.

    1166:

    I wonder how the GOP is going to twist this.

    They will just ignore it. At the top. Mostly. There are a few, and their numbers seem to be growing, with more and more latching onto the fraud and hoax aspects. But the Trumpist base is hard core in on it.

    My brother, his clan, and friends have stated the following over the last 18 months:

    • Hospitals are writing Covid on death certificates so the feds will pay them extra money.

    • It is all a hoax

    • There are empty hospital ICU beds which proves it isn't real. (Staffing anyone?)

    • The CDC is lying and making up the numbers to hurt DT

    • People are dying of the flu/pneumonia not Covid. Don't even mention that pneumonia is a broad label on many things that cause liquids to build up in your lungs till you can't get enough O2. See the next point.

    • "Why are you making hurtful comments?" when you point out flaws in their "facts".

    • It is a made up thing to hurt Trump

    And the big one

    • Trump really won but there was/is a conspiracy of the D's and Rino R's which falsified the election results to elect Biden

    • Biden is suffering serious dementia and his staff is faking it for him.

    Oh, yeah, Jan 06 was done by anti-Trumpers. Mostly ANTIFA and BLM folks dressed up to look like MAGA supporters.

    These people are more and more into QANON and facts mean nothing because to them your facts are all invented.

    1167:

    And to be a bit more scary there's a story in the Washington Post: "The global far right is here to stay" by Ishaan Tharoor.

    His premise is this is happening world wide. The not so far right is being pushed out of political power. Many of them are repulsed by the far right but can't bring themselves to vote for the left either. And are basically becoming irrelevant in politics around the world. Ronald Reagan and Margaret Thatcher would be ignored these days. (The article has links to many other articles from other sources.)

    I see this in the US and in the UK from what I read here at CS land. Plus stories from around the world.

    For the first time in a long time I'm not looking brightly into my and now my children's future.

    I didn't provide a link as I think Charlie doesn't want wapo links here.

    1168:

    David L
    Looks more & more like "The International Jewish Conspiracy" of 90 years ago, doesn't it?
    Really nasty - & as you note - The not so far right is being pushed out of political power.

    1169:

    1161 - I'd suggest that this is where modular programming techniques apply, even with monolithic languages.

    1164 - "BigMuddy" - I'm not aware of a company using a name like Mississippi.com!

    1167 - OTOH there are seats like the one I live in, where a very marginal (think under 100 majority) became an apparently safeish Liebour seat due to a relative mass of Cons switching their votes to Liebour.

    1170:

    I'm not sure GOTO is necessarily the most evil programming language construct. Some others were attempts to work round hardware limitations, e.g. overlaying data definitions to reuse memory in different phases of a program, but others... ... I give you Nixdorf Basic (IIRC) from the 1970s. Every line numbered (of course), variable names limited to 2 characters, ungenerous limits on source code size that included comment text, and (best of all) a RETURN n statement where the numeric value n determined which line was executed next relative to the calling (CALL/GOSUB) line - n could be +ve or -ve and, needless to say, there was no automatic correction if lines were subsequently added/removed.

    1171:

    It's not, but the remarks about GOTO spaghetti were fully justified back in the days of Fortran II/IV/66 - it required competence and self-discipline not to end up with that mess. But, from about 1980 onwards, that disappeared as a way of obfuscating code in favour of more modern methods. There are plenty of them still in use today.

    There WERE a few people who attempted to show that you could write BASIC in any language, but thankfully not many.

    1172:

    Not entirely certain either way about BASIC, but you can certainly write Fortran 4 in Ada and in Pascal. I've seen it, and even tried to fix it.

    1173:

    I've seen it. It was NOT pretty. I asked what programming experience, advised forgetting that entirely, and learning again from scratch.

    1174:

    Thanks. I feel a bit better about using it now. (Still not enamoured about the trip, but that's a separate matter.)

    1175:

    Yeah, I got a pile of spaghetti Fortran from the Naval Postgraduate Institute in 1977. At the time, it was the fastest code in the world for solving linear network flow optimization problems. After benchmarking it on a set of test problems, I spent two weeks untangling the GOTOs -- many of which were used to implement an alternate arrangement to simply making subroutine calls. About 10% of the lines of code simply went away, and with it straightened out enough for the compiler optimization pass to be able to do things, it ran the test set in about 40% less time. So for a few months, I had the world's fastest code for that particular problem domain by a substantial margin.

    1176:

    However - seems that McConnell is wooing Manchin.

    Well, not that I think a lot about McConnell but the only reason he is wooing Manchin is because part of the Democratic Party is trying to force him out, thus creating the opening for McConnell.

    Which, while on the face of it would seem stupid (because they would potentially give up control of the Senate if he did go Republican, though he has stated in the past he would sit as an Independent) it might make sense from a strategic point of view for the coming elections in 2022 and 2024 - easier to sell the reason for a lack of legislation on not controlling the Senate than because the party is split on the issues.

    1177:

    And to be a bit more scary there's a story in the Washington Post: "The global far right is here to stay" by Ishaan Tharoor.

    His premise is this is happening world wide. The not so far right is being pushed out of political power. Many of them are repulsed by the far right but can't bring themselves to vote for the left either. And are basically becoming irrelevant in politics around the world.

    This really shouldn't be a surprise to anyone paying attention to things beyond Trump losing.

    None of the underlying societal issues that Trump and others have taken advantage of have been dealt with, and there is no indication of any serious attempt by the non-far-right parties to do so.

    1178:

    Mancin is definitely in trouble. On one hand, he can't become a Republican and successfully run for office. He's not crazy enough to win a Republican primary. On the other hand, he voted against the "Build Back Better" bill because (among other reasons) the bill would give a small tax credit to people with below-average incomes, and he was expressed concern that such people would spend the money on drugs. So don't expect any Democrats to do much for him, and do expect him to be primaried.

    He's heavily tied to gas and coal. In fact, he owns a coal brokerage, and will probably never vote for anything that restricts the ability of West Virginians to mine, sell, and burn coal.

    His daughter, Heather Bresch, has been heavily involved in price inflation for Epipens. (A google search for "Epipen prices" will be very revealing.)

    In short, he's a dinosaur, and I don't think I can describe how badly I dislike his behavior.

    1179:

    Ah. I heard of that one. Part of the reason for avoiding subroutine calls is that they were often very expensive with 1960s compilers, because those generated gruesome code for them. On some systems, DSQRT was much faster than a call to a null subroutine, and sometimes even DSIN was.

    1180:

    Troutwaxer
    Let's get this straight ... Mancin is against slightly more money to poor people ... "Because they might spend it on drugs" ...
    A supposedly "Democrat" Senator is against giving more money to poor people ...
    And - W Virginia is one of the poorer states, yes?

    1181:

    "None of the underlying societal issues that Trump and others have taken advantage of have been dealt with, and there is no indication of any serious attempt by the non-far-right parties to do so."

    That's true in the UK, too, and is one of the reasons I can't stand Blairism (a.k.a. New Labour).

    1182:

    Yes. Manchin comes fairly close to being an old-style Southern Democrat. West Virginia is a very conservative state, and many there will doubtless be swayed by such arguments. Drugs are bad, Mm'kay, and allowing poor people to have more money is communism, and what if some of those poor people are Black? If Black people are going to get money, it's probably best that nobody gets money.

    What you have to remember is that in the U.S. both the Republicans and the Democrats are in the business of selling a very toxic version of Capitalism. The toxicity level of Democratic Capitalism might be compared to as heavy smoking habit, while the toxicity of Republican Capitalism might be compared to a heavy smoking habit plus a lifetime of work in an asbestos plant. In short, both versions of American capitalism suck, but one sucks just-enough less that it is worth voting for.

    The other major issue is the social agenda, of course, with Democrats preferring a very Liberal version of society, and Republicans preferring a very conservative version of society (for everyone but White Males, who of course can do what they want.)

    The willingness of Republicans to make changes to our system which are essentially totalitarian is fairly new, however, and goes straight to the issue of Democratic weakness in prosecuting crimes of corruption when they are in power. This may be changing.

    1183:

    Manchin's very special, at least in my ignorant opinion. What I know about him I've gotten from the media, so I'll welcome someone closer to the action straightening me out.

    Anyway, he's wealthy, and he and his family made their money in the coal business. Normally that would make him a bleach-gargling Republican, but here's where the specialness comes in.

    Manchin's major political supporters are the coal miners. UNIONIZED coal miners, who are very definitely democratic. So, by strange bedfellows, he's a Democrat.

    This makes for a bit of a problem. The West Virginia coal mining union has pretty clearly decided (at least from what their spokes-critters say to the national press), that their power lies in mining coal, not in heroically shutting down the mines and retraining their workers to build wind turbines and rehabilitate aquifers, or anything life-affirming. So they've made common cause with their bosses, Manchin among them. So here we are.

    Now personally, I'd be thrilled if Manchin abandoned politics. But I suspect that, if he did, the West Virginia Governor would appoint a Republican senator to replace him, and it would be even worse.

    While I'm officially pro-union, my personal opinion of them is rather more nuanced, as the Manchin case is far from the only one where the unions are in lickspitle thrall to the bosses. I'll let others bring in the IWW comment on this.

    1184:

    OOC - how much technical background/expertise in avionics did you/your coding team have before writing this?

    For the 5KLOC avionics project, the overall lab had been doing avionics software for the better part of a decade, with one major (and very successful) project just completed. However, the changes involved a move from VLIW assembler to C; from locally-designed CPUs to SPARCs; from SIMD to MIMD; and from AQAP1/3 to DOD-STD-2168. There was me in my first team lead role, and a new graduate (at the start); along the way there were a couple of software apprentices, two guys who had transferred from COBOL programming in Marconi, and an attached German engineer, none particularly experienced... but if you can't train up your own team, can you call yourself a team leader?

    For the 3KLOC library that didn't change for several years? That was in another industry, using C++ (by then, twenty years of C/C++ and five years domain experience), and the design/code team was just me.

    1185:

    "Why are you making hurtful comments?" when you point out flaws in their "facts".

    It is a made up thing to hurt Trump

    I find it ironic that people who glorify in hurting others ("owning the libs") who support a person who acts like a grade school bully who used his power to hurt others, are such special snowflakes that saying anything they don't like hurts their fee-fees and you're a cruel person who must show human consideration and stop.

    Not to cast aspersions on your relatives, of course.

    1186:

    That's the real value of 80 column strict ;)

    What really annoys me are the engineers who appear to think that you achieve 80 columns by reducing the length of all your variable and function names to the absolute minimum, normally using homebrew / cryptic abbreviations (at best).

    Why yes, pointers named 'p', iterators 'i' and 'j', and strings called 's'; all combine to make life so much crappier... we're past FORTRAN, so YOU CAN CHOOSE MEANINGFUL NAMES!

    1187:

    I am currently using one library that only communicates errors as exceptions.

    If you're consistent in using exceptions, it can lead to really clean code. After all, you don't have to check anything for correctness - because if there had been any problems, an exception would have been thrown, and you'd be sitting in the catch block of the API call with a meaningful message from the offending object.

    That "3KLOC, no known bugs" example I mentioned, did things just that way. It surprised me that consistent use of exceptions, was quite so efficient and understandable - but you had to be consistent.

    However, a lot of our code was written in the style of "returns an error code in case of error", and we found that mixing the two approaches didn't really work (not least because of engineers refusing to believe that exceptions could work well), and it was far better to stay consistent. Mutter.

    IMHO, things work if you start from the ground up, with properly-designed objects, and a consistent error-handling policy throughout. Otherwise, it turns into a nightmare :(

    1188:

    I find it ironic that people who

    Ahem.

    Trumpism (and the modern right wing in general) can be understood quite simply if you take on board two axioms:

  • The cruelty isn't a side-effect, it's the entire point: they want to see people not like them suffer (and don't care if they hurts themselves in the process, e.g. blocking public single-payer healthcare hurts the non-whites even though it hurts the poor white folks at the same time)

  • Whenever they accuse their opponents of something bad, they're employing a mix of projection and DARVO. ("Crisis actors"? Think in terms of Trump hiring actors to bulk up the crowds at his rallies -- which happened. The loudest homophobic denunciations come from Republican politicians who are later caught in bed with a rent boy. And so on.)

  • They are grade-school bullies, it's what they're here for, and they want to hurt their victims and then blame them ("stop hitting yourself!"). Meanwhile the cynical grifters indulge them and make bank.

    1189:

    Troutwaxer @ 1178:

    Mancin is definitely in trouble.

    Maybe, but doubtful.

    So don't expect any Democrats to do much for him, and do expect him to be primaried.

    They have already sort of tried, when Bernie's staff helped out a competitor in the 2018 primary. Manchin won the primary with 70% of the vote.

    (and this reflects a general trend - the progressive Democrats attempt to primary more centrist candidates and lose)

    That person who attempted to primary Manchin then also ran in 2020, took the Democrat nomination, and proceeded to be thrashed by the Republican candidate 70% to 30%.

    Without Manchin his seat goes Republican.

    In short, he's a dinosaur, and I don't think I can describe how badly I dislike his behavior.

    Fair enough, but as the only Democrat holding state wide office in West Virginia currently he obviously is doing well enough representing what his voters want to remain in office.

    Heteromeles @ 1183:

    Manchin's very special, at least in my ignorant opinion. What I know about him I've gotten from the media, so I'll welcome someone closer to the action straightening me out.

    Similar, in part because he is currently the saviour of a major part of the Canadian economy (auto makers) at the moment.

    Manchin's major political supporters are the coal miners. UNIONIZED coal miners, who are very definitely democratic. So, by strange bedfellows, he's a Democrat.

    Maybe.

    This makes for a bit of a problem. The West Virginia coal mining union has pretty clearly decided (at least from what their spokes-critters say to the national press), that their power lies in mining coal, not in heroically shutting down the mines and retraining their workers to build wind turbines and rehabilitate aquifers, or anything life-affirming.

    Not true. The coal miner union wants Manchin to support BBB precisely because of the retraining.

    https://www.cnn.com/2021/12/21/business/coal-miners-joe-manchin/index.html

    Now personally, I'd be thrilled if Manchin abandoned politics. But I suspect that, if he did, the West Virginia Governor would appoint a Republican senator to replace him, and it would be even worse.

    Manchin is in office until 2024, he has already indicated that if the Democrats want him out he is willing to sit as an independent.

    But note that FiveThirtyEight reports that as of this month Manchin has voted with Biden 97.4% of the time - he generally is a reliable vote for the Democrats unless the legislation is something the voters of West Virginia would oppose.

    The problem for the Democrats is there are multiple things that Manchin can't support in BBB (despite the Democrat media spin that it is all about the tax credit).

    For example, a Democrat from Michigan got a provision added to the EV tax credit that it would only apply if the vehicle is union built - Manchin can't support that given Toyota is a major employer in West Virginia.

    https://www.autonews.com/manufacturing/sen-joe-manchin-speaking-toyota-event-west-virginia-calls-union-built-ev-tax-credit

    1190:

    I was thinking more the “not knowing the rules of American football.” Many decades ago (I forget how many,) on a winter Sunday when the entire nation was glued to their TV sets I was in a dorm lounge with a big TV. But ours was wasn’t tuned to the Super Bowl, it was tuned to a live feed from JPL of pictures coming in of I forget which gas giant.

    1191:

    i and j don't bother me as "outer and inner loop counter" are pretty much idiomatic by now, but I agree. Sensible names all the way.

    I do remember getting a bollocking once after starting a new job because I didn't know that one of our target compilers had a particularly short maximum identifier length and people were keeping things terse for a reason. That hasn't been a real problem for nearly 20 years though.

    1192:

    1179 - Another one, with dialects like Commodore BASIC that actually did support a GOSUB - RETURN construct, was that the code ran faster if you started with a GOTO to pass over the subroutines to the main loop, because it parsed from line let's call it 10 down til it found the subroutine, every time you called the sub.

    1180 - There's more; IIRC West Virginia is one of the 5 poorest states.

    1186 - I'm not a fan of "80 column strict" as such, but I am a fan of "one screen preferred", where you wrap long statements over multiple lines so you can see column 1 and the RHS of most or all lines. This may mean that a single statement gets split over 2 or 3 lines of text. I will still use single letter variable names, but they tend to be loop counters, or SI constants, for example:- c : constant Long_Float := 186_000.0 ; -- Speed of light in miles per second.

    1187 - Agreed. The most trouble I've had with bugs in Ada was caused by an outside developer who caught the pre-defined Ada exceptions and overwrote them with a single developer defined exception, so you couldn't tell what the bug actually was!

    1190 - Works for me.

    1193:

    Re: 'But ours was wasn’t tuned to the Super Bowl, it was tuned to a live feed from JPL of pictures coming in of I forget which gas giant.'

    I'm hoping to watch the Webb Space Telescope launch tomorrow. They had to shift the launch because of space weather.

    https://www.nasa.gov/feature/goddard/2021/ahead-of-webb-launch-nasa-is-watching-the-weather-in-space

    As of three days ago ...

    'The new targeted launch date is Dec. 25, as early as possible within the following launch window:

    Between 7:20 a.m. and 7:52 a.m. Washington Between 9:20 a.m. and 9:52 a.m. Kourou Between 12:20 p.m. and 12:52 p.m. Universal (UTC) Between 1:20 p.m. and 1:52 p.m. Paris Between 9:20 p.m. and 9:52 p.m. Tokyo'

    1194:

    Re: '... but if you can't train up your own team, can you call yourself a team leader?'

    Sounds like classic fly-by-the-seat-of-your-pants - lots of opportunity for learning across team members interspersed with interesting potential/actual oopsies. Better suited for a younger rather than older manager. :)

    Also sounds like you quite enjoyed the experience.

    1195:

    Re: James Webb Space Telescope launch

    Here's the live stream with countdown clock showing time to lift-off. Right now it's background info, interviews, etc. --- about 300 viewers already signed on.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EqMBCz3WKXU&ab_channel=CosmoSapiens

    1196:

    "Why yes, pointers named 'p', iterators 'i' and 'j', and strings called 's'; all combine to make life so much crappier... we're past FORTRAN, so YOU CAN CHOOSE MEANINGFUL NAMES!"

    Haha, I do that. Not to try and keep under 80 characters - that's fine for human text, but too restrictive for code now the option of going wider is commonplace - but simply to save typing.

    (Not just saving typing as in sheer number of characters; that for sure, but also as in not having to dance up and down on the fucking shift key, which probably counts as about five ordinary characters. Why the fuck couldn't computer keyboards have followed the model of the layout of the PET keyboard, where all the squirrely twiddly characters were keys in their own right that you didn't need to shift for... and the PC layout with so many of the most common ones concentrated next to the right shift key, and the left shift key being titchy, is particularly awful.)

    There's a good chance that there can't really be a meaningfully meaningful name for something anyway. Especially for things like loop counters, or variables that you need to remember a result that you want two lines later and then never need again. Indeed, with some loop counters, one letter is the most meaningful and intuitive name in any case - if you have three nested loops to iterate over a Cartesian volume, how could you not call the counters x, y and z? And the same for other things of the kind you learnt about using standard single-letter variables in maths lessons at school before you even knew what a program was.

    Other, wider, aspects of programming style also make a difference. Say you have char *frobnicate_string(char *str) which is maybe 10 or 15 lines long. You probably need a comment block immediately above it to explain what it means to frobnicate a string and why a string might need it done. Having got that plain-language explanation, it does not, usually, really help to try and give the variables names like start_of_arbitrary_length_whitespace_sequence to try and tie them into it. You know broadly what's going on from the comment, and in going from "broad" to "fine" the operators are more significant than the variables, so it's easier to understand it if it's reasonably compact and easy to scan around it with your eyes to see how it all relates to itself without having to keep jumping half way across the page because long variable names have shoved everything over. (Compare mathematical notations whose compactness is, apart from saving writing, a lot to do with the same aim of communicating the logical relations between things without flooding you with guff about what the things are called.)

    I think long variable names are most useful for things that have large significance but don't crop up all that often as explicit references by their own names, so you need reminding what they are when they do crop up. This of course does not happen within a single scope that all fits on the screen at the same time, and in that case the clarity is improved by the reduction of clutter.

    (I get a very direct personal demonstration of this when I'm writing code to unfuck fucked websites. Eventually I got sufficiently fed up with the incredibly verbose and lengthy names the browser uses for common javascript functions that I wrote a set of wrappers to call them something shorter. So now I have unfuckers that I originally wrote before I made the wrappers that have needed alteration after I wrote them to keep up with the website fucking itself differently, which gives me examples of "before" and "after" code to do similar kinds of things side by side. It is much easier to see what's going on in the code that uses things like doc.getn() than it is to follow the same kind of operations in the older code that has to have document.getElementsByTagName() all over the place and drowns the logic in guff.)

    Re error handling with exceptions: I agree that clean code where you can comfortably rely on errors having been made harmless so you can just get on with things does make life a fuck of a lot easier, but I don't consider the use of exceptions to be a necessary condition. (After all, I default to using C if I have a free choice.) The important bit is your second aspect - consistency. As long as you set a sensible convention for what to do about errors and stick to it rigidly, you can get that comfort no matter what the convention actually is, as long as it is sensible. (And we have examples further up this thread of languages with shitty exception handling and other people's libraries doing bloody weird things as producing situations where you can't have a convention based on exceptions which is consistent and sensible...)

    1197:

    "DARVO"

    Funny that there's a wikipedia acronym for that rather than just a long-established ordinary word, when the actual practice probably dates from the point when language became complex enough to make it possible at all.

    It does have to be said that it is unbelievably fucking annoying, especially the RVO bit. It acts as an excellent signifier that the person doing it is a complete and utter twat who is absolutely impervious to anything you can possibly say to them and is purely and simply determined to be a wanker, but it can be horribly difficult not to keep trying when they are expressing it as propagandistic encouragement to other people to accept their fucked-up twisted shit as the true version.

    1198:

    Ha, that reminds me of a story my parents have of going into town one day to buy some item of urgent need. They were amazed to find that the usual crowds of people were completely absent: the place was utterly deserted, in the kind of post-apocalyptic completeness that suggests aliens have come along and hoovered up the entire population or something. And all the shops they tried were shut or had nobody there, completely contrary to their normal opening hours. Eventually they found some obscure shop in a back street that wasn't entirely deserted, as in they could hear some kind of "noises off" that were indicative of human presence. After much banging and calling they finally managed to get someone to realise that there were customers needing attention, and a bloke emerged in a state of extreme disgruntlement at having been summoned. All the staff had been holed up in a back room with a portable telly, watching that bloody football match where England beat Germany 4-2 and idiots unborn at the time still go on about it as if they were fighting WW2.

    1199:

    The cruelty isn't a side-effect, it's the entire point: they want to see people not like them suffer (and don't care if they hurts themselves in the process, e.g. blocking public single-payer healthcare hurts the non-whites even though it hurts the poor white folks at the same time)

    This was driven home for me in an interview with a Republican voter about the Tennessee governor's race. The woman being interviewed said that she understood that the candidate she voted for was going to terminate her ability to get the medication she needed to live by ending Medicare expansion in the state, but she voted for him anyway because he was against the gays.

    1200:

    Commodore BASIC

    Pretty much my first computer language!

    Studied BASIC in elementary school, using punch-tape and a 300 baud acoustically-coupled modem to send programs to computer at the university. Never really got the paradigm. Took a compulsory half-class in FORTRAN in first-year engineering, but never used it again.

    Bought a Commodore 64 when they first came out ($1000 in 80s money), and did all my serious programming on that. Even wrote a database for a plumbing company* on it.

    *Salesman had told the plumber that a C64 could do his invoices, so he bought it, took it home, and typed in "do my invoice" and of course got "syntax error". being it was a small town (computer shop was in closest city) one of his friends put him onto my and I wrote him a database/invoicing program.

    It was an absolutely horrible program (I was just a student), because I had no idea what I was doing, but it was customized to his needs and cheaper than a commercial database.

    1201:

    1198 - "50 years of hurt; Ingurlund still neeping"!

    1200 - Mine too, whilst on an engineering course, on which we "had to do computers because they're the tool of the future".

    1202:

    If you're consistent in using exceptions, it can lead to really clean code

    The problem with C++ is that exceptions are fundamentally broken. It's probably easier to think of them as a form of SIGSEVF - your program will abruptly exit with few clues as to what went wrong. It's closer to "all errors result in exit()" with a magic number as the code. Having a library that communicates "I had a go at using the internet but it didn't work out" via exceptions, especially async exceptions, makes it really hard to debug. C++ decided that everyone should implement exceptions independently, including collecting stack traces (or not) and what other information should be included. As you would expect most C++ projects don't bother, they follow the system library pattern of only throwing strings. Normally static strings, making them almost as useful as setting errno and returning false.

    I've worked extensively with languages that do exceptions well (Delphi and Rust) and in both cases exceptions make it really clear not only that something went badly wrong, but where that happened and a bunch of related context. Both languages also use error codes for unexceptional cases, generally quite consistently.

    The difference between "open this file" -> "file not found" and -> "out of memory" is (hopefully) obvious to you, and the former should have code to deal with it in a polite manner. But the latter... that's throw your hands in the air time. It's... an exception!

    1203:

    YOU CAN CHOOSE MEANINGFUL NAMES!

    And you should. Especially these days when iterators are often chained or implicit so you don't need a pile of little iterator variables at all. They've become a code smell. Albeit sometimes the "lines can only be 80 chars" rule means more than two parameters means you have to wrap.

    resultt WurbleFinangler::GetNextWurble(const wurblefilter_t filter)

    That's 69 characters, with a single parameter.

    I still kind of treasure the access control library I built in one job that had a whole setup for managing users, groups, permissions etc. And because it had to be usable by a website had a function with a 100+ character name along the lines of invoke_super_override_mode_bypassing_all_restrictions_and_just_let_me_do_what_i_want()

    This was taken to management because I was "being difficult" but they discussed it and decided the name was appropriate. I got the impression their response was more like "you're right, that is stupid, you shouldn't need a function like that in the API at all". Not quite what the web cowboy was looking for...

    1204:

    I write code that acts like that (not code that is like that, because that would mean using C++) sometimes, usually when the operation of GetNextWurble is something a bit more complicated than just retrieving the next entry in an array, like "pull the next chunk of data out of the buffer or do something sensible if it isn't there yet". But if I'm doing something like
    for (i = 0; i < n; i++) a[i] <<= 1; then (I really don't see the point of calling the counter anything other than i, and) nor do I see that the "iterator" style is any clearer; if anything it's the opposite.

    It's also something I would avoid unless I could be confident that the compiler would understand what I was at and turn it into something equivalent to the plain for loop under the hood; and I think it's far more likely that it would instead decide that it couldn't actually tell at the point of compilation whether it was safe to do that, and just cough up all the standard iterator gubbins wrapped around the single shift instruction. On the other hand I would be confident that if I gave it a simple for loop, it would know fine what I was at, and be perfectly happy to unroll the loop and do it with SIMD instructions or whatever if that would help.

    Of course what I really want there is something in the language that expresses the same thing as writing down "matrix op scalar" on paper. I believe you can do that in Fortran (I have written precisely one program in Fortran, and I didn't enjoy the experience), but there is nothing of the kind in C...

    1205:

    Back to the original post:

    Parallel COVID-19 variant pandemics mentioned upthread, but this is a clear-minded long piece, including an interview with a publishing epidemiologist ("Deepti Gurdasani of the Queen Mary University of London").
    Is Omicron a New Wave or a Parallel Pandemic? Why the variant may not mean much for the course of the pandemic. (David Wallace-Wells, Dec. 23, 2021, NYMag)

    Haven't seen many indications in published science of how well Omicron infects various cell types vs other variants. There's this preprint, about lungs(/in vitro):
    SARS-CoV-2 Omicron spike mediated immune escape, infectivity and cell-cell fusion (December 22, 2021, BioRxiv (preprint))
    These in vitro data indicate that suboptimal Omicron S1/S2 cleavage reduces efficient infection of lower airway cells expressing TMPRSS2, but not TMPRSS2 negative cells such as those found in the upper airway. (In particular, people have to be wondering about how moch endothelial cell damage/dysfunction Omicron causes, indirectly or directly.)

    1206:

    Modern compilers have a tendency to emit all sorts of optimisations, not limited to loop unrolling and SIMD instructions etc. Then it gets fed into a CPU that takes further liberties.

    The advantage of collection classes, iterators and all the rest is that they save you having to think about bounds checking etc. Or more accurately, save you from the times when you don't think about those things.

    In theory the difference between, say strncpy(dest,src,size) and dest=src is negligible and mostly syntactic sugar. But in practice one of those is a notorious source of buffer overflow bugs and one isn't. And most calls to the former will do some kind of size checking verbiage before the call, while in the latter case that's all done by a machine that is less likely to get it wrong. This is also a place where exceptions are handy because while they are triggered by the same cause as a SIGSEVF, they sometimes contain slightly more information (out of memory vs stack corrupt, say).

    I've spent time this year importing a C-ish C++ codebase that had lots of (buffer, size) code that's been mostly replaced by either std::vector<byte> or std::vector<char> ... which are types that consist of a buffer and a size that you pass around as one object. A lot of code has got simpler and easier to read, not least because "foo = bar" replaces a lot of realloc+memcpy. But also through a bunch of std::findif and std::foreach stuff replacing "for(size_t i;i<somesize;++i) { if(array[i]==target) break;}" which is simple enough to understand but just tedious to check for bugs. When every buffer knows its size and the iterator is guaranteed not to run off the end (etc) there's just less code. When you're looking for a field in a struct/object the code is ugly to a C programmer (lambdas) but no worse than the C verbiage once you get used to it.

    In Rust you have the benefit of generally almost C performance and size, with a much safer language. Albeit at the cost of spending time up front looking at compiler errors rather than time downstream looking at weird bugs ("the LED blinked green four times... what does that mean?")

    [[ html fixes for the < symbol - mod ]]

    1207:

    ECB @ 1199
    Yet again - The cruelty isn't a side-effect, it's the entire point
    See also P Patel.

    1208:

    1202 - If you think that, then you have an issue with your language, and/or with any project level user-defined fatals. In Ada I have once (and once only) thrown an Out_Of_Memory exception. I was able to look that up in the Ada language reference manual(s; I've access to several of them, all with the same standard but different commentaries) and determine that it was literally the case; I was trying to create several memory arrays that between them used more memory than the execution space on the target machines. Once I knew that, the solution became obvious.

    1203 - invoke_ super...what_I_want . I like it, because it tells me exactly what the functionality actually is. When I use a single character as the name of a loop control variable, it is because that variable has no functionality other than meeting the language syntax and/or passing which iteration of the loop we're in to constructs within the loop as a mode in parameter.

    1205 - Or Omicron may actually be typical of the progression of a virus family, and represent a more infectious but less lethal strain. Like how 1918 "Spanish" flu still exists, but is "just another flu virus strain" rather than a global pandemic.

    1207 - Must I? ;-)

    1209:

    I know this is nitpicking...

    The cruelty is not the goal in itself.

    The goal is old-testament-style "justice" and the cruelty is, in their perception, proof that they are doing "the right thing".

    Both the USA gun-nuttery, death-penalty-fetish and crude tribalism have their roots in the old testament vengance-fixated fetish.

    1211:

    I have been reading about JWST since I was a teenager and it has been imminent for at least 20 years. Hard to believe it is actually flying.

    1212:

    Hard to believe it is actually flying.

    Unlike fusion power. :)

    1213:

    I didn't want to sound bitter. In any case I think we are pretty much on track given investment levels.

    1214:

    "matrix op scalar" We can do that, with a couple of small niggles. a) if “op” is one of list of symbols that we commonly think of as “maths stuff” (ie + - * <= and so on) then we just implement a matrix class and suitable methods named + - <= etc. In fact, it’s already in the system image for graphics transform purposes b) if you need some other symbol there are two options 1) just take the easy way and use a keyword message, which involves the horribly complex process of having a : at the end of the symbol. Like perhaps invertAgainst: ? 2) tweak the compiler (it’s all there in the system image anyway) to accept your required extra symbols as binary selectors instead of keywords. I think we might have done that once or twice. When you have a totally live and reflective system with all the tools built in and written in the same language you can do this amazingly easily

    1215:

    I didn't want to sound bitter. In any case I think we are pretty much on track given investment levels.

    Or you can look at it that running a net power-generating fusion system that's artificial, small, and contained is really hard, so we've decided to go with a fusion system natural, huge, and isolated from us by 96 million miles of reasonably hard vacuum. We've then worked on optimizing the energy capture and storage parts of the natural fusion power system, because those seem more tractable at the moment.

    But yes, it would be nice to have neighborhood fusion plants about now.

    Although given the way drones, high explosives, and missiles are converging in form and function, putting all our critical generators in a few targets is maybe...a suboptimal strategy going forward? I'm not sure.

    1216:

    Well, there are two things I was thinking of when I wrote that.

    First was a 70s study I'm too lazy to dig up that essentially predicted how long it would take to get a working artificial fusion reactor for a given amount of effort. We made minimal effort, we are at the point predicted.

    Second was a drunken conversation with an old uni mate at about the time LHC was coming on line and there was lots of ITER horse trading. He was in the business of developing instrumentation for oil drilling. He mentioned that at any given time there were about a dozen oil exploration projects in progress, each of which cost significantly more than LHC or ITER.

    the bitterness is about not trying.

    I accept there's no good reason to believe fusion power will be cost effective once it works but knowing would be handy.

    1217:

    putting all our critical generators in a few targets is maybe...a suboptimal strategy going forward

    This is why I do not believe we will have a space elevator any time soon -- and by "soon" I mean "within next two centuries". I know we do not have the materials for it yet, but that's a minor problem. Major problem is that space elevator would be the biggest, most tempting terrorist target ever.

    We cannot even start working on such elevator until metal detectors in the airports are the stuff of historical novels.

    1218:

    I don't care whether it's "cost effective"; if it looks like it isn't, then that's easily solved by making up some different fairy numbers. The important thing is whether it can produce enough energy to keep itself going and give you a useful amount left over, which we know for sure it theoretically could do, and it basically comes down to getting the confinement sorted out.

    Of course it would help a great deal if we could figure out a way of generating gravitational fields to order with the same ease and control that we have for generating electric and magnetic fields. And it's possible then that we wouldn't need to bother with fusion, because we'd find ourselves able to do things like generate a microscopic black hole and drop rubbish into it, which gives the kind of mass to energy conversion rate that is really hard to beat. The safety aspects would be a bit of a killer though.

    I do very much agree with your frustration over the lack of effort. I get thoroughly fed up with seeing the amounts of money spent on fusion research quoted in isolation with comments like "look how much it is" and the implication that it would be far too expensive to do any more than we're doing already, when as you point out it's actually fuck all compared to what is spent on oil exploration - and that in turn is itself fuck all compared to what is spent on all sorts of other examples of misdirected effort that the general public never know exist. It's not a case of "can't", it's just "can't be arsed", and that's not good enough.

    1219:

    Manchin...yeah, the Democrat trying to primary him really needs to make the point, in their ads, that "oh, someone might use their tax credit for drugs" is driving a Maserati (for real).

    1220:

    Yep.

    There's a line in Djelli Clark's first novel that I'm reading*: "I know what I want, I know what I need, and I know what's likely to kill me."

    They don't.Or they don't care, as long as someone else is hurt first/worse.

    1221:

    Cost effective is relative to other things that work. Some things that are possible really aren't worth doing but you will never know unless you try.

    1222:

    I couldn't afford a computer in the mid/late seventies - but I went back to college then. First course was a pseudo-assembly language, with 13 instructions (including add, subtract, multiply, and divide, that a late friend, the school's systems' programmer, wrote. 36 or so of us started the class, 13 finished it.

    Then, to be sure you really wanted to be a programmer, the second term was BAL (IBM mainframe assembler). Only then did we get to COBOL...

    Let me assure you that several times in my career, understanding what assembler was, and the kinds of things it did was important in debugging.

    1223:

    Sorry, missing footnote: great, I'm reading it because it's up for the Compton-Crooke award, which BSFS oversees... and so is my novel, so I'm up against someone with two Hugo nominations....

    1224:

    "Exit with a magic number"... what, you've never gone to the IBM mainframe error manual, all 20cm thick of it?

    1225:

    "...until metal detectors in the airports are the stuff of historical novels."

    Well, I can quite see that there could well come a time when the default material for making penknives is super-ceramic-diamond-fibre-composite or whatever and steel ones are quaint old-fashioned rusty things that go blunt and cost more and aren't worth the money except to historical re-enactors...

    But I don't see it being impossibly hard to defend a space elevator against terrorist attacks. The site will necessarily be remote and isolated and a long way both from anything important on the ground and from civilian air routes, and it will in any case need a large and strictly-enforced exclusion zone around it for ordinary safety reasons. So there is no reason why anything should come near it, and it can be made very clear in advance that if anything does come too close it will be shot down before anyone bothers to wonder what it's actually doing. Same kind of thing as a big top secret military base. Of course this is rather nasty, but with there only being one site (or at the most only a very small handful of sites) and it being well out of the way to begin with, there is very little chance of it actually affecting anyone who isn't deliberately taking the piss.

    As another thing, if someone does sever the cable... the bottom end falls only inside the exclusion zone (as long as it's big enough), and the top end falls upwards. So they've buggered a great big expensive thing right enough, but without producing any proportionate degree of spectacle, and without killing all that many people, fewer still visibly. There are any number of more sensible things to crash your hijacked airliner into, and any even bigger number of possible attacks that don't involve hijacking airliners which have a much higher reward/effort ratio. It's a bit like the "terrorist nuke" thing: if they're clued up enough to be able to do it at all, they're also clued up enough to realise their effort would be far more productively directed to something a lot less exotic.

    1226:

    exit with a magic number as the code

    Er, in this context it's not a "magic" number, but but a reference to an entry in a reference, where you should find a meaningful narrative.

    1227:

    Yes, but the correlation between "cost" and "really not worth doing" is basically random and comes out negative as often as not. Were it not for the pervasive dedication to the false assumption that it is necessarily meaningfully positive, we would have been moving seriously away from fossil fuels since about the 1950s and they'd be limited to niche applications by now.

    1228:

    Heteromeles @ 1164:

    I dutifully looked up The Phenomenon of Money. It's Routledge and hence phenominally expensive at £39 for paperback, so it will have to remain unread by me. Pity.

    You might find it more satisfying to search alibris.co.uk for "Phenomenon of Money": https://www.alibris.co.uk/The-Phenomenon-of-Money-Thomas-Crump/book/5097629?qsort=p&matches=13

    Interesting that BigMuddy doesn't carry any of the used copies, since AFAIK they also own alibris.

    "BigMuddy" in the U.S. had used copies, sold through the "BigMuddy" Marketplace Partners. I found one for $42 (USD). That £39 sounds about right for current exchange rates if you include VAT.

    1229:

    Back to the topic, Charlie linked to an article on his twitter feed that ought to be jully fun reading for us all.

    Basically, the author believes that COVID is here to stay, will come roaring back every winter, and it's a matter of time before we get a variant that is as contagious as omicron and as deadly as SARS or MERS.

    The only way out: a lockdown of at least two weeks (and probably a couple of months) during which time everybody in the whole world gets vaxxed.

    Of course, doing this would be very unpopular. At least until the omicron / MERS variant shows up. By which time it will be Too Late.

    1230:
    Cost effective is relative to other things that work. Some things that are possible really aren't worth doing but you will never know unless you try.

    Funny you should mention that, but it came up in what is possibly the first SciFi novel: Jonathon Swift's "Gulliver's Travels" -- particularly his satire on The Royal Society -- Lagado.

    How about an eight year project to store sunbeams in cucumbers? (Bear in mind that cucumbers were rare and fabulously expensive at the time.)

    1231:

    (That's jolly, not jully. And I don't even have the excuse of autocarrot).

    1232:

    Greg Tingey @ 1180: Troutwaxer
    Let's get this straight ... Mancin is against slightly more money to poor people ... "Because they might spend it on drugs" ...
    A supposedly "Democrat" Senator is against giving more money to poor people ...
    And - W Virginia is one of the poorer states, yes?

    Manchin won re-election in 2018 in the middle of Trumpolini's term and is the lone Democrat in a state that is heavily gerrymandered towards the GQP - 3 RepubliQan Congress Critters & the other Senator from WV is a RepubliQan.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_congressional_delegations_from_West_Virginia

    Manchin is a holdover from Reaganomics and the kind of Clinton era "Triangulation" that "ended welfare as we know it".

    Plus West Virginia is one of the states hardest hit by the FLOOD of Oxycodone & other prescription opioids that have precipitated the current US addiction crisis.

    As rancid as some of his beliefs might be, he'd never fit in with the GQP, because his beliefs appear to be motivated by principle. And as questionable as some of his connections to Big Coal and his family members "business" dealings, he's probably one of the more honorable members of the Senate.

    Think about THAT for a minute.

    1233:

    1228 - er, books are zero rated for VAT in the UK. OTOH you can easily get stiffed for a 10% "sales tax" in the Yousay.

    1229 - Which assumes both infectiousness ^ and lethality ^. "Variants of concern" to date suggest that infectiousness ^ and lethality \/.

    1230 - Isn't Gulliver's Travels a political satire though? (and yes I have read the 3rd and 4th voyages rather than just the first 2). I was going to suggest an earlier title, but I've never read it and think from the elevator pitch I've heard that it's a fantasy.

    1234:

    Dave Lester
    LAPUTA
    Don't forget that Laputa, erratic though it's governors seemed to be ... the Island was invincible - it could bombard its enemies from the air ...

    1235:

    Heteromeles @ 1183: Now personally, I'd be thrilled if Manchin abandoned politics. But I suspect that, if he did, the West Virginia Governor would appoint a Republican senator to replace him, and it would be even worse.

    West Virginia law requires the Governor to appoint someone from the same party as the incumbent being replaced. The current Governor of West Virginia is a former Democrat who switched parties to RepubliQan six months into his first term (elected 'D' in 2016 - took office Jan 2017, re-elected 'R' in 2020).

    I'm sure he'd try to choose the most unpopular Democrat he could find in West Virginia, but it would have to be a Democrat.

    The U.S. Senate is divided into three "classes" serving staggered 6 year terms; Class 3 is the next class that will stand for election in 2022, Class 1 will next stand for election in 2024, Class 2 in 2026 - Class 2 includes those Senators elected in the 2020 election.

    Manchin won re-election in 2018 by a 3.31% margin (49.57%-46.26%). Under Federal Law, anyone appointed by the Governor would have to stand for re-election in the next General Election (2022), with the winner filling out the remainder of Manchin's term - as a Class 1 Senator he's next up for re-election in 2024.

    Manchin was Governor of Governor of West Virginia when Robert Byrd died in June 2010. He decided to appoint another Democrat to Byrd's seat for the interim, but ran to fill the remainder of Byrd's term in the 2010 General Election. He then won the seat in his own right in 2012 (when Senate Class 1 came up for election again).

    I guess that since the current Governor of West Virginia is a RepubliQan and by definition has no principles, he could switch parties again and try to appoint himself if Manchin quit (and then switch a third time after he was sworn in) ...

    1236:

    What do they call it in the Spanish translation?

    1237:

    Which assumes both infectiousness ^ and lethality ^. "Variants of concern" to date suggest that infectiousness ^ and lethality \/.
    That piece is a bit shrill, but it's not wrong; there isn't much selection against lethality going on in COVID cases, excepting maybe selection against death while infectious through heart attack/stroke. Maybe some selection against severity when infectious, if early severity is causally correlated with risk of death. Most people who die of COVID-19 are not infectious when they die. If some recombination made a virus strain both somehow more infectious and more lethal, it would take off. And if and when proper anti-pandemic NPIs were put into place to slow the spread, they would tend to be neutral in effectiveness against strains with similar R.
    Also, arguably, Delta produces more severe cases than the original wild strain.
    Some potential savior wildcards will be more generic COVID-class vaccines, better treatments, and infrastructure and practice for rapidly producing new mRNA vaccines and updated monoclonal antibody treatments. And expect other unexpected positive wildcards, in a continuous dribble over years.

    ---
    SotMNs: sorry, my comment now at 851 should have included this "How do you do it? at 850,855,780" [first two since deleted.]
    [See also Charlie's "Glasshouse", towards the end, maybe, sort of.]
    Not sure: Reformat + Upgrade all their Minds is tempting. And that's like only 3 Covenant Tokens, fuckers.
    I seldom see a "Not sure" from you, but kinda sorta agree, though am more of an incrementalist.

    1238:

    deep (full stack + external services) automated integration testing with data fuzzers as the input.
    Good to hear: underused approach.
    There is a reason that professional (vulnerability) bug hunters (bounty or market) vigorously (sometimes with parallelism) probe attack surfaces with fuzzers - they expose bugs that were not found by SW developer test suites. (Partially excepting those devs who test with fuzzers.)
    This applies to probes of complex non-computer domains, as well.

    1239:

    Manchin...yeah, the Democrat trying to primary him really needs to make the point, in their ads, that "oh, someone might use their tax credit for drugs" is driving a Maserati (for real).

    Your assuming Demcrat voters in West Virginia disagree with his position.

    Given how heavily right wing the state is that may not be a safe assumption.

    Your also assuming that the Democrats can afford to give up a Senate seat that votes Democrat 97% of the time (for Biden), because any Democrat not named Manchin will lose to the Republican candidate.

    1240:

    Basically, the author believes that COVID is here to stay, will come roaring back every winter, and it's a matter of time before we get a variant that is as contagious as omicron and as deadly as SARS or MERS.

    Sort of obvious for several months now that the only way Covid disappears is if it dies off on its own, which would seem unlikely.

    We simply can't get enough people vaccinated in the west, let alone attempting to get the entire world vaccinated.

    As to whether it at some points gets more dangerous, no idea, but my guess/fear is that nobody can really answer that.

    The only way out: a lockdown of at least two weeks (and probably a couple of months) during which time everybody in the whole world gets vaxxed.

    The story of omicron is how few governments are doing what is necessary, and how quickly many of the more serious restrictions get rolled back after public backlash.

    The idea that we could somehow do a complete lockdown worldwide is sadly laughable.

    1241:

    The idea that we could somehow do a complete lockdown worldwide is sadly laughable.

    100% agree.

    1242:

    because any Democrat not named Manchin will lose to the Republican candidate.

    Most likely with the largest margin in any federal election that year.

    Trump won WV in 2020 by 70/30. So Manchin was able to get 2 of every 7 people who voted for Trump to vote for him. That's just a crazy outlier.

    1243:

    Major problem is that space elevator would be the biggest, most tempting terrorist target ever.

    Sounds like a possible plot element for a movie. I wonder if anyone has thought of it? [/sarcasm]

    1244:

    Cost effective is relative to other things that work. Some things that are possible really aren't worth doing but you will never know unless you try.

    Actually they've been trying for a very long time. Each of the approaches tried so far require magic materials that no one has figured out. Or the experiments lead to conditions that no one has figured out how to create and sustain.

    Anyone know what happened to that SMR type fusion thing someone was saying they'd make in 10 years?

    My undergrad college roommate when on to LLNL to get his doctorate. While not engaged directly in any fusion projects or even the laser effort he rubbed elbows with them. And the general feeling even there was there was nothing they (or anyone else) was doing that would allow for power generation within 20 years. They liked the laser project as it allowed lots of basic research in high energy physics but they didn't think it would lead to power generation within a decade or few. Congressional budget line items descriptions not withstanding.

    His thesis had to do with high energy sound impacting surfaces in my limited memory. This was in the 80s.

    1245:

    1237 - I agree some of this, but to date, there have been something like 18 designated variants of concern, 3 or possibly 4 of which have been endemic "most common variants" (alpha, delta and omicron spring to mind; beta or gamma may also have briefly been most common before being overtaken by delta). The change from delta to omicron more than anything else is what suggests to me that increasing infectiousness significantly also reduces lethality in a Covid-19 strain. If I'm wrong, then the BBC have misreported the science.

    1241 - 41 - Strongly thirded. :-(

    1243 - Not sure about a fillum plot, but beanstalks have featured in the works of several SF authors.

    1246:

    The history of dominant variants goes: the original, alpha, delta, omicron. VUI-OCT21-01 (a variant of delta) would have been, but was overtaken by omicron. Beta and gamma weere taken seriously more because they seemed to have rather more severe infections, than because of their infectiousness.

    The feeble attempts at lockdown used in most countries won't help with omicron, and even those are impossible in many. What is both disgraceful and self-harming is the way that the leading countries (mainly the USA and UK) are not attempting to provide vaccines for free to the whole world. No, that wouldn't stop COVID, but it would help.

    1247:

    "What is both disgraceful and self-harming is the way that the leading countries (mainly the USA and UK)"

    I am not trying to be snarky here, but "leading" in what sense ?

    1248:

    Leading in the sense of developing vaccines, plus various related aspects.

    1249:

    "Leading in the sense of developing vaccines..."

    Really ? Hmm, OK, there may be a few details and scientific breakthroughs you have overlooked there...

    1250:

    Not really. I am fully aware of what is going on elsewhere, and where the UK's vaccines are made, but it is mainly the USA and UK that have a vaccine surplus.

    Anyway, that's irrelevant to the point I was making, as I hope you are aware.

    1251:

    Sounds like a possible plot element for a movie. I wonder if anyone has thought of it?

    It would have to be more than an element of the plot. More like the foundation of it.

    1252:

    "but it is mainly the USA and UK that have a vaccine surplus."

    But that surplus is not there because of "leading" production facilities ?!

    The surplus exists because both countries have well below benchmark health-care systems and large brain-washed (sub-)populations.

    1253:

    The UK led the field in ordering COVID-19 vaccines even before they were fully tested and ready for production. These pre-orders and early deliveries meant we had a surplus of AstraZeneca vaccine doses in stock after the summer of 2021 because the risk factors of blood clots and cerebral venous blockages resulted in JCVI recommendations that anyone under the age of 40 should receive mRNA vaccines rather than the adenovirus-based AZ vaccine. By that time the UK had already vaccinated nearly 100% of the population over 40 so we had no further use for them. This was the reason the UK government generously donated 20 million AZ vaccines to Africa a few weeks back.

    1254:

    Was that a pun? Because it’s an element in the Apple TV Foundation!

    1255:

    Yes, you got it!

    1256:

    More like the foundation of it.

    https://www.freesoundslibrary.com/rimshot-sound/

    Scroll down and hit play.

    1257:

    I can't resist: no one expects the Spanish Translation!

    1258:

    "What do they call it in the Spanish translation?"

    Pretty much the same: gripe española.

    1259:

    Oh, for heavens sake! You don't normally troll, so stop it.

    Nowhere did I claim the UK (in particular) had leading production facilities - indeed, I said that it DIDN'T in #1250. And, however dysfunctional our health system is, our vaccination rates are high so our surplus is NOT due to that.

    Nojay in #1253 is correct. I have no idea why you are denying what I said in the second paragraph of #1246, but you are wrong to do so.

    1260:

    mdive @ 1240
    "Covid disappears" ... After 1918/19 & 20 ... what happened to Influenza?
    There have been bad outbreaks in my lifetime, but absolutely nothing on the scale of that intial eruption. Even so "flu" was killing 500-1000 people in Britain, every year, usually the elderly/frail/otherwise vulnerable.
    Is C-19 going to go the same way, with a constant, low level & periodic outbreaks, whilst the medical/science professionals "remix" vaccines & drugs against the latest versions. A "low level" threat that we simply - live with ????

    Notes not too far up-thread on fusion being 20 years away - always.
    HOWEVER: - I just saw a note to the effect that RR-Engineering have now got enough money lined up to practically start on their SMR reactors project, seriously. In terms of Non-Carbon power sources, that is really important, provided the fucking stupid fake greenies are not allowed to wreck it.

    1261:

    Re: 'The surplus exists because ...'

    They all ordered excess doses from across potential vaccines because no one knew which vaccines would ultimately be approved - it was a very expensive crap-shoot.

    Once roll-out began all the vaccines were monitored for side-effects and efficacy, i.e., the post phase-3 clinical trial time which happens to also be SOP for any drug. Thus it was discovered that certain vaccines were problematic for certain (younger) age groups - therefore those groups were subsequently advised to use some other - ideally mRNA - as their second dose.

    Countries with excess doses - roll-out was not perfectly smooth. Shipping concerns - remember how everything was supposed to need super-super-cold refrigeration? Then there was place and staff issues: where can the largest number of at-risk people get vaccinated fastest? Can we pull medical staff away from their usual jobs in order to administer shots, etc.? I've no idea how the various logistics were ultimately worked out - but I imagine that there were more than a couple of 'surprises'. This was a first-of event for most of the planet - no one knew exactly what issues - large or small - they'd have to contend with.

    There's also vaccine stale-dating/best-before-dates - I think the manufacturers and gov'ts erred on the side of safety - and because opened vials that were not completely used up (given as shots into arms) could not be safely stored, there was wastage. No idea whether total wastage - by type and in total - was below or above best-guesstimates pre-roll-out.

    Shipping to/sharing with other countries - all of the above issues also applied and still apply to countries that were not able to afford to order tons of doses with shortage of personnel and ability to physically deliver dosages much much worse than here. (Haven't read anything about anti-vaxxers in those countries - but they've been a persistent nuisance in getting more jabs-in-the-arms done over here.)

    1262:

    "Covid disappears" ... After 1918/19 & 20 ... what happened to Influenza?

    Not an expert in this field, so use that is judging my responses.

    I think that would be a best outcome given our realistic choices, but I also think there is potentially a danger in assuming the Covid virus will behave the same as the Flu virus and turn into a relatively tame thing with time.

    Is C-19 going to go the same way, with a constant, low level & periodic outbreaks, whilst the medical/science professionals "remix" vaccines & drugs against the latest versions. A "low level" threat that we simply - live with ????

    I think it is far too early to tell - in part because health records from 100 years ago are too incomplete.

    The key point though is Long Covid - as far as I am aware while Flu killed people and wasn't necessarily a pleasant experience for those who got it, it doesn't have long term health consequences on some of those who survive.

    Long Covid is something that has the potential to become a problem if some x% of people end up with it every year, even if x remains very small.

    Also worth considering that apparently pre-Covid most people who though they had the Flu never had the Flu - they merely had a bad Cold or something else - so many people's perception of the severity of the Flu is biased and made them think the Flu wasn't as dangerous as it was.

    1263:

    most C++ projects don't bother, they follow the system library pattern of only throwing strings

    Are you sure? Most projects I’ve seen which use exceptions, have taken the approach of throwing either std::exception, boost::exception, or something that derives from them (note for the unwary catch block author: boost::exception doesn’t derive from std::exception).

    Now, you can argue that it’s fundamentally just a wrapper around a string, but it works for us. We’re currently removing some fifteen-year-old code where the exceptions just throw an integer value error code (as you say, as much use as a chocolate fireguard)

    I rather like RAII; so, where something failed to construct, it threw with a meaningful error; e.g. if the tool tried to request something of our library via the API, and used a string that didn’t form a valid identifier, the API boundary catch block logged the identifier constructor’s “the identifier X is broken, and here’s why” message while reporting an error code.

    1264:

    Re: 'The key point though is Long Covid - as far as I am aware while Flu killed people and wasn't necessarily a pleasant experience for those who got it, it doesn't have long term health consequences on some of those who survive.'

    There's very little research on long-flu or long-any-other-type-of-virus so far but because of long-Covid, scientists/medicos have started looking into this including digging up whatever data they can about Spanish Flu survivors.

    Below is one of the first studies looking into long-flu - first published in December 2017:

    'Long term outcomes in survivors of epidemic Influenza A (H7N9) virus infection'

    https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-017-17497-6

    'Abstract

    Patients who survive influenza A (H7N9) virus infection are at risk of physical and psychological complications of lung injury and multi-organ dysfunction. However, there were no prospectively individualized assessments of physiological, functional and quality-of-life measures after hospital discharge. The current study aims to assess the main determinants of functional disability of these patients during the follow-up. Fifty-six influenza A (H7N9) survivors were investigated during the 2-year after discharge from the hospital. Results show interstitial change and fibrosis on pulmonary imaging remained 6 months after hospital discharge. Both ventilation and diffusion dysfunction improved, but restrictive and obstructive patterns on ventilation function test persisted throughout the follow-up period. For patients with acute respiratory distress syndrome lung functions improved faster during the first six months. Role-physical and Role-emotional domains in the 36-Item Short-Form Health Survey were worse than those of a sex- and age-matched general population group. The quality of life of survivors with ARDS was lower than those with no ARDS. Our findings suggest that pulmonary function and imaging findings improved during the first 6 months especially for those with ARDS, however long-term lung disability and psychological impairment in H7N9 survivors persisted at 2 years after discharge from the hospital.'

    In retrospect, the signs were there.

    One thing I'm hoping will become more commonplace in the future is a quick, affordable at-home flu test. Plus long-term follow-up across severity of cases (upon diagnosis).

    1265:

    One thing I'm hoping will become more commonplace in the future is a quick, affordable at-home flu test.

    I'm hoping that staying home if you're sick becomes normalized, so you don't infect everyone else at your workplace/school.

    I think it a forlorn hope, though, given the current governmental attitudes towards compulsory sick leave in North America, and the presentee-ism that is deeply-embedded in management culture.

    1266:

    I also think there is potentially a danger in assuming the Covid virus will behave the same as the Flu virus and turn into a relatively tame thing with time.

    This needs to be understood by many who are wishfully hoping that this coronavirus epidemic will somehow follow the same path as a non-coronavirus influenza virus did a century ago. It doesn't have to, and perhaps it won't.

    1267:

    it’s fundamentally just a wrapper around a string

    Precisely. Decorate it all you like, but unless you add more information it's just a string. Generally a static string. Not even "file '/foo/blah/ooops.log' not found", just "file not found". Good onya, you've turned errno 15 into a 40 byte string.

    To be useful an exception needs context, otherwise all you know is that somewhere below an exception handler something bad happened. Which means that useful exception-based code ends up containing an awful lot of if(!function()){report error} turning into try{function()}except on e:std::exception{log(context,exception)} which obviously wraps out to ~5 lines of code instead of 2.

    I admit to suffering trauma when I switched from Delphi(Pascal) to C++, because it was my first exposure to really crap exceptions and I finally understood what Raymond Chen was talking about when he ranted about not being smart enough to understand exceptions.

    It still annoys me pretty much every day, because I like exceptions, and I really dislike the complexity of code that has to deal with every possible error as it possibly happens. The overwhelming majority of what I write is error handling code. There's no such thing as "do steps 1,2,3, and 4, then make sure nothing went wrong". It's more like "do step one. Did the obvious thing go wrong? No, well how about the less obvious thing? No, well maybe it timed out? Oh, my gosh, it succeeded. Now, how can I write some obfuscated bullshit so that I can continue my chain of if-elseif clauses rather than going in another indent level?"

    In Delphi, and Rust, and Eiffel, and pretty much every other language I've used recently, the code just goes StepOne(); StepTwo(); StepThree(); StepFour(); except {well that's a bit shit} because the only time you care about errors is when you have to say to whoever called you "sorry things didn't work out", generally via a custom exception. BUT, and this is crucial, you can include not just the original exception and the context in which it was thrown, but your own context. So you don't need to say OpenFile("called by FrobinateWhatzits","Whatsit #12345", "Frobinator #97", {something about a file}) because all that stuff will be available anyway in the event of an exception.

    1268:

    where something failed to construct, it threw with a meaningful error

    My vague understanding is that in C++ you shouldn't throw exceptions from constructors. Which leads to even more obfuscatory bullshit where people "construct" an object then immediately call a "Setup" method to handle all the things that might fail.

    I freely admit to not doing that, mostly out of habit, because I still occasionally find constructors that do non-trivial things. IIRC even initialising a mutex is dubious, you're supposed to leave them in an unusable state as you exit the constructor then initialise them before using them. I dunno, I remember going through the whole process ~5 years ago and deciding that pthreads rwlocks were a lot simpler to actually use. That plus some RAII wrapper around some kind of std::locking class that I found on the net that seems to work reasonably well.

    One thing I like about Rust is that the process of research and discovery normally results in a crate (library) that you include once, set a minimum required version, then forget all about. Occasionally people whine that their simple Rust project has 400 dependencies, but the flip side is that 99% of them need zero attention ever (this is a big community emphasis), you just magically gained new capabilities in the language. C++ makes that a very manual process and easily turns into a mess of warring libraries, so I suspect having 400 of them would just be intractable. Hence, I guess, Boost::AllTheThings.

    1269:

    C++ makes that a very manual process and easily turns into a mess of warring libraries, so I suspect having 400 of them would just be intractable. Hence, I guess, Boost::AllTheThings.

    My opinion on C++ is about this. I last used it in any bigger project about ten years ago, when working in the Meego project (which was used in the Nokia N9). We used C++, but a quite limited subset of it to avoid some of the problems. That's 'we' as in our team.

    I worked on a user application, so we used mostly Qt stuff, not Boost. The Meego UI was called DUI (I can't remember where that came from but it was joked about, of course) and that was built on top of Qt, which I was owned by Nokia at the time (it was sold off in August 2012). The DUI (and Qt) had a nice subset of C++ that was easy to use and could be used for all our stuff, so we used mostly that.

    There were other teams, especially in the not user application land, who did not limit themselves that much, and that created some issues, for example when testing. There was one in-house C++ library which was basically a wrapper around a C library, but written in a 'C++ way', meaning it used many, many C++ features, and was a pain to use and especially mock in testing. We were trying to avoid dependencies to other libraries in unit testing, and that one we didn't mock, after trying by two teams and not succeeding.

    The testing was also done on different levels, but we wanted to have good tests before having to use either simulated or real hardware as with phones it was always in flux and not always that easy to get to work.

    In the end I think we did manage to make a good application - the phone itself and the piece I was working on got good reviews at the time. Anyway using Qt made things much easier than taking all of C++ and trying to get something useful out of all of that.

    Qt is a library of mostly user-interface stuff, but also other related items, like a message passing system. It at least used to be the basis of KDE, one of the X window desktops, used for Linux sometimes.

    1270:

    "Oh, for heavens sake! You don't normally troll, so stop it."

    I'm not trolling, I'm baffled why anybody would use the word "leading" about USA and UK in relation to Covid-19 unless they were talking about preventable death and suffering ?

    1271:

    just "file not found"

    Then you get to situations where you have to explain to the end user this isn't really the error. That after some digging it appears that his message is the last choice in the list and the programmer didn't deal with the "I have no idea" case. So it IS NOT always "file not found". If you see this and the file is THERE then there is likely some error that the programming didn't expect.

    [sigh]

    Too many programmers don't understand that they can get results which don't fit the documentation. At any level.

    1272:

    The main one is the ability to supply them to poor countries.

    1273:

    The main one is the ability to supply them to poor countries.

    Well, in Canada we learned that America is willing to ignore contracts and treaties to seize medical supplies already bought and paid for, keeping them for domestic use.

    Forget 'supplying to poor countries'. 'Honouring contracts with your allies' isn't high on the list.

    1274:

    I stand by what I said in the second paragraph of #1246. Will you agree with "disgraceful and self-harming"?

    1275:

    Re: 'America is willing to ignore contracts and treaties to seize medical supplies ...'

    If this is about the medical masks - then I think that this was DT's knee-jerk response while at exactly the same time he kept insisting to MAGAhatters that Covid was trivial and would blow over in a matter of days. I think there were also some issues with border folks - they historically have near limitless authority/autonomy to seize product at the border.

    A couple of the US vax manufacturers had some significant ramp-up (Moderna) and QC (J&J) snags -- don't think they reneged.

    1276:

    A couple of the US vax manufacturers had some significant ramp-up (Moderna) and QC (J&J) snags -- don't think they reneged.

    The US Government, including under Biden, forbid US manufactured doses of either Pfizer or Moderna be used to fulfill non-US orders.

    It's easy to sweep away any negative stuff as being the fault of Trump and that Biden's election returned the world to being normal, but that is sadly false.

    There is a sad irony in that a Trump led US was better for Canada than the current Biden led US, with Canada actually contemplating/planning a trade war with the US currently over the (yet again) willingness of the current US administration to ignore treaties and a very long term friendship.

    1277:

    Re: 'It's easy to sweep away any negative stuff as being the fault of Trump and that Biden's election returned the world to being normal, but that is sadly false.'

    Hard to tell because the process (therefore analysis) of likely vs. actual steps and consequences of the invoked Defense Production Act remains opaque.

    I think the argument here would be whether invoking the PDA (self-protection) is counter to their obligations as a WTO member state (helping someone else in peril). Good luck sorting this out.

    'The Real Vaccine Procurement Problem Why America Should Make Its Supply Chain More Transparent' https://www.wto.org/english/tratop_e/trips_e/techsymp_290621/bown_pres3.pdf

    1278:

    They (the feds) had to put restrictions on the export of the vaccines due to the classified technology of the chips in the vaccines.

    GDRFC

    1279:

    There may be some subtleties here.

    US sending additional Covid-19 vaccines to Honduras and El Salvador By Priscilla Alvarez, CNN Updated 1336 GMT (2136 HKT) July 20, 2021

    Washington (CNN)The United States will begin shipping more than 3 million additional Covid-19 vaccines to certain Central American countries on Tuesday, a White House official told CNN.

    The US plans to send ship 1.5 million doses of the Moderna vaccine to Honduras and 1.5 million Moderna doses to El Salvador through the global vaccination program called Covid-19 Vaccines Global Access, or COVAX, adding to prior shipments provided to both countries this year. The US will also provide 500,000 doses of the Pfizer vaccine to Panama in a bilateral donation, the official said. White House press secretary Jen Psaki announced Monday that the US was also sending 3 million vaccines to Guatemala, after shipping 1.5 million Moderna doses there earlier this month.

    1280:

    Any comments on the (now) late E O Wilson?
    [ Nobel Biologist - Ant specialist & Conservationist ]

    1281:

    Hard to tell because the process (therefore analysis) of likely vs. actual steps and consequences of the invoked Defense Production Act remains opaque.

    You can't blame the current ignoring of NAFTA II (CUSMA) on Trump — it's Biden's administration that has decided to ignore the treaty.

    1282:

    One of the best Ezekiel jokes you've ever seen[1] frontrunning a "Lawfare" victory.

    ...Before it was announced to the Vox Populi.[0]

    This is the entire of your fucking tail-end nonsense getting dunked on three thousand years later with a cracking joke about a port 99% of modern rabid Zionists have never heard of and would probably decry.

    Fucking Frothing Mad Nonsense is their Game: not ours.[2]

    "Illogical"

    Logic is a closed System and requires Meta-analysis to actually become a T-System. Thus 1+1=2 being a little bit more complicated than you'd imagine. It's also mostly wank, Law of the Excluded Middle and all that and extremely primitive.

    Anyone being an Analytical Philosopher in the 21st Century is a fucking muppet.

    ~

    shrug

    Deleted the previous comment, which was also 100% smarter than average bears.

    [0] That's the Cheat/Hack/"BE NOT AFRAID" bit, fyi.

    [1] Read it: they have.

    [2] No, really: read EZ... thatsthejoke.jpg

    [3] No, really: read EZ... that's the bit of the Torah / Bible who mentions that port (spelt incorrectly)

    [4] No, really: we're really much better at you at this

    [5] Shove it into a friendly Rabbi, see if they get the joke.

    1283:

    Hard to tell because the process (therefore analysis) of likely vs. actual steps and consequences of the invoked Defense Production Act remains opaque.

    Actually, not hard to tell at all because is sadly doesn't stop with that.

    Biden and the Democrats deliberately inserted sections into the Build Back Better bill that not only violated CUSMA/NAFTA II but would effectively kill off Canada's auto industry and take all those good paying jobs with it. They did this with the requirement for the EV tax credit, which needs the car to be built in the US at a union facility.

    Attempts by the Canadian Government to get things changed to recognize the long standing (55+ year) integration of the auto industry that benefits both of us got polite responses from the Democrats to get lost.

    Hence the reason why Canada indicated we would be forced to invoke a trade war under CUSMA.

    Trump was bad, but his general incompetence made it relatively easy to deal with - you just needed to wait him out.

    Biden and the Democrats are far worse. Which is a sad reflection on the US, where Canada would be better off with Trump and the Republicans returning to power.

    1284:

    For the record: she was telling the Truth Yes, maybe, but how the fuck were we supposed to find out, through all the obfuscation?

    Given the room is almost 99% male now-a-days[0], you really need to read the Original Versions (in this case, mostly Ezekiel) and recognize one thing:

    You find out when it comes / becomes Reality.

    That's what Prophets (old style) do

    And you missed some cracking jokes there. Wigs = Judges? Judges = Bought Off by (modern day) Higher Caste (she meant IL power-brokers & UK Arms dealers) stuff against the little voices of (much younger) Truthful Light Jewish Voices?

    Read the book: she's not doing pastiche here, she's giving you a "happy ending" massage (if you happen to be Abrahamic Religious Types).

    [0] Sarah, PHD, killed in Greece, ear cut off.

    1285:

    SFReader @ 1275:

    Re: 'America is willing to ignore contracts and treaties to seize medical supplies ...'

    If this is about the medical masks - then I think that this was DT's knee-jerk response while at exactly the same time he kept insisting to MAGAhatters that Covid was trivial and would blow over in a matter of days. I think there were also some issues with border folks - they historically have near limitless authority/autonomy to seize product at the border.

    A couple of the US vax manufacturers had some significant ramp-up (Moderna) and QC (J&J) snags -- don't think they reneged.

    The U.S. is supposed to have a National Strategic Stockpile for medical supplies (especially PPE). Obama had significantly depleted it during the West Africa Ebola outbreak 2013-2016. Moscow Mitch blocked the Obama administration's requests to fund replenishment.

    When Trumpolini took office he didn't give a shit, so the stockpile was still depleted when Covid-19 hit. A number of hospitals around the U.S. ordered supplies when they couldn't get them from the government stockpile. Then Jared Kushner (asshole, son-of-a-bitch, privileged FAILson-in-law and all around USELESS GIT) aka MISTER Marie Antoinette Barbie appointed himself to head up Trumpolini's Covid task farce and ordered the illegal seizure of those incoming supplies and handed them over to his cronies to "distribute".

    It had nothing to do with the power of Customs & Border Patrol legal authority to seize contraband at the borders. It was blatant theft for political gain pure & simple

    1286:

    Yes, maybe, but how the fuck were we supposed to find out, through all the obfuscation?

    That's rather the point. You're supposed to be able to spot it immediately, it's what her fellows do (and not just the ones on the high end of Bloomberg terminals).

    To explain her meta-joke there: while the UK libel Laws can (perhaps Unjustly and certainly not able to deal with modern media like Twitter where the claimants do not even understand that a "re-tweet" is not a repeat of said Libel, but merely a semaphore flag to other followers saying "See this Here, Note this"... yes. They even missed that, the ruling relied upon not "directly quoting" the tweet when almost the entiriety of Twitter Manners relies upon a) not direct linking (to avoid dog-piles / follower wars / traffic) and b) the actual code framework really doesn't support it if you all do it (you will break all the things in under a week).... says a lot more about how fucking inept the Judiciary is rather than anything else.) produce such results... and a load of Oik Gremlins will cheer...

    She'll do something a little bit more impactful like make TR burn its entire foreign reserves (+$5-15 bil, depending) just by playing footsie (It's a pun) with the Razzle Dazzle Wide-Boy Traders.

    For them: £10,000 is a fucking meal. £100,000,000 is a punt. £10,000,000,000 is more like it.

    She was making a joke about how fucking pathetic these people are. Biblically.

    1287:

    He died in the hospital where my wife works. Very likely she was in the building when it happened, but a different ward.

    1288:

    "Henry Athelton"
    ( a.k.a. the shitgull under another name, or so it seems. )
    Oh do STOP IT.
    Stop trying to troll me, just for your pathetic amusement.
    That's rather the point. You're supposed to be able to spot it immediately, it's what her fellows do - LYING BOLLOCKS.
    # 1288 - more meaningless drivel, tied in with religious claptrap. ALSO: 1290, 1289, 1288, 1286, 1284, 1282 - bit of a give-away there ....

    1289:

    "Henry Athelton"
    1282 / 1283 / 1284 / 1286 / 1288 /1289 / 1290
    STOP IT TROLL
    Deliberate attempts to wind me up, out of petty spite.
    It's NOT CLEVER
    Also - 7 messages.

    1290:

    Oh BUGGER
    Please DELETE one of either 1291 or 1292 ...
    "I am Spartacus"

    1291:

    A question for the UK folks.

    Is this a legit site? (So many these days are fakes.)

    https://coronavirusexplained.ukri.org/en/

    1292:

    to SFReader @1073:

    I do still visit this site about once in a month or so, and I guess I can provide some POV. Don't think I wrote anything at all since 2020, and I don't even remember if I wrote about Covid before that.

    I do have contacts in many regions and hear a lot of rumors. The situation does vary between regions, sometimes very much, and on my personal observation it is dependent on condition of medical services or economy in general. Self-sufficient, or rich regions have different issues than poorer and subsidised regions. I live in region with rather bad economic situation, but medically it all has been slightly improved since the cluster of trouble that has been there in Summer 2020.

    a) 'catch Covid' - I've noticed that areas where trust in the pols/gov't system is low

    I have no idea how "trust" is measured here because following medical advice has nothing to do with trust in government. Everybody takes it personally - most people don't really care that much. I am vaccinated and yet I always take my mask to my work (because there are certain regulations) and in public transport (because it is decently effective against cold too). I can say that people underreport a lot, just like I am because I get sore throat every season and it's not worth it to go thorough entire bureaucracy for a couple paid leave days.

    Most people I know has not been strictly against vaccinations but they have been delaying their final assessment and there has been a lot of rumors. Which also means that almost everyone around me who has been openly hesitant for the last year has now finished with that, partially by my example, I believe. Not too hard to do as it is officially free for every type out there (there's now total of 4).

    b) 'die of Covid' - This part shows how strong/weak the underlying social norms and corresponding infrastructure are that in turn directly impact overall physiological (and other) health of the populace. The alcoholism rate among males in Russia is over 1 in 3 - that's staggeringly high!

    "The norms" have been evolving through the years. Same for me who would never take flu shot before the pandemic because I never seen anyone actually have . Now that I've been hammered by Covid once, I hesitated only slightly. As for alcoholism, the situation has been drastically improving through the years, and you know, it's been a decade already since 2011 reports. Also of course alcoholics just die off faster, improving the statistic permanently.

    The problem of Covid reporting is that different parts of the state (every state) profit from Covid, and in different matter. It all depends on laws that were introduced early and rarely supervised very well. Clinics can overreport numbers to government if government pays them per patient, but the government agency will underreport numbers because it impacts their reputation. Then again, patients and medical staff underreport because clinics and government are corrupt and steal the money anyway, so they can all go to hell and the goal is to save human lives.

    I haven't seen no reporting about these things anywhere at all. The journalists will be paid by government, by companies, by corporations, to wiggle their way somewhere in between numbers and close their eyes when necessary, and of course nobody will admit to anything. Our only hope is a law of big numbers against all of this pandemonium. But as for BBC or other foreign agencies, I will not believe a single claim they make, not for a second, not even implicit ones.

    1293:

    The webpage does say it's not been updated since June 2020 so I wouldn't bother with it. AFAIK UKRI is a three-letter-agency of the UK government although it may have been reorganised out of existence recently hence the lack of security certificates and updates.

    1294:

    to Heteromeles @1059:

    There are limitations of western view of Russia because in their judgement the mass-media prefer to depend on consummate liars, bootlickers and stooges with little sense of belonging.

    The answer reveals a great deal about the true power, and limitations, of the Putin system. Ekaterina Schulmann, a prominent political scientist in Moscow

    last month, a survey showed that trust in the President was fifty-three per cent, the lowest such figure since 2012 fifty-three per cent, the lowest such figure since 2012 fifty-three per cent lowest

    Every other day I hear from those same people that I live in the oppressive state that controls my every movement all my life and everybody is afraid to speak, etc etc and yet they are again struggling to explain to their peers that even such strong omnipresent state fails to tackle down simplest issues. They feign understanding and pretend they didn't hear the question.

    There's great saying about the situation (which those "political scientists" don't remember): "The severity of Russian law is limited by their optional execustion". So here are two stories to tell from the age of pandemic. 1. Anti-vaxxer campaign. (mostly unsuccessful, but had-struggling) 2. QR code screening campaign. (mostly successful but rather sloppy)

    One. Anti-vaxer campaign has been a very public discussion for at least a year, and if you think it's a campaign of government against the nation, you would be very wrong. It is a campaign of anti-vaxers against the state. There are of course degrees of being such. a) There are actual communists from CPRF who were agitating against vaccines because... just because they could, I guess. Just because it's anti-governemnt or something. Also other marginalized politicians on that bunch. How it started: How is it going. b) There's a certain media campaign against vaccines in general, and it seems a lot of hidden actors has been paying for it, so government has been hesitant to crack down on those too, especially because it involves threatening The Big Tech in a big way. It has come around to the point where The Big Tech takes the action first where the government does not (i.e. YT removing videos of celebrities for propaganda instead of government charging them for misinformation publically). There's an article on very certain lead in lobbying of such movement (in Spanish). c) There are also certainly a lot of those "progressive" people who aren't strictly against vaccines, but they are just against Russian vaccines in particular. This includes WHO, of course. I doubt that their motivation needs any explanation.

    In any case, I will not be surprised anyone at all starting to fight my country tooth and nail by joining one of those groups only to later blame it for not taking enough measures disperse anti-vaccine dissident. While at the same time of course blaming the country for crack down on dissidents. We all live in such world.

    1295:

    Oh well, the paragraphs are all messed up. I hope it gets better now.

    Two. The QR code screening campaign is the same as vaccine promotion campaign, of course. Except it is something that everyone is experiencing on personal level and not in politics.

    There were more or less severe restrictions everywhere during peak pandemic times (which continue today) and to visit many of the places you are required to have QR code certificate with you that identifies you as a person with immunity, printed or on the phone. Of course the simplest way to do it is to make a jab. There's also a way to get one if you have the immunity after the illness but the process is murky and I'm lucky I never got through it. Simple enough, but a lot of "but" in the question.

    1) There are fake certificates being handed out, of course, and not for free. That's a crime, btw, and yet nobody knows how much are in circulation and barely 30 ppl were charged with criminal activity last time I looked up. There was even case when the certificates were authentic but the nurse did fake jabs.

    2) The QR code verification is of varying quality - they most often verify name or date of birth. They don't ask every time. Recently when pandemic started to recede they don't even ask them at place I visit for a dinner and inflow of people increased again as well. What is social distance in such places in anybody's guess.

    3) Most of the necessary places like grocery shops and barbers and small are open, but at least majority of people here are using masks. Elderly people are rare sight in here. Other parts of the big malls are usually cordoned off with several guards. Delivery services continue to get more busy.

    4) Some very smart deputy in Duma suggested to limit access to a public transport for those without a code, but was talked out of it pretty quickly because he doesn't seem to know how public transport works here (at winter with -15C outside). It is hard to even ask many people to put on the mask. And the public transport system is always strained to the very limit so people have zero "social distance" in a bus, IYKWIM.

    5) Lastly, literally everyone and everywhere in my city have been getting a pretty light forms of common cold or flu for the last month. Some, like me, reacting more strongly, some went through just OK. Nobody has any idea where it comes from, and there's nothing much to report.

    All in all, something is working, I can say that much, and I am satisfied to have even that. I believe it can easily swing other way at any convenient moment, but for now people don't feel threatened en masse. And you certainly won't see masses of police trying to tear down unwilling population, no COVID riots and no mandatory screening. Putin and his government has also been against such drastic measures (because they aren't sure they can handle it, I imagine). And I fear of the moment this will be necessary because it will be certainly used to stir the country as much as it's humanly possible.

    1297:

    There are also certainly a lot of those "progressive" people who aren't strictly against vaccines, but they are just against Russian vaccines in particular.

    If you're referring to Sputnik V, that is/was a two-dose vaccination using two different existing coronavirus vaccines rather than anything targetting original-version Wuhan SARS-nCoV-2 coronavirus, unlike the Pfizer and Moderna mRNA vaccines and AstraZeneca's genetically modified chimpanzee adenovirus. The efficacy data on Sputnik V is... suspect, shall we say but it is probably better than nothing. In contrast Merck had a couple of vaccine candidates (V.590 and V.591) that failed to meet the 50% efficacy guideline and they never even tried to get them approved even for EUA in any country.

    1298:

    Speaking of R0, I hope this turns out to be a mistake:

    https://www.prensa.com/impresa/panorama/un-infectado-por-el-linaje-micron-podria-contagiar-a-10-o-mas-personas/

    [Via Google Translate]

    The epidemiologist and director of Panama's Vaccine Research Center, Rodrigo De Antonio, warned that the information available on Ómicron suggests that 10 people can be infected for each case or even more.

    1299:

    sleepingroutine @ 1297
    That sounds horribly like the Trumpists attitude to C-19 & its aftermath

    Kardashev
    No, I'm afraid that is probably not too far off, the "R" number is certainly 4-6 or higher. It's really infectious.

    1300:

    Hi, SR - glad to see you still around. Interesting to hear reports from you.

    What you report about public transit sounds like they really need more money in public transit (yeah, I'm speaking from one of the richest counties in the US, and they keep raising the fares, and it truly sucks... but they want to widen overcrowded roads for more cars).

    1301:

    To: Sleepingroutine
    Any comments?
    ISTM that they were & are not funded externally, just that Putin cannot take any criticism, but that's just me.

    1302:

    Gam-COVID-Vac is a viral vector vaccine based on two recombinant replication-defective human adenoviruses: Ad26 (serotype 26) and Ad5 (serotype 5) replicated in HEK 293 cells. The viruses contain the gene that encodes the full-length spike protein (S) of SARS-CoV-2 to stimulate an immune response. It is similar to the approach used by the Oxford–AstraZeneca COVID-19 vaccine that also employ HEK 293 cell line for the vector replication during the manufacturing process.
    (Decent wikipedia article. The (well one) major mistake affecting uptake IMO was approval before phase 3 clinical trials.)

    I see sleepingroutine links themoscowtimes - their daily reports on COVID-19 in Russia usually include an excess deaths estimate along with the official numbers. Currently somewhere 2-3X the official numbers.
    Here's a 2021/11/01 piece with more details.
    (The US is at about 1.1-1.2 million using similar methodologies; some moderate under-reporting, especially in some (cough Republican) jurisdictions. )

    1303:

    And, for those nations too impatient to wait for Omnicron to thin the herd: https://www.scmp.com/news/china/science/article/3160997/chinese-scientists-develop-ai-prosecutor-can-press-its-own

    Complete with a self-driving version of this, no doubt: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Execution_van

    1304:

    to Nojay @1300:

    If you're referring to Sputnik V, that is/was a two-dose vaccination using two different existing coronavirus vaccines rather than anything targeting original-version Wuhan SARS-nCoV-2 coronavirus

    I thought that after 1,5 years after vaccine introduction to the public and 100+ million of vaccinated people can get their information straight. But it turns out I'm usually wrong and people keep talking that "it's not approved" and "it needs years of testing".

    The efficacy data on Sputnik V is... suspect, shall we say but it is probably better than nothing.

    WHO doesn't cite any problems about their "efficacy" or anything like that, they are blocking it because of some undisclosed "manufacturing" issues, which is of course a little less than a straight ransom.

    https://www.euronews.com/next/2021/09/16/sputnik-v-who-suspends-approval-process-for-covid-vaccine-due-to-manufacturing-concerns

    to whitroth @1303: Thanks for the greetings.

    What you report about public transit sounds like they really need more money in public transit

    On the second thought, it is only overcrowded during peak hours, as usual (I live in medium sized regional capital). The investments have been coming for the last 2 years so there are a lot of new bus models arriving while they keep extending the use of what is left in the storage. Not to say about Moscow where they went as far to replace all trolleybusses with autonomous electric ones. And the new metro expansion. https://www.globalconstructionreview.com/moscow-opens-10-station-section-of-metros-new-big-circle-line/ They of course have a lot more money than any other city in the country.

    to Greg Tingey @1304:

    It says something that 21 of this organization's 34 years lifespan have been under "regime" and if there were any options to legalize it's activity they missed every single one of them. Putin has been rather tolerant to their activity, as opposed to a lot of critics an yours truly. They have enjoyed a lot of freedom. I cannot really imagine what could possibly trigger such response short of direct involvement in intelligence activity.

    ISTM that they were & are not funded externally

    They may keep their records hidden from public (which is a violation of law and official reason for prosecution) but they can't hide them from the state. In fact, they never tried to, they even call themselves "international" and regularly brag about heir wide connections and venerated status outside country. Too bad that inside the country they don't enjoy even minimum amount of public support.

    It is also a case that has been brewing for years and only the regular visits of various ambassadors from different European countries has been stalling it process as much as possible (which is of course is never mentioned). https://eeas.europa.eu/delegations/russia/107663/node/107663_en

    1305:

    It says something that 21 of this organization's 34 years lifespan have been under "regime" and if there were any options to legalize it's activity they missed every single one of them. Putin has been rather tolerant to their activity, as opposed to a lot of critics an yours truly. They have enjoyed a lot of freedom. I cannot really imagine what could possibly trigger such response short of direct involvement in intelligence activity.

    I think you need to take a look in a mirror and read that back to yourself.

    "if there were any options to legalize it's activity they missed every single one of them". What if there were no such opportunities?

    "Putin has been rather tolerant... They have enjoyed a lot of freedom." It is not the job of a government to decide whether or not to tolerate dissent or to grant freedom of speech.

    "I cannot really imagine what could possibly trigger such response..." Oh really? Powerful people have been silencing critics for thousands of years, but you can't imagine that this is another example?

    They may keep their records hidden from public (which is a violation of law and official reason for prosecution) but they can't hide them from the state. In fact, they never tried to, they even call themselves "international" and regularly brag about heir wide connections and venerated status outside country. Too bad that inside the country they don't enjoy even minimum amount of public support.

    The second sentence openly contradicts the first.

    1306:

    Omicron

    I don't know if it can be watched outside of the US but Netflix here has a recently released movie called "Don't Look Up".

    Off the charts satire of the US political reactions to Covid in 2020. Is very overloaded with big name stars. Who will never make an R dinner invite list. They must have worked for very reduced pay to make this possible.

    Worth a look.

    And there is no mention of Covid or pandemic or disease.

    1307:

    My vague understanding is that in C++ you shouldn't throw exceptions from constructors. Which leads to even more obfuscatory bullshit where people "construct" an object then immediately call a "Setup" method to handle all the things that might fail.

    One of the major reasons that exceptions were introduced into the C++ language was to avoid having to do what you describe. Before exceptions, there was no good way to indicate an error in construction, so the strategy for complex objects was to create a consistent state, and for the user to then call a subsequent setup() which could return a status.

    That was horrible - not only could you end up missing calling the setup function, but it also prevented the object being used anonymously such as a parameter to a function.

    The addition of exceptions meant that constructors could now fail and the rest of the program could detect it.

    If you encounter C++ code which avoids exceptions in constructors and does two stage construction, then it's a couple of decades out of date.

    1308:

    I'm not surprised it doesn't mention COVID, given the project was started back in 2019 ...

    (AIUI it's about the reaction to Climate Change)

    1309:

    Ignoring the technical issues of the crisis, it sure looked a lot like the previous admin was in charge. Which was true in 2019.

    So I'll rephrase as a satire of the previous admin.

    1310:

    Um. Not really. It's fairly well hidden, but throwing an exception in non-trivial constructors and constructor use is potentially undefined; throwing ones in destructors is worse. The reason is the implicit calls to constructors, which are largely unspecified, and do not always happen in well-defined contexts. I was in some debates about this issue in SC22WG21, and the outcome was to sweep the matter uner the carpet (surprise! surprise!)

    You can usually avoid trouble if you can keep your constructors simple and orthogonal, and avoid some of the fancier exception-handling facilities, some of which are inherently insane. The extreme one is rethrowing an exception in a separate thread from the one in which it was first raised.

    Two stage construction remains essential for some complicated uses, and is always more reliable because you aren't depending on the compiler interpreting the standard and code in the same way that you are!

    1311:

    It probably does need more formal testing to be acceptable in the EU, UK and USA; the thing that shows it to be political is that that possibility is ignored in favour of flat-out rejection.

    I am afraid that you are correct about the BBC and (editorially) even the Guardian and Independent. They show only negative slants on Russia, whereas Reuters, Al Jazeera and even Deutsche Welle and France 24 show some positive ones.

    While the case of Memorial is probably repression, the USA in particular has a record of infiltrating and manipulating NGOs for political purposes. The worst was what they did with the polio vaccination campaign in Pakistan and Afghanistan, which is why it has not been eradicated in those countries, but there are other examples.

    1312:

    Throwing exceptions in destructors is the big no-no, since you're quite possibly in a stack unwind due to another exception. Yes, there's std::uncaught_exception(), but that is messy.

    Anyway, if the job of a d'tor is to clean up resources, and a resource refuses to be cleaned (which is what I presume the exception is about), what's the rest of the program to do that the d'tor couldn't?

    1313:

    Yes, and it's one of the aspects of C++ that is an ungodly mess. Let's say your resource is a file or network connection, and it fails to close - what do you do? The traditional approach is to ignore that, and indicate success, which is NOT good practice. And those are not complex resources - there are worse ones.

    You also seem to have missed the point that large and complex programs are often (and almost always best) designed with multiple levels. Consider one with a TCP link, which jams; destructors of objects linking to that fail because it can't be cleaned up. The higher level of the program needs to know that, so that it knows the transaction failed and to proceed accordingly.

    I have lost count of how many applications get that wrong. The lower levels fail, awkwardly (e.g. in a destructor), but the error state gets lost because the flagging mechanism (e.g. exceptions) can't handle that, so the higher levels proceed normally, and you end up with corrupted databases, accounts locked out, stuck systems and worse. I have seen all of those.

    1314:

    Charlie will, I'm sure, confirm this, but the first stage in acceptance of $new_drug is for the manufacturer to submit it (and documentation of testing in other markets) for regulatory approval.

    1315:

    As I understand it, yes. But I saw several statements by people involved in the regulation that rejected it out of hand, rather than saying "if it is submitted, we will consider it". I don't know the full facts, don't believe either side, but am certain politics is a major factor.

    1316:

    In the US it would be a total wasye of all kinds of time and money to have everyone go through the process of adding another new vaccine to the mix just now. We have 3. I'm thinking the FDA and other agencies involved want to be dealing with trials of treatments just now. Especially since the existing vaccines seem to work as well as they do.

    Call it politics but it doesn't make practical sense just now. There are only so many people qualified to deal with trials and the analysis of the results and writing of the regulations and .... and they are kind of all busy. My daughter just left a job involving a US company that admin'd such. And they are very busy just now.

    1317:

    Public transit - as I said, there's no way I should criticize, given the outright hatred, esp. on the wrong-wing, for it. I think one of the reasons they hate Build Back Better is a lot of money for public transit in there, including our passenger rail system, which is lousy. (The wrong wing doesn't seem to understand that passenger traffic, even when private companies run it, was always a loss-leader).

    Btw, not sure if you saw, but my first novel, 11,000 Years, was published late May, and it is a truly international crew (Palestinian first mate, French-Vietnamese second, engineer is Russian....)

    1318:

    sleepingroutine - forgot to mention, if you decide to read my book, I'd really like to hear your comments on it.

    1319:

    WHO doesn't cite any problems about their "efficacy" or anything like that, they are blocking it because of some undisclosed "manufacturing" issues, which is of course a little less than a straight ransom.

    Um, not quite. All drug companies get held to this, because it's straight up QA/QC stuff. Basically, it's a matter of assuring that only what's supposed to be in the dose is actually in the dose, and nothing else. If some company insists that they deserve a special exemption from this rule, there's a problem.

    Note that this is a normal problem in the pharmaceutical industry. A hospital I know quite a bit about locally normally deals with shortages of random drugs, because there's a manufacturing issue. The drug industry is global, thousands of products are made, and often only one factory makes a particular product. For example, the hurricanes that messed up Puerto Rico a few years ago led to severe shortages of normal saline IV bags, because the only US plant that manufactured the stuff was in Puerto Rico, and they had to rebuild and recertify the assembly line after the hurricanes.

    As for Sputnik V, here's a more lengthy report: https://www.statnews.com/2021/05/26/data-needed-know-if-sputnik-v-vaccine-too-good-to-be-true/

    The basic problems are: --It got approved in August 2020 after only a Phase 2 trial on 38 patients. Given where we were in August 2020, this isn't stupid. Remdesivir was launched with little better data for the same emergency reason. Thing is, remdesivir is being pulled now because it was only marginally useful against basic Covid, it appears utterly useless against Omicron Covid, and it costs around $3500 per full treatment. But that kind of emergency authorization unfortunately doesn't tell us how well a drug works.

    --Sputnik's Phase 3 trial results have been published. However, the raw data underlying the results have not. This is unusual, because it gives the appearance of something to hide. If Sputnik V works as the results say, publishing the raw data only adds to the confidence.

    Unfortunately, being approved by a drug agency doesn't necessarily mean something is valid. Political pressure may always play a role, as we saw in the US under the Trump administration.

    Personally, I hope Sputnik V works as described, and this is all a paper tangle and not deception. I'd say the same thing about any Covid19 treatment.

    1320:

    HEALTH WARNING
    - You may need brain-bleach if you read the following ...
    A US wingnut on how Universal Health Care cannot possibly work
    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
    I don't know a soul who has said they liked Obamacare. I couldn't afford it myself, and it looks alarmingly close to time for people of my generation and younger to kiss their SSI and Medicare benefits goodbye. The country's broke—how do you propose we pay for all this top-quality insurance? If you desire the healthcare in some other country because you're certain that “it seems" to be fine, then I'm sure there are planes still traveling out of the country. Our poor state of health has been caused primarily by our insistence on eating fried and fatty foods, and drinking soda with them for most meals. Americans desire the fast pace of City life rather than the more balanced existence in rural America. Gardens are no longer necessary for most of us, and we've exchanged minerals for mayhem. If you throw in the steady decline of the family unit, it's indeed rare for a family to sit down for a meal and discuss life and some of the better choices to be made. I salute the folks who make time to exercise—but they are the exception. They insurance companies are tripping over one another for our business, and the docs aren't going to take that big paycut lying down. If you have a viable answer for all of this mess that we will welcome with open arms, then kiddo you're badly needed in Washington…

    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
    End of Brain Fart

    OTOH
    "The Atlantic" have just completely skewered DJT Jnr ...
    - Open in incognito window - limited number of access-points to "The Atlantic"
    LINKIE

    1321:

    Before exceptions, there was no good way to indicate an error in construction,

    I'd love to hear an explanation of how exceptions are a good way to handle those errors, because as I've said above, I don't understand how they work or even how they can be made to work.

    Right now my strategy, such as it is, is that exceptions are crashes and my goal is to report at least something useful during the crash. That's often pretty minimal except when it's nothing. "redis failed"... noting the thread that caught that hopefully suggests which particular redis connection failed, but that is all.

    I have a few test programs to investigate exception throwing and handling, and they are not encouraging. My ability to revert and retry based on exceptions is very limited and the errors I get often suggest that the destructor didn't work properly.

    Here's one of the standard libraries used in Delphi to report exceptions in released code: http://www.madexcept.com/madExceptDescription.htm

    I can live without the remote reporting capabilities, but the stack trace and program state etc in a local text file is the kind of minimum viable exception report that I'm looking for. I'm not sure it's even theoretically possible to get that from a C++ exception.

    1322:

    To be a little more specific, I have a bunch of threads that sit on UDP sockets and process traffic. They use database connections, UDP and TCP connections, redis, files, and probably other things (they spawn curl threads, for example, but not during startup). So in theory the constructor would open the UDP connection, open the database connection, open a redis connection, register with a bunch of internal queues, register for redis notifications from two sources, then say "ok, ready to rumble".

    In practice those threads just store the constructor parameters in local variables and they're done. Because anything else, even just a timeout opening a connection, makes the whole program unusable. SIGSEVF from another thread calling a method on the object unusable, even just std::atomic_bool.load() can break things.

    The actual worker method of the thread does all the rest. If it takes 60s or more to establish all its connections no big deal. If one or more fail it can log all sorts of useful information, then notify the watchdog thread that it's unable to operate, and then shut down whatever it managed to start up, then exit. The constructor doesn't seem able to do that. And using an exception to notify of problems often leaves database connections open, redis notifications active, files open, you name it. I'm not entirely certain it's even valid to expect the destructor to run if the constructor throws. But obviously if it doesn't run then everything up to the point the constructor throws can't be cleaned up. Much safer to do as little as possible inside the constructor.

    1323:

    "It is not the job of a government to decide whether or not to tolerate dissent or to grant freedom of speech."

    Er, yes it is. One may have one's own views on what the answers ought to be, and consider that those desired answers should be universally applied without variation, but that doesn't mean that a government has no place to decide on its own answers. Even if you don't like its decision.

    This is particularly so in regard of those two points since they are not straight binary choices of the "allow all" vs. "deny all" kind, and moreover there are not universal answers that always apply regardless of time and place.

    It seems almost too obvious to be worth pointing out that "dissent" can cover things as disparate as staggering drunkenly up the street chanting "Bozo is a wanker, Bozo is a wanker, na na na na, na na na na", and scaling St Stephen's Tower with a sniper rifle to pick off MPs as they go in and out. Neither "allow all" nor "deny all" seem appropriate to both, so there has to be some kind of governmental decision as to what counts as tolerable dissent and what doesn't.

    More relevantly to the current discussion, universal answers can't exist because people are not the same everywhere. It's fashionable to pontificate as if they are, but in reality they are not. Different lots of them have different habits of thought and different base assumptions which they have been assimilating from each other as they grow up for hundreds or thousands of years, and the result is that the same policy applied to different groups can meet with wildly disparate reactions.

    Often this is because the policy originated among one particular group and carries along with it a huge tail of that group's own unspoken assumptions. If you try and transfer it to another group with their own background habits of thought, most of the information which made it successful with the originators either goes missing altogether or gets replaced with some slightly different thing according to what seems natural to the nother group. And the (surely fairly predictable) outcome is that what succeeded well in one place tends to become something anywhere between "sort of looks like a success if you squint at it the right way" to "complete clusterfuck".

    Such situations tend to defy analysis because the incompatibility is not by and large a matter of a relatively small number of high-level points which are tolerably possible to pick out due to their scale, but of an incredibly large number of tiny points which pervade the whole thing and derive from one group habitually thinking of this or that in some manner which to the other group is inconceivably bizarre and never occurs to them. Each one is the kind of thing that you can't elucidate by asking about it because you have no idea what to ask or even that you need to ask anything; the kind of thing that can lead to two people from different groups having a conversation that spends half an hour getting weirder and weirder with each one getting more and more convinced that the other is an idiot and/or a dick, until maybe someone finally twigs that the ultimate origin of the dissension is that one of them thinks of socks as a cheap mundane necessity and the other one thinks of them as a weird and expensive luxury for strange rich people. Which is an impressive bit of twigging when the conversation wasn't anything about socks.

    Russia suffers particularly from this sort of thing because it is close enough to the "cultures that one may loosely categorise as "Western European", including their offspring exported to North America" (geographically close, people who look much the same, language that works the same sort of way, aristocracy with the same sort of ranks and which imported WE gloss like speaking French at court, and so on) that people on the WE side think it ought to be the same, and then freak out when reality shows that it isn't. (Kipling probably put this rather more neatly.) And furthermore, as a consequence of the various expressions of freaking out, the Russian background includes hundreds of years of paranoia and disgruntlement from WE considering them as second-class people and bitching and picking at them the whole bloody time... and the WE background includes not seeing why they shouldn't do this. Which obviously doesn't help.

    These days if anything it's got worse because people haven't learned, instead we have WE still picking on Russia for not being the same, exacerbated by long-range military force projection ability and the augmentation and formal legitimisation of the arrogant idea that WE somehow has the right to insist on other people being the same. I have considerable sympathy with sleepingroutine's snarky comments along the lines of "of course everyone will say this is shit because it's Russian", because so much of history is full of that kind of behaviour towards Russia, and it's a particularly naked demonstration of international statesmen behaving like five-year-olds asking for a clip round the lughole.

    1324:

    "Yes, and it's one of the aspects of C++ that is an ungodly mess."

    Aren't all its aspects like that? :)

    C is a personal favourite for various reasons (some technical, some personal), but from my outsider's view C++ just seems to be a perversion. I look at code written in it and think things like "what a non-intuitive and gross way the language makes them have to go about doing X, why doesn't it just let you do so-and-so". The more detail you look in the worse it seems to get, so I have declined to look any further than the minimum necessary to be able to bolt in functions from some library that doesn't come with a plain C interface if I can't find a more helpful one.

    I remember when C++ first came out there was some rumour that it was just plain C underneath a big pile of macro magic. I can't see how that can have ever been true though. I've occasionally played with trying to implement "the nice and useful bits of objecty stuff" in plain C and I always find that I'm relying heavily on nonstandard compiler extensions, bits of assembler, and gaffer-taped flakiness, to cover stuff the preprocessor just doesn't know about.

    Things concealing errors from deeper levels and reporting success regardless is the reason I found myself unable to use Python for a problem that half the internet seemed to suggest it was ideal for. The function to open an HTTP connection would return a sensible error code if the connection was over SSL and the SSL negotiation was rejected. But too many webservers are broken and just don't do the negotiation bit at all: if the client doesn't happen to guess correctly from cold what the server wants to see in its initial offering, the server just immediately bins the TCP connection with a RST. When that happened, Python just ignored it and returned something it said was a successfully opened connection which wasn't actually anything. Since dealing usefully with those broken servers was half the whole point of what I was doing, this made Python about as useful as a chocolate teapot.

    1325:

    C++... I know what cout means. But 15 years or so ago, I tried to figure out templates, because I really, really LOVE associative/hash arrays from awk/perl.

    I gave up. I could never figure out how to make the template work, and I do actually know what I'm doing in C.

    1326:

    Paul It is not the job of a government to decide whether or not to tolerate dissent or to grant freedom of speech.

    Pigeon @1323 Er, yes it is. One may have one's own views on what the answers ought to be, and consider that those desired answers should be universally applied without variation, but that doesn't mean that a government has no place to decide on its own answers.

    I would go further within this topic to state that it's not only a job of the government to do so, but it's a duty (a duty that a the government has no right to derelict lest there will be consequences). Namely, to extend or limit the rights of different people to the point where the balance between various constitutional rights. In the same way the right of free speech doesn't allow anyone to barge into my bedroom at 6 am and shout into my ear because it violates several of my other rights.

    The most peculiar situation is when the same "human rights" are brought forward to increase human misery and shut down dissent, when "serving the memory" of the people brings us down to destruction of that memory instead because of corruption and sponsorship that has been rooted in the system from the very beginning.

    Paul Oh really? Powerful people have been silencing critics for thousands of years, but you can't imagine that this is another example?

    Oh, there's nothing to be upset about, powerful people has been silencing criticism to liberal order for decades and every time somebody voiced a consistent opposition there has been the same display every time - more accusations, more sanctions, more demands. Two weeks later they will all forget about it and everything will start anew.

    The second sentence openly contradicts the first.

    There's absolutely nothing contradicting. It is in fact a SOP of overly corrupt organizations aka "bipolar disorder" - one day they brag about their power and reach and the other day they are faced with consequences and feign innocence and harmlessness.

    1327:

    Meanwhile - on the subject of "Omicron" ... Total fucking Nutters - what can be done about this? It's criminal damage & intimidation, at the least.
    Is it worth jailing the lot for a week?

    1328:

    Trump and Bozo decided to appeal to these folks as a way to power. The serious politicians went along figuring when Trump's and Bozo's flames burned out they would take charge and clean things up.

    Now, it more and more looks like the only way out is to head to the China model. Which is OK with many of the "serious" folks but not what the "regular" supports want. They might THINK they want it but have no idea where the end point is.

    In the US they decry China's government and policies but don't get that they are supporting folks who will give them that exact government down the road if they get into and hold power for a while.

    Tiger by the tail indeed.

    1329:

    (Stack trace etc.) It's theoretically possible, yes, but only when the exception is first caught. There was a conflict between the 'exceptions are a state' and 'exceptions are simply pure data (e.g. an error number)' models so, in typical C/C++ fashion, they standardised both without distinguishing them. Yes, some of us opposed that.

    1330:

    NOBODY knows what templates mean, as perpetrated by SC22WG21, and that statement is based on certain information. They aren't a help to you, anyway.

    There are associative arrays in the library, or it is easy to write your own class.

    1331:

    Tiger by the tail indeed.

    Trump is now being thrashed by his hard core pod caster supports for saying people should get the vaccine. Hard.

    Do a search in the dailybeast for trump and vaccine and you can get a feel for it.

    1332:

    I took a bit but to figure out where it's published but I found it. I'm going to read it, if only for the reason that I want to study more examples of, um, amateur novel writing to finish my own long-abandoned project. Or at least some of the many of it's parts.

    1333:

    if you decide to read my book, I'd really like to hear your comments on it.

    A link would be useful, as searching for "11,000 years novel" produces things like a story about collapsing author incomes but nothing even vaguely SF-ish.

    Ideally either paper copy or epub not Kindle (as I don't have Kindle).

    1334:

    Using "whitroth as the first search term helps :-)

    https://ringoffirepress.com/shop/11000-years/

    1335:

    amateur novel writing

    Hey dude, don't be unkind.

    1336:

    Pigeon @ 1323:

    It seems almost too obvious to be worth pointing out that "dissent" can cover things as disparate as staggering drunkenly up the street chanting "Bozo is a wanker, Bozo is a wanker, na na na na, na na na na", and scaling St Stephen's Tower with a sniper rifle to pick off MPs as they go in and out. Neither "allow all" nor "deny all" seem appropriate to both, so there has to be some kind of governmental decision as to what counts as tolerable dissent and what doesn't.

    I'll grant the existence of grey areas. The Americans call this kind of thing "expressive acts". Exactly which expressive acts should be allowed is certainly a matter for government to decide, as you say; a current UK example is gluing oneself to a road, and over in the US the Proud Boys have just had a claim that the 6th of Jan riot was an expressive act denied by a court. However simply voicing political opinions (excluding calls for violence) should not be banned under any circumstances. I'm not aware that Memorial has ever done anything more than that.

    You seem to be saying (if I understand you correctly) that the freedom to speak about politics can be limited by government because it depends on the culture and the country and freedom of speech doesn't work for everyone. If so then you are well on the way to justifying any kind of political repression on the grounds that it seems to work for them. I believe that there are such things as human rights, that freedom of speech is one of them, and that all governments should respect it, including Russia.

    sleepingroutine @ 1326:

    powerful people has been silencing criticism to liberal order for decades and every time somebody voiced a consistent opposition there has been the same display every time ...

    What is this "liberal order" of which you speak, and who is opposing it? We are talking about freedom of speech here. Is that part of the "liberal order", or are you talking about something else?

    Memorial has been saying things that irritated the Russian government. The Russian government has reacted by shutting them down hard. This is not an isolated incident; they have done the same to independent newspapers and opposition political parties. Quite how the Russian government is the victim here I fail to see.

    There's absolutely nothing contradicting.

    You said "They may keep their records hidden from public [which is a crime] but they can't hide them from the state. In fact, they never tried to, they even call themselves "international" and regularly brag about heir wide connections and venerated status outside country.

    So on one hand you claim that their crime was to have secrets, and then you say that they never tried to hide stuff and in fact they bragged about it, and this bragging is also somehow wrong.

    So which is it? Are they guilty of secrecy or speech?

    Also, why is it so wrong to be respected internationally?

    In short, please tell us what exactly has Memorial done wrong? (I hope I'm not about to break the rule on sealioning here).

    1337:

    As I read it, for accepting foreign money and potentially influence. Israel has banned several human rights groups on the same grounds, but that doesn't get the same coverage.

    1338:

    what can be done about this? It's criminal damage & intimidation, at the least. Is it worth jailing the lot for a week?

    No - because you end up proving their point - that the government is evil.

    You need to examine the evidence and jail those who did the worst stuff - ie. you can do the proverbial "prove beyond a reasonable doubt" that they did actual criminal activity.

    But it is worth remembering that many/most in those crowds didn't show up with the intent to do what eventually happened. Ultimately the goal has be to to go after the ringleaders of these events, those who take advantage of these gatherings to lead many of the protestors into doing things they normally wouldn't.

    1339:

    humph Having sold a short novelette and a short story to a SFWA-qualified market, and had the novel published by a small press, I'm at least semi-professional. Not writing fan-fic.

    I didn't want to post the link here - it is Charlie's blog, and his new novel's about to drop, and it seemed rude.

    1340:

    Just like the US Capital mess on Jan 6. No one is facing charges for being on the steps. Video of someone doing something more is resulting in charges.

    And like you or others said, ramming a pole through a window is NOT acceptable protest speech.

    1341:

    DavidL

    "In the US they decry China's government and policies but don't get that they are supporting folks who will give them that exact government down the road if they get into and hold power for a while."

    I think the level of competence assumed for these people is much too high. For all their faults, the leadership of China have been running a country of over a billion people and the country is on the upswing (at least for now).

    In contrast, the GQP types are trying very hard to take over a country that is very possibly past its peak, and they show no signs of the competence necessary to successfully run a corner store, nevermind a country. Their MO has been to pillage and much as possible while enjoying the momentum and benefits of being in a massively powerful country. When that starts to crumble due to their looting the top .01% will simply leave.

    1342:

    You seem to be saying (if I understand you correctly) that the freedom to speak about politics can be limited by government because it depends on the culture and the country and freedom of speech doesn't work for everyone.

    That is entirely correct, because it is a standard feature of modern forms of free speech where you are allowed to speak freely as long as it confirms with current narrative of the free speech. It's just harder to see from within the system, I guess.

    What is this "liberal order" of which you speak, and who is opposing it? We are talking about freedom of speech here. Is that part of the "liberal order", or are you talking about something else?

    I think the term "liberal order" has established itself very firmly and if you have missed this page in modern history, it is never too late to read about it in full. Just to remind you, the Memorial has been claiming very often that it is a part of such respectable, powerful and omnipresent organization.

    https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/international-organization/article/challenges-to-the-liberal-order-reflections-on-international-organization/2FE0E2621F702D1DD02929526703AED3

    Memorial has been saying things that irritated the Russian government.

    You apparently missed entirely everything related to their activity since it has been supported by the government itself through many years of it's existence and had very powerful friends that helped them stay above law until recent times. What it has been irritating is not the government but civil society of the country and historical memory of the people, which it has been ignoring and exploiting for their own goals.

    https://www.nytimes.com/2017/10/30/world/europe/russia-soviet-repression-monument.html

    I'm not going to claim that our government is completely innocent and not corrupt, but it has never been a reason to allow somebody else to stay above the law, or get rid of it, or replace it with aforementioned Liberal Order.

    It appears that any attempts to appeal to primary function of such organizations lead to nothing. More and more people understood what is an actual purpose of such organization, and finally the government has decided that it bears no benefit to follow the trend. There's nothing unexpected in this course of action (unless somebody expected the government to be destroyed completely).

    So on one hand you claim that their crime was to have secrets, and then you say that they never tried to hide stuff and in fact they bragged about it, and this bragging is also somehow wrong.

    A crime of lying to public, which is different from the crime of lying to government. A crime of using corruption and intimidation for suppression of lawful activity. A crime of using outside sponsorship to influence democratic process within a country. This, of course, is barely scratching a surface of scale and reach of such activities in my country.

    https://www.perild.com/2021/12/27/veterans-of-russia-ask-the-prosecutor-generals-office-and-the-investigative-committee-to-bring-memorial-to-justice-for-the-rehabilitation-of-nazism/

    1343:

    Having sold a short novelette and a short story to a SFWA-qualified market, and had the novel published by a small press, I'm at least semi-professional.

    I'm really sorry if I'm confusing the terms here or implying that your writing is amateur, I was speaking about general idea. I've heard from some other people who used pandemic isolation to concentrate on writing, too. It's just I am not professional to see the difference at glance. But I am glad to hear that your writing carer is even greater than I though it was.

    1344:

    Their MO has been to pillage and much as possible while enjoying the momentum and benefits of being in a massively powerful country. When that starts to crumble due to their looting the top .01% will simply leave.

    So they leave. So the US is badly run. That doesn't change that we might wind up with the ass hole R's in charge of enough states to keep all the power and make sure the decks are stacked to keep it.

    And passing more and more "act and look like us or you're not really a citizen with rights".

    And marginalizing the poor to the extent they can (Trump like) keep looting things until it totally falls apart.

    To me this is a dark future with no easy way out.

    It will not last forever. But to get from there to somewhere better will likely be very very painful.

    1345:

    “However simply voicing political opinions (excluding calls for violence) should not be banned under any circumstances.” If I understand correctly in Germany it’s illegal to say “The Nazis were right.” I’m in no hurry to persuade them to change that policy, and as an American I’m in no position to question the quality of any other nation’s democracy.

    In general it’s well known that there are paradoxes, difficulties, and dangers related to tolerating the intolerant, with no known general solutions.

    1346:

    RvdH
    it’s well known that there are paradoxes, difficulties, and dangers related to tolerating the intolerant, with no known general solutions.
    What about tolerating the Criminally Stupid, who recklessly endanger other people's lives?

    I'm obviously thinking of the Piers Corbyn crowd, but also others who wantonly spread C-19 about ...
    ? ? ? ? ?

    1347:

    For those of us who’ve never heard of “Memorial” until today, what are a couple of examples of things they’ve done that you don’t like? (Outside links to English language sources please, or French if written for school children.)

    1348:

    I wish the US AG, or the Surgeon General (or that I had "standing" to sue) Faux "News" to shut them down - Newscorp has mandates that all employees be vaccinated (like F*er Carlson), and they keep pushing the antivax line.

    That's deliberate reckless endangerment.

    1349:

    How do you run a democracy when a significant fraction of voters think Trump won the last election, and significant fraction of the politically active believe Hillary Clinton drinks the blood of babies to stay young?

    1350:

    Re: '... since 2020...'

    Glad to see you back and that you've made it okay (?) through a COVID bout! With all the to-and-fro comments above, you'll probably be soon caught up with the folks here.

    One comment -

    It's not the FDA approval that's lagging or important from Russia's point of view as per the December 5 2021 article below, it's the WHO's. Mind you the WHO scientists are basically saying the same thing as the FDA scientists: show us the clinical trials (raw) data! Also - despite the favorable Lancet reference, data from other countries where the vaccine has been rolled out is not sufficient for a number of reasons, i.e., sampling skews/glitches, sample sizes and composition, side-effects and mortality reporting, etc.

    https://www.rferl.org/a/russia-who-approval-sputnik/31594929.html

    'But a study published in the British medical journal The Lancet in February showed the Sputnik V was 91.6 percent effective in preventing people from becoming severely ill with COVID-19.

    The shot has been given the green light in more than 70 countries, and Putin said data from those countries indicated that the vaccine is safe.'

    That said - there are also some econo-political issues screwing things up.

    BTW - I've been checking the Johns Hopkins Covid tracking site regularly and it looks as though Russia and Ukraine have very similar patterns. Russia's mortality is comparatively worse but both have mortality rates about 2.5 to 3.0 times higher than EU/NA countries. Also - the infection rates for both don't look as though they're really dropping. Based on the rather low and late uptake of vaccines in Russia, I'm wondering whether Russia is actually now battling two very well established variants - Delta and Omicron. The Delta is deadlier overall, but the Omicron appears to be as deadly among the unvaxxed.

    Another question for you:

    How has the Omicron variant affected the medical practitioners in Russia? Over here (in the USA/Canada) we're seeing very high infection rates among that group - so high in fact that the CDC and the Canadian equivalent are saying that double-vaxxed and boosted infected medical workers will continue working in hospitals and seeing patients.

    1351:

    (Stack trace etc.) It's theoretically possible, yes, but only when the exception is first caught.

    My understanding is that when caught I can only get a stack trace to the point I'm at, not to the source of the exception. Viz, I can say "exception 'file not found' caught at line 123 of MozCode.cpp" but I can't get "thrown at /usr/include/c++/11/x86_64-redhat-linux/bits/c++config.h:2145" with a list of intermediate calls (real file, some random C++ library header used by iostream), or any of the context that something like gdb can show if it is in control.

    That stuff is what the Delphi tool gives me. And it can be really important when you get dependency stacks - AWS calls cURL calls OpenSSL and one of those decides that exceptions are appropriate. So instead of an error code that translates to "unsupported SSL version" that has percolated up from OpenSSL, I get "exception: connection failed".

    1352:

    I believe that there are such things as human rights, that freedom of speech is one of them, and that all governments should respect it, including Russia.

    But whose definition of "freedom of speech"? If we use the USA-for-citizens definition but apply it universally, Putin should have just been able to outright give Trump a billion dollars as a campaign contribution, rather than having to make like Murdoch and buy media outlets to spread his message in a more complicated and tedious way.

    But not even the US recognises that level of "freedom of speech". Why not, and what should we do to fix it? Is invading the USA and changing their broken constitution* at gunpoint appropriate, or should we just nuke the site from orbit?

    (* clearly it's broken, since it doesn't meet one possible definition of "freedom of speech")

    I exaggerate for effect, to reveal the definitional question. The USA sometimes regards money as speech, other times not, and imposes restrictions on it either way.

    In Australia, for example, we don't have a right to free speech, at best we have a limited, implied right of political communication but that is uncertain in extent. It is definitely subject to our libel laws, which are both strong and odd, but not strong enough because there are ongoing moves to strengthen them - right now there's a move to make all internet publishers track the legal identity of anyone who posts on their sites so that they can be sued if they say something that "offends or insults" anyone inclined to sue them.

    That's not free speech, it's bloody expensive speech, but at the same time Australia would claim to have some form of "freedumb and domacrazy"... do we?

    1353:

    Israel has banned several human rights groups on the same grounds, but that doesn't get the same coverage.

    Well no, because pointing that out is antisemitic, and we all know that antisemitism is bad.

    Australia takes a subtly different approach, drawing a harsh but wavy line between "genuine charitable purposes" and "political activism", with the latter groups being subject to both more intrusive regulation and money given to them not counting as tax deductible donations. Interestingly donations to actual political parties are tax deductible, at least the first $1500/year. But not to "political campaign groups" etc. That's "free as in speech" not "free as in beer" freedom.

    We also have anti-tourist laws that have been used to arrest, detain, and deport "political activists" on the basis that what they say could incite violence, because of course "political violence" is one form of tourism and that can never be permitted. Except when explicitly supported by our government, in our name, of course, in which case it's a wonderful and joyous expression of the inherent dignity of humanity, the free expression of political opinion via the medium of indiscriminate slaughter, and a necessary step towards a free and democratic society like the one that Australia... is quietly moving away from. Ahem. Never mind, nothing to see here, get in the van.

    1354:

    https://principia-scientific.com/the-5-basic-laws-of-human-stupidity-according-to-cipolla/

    The above is an interesting read, another reminder that human stupidity has been around for a long time and we still don't have a reliable answer to it.

    1355:

    Re: '... whose definition of "freedom of speech"?'

    Okay - but I thought every jurisdiction already had something along the lines of: free speech does not mean that you can shout 'Fire!' in the movie theater and cause a stampede. So there is a recognition that 'free speech' has limits and that 'unregulated speech' can cause harms -- bodily and other (financial). Maybe the problem is inconsistent enforcement therefore eventual social acceptance of 'stupidity' as normal/permissible.

    Would be interesting to see 'enforcement-acceptance' as an additional dimension in 'the 5 basic laws of human stupidity'. (Nice article btw - thanks!)

    1356:

    Yeah, but often people forget that their local version of "freedom of speech", "democracy" or whatever isn't shared by people outside their local area, and even within it is often contested.

    We get protesters in Oz waving MAGA flags and ranting about their rights under the constitution... of the USA. There is much amusement to be gained by observing that in Australia our "second amendment rights" are for the federal government to take over debts incurred by state ones. While I'm glad that so many people are out in the streets defending that right, I'm also somewhat confused because I did not realise it was contested by anyone.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitution_of_Australia#Historical_referendums_and_amendments

    1357:

    Enforcement/Acceptance of laws or ignored laws is an interesting concept that reminds me of a couple of real life examples.

  • Marijuana. It is now legal in Canada, but has been de facto legal for a long time, with some important exceptions.(x) By 'legal' in this case I mean that most people I knew who smoked marijuana did so openly, as much as anyone who smoked cigarettes. At least in some provinces the police had been directed to ignore minor possession and focus their efforts on crimes that harmed others. So the change to the law merely followed the common practice.

  • Open consumption of alcohol. As a relic of Canadian Prohibition, most provinces have strict laws about where and when alcohol could be consumed. Here in BC it was illegal to consume alcohol at a public park, or at a beach. In practice I've been taking cans or beer or a bottle of wine to barbeques on the beach as long as I can remember, and any interactions with police were innocuous. Every other adult I know has been doing much the same thing forever, and the police have ignored it entirely unless someone is visibly drunk or belligerent. The pandemic, for some reason, caused the government of BC to strike several of those silly laws off the books. In practice they were ignored and not respected. (x)

  • (x) The exceptions include, as always, young people misbehaving, indigenous and other people of colour, or people who were caught doing something else as well. In those cases the law continued to be enforced. The arbitrary nature of such enforcement undermined the credibility of the police and the legal system, and the victims of that enforcement had still more reasons to distrust the legal system.

    1358:

    In contrast, the GQP types are trying very hard to take over a country that is very possibly past its peak, and they show no signs of the competence necessary to successfully run a corner store, nevermind a country. Their MO has been to pillage and much as possible while enjoying the momentum and benefits of being in a massively powerful country. When that starts to crumble due to their looting the top .01% will simply leave.

    The decline of the US started with Reagon, and his enacting policies that various groups had been pushing for the decade or so previous.

    In essence, start the looting of the US and damn the consequences - because as you say the rich can simply move.

    The current bunch are simply being more obvious about looting the system, simply because they were never successful or rich enough to take advantage of what the GOP was providing.

    1359:

    The concept of shouting "fire" isn't static across countries either.

    The idea of democracy is that it allows for a violence free transition of power. In that context free speech demanding a "change" of government is fine (as long as its not a real change of course)

    Now put yourself in the position of the leaders of a country that's large, both by population and geography. Resources are being distributed as well as possible by a central planning committee, avoiding hoarding or artificial scarcity, and for the last 5 decades you've avoided the semi regular famines that used to kill millions. There hasn't been armed conflict with your borders for 5 decades that used to kill millions every 10-20 years. The lived experience of famine and civil war has mostly passed out of first hand memory.

    Now protesters, fuelled by the completely unrealistic images of foreign countries' way of life that are put out by their media, are calling for a return to the bad old days without the central committee, and a breakup of the country into warring states under the banner of "personal freedom". Bring back the ability to manipulate the market for profit, rent seeking, manufactured shortages and scalping, and the freedom to starve to death of you're not one of the lucky 0.1%

    If they succeed, at least 10 million people will die, possibly much more.

    Does that count as shouting "fire in a crowded theater"? Should it be protected speech?

    1360:

    How do you run a democracy when a significant fraction of voters think Trump won the last election, and significant fraction of the politically active believe Hillary Clinton drinks the blood of babies to stay young?

    1) you end the current loopholes that allow "entertainment" programming claim to be News - if they report it they have to be able to prove they believe it to be accurate.

    That would not only remove Fox, but much of the current iteration of CNN, with a potential side benefit of reputable news organizations not having to fight with entertainment for readership/viewership and the resulting ad revenue.

    2) stop treating education as a daycare. Properly fund it and treat teachers with respect. Find a way to deal with the disruptive students. You can only have a functional democracy when the electorate has a minimum level of education.

    1361:

    What about tolerating the Criminally Stupid, who recklessly endanger other people's lives?

    I'm obviously thinking of the Piers Corbyn crowd, but also others who wantonly spread C-19 about ...

    At the end of the day living in a free and democratic society means we have to put up with the stupidity of some.

    And some days it easier than others.

    Don't get me wrong, I think the nonsense these people are peddling is harming people, and likely even killing people (and sadly not just those who die from Covid because they are too stupid to get vaccinated or wear a mask, but those who lose out on healthcare currently and in the future from the fallout of all of this).

    But attempting to make what they are doing is a very dangerous road to take - because any laws are likely to be abused and used for other valid things - like say opposing Boris or Trump.

    The key point is at the end of the day those people peacefully protesting (as I noted in a previous post, by all means prosecute those doing violence) are using their democratic right in a free society.

    The ultimate solution is to curb the people behind the scenes who are manipulating many of those people with deliberate lies and benefiting financially. Solve the misinformation sources, and those people go away.

    1362:

    oh, and

    3) go after the social media platforms that are profiting off the spreading of false information.

    1363:

    On the resurrection of dead threads...

    Books like that... ok, did you ever read "Man's Rise To Civilization"? https://www.amazon.com/Civilization-Indians-America-Primeval-Industrial/dp/0525152695

    Now I've tried to read it...and I guess I'm too woke and light weight to keep from bouncing off it in incredulity every few pages. Although I realize that it was written in 1968, not 2021, it hasn't aged very well at all. More to the point, when one is talking about Indians and leaves off California, aside from a two-sentence lament about Ishi? Good. Grief. Alfred Kroeber's doorstop Handbook of the Indians of California was first published in 1925 and is still in print, so anyone talking about Indians and ignoring that tome is not doing their research (and I've actually read it, cover to cover). Heck, even Graeber and Co. at least referenced that.

    Speaking of Graeber, I'm still plowing through Dawn of Everything, and I think my original assessment of it holds. It's quite good for showing that many of our standard tropes about the development of culture civilization were molded out of bovine excrement and other found materials for various and often imperialistic purposes. What they propose to replace the bullshit with has some holes and fertilizer spackling of its own, but still. If you're looking for a book to help with SFF worldbuilding, it's better than most. If you're looking for The Truth, go live in a big jar and use a lantern to see if anyone's honest.*

    They also pointed me at a Kroeber book I'd never heard of before, 1944's Configurations of Culture Growth, that I requested from the library. This book was Krober's attempt to determine whether there were any patterns or laws in how cultures grow. His conclusion (per Graeber) is "Kroeber examined the relation of the arts, philosophy, science and population across human history and found no evidence for any consistent pattern...Kroeber began his grand conclusion as follows: ‘I see no evidence of any true law in the phenomena dealt with; nothing cyclical, regularly repetitive, or necessary. There is nothing to show either that every culture must develop patterns within which a florescence of quality is possible, or that, having once so flowered, it must wither without chance of revival.’ Neither did he find any necessary relation between cultural achievement and systems of government."

    While I don't think Alfred Kroeber is infallible, I do have great respect for both him and his daughter, Ursula Kroeber Le Guin. And I figure that anyone who's spent decades looking for patterns and is brave enough to spend 800-odd pages saying there aren't any deserves a read.

    *per Diogenes.

    1364:

    The ultimate solution is to curb the people behind the scenes who are manipulating many of those people with deliberate lies and benefiting financially.

    I suggest many of them have money already and DGAF about profit so much as they care about power, mostly in the form of keeping what's theirs.

    https://blog.franklinveaux.com/2021/12/how-facebook-convinced-me-democracy-is-in-trouble/

    So why would Facebook, that giant creepy Hydra in the cloud, show me alt-right ads when it knows I’m a lefty Portlander?

    Because the advertisers know I won’t buy their products. They don’t care. That isn’t why they’re spending tens of millions of dollars on Facebook advertising.

    ...

    these ads are a propaganda effort. The purpose is to put right-wing slogans and ideas in front of as many eyeballs as possible. They’re advertising ideas ... A great identity brand for a certain kind of person? Oh yeah. And this brand is everywhere.

    1365:

    gasdive
    Ru? - or - USA?
    Hard to tell, actually.

    mdive
    I never said it was going to be easy ( Or even possible? )

    1366:

    For how to deal with exceptions in C++, there is a website Exception-Safe Coding in C++. It has videos and handouts. This is the best place to start.

    David Abrahams wrote a paper, Exception-Safety in Generic Components. It is a good explanation of how the current best practices in exception safety evolved.

    Bjarne Stroustrup's paper Exception Safety: Concepts and Techniques is a comprehensive and detailed discussion of exception-safety in C++.

    Converting code to use exceptions and RAII is a joyful experience. The boilerplate code in the destructors goes away, until you can get rid of most of your destructors completely. If the destructors weren't there in the first place, in that case you're watching the bugs and memory leaks go away. It still feels good.

    Java and C# have exceptions but don't have best practices for exception-safe coding like C++. Your best bet, if you have to write code in Java or C# and it has to be rl=eliable, is to figure out how to write it in C++ and translate the code.

    1367:

    We get protesters in Oz waving MAGA flags and ranting about their rights under the constitution... of the USA. There is much amusement to be gained by observing that in Australia our "second amendment rights" are for the federal government to take over debts incurred by state ones.

    Back in the early 80s when I was visiting Toronto multiple times a year for business, the locals told me about how many inebriated folks would get arrested by the local police. Then start demanding their rights. All based on the TVs shows from the US. Mostly the cops just laughed and/or shook their heads as they hauled them off to jail.

    1368:

    1357 bullet 2 - Yes, I've argued for some years that any law that is ignored by at least a significant non-vocal minority is (or may be) a bad law.

    1360 - I'd suggest it should also remove large numbers of the " 'human interest' pieces masquerading as news" that organisations like the English Broadcasting Corporation put out.

    1367 - So I'm guessing this means the arrestees hadn't noticed they were in a different nation, with different code of laws?

    1369:

    go after the social media platforms that are profiting off the spreading of false information.

    Now all we need is a perfect, non biased way to determine if something is true or false. And to define what exactly is an "opinion".

    And a way to deal with things that ARE true but go against what everyone thinks is true.

    Einstein in 1905? And so many more.

    Sounds like we need a AI overlord. Or a new God.

    1370:

    https://principia-scientific.com/the-5-basic-laws-of-human-stupidity-according-to-cipolla/

    Nice read. During it I kept thinking of Bill "Here's Your Sign" Engvall. A comedian who may or may not be known outside of the US.

    1371:

    Toronto, like most Canadian town/cities near the US border would get most US broadcast TV and thus were big watchers/fan of shows like the US based "Law and Order".[1]

    When folks are arrested on US TV shows they cops don't put in any footnotes about which country this is in.

    This just shows how many folks in Canada (AND the US) don't pay attention in their civics classes growing up. Or pay much attention to such things in general.

    See the other references to "stupid" people.

    [1] Cable and satellite TV options may have changed this dynamic somewhat. But before those this entire issue was of consternation of the civic "elites" in Canada. And with the media companies where 1/3 or more of their audience preferred shows from the US many times. I know now that a lot of countres have rules about the amount of local content that must exist if you want to operate in their country. Then you get into "illegal" sat dishes and VPNing to pretend to be in another country to watch what you want. Around here there's a non trivial number of people who are constantly engaged in "whack-a-mole" VPN options to be able to watch UK content. I'm sure there are others for other countries/areas but I don't mix with them so much these days. Just now most people have the same circles of friends they had 3 years ago.

    1372:

    I like CSI, Laura Norder ;-) and NCIS, but I do realise that they're not set in the UK.

    1373:

    I said "theoretically possible". The rules for stack unwinding are such that an implementation could fairly easily provide that information. But that doesn't mean that any do.

    1374:

    More particularly, "free speech" often applies only to speech that TPTB regards as favourable or no more than a nuisance. The UK does things more subtly and indirectly (one could say deceitfully), but we have a significant amount of censorship. Whether more or less than Russia, I can't say.

    1375:

    I tend to feel that the vast majority of the commenters here do not act stupid very often in their lives.

    If course I've seen nearly every one here make such a comment at one time or another.

    Why UK and Canadian accents do have some overlap, Merican speakers can (or did when I was there in the 80s) flow around Toronto and fit in. Most of the locals seem to feel you're from either south of the border or the Canadian west. (Brooklyn and Boston accents excepted.) But TV shows from the US fit in easier than most anywhere else in the world.

    But again, I didn't say these arrestees were acting or living in a "smart" manner. And being drunk was not helping them at all.

    1376:

    With the Ghislaine Maxwell conviction in the US I wonder how some of the related (not by blood) characters in the UK will be covered in the "news".

    I'll not name names as my understanding of UK laws on such matters is a dark but not favorable hole to me and may problematic to Charlie.

    1377:

    I've been checking the Johns Hopkins Covid tracking site regularly and it looks as though Russia and Ukraine have very similar patterns.

    A major source for knowledge here is Yandex Datalens portal on COVID which mirrors most reliable sources for daily rates of everything happening. I don't think there are any more similarities with Ukraine than within usual confidence, for the same region at least.

    https://yandex.ru/covid19/stat

    The shot has been given the green light in more than 70 countries, and Putin said data from those countries indicated that the vaccine is safe.'

    Yes, the international recognition grows steadily and the scientists are also working on further development of new vaccines (boosters and what they call nasal variants) but there are still some major obstacles for approval and/or exchange of experience. To hell with safety, they don't even recognize it as immunity proof yet. On the contrary, Russia does recognize many other vaccines as a proof but blocks usage until there will be fair competition (I know of some people who has been vaccinated with Moderna or Phizer abroad, to travel across borders). Not to mention that regulation of personal data of the vaccinated has been avoided/abandoned ever since the beginning of pandemic.

    Based on the rather low and late uptake of vaccines in Russia, I'm wondering whether Russia is actually now battling two very well established variants - Delta and Omicron.>/i>

    Apparently not, the corvid rates are falling down pretty consistently during last two months or so. Which is a major point of concern of me because it means that within next several months the Omicron variant will be especially challenging. I expect major crackdown if it goes especially hard.

    https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/russia-shelves-plan-qr-vaccination-proof-planes-trains-2021-12-13/

    How has the Omicron variant affected the medical practitioners in Russia? Over here (in the USA/Canada) we're seeing very high infection rates among that group - so high in fact that the CDC and the Canadian equivalent are saying that double-vaxxed and boosted infected medical workers will continue working in hospitals and seeing patients.

    It hasn't yet, for all I understand, Delta is still prevalent and the government says it's keeping the situation under control, of course. "It's too early to judge assuredly" and "It seems that our vaccine is sufficiently effective" is their usual response. We have about 10 days of holidays ahead of us where it is expected to help with lowering transmission rates significantly.

    Besides that, there has been a major flu epidemic too, and I've been recovering from it recently. Judging by how it went I really, really hope Omicron isn't as easily transmissible.

    1378:

    sleepingroutine @ 1342:

    That is entirely correct, because it is a standard feature of modern forms of free speech where you are allowed to speak freely as long as it confirms with current narrative of the free speech. It's just harder to see from within the system, I guess.

    I'm still trying to parse this. I'm aware of the Overton Window, but that is a matter of public opinion, not Government intervention. Lawmakers follow the Window, they don't move it. Are you talking about the OW? Or something else?

    Whenever the executive wing of a government starts declaring that certain topics are not up for discussion and backing any attempt to raise them with the power of the law, you can be certain that the government will use this power to suppress dissent. This isn't to do with the government restricting stuff outside the current Overton Window, its just the executive protecting itself against speech it perceives as dangerous to it.

    (I'm tempted to go off on a comparative law jag here and discuss all the ways in which other countries deal with these trade-offs. However that would not be useful.)

    I think the term "liberal order" has established itself very firmly ...

    Its not that I'm unaware of the term, its just that its the kind of phrase that different people use in different ways, so its always a good idea to establish exactly what is meant before going further. Thanks for the link; that clears it up.

    Just to remind you, the Memorial has been claiming very often that it is a part of such respectable, powerful and omnipresent organization.

    But the Liberal International Order (LIO) is not an "organisation" in the traditional sense of the word, i.e. it has no legal existence, HQ, staff, a budget etc. If I understand the article you reference, the LIO is actually a consensus across the rich, powerful, democratic nations about how things ought to be run. The article describes the LIO consensus as a "liberal" (in the 19th century meaning) overlay on top of the Westphalian system of sovereign independent states. It sums up the tenets of the LIO as:

    • Liberal democratic polity and economy.

    • Free movement of goods and capital.

    • Human equality; freedom, rule of law and human rights.

    • Multilateralism (including pooling and delegating authority).

    • Collective security.

    What parts of this do you think are incorrect?

    Given the above, what is wrong with Memorial publicly agreeing with the LIO consensus?

    [On Memorial] A crime of lying to public, which is different from the crime of lying to government. A crime of using corruption and intimidation for suppression of lawful activity. A crime of using outside sponsorship to influence democratic process within a country. This, of course, is barely scratching a surface of scale and reach of such activities in my country.

    Do you have any evidence for any of this? Your link doesn't provide it: it seems that Memorial published a list of almost 1.5 million names of "victims of political terror". According to your linked article the Veterans of Russia subsequently found that a mere 19 of these were actually Nazi war criminals. Memorial apologised for the error and removed those names from its list. How is this a crime?

    From what I have read, Memorial, along with a long list of other organisations and people, have been designated as "Foreign Agents". This obliges them to include a legal mea-culpa whenever saying anything in public plus a bunch of other onerous conditions. The only criteria for this are 1: political speech and 2: receiving foreign money.

    So if the Russian government wants to label someone who speaks about politics as a "Foreign Agent" it merely has to send them some money via a cut-out in a foreign country, and hey presto, they are now legally a Foreign Agent.

    Anyone who knows who you are could easily do the same to you; you speak about politics here, and it would be easy to send you some money from a foreign bank account. How does that make you feel? Do you feel vulnerable? Or are you happy that you are safe because you don't post anything that your government doesn't like?

    1379:

    If they succeed, at least 10 million people will die, possibly much more.

    Does that count as shouting "fire in a crowded theater"? Should it be protected speech?

    It turns out, even though World War has major historical importance in nation, there's really no need to dig that far to actually touch upon nerve of many people. In fact, it comes along as a borderline comedy, really. Everybody understood what has been said. Everybody half-expected there will be an uproar, a scandal, maybe a repression, but nothing really happened, they all forgot it after a week.

    https://thebell.io/en/talk-of-north-caucasus-secession-angers-putin/ https://english.pravda.ru/news/russia/149843-putin_sokurov/

    1380:

    I can assure you that governments DO move the Overton window, usually indirectly but sometimes directly. The anti-communist witch hunts of the 1950s (and wider) in the USA and to some extent the UK are one example. Recently, the UK government has made it illegal to support the Palestinians' democratically elected government.

    1381:

    We have about 10 days of holidays ahead of us where it is expected to help with lowering transmission rates significantly.

    Really? In the US/Canada and I suspect Europe the Christmas / New Year's holidays tend to create spreading events. I would also suspect the same in south of the US border all the way down.

    1382:

    Are you talking about the OW? Or something else?

    No, it is you who are talking about OW. I'm talking about static image. OW is about dynamic image which cannot be considered without static balance of opinions.

    Whenever the executive wing of a government starts declaring that certain topics are not up for discussion and backing any attempt to raise them with the power of the law, you can be certain that the government will use this power to suppress dissent.

    The dissent cannot form in the first place if there are no forbidden topic to discuss. As cannot any consent form unless there are agreed terms and conditions. Whether to support consent and/or suppress dissent, every government makes decision individually for each case. But most governments agree that some sort of action is required.

    What parts of this do you think are incorrect?

    They are all correct, and furthermore, as an "Order", seems like it implies that it has no limits and is free to act on it's own volition to further it's sacred goal. Well, I'm pretty sure it isn't as strict as religious order just yet but it verges upon it regularly.

    Do you have any evidence for any of this? Your link doesn't provide it: it seems that Memorial published a list of almost 1.5 million names of "victims of political terror".

    Besides the fact that NOBODY, NOWHERE has been incriminating them following their primary declared goals of keeping the memory and "defending rights", I would like to note that publishing names of people, their criminal records, their accusers and informants, their prosecutors and other SENSITIVE topics is by all means HUGE and INSURMOUNTABLE amount of responsibility. Memorial, it's members, and it's supporters, simply ignore all of such responsibility to the last drop of it. The government, on behest of which such actions can be partaken, cannot ignore it under any circumstances.

    A quote from FT article, if you will:

    Memorial has also combed through archives to create searchable databases of the prison and death records of the Soviet era’s many millions of victims — but also of the names of more than 41,000 perpetrators from the NKVD secret police.

    So yeah, a rhetorical question, what could possibly such list achieve, especially when the people on their duty of protecting the country are called "perpetrators"? What "human rights", "memories" and "history" can such people receive, not to talk about their descendants? What is the goal of calling every criminal in the system as "a victim" regardless of their record? Etc, etc.

    Memorial apologised for the error and removed those names from its list.

    It did not (and it never does). At least I haven't seen any indication of it anywhere. What it said is "there was an error and it was corrected", nothing more. But we all know that it wasn't an error.

    So if the Russian government wants to label someone who speaks about politics as a "Foreign Agent" it merely has to send them some money via a cut-out in a foreign country, and hey presto, they are now legally a Foreign Agent.

    Speaking about politics and having a political influence is rather different activity. Everybody speaks about politics and many people receive the money from abroad in sufficient quantities, but it is natural that government has no resources nor goals to get every person under criteria behind the bars. The goal is to limit foreign influence to internal politics and defend constitutional right of sovereignty and it will be achieved through that law and through many others.

    1383:

    As ever I fail to see why anyone engages with sleepingroutine, I mean "poor secret police, evil prisoners"?

    1384:

    At least in some provinces the police had been directed to ignore minor possession and focus their efforts on crimes that harmed others.

    Except, as you noted, if you weren't white, in which case it was enforcement as usual… and those convictions for possession followed you around limiting your life while white potheads moved on to university and decent jobs.

    1385:

    Now all we need is a perfect, non biased way to determine if something is true or false. And to define what exactly is an "opinion".

    Certainly, like anything human, there are going to be grey areas that need to be ignored.

    But there are a lot of things that are false - like claims Biden lost, Gates is putting tracking chips in vaccines, etc - that can be clamped down on (in theory) and would make a significant difference in the functioning of society.

    1386:

    stop treating education as a daycare. Properly fund it and treat teachers with respect. Find a way to deal with the disruptive students. You can only have a functional democracy when the electorate has a minimum level of education.

    The daycare aspect is what is most important, to most people including parents. Second most important is extra-curricular activities like sports, possibly tied with after-school clubs (ie. extended daycare).

    Actual quality of education is a much lower priority — as witnessed by the large number of parents obsessed with how their kids deserve high marks for doing nothing.

    I love the idea of properly funding it, but having seen how money gets diverted before it reaches the classroom you need more than just money — and yet too many centralized controls stifle the system. It's a tough problem.

    Any solution for disruptive students is going to require more than just in-school elements. Most disruptive kids have either horrible home situations, or serious psychological issues, or both.

    (I was at a small family gathering* earlier this week where the topics of conversation included how unaffordable Toronto housing has become, and how horrible it was that homeless people had set up tent cities in parks — and no one else noticed the connection between the two problems.)

    *Boosted, socially-distanced, masked, etc.

    1387:

    sleepingroutine @ 1382:

    No, it is you who are talking about OW. I'm talking about static image. OW is about dynamic image which cannot be considered without static balance of opinions.

    OK, what is this "static" image / balance of opinions? I haven't heard about that.

    The dissent cannot form in the first place if there are no forbidden topic to discuss. As cannot any consent form unless there are agreed terms and conditions. Whether to support consent and/or suppress dissent, every government makes decision individually for each case. But most governments agree that some sort of action is required.

    This isn't making sense. Possibly its the word "dissent"? I mean "a strong difference of opinion on a particular subject, especially about an official suggestion or plan or a popular belief" (Cambridge Dictionary). So arguing against official policy is still dissent even if discussion of it is not forbidden.

    I recognise that English is your second language (and its pretty good English BTW, my compliments). Can you try explaining what you mean again? I'm honestly doing my best to understand where you are coming from.

    [I summarise the tenets of the "Liberal International Order"]

    They are all correct, and furthermore, as an "Order", seems like it implies that it has no limits and is free to act on it's own volition to further it's sacred goal. Well, I'm pretty sure it isn't as strict as religious order just yet but it verges upon it regularly.

    By the reference you gave, "Order" here does not mean a religious order in which members submit to the authority of a divinely inspired leadership. The Cambridge Dictionary has rather a lot of definitions, but the ones that seem most relevant here are:

    • a situation in which rules are obeyed and people do what they are expected to do

    • a social or political system

    The second seems the most appropriate, but the first is also relevant because rule of law and human rights are key components of the LIO; governments are expected to respect the rule of law and human rights.

    I defined the LIO as a general consensus, and you seemed to agree with that.

    From here, it looks like the the Russian government disagrees with the tenets of the LIO. Specifically, it does not extend human rights, including freedom of speech, to its citizens. That is why I asked you if you agreed with them.

    Earlier you admitted that your government is sometimes corrupt. But at the same time you seem to assume that everything they do is driven only by the highest of patriotic motives.

    What do you think of these propositions:

    • The reason that so many of the countries that support the LIO are rich and powerful is because they adhere to its tenets.

    • The act of opposing the LIO actually makes Russia poorer and weaker, not because of sanctions, but because adhering to the tenets of the LIO is the way to become strong and rich.

    • The reason that the Russian government opposes the LIO is not because this will be good for Russian people, but because it will be good for the Russian ruling class.

    • If strong and rich countries encourage Russia to join the LIO, they are therefore encouraging it to become strong and rich like them.

    Memorial has also combed through archives to create searchable databases of the prison and death records of the Soviet era’s many millions of victims — but also of the names of more than 41,000 perpetrators from the NKVD secret police.

    So yeah, a rhetorical question, what could possibly such list achieve, especially when the people on their duty of protecting the country are called "perpetrators"? What "human rights", "memories" and "history" can such people receive, not to talk about their descendants? What is the goal of calling every criminal in the system as "a victim" regardless of their record? Etc, etc.

    It may be rhetorical, but I'll answer it anyway.

    The Gulag system of prison camps was probably a crime against humanity; it was a widespread and systemic attack on a civilian population which led to the deaths of around 1.5 million people. The Soviet system also included the forced relocation of populations, another element of a crime against humanity. We can argue about whether specific elements of the definition were or were not met, but its certainly up there.

    So you ask "what could a list of victims achieve"? It helps to memorialise the victims, and provide comfort to their relatives. It counters revisionist attempts to claim that the history books are exaggerations or fables.

    ...especially when the people on their duty of protecting the country are called "perpetrators"

    What else do you call them, if they helped to commit a crime?

    What is the goal of calling every criminal in the system as "a victim" regardless of their record?

    We don't know who were actually criminals, who were really political dissidents imprisoned under the guise of criminal allegations, and who were just innocent people abducted to make up the numbers. There was no due process for these people, and forced confessions were common. NKVD officers competed with each other to arrest more and more, to show their zeal and hard work. The fact that they may have thought they were doing the right thing is no defence.

    [On Memorial making a mistake on 19 names out of 1.5 million]: But we all know that it wasn't an error.

    Really? And how do you know that? 19 out of 1,500,000 seems a pretty low rate of error to me.

    Speaking about politics and having a political influence is rather different activity.

    Not at all. If you speak and nobody listens you might as well be silent. If you speak about politics and people listen, you have political influence.

    You seem to be suggesting that the real crime is having too much political influence, that its all OK as long as you fly under the radar. That's not freedom by any definition I would accept.

    The goal is to limit foreign influence to internal politics and defend constitutional right of sovereignty

    If you believe that, I have a bridge to sell you.

    1388:

    This just shows how many folks in Canada (AND the US) don't pay attention in their civics classes growing up. Or pay much attention to such things in general.

    Back in the 80s I attended a David Suzuki lecture, in which he told the story of how he was reading the tabloid headlines* while in line at the grocery story and later brought up the subject of one of them in a conversation with a colleague in an "I read somewhere that…" way before recalling, to his chagrin, just where he had read it.

    His point being that our picture of the world is made out of everything we see and hear, not just the good-quality sources of information, because our brains aren't really good at filtering out the bad stuff.

    * Ie. the totally-made-up kind of 'story'.

    1389:

    I'm aware of the Overton Window, but that is a matter of public opinion, not Government intervention. Lawmakers follow the Window, they don't move it.

    Seriously?

    Any organization that communicates with the public influences the public. Government propaganda can be just as influential as the private kind (if not more so in pre-internet days).

    1390:

    I was quoting the Wikipedia article. But I think the word "lawmakers" is significant; you seem to be confusing the executive with the legislature.

    1391:

    This just shows how many folks in Canada (AND the US) don't pay attention in their civics classes growing up. Or pay much attention to such things in general.

    Yes, students not really paying attention is a problem.

    But what amounts to a handful of hours in a classroom can't really compete with hundreds of hours of TV for many people - particularly when the TV exposure often pre-dates that classroom instruction.

    1392:

    Yes, Central American governments are issuing and occasionally enforcing decrees against spreading events like parties and "actividades bailables." That literally means "danceable activities" and sounds as bureaucratically stilted in Spanish as it does in English.

    1393:

    Toby
    At the very least it gives us a picture of the depressing level of acceptance of Putin's apparat & the overbearing pressure on Ru society.

    1394:

    RP 1388. Back in 1998 I had just moved to Vancouver, and was trying to navigate the downtown area. I made a turn and came within about 3 inches of hitting a jaywalking David Suzuki with my car (He stepped out from between 2 vehicles). He gave me a dirty look. I suspect that if I had hit him I'd have had to leave the province in shame.

    As for students and civics classes, attention is only part of the problem. I was always very interested in social studies/humanities type classes and so had no problem paying attention (hence the MA in PoliSci). Others, including my elder son and wife, have always found them excruciatingly boring.

    There are ways to make social studies and civics style classes interesting and engaging. They are not compatible with the current model of education that is effectively a hamfisted attempt to balance mass child minding with neoliberal cost cutting.

    Yes, the people within one SD of the mean on most metrics get some benefit from their slog through the system, but the further away from the top of the bell curve you get the more you either fall behind or die from boredom.

    I have seen both of my kids reach the realization that much of grade school is time wasting bullshit. I have then had to help them understand that in order not to close doors for themselves in the future they need to continue checking the boxes until at least adulthood. This is not a system that will reward independent youthful thinkers.

    On the other hand my cousins attended a prestigious private school with eyewatering tuition and a 4:1 student to teacher ratio. Both of them are poster children for the 'Failed to Launch' concept of adulthood.

    1395:

    About Man's Rise... I understand your complaint about California, but this wasn't a survey of Native Americans, it was descriptions of culture level, based heavily on local climate and resources.

    Have you read the chapter on the Utes?

    1396:

    Re "liberal order" - I read this as "neoliberalism", where Bush, Sr. and Blair would both see eye-to-eye... in other words, the redefinition of "liberal" to "the same as "conservative" was 20 years earlier. It involves vehement opposition to public ownership of anything, pro-privatization, and if you're in the bottom 80%, shut up, tug your hat, and do what I tell you.

    1397:

    So, you're ok with someone doxxing members of the FBI, the Secret Service, or whatever the three-letter government agency is where you live?

    1398:

    No, I returned it.

    The things about California and its Indians are: --They're pretty well documented --California was heavily settled pre-Conquest --What was here doesn't really match up with the standard scheme. "Hunter-gatherers" with primitive technology in villages? Yup. --And yes, there were Utes in California.

    So if someone's cooking up an evolutionary scheme involving American Indians and they ignore California, that's a huge red flag, because it means they're excluding anything that doesn't fit into a neat story.

    More to the point, I've also read a bit about the Plains Indians, and there's a long-ass history before they became the horse-riding heroes of Dances With Wolves that show up in Man's Rise. There's also a lot of diversity that didn't appear to be covered in the book, even though the history is out there (cf: Hamalainen's Comanche Empire for a fairly uncomfortable example).

    What happened when I read Man's Rise was that I was going "why is that missing?" and "why is that presented simplistically?" and pretty soon "why do I want to keep reading this?" Sorry about that.

    1399:

    to Toby 1383:

    "poor secret police, evil prisoners"?

    I'm going to have to write it down.. for future reference.

    to Paul @1387: So arguing against official policy is still dissent even if discussion of it is not forbidden.

    Well, the fact that policy is already official means that you can't overrule it with simple arguments. It is what's forbidden here. What is also forbidden usually is to dissuade official policy from being executed, engage in corruption and ignore the law.

    The second seems the most appropriate, but the first is also relevant because rule of law and human rights are key components of the LIO; governments are expected to respect the rule of law and human rights.

    The caveat here is that they are also to expected to respect what LIO says and how it defines this rule of law and those human rights. This is unfortunately all too similar to the difference between Tenets of Communism and their practical realization in many communist regimes. In the past.

    What do you think of these propositions:

    There cannot be any freedom of speech, or rule of law, or whatever of justice if there are no consent, if there are no agreement. Unfortunately, there is no consent, or agreement, or any sort of balance or consistency in LIO, only order, dictate and punishment.

    So I'm going to educate you on the fact that Russia represents a dissent to Liberal Order and faces repressions for it's criticism.

    • In the past, Russia has been following Liberal Order and taking it to heart for more than decade and the Order has tried to make it poor and weak, and as a matter of fact, have never stopped doing so since then.

    • The act of opposing the LIO will make Russia richer and stronger, because adhering to Liberal Order rather than their declared tenets will never lead for anyone to become strong and rich.

    • The reason the Russian government opposes the LIO is not because it will be good for someone or better for someone else, but because the end goal of LIO is complete destruction of a Russia, it's history and identity (further on that down below).

    • If strong and rich countries encourage Russia to join the LIO, they are lying. They need not anyone to become strong and rich, for these positions are already taken.

    The Gulag system of prison camps was probably a crime against humanity; it was a widespread and systemic attack on a civilian population which led to the deaths of around 1.5 million people.

    This point of view seems to completely ignore existence of any other forms of crimes in the USSR, such as murder and robbery, stealing and looting, fraud and corruption, sabotage and terrorism. It also completely ignores the crime of abusing of authority itself (the crime that leads to conviction of innocent people). It simply defines the entirety of USSR through 75 years of its existence as a criminal syndicate incapable of single act of justice.

    So you ask "what could a list of victims achieve"? It helps to memorialise the victims, and provide comfort to their relatives. It counters revisionist attempts to claim that the history books are exaggerations or fables.

    It unfortunately has never stopped any revisionist attempts, or exaggerations, or fables when they were aimed against USSR. For pure propaganda purposes, of course. I could search and post those, but they're too disturbingly "fabled" for civil discussion.

    We don't know who were actually criminals, who were really political dissidents imprisoned under the guise of criminal allegations, and who were just innocent people abducted to make up the numbers.

    Surely we know that, with rather little room for error, too. It may not be a widespread knowledge of the West, but processes like 20th Congress of the Communist Party, destalinization and many others has been done by USSR and the Communist party itself through decades. The archives has been opened, the sentences reviewed, the documents has been presented to public (within the limits that do not disturb civil society and do not lead to acts of revenge or destruction).

    Why is that never considered is a very big question. There may be a wide range of opinions about the meaning of those actions and their end goal, but I have constructed my own simplified explanation for the sake of clarity here.

    What Memorial and other members of Liberal Order are proposing is not about memory, comfort and justice. They look to criminalize the entirety of USSR, and to invalidate all and any signs of justice within it. They look to restart the process of reviewing crimes against humanity and also look to assign a blame for starting the World War to it, no less. They look to invalidate any achievement of USSR in prevention of crimes against humanity, too.

    If you go to Google and ask about USSR in WW2: When World War II started, the Soviet Union was effectively an ally of Nazi Germany in a relatively conventional European interstate war.

    I don't need to ask Putin what it means, he's a busy man for his own policy, everything that I need to know is presented by people, rent free, and on regular basis. If it isn't a freedom of speech, then I don't know what is.

    If you believe that, I have a bridge to sell you.

    It's going to be a very big bridge because, as mentioned above, Liberal Order does not believe in the right of sovereignty. It is, IMHO, does not believe in right of my country to exist.

    Really? And how do you know that? 19 out of 1,500,000 seems a pretty low rate of error to me.

    This is because, as I said, it is not an error. Nor is there any goal to correct any errors. Nor there are any attempts to issue apologies. It is absolutely clear as day that a number of known people with known crimes are being represented as innocent victims of evil regime.

    Here is the original article btw, word to word (in Russian). If you read it, you may even notice that author describes vehement attempts to defend these names.

    http://www.isrageo.com/2021/08/26/etone426/ "Poor secret police, evil prisoners" indeed.

    1400:

    the policy originated among one particular group and carries along with it a huge tail of that group's own unspoken assumptions. If you try and transfer it to another group with their own background habits of thought, most of the information which made it successful with the originators either goes missing altogether or gets replaced with some slightly different thing according to what seems natural to the nother group

    Pigeon --

    What you wrote seems intuitively obvious, but I can't think of any specific examples of such misapplied policies. Can you?

    1401:

    Might I suggest that the issue with Social Studies and Civics style classes is as often poor presentation as poor students?

    1402:

    What you wrote seems intuitively obvious, but I can't think of any specific examples of such misapplied policies. Can you?

    How about scientific forestry, AKA farming trees for the timber industry?

    This started in what's now Germany in the late 18th Century. The key assumption is that you can grow trees the way you grow wheat, as a crop. This is, of course, if you're clever and apply Science.

    Turns out it's not so clever. The intractable problem is that trees take 30-100 years to reach marketable size, unlike wheat, which takes a few months. Also unlike wheat, you want timber trees for their stems, not for their fruit (excepting pine nuts, which are a different issue).

    Now, when you manage a crop of trees like a crop of wheat for decades, you run into problems, with everything from pests, pathogens, parasites and predators (eat the trees, name depends on scale) to competition from "weeds" (other plants). These problems occur with wheat, but by being clever with crop rotations, you can avoid mass quantities of pesticides, fertilizers, and the like (or not, if chemicals are your thing). With tree cropping, not so much, because you're stuck growing the single crop for decades. Then you're stuck rehabbing site and soil when you're done.

    So the end result of treating trees like wheat is a long, long list of environmental problems. To be clear, scientific foresters have been trying to solve these problems for centuries. Thing is, that's not very long in tree crop cycles, and there are still many, many problems out there.

    The awkward part is that the "unscientific forestry" that got sidelined appears to be a more pragmatic approach. It just doesn't deliver what the tree croppers wanted in the first place, which was a predictable amount of timber of a predictable quantity at a predictable time. Systems that can handle the unpredictability of decades of growing tend to be unpredictable themselves.

    1403:

    I see your point, but it's not quite what I was asking (and I don't think it is quite what Pigeon meant). I was asking about policies failing because they are applied to humans whose unstated assumptions differ from the policymaker's assumptions. Hypothetically, a timber policy which works successfully in say, China, but fails in Germany.

    1404:

    whitroth
    Yes, that's a problem, the redefinition of "liberal" ... but not in this case ( I think )

    Arguing against official policy is forbidden - even in discussion? That automatically says serious repressive autocracy.
    Where did "engage in corruption" come from? Looks & sounds like a spurious & made-up excuse to me. The "tenets of Communism" are, unfortunately, well-known from history - the Great Terror & the Gulag.
    Unfortunately, there is no consent, or agreement, or any sort of balance or consistency in LIO, only order, dictate and punishment. - that is an open straight lie, oops.

    ...SERIOUS loopy paranoia ... * because the end goal of LIO is complete destruction of a Russia, it's history and identity*
    DO NOT BELIEVE YOU
    The Gulag system actually really was a vast crime against humanity, comparable in scale to the Nazi's "other" death & work camps. We too have "other" crimes, as you list, but we do not need or use death camps or ultra-repression to deal with them.

    1405:

    Sorry, but in that last part, I agree with sleepingroutine: the West wanted to do to the USSR what it did to the Ottoman Empire, no more, and no less.

    I don't like the whole gulag system... but then, I don't like the literal genocide the US used against the Native Americans. And then there were the slaves... and before I can criticize Putin... I've read that 10% of all Black men in the US spend some time in jail. How much difference is there?

    1406:

    whitroth @ 1348: I wish the US AG, or the Surgeon General (or that I had "standing" to sue) Faux "News" to shut them down - Newscorp has mandates that all employees be vaccinated (like F*er Carlson), and they keep pushing the antivax line.

    That's deliberate reckless endangerment.

    Dominion Voting Systems is suing Faux Newz for Libel.

    So far the courts have ruled against Faux on every motion they've submitted. I think Dominion has a good chance of bankrupting them.

    1407:

    One that immediately springs to mind is the British colonial habit of exporting something as close as they could get to a straight clone of the British law/justice/court system to all the "far-flung posts of Empire". A good deal of the scenery in Kipling's writings is built from description of the somewhat farcical results this often achieved in India due to all the various unspecified dependencies on the Britishness of its environment going to pot one way or another when the environment was Indian. At every level from apparently trivial everyday behaviour patterns up to the whole idea of what a system of justice actually is, Indian people followed patterns that differed significantly from the British patterns around which the imposed system had evolved, with the result that the system itself was unable to behave as expected and tended to produce verdicts with only minimal correspondence either with reality or with its originators' idea of justice. (Naturally the controlling authorities were either just plain unaware, or thought the problems were the fault of Indian people for not being British, which didn't help improve anything.)

    Kipling was a rather good observer since although he certainly believed in the "civilising force of Empire", he was also aware that the colonised peoples did have a civilisation of their own which was worthy of respect and indeed had points actually superior to the British version. And he paints his pictures simply by having his characters straightforwardly and openly doing the same kind of things he knew real people to do, without judgemental descriptions or fulminating moralistic asides, according the dodgy ones just as much right to be people as people are as he does the respectable ones. To try and post a summarised encapsulation of the compatibility problems is kind of a bit much, partly because of the host of small details and partly because the terms for the behaviours concerned are so loaded that it's an impossible struggle to concoct something of summary length that doesn't sound insulting. But fortunately Kipling puts it across pretty well in the form of illustration, showing us what his characters do and in what way the other people around them, both Indian and British, view their actions. Of course he's not unbiased or free from embellishment, but he is far better than the standard of his time. Those of his tales of India where court cases feature are accordingly, and when read with due regard for their nature, pretty enlightening about what happens when you transplant a lump of one culture into another and expect things to Just Work.

    (To be sure there were plenty of other reasons why this kind of export went wrong; George Orwell's description of his time in Burma is a similarly enlightening illustration of a different kind of fuckup where boring old resource constraints are the overwhelming influence. But the operation in India proper was big enough to fuck up in a more interesting way.)

    1408:

    David L @ 1376: With the Ghislaine Maxwell conviction in the US I wonder how some of the related (not by blood) characters in the UK will be covered in the "news".

    I'll not name names as my understanding of UK laws on such matters is a dark but not favorable hole to me and may problematic to Charlie.

    I did see that the BBC interviewed American lawyer Alan M. Dershowitz about the verdict and some are now questioning the appropriateness of that interview.

    BBC Will Look Into Alan Dershowitz Appearance on Maxwell Segment
    The British broadcaster, which introduced Mr. Dershowitz as a “constitutional lawyer,” said later in a statement released on Twitter that the interview did not meet its editorial standards: “Mr. Dershowitz was not a suitable person to interview as an impartial analyst, and we did not make the relevant background clear to our audience,” the statement said. “We will look into how this happened.”
    1409:

    "I was asking about policies failing because they are applied to humans whose unstated assumptions differ from the policymaker's assumptions. "

    A recent couple of examples that come to mind are Afghanistan and Iraq. In both cases the core assumptions were that the residents wanted to live in a liberal democracy, and that given the opportunity it would thrive. Yes, there were all kinds of other reasons for the invasions, but there was some attempt to create a democratic system in those places.

    Suffice it to say that liberal democracy has not taken root in either place. It remains possible that some form of peaceful transition of power will start to take place in either country absent outside interference, but I haven't the cultural knowledge to even begin to project what that might look like. It most certainly will not look like a western constitutional democracy, for better or worse.

    Another example which has happened a lot to ill effect is an applied notion of property when modern or premodern societies have interacted with other cultural configurations (i.e. indigenous groups in North America). The notion of private property is an iceberg tip above a vast collection of assumptions about human goals, behaviour and norms which came directly into conflict with the norms of societies with different constructions of property (and 'private').

    A third example would be the conflict between western feminism and how women's rights are understood and constructed in nonwestern societies. I struggle with this myself as I have strong views about gender equality that conflict with my similarly strong views not imposing western beliefs on other cultures. I am also not a woman so can't and won't start lecturing anyone on the topic, but I am very conscious of the challenges inherent in projecting women's rights as westerners understand them onto nonwestern cultures without accidentally starting another monstrous round of 'white saviours civilizing the primitives'.

    1410:

    "I was asking about policies failing because they are applied to humans whose unstated assumptions differ from the policymaker's assumptions. "

    Free vaccines against a pandemic virus?

    1411:

    I see your point, but it's not quite what I was asking (and I don't think it is quite what Pigeon meant). I was asking about policies failing because they are applied to humans whose unstated assumptions differ from the policymaker's assumptions. Hypothetically, a timber policy which works successfully in say, China, but fails in Germany.

    Timber mill towns, house construction policies (wood frames work in high fire areas!), catastrophic fires, climate change, loss of species, ...But yes, humans are special and different from the rest of the world. Our detachment makes it easy for us to science our way through our relationship issues with non-human entities. (/Sarcasm).

    It's entirely possible that the greatest policy blunder western civilization (including especially the US and Russia, but also China, Japan, the EU, India, Indonesia, Brazil...) has made is systematically silencing and ignoring everyone, from tribespeople to theologians to scientists, who have pointed out that humans are not special, not very different, and utterly dependent on the non-human species and entities around us. That's what the data say, and that's what most everyone in power ignores. I suspect the survivors of climate change and the extinction crisis will think rather differently. The question is, how many of them will there be?

    But let's do talk about humans, shall we?

    1412:

    "The "tenets of Communism" are, unfortunately, well-known from history - the Great Terror & the Gulag."

    It is well known from history that a large country with crap communications and a huge population, mostly uneducated and knowing nothing of life beyond being repeatedly and brutally shat on by those half a millimetre further up the scale, and an aristocracy totally addicted to uncompromisingly absolute rule enforced by flaying people who looked at them funny, had, in the convulsion of a gigantic megadeath war, finally been pushed to give the aristocracy what they deserved, and was then faced with the struggle to patch itself up and stagger back into life while for several years the rest of the world continued to put the boot in. With essentially no skills. They had to put together the entire apparatus of a functioning country from people who, if they were among the more fortunate, might have as their principal area of expertise a detailed knowledge of what a horse's arse looks like. Nobody had any experience of any kind of governing or of fulfilling a position of honest responsibility. They did have experience of being governed; and they knew it to mean being shamelessly ripped off and brutalised by those on the next rung up, occasionally and unpredictably massacred, and being sent to Siberia for letting the wrong person hear you say you're sick of this shit (AFAIK it wasn't called "the gulag" in those times but you know, a turd by any other name as shite would smell and all that).

    So they were basically in the same position as Cromwell had found himself in - chop the ruler's head off / make him dance the dodge the bullet dance in a cellar until he stops moving, then realise that you can't actually think of any good ideas for what to have instead, and end up basically carrying on with the same kind of methods that you do know about because the hammer is the only available tool in your box. Only they were in a far worse position because they had learnt about hammers mainly from the point of view of the nail, their entire country was in the kind of fucked up state that would pose major difficulties for any kind of government, and the people had had it up to here with things being shit and just wanted it to get better regardless of the practicalities, being disinclined to patience because they wanted their dinner. Unfortunately too this is also very much the kind of situation in which the larger turds acquire greater buoyancy.

    The Great Terror and the Gulag are not emblematic of Communism, they're basically just same old same old but someone's changed the pattern on the flag.

    Rather than castigating the Soviets for not doing any better, I think they deserve congratulating for doing amazingly well in such adverse circumstances. I also don't find it surprising that once they had achieved a stable condition, they had a lot of people in government who were left with a lifelong obsession with keeping things just as they are, because at least it does work even if it's suboptimal, and the idea of rocking the boat is too terrible to contemplate when you can so clearly remember not even having a boat.

    "...SERIOUS loopy paranoia ... * because the end goal of LIO is complete destruction of a Russia, it's history and identity*"

    It's not paranoia when they really are out to get you, and again history shows pretty well that such is indeed the case. The worst you might charge sleepingroutine with is hyperbole, but there's nowt wrong with that, I use it myself :) I mentioned above the way the winning side in WW1 kept on putting the boot into Russia for several years after the war was supposed to have ended. The understanding between France and Russia was a novelty and viewed as a strange anomaly at the time; and Russia was still being shafted by those supposedly on the same side while the war was going on. The obsession with preventing Russia from being able to trade through a warm water port, never mind naval use. Various people in Europe deciding that Russia was a nice bit of territory up for grabs (though they did tend to forget that it snows there). The "Russian bogeyman" thing has been going on for goodness knows how long, and its overlap with "Russian punchbag" is uncomfortably great.

    And it is still going on. NATO encroachment is a topic that has come up a few times, inevitably to be dismissed with depressingly Western-centred arguments based around the assumption that NATO is unquestionably wonderful and an utter inability to imagine how it might look from a Russian point of view. The nonsense over the Crimea, where as far as I can tell there is a much higher level of support among its inhabitants for being in Russia than there is in Britain for leaving the EU (and they even did a referendum), but it can't be allowed because they didn't do it in rigid accordance with the way Western governments think things ought to be done. Ukraine is always right and Russia is always wrong, even though Ukraine's government is nastier than Russia's, but they still get Western support because they're not Russia. China's government isn't very nice either but we don't keep behaving threateningly towards them because we care too much about being able to buy cheap shit made in conditions not much different from what people like Engels described in Victorian England. Again, the list goes on and on in a most depressing way. I don't think Russia's perfect, but I do think the West should pack it in trying to tell them what to think and how to behave as if they had some kind of right to.

    1413:

    Yeah, problem is: a lot of that is false.

    Your Narrative structure reeeks of cover-your-ass, and we're a bit busy right now, but take a hint from Ezekiel that you are in no way even close to being the Smartest or Scariest Bug-Bear in the room.

    Think very carefully indeed before responding to this post. Because Charlie is on the hook for any libellous comments made on his blog.

    We have done. Even the deleted stuff: all True.

    And, he's not. 100%, no blog author can be held libelable (puntastic) for said content, which is why the Neo-Khananist muppets aren't suing Twitter (or Square, for that matter).

    Before swinging your pathetic little pecker, perhaps read the Room and/or TR stuff.

    And, no: The Egg thing was 100% misrepresented by the UK press, we do not expect them (let alone the Libel Judges, hello Private Eye) but know this: you can threaten us all you want, and you might lose your entire Countries' economy in about five years, but do not threaten host.

    In the UK, no blog host can be held for libel if a genuine request for removal of content is recieved and they willingly do so.

    Which, after Seven years, you might have noticed our posts disappear a lot. It's not due to Lawyers.

    P.s.

    Don't threaten us again. You're waaaaaaaaaaaay out of your league here, Mr Man.

    1414:

    Here's a tip:

    The Next Generation is solidly not in your Camp, all your Keyboard Warriors are total Mind-wrecks / Non-Self-aware Wolves and we can trash your spend of $150,000,000 by spending: $50. And we're not doing offense. We're attempting to stop something a little larger which you're too stupid / myopic to notice.

    If you wish us to either a) become Offensive or b) stop covering your flabby and pathetic asses, then by all means: renounce the Covenant.

    Please, be our Guest.

    In other News, just read Agency by old Gibson. My oh my, aren't we flattered... He actually loves us.

    p.s.

    https://markets.ft.com/data/world/countries/israel --- compared to TR, this is Pew, Pew, Bonny-Magrue, Cuthbert, Dibble, GRUB.

    1415:

    Dear Mr Lester

    Please be aware that an entire generation of UK, USA, IL, FR and other nationalities are now becoming "immune to the bullshit". That includes all the 20th C media tricks, the Lawfare and all that jazz.

    You might want to alter your Tone somewhat.

    Remember: we only need 10% to change societies. And your kind are dying out (old age, disease, omnibuses). If you were a wise Prophet, you'd start counting your Blessings that some of us were steering things against the Hate-Grain and into something New and Better (Neo-Bundists... now, that's got a ring to it).

    You've left us in the shit. On a scale of "one to totally don't give a shit", your relevence is... zero.

    You'll be dead soon: may your Memory be a Blessing to those who care to remember.

    Yours.

    [You cannot pronounce our Real Name]

    1416:

    Welcome to Principia Scientific International’s OUR PUBLICATIONS section. The papers listed below are considered thoroughly evaluated, having been subject to our unique, open peer review by senior scientists and members before being accepted.

    Greenhouse Effect Refutation (PDF) by Alberto Miatello

    Absence Of A Measurable Greenhouse Effect (PDF) by Joseph E. Postma

    Why CO2 Has Nothing To Do With Temperature (PDF) by Darko Butina

    CO2 Not Causing Climate Change (PDF) by Joseph Reynen

    Alternative Theory To Man-Made CO2’s Influence On Climate (PDF) by David J. Pristash

    Is Sustainable Energy Even Possible Globally? (PDF) by David J. Pristash

    And a front page full of antivax propaganda, half of it sourced from the Epoch Times. I don't think I'll be taking their recommendations on who is stupid and who isn't.

    1417:

    A recent couple of examples that come to mind are Afghanistan and Iraq. In both cases the core assumptions were that the residents wanted to live in a liberal democracy, and that given the opportunity it would thrive.

    I don't know that those assumptions were false per se, but rather the botched operations - particularly in Iraq - mean democracy of any sort never really had a chance.

    The assumption that democracy would somehow just magically appear in Iraq certainly gave not just a window of opportunity for those opposed, but a door the size of an entire wall.

    Suffice it to say that liberal democracy has not taken root in either place.

    I think the bigger lesson, combined with the various Arab Spring happenings, is that the few benefiting from the current systems don't give up those benefits easily. And as a result what the people in those places want sadly didn't/doesn't really reflect in what eventually happens.

    A third example would be the conflict between western feminism and how women's rights are understood and constructed in nonwestern societies.

    but I am very conscious of the challenges inherent in projecting women's rights as westerners understand them onto nonwestern cultures without accidentally starting another monstrous round of 'white saviours civilizing the primitives'.

    An interesting problem.

    I don't think your "white saviours" fear really applies though - in most cases women seem to welcome the potential of women's rights, with girls being sent to schools to be educated, etc.

    The problem is that while those women welcome the change, the men fight back - really just another variation of those who fight against democracy.

    Those who benefit from the entrenched inequality don't want to give up those benefits, regardless of what form of system they are attempting to maintain.

    1418:

    dude (unisex dude i mean), that wasn't a threat (i presume ur behind seven proxies in any case) he was saying be careful what you say for charlie's sake, because charlie has expressly asked people to avoid saying libellous things, even if he is safe if he removes them on request within seven days

    1419:

    Happy new year!

    whitroth @ 1396: Re "liberal order" - I read this as "neoliberalism", where Bush, Sr. and Blair would both see eye-to-eye...

    No, not at all. The tenets of the LIO I quoted are much broader than that; they can encompass anything from the USA of Bush I and Bush II to the high-tax-high-welfare "Nordic model". The EU is one of the biggest and best examples of the LIO; Brexit was a rebellion against it, as is Trumpism.

    1420:

    HM is sending messages
    It's known that that Blair was not necessarily her favourite person, but the Garter? It's a message to Bo Jon-Sun. Also, the other Garter recipient is really deserving - please go & look her up?

    H @ 1411
    Yes, well - I'm right with you there - maybe having an allotment might have something to do with it.

    pigeon
    I tkke some of your points, but no - we are NOT "out to wipe Russia off the map & eradicate its culture" ( My paraphrase ) - see my Q to sleepingroutine, below, about an authentic Ru voice who loathed Communism, yet did not actually buy right into "the West" either - ok?
    ... which leads to Paul @ 1426 ...
    Agree - the EU is the "LIO" & Trumpism/Brexit is a truly scary & horrible reaction to it.
    I'll take the beige over fascism, any day, thank you.

    A question for sleepingroutine.
    What's your take on a genuine Russian, who loathed the Soviet system, yet who clearly wanted a truly Russian approach - & who was strongly tending towards (religious) Russian-Orthodoxy when he died.
    The author of: One Day in the Life ... / First Circle / Cancer Ward & many short stories.

    MEANWHILE
    1413 / 1414 / 1415 / 1416 / 1417 / 1418 / 1419 / 1420 / 1422 / 1423
    EIGHT contiguous obfuscating rants ... plus another two ...
    ... Adrian Smith
    She has done this before & nearly got Charlie into serious hot water, 3-4 years back - depressing, isn't it.

    1421:

    Really? In the US/Canada and I suspect Europe the Christmas / New Year's holidays tend to create spreading events. I would also suspect the same in south of the US border all the way down.

    That's because for US/UK/EU (and most of Canada too) the travel is pretty cheap and the weather is pretty mild. Most transmission happen when people go to work or stay in public transport, but traditionally like 80% people prefer to stay at home or visit their relatives or friends at best. Hopefully this will slow down the transmission rates in combination with other lockdown measures, especially because such measure would never really stop anyone who really wants to go where they want. In any case, it's been successful in the past.

    1422:

    sleepingroutine @ 1399:

    In the past, Russia has been following Liberal Order and taking it to heart for more than decade

    No, really, it hasn't.

    The crony capitalism practised in Russia is a cargo-cult version of the real mixed-market capitalism that underpins the LIO; it has all the forms and symbols of capitalism, but without the substance. It is better understood as a form of feudalism. In the feudal system the King granted land to the barons in exchange for military and political support. The barons were free to exploit their lands as long as they acknowledged the power of the King. If a baron became too powerful he was apt to be killed and his lands given to someone else. Sometimes a powerful and wealthy baron would be able to take on the king, depose him, and take the kingdom.

    In the modern world power and wealth come from industries rather than land, but the principle is the same. The president hands out industrial fiefdoms to favoured supporters. The barons (aka oligarchs) are free to exploit these fiefdoms to enrich themselves as long as they provide financial and political support to the president. If they fail to do so, they are arrested and their fiefs are given to someone else.

    This system got started in Russia under Yeltsin, but Putin has certainly been following the standard playbook.

    Of course this leads to the immiseration of ordinary Russians because all the wealth is being syphoned upwards, just as it was under feudalism. However the solution is simple: blame it all on vaguely defined malign foreign forces that are, for reasons never clearly explained, intent on destroying Russia in particular. Once the people are convinced of this, their further immiseration actually strengthens the leadership because the people become convinced that their poverty is due to foreign enemies and the strong and wise leader is the only possible way to fight these sinister forces, so the poorer they get the stronger the leader becomes.

    I should add that my country is not entirely innocent in all of this.

    In the West there is still a tendency to syphon wealth upwards in the same way, but multi-party democracy and proper elections act as a counter to that. In democracies the position of President or Prime Minister can be withdrawn at the next election. Once that possibility is removed there is no longer any need to care about the welfare of the people.

    because adhering to Liberal Order rather than their declared tenets will never lead for anyone to become strong and rich

    Really? Here are some counter-examples: Japan, Taiwan, West Germany, South Korea, China under Deng, Finland. More recently Eastern Europe, although much of that is still a work in progress.

    And for that matter, look how well Brexit is going for Britain. We are still part of the LIO, but less than we were before, and we are paying for it.

    ... the end goal of LIO is complete destruction of a Russia, it's history and identity (further on that down below).

    Its a belief system I am sadly familiar with: my parents were convinced that the EU was merely an anti-British conspiracy run by the French. Every nationalist everywhere believes that their country is the special victim of a grand conspiracy by the rest of the world.

    They look to restart the process of reviewing crimes against humanity and also look to assign a blame for starting the World War to [Russia], no less.

    Well, the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact was a thing. Hardly a single cause of WWII, but then I haven't heard anyone say it was. I'm not aware of any serious theories of WWII that don't put the bulk of the blame squarely on Hitler, but they also acknowledge that he had enablers too.

    This point of view [that the Gulags were a crime against humanity] seems to completely ignore existence of any other forms of crimes in the USSR, such as murder and robbery, stealing and looting, fraud and corruption, sabotage and terrorism.

    We have all of those crimes in the UK too. Somehow we manage to deal with them without a giant system of forced labour camps in which vast numbers of people die of cold, disease and starvation.

    The fact that a minority of the people caught up in the gulags were real criminals does not justify it.

    1423:

    to whitroth @1405:

    I don't like the whole gulag system... but then, I don't like the literal genocide the US used against the Native Americans. And then there were the slaves... and before I can criticize Putin... I've read that 10% of all Black men in the US spend some time in jail. How much difference is there?

    For "genocide" against Indians, there's unfortunately a semi-free pass that partially lies within the fact that this wasn't for the most part a planned extermination (for what I know) and it happened at the times when the human rights weren't strictly defined. What it doesn't extend to is treating their descendants as inferior people. What lies in the past should be left in the past.

    I particularly invoke that because there's history of Russian conquest of Siberia (and several other territories) where the nations that lived there were conquered as well, and they did suffer some (to much lesser extent) of the issues of "colonial" past. But the positive side of that that it has all came to past and they are just the regular people who enjoy the same rights ands the same life we all do. How could that have been achieved without a solid goal in mind?

    to Pigeon @1412:

    The Great Terror and the Gulag are not emblematic of Communism, they're basically just same old same old but someone's changed the pattern on the flag.

    People who particularly stick to those events usually ignore similarities to the other signs of the same time, i.e. other labor and penal colonies of the world, revolutions, terror, etc, etc. As if when people suffered catastrophic events and inhumane conditions in one country, everywhere else on Earth there was a peace, love and agreement.

    For example, a lot of newer historians who have the chance to look into newly opened archives, have been changing the rhetoric of The Great Terror since it was vastly more complex than it's presented by classic Cold War era stories and myths. They're not going as far in their narrative as to claim that the reign of Stalin has put an end to any or all terror, but even simplest glance indicates that there were people in government who genuinely understood the problems of their time and applied maximum effort to solve them in the most humane manner possible. It is of course far from the classic images of absolute evil. Attributing every evil deed to "them" while reserving every good deed for "us" is a standard selfish human psychological behaviour that has no place in historical analysis.

    to Greg Tingey @1427:

    we are NOT "out to wipe Russia off the map & eradicate its culture"

    There are unfortunately people that are directly supported by that "we". Not that I expect everyone to see through that after all that happened, but it never goes away.

    What's your take on a genuine Russian, who loathed the Soviet system, yet who clearly wanted a truly Russian approach - & who was strongly tending towards (religious) Russian-Orthodoxy when he died.

    It isn't strictly a religious Orthodoxy, but entire movement which is a bit similar in motif. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Village_Prose

    Here's the things that I know: 1) He wasn't the only one in his profession or attitude towards USSR. There is a plethora of other authors that were more known in their homeland but didn't get to known internationally. 2) He wasn't the best one too. Unfortunately his writing has deteriorated during his lifetime (a usual satellite of success). I have read two of his books but the rest of them didn't attract my attention at all. 3) He would never be able to attain his known position without strong partnership from within the government. These were the signs of times where struggle within party was very important, but hidden part of life. 4) His disillusionment with Western countries is unfortunately well hidden from peers because it breaks his image of stern supporter of Western values.

    Most of the public consider him a traitor nowadays for his fame. But frankly his story isn't an enviable one.

    1424:

    Before commenting further on "human rights" abuses, you might do well to read https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pogrom and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cossacks .

    1425:

    Most transmission happen when people go to work or stay in public transport, but traditionally like 80% people prefer to stay at home or visit their relatives or friends at best.

    I don't think you know the American continents all that well. I just got to watch clips of all kinds of people in major US cities out social distancing at 6 in inches and wearing mandatory masks mostly on their chins. (The TV closeups seem to be aimed at correct mask wearing but the folks in the backgrounds? Oy vey.)

    And the US and much of the Americas have just had their biggest air travel weeks. Or would have except for all the flight crews in isolation leading to 1000s of cancelled flight. And South of the US border the street celebrations in the past have been huge. And I can't imagine that fellow in charge of Brazil curtailing those.

    Oh, and holiday shopping in person.

    What this all adds up to is the people doing things somewhat correctly to slow the spread are having the work and exist along side those who really don't give a damn. And masking is just not anywhere near perfect enough to stop such spread.

    1426:

    The crony capitalism practised in Russia is a cargo-cult version of the real mixed-market capitalism that underpins the LIO; it has all the forms and symbols of capitalism, but without the substance. It is better understood as a form of feudalism.

    This is all too familiar of an argument I've been hearing since 00s. "It wasn't real capitalism" and "it's not our failure". I'm sorry, this is absolute bull. The constitution of the country was written in tight cooperation with the US advisors. The internal politics was intertwined with foreign funds and NGOs. The entire economy was shaken up to fit western standards. Even the bank system remains strictly liberal, to this day.

    https://www.reuters.com/article/russia-cenbank-euromoney-idUSL5N11M1X420150916

    This rhetoric is but a fig leaf to cover the usual failure of Liberal Order to implement what it has promised. Some people say that Russian state is a different form of capitalism from western countries. Some say it is not a capitalism at all. I argue that not only it is the same as western system, it is an integral part of the system and it's failure and attempts to get rid of it is only a part of general strategy hypocrisy, rejection and exploitation.

    I should add that my country is not entirely innocent in all of this.

    See, my government also argues that it's not a failure of Russian government, it is quite the opposite, a success when we are able to detach from western corruption and concentrate on domestic goals.

    Really? Here are some counter-examples: Japan, Taiwan, West Germany, South Korea, China under Deng, Finland. More recently Eastern Europe, although much of that is still a work in progress.

    A lot of things in this world is nothing but an illusion. They are not strong, neither they are rich (especially since they are extremely dependent on other strong and rich countries like US). Mind you, Japan was prothesized to be a leader of the new world, and yet it took US to string their monetary reins to send them in stagnation spiral for entire generation. As for the Finland, I consider them being a case of smart neutralist politics and Russia would appreciate them staying the same.

    I'm not aware of any serious theories of WWII that don't put the bulk of the blame squarely on Hitler, but they also acknowledge that he had enablers too.

    Well you are now in for a big surprise because it is all has been heading in the direction where all fault for WW2 is going to be put squarely on USSR and all honor of winning it assigned to the US.

    http://www.andrewlownie.co.uk/authors/sean-mcmeekin/books/stalins-war-a-new-history-of-world-war-ii

    "Hitler’s genocidal ambition may have helped unleash armageddon, but as McMeekin shows in Stalin’s War, the war which emerged from the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact of August 1939 was the one Stalin wanted, not Hitler. So, too, was the Pacific war of 1941-1945 the direct result of Stalin’s non-aggression Pact with Tokyo of April 1941, which had the goal of unleashing the furies of war between Japan and the “Anglo-Saxon powers.”"

    I don't think if it needs any more direct implication, considering that stops a little short of the line drawn by Reich Ministry of Propaganda (I'm sure you know about that one).

    Its a belief system I am sadly familiar with: my parents were convinced that the EU was merely an anti-British conspiracy run by the French.

    Well there's a huge gaps of difference between actually wanting/trying to do something and being able to do so. The UK was preparing to bomb USSR into oblivion with nuclear bombs and yet generations later there are people who say "SURELY it was only a plan, SURELY they were never really going to do that".

    Somehow we manage to deal with them without a giant system of forced labour camps in which vast numbers of people die of cold, disease and starvation.

    Um, are we, like, on the same planet or something?

    1427:

    If I'd been one of Putin's advisors on his recent call to Biden, I would have suggested that he say: "You are doing your best to screw Canada, your best friend and closest ally in the entire world. You are doing this contrary to agreements solemnly entered into. If you are doing this to your best friend, how will you behave to us, someone you consider to be at least slightly a threat?"

    ... and then Putin would fire me and send me back to Canada tout suite. Ah, well. Government work isn't for me, I guess.

    1428:

    As to how the spread is happening in the US.

    In my area there live about 3 to 4 million people depending on how you draw the circle. There are two major hospital/health care systems that cover most of the area. Here's a quote from the local paper from one of them.

    Meanwhile, across UNC Health Systems, COVID-19 hospitalizations have risen from 255 to 345 since Monday — a 35% jump. Spokesman Alan Wolf noted UNC had declined to 77 patients on Nov. 20, just before Thanksgiving.

    1429:

    The NKVD was dissolved 75 years ago, I don't think anyone is worrying about being doxxed.

    1430:

    Paul @ 1429
    Thank you ... I KNEW there was something missing & you have provided it. Ru simply hasn't actually tried real "Western liberal capitalism - it's make-believe & it collapses.
    Of course this leads to the immiseration of the ordinary people of RussiaUSA because all the wealth is being syphoned upwards, just as it was under feudalism. - The exact funhouse mirror-image of Trump's money-wringer, how nice.
    And, as you note, the Trumpists are trying for a "president-for-life" scenario, to continue the money extraction.

    sleepingroutine - - See what Paul said? And the bit about a self-perpetuating false paranoia & "cargo cult"? I'll stick with that.
    "Solzenhitsyn" - actually, I was aware of his gradual disillusionment of "Western" values - principally, because he went down the religious mysticism route. Which I reject for other, obvious reasons.
    "Blame for WWII" - BOLLOCKS - Adolf wot dun it ... an antidote to the dangerous lying shit you linked to is Alan Bullock: "Hitler & Stalin - Parallel lives" - OK?

    JReynolds
    * YES!*

    1431:

    "World War II is Stalin's fault" comes under the heading of whack-job conspiracy thinking, and it's probably aimed more at ignorant people in the U.S. than anything else, along with the idea that "Hitler was a communist." These are standard John Birch talking points ultimately aimed at legitimizing fascism and obscuring the similarities between Trumpists/U.S. Republicans and Nazis.

    1432:

    What lies in the past should be left in the past.

    In terms of blaming those currently alive for what their ancestors did, sure.

    But you can't just say "that's in the past, so forget it" and ignore the continuing effects. I'm sure Rocketpjs could explain this better than I can, but the legacy of residential schools is still harming Canadian First Nations children after two generations, as children who never had a functioning family become parents in turn without a good model for how to be good parents.

    1433:

    Re: (Reynolds) '"You are doing your best to screw Canada, your best friend and closest ally in the entire world.'

    I think the UK is the current 'bestie'. Besides, I imagine that Justin's dad probably mentioned how the US-Canada relationships typically (don't) work. Here's one of PET's more famous quotes:

    'Living next to you is in some ways like sleeping with an elephant. No matter how friendly and even-tempered is the beast, if I can call it that, one is affected by every twitch and grunt.'

    No idea whether there's been any trade disagreement between the US & UK recently and, if yes, the resulting outcome. Maybe someone here could contribute info.

    Re: The US/EU/Western capitalism vs. Russia/former SSRs discussion ...

    Until you identify, define and measure human-scale metrics directly impacted by these different 'isms' this is all just hot air/bluster. Number of new billionaires created per fiscal year although a headline grabber is not an effective metric for evaluating a nation's health. Also, right now the discussions/arguments read as though there's a ton of unvoiced nasty baggage associated with the words central to your arguments 'capitalism', 'West', 'socialism', etc. which further clouds whatever points are being made.

    Maybe your argument could be reframed using some other countries as your examples - that is, if you really want to make a point about one or a few systems/beliefs inherent to that system.

    1434:

    "...the core assumptions were that the residents wanted to live in a liberal democracy,"

    No. Just no. You may not have seen things like Cheney, as VP, saying that the invasion would "pay for itself" (never mind that being against international law for a century or two). They went in with the usual Western attitude of "we'll talk about it, but we just deal with strongmen, who are easier to deal with/control than actual democracy, which is messy, and we may not want want they vote for".

    And if you think I'm exaggerating, I recommend you look up the non-biased version of why "South Vietnam" came to exist in the first place.

    1435:

    Really? Which part of the EU - France? Germany? Hungary? Italy?

    1436:

    Sorry, but the West has wanted to break up and own Russia for centuries. Let's see... if not, why were US and British (and maybe others - not sure) expeditionary forces fighting in Russia after WWI? Why not let the USSR (and Russia before it) a warm-water port?

    For that matter, why did Nixon go to China, and not to the USSR?

    1437:
    No idea whether there's been any trade disagreement between the US & UK recently and, if yes, the resulting outcome. Maybe someone here could contribute info.

    Yes.

    Trump's Steel tariffs are still in place for the UK, but were recently rescinded for the EU.

    Our Trade Minister was in Atlanta recently whining about this -- and the fact that she couldn't get anywhere with a US-UK trade deal (with the Tory-party-necessary ISDS clauses).

    1438:

    Fine. Feel free to bring up those.

    Can you say "Spanish Inquisition"? How about the last time England chased the Jews out of England? Or France?

    And there's always the Roma. And the slaughter of the Hugenots. And Richard the Lionhart's slaughter of Muslims in the "Holy Land"?

    And the US really did have a policy of chasing away and/or genocide against the Native Americans (see, for example, President Jackson and the Trail of Tears")

    1439:

    I think you've misread my actual point of "let he who is without Sin cast the first stone".

    1440:

    Re: '... why were US and British (and maybe others - not sure) expeditionary forces fighting in Russia after WWI'

    My understanding is that this was to prevent what happened anyway, i.e., the creation and isolation of 'satellite' countries as a buffer against any direct military offensive against the USSR.

    I think this started with Siberia which got absorbed shortly after WW1 as one of the Soviet republics and then ramped up when it looked as though Czechoslovakia was about to go the same route. (It's been a very long time since I read any world history so feel free to correct me.)

    1441:

    SFR
    US/EU/Western capitalism vs. Russia/former SSRs discussion ...
    Why not ask those who have experienced both? Like, um, err Estonia, Latvia & Lithuania, who NEVER, EVER want to see or experience that obsessive cruelty & repression again, at all. Or Rumania, with the ongoing ghastly example of "Moldova/Transnistria" & I wonder why that might be?

    At the same time, as whitroth points out ....
    Cheney & his grifting friends really screwed the pooch, didn't they?

    1442:

    Sorry, but what are ISDS clauses?

    1443:
    Sorry, but what are ISDS clauses?

    Investor State Dispute Settlement.

    Secret Courts that are set up to judge whether a country has spoilt commercial opportunities for a multinational company ("investor"). These need not be symmetric, so the US Government need not worry about this, but the UK -- as supplicant in this process -- will submit to, so as to ensure any subsequent Government (for thirty years?) cannot introduce socialism without reimbursing the international investors/companies.

    This is the whole point of Brexit for some sections of the Tory Party.

    1444:

    Troutwaxer @ 1438: "World War II is Stalin's fault" comes under the heading of whack-job conspiracy thinking, and it's probably aimed more at ignorant people in the U.S. than anything else, along with the idea that "Hitler was a communist." These are standard John Birch talking points ultimately aimed at legitimizing fascism and obscuring the similarities between Trumpists/U.S. Republicans and Nazis.

    World War II was started by Adolph Hitler. But he wouldn't have invaded Poland without the assurances provided by the secret protocol from the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact.

    Don't forget that the Soviet Union invaded Poland from the east on Sep 17, 1939 ... and the USSR got to keep those territories after the end of the war ... so Stalin does have some liability there, if only as another of Hitler's enablers.

    The territories of Poland annexed by the Soviet Union after the 1939 Soviet invasion east of the Curzon line remained in the Soviet Union after the war ended and are now in Ukraine and Belarus. Vilnius was given to Lithuania. Only Podlaskie and a small part of Galicia east of the San River, around Przemyśl, were returned to Poland. Of all the other territories annexed by the Soviet Union in 1939 to 1940, those detached from Finland (Western Karelia, Petsamo), Estonia (Estonian Ingria and Petseri County) and Latvia (Abrene) remain part of Russia, the successor state to the Russian SSR after the dissolution of the Soviet Union in 1991. The territories annexed from Romania had also been integrated into the Soviet Union (as the Moldavian SSR or oblasts of the Ukrainian SSR). The core of Bessarabia now forms Moldova. Northern Bessarabia, Northern Bukovina and the Hertsa region now form the Chernivtsi Oblast of Ukraine. Southern Bessarabia is part of the Odessa Oblast, which is also in Ukraine.
    1445:

    Greg Tingey @ 1448: At the same time, as whitroth points out ....
    Cheney & his grifting friends really screwed the pooch, didn't they?

    Long before 9/11.

    But, they were able to fuck up so BIG TIME because they were "Standing on the shoulders of giants"

    1446:

    Thanks for the definition. Of course, the kind of government that's likely to introduce socialism is the kind of government that's like to say say, "Fuck you, international investor/oppressor."

    1447:

    No disagreement whatsoever - Stalin was nothing which remotely resembled a nice guy.

    1448:

    Complete and total topic drift into a very delightful story: https://imgur.com/gallery/xPXs35U

    1449:

    Read that on Reddit. That was entertaining, and the sequel was more entertaining still (manager alternates between cajoling and threatening poster, who has quit directly because of manager's monkeyshines, to come in and do the work).

    Unfortunately, OP took it down from Reddit & it is thus more difficult to read.

    1450:

    Dave Lester
    The answer to that is: "We are nationalising this, without compensation, because of the corruption in the intial statement/operation" ...

    kiloseven/JReynolds
    YESS!

    1451:

    "even simplest glance indicates that there were people in government who genuinely understood the problems of their time and applied maximum effort to solve them in the most humane manner possible."

    Certainly this is true, I'm not wishing to deny it. I was just limiting my post to a somewhat hyperbolic description of the horrible disadvantages which made everyone's tasks so much more difficult, because what I was trying to convey was that the situation was so awful that even if all the actors had had the best will in the world they still wouldn't have been able to achieve in one hit the kind of result that met everyone's ideals, so given that they in fact were simply the ordinary kind of mixture of humans, and looking at what they did achieve, they did amazingly bloody well, and it is not at all fair to paint the whole lot of them as evil monsters for continuing to use some of the same tools as the previous regime when that was caused far more by circumstance than by intention.

    1452:

    It's Theatre, in the traditional Parisian sense[1]: lots of cloaks, hoods and knowing winks.[2] If you need a reference, try out "Interview with the Vampire: The Vampire Chronicles".[3]

    She has done this before & nearly got Charlie into serious hot water, 3-4 years back - depressing, isn't it.

    Seriously? You've never heard the joke: "You should see the Other Guy?". In this case, well. You probably will not.

    Mr Lester is no doubt fine and dandy and still breathing[6]. Our message was to other things apparently completely invisible to you.

    Stalin was nothing which remotely resembled a nice guy

    The irony of Stalin is that many (not all) of those "erased from Memory / History" in the photos... were far.....faaaaaaaaaaaaar... worse than him. Literally, cleaning up the Polit Beu of the horrors that revolution and war had created.

    Like, that's not even the first time in history that's happened. Check out the UK and various Barons and stuff after Cromwell's revolt got rescinded. Some real fucking nasty ones got "quietly shuffled" off the turf.

    And, as we already told you: he liked Pinapples. What you also do not understand is that Pinapples were a major English Class nominator (they even hired them for parties), so... having x4 pinapples on your brand new MSU making the brains for the new Communist dream was an Epic feat of Posting.

    Ignorance. It's not a fucking good character trait.

    ~

    And no, you don't quite get how bad things are going to get because you're all nice normative Homo Sapiens who haven't run a Hell Crown[4] experience in their lives. You might notice when it matters we're actually quite compassionate[5].

    And it's not getting nice. OMMMM.

    [1] Even knowing why that is spelt that way is trouble. Think 18th C, not 19th C.

    [2] He's not a spook, but he does know his Trade Legislation

    [3] Memory is a blessing, despite all that weirdness about penises in her works. And we're 100% sure that wasn't the title when the movie released, but hey. ~Berataasssaaaiaiiiin.

    [4] We really have read all your SF stuff

    [5] grep Lebanon, Martin and use of fertilizers. We do know what the boys went through and do not seek to traumatise them further.

    [6] The Curse remains: absolute shit-show of arrogance over there right now.

    1453:

    Also, MR LESTER forgets to mention who adjudicates said clauses. Hint: IMF, but USA runs the show. Which everyone with any sense knew before Brexit, but thanks for the reminders.

    Despite currency woes, Turkey may be right to cut interest rates

    https://www.scmp.com/comment/opinion/article/3161683/despite-currency-woes-turkey-may-be-right-cut-interest-rates - South China Morning Post, 2nd Jan 2022 (we're not in the UK).

    Hint: It's all about the Silk Road and so on.

    Yaun / Renminbi moves? Of course.

    Western Powers essentially printed a huge amount during this crisis, didn't pass it on to workers and are denying that inflation occurs[1] and the Reverse Repo just hit $1.9 trillion dollars. Welcome to Feudalism, and Greg hasn't spotted it yet [The City, The City].

    Hey. Mr Lester. Perhaps you're not the Most Dangerous Purple in the Room[2]. And perhaps we want those things to jaunt at Host so we can... do other things. shrug

    ~

    "Put a bullet in Xirs Head"[7] "FUCK!! FUCK WHAT WHAT WHAT" "He missed" "THAT IS NOT POSSIBLE" "No, but I am sorry for this"

    *SPLAT**

    And so on.

    Unlike you, we survive. We can also alter reality to do it. Stop threatening things you do not understand.

    Btw: The definition of "Being a Fascist" is living in a Country where the Governing State Organisation is Fascist and you voted for them.

    QED.

    [1] Petrol in the UK is ~£1.40 now? We remember when it hit £1.30 and Brexit happened.

    [2] And yeah, we get it: you want blood, guts and giga-death kills. Trust us: we do not want to be a Knight of the UK Realm, sociopaths. Our death-count is in the billions.

    [3] Of course this was gender specific: but they were wrong about that as well.

    1454:

    Triptych

    If you want to see want your Future is like (UK readers), here it is:

    I have been awarded a British Empire Medal (a bit like a baby MBE) and I’m on the New Year’s Honours List.

    I am the youngest recipient on record of any Medal of the British Empire and, therefore, to have an honour from The Queen.

    I’m…guess what…you got it…chuffed to bits!!!

    https://twitter.com/CaptainTobias9/status/1477046645946986499

    Modelled directly over the ghoulish Captain Tom (post h awarded) walk around the garden that lead to the utterly brave and important awarding the NHS a 1$ pay rise. And Labour (UK) not even arguing for even 5%. Oh, and it's a direct USA import where every story of distress (in the middle classes) is sung as a "Heroes' Journey".

    And so on.

    Hey, kids: you might not want to ever listen to the hate-trash that make these things happen. And as a middle-class parent, not doing this shit to enable it happening is probably smart.

    But, hey: The Queen said you were a Good Boy[1].

    p.s.

    For the record: 252. That's how many H.S.S we've personally killed. The indirect count, like Mr Sir T. Blair is in an order of magnitude higher. Does that make you hard?

    [1] Never ask what her favourite Good Boy had done. True-Anon-Pod, whelp. Told you, armed it, hitting it outta the park. $150,000,000 of your bullshit, $50 sayin "Here's the real deal...".

    Keeping Score?

    1455:

    whitrith 1411 (at least until seagull's stuff gets deleted). I know that the 'real reasons' for the invasions of Iraq and Afghanistan were much more banal and/or venal, but there was a strong thread of 'imposing democracy for the people' through all their propaganda. A great many people believed that given the opportunity for 'freedom' that Iraqis and Afghans would leap at the chance.

    The mental definition of 'freedom' as expressed by a North American or European is very different from that of an Iraqi or Afghan. At no point has either country been ready or interested in a western style democratic system. Nor was any such transition helped by the flagrant venality and willful blindness of the occupying leadership.

    1456:

    “we do not want to be a Knight of the UK Realm, sociopaths. ” Not all of us by any means. Me... well, sure. Just smart enough to fake being decent and fitting in politely. Most of the time. Ask UK Actual.

    1457:

    No, there was a strong CLAIM of that. The underlying meaning was that they would elect a government acceptable to the USA etc. - and cancel it if not (vide Palestine, Venezuela and others). With Libya and Syria, there wasn't even an attempt to create a new government - the intent was to reduce the countries to anarchy.

    1458:

    Returning to COVID-19 for a moment,

    https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-04353-x_reference.pdf

    SARS-CoV-2 infection in free-ranging white-tailed deer

    Received: 12 November 2021 Accepted: 14 December 2021 Published online: 23 December 2021

    Humans have infected a wide range of animals with SARS-CoV-2 viruses1–5, but the establishment of a new natural animal reservoir has not been observed. Here, we document that free-ranging white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus) are highly susceptible to infection with SARS-CoV-2 virus, are exposed to a range of viral diversity from humans, and are capable of sustaining transmission in nature. SARS-CoV-2 virus was detected by rRT-PCR in more than one-third (129/360, 35.8%) of nasal swabs obtained from Odocoileus virginianus in northeast Ohio (USA) during January-March 2021. Deer in 6 locations were infected with 3 SARS-CoV-2 lineages (B.1.2, B.1.582, B.1.596). The B.1.2 viruses, dominant in humans in Ohio at the time, infected deer in four locations. Probable deer-to-deer transmission of B.1.2, B.1.582, and B.1.596 viruses was observed, allowing the virus to acquire amino acid substitutions in the spike protein (including the receptor-binding domain) and ORF1 that are infrequently seen in humans. No spillback to humans was observed, but these findings demonstrate that SARS-CoV-2 viruses have the capacity to transmit in US wildlife, potentially opening new pathways for evolution. There is an urgent need to establish comprehensive “One Health” programs to monitor deer, the environment, and other wildlife hosts globally.

    1459:

    to Troutwaxer @1438: "World War II is Stalin's fault" comes under the heading of whack-job conspiracy thinking, and it's probably aimed more at ignorant people in the U.S. than anything else, along with the idea that "Hitler was a communist."

    It may also come as not-news that this point of view has been gaining traction in Eastern Europe as well - idk about E. Germany or Balkans, but certainly among US/NATO allies against Russia. Steadily, for last three decades, and there's no sign of it to slowing down.

    to JBS @1451: World War II was started by Adolph Hitler. But he wouldn't have invaded Poland without the assurances provided by the secret protocol from the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact.

    I think it's pretty clearly established in history that he wouldn't consider invasion anywhere if League of Nations members provided enough safety guarantee for everyone and not only for themselves. My point being, unfortunately for said history, current mainstream narrative is that "both Hitler and Stalin are equally responsible for the war", AND I don't expect it to stay it in this position for too long.

    to Greg Tingey @1448: Why not ask those who have experienced both? Like, um, err Estonia, Latvia & Lithuania, who NEVER, EVER want to see or experience that obsessive cruelty & repression again, at all. Or Rumania, with the ongoing ghastly example of "Moldova/Transnistria" & I wonder why that might be?

    You might as well ask them directly if you earn yourself an opportunity. I don't think people who use "obsessive cruelty & repression" to perpetuate their regime forward, especially towards vulnerable minority, would like to experience any of it again. But it is not the point of making a difference.

    One. Two. Three. Four.

    1460:

    along with the idea that "Hitler was a communist."

    No no nope. The current social media (or at least recent) posting in the USA are that he was a socialist. Due to the translation of the NAZI part name into English. Of course. Right?

    And thus, drum roll please, "Hitler and the USA Democrats" are one and the same because everyone know the USA Democratic party is a socialist organization trying to wreak out country.

    And I wish I was making this up but relatives and folks from my distant past have posted such nonsense.

    1461:

    David L
    I see that with depressing frequency.
    But, by the same standard, N Korea is a functioning Democracy, because it's there in the name "DPRK". Right ...

    1462:

    Greg Tingey @ 1437:

    Of course this leads to the immiseration of the ordinary people of ~~Russia~~ USA because all the wealth is being syphoned upwards, just as it was under feudalism. - The exact funhouse mirror-image of Trump's money-wringer, how nice.

    • And, as you note, the Trumpists are trying for a "president-for-life" scenario, to continue the money extraction.*

    And then there is the whole Trump vs Bezos thing, which led to Trump's attempt to lock Bezos out of a lucrative government contract. The US president doesn't have the power to freely hand off lucrative positions to favoured courtiers, but the intent is clearly there.

    Over here in the UK we've seen a similar sort of thing happen on a small scale. Hopefully it gets nipped in the bud and we don't see it happening in a larger way. We also have a quangocracy; jobs running Quasi Autonomous Non-Govermental Organisations (QUANGOs) are commonly handed out as favours. These people are not (AFAIK) in a position to enrich themselves in overtly corrupt ways, but they are well paid jobs with not much in the way of accountability to anyone apart from a Government minister.

    So yes its a problem, but not (yet) at the neo-feudal level seen in Russia.

    1463:

    No, there was a strong CLAIM of that.

    I think what you're missing here is the sheer stupidity and cultural ignorance of an typical American Neoconservative. The idea which most condemns these folks is that the vast majority of them were entirely sincere! They BUH-leived!

    Doug Feith, one of the architects of the Iraq war was described as the "fucking stupidest guy on the face of the earth" by General Tommy Franks.

    To answer a possible objection, yes, plenty of lies were told to sell the project, there's absolutely no doubt about that, but for the most part they were "sincere" lies told by believers to sell the project, and those believers imagined that once they got troops on the ground and remade Iraqi/Afghan society everything would go beautifully, because Freedom! (In a sane world, none of these people would ever be allowed within a hundred miles of a state or national capital again, and would be required to stay 100 meters away from any city hall or county administrative building.)

    1464:

    But, by the same standard, N Korea is a functioning Democracy, because it's there in the name "DPRK".

    Thanks, I'm going to save that for use elsewhere if you don't mind. It's the perfect reply otherweb.

    1465:

    sleepingroutine @ 1433:

    [Me:] The crony capitalism practised in Russia is a cargo-cult version of the real mixed-market capitalism that underpins the LIO; it has all the forms and symbols of capitalism, but without the substance. It is better understood as a form of feudalism.

    This is all too familiar of an argument I've been hearing since 00s. "It wasn't real capitalism" and "it's not our failure". I'm sorry, this is absolute bull. [LIO influences on post-communist Russia listed]

    This rhetoric is but a fig leaf to cover the usual failure of Liberal Order to implement what it has promised. Some people say that Russian state is a different form of capitalism from western countries. Some say it is not a capitalism at all. I argue that not only it is the same as western system, it is an integral part of the system and it's failure and attempts to get rid of it is only a part of general strategy hypocrisy, rejection and exploitation.

    This is a fair question. To paraphrase, is the "crony-capitalism" argument a case of the No True Scotsman fallacy; a post-hoc attempt to explain away the failure of capitalism in Russia?

    One way to answer this is to see if the LIO was sounding warning bells early on. If the crony-capitalism theory is true then at some point Russia will have been departing from the LIO program, and observers will have been pointing this out and warning that this is going to cause problems. On the other hand if, as sleepingroutine claims, the LIO program was implemented properly but failed anyway, then there will have been no warnings until after failure became evident.

    During the early to mid 1990s things seemed to be going tolerably well. The initial wave of privatisation was done by issuing vouchers that could be traded for shares in privatised companies. The hope was to turn Russia into a nation of shareholders, who would then make the managers of the privatised companies accountable for their performance. However this didn't happen; Russians preferred to sell the vouchers for whatever cash they could get, and as a result the privatisation wound up concentrating ownership in the hands of a few wealthy people, who then became the oligarchs of the Russian economy. However in mid-1997 there was still optimism that things could turn out right:

    The strongest sign of spring, though, is in the ascendancy of Mr Chubais, Mr Nemtsov and, it should not be forgotten, Mr Yeltsin himself. If Mr Yeltsin—never a man for day-to-day administration, always better at rising to the occasion in a crisis—can continue to put his weight behind reform, there is a real chance that it will bring results. The small signs would be a sensible budget before the Duma, a decent foreign-investment law, the bringing to book of a corrupt oligarch or two: do not rule out a show trial. But bigger changes have to take place, and quickly. In some respects, the pace of change in Russia is astonishingly fast. The transformation from robber-baron to prominent politician that took three generations in America takes just a few years in Russia. Similar speed is called for in the transformation of new money to old if, as must be hoped, old money has an interest in seeing the rule of law applied to business and government.

    However by November 1997 it became clear that these hopes were false. This article in the Economist dated November 1997 describes how things went wrong. Anatoly Chubais, the architect of the privatisation, was forced out.

    But in reality the tycoons who had helped carry Mr Chubais back to power were already squabbling with him and with one another. They felt they deserved to be treated generously for helping Mr Yeltsin stay in power. They had in mind a steady flow of favours in the form of state assets sold cheaply, free floats of public money to enrich their banks, tax breaks, licences for this and contracts for that. They got some of it, but they soon found Mr Chubais telling them they had had enough. Moral considerations aside, the government was nearly broke. It could no longer afford to squander revenue opportunities.

    [...]

    Worse, “crony capitalism” is far from vanquished, and may yet conquer. Market forces have grown stronger with each year, but may not yet be strong enough to propagate themselves unaided.

    This article clearly describes how those who had managed to seize control of key parts of Russian industry were now acting as kingmakers in the feudal style; providing political support to the ruler in return for freedom to enrich themselves.

    This article by the IMF has a retrospective on the whole thing.

    Ever since then various organs aligned with the LIO have been warning that Russia was heading in the wrong direction, and that this would lead to economic stagnation. As you say, this warning has been repeated continuously since then. In the 20 years since, Putin has not tried to tackle this fundamental problem. Instead he exploits it to remain in power.

    Also, notice the tone of these articles: all of them consider a prosperous successful Russia to be the desired outcome; they all express regret when things go wrong, and hope that they might go right in the future. They seek to learn lessons from mistakes. If your picture of the LIO were correct then this would be the opposite: they would celebrate the weakness of Russia and warn against policies that might assist her.

    (Or are you going to claim that the LIO has some super-secret governing body who control everything in the media?)

    [Japan, Taiwan, West Germany, South Korea, China under Deng, Finland.] They are not strong, neither they are rich (especially since they are extremely dependent on other strong and rich countries like US).

    Rich: lets compare GDP per head:

    Russia: $10,126 (down from $16,000 in 2013).

    Japan: $40,193.

    Taiwan: $32,787 (from Wikipedia)

    Germany: $46,208.

    South Korea: $31,631.

    China: $10,434, and rising very fast since about 1994.

    Finland: $48,773.

    They are not strong

    I think the governments of China and Germany might beg to differ.

    I chose those countries deliberately: they were the ones who were defeated in WWII or otherwise started from zero in recent history, but have prospered since. All of them, without exception, did so by aligning themselves with the LIO. Countries that refuse to align with the LIO, on the other hand, do badly. Since 1997 that has included Russia.

    China is an interesting case in point: ever since Deng Xiaoping was in charge it has been pursuing "Socialism with Chinese Characteristics", which might better be described as "Capitalism with Chinese Characteristics". The result as been awesome growth. However the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) remains firmly in charge. Now we are seeing Xi Jinping yanking hard on the leashes of the wealthy in China to bring them to heel.

    Xi is also making noises about the West (and by implication the LIO) which sound very similar to Putin. So far a great deal of Chinese growth has been due to its willingness to play along with the LIO; an awful lot of the stuff that we in the West buy has Made In China stamped on it, and quite a lot of smaller items ordered from Amazon arrive a month later with Chinese postmarks. I've yet to get anything with Cyrillic on it.

    Its going to be interesting to see what Xi's new policy does to the Chinese economy in the coming decade.

    Well you are now in for a big surprise because it is all has been heading in the direction where all fault for WW2 is going to be put squarely on USSR and all honor of winning it assigned to the US.

    Others on this thread have demolished that one. And I can assure you that 1) the sacrifices made by the Russian people in the Great Patriotic War are not forgotten, and 2) the UK will certainly NOT allow the US to claim all the honour for defeating Hitler, much as they might like to try.

    (The World at War can be found on The Daily Motion. This was a major video history of the war made in the 1970s, and is still repeated periodically today. The Russian role is described in detail in episodes 5, 9 and 11. Hardly a failure to credit Russia's role in the downfall of Hitler. Episode 1 also deals with events that led up to the war. You might like to watch it.)

    The UK was preparing to bomb USSR into oblivion with nuclear bombs

    Err, what? Yes, the UK had (and still has) its own independent nuclear deterrent, part of the Mutually Assured Destruction paradigm of the Cold War. But you seem to imply that there was a specific plan for the UK to carry out a nuclear first strike. Is that what you mean, and if so do you have any evidence at all to support that claim?

    Somehow we [in the UK] manage to deal with them without a giant system of forced labour camps in which vast numbers of people die of cold, disease and starvation.

    Um, are we, like, on the same planet or something?

    I'm beginning to wonder.

    1466:

    Everyone had/has a first-strike capability and a first-strike plan, just in case it was/is needed for some reason. Not having a first-strike plan would be rank military incompetence; what needs to be characterized is the willingness to use the first-strike plan.

    1467:

    Paul
    For a more recent, really detailed take on WWII, there is an ongoing weekly series on "WWI - week by week" on You Tube, hosted by Brit/US national Indy Neidell - { Put: "Neidell WWI" into You Tube & you will get it } It's impressive & good.

    1468:

    The UK's first-strike plan against the USSR was almost certainly an expansion of "don't be imbecilic."

    On the other hand, the USA certainly had one, and there is some evidence it was setting up to be able to use it in 1962 (*), which was why Krushchev was so worried. I don't think we are quite back there, today, but it's close and would be certain if the USA manages to put missiles in Ukraine and Georgia. But neither I nor any poster on this blog know what the senior military on either side actually believe about the possibility.

    (*) Whether it was realistic or not is irrelevant, as both sides thought it was, and knew the other knew, and ....

    1469:

    1466 - The only thing about this that is particularly suprising, given how mutagenic SARS-COV-2 is, is that anyone considers it particularly comment worthy.

    1468 & '69 - Likewise, frequently (but not always) associated with "Da'esh are Muslims because they say they are". Of course, that ignores how the other 99.9% of Muslims say that Da'esh are not Muslims.

    1470:

    It's a bit like the meme that's been circulating a little in recent years: "Everyone has a test environment, some people are lucky enough to have a totally separate environment to run production in". Every country with a deterrent (ie, retaliatory strike) capability must have a first strike capability because you can't make the former without making the latter, if anything it's the former that has "extra" characteristics. Even a SLBM retaliatory strike capability (like the UK's) is indistinguishable from a first strike capability, despite being obviously designed for possible retaliatory scenarios. Ordering a launch while the missiles are still flying isn't any different logistically to ordering one before the other side has launched. The ability to do it after the other side's missiles have hit their targets is a bit extra even without all the dead man's switch capabilities that are supposed to be important to deterrence too.

    Then of course anti-missile defence is also dual-edged: developing a capability to protect yourself from first strike missiles is seen as offensive because it also protects you from a retaliatory strike, therefore it's all about increasing the effectiveness of your first strike capability. This logic is circular and following through with it is just an ever-escalating cycle of madness, but that doesn't stop people from trying I guess.

    1471:

    "1466 - The only thing about this that is particularly suprising, given how mutagenic SARS-COV-2 is, is that anyone considers it particularly comment worthy. "

    I think the more important part of the paper is that SARS-COV-2 appears to be able to establish itself in a self-sustaining way in a large animal population that has frequent interaction with humans*. The tendency of coronaviruses to mutate frequently just makes the story more interesting, for unpleasant values of interesting.

    Year in and year out, the whitetail deer reigns as America’s No. 1 big-game animal, with an annual harvest of roughly 6 million animals.

    1472:

    Year in and year out, the whitetail deer reigns as America’s No. 1 big-game animal, with an annual harvest of roughly 6 million animals.

    The cervid population of North America, including whitetail deer, is under pressure from Chronic Wasting Disease, an easily spread neurological prion infection. Most US States and Canada have hunting range restrictions, limits on transportation of live animals and carcasses across state boundaries etc. Some State wildlife departments have carcass testing programs in place, others simply discourage people from eating the meat of possibly-infected deer, elk etc. At the moment the disease doesn't seem to have crossed over into primates although there are some indications monkeys in other parts of the world scavenging contaminated meat from infected cervid carcasses have become infected in their turn.

    Any attempt by the US government to ban deer hunting because of this disease spreading into humanity would be, let us say, not looked on kindly by tens of millions of American hunters. The resulting horde of zombified camo-wearing Good Old Boys would be like something out of a zombie movie, WWZ as a follow-on to COVID-19's Contagion.

    1473:

    "Any attempt by the US government to ban deer hunting because of this disease spreading into humanity would be, let us say, not looked on kindly by tens of millions of American hunters."

    My very thought. Assuming the not inevitable but not implausible worst, SARS-COV-2 gets established in the deer population, does its mutation thing, and now and then sends some excitingly new variant over to the human population via hunting. As you say, a government attempt to restrict hunting as a solution would not go down well.

    1474:

    Assuming the not inevitable but not implausible worst, SARS-COV-2 gets established in the deer population, does its mutation thing, and now and then sends some excitingly new variant over to the human population via hunting.

    Yes, I was thinking something like this during the early times of COVID-19's spread around the world with the disease being detected in various wild animals, zoo populations and places like mink farms adjacent to humanity. Various US folks were condemning China's "wet markets" such as the one on Wuhan where it is likely SARS-nCoV-2 crossed over into Patient Zero, people eating wild animals ewww! while ignoring the hunting and fishing and subsequent consumption of wild animals, birds, fish etc. that has been going on in large parts of the US for centuries.

    1475:

    kiloseven @ 1455: Complete and total topic drift into a very delightful story: https://imgur.com/gallery/xPXs35U

    I'm pretty sure that story is a ghost from Christmas Past. This ain't the first year I remember reading it.

    It's still a great story whether it happened this year or 10 years ago.

    1476:

    Rocketpjs @ 1463: whitrith 1411 (at least until seagull's stuff gets deleted). I know that the 'real reasons' for the invasions of Iraq and Afghanistan were much more banal and/or venal, but there was a strong thread of 'imposing democracy for the people' through all their propaganda. A great many people believed that given the opportunity for 'freedom' that Iraqis and Afghans would leap at the chance.

    The mental definition of 'freedom' as expressed by a North American or European is very different from that of an Iraqi or Afghan. At no point has either country been ready or interested in a western style democratic system. Nor was any such transition helped by the flagrant venality and willful blindness of the occupying leadership.

    A major part of the problem is they started believing their own propaganda (lies). They BELIEVED they were going to create a Randian Libertarian Paradise in Iraq; a real world Galt's Gulch" to show the world how it should be done.

    BAGHDAD YEAR ZERO Pillaging Iraq in pursuit of a neocon utopia by Naomi Klein

    1477:

    "while ignoring the hunting and fishing and subsequent consumption of wild animals, birds, fish etc. that has been going on in large parts of the US for centuries."

    Yes, my late and favorite uncle lived in Montana and kept us well supplied with venison, occasionally mooseburger, and antelope ham. Antelope ham is very tasty.

    1478:

    Troutwaxer @ 1471: Doug Feith, one of the architects of the Iraq war was described as the "fucking stupidest guy on the face of the earth" by General Tommy Franks.

    That's REALLY saying something because General Franks was NOT highly regarded as the brightest bulb among his peers.

    Generally officers have two attributes - smart/stupid and energetic/lazy. If you plot smart/stupid along the Y-Axis and energetic/lazy along the X-Axis, Tommy Franks falls somewhere near the origin in quadrant IV.

    Unfortunately, most of the neocons fall in the extremes of quadrant III. These guys wouldn't know Dunning-Kruger if it rose up and bit them on the ass ... which it did.

    1479:

    Troutwaxer @ 1474: Everyone had/has a first-strike capability and a first-strike plan, just in case it was/is needed for some reason. Not having a first-strike plan would be rank military incompetence; what needs to be characterized is the willingness to use the first-strike plan.

    There's not really much to the first-strike "plan" ... push the button then bend over, put your head between your legs and kiss your ass goodbye.

    The really important plans are for what you can do IF the OTHER GUY is threatening to push HIS button and what can you do to dissuade him from doing so. How do you convince him it's not in HIS interest to go for it. If you have a viable retaliatory (second-strike) capability, that might be one factor in his decision making. That's where competence matters.

    1480:

    crossed over into Patient Zero, people eating wild animals ewww! while ignoring the hunting and fishing and subsequent consumption of wild animals, birds, fish etc. that has been going on in large parts of the US for centuries.

    A key difference though (other than fish/shellfish) is that the hunting kills the animal in the wild - we aren't bringing these animals to a market alive.

    So the fact that the deer population has Covid is hopefully irrelevant because as long as Covid remains an airborne respiratory spreader the risk of transmission to the hunter should be minimal unless I am missing something.

    1481:

    Sounds like conclusions drawn by Kurt von Hammerstein-Equord, an anti-Nazi general who died (of illness) in 1943, viz:

    I distinguish four types. There are clever, hardworking, stupid, and lazy officers. Usually two characteristics are combined. Some are clever and hardworking; their place is the General Staff. The next ones are stupid and lazy; they make up 90 percent of every army and are suited to routine duties. Anyone who is both clever and lazy is qualified for the highest leadership duties, because he possesses the mental clarity and strength of nerve necessary for difficult decisions. One must beware of anyone who is both stupid and hardworking; he must not be entrusted with any responsibility because he will always only cause damage.
    1482:

    Nojay @ 1480: Any attempt by the US government to ban deer hunting because of this disease spreading into humanity would be, let us say, not looked on kindly by tens of millions of American hunters. The resulting horde of zombified camo-wearing Good Old Boys would be like something out of a zombie movie, WWZ as a follow-on to COVID-19's Contagion.

    The other problem is there are no longer large predators capable of taking down deer in most of the U.S.

    Without hunting who or what is going to cull the herd? What happens to the deer if the herds don't get culled? Where did Chronic Wasting Disease come from and why has it spread so past in the wild dear population?

    We're kind of in a cleft stick here.

    1483:

    Male white tail deer, if surprised, will snort/exhale very loudly. This exhalation probably would carry SARS-CoV-2, and could pose a risk if the deer were slightly upwind of you (surprise is more likely if upwind). This would be outdoors, though, which would lower the risk a lot through immediate dilution. But it could be an avenue for re-entry of evolved-in-deer-for-a-while SARS-CoV-2 into the human population.

    (First time it happened to me (a couple of decades ago) I was doing quiet karate exercises outside, during a dark night. Spun really quickly; buck was already running off.)

    1484:

    Wide Character In Process at 1413 and various. (Name noted):
    It helps if your grip PSI is like... above a chimp or gorilla.
    Interesting. The usual approach for high pressure/PSI(/N/m**2) is speed, but it need not be crude speed.
    Several years ago I detached a tendon on the last joint of one of my pinkies in a rapid twist/move of an inaminate object while distracted. Grip was correct; the motion was too fast, and sloppy.
    (A sufficiently quick/hard knife-hand will also break a forearm. That's what I mean by crude.)

    ----
    Interesting interview. A reminder that global heating will have effects that most people don't expect.
    The Return of the Urban Firestorm - What happened in Colorado was something much scarier than a wildfire. Climate scientist Daniel Swain explains that what happened Thursday in Colorado wasn’t a wildfire, but something potentially much scarier. (David Wallace-Wells, Jan. 1, 2022)

    1485:

    Male white tail deer, if surprised, will snort/exhale very loudly. This exhalation probably would carry SARS-CoV-2, and could pose a risk if the deer were slightly upwind of you (surprise is more likely if upwind). This would be outdoors, though, which would lower the risk a lot through immediate dilution. But it could be an avenue for re-entry of evolved-in-deer-for-a-while SARS-CoV-2 into the human population

    But realistically how many hunters, carrying their AR-15 and other rifles, are close enough to worry about being breathed on by a startled deer?

    1486:

    Interesting interview. A reminder that global heating will have effects that most people don't expect.

    Very interesting article.

    Particularly the bit about how concrete buildings aren't safe in those sort of fire events - a key point for anyone facing such things that you really do need to evacuate if at all possible rather than attempt to shelter in place.

    1487:

    We don't really talk much about blood-to-blood infections with Covid19. I'd speculate, though, that the big risk with white-tailed deer is when a hunter is gutting a carcass ("cleaning the kill"), and comes in contact with infected tissues. One of the risks when cleaning any animal is slicing yourself with your own knife. I'd be more worried about someone getting infected by getting deer fluids into an open wound than from a deer snort.

    1488:

    The reason we dont talk about blood-to-blood infections is that there is no sign of it happening, certainly not on any relevant scale compared to infection via the respiratory system.

    If the deer is infected with an aerosolized lower respiratory-tract variant, your would be safe by keeping a 10 meter, 30 second distance to any live deer.

    If the deer is infected with an airborne upper respiratory-tract variant like omicron, simply breathing in the same area as a deer has passed through the last half hour will put you at risk.

    1489:

    It's more that buildings have to be designed for both the wind and embers. Conventional buildings are designed to be replaced after events like that.

    The roof and walls will be rated for X amount of wind speed but you quickly get into power law relations between wind speed and building cost. Wind energy is roughly velocity squared, but drag for a square box goes up at roughly the fourth power. Wall cost goes up with volume, but strength only with thickness. Roof cost likewise, but with extra structural loading on the walls as a bonus extra cost! It's much cheaper to buy insurance.

    Ember attacks come down to details. Your roof is only as good as the weakest point, so every single little detail has to be properly designed. And installed. And maintained. One pile of leaves blown under an air conditioning unit gives you the initial fuel to set the insulation around the roof piercing pipes on fire and now you have a real problem. Times every square metre of roof.

    In Australia we have a lot of "community centre" buildings that are also fire refuges. They're expensive to build, require labour-intensive maintenance, and don't protect very well against major fire events. On the other hand, a nice solid wooden house does even worse... probably airborne and on fire. Most buildings are designed to delay the impact of the event, in the hope that it blows over quickly. Which most fires do, they burn out within an hour or two (in any specific place) so you just have to survive inside until the outside is survivable again.

    I don't think it's possible to actively defend against an event like that firestorm, it's too fast for any response short of bombers in the air over every city all the time. You have to build to cope.

    Note that this fire was in winter, not when people normally expect wildfires. That's one of the more scary aspects.

    1490:

    1488 - There is also much talk about Covid aerosols, and "the importance of ventilation in reducing spread". I can't think of many environments that are much more ventilated than a deer forest or a salmon river!

    1495 - Maybe you know something I don't, but I'm not aware of there being any work at all on blood to blood transmission of Covid. Indeed, I can confirm from personal experience that barrier PPE is well-used and respected in hospital and health centre environments. (to the extent that staff making observations use fresh PPE for every round, and those doing tasks like starting or ending haemodialysis sessions use fresh PPE for every patient, and dispose of used PPE in a "potentially contaminated bin" from where it is sent for high temperature incineration).

    1491:

    JBS
    Wolf-Packs
    Somewhere, I forget where, in the US, there was & is a Park/refuge/wilderness area, where the ecosystems simply did NOT "return to normal" - until ....
    They let the wolves back in, or re-introduced a pack. The wolves culled the deer, tree regrowth restarted, other animals moved back in, the plant ecology-system re-integrated themselves .. Al by reintroducing an apex predator.
    I'm sure someone out there can remind me & everybody else where this is?

    1492:

    "Note that this fire was in winter, not when people normally expect wildfires."

    It was only winter according to the calendar, not according to the weather.

    The major effect of greenhouse-gas pollution is more energy in the atmosphere and the manifestation of that is not just "global warming" but higher variability in all weather outcomes, including when certain kinds of weather driven phenomena can happen on the calendar.

    People really do not understand how wildly different that makes our cozy world, and to make matters worse, pretty much the only solid data points we will have for a long time are the extremes, the highest temperature, the latest hurricane and so on.

    There is an obscure branch of statistics called "extreme value theory" which lives on precisely that kind of data, and the output is pretty scary.

    For instance, back in 1992 this JASON report concluded that the probability that global temperature had a positive trend was 100k to 1M against 1:

    https://www.fas.org/irp/agency/dod/jason/statistics.pdf

    Compare that to what the climate scientists at the time.

    Yes, the uncertainty is a factor ten, and that happens so often with EVT that most scientists routinely dismiss it, but if you want to understand what the future holds, that is currently our most useful tool...

    1494:

    On the other hand if, as sleepingroutine claims, the LIO program was implemented properly but failed anyway, then there will have been no warnings until after failure became evident.

    That is a very fascinating story but the assumption that it "failed" comes from the idea that the goal of that program was a development or modernization of economy. This, by coincidence, was a declared purpose, which is also an integral part of the plan to keep the hopes going in the gap between boom and bust.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vulture_capitalist

    From the point of view of of IMF and their cronies in international banking system, the program was another total success and all the problems of course could be easily written off to those cargo cult monkeys, who think they've earned any right to be rich and powerful.

    This article by the IMF has a retrospective on the whole thing.

    Yeah let's just ask the main governing body behind the whole system if they're thinking they've done anything wrong.

    Rich: lets compare GDP per head:

    Great observation but there's two things you missed:

  • GDP has been dropping like a stone through the entire reforms period until 1998. So fast, in fact, that failing population couldn't keep up.
  • Any "economist" that compares GDP by exchange course probably doesn't understand a single digit in economy so here we are back at cargo cult.
  • In the 20 years since, Putin has not tried to tackle this fundamental problem. Instead he exploits it to remain in power.

    Speaking of stagnation.

    Take your time to look and note the 20 year gap of "successful capitalist model" which has, by some estimations, resulted in more ruin and death than deadliest war in history (in ex-USSR alone that is). I am beginning to wonder if "fundamental problem" that you are talking about... is a bit different than you think it is.

    I think the governments of China and Germany might beg to differ.

    Germany is still occupied by US forces hosting US nuclear weapons. As for China, it wasn't under Deng that it earned it's fame of world's business leader, rather it was a biggest sweatshop. This is a rather wide interpretation of success.

    I'm beginning to wonder.

    Well the imperial practice to send people "to colonies" is not unlike putting people on other planet (rather than putting them behind the bars or barbed wire), so it might as well be a good metaphor.

    1495:

    Adrian Smith
    Thanks, that's it - Yellowstone.

    Sleepingroutine
    Sending people to colonies - we stopped doing that in, um ( looks it up ) - 1868. TRY AGAIN. Germany isn't "occupied" by anybody, actually.

    1496:

    Stalin died in 1952, and Krushchev almost immediately stopped the worst of the Gulag system; they did not last in any form into the post-USSR Russia. You anti-Russian bigots are keen on damning modern Russia for the sins of the past, but object when it is done to you.

    1497:

    The other problem is there are no longer large predators capable of taking down deer in most of the U.S.

    I dono. I would consider autos a large predator. They take out around 1 million per year.

    Many between where the two of us live and the coast. I hate driving those roads a night when it's cloudy. All you can see are the lines on the roads but not too far ahead. And there is NOTHING along the side of the roads but trees so it's a tunnel effect. And you have to watch for deer eye reflections of your head lights or you get to play deer dodge car. At 60-70mph.

    1498:

    It was only winter according to the calendar, not according to the weather.

    When just had a week where the high each day was near or just above 70F(21C). We might have gotten to 75F Fri/Sat. A front just came through generating gusts of up to 50mph and some Noah looking rain. Temp is now in the 30s and still falling. Snow flurries but they melt when they hit ground. And the morning low should be 25F(-4C).

    How do you plan?

    1499:

    Many between where the two of us live and the coast. I hate driving those roads a night when it's cloudy. All you can see are the lines on the roads but not too far ahead. And there is NOTHING along the side of the roads but trees so it's a tunnel effect. And you have to watch for deer eye reflections of your head lights or you get to play deer dodge car. At 60-70mph

    Been there, done that, missed the deer.

    Anyway, that's when I learned to use high beams. It's more to give the deer notice that you're coming.

    The awkward/amusing part goes as follows: --White market hunting for deer is too efficient, which is why it was banned. This is true for most animals (cf Passenger pigeons). --Recreational hunting is too inefficient to keep herd sizes constant. This leads to herd sizes exploding, with some really nasty follow-on effects that last for decades/centuries. The most pernicious is when the deer eat all the tree seedlings, so that the forests dies, and then the deer starve. No one wants to hunt a starving deer, either, so culling falls to professional hunters (see above).

    There are two solutions, both of which are hated by different factions. --Subsistence hunting year-round. Indian nations that practice this don't have problems with too many deer. They do have problems with "liberal" animal rights activists and other people who think killing is bad.
    --Reintroducing top predators like mountain lions and wolves. These also work (subsistence hunting again). This method is hated "conservative" ranchers who are afraid of losing livestock, sometimes for a good reason, generally for ideological reasons.

    And so here we are. Anyone who says that human culture plays no role in environmental issues is suffering from advanced CRIS.

    1500:
    Stalin died in 1952, and Krushchev almost immediately stopped the worst of the Gulag system; they did not last in any form into the post-USSR Russia. You anti-Russian bigots are keen on damning modern Russia for the sins of the past, but object when it is done to you.

    That's all fine and dandy, but sleepingroutine let on what Memorial had really done wrong: listed the "operatives" of state security who'd, ... errr, .. been active during the deaths of so many Soviet Citizens. (I'm struggling to find neutral words here, as you can tell.)

    Now the reason I found that fact interesting was (1) I didn't know that before; and (2) it would not be how UK politicians would have played it.

    You and I know that if something like the events in Russia in 1991 had happened in the UK, our politicians would have jumped at the chance to free themselves from any obligations to the past, by making bold claims that everything to do with what happened in the 1950s had been cleaned up, bad apples cast out, etc, etc. All whilst actually continuing to employ mostly the exact same people (bar a few visible scape-goats who'd be sent to spend more time with their family).

    Actually, having had run ins with members of "The Security Service" (as they like to call themselves, or "The SS" as I prefer it, or maybe you know them as MI5), having them spend more time with their families couldn't happen to a nicer bunch of psychopaths.

    1501:

    I had started on yet another refutation of sleepingroutine's unsupported claims that all Russia's woes are due to some grand conspiracy of foreigners, and that the primary concern of foreign and economic policy around the world is the destruction of Russia.

    But half way through I accidentally closed the tab I was working in, and I can't be bothered any more. sleepingroutine is welcome to go off and believe what he wants.

    1502:

    To me this article about stupidity seems to be—frankly—BS. Also, just from the links to other articles (and the book adverts) the site it's on seems to be climate change denying and antivax. Doesn't seem like a respectable source to me.

    1503:

    There are two solutions, both of which are hated by different factions.

    There is a problem with both of these. And the Yellowstone approach doesn't scale to this problem.

    Most deer now live in the "burbs" in the US. We grow food they really like and it is more nutritious than what is found in the "wild". So the they have more live births that survive the first year in the "burbs". And no one (well virtually no one) is going to say let's drop wolves into the burbs. Or go for rifle hunting in the land of apartments and 1/3 and smaller lots with houses.

    Greg, think of wolves walking down the street in front of your house. Wolves are NOT small and don't really domestic well.

    1504:

    You are misrepresenting sleepingroutine to set up a straw man. He has never claimed that ALL of Russia's woes are due to a conspiracy of foreign organisations, but that many are, and the facts are on his side. Not, perhaps, as strongly as he claims, but a DAMN sight more strongly than your claims that the woes are all home-brewed.

    Let me start by saying that Putin is a nasty piece of work, and the Russian state at least as dysfunctional and corrupt as the UK one, but that is irrelevant to most of the points.

    When Gorbachev dissolved the USSR, he did not realise just how badly foreign kleptocratic organisations would move in to take advantage of Russia's naivety in a 'free' market and lack of governance. Oh, yes, there were lots of Russian kleptocrats, too, but (as with third-world countries, including the UK), at least local ones feed SOME money back and are subject to SOME control. Putin has been trying to rein that back, at least in favour of the local kleptocrats (including himself), which is one reason the west is so hostile to him(*).

    More culpably, the USA and NATO in particular have been waging economic and political war against Russia since 1991, though it did not become apparent for some time. If you follow a neutral and 'brave' source like Reuters, you can see that quite clearly. The reason that Putin was elected was precisely because the Russians realised what was happening - they wanted someone who would stand up to the bullying. And, yes, they got a typical Russian solution - a somewhat brutal autocrat.

    (*) I.e. we are effectively governed by those kleptocratic organisations.

    1506:

    Yep. And they are smart. And don't domesticate well.

    Recently here in North Carolina a group of half dog / half wolves got loose from someone who is likely in trouble for breeding them. There was a concerted effort to track them all down with prejudice.

    1507:

    "How do you plan?"

    That is a very good question, but it presupposes that planning is happening og going to happen in the first place, most countries and most people are only playing lip-service to planning for climate change at this point in time.

    There are two geo-historical facts that worry me a lot.

    The first is that if you look at the paleoclimate, pretty much all of our civilization is built during what looks like an almost supernaturally stable climate during the last 10K years, and we have already significantly veered out of that domain now.

    It's a bit like Sagans pale blue dot: All the weather we have ever known is on the straight line we have now left.

    It also really stands out how few permanent settlements North America have had. On any other continent, if you had two rivers merging, you had some kind of permanent settlement, but NA ? Nope.

    One not implausible simple explanation, is that for reasons of random geography, pretty much all of NA is subject to so frequent natural disasters that only technology makes it habitable for a civilization with digital watches.

    Both of these point to a future where our civilization is at risk. By civilization I mean neither "the planet" nor Homo Sapiens, but our civilization with its mobile phones, courts of justice, democracy, libraries, public schools and antibiotics.

    The biosphere is our space-ship, and the sooner we treat it as one, the better or chances of survival.

    That is how we should plan.

    1508:

    In the UK, outside of the Scottish Highlands, the problem deer are roe and muntjac, and the appropriate predator the lynx. I would LOVE to see them visiting my back garden (yes, in the suburbs).

    1509:

    Most deer now live in the "burbs" in the US. We grow food they really like and it is more nutritious than what is found in the "wild". So the they have more live births that survive the first year in the "burbs". And no one (well virtually no one) is going to say let's drop wolves into the burbs. Or go for rifle hunting in the land of apartments and 1/3 and smaller lots with houses.

    Wolves also really, really hate being around that many humans. Mountain lions do too, but they do marginally better in the suburbs, until they get conditioned enough to attack a human who annoys them.

    However, there is one key bit that's missing. In deer hunting country (I'm used to Wisconsin), hunting is allowed in the outer burbs. But rifle hunting is not. It's bowhunting and shotgunning with slugs only, because the lethal range for a slug is around 100 meters, not five miles. Where human density is low enough, this is perfectly viable.

    Out here in Southern California, that doesn't work. Mostly deer are in fairly open country (giggling at calling chaparral open, but still). Usually deer hunting is done at extreme range (300-500 meters), so rifles are mandatory and deer don't get hunted in the burbs. Instead, we use things like cars, droughts, wildfires, and mountain lions to try to keep the deer under control.

    1510:

    I had started on yet another refutation of sleepingroutine's unsupported claims that all Russia's woes are due to some grand conspiracy of foreigners, and that the primary concern of foreign and economic policy around the world is the destruction of Russia.

    Well....

    I figure anyone who's worried about getting in trouble for posts on an international blog deserves a wee bit of slack.

    That said, I think OGH's point about DARVO applies quite thoroughly here.

    There's also Paul Linebarger's point (in Psychological Warfare) about people who think that everything's propaganda are paradoxically easier to influence with propaganda. It's dangerous to assume that everything's a lie, because you then have to rely only on your own knowledge to figure out what the truth is. And no one's that bright. And everyone is most adept at fooling themselves. So rather than being clever, the general result is that people who think it's all propaganda end up like American Anti-Vaxxer MAGAts, gargling bleach, downing horse dewormer, and believing that anything the US government emits is a lie, unless it's from someone like Donald Trump, or whoever gets past their defenses and gives them something plausible to believe in.

    Of course, the normal response to something like the last paragraph is a DARVO: deny the possibility, attack me for pointing it out, then reverse the victim and offender to accuse me of being the attacker, to justify a disproportionate negative response. Let's see what happens.

    1511:

    Deer are certainly thriving in my neighbourhood. We have a family of white tailed deer that live on our street, and for whatever reason are in my front yard every evening around 8 (when I walk the dog). This is normal enough that the dog and the deer utterly ignore each other, except when there is a new fawn and the mother is a bit protective.

    It means my front garden has an 8 foot metal fence with a couple more feet of wires above it, and our back garden has a 7 foot fence all around it to protect the berry bushes.

    We also occasionally have a pack of coyotes, though not recently. They quite helpfully keep the rats down.

    Every couple of years some of the deer disappear, and we then hear that there is a cougar in the area. Usually it is a young cougar looking for food (i.e. fawns) that doesn't know about the hazard of humans. Since they can and sometimes do mistake toddlers or small children for food, they tend to be shot fairly quickly.

    For the first 8 years we were in our house there was a large black bear sow that lived in the neighbourhood as well. She had some cubs a couple of years ago. It made for interesting late evening dog walks. Generally it means we keep our trash in the garage until garbage day. I never thought it would be possible, but we just get used to having wildlife in the neighbourhood. My kids occasionally encounter a bear while walking home from school and sometimes don't even mention it to me because it is so commonplace.

    1512:

    I would LOVE to see them visiting my back garden (yes, in the suburbs).

    I've had 6 in my yard at one time. At least that were caught on my security camera. Haven't seen any for a year now. I don't know if that's worrisome or just they don't like the grass here as well as a block or two over. I live less than a mile from a creek (not a river but big enough) and our green way system. Plus a park that has a lot of thicket in it.

    Recently, aside from the regular gray and white cat, we get a possum and/or raccoon about once a week. I have an easy to squeeze through temporary fence they may be annoyed at just now. But the rabbits and chipmunks that live in my yard can get through it in a hurry when they want. And the assortment of squirrels and birds that congregate around my feeder.

    1513:

    We also occasionally have a pack of coyotes, though not recently.

    Coyotes are becoming a "problem" around here. Well to the extent that people let out their rabbit sized dogs without a leash or escort. And then get upset and think someone should do something. Ditto hawks and owls.

    Some of us shake out heads and leave the conversations.

    Telling them the coyotes are here due to the wolves being gone tends to create more tension than light.

    1514:

    sigh Look up "red scare" 1919.

    Hell, no, it was explicitly in support of the White Russians, or, better yet, to do to the then-just-born USSR what was being done right then to the Ottoman Empire.

    The capitalists were a) TERRIFIED of socialism, esp. in whole countries, and the chance that it might work, and b) they wanted then to do what they did starting in 1991 - emphasis on "vulture".

    1515:

    About the manager coming after him after he'd left: around '85 or so, I had a manager's manager who moved to another company, then called up and gave someone grief who had left the other company two weeks before a deadline.

    That got the manager fired.

    1516:

    "Strong thread of imposing democracy"

    That's right there with "kill for peace", and "we had to destroy the village to save it": IT WAS 500% LIE. It was ALL propaganda for the US market. They never had any plan to bring actual democracy there.

    Really - show me one country the US went into that had a real democracy afterwards. Vietnam? South Korea?

    1517:

    "During the early to mid 1990s things seemed to be going tolerably well."

    What is your source for this, Faux News?

    Every story I saw in the nineties and into the oughts said it was an utter, complete, and total disaster, with empty store shelves, actual starvation, and on and on.

    But I have to assume, from your statement, that what happens to the wealthy is all that matters.

    1518:

    EC
    Even now, with Bo Jon-Sun at the top we ara still not ( YET ) as dysfunctional as Ru - that will be the case by 2024 unless we are lucky! Ru is going to implode, anyway, unless they can get hold of money/resources - their population is small for the area, they are ill & the miltary overspend for their standard-of-living is ridiculous. So, he has to do something to keep the tiger trotting along, savaging others & not him.
    Unfortunately, this is a very similar situation ( Strong parallels, anyway ) with Nazi Germany in 1938-40 ... Overspent, huge miitary budget & limited & falling credit. Not quite as bad, because Putin is at least borderline-sane, unlike Dolfie.

    Lynxs .. Beautiful, strkeable, combeable, tickleable giant pussycats! Like this - just listen to the rumbling "purr" of this one ...

    1519:

    I will note that, whether or not you believe it, the USSR (and, I believe, Russia since) had an official stated policy of "no first strike", while the US refused to even suggest that.

    1520:

    The best trick I've found for getting rid of deer is a couple of modern LED camping flashlights. They don't have to particularly bright, but they do have to have a strobe feature. The best combination is if they have different strobe features (the SOS is particularly good in combination with one that blinks rapidly).

    To chase off the deer, you get the flashlights strobing in different patterns, take them out, and shine them at the deer, while yelling at them (it helps to have two or more people doing this). Imagine running through someone else's yard and leaping a fence with uncoordinated strobes messing with your vision. It gets the deer out quite nicely. They don't come back very quickly either.

    As for wildlife, my mom's been feeding her local raven clan for decades now. They have a special call for her and warn her when something's weird in the neighborhood. If I had more ravens around here I'd probably do the same. Living with wildlife is just...living with wildlife. You watch out for rattlesnakes and apologize to the birds for disturbing their feeding, and keep fence lizards around to keep off Lyme disease.

    1521:

    Yep. I know folks who put meat on the table that way, or buy it from the processors that the hunters take it to.

    "Wet market", anyone?

    1522:

    We agree, it was bullshit, a thin veneer at best. I was in the streets saying as much at the time, for all the good it did.

    I do think they had consumed their own PNAC brand Sugary Drink in thinking that they would create a Randian paradise of oil wealth. Certianly many of the apparatchiks on the ground, though I am fairly sure the cynicism of people like Cheney and Rumsfeld was profound.

    I was using that invasion as an example of when the world view and common assumptions of one culture do not mesh with the views and assumptions of another, if you read the entire post. I was not, at all, trying to claim that it was anything like truth.

    1523:

    So, the same as programmers and sysadmins: lazy is good - you need to do something more than once, you write a script, or a function, and make sure it's correct (had a co-worker who kept missing that step).

    1524:

    Nope. The US bases in Germany aren't "occupation forces", they're there by treaty. From when we were occupying forces.

    1525:

    Really - show me one country the US went into that had a real democracy afterwards. Vietnam? South Korea?

    I would say Texas, but I'm not sure anymore. California, perhaps? Sad to say, Hawai'i does qualify, since it was a monarchy prior to be conquered for sugar plantations.

    But getting back to your originals, I think that Japan and South Korea are as good a facsimile of democracy as we have in DC, although it took quite a lot of work in the case of South Korea. We might even add Germany to the list, conditionally.

    1526:

    The best trick I've found for getting rid of deer is a couple of modern LED camping flashlights. They don't have to particularly bright, but they do have to have a strobe feature.

    My reading indicates that most of the vision of a deer is off the edge of what we see. About 2/3s of it towards the UV direction. Which is why they get hit by cars at night. The typical incandescent headlights aren't all the bright to them. I wonder if the newer LED units are designed with some UV characteristics?

    As to LEDs, I suspect the effectiveness has much to do with light emissions we can't see. Of course I've never seen a spec on the UV characteristics of a hand held light. :)

    1527:

    As noted, absolute brightness doesn't matter, relative brightness does. We chased away three deer with an ordinary Petzl headlamp on strobe, and a keychain LED light on SOS, on a dark night. Try running at night with two strobes highlighting the scenery, if you don't get the idea.

    1528:

    If we had been under economic, political and (to some extent) military siege for decades by hostile countries with 15 times our wealth, how well do you think WE would be doing?

    1529:

    "Ru is going to implode,"

    DuH! Why do you think Putin feels like he needs a war ?

    1530:

    When we invaded Iraq, I was aware that the pretext was nonsense, but hoped we were cynically crippling OPEC. Turns out, well, I was too optimistic when I hoped that someone evil and competent was in charge...

    Looking at the US, is it possible that the CDC has simply given up and has opted to facilitate a collapse of the medical system, thereby maximizing deaths among the unvaccinated? That would, presumably, benefit the administration in power...

    I mean, mostly an emergent phenomenon, wherein home testing, the holidays, a new variant bypassing immunity, winter, all coincide. But, meh, CDC guidance reads like 'well, not much to do, keep the country running, and, well, welcome to Darwin.'

    1531:

    While, originally, that treaty was signed at gunpoint, that hasn't been the case for some time. Unlike Iraq, of course.

    1532:

    Thanks, I'm going to save that for use elsewhere if you don't mind. It's the perfect reply otherweb.

    It won't work. People who equate Socialist and Nazi because of the name are perfectly capable of believing that while discounting Democratic Republic as baseless propaganda. At least, that's been my experience since the 1980s while the GDR was still around…

    1533:

    If we had been under economic, political and (to some extent) military siege for decades by hostile countries with 15 times our wealth, how well do you think WE would be doing?

    Ask China, perhaps? They were there not very long ago.

    1534:

    @1530 [ "Looking at the US, is it possible that the CDC has simply given up and has opted to facilitate a collapse of the medical system, thereby maximizing deaths among the unvaccinated? That would, presumably, benefit the administration in power..." ]

    Fer Pete's sake, get a grip. The entire system, even such as it is, means the end of all cancer treatments, emergency appendicitis treatment -- the end of everything. Not even cynical moi can believe that the CDC wants that -- at least since the shoggoths are not in charge currently.

    1535:

    My guess at this point is that the CDC is badly demoralized, with multiple cases of really-bad depression among the higher-level bureaucrats.

    1536:

    While, originally, that treaty was signed at gunpoint, that hasn't been the case for some time.

    People keep tossing out one liners to simplify the last 100+ years of European history. It's nuts.

    Those oppressed German's LIKED (well mostly) having US and other nation's troops stationed there for the 40+ years after WWII. The Soviets had a, what, a 5 or 10 to one advantage in main battle tanks on the border. Which as a side diversion ties into the "No first strike pledge." If the US takes off the table the first use of nukes then the CCCP new it could win most any conventional battle.

    And I've yet to meet any (west) German's who wanted the CCCP to occupy all of Germany. I'm sure there were some but they seem to be thin on the ground. I spend an evening not too long ago with someone who grew up on the border. He was talking about when the border fell. The foot traffic was 99% east to west. The easterners were all curious about the west. The westerners not so much the east.

    Now my wife's mother is German. From the Stuttgart area. There is a story of a family get together where my wife's (older by 15+ years) cousin was going on and on about how the East Germans had it so much better in terms of, well, everything than the West Germans. Her father shut down the debate by stating that "that wall was obviously built to stop the huge flow of West Germans to the east.

    1537:

    My guess at this point is that the CDC is badly demoralized, with multiple cases of really-bad depression among the higher-level bureaucrats.

    You could be right. A more charitable reading is that they've got metrics telling them that a lock-down at this point would be irrelevant. The people who will do it already know the drill. The people who want to do it probably still can't, and the people who need it probably won't do it, because at best they're only now getting around to getting vaccinated in the first place. It's another version of "only give an order that you're pretty sure will be followed."

    Whether any such hypothetical metrics are correct is another question entirely.

    A less charitable explanation is that the White House has decided that they're in a tough political spot, that any lockdown orders they give now will be used as political cudgels against them, and that they're instead going to gear up emergency support to collapsing hospitals, especially in red states, rather than trying to get the non-compliant parts of the US to try to comply now, because being saved by heroes is more 'Murrican than not needing heroes in the first place (gak.).

    And of course, it could be any or all of these three in combination.

    1538:

    You left out the "No mandates or die" crowd who will use it to drive up the frenzy level.

    And the court battles in Florida and Texas would drag on long after it was to happen and end. And without those states on board (plus all of them in between) what would the point be?

    1539:

    If we had been under economic, political and (to some extent) military siege for decades by hostile countries with 15 times our wealth, how well do you think WE would be doing?

    Regardless of any real or imagined issues like you suggest, Russia should be doing far better.

    They have enormous valuable natural resources to generate revenue for the country and an education system that while it may possibly be uneven is known for putting out top class scientists, mathematicians and engineers.

    Their problem is leadership and an insistence on acting as though we are still living in the past, wasting money on military adventures in the middle east and elsewhere.

    1540:

    PHK
    Yes - & where do you think the phrase: Short, Victorious War came from then?
    Because, unless Putin gets exactly that, it will drag on & Ru really collapses. I think he's be really stupid to start one, but, he may feel he "has no choice" - he does, of course, but ...
    See also mdive @ 1639

    1541:

    "I figure anyone who's worried about getting in trouble for posts on an international blog deserves a wee bit of slack."

    Sleepingroutine has nothing to fear posting on here, he is literally posting Russian propaganda. I mean he was posting NKVD apologism:

    "So yeah, a rhetorical question, what could possibly such list achieve, especially when the people on their duty of protecting the country are called "perpetrators"? What "human rights", "memories" and "history" can such people receive, not to talk about their descendants? What is the goal of calling every criminal in the system as "a victim" regardless of their record? Etc, etc."

    Peoples seeming inability to see what SR is doing is mystifying. Your comment:

    "Of course, the normal response to something like the last paragraph is a DARVO: deny the possibility, attack me for pointing it out, then reverse the victim and offender to accuse me of being the attacker, to justify a disproportionate negative response. Let's see what happens."

    Seems like a neat way to avoid criticism!

    1542:

    "Wasting money in the Middle East? I'm sorry, are you talking about Russia or the US?

    1543:

    David L @ 1498:

    It was only winter according to the calendar, not according to the weather.

    When just had a week where the high each day was near or just above 70F(21C). We might have gotten to 75F Fri/Sat. A front just came through generating gusts of up to 50mph and some Noah looking rain. Temp is now in the 30s and still falling. Snow flurries but they melt when they hit ground. And the morning low should be 25F(-4C).

    How do you plan?

    It was only raining this morning when I took the dog out for his walk. By the time I got ready to make my annual trek down to the county tax office at noon it was snowing heavily and still raining ... plus the wind gusts were strong enough to almost knock me down.

    But I've paid my taxes & won't have to brave the elements downtown again for another year and looking out my window there's a nice, warm alpenglow just beginning to form on the side of my neighbor's house.

    My plan is to turn my electric blanket on before I go to bed tonight & snuggle in an extra while in the morning ... at least until the crack of noon.

    1544:

    Heteromeles @ 1509:

    Most deer now live in the "burbs" in the US. We grow food they really like and it is more nutritious than what is found in the "wild". So the they have more live births that survive the first year in the "burbs". And no one (well virtually no one) is going to say let's drop wolves into the burbs. Or go for rifle hunting in the land of apartments and 1/3 and smaller lots with houses.

    Wolves also really, really hate being around that many humans. Mountain lions do too, but they do marginally better in the suburbs, until they get conditioned enough to attack a human who annoys them.

    However, there is one key bit that's missing. In deer hunting country (I'm used to Wisconsin), hunting is allowed in the outer burbs. But rifle hunting is not. It's bowhunting and shotgunning with slugs only, because the lethal range for a slug is around 100 meters, not five miles. Where human density is low enough, this is perfectly viable.

    Out here in Southern California, that doesn't work. Mostly deer are in fairly open country (giggling at calling chaparral open, but still). Usually deer hunting is done at extreme range (300-500 meters), so rifles are mandatory and deer don't get hunted in the burbs. Instead, we use things like cars, droughts, wildfires, and mountain lions to try to keep the deer under control.

    One of my enduring memories from Ft. Carson, CO was driving up through a suburb on Cheyenne Mountain (yes, THAT Cheyenne Mountain) and coming to a stop sign ... looking to the right there were joggers on the sidewalk and deer calmly grazing in the front yards right next to the sidewalks. Talk about habituated to human presence ...

    One of the big disappointments the first time you go to Ft. Carson is looking up at Cheyenne Mountain and seeing all the antennas up there only to be told later those are for the local TV & radio stations. All the MILITARY communications facilities are either buried in the side of the mountain or remotely located using underground cables.

    1545:

    @1535 -- Absolutely, though we don't need to guess, we know the CDC is demoralized, in the same ways medical people and teachers and so many others are. They keep advocating and doing the right things and about 35% of the country responds with howls of how they should be killed.

    Ya, that is demoralizing all right. Which is why so many people in these areas of expertise and experience in their careers are quitting.

    Our governor tells us, that despite Omicron seemingly being less dangerous, at least for fully vaxed healthy people, our state is in a terrible situation which can only get worse -- yet teachers are expected to teach f2f. Same in Chicago where the Teachers Union are demanding distance learning not f2f -- and lets not forget the students -- not vaxed, too young or bad parents -- and the parents who howl about both masking and testing for the classroom, and literally threaten the teachers with violence and other harms.

    1546:

    Do they actually have a working Stargate there? :-)

    1547:

    I'm not sure what the problem is, and I'm not particularly astute politically, but I'd love to see Biden declare an emergency, shoot the next judge who rules against any kind of pro-vaccination rule, haul most of the Republican governors to Gitmo to be held against some kind of criminal public-health charge, and vaccinate everything that moves. (IMHO he should have done that on Inaugeration day!)

    Watching the Republicans auto-Darwinate is not nearly so nice as a properly-led public-health response would have been (or would be.) In fact, it's rather difficult to watch.

    My rather ugly suspicion is that Democrats will win the next election purely on COVID-death demographic changes, and I can only hope I will be properly humble and mournful of all the deaths, and not cackle maniacally at the behavior of a self-executing political enemy, despite my rather despicable urge to do just that.

    If I sound ranty, pissed-off, and confused, there's a reason for that!

    1548:

    whitroth @ 1519: I will note that, whether or not you believe it, the USSR (and, I believe, Russia since) had an official stated policy of "no first strike", while the US refused to even suggest that.

    ... while their MILITARY doctrine vis-à-vis NATO called for tactical nuclear weapons to be used as an opening salvo to clear pathways through West Germany for the motor rifle divisions to reach the Rhine in seven days.

    You can endlessly debate whose plans were morally justified, but the bottom line is NATO never invaded the Warsaw Pact and the USSR did not invade NATO despite whatever contingency plans either might have drawn up.

    You cannot assign fault to one side or the other for a war that never happened!

    1549:

    paws4thot @ 1546: Do they actually have a working Stargate there? :-)

    Inside Cheyenne Mountain? I dunno. They stopped doing "civilian" tours before the first time I went to Ft. Carson, so I've never been inside.

    Google image search results for "Inside Cheyenne Mountain"

    1550:

    Do they actually have a working Stargate there?

    If he tells you he has to kill you.

    There are much more secret areas of the US. The people who "work" in them can be strange to talk to.

    1551:

    I'm used to that; it's my stock response to my North American and ANZ relatives if they ask what my job is.

    1552:

    What is this "talk to" that you're referring to?

    My son, who's finally looking for a job in a different agency (I won't mention who he works for), hasn't been able to meet anyone, or have friends. He can't talk about work, or co-workers, or anything.

    I commented that where he works is really bad for him, and he responded that working for any agency in the DoD is bad for its people.

    1553:

    You could be right. A more charitable reading is that they've got metrics telling them that a lock-down at this point would be irrelevant.

    We are rapidly approaching the 2nd anniversary of the first major lockdowns outside of Italy/Spain/China.

    The Covid threats remain for the most part abstract. Not to minimize the deaths or the pain of those who have lost loved ones, but the number of deaths simply isn't anywhere close to high enough for the average person to feel threatened.

    The real threat is to the hospitals, and again that is abstract - most of the population doesn't interact with hospitals in any given year and as a species we are generally arrogant enough that even when doing risky things (like driving a car) we assume nothing will happen to us - so we won't need said hospital.

    So in general people aren't willing to put up with any major intrusions to their lives anymore. While I have noted that generally everyone around where I live wears masks it has been notable that there is no indication any of the retailers are enforcing a 50% occupancy rule this time around.

    But, to get back to the CDC, I think part of it also is that they like everyone can guess at the future - that the Republicans will be back in charge come 2022/2024 - and they are preparing for that future by not risking their necks on reprisals.

    1554:

    How do you plan?

    A quote from today's paper. Over a few hours Monday, the Triangle saw thunder, lightning, pounding rain, gusting winds, sunshine, sleet and snow — everything but frogs.

    And by 2:00pm it was sunny with not much wind.

    And an area in rural Texas had some fish fall from the sky the other day. I think they got caught up by a small water spout.

    1555:

    "Wasting money in the Middle East? I'm sorry, are you talking about Russia or the US?

    Russia.

    Who decided to join in the fun of playing in the desert and entered the Syrian conflict.

    Because, at a guess, it plays well at home - look, we are still a superpower.

    Which isn't to say the US isn't wasting significantly more money in the Middle East, just that they aren't alone in playing soldier in the area.

    1556:

    If we had been under economic, political and (to some extent) military siege for decades by hostile countries with 15 times our wealth, how well do you think WE would be doing?

    Ask the Haitians — they've had experience with that.

    1557:

    they're instead going to gear up emergency support to collapsing hospitals, especially in red states

    Well, the governor of Texas has requested emergency medical aid from the Federal government. Gotta admire those proud independent stand-on-their-own-feet Texans…

    1558:

    The real threat is to the hospitals,

    I have various relationships with medical folks. They are totally fed up with the no masking, anti-vac, it is all a hoax, I'll wear a mask but keep it on my chin, folks. Utterly.

    When you are a nurse in an infusion clinic dealing with transplant and cancer patients taking immune suppressive drugs and attending funerals anyway, these folks are considered insane. Or working in an ED with face masks and such.

    While the ethos in the medical community in general is we treat everyone who shows up, more and more they are thinking "why not ship them to a local gym with cots and let their medical experts treat them?"

    1559:

    My guess at this point is that the CDC is badly demoralized, with multiple cases of really-bad depression among the higher-level bureaucrats.

    My guess would be depression being more common at the lower levels, where studies are done, recommendations formulated, and you get to see that it's all useless because you get ignored.

    Certainly you have many more nurses quitting than hospital administrators (for example). Of course, nurses have been hit with pay cuts while administrators are getting bonuses. (Not to mention priority access to PPE and vaccines, even when they work remotely.)

    1560:

    They are totally fed up with the no masking, anti-vac, it is all a hoax, I'll wear a mask but keep it on my chin, folks. Utterly.

    presumably by the time they get to deal with them they've started rowing back the "it's all a hoax" part tho

    1561:

    While the ethos in the medical community in general is we treat everyone who shows up, more and more they are thinking "why not ship them to a local gym with cots and let their medical experts treat them?"

    It isn't restricted to them.

    I have heard from people who are fed up that we are going into yet more restrictions all because a small percentage of the population are acting like spoiled little kids and refusing to get vaccinated.

    1562:

    Well, the governor of Texas has requested emergency medical aid from the Federal government. Gotta admire those proud independent stand-on-their-own-feet Texans…

    Not the first time that Texas has run to the United States for help. My understanding was that the Republic of Texas was bankrupt in the 1840s when it joined the United States to prevent reconquest by Mexico. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Republic_of_Texas)

    As the independent Republic of Texas, they also tried to claim California, in their failed bid to extend to the Pacific. There's some sort of continuity of their internal politics, can't put my finger on it... (/Sarcasm)

    1563:

    I'd put it as simpler than that.

    Since I'm an environmentalist, I can readily, readily point to the contemptuous ignorance that most people display towards climate change. This includes even some environmentalists, who have no problem flying all over the world to reward themselves for the good job they're doing, getting others to cut back on fossil fuel emission.

    If I was black, I could point to the US' 400 year-long history of importing slaves, while pretending all men are created equal.

    If I was Indian, I could point to a 500 year-long history of enslaving and/or massacring native peoples throughout the western hemisphere, all while glamorizing these "noble savages" and playing pretend Indians, but not helping real ones.

    Hispanics, Asians, gays? How far do you want to go?

    I'd say that the refusal of a group of reactionary, mostly white, mostly loudly and hypocritically "Christian" people to get vaccinated for the public good is absolutely typical of the way they and their ancestors have behaved in the face of a host of previous evils and threats. When you think of it this way, it's actually pleasant that only 30% of the US population is in this particular camp.

    It's just too bad that gaining clarity about one horrible, life-threatening problem doesn't automatically help with gaining clarity about all the others.

    1564:

    Well, not in the US though a lot of what you say likely still applies.

    But in our case it really is closer to a small minority.

    Ontario's adult population is at 88.6% fully vaccinated, so 11.4% trouble makers.

    We are at 77.6% fully vaccinated if we include under 5 (no vaccine) and 5-11 (only eligible for 1 shot so far, 43% at one shot)

    So it really is apparently a small number of people causing a lot of misery for everyone else.

    https://www.thestar.com/news/canada/2021/01/07/covid-19-vaccine-tracker-tracing-every-dose-of-the-coronavirus-vaccine-administered-in-canada.html

    1565:

    For the first 8 years we were in our house there was a large black bear sow that lived in the neighbourhood as well.

    Reminds me of a bear that Mary Roach mentioned in her recent book Fuzz: when nature breaks the law.

    Roach demonstrates a beautiful case of nature facilitating cohabitation between animals and humans in Aspen, Colorado. We’ve all seen animals snooping for food, but according to Roach, the bears of this mountainous town take it to another level. Here, residents don’t just find bears dumpster-diving; they find bears snatching food off dinner tables and hiding in the rooms of houses. There is hope for the future though: laid-back bears, like an infamous one nicknamed "Fat Albert," are favored by natural selection because they calmly carry out their food operations in such a suave manner that homeowners can tolerate it. They are therefore more likely to get away, survive, and pass on their calm temperaments to their offspring.

    More deer anecdata: Last year, my mother witnessed a doe giving birth to a faun. The doe was in the back yard, my mother was in her kitchen. In the north end of a city of 380K people.

    1566:

    David L replied to a comment from JBS at January 3, 2022 15:25 #1497:

    The other problem is there are no longer large predators capable of taking down deer in most of the U.S.

    I dono. I would consider autos a large predator. They take out around 1 million per year.

    Witness this result from within the Portland (Oregon) Metro, from I-5 at 55mph:

    https://imgur.com/a/0yEC8l8

    1567:

    On two occasions in our neighbourhood a bear has wandered into someone's house. In both cases it was during the day, and a parent home with preschoolers.

    One of the families locked themselves in the bathroom and called 911. The second time the kids were locked in the bathroom, and the mom's boyfriend punched the bear in the nose and chased it out of the house.

    Effective but high risk strategy.

    1568:

    Oh, yes, but you need to read my reply and the context again. The assertion was that the UK is not as dysfunctional as Russia, and I pointed out that is not ALL due to the superiority(*) of its governance. Russia is BOTH dysfunctional AND being attacked from outside by a vastly more powerful force.

    (*) as in "there's small choice in rotten apples".

    1569:

    That is revisionism.

    The USA started arming and financing Syrian terrorists in 2010 (yes, before the Arab Spring); this has been admitted in a congressional hearing, so is official. The intent was to overthrow Assad and kick Russia out of its last overseas base, so Russia had no alternative but to back Assad or accept that. All attempts by Russia to agree a 'regime change' with the USA were rejected, because that was never the USA's objective.

    1570:

    Rbt Prior
    Doubtless to be followed in election years by Niagara's of verbal sewage about how grasping evil & treacherous those Washington libruls, are ...
    - H ... Yeah, they are arrogant, selfish arseholes.

    Adrian Smith
    No
    Several & well-noted cases of people & couples dying of C-19. maintaining it's a hoax, even as they snuff it.

    mdive
    I have heard from people who are fed up that we are going into yet more restrictions all because a small percentage of the population are acting like spoiled little kids and refusing to get vaccinated. - - include me in there. My local area vaccination rate is ridiculously low: 1st dose - 66.7% / 2nd - 61.9% / 3rd - 37.4%

    1571:

    Witness this result from within the Portland (Oregon) Metro, from I-5 at 55mph:

    I was in a car driven by my cousin in the later 60s when we took out a deer at more than a trivial speed. Deer was killed. Car had much more front end damage than that photo. My cousin was totally pissed due to, (I'm guessing in hindsight), no collision insurance. (My cousin is 10 years older than me and was driving responsibly.) And since it was a mid to late 60s car it survived so we could keep driving but he was looking at a lot of body work.

    Talking to the park ranger where we were this was a common occurrence in the area.

    1572:

    presumably by the time they get to deal with them they've started rowing back the "it's all a hoax" part tho

    A few. But in many cases, especially in some states, families put a lot of pressure on docs/admins to NOT list Covid as the cause of death as it wasn't real and would cause issues with friends/relatives and ...

    My brother and his clan were claiming that hospitals were listing Covid to get more money from the feds when the real cause of death was something else. Such as pneumonia. I had no idea my gene pool could be so stupid.

    These reports from medical people seem to have died out in 2021. But from "no longer news" or "no longer happening much", I don't know.

    1573:

    Certainly you have many more nurses quitting than hospital administrators (for example). Of course, nurses have been hit with pay cuts while administrators are getting bonuses. (Not to mention priority access to PPE and vaccines, even when they work remotely.)

    Must be a Canadian thing. Not the way it has gone down in most of the US. Nurses are paid by the hour so hospitals are paying them a LOT more than normal due to overtime and such. And the mid to upper level admins are putting in more time with no overtime (salaried). And getting the majority of the abuse by the crazies.

    And both groups getting burned out by it all.

    1574:

    I think it's just some confusion about what the roles are in hospitals. The people who are in charge of hospitals, at least over here, are usually doctors who've gone into management. Administrators are the people on reception desks and other relatively menial, low-paid tasks, who actually make things work and get the brunt of everything when something goes wrong, pretty much from everyone including patients, doctors and nurses and senior management. Health systems are basically heat engines that run by burning admin staff. Their work is rarely valued and practically no-one listens to them, even though it doesn't take a genus to see how much effort goes into just the day-to-day stuff (sometimes exacerbated by IT systems that require complex and labour-intensive manual processes when something goes wrong, or even when they don't and are just crap by design...).

    There's a general confusion this plays into. Over here there's a distinction between enrolled nurses (ENs) which are a diploma level career path and registered nurses (RNs) which are degree-plus-prac and fully fledged clinicians (there are also "nurse practitioners" who can be individually authorised to prescribe certain drugs and order diagnostics). I think (per discussion here) in the UK there are no ENs, but a similar role is referred to as "nursing assistant". In contrast "admin" is neither of these, but nor is it "senior management", which is what Robert appeared to be thinking of up above. It's worth noting that cost accounting is always labour intensive, so I'd imagine a need for more admin staff where more of this is required, though I don't see that those would be the people getting "bonuses".

    1575:

    Worked personal account:-

    I was an out-patient in one unit where the receptionist was known as "the dragon lady", for the ferocious way she dealt with people checking in for clinics. I arrived when she was having a fight with the computer (running Mickeyshaft Windoze NT/4 BTW) and was politely sympathetic to her. After that she was always polite, efficient and helpful when dealing with me.

    So think about being "nice" to your administrators, because it will make your life easier.

    1576:

    The facts are as I stated.

    While partially true, your anecdata reminds me of the last two sentences of 1984 :-)

    1577:

    presumably by the time they get to deal with them they've started rowing back the "it's all a hoax" part tho

    Some have. Some haven't. Some have anti-vaxxer relatives who hassle medical staff to use the latest fad cure they saw on Twitter that morning…

    1578:

    I wasn't rebuting you. At least I didn't mean to.

    But I did have 30 years of conversations with someone born in 1928 Germany who grew up there. Stories of friends of her older sister disappearing from college who were involved in criticizing the Hitler government in the early to mid 30s. (Dachau was started about then just down the road.) The family portrait in my living room with a bullet hole through it from 45. Various friends of all ages who live there now who we discuss things with. And so on.

    Yes it is anecdata but it fits with the history I've read. Not while in school but on my own.

    1579:

    Around 40 people are killed and 200 injured by road accidents involving deer every year in England (2019 figures). One particular stretch of the A11 going through Breckland is one of the contributors to these figures. it’s reasonably common to see Roe Deer and Muntjac by the side of the roads alive and also to see them as roadkills. But the roadkills don’t last wrong unless they’re badly mangled because at least one local butcher in a nearby town buys them for meat. I’ve seen people load roadkills into the boots of their cars. But they do have some street cred. Unlike hares who always run directly away with the cars chasing them. When they see cars at night they stare and then move to one side. Deer are also possibly aware of the timing of traffic since there is always an increase in road kills when the hour goes back in Autumn

    1580:

    I have heard from people who are fed up that we are going into yet more restrictions all because a small percentage of the population are acting like spoiled little kids and refusing to get vaccinated.

    Not to mention those who have had surgeries and cancer screenings cancelled yet again to free up hospital space for the mostly-unvaccinated…

    Or those locked into long-term care again…

    1581:

    Must be a Canadian thing. Not the way it has gone down in most of the US. Nurses are paid by the hour so hospitals are paying them a LOT more than normal due to overtime and such. And the mid to upper level admins are putting in more time with no overtime (salaried). And getting the majority of the abuse by the crazies.

    In Ontario our nurses got limited to a less-than-inflation wage increase by the government (1%) just after the police got 8.5%/0%/0%/5% (and some MPPs got 14%).

    Nurses may be earning more with overtime, but per-hour they're losing money. And have lost a lot of flexibility in turning down shifts and assignments.

    In terms of America, other than anecdata from a couple of nieces working in health care down there* I see things like this article in the Atlantic:

    https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2021/11/the-mass-exodus-of-americas-health-care-workers/620713/

    Several health-care workers told me that, amid the most grueling working conditions of their careers, their hospitals cut salaries, reduced benefits, and canceled raises; forced staff to work more shifts with longer hours; offered trite wellness tips, such as keeping gratitude journals, while denying paid time off or reduced hours; failed to provide adequate personal protective equipment; and downplayed the severity of their experiences.

    The American Hospital Association, which represents hospital administrators, turned down my interview request; instead, it sent me links to a letter that criticized anticompetitive pricing from travel-nursing agencies and to a report showing that staff shortages have cost hospitals $24 billion over the course of the pandemic. But from the perspective of health-care workers, those financial problems look at least partly self-inflicted: Many workers left because they were poorly treated or compensated, forcing hospitals to hire travel nurses at greater cost. Those nurses then stoke resentment among full-time staff who are paid substantially less but are often asked to care for the sickest patients. And in some farcical situations, “hospitals hired their own staff back as travel nurses and paid them higher rates,” Bettencourt said.

    Also relevant to an earlier comment:

    COVID patients are also becoming harder to deal with. Most now are unvaccinated, and while some didn’t have a choice in the matter, those who did are often belligerent and vocal. Even after they’re hospitalized, some resist basic medical procedures like proning or oxygenation, thinking themselves to be fighters, only to become delirious, anxious, and impulsive when their lungs struggle for oxygen. Others have assaulted nurses, thrown trash around their rooms, and yelled for hydroxychloroquine or ivermectin, neither of which has any proven benefit for COVID-19. Once, Americans clapped for health-care heroes; now “we’re at war with a virus and its hosts are at war with us,” Werry told me.

    I saw a different story, which I can't locate just now, interviewing a nurse who had quit. Increased hours and reduced salary, and the hospital administrator had been given a bonus for 'controlling costs'…

    *One being a surgeon who worked in NYC with one mask a week during the early stages of the pandemic, while your president was claiming there was no pandemic and no equipment shortages while starving anywhere that didn't vote for him of assistance…

    1582:

    That wasn't my point. East Germany was a hell-hole, Hitler's Germany was much worse and Stalin's USSR was pretty bad; the post-Stalin was more dysfunctional than anything else. No dissent there.

    But the stories that the USSR had squadrons of tanks poised to invade were lying propaganda, pure and simple. I was fed those stories (and w.r.t. nuclear weapons and so on), but subsequent disclosure showed that they were a pack of lies, and the authorities knew they were. The USSR then, as Russia today, is afraid of the West's vastly superior technology and resources, and uses almost its only advantages (manpower and tanks) to discourage the West from invading.

    1583:

    And that, dear children, is why it is impossible to have an intelligent discussion about international matters with "Real Americans"...

    1584:

    There has been some discussion her3e about extremism in the US military. Therefore, this may be of interest: https://www.politico.com/news/2022/01/04/pentagon-extremism-ranks-jan-6-526441

    1585:

    EC
    If you compare Ru vs NATO forces, the Ru have more men, concentrated on the ground, but a smaller number of them in total. Their tank numbers are also less than NATO. In purely military terms, their only advantage is interior, shorter lines of communication & high concentration of their avilable forces.
    Almost everywhere, their total numbers are lower, in some cases, ridiculously lower.
    IIRC they only "match" in actual artillery & in personnel-carriers .....

    1586:

    Of course there is a rather more understated British version. "I could tell you but it would bore you to death." See the works of John le Carré for fictional examples worked out in excruciating detail, then consider the same principle applied to someone whose job is nothing more than sitting in an office shuffling figures to begin with.

    1587:

    "Lynxs .. Beautiful, strkeable, combeable, tickleable giant pussycats!"

    In the same way, the discussion of wolves is reminding me of Freefall. DOGGY!

    1588:

    "I wonder if the newer LED units are designed with some UV characteristics?

    As to LEDs, I suspect the effectiveness has much to do with light emissions we can't see. Of course I've never seen a spec on the UV characteristics of a hand held light. :)"

    Nope, no UV. An LED emits in a single narrowish band with a half-power width of about 50nm or less. A "white" LED is an ordinary narrowish-band blue LED emitting at 450nm or so, with a blob of phosphor on top to down-convert some of that emission into longer wavelengths. So they all have much the same kind of spectrum, with only minor variations: absolutely nothing in the ordinary violet or UV, a ruddy great spike at 450nm, back down to bugger all again in the bluey-green region, then a broad camelious hump over most of the rest of the visible range with a maximum roughly around 550-600nm. For a typical example download a manufacturer's datasheet for any old random "white" LED and there should be a spectrum in it somewhere.

    The lights relevant to the situation that do have significant near UV emission are HID headlights on cars. These produce light by a messy broadband-plus-spikes mechanism in plasma, and a fair bit of it falls into the UV region naturally. The glass is supposed to "block UV" but it is not a brick wall filter and a decent amount of near UV still gets out. Some people replace the "reasonably normal" colour temperature bulbs their cars come with with "bloody silly" ones that look very blue indeed or even purple, and I'd expect those to emit even more UV.

    I'm not sure that mammals (unlike, say, birds or bees) do see UV particularly though. In humans the retina certainly can respond to it, but it doesn't get through the lens; people who have their lenses removed for cataracts gain this minor extra ability as a side effect. AFAIK mammals with limited colour vision to begin with are most sensitive to the green and blue visible regions, which is where the most radiation is (plants are perverse); there's not a lot of point in them having an ability to see UV anyway. But their insensitivity to red is significant, for which reason some people use red lights for watching nocturnal wildlife.

    1589:

    "Unlike hares who always run directly away with the cars chasing them."

    Well, it makes sense if you're a hare. (Or a pigeon, for that matter.) Whatever's chasing you most likely can't run as fast as you can, so all you have to do is run away in a straight line and you're sorted. If you try and go sideways you give it a chance to cut the corner and it might then be able to get you. So you don't do that unless it does manage to catch up with you, and then you do it right at the very last possible instant to try and win on manoeuvrability instead.

    See also the difficulty of persuading a Devon sheep to stop running straight down the lane and turn off through one of the holes in the hedge instead. All you can do of course is slow down, and then it thinks you've given up chasing it and stops trying to get away...

    1590:

    AFAIK mammals with limited colour vision to begin with are most sensitive to the green and blue visible regions, which is where the most radiation is (plants are perverse); there's not a lot of point in them having an ability to see UV anyway. But their insensitivity to red is significant, for which reason some people use red lights for watching nocturnal wildlife.

    The reason plants don't eat green isn't obvious, but it is interesting: https://www.quantamagazine.org/why-are-plants-green-to-reduce-the-noise-in-photosynthesis-20200730/

    1591:

    Er, yes, I was thinking in historical terms, and not being clear. That is why it is such bullshit to claim that Russia is is going to attack the West, or even attempting to expand its borders; Putin knows damn well that it would succeed, initially, but would then be demolished. Ukraine's claims are even more the converse of the truth, but are promulgated by anti-Russian idiots and bigots in the West.

    https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/ukraine-emily-in-paris-war-b1986559.html

    The last I heard (Reuters, if I recall) is that Russia had WITHDRAWN many or most of its troops from Ukraine's borders. If Russia wanted to invade, it could trivially have done at any time since 2013; it makes no sense for it to do so now, when the USA/NATO has been arming Ukraine up to the teeth. What I expect to happen is that Ukraine is going to attack first, to recover its territory and complete the pogrom it started in 2013, and will claim that Russia is invading when the latter responds.

    It will then come down to whether Biden is suckered by the "Russia must die" camp into starting WW III. From his rhetoric, I am horribly afraid that he will :-(

    1592:

    It's not just in Devon. I have had a sheep run half a mile before me, as I walked along a farm road. But that was through an open field, with other sheep to either side! Talk about stupid.

    1593:

    Around 40 people are killed and 200 injured by road accidents involving deer every year in England (2019 figures).

    Top Google hit for such in the US states:

    1.23 million collisions per year

    200 deaths

    10,000 injuries

    I suspect most of the deaths are from when a deer jumps and then come into the car through the front window. If it dies things will be bad enough. If alive and "kicking" I would not want to be in the car. If you just ram one, the seat belts and air bags will typically keep things to "just a bad day".

    1594:

    I'm not sure that mammals (unlike, say, birds or bees) do see UV particularly though. In humans the retina certainly can respond to it, but it doesn't get through the lens; people who have their lenses removed for cataracts gain this minor extra ability as a side effect.

    Apparently deer eye lenses don't filter out much UV like most mammals. Which may explain why they tend to be nocturnal. Or it is a very wide spread bit of misinformation.

    1595:

    but subsequent disclosure showed that they were a pack of lies, and the authorities knew they were.

    I'm open to being wrong. Show me some links to details please. I'm thinking 1945 to 1990.

    1596:

    As far as nuclear weapons goes, the references include An Official History of MI5 and a book on the Skunk Works, plus commonly-available information on the technologies (*). Plus LOTS of references describing the unreliable (and scarcity) of the USSR's technology. No, I haven't kept links. You could also read The Third World War by Hackett, though I can't recommend it.

    (*) Together, those made it explicit that the USSR did NOT have an effective retaliatory capability against a USA first strike, and made it clear that the converse was not true. Krushchev was scared, not aggressive, in 1962. It is possible that applies today with Russia and the USA.

    1597:

    I'd say rather that Putin's found that bribery, psyops, and infowar are cheaper and more effective against the US than big iron and nukes are, and has shifted his strategy accordingly.

    1598:

    I'd also point out that there are two frames for what's going on.

    One is the old, nationalist US/USSR nation-state feud.

    The other is basically plutocracy versus democracy, where a few ultra-rich people are trying with fair success to put themselves above any law, like the old god-kings, while the rest of us suffer under their laws, unless we can chain them down.

    Given that some of the new "offshore money havens" on the globe are now poor red states in the US (the Dakotas, for example), I'd suggest that the second frame's more useful.

    Thing to remember is that Putin's more a plutocrat who might want to be a Czar-oid. When he's attacking the US government, it's worth thinking about what he and his coterie get out of it. It might be less safety for the state of Russia, and a bit more on protecting his personal power, which might run through wealth managers in US red states through a gratuitous number of cutouts.

    1599:

    Re: 'Putin's more a plutocrat who might want to be a Czar-oid. When he's attacking the US government, it's worth thinking about what he and his coterie get out of it.'

    Tend to agree with this - a lot of the activity (pre-Covid) seemed to be directed at showing the world how well Russia could out-do the US in glitz via newly made billionaires some of whom were unmade when they crossed Putin.

    Russia - Ukraine: I've no idea what the Russia and Ukraine military personnel vax rates are but if they're similar to their overall populations' (as per Johns Hopkins Covid Tracker) then neither is likely to have a reliably large number of healthy military personnel to sustain any long haul operation. That said, the biggest threat would be cyber attacks which don't need physically healthy specimens capable of withstanding fierce winter conditions, etc. Not sure side which would win that type of campaign.

    BTW - thanks for the aviation articles - very interesting. The story about the wire tap made me laugh --- so Tricky Dick era: Bug your 'enemy', you'll probably not get caught!

    1600:

    Did you actually read that article?

    "Nato will not put boots on the ground in Ukraine – as the British defence secretary, Ben Wallace, correctly pointed out recently."

    Rather makes your position seem unlikely.

    1601:

    David L @ 1550:

    Do they actually have a working Stargate there?

    If he tells you he has to kill you.

    Nope. I'm retired and I don't have to kill anyone unless I want to.

    There are much more secret areas of the US. The people who "work" in them can be strange to talk to.

    I was in one of them a couple of them when I worked for the fire & burglar alarm company. Escorted by armed guards while I did my work. I had to fill out an FBI background investigation questionnaire providing details of everywhere I'd lived for the preceding 25 years. I was about 30 years old at the time ... and they DID go and talk to all the neighbors.

    Oddly enough, nothing to do with weapons technology, it was where the military kept the computers for a (regional?) finance & accounting office.

    1602:

    and they DID go and talk to all the neighbors.

    I got a summer job at the plant where my father worked. It was a thing for college students to work there. If one of your parents worked regularly at the plant it was much easier to get you a clearance. So every summer they'd bring in us family college students to cut grass, scrape paint, and in general move that pile of stuff from there to here.

    When they stopped by the community college where I was that spring they talked to a friend. The FBI dude flashed his badge. My friend asked if he could see it. And then made sure it looked real and the picture matched. The FBI dude then went around asking about my friend. This was 1972 I think.

    I met an ex Cray system engineer (repair tech) who got called into Ft. Mead NSA HQ to fix their Cray. He did NOT have a clearance as all of the folks with such were all not available. So two military MPs plus an admin or two shadowed him in and during the repairs. He then said he was ready to leave and they told him they wanted him to stay until the current run was done. He threw a hissy fit and the NSA decided they'd be better off with him OUT of the building. A computer run back then could be days.

    1603:

    As Spider Robinson wrote, "God is an Iron". Substantiated by this newsflash from Behind The Orange Curtain: https://boingboing.net/2022/01/04/california-deputy-da-who-opposed-vaccine-mandate-dies-from-covid-at-age-46.html

    1604:

    (On a side topic, I've had a good rundown on No Country for Old Men analytics. There is original in Russian, but I found a similar video in English)

    to Paul @1501:

    But half way through I accidentally closed the tab I was working in, and I can't be bothered any more. sleepingroutine is welcome to go off and believe what he wants.

    Seems like be a generous present on your side but I doubt this will be the last time this talk happens.

    to Heteromeles @1510:

    There's also Paul Linebarger's point (in Psychological Warfare) about people who think that everything's propaganda are paradoxically easier to influence with propaganda.

    It is, so to say, a slippery slope of psychology of projection. I have seen it sometimes in people, when they just become suddenly agitated and attack for no rational reason (to score some points maybe), and then assume they are attacked back (regardless of what actually happened), and become paranoid, and it doesn't matter what you do, they will say it's your fault and start pulling in other people too. It is called a "destructive behaviour", either it destroys humans, or humans prevail and destroys it.

    It is impossible to understand it, impossible to prevent it in a good will. We Russians keep good relationships and economical ties with our neighbours, while at the same time their leaders lash at us and blame all of their trouble on us becasue they think we are stronger. They keep demanding more and keep threatening us with their "powerful friends" and "strong ties". And our government still thinks it is possible to negotiate, to mitigate, to agree. Our bureaucrats are still soft on opposition. Our country still doesn't want to see itself powerless, surrounded by enemies. And just so it won't be like that, no matter how our rivals want it.

    Sleepingroutine has nothing to fear posting on here, he is literally posting Russian propaganda.

    So you say that I channel Russian "propaganda" and yet it seems, you have never read anything of it beyond same MSM headlines. You have no idea what the real propaganda looks like. You have no idea what you are asking for, do you? Do you think you are immune to wrongdoing? Do you think you don't make mistakes?

    to Elderly Cynic @1591:

    it makes no sense for it to do so now, when the USA/NATO has been arming Ukraine up to the teeth.

    More than that, it makes no sense to arm Ukraine either. NATO is arming them, since they assume there will be any sort of resistance or force, but it is known for anybody who is not delusional about military, that not only it will not help, it is a waste of resources. Aka self-harm. The "Collective West" does not understand that by providing all sorts of "assistance", "support", by keeping the corrupt and idiotic regime in power, they've been doing much more damage to that nation than Russia could have ever hoped to do - if it ever really wanted to. And they don't understand, refuse to understand that idea.

    Speaking of self-harm, my usual rubric about situation in that country is to count how many times for last week there have been an incident with grenades exploding (a lot of news are still in Russian despite the hard push against it). It is never less than one (per week). Never. Maybe there are exceptions or lack of reports sometimes, but I check it regularly and every time I am impressed - it's been going on for EIGHT YEARS.

    to Greg Tingey @1585:

    If you compare Ru vs NATO forces, the Ru have more men, concentrated on the ground, but a smaller number of them in total. Their tank numbers are also less than NATO.

    If you're wandering why there are still no "solution" to these conflicts, it probably also has to do with NATO being a useless burden on average taxpayer which is thoroughly incapable of preventing a slightest internal or external conflict by itself.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2021_Jersey_dispute

    P.S. "Nato will not put boots on the ground in Ukraine" - seems to be strictly in the same line: do nothing, demand everything.

    1605:

    "Oddly enough, nothing to do with weapons technology, it was where the military kept the computers for a (regional?) finance & accounting office."

    Was that in the mid to late 1980s? There was a lot of squirrely stuff going on then with Continuity of Government(TM) preparations for the War that Was to Come. Some of it involved setting up hidden/undercover places for the government to continue in out of the way places.

    1606:

    sleepingroutine writes: "The "Collective West" does not understand that by providing all sorts of "assistance", "support", by keeping the corrupt and idiotic regime in power, they've been doing much more damage to that nation than Russia could have ever hoped to do"

    For anyone who disagrees with that, I suggest you consider Iraq. And Afghanistan.

    1607:

    Pigeon @ 1589: See also the difficulty of persuading a Devon sheep to stop running straight down the lane and turn off through one of the holes in the hedge instead.

    I've had similar experiences with Welsh sheep back in my University hang-gliding days. No hedges, no reason not to get off the road, but would they?

    The trouble, as you say, is that the sheep is running its escape-from-predator algorithm, which goes like this:

    Phase 1: run as fast as you can in a straight line directly away from the predator, because if you do anything else the predator can cut the corner and catch up with you.

    Phase 2: If the predator catches up despite your best efforts, make a last desperate jink sideways as hard as you can, in the hope that the predator is taken by surprise, misses its footing, and you can open up a bit of a lead again.

    Unfortunately this doesn't work well for cars. As you drive down the road, the sheep in the road runs as fast as possible in a straight line along the road. A naive driver will slow down to keep a safe distance from the sheep, but as far as the sheep is concerned this means it is just barely running fast enough to survive, and therefore it will keep on going as hard as it can in a straight line down the road until it drops dead of exhaustion. The trick is to catch up slowly enough that the last desperate jink sideways is fast enough to get it out of your way before you run it over.

    1608:

    Robert Prior @ 1556:

    If we had been under economic, political and (to some extent) military siege for decades by hostile countries with 15 times our wealth, how well do you think WE would be doing?

    Ask the Haitians — they've had experience with that.

    When Haiti "gained its independence" from France in 1825 (twenty-one years after the Haitian revolution):

    France, with warships at the ready, sailed to Haiti in 1825 and demanded Haiti to compensate France for its loss of slaves and its slave colony. In exchange for French recognition of Haiti as a sovereign republic, France demanded payment of 150 million francs. In addition to the payment, France required that Haiti provide a fifty percent discount on its exported goods to them, making repayment more difficult.

    Haiti was forced to borrow from foreign (French, German and American [US]) banksters on USURIOUS terms in order to make those extortion payments.

    Haiti indemnity controversy

    1609:

    kiloseven @ 1566:

         The other problem is there are no longer large predators capable of taking down deer in most of the U.S.
    I dono. I would consider autos a large predator. They take out around 1 million per year.

    Witness this result from within the Portland (Oregon) Metro, from I-5 at 55mph:

    https://imgur.com/a/0yEC8l8

    I don't have photos, but I once saw a Volvo Station Wagon tangle with a Bull Elk that jumped the road-side barriers on US 24 just outside of Manitou Springs, CO. I was on the way back to Ft. Carson after dropping hikers off at the Pike's Peak trailhead.

    The Volvo sustained as much damage as the elk did, although the driver survived.

    1610:

    David L @ 1571:

    Witness this result from within the Portland (Oregon) Metro, from I-5 at 55mph:

    I was in a car driven by my cousin in the later 60s when we took out a deer at more than a trivial speed. Deer was killed. Car had much more front end damage than that photo. My cousin was totally pissed due to, (I'm guessing in hindsight), no collision insurance. (My cousin is 10 years older than me and was driving responsibly.) And since it was a mid to late 60s car it survived so we could keep driving but he was looking at a lot of body work.

    Talking to the park ranger where we were this was a common occurrence in the area.

    I learned a lesson in deer behavior many years ago late on a Christmas Eve driving back to Raleigh from Roxboro, NC.

    A doe (no antlers) ran across the road ahead of me and stopped. Just as I reached the spot on the road where she was standing on the far side, a yearling faun darted out from my side. I managed to swerve so I didn't hit it head on, but it smashed into the passenger side door on my van.

    My guess is the bright headlights "froze" them both and the yearling unfroze & bolted across to catch up with mama just as my headlights began to sweep past it.

    If you see a deer cross ahead of you and it doesn't immediately disappear into the woods, there's a high probability another deer is lurking somewhere on the roadside where the first one came from and you should slow down a lot before you reach that spot to improve your chances of avoiding a collision. I was only going about 45 mph on that stretch of road, and if I'd slowed down to 25 mph, I probably could have avoided "Bambi" altogether.

    1611:

    Damian @ 1574: I think it's just some confusion about what the roles are in hospitals. The people who are in charge of hospitals, at least over here, are usually doctors who've gone into management. Administrators are the people on reception desks and other relatively menial, low-paid tasks, who actually make things work and get the brunt of everything when something goes wrong, pretty much from everyone including patients, doctors and nurses and senior management. Health systems are basically heat engines that run by burning admin staff. Their work is rarely valued and practically no-one listens to them, even though it doesn't take a genus to see how much effort goes into just the day-to-day stuff (sometimes exacerbated by IT systems that require complex and labour-intensive manual processes when something goes wrong, or even when they don't and are just crap by design...).

    In the U.S. Hospital Administration is management. They have decision making authority. Some of them may be former physicians, but generally they're Professional Managers; interchangeable with MBAs from any other industry, such as "finance" or "investment banking" ... or particularly "private, for profit, health insurance companies". Their compensation is loosely based on how much blood profit they can squeeze out of an organization "Return on Investment for the shareholders". I say "loosely based", because their compensation & bonuses invariably go up even when the organization doesn't make a profit.

    There's a general confusion this plays into. Over here there's a distinction between enrolled nurses (ENs) which are a diploma level career path and registered nurses (RNs) which are degree-plus-prac and fully fledged clinicians (there are also "nurse practitioners" who can be individually authorised to prescribe certain drugs and order diagnostics). I think (per discussion here) in the UK there are no ENs, but a similar role is referred to as "nursing assistant". In contrast "admin" is neither of these, but nor is it "senior management", which is what Robert appeared to be thinking of up above. It's worth noting that cost accounting is always labour intensive, so I'd imagine a need for more admin staff where more of this is required, though I don't see that those would be the people getting "bonuses".

    Here in North Carolina those "enrolled nurses" would be called "Licensed Practical Nurses". Other states might call them by other names, but it's the same thing; the lowest level of actual nursing. Next level up would be the Registered Nurse. This is a two or three year college level course, and more & more it seems like it's going towards a Bachelor Degree in Nursing. Nurse Practitioner would be someone with Master's Degree level education and an actual Doctorate (PhD) in Nursing is not unknown.

    Hospital STAFF - nurses aides, ward secretaries, back office - are NOT "administration" in U.S. hospitals. They have no decision making authority. They're also the lowest of the low on the pay scale, although you can make reasonable money off of Overtime Pay if you're willing to work 60+ hours per week.

    1612:

    Speaking as someone who's immediately hospital adjacent (meaning my wife and many friends work in hospitals)....

    Around here the management aren't, for the most part, interchangeable MBAs, at least here. They're registered nurses (bachelors, masters or PhDs in nursing) and MBAs that they earned after becoming nurses.

    The general medical system right now is that doctors diagnose, nurses provide care, pharmacists double-check lab results, formulate, and dispense meds. Having trained caregivers running the place actually isn't as stupid as it might sound.

    Doctors can be in management, but around here (where there are two extremely good hospital systems and two more decent systems), the upper management is mostly composed of nurses who moved to administration.

    1613:

    Poul-Henning Kamp @ 1583: And that, dear children, is why it is impossible to have an intelligent discussion about international matters with "Real Americans"...

    Or for that matter for anyone from the U.S. to get past you children's condescending "Real Americans" bullshit to have any kind of intelligent discussion.

    Remove the plank from your own eye.

    1614:

    waldo @ 1584: There has been some discussion her3e about extremism in the US military. Therefore, this may be of interest: https://www.politico.com/news/2022/01/04/pentagon-extremism-ranks-jan-6-526441

    At least part of the problem with holding focus seems to stem from the Biennial Budget Process. Can't really plan anything beyond Jan 3, 2023 when the next Congress may have different priorities regarding who needs to be weeded out.

    There's also some questions about service members Constitutional Rights (1st Amendment).

    1615:

    Another maladaptive 'prey' strategy is that of the Blue Grouse, which is abundant in parts of BC. Generally when they encounter a predator their strategy is to freeze in place and 'be invisible'. If the predator continues to approach the grouse will burst up and fly away at the last moment.

    This led to more than one near coronary for myself when I was working as a treeplanter. I was focused on my work while a random grouse was hiding directly in front of me. A sudden burst of loud squawking activity right in front of you after hours of relative quiet can be something of a jolt.

    The weakness of the 'hide' strategy is most evident on roads. While a deer or sheep might run away, a grouse that sees a vehicle bearing down on it will immediately squat down and freeze. On multiple occasions I have run over a grouse that waddled onto the road, noticed me bearing down on it at speed and frozen in place. Given the choice between swerving (on a muddy logging road) or continuing forward, well, sorry birdie.

    1616:

    All non medical NHS staff are on the same pay scale. Recently qualified nurses (Batchelor’s degree) are on level five. This is the pay scale of all State Registered NHS staff on qualification. The levels actually start with level two - one was closed for entrants a few of years ago. More experienced nurses will be on level 6. Level seven is master’s degree equivalent and would be a ward sister. Everyone up to level seven would be paid time - and a - half for overtime (over 35 and a half hours per week). Double time for bank holidays. Level 8 staff - for nurses that’s a modern matron do not get overtime however long they work. Administrators are paid on the same scales but the highest can reach level 9 and above. I was a level 8A biomedical scientist manager and worked about 45 to 50 hours per week without extra pay. A big effect of COVID-!9 on lab staff will be the availability of staff to cover the height shift. In a large lab this would be less of a problem but our associated hospital only had 8 state registered staff and had trouble filling all the posts without locum staff. The 25% sickness forecast by the UK government would make out of hours staffing very difficult.

    1617:

    David L @ 1602:

    and they DID go and talk to all the neighbors.

    I got a summer job at the plant where my father worked. It was a thing for college students to work there. If one of your parents worked regularly at the plant it was much easier to get you a clearance. So every summer they'd bring in us family college students to cut grass, scrape paint, and in general move that pile of stuff from there to here.

    When they stopped by the community college where I was that spring they talked to a friend. The FBI dude flashed his badge. My friend asked if he could see it. And then made sure it looked real and the picture matched. The FBI dude then went around asking about my friend. This was 1972 I think.

    I met an ex Cray system engineer (repair tech) who got called into Ft. Mead NSA HQ to fix their Cray. He did NOT have a clearance as all of the folks with such were all not available. So two military MPs plus an admin or two shadowed him in and during the repairs. He then said he was ready to leave and they told him they wanted him to stay until the current run was done. He threw a hissy fit and the NSA decided they'd be better off with him OUT of the building. A computer run back then could be days.

    My experience was in the 1980s. I wasn't there to work on their computers, but we walked past the computer room on the way to the room where the equipment I was there to work on was located. I could see in through the windows as we walked past & looked like any other IBM computer room I've ever seen (I'm guessing based on WHEN I was there, it was probably a System/370). What I saw through the window as I walked past looked like IBM.

    The guards just looked at my company issued photo ID (and my North Carolina Private Protective Services photo ID) and verified I was on the list of people who were allowed to come into the building to work on the security system. It wasn't really a big deal when I was there, but "befehl ist befehl" so they were required to stay with me while I was inside.

    1618:

    They're also the lowest of the low on the pay scale, although you can make reasonable money off of Overtime Pay if you're willing to work 60+ hours per week.

    The difference here is that overtime pay is less common, and most low level staff have a flexible hours arrangement that means if they work more than 7.6 hours a day they accrue Time Off In Lieu (TOIL) of overtime. However there's usually a maximum number of TOIL hours you're allowed to carry over from one 2-week period to the next (leading to the "9-day-fortnight" some people regard as a perk, but which in practice just gives up on the flexibility that was the point in the first place), and there are often some pretty onerous bureaucratic requirements around working long hours. So in many cases people simply do the long hours and don't bother claiming for their time. It's called unpaid overtime and it's hugely more common than most people would imagine in the public sector here (where there's a huge cultural stereotype about people working short hours and following the clock to the second).

    In areas where you really do need to compete with private sector salaries to attract capable people (IT project land is the one I'm most familiar with) there are private-contractor labour-hire arrangements where it's treated as procurement rather than HR. So if you work as a daily-rate contractor* under one of those arrangements, you fund your own entitlements including sick leave and time off, but after allowing for everything you are still being paid about double what someone doing the same work as a direct employee would be paid. There's a bit of a balance in terms of how public sector organisations can do this, as it costs more and the gotchas are in the same realm as Machiavelli's advice about relying on mercenaries.

    * I may be going back to daily-rate contracting shortly, ending the hiatus that followed throwing in my PhD studies for a bit of a stale joke after the year that was 2021, sigh.

    1619:

    One of my first jobs was in an academic setting, working over the summer, measuring tree-rings for a professor of climatology.

    One of my colleagues was a Ph.D student from the USSR (this was in 1990, so the USSR was taking its last tottering steps towards its grave).

    He'd served in the Soviet Army in Afghanistan in their Meteorological Service. An anecdote of his that stuck with me: the motor pool of one of his units only had one working starter for a couple of dozen trucks. So every morning to get going, the truck would start, then have to jump-start the other trucks. There were only 2-3 starter cables, so just getting going took time.

    Plus he talked about the alcoholism (routine) and corporal punishments that were handed out (also routine, for small infractions and being drunk / hung over on duty).

    Not at the mighty globe-spanning imperial force that stoked right-wing fears in the West.

    1620:

    BTW - thanks for the aviation articles - very interesting. The story about the wire tap made me laugh --- so Tricky Dick era: Bug your 'enemy', you'll probably not get caught!

    De nada. I like aircraft, even when the CIA flies them. IIRC, that was the era when the bugging division of the CIA thought they were the hottest thing the agency had.

    1621:

    Kardashev @ 1605:

    "Oddly enough, nothing to do with weapons technology, it was where the military kept the computers for a (regional?) finance & accounting office.""

    Was that in the mid to late 1980s? There was a lot of squirrely stuff going on then with Continuity of Government(TM) preparations for the War that Was to Come. Some of it involved setting up hidden/undercover places for the government to continue in out of the way places.

    No, early 80s. This was more like the U.S. military had their own internal bank clearing house type operation. It was on a military base in a non-descript building. It was all about keeping the government's money secure ... or at least that part of it allocated to operating military bases in several southeastern U.S.

    Not military operations themselves, but operating the military bases - the physical plant; contracts, payments & disbursements. The U.S. military still paid cash for some stuff ... may still do, but this was 40 years ago and they did back then.

    At the time, I'm pretty sure "trainees" - soldiers attending BASIC & AIT or MOS school - were paid in cash (we were when I went through BASIC and AIT about 5 years earlier and I think they were still doing it then) and there were at least two bases for BASIC in South Carolina and several bases in North & South Carolina where there were AIT or MOS schools. I never thought about it before, but this was where those payrolls were assembled and distributed to the training bases ... so they were handling a lot of money just before paydays.

    I think they were also the central point for paying for stuff like food for the mess halls (which were not yet "dining facilities" - the military still had their own cooks) & who's going to get the contract to repair the leaky roof on the Base Chapel (or the PX/BX building) ...

    There are a lot of mundane expenses for operating a military and this was the building where most of that activity in North & South Carolina (and maybe parts of Tennessee & Georgia) was conducted at the time. It was a secure facility and while not exactly "Top Secret", they didn't advertise what they were doing.

    1622:

    Damian @ 1618:

    They're also the lowest of the low on the pay scale, although you can make reasonable money off of Overtime Pay if you're willing to work 60+ hours per week.

    The difference here is that overtime pay is less common, and most low level staff have a flexible hours arrangement that means if they work more than 7.6 hours a day they accrue Time Off In Lieu (TOIL) of overtime. However there's usually a maximum number of TOIL hours you're allowed to carry over from one 2-week period to the next (leading to the "9-day-fortnight" some people regard as a perk, but which in practice just gives up on the flexibility that was the point in the first place), and there are often some pretty onerous bureaucratic requirements around working long hours. So in many cases people simply do the long hours and don't bother claiming for their time. It's called unpaid overtime and it's hugely more common than most people would imagine in the public sector here (where there's a huge cultural stereotype about people working short hours and following the clock to the second).

    In the U.S. "overtime" strictly means more than 40 hours per week. And private employers will try to screw you every way they can to keep you from getting paid.

    I encountered that TOIL system a few times during my working life. Looks good on paper, but my experience is it's Use it or Lose it and you never get to use it. It's routinely abused to to coerce unpaid overtime.

    1623:

    It's routinely abused to to coerce unpaid overtime.

    at least the acronym is on point

    1624:

    Next level up would be the Registered Nurse. This is a two or three year college level course, and more & more it seems like it's going towards a Bachelor Degree in Nursing.

    You're showing your age. [grin]

    It is a 4 year full degree program in the US and has been for a few decades. Our (LOCAL) Wake Tech Community College system is a mostly 2 year system. But for nursing is 4 years and was for a long time before my son flamed out with it over 10 years ago. (His temperament just wasn't suited to the type of things you had to learn. He does just fine now in another field.)

    1625:

    "The Volvo sustained as much damage as the elk did, although the driver survived."

    Volvo pioneered the concept of "crumble-zones" in cars, exectly because a lot of swedish cars ran into elks.

    1626:

    Deer
    Not "right here", but quite close to me, there is a large-ish forest - with deer ( That also wander across the local farmland )
    Like right here, in daylight - I've also seen a small herd, again in full daylight, half-way along the road the goes off in an ENE direction.
    ... PHK - beat me to it, about Elks!

    JBS
    PLEASE
    No quoting from the Big Bumper Fun Book of Bronze-Age Goatherders' Myths?

    1627:

    There are a lot of mundane expenses for operating a military and this was the building where most of that activity in North & South Carolina (and maybe parts of Tennessee & Georgia) was conducted at the time. It was a secure facility and while not exactly "Top Secret", they didn't advertise what they were doing.

    I live in a city which grew up on banking and still hosts major financial centres. The bank offices often have cash handling facilities alongside the shiny corporate structures. They are not advertised or signposted, just discreetly set around a corner or down an alleyway after a concrete chicane with high wire fences and lots of CCTV cameras. They don't do wages vans any more, instead they fill up ATM dispenser cartridges and deal with cash from shops, supermarkets etc.

    1628:

    I think it's just some confusion about what the roles are in hospitals. The people who are in charge of hospitals, at least over here, are usually doctors who've gone into management. Administrators are the people on reception desks and other relatively menial, low-paid tasks,

    Different terms over here. A "Hospital Administrator" is the chap in charge (and it's usually a chap), not the secretary at the front desk (who would be "staff" or "administrative staff").

    They make significantly more than nurses. If one has a masters in hospital administration the salary is quite nice:

    The average hospital administrator gross salary in Toronto, Ontario is $362,040 or an equivalent hourly rate of $174. This is 7% higher (+$24,991) than the average hospital administrator salary in Canada. In addition, they earn an average bonus of $104,449. Salary estimates based on salary survey data collected directly from employers and anonymous employees in Toronto, Ontario. An entry level hospital administrator (1-3 years of experience) earns an average salary of $220,986. On the other end, a senior level hospital administrator (8+ years of experience) earns an average salary of $604,766.

    https://www.salaryexpert.com/salary/job/hospital-administrator/canada/ontario/toronto

    1629:

    That was kinda my point.

    Also from the Wikipedia article:

    Historians have traced loan documents from the time of the 1825 Ordinance, through the various refinancing efforts, to the final remittance to National City Bank (now Citibank) in 1947.

    France's demand of payments in exchange for recognizing Haiti's independence was delivered to the country by several French warships in 1825, twenty-one years after Haiti's declaration of independence in 1804. Though France received its last indemnity payment in 1893, the government of the United States funded the acquisition of Haiti's treasury in 1911 in order to receive interest payments related to the indemnity. It took until 1947 – about 122 years – for Haiti to finally pay off all the associated interest to the National City Bank of New York (now Citibank).

    1630:

    Obviously, as I pointed out some of its errors.

    Do you SERIOUSLY believe that anyone in the UK government can be trusted to tell the truth? In Wallace's case, that's compounded by him being one of the dimmer members of the cabinet, and quite likely to not have a clue.

    But, more importantly, boots on the ground is SO outdated. Look at what they did to Libya. As I said, it will depend entirely on whether Biden cocks it up.

    1631:

    I killed my first deer with a GS 550B in the mid-eighties, a fawn bolted from it's hiding place in a futile attempt to escape the noise from nearby train tracks and ran into the front wheel, I like to think of the incident as "Bambi vs Suzuki". I was told by the Mother of a friend "Doncha' know you're supposed to do that with a gun?". The incident happened in Central Kansas, and several Kansans were helpful, to this day I don't share the antipathy other Missourians hold against Kansas.

    1632:

    That's viewing entirely through western eyes, and possibly western propaganda.

    Putin is far more an autocrat than a kleptocrat, and is nothing like the third-world kleptocratic dictators favoured by the west; while there is almost certainly some truth in the stories, I haven't seen anything about personal kleptocracy in media that is even remotely unbiassed. And, as I hope you know, the Russian ruling tradition is autocracy, where the UK's and USA's is kleptocracy.

    Also, unlike at least Trump and Johnson, he is a genuine patriot, and at least attempts to do what is best for his country. In his view, to be sure, but I have seen no evidence that he puts personal or tribal interests first.

    1633:

    I like to think of the incident as "Bambi vs Suzuki". I was told by the Mother of a friend "Doncha' know you're supposed to do that with a gun?".

    I recently asked my brother in law in law, the retired after 25+ years as a cop, if he ever had to use his gun other than at practice. He said all of his usage was finishing off auto / animal collision incidents.

    1634:

    Putin is far more an autocrat than a kleptocrat, and is nothing like the third-world kleptocratic dictators favoured by the west; while there is almost certainly some truth in the stories, I haven't seen anything about personal kleptocracy in media that is even remotely unbiassed. And, as I hope you know, the Russian ruling tradition is autocracy, where the UK's and USA's is kleptocracy.

    Well, you're missing the fun if you don't google "Putin Net Worth."

    A good little explainer is at https://www.businessinsider.com/how-putin-spends-his-mysterious-fortune-2017-6

    He's not on the list of the world's richest men, because his official filings say he lives on $133,000/year in a little apartment. His critics charge his net worth is somewhere north of $70 billion, perhaps north of $200 billion. He's in the Panama Papers (link to Guardian Article). How much of that $2 billion is under his direct control and how much is under the control of his friends is quite obviously obfuscated. He has access to 20 large mansions, the largest of which cost $1 billion to build. He "owns" multiple passenger jets and yachts, including a $35 million yacht he was gifted that is run on government funds. He also owns a collection of watches that collectively costs more than a median house in San Diego.

    Since I dipped my toe into the whole wealth management industry, I'll point out that obfuscation of ownership is at the core of how basically all of the super-rich protect their fortunes. They don't directly own assets, and as with Putin, their declared assets are usually comically modest. The key is always hidden control.

    In this, Putin is very much like, say, the House of Saud, or like Trump. Kleptocrat? It's hard to figure out where the money is coming from, if not kleptocracy. He certainly isn't earning it as his salary.

    I'll point out again, that the big battle we have now is between democracies, where the rule of law is at least theoretically supposed to benefit everyone, and plutocracies, where the laws are made to protect the most powerful from responsibility to pay their debts or any consequence for their actions. It's a dangerous global problem that ties into fights over things like climate change and mass extinction (where the wealthy work to make sure that consequences only affect the little people like us). And I'd put Trump and Putin both firmly in the camp of the super-rich.

    1635:

    it’s fundamentally just a wrapper around a string

    Precisely. Decorate it all you like, but unless you add more information it's just a string.

    Well no. You can add additional information to the string. You can even throw a struct if you wish.

    Generally a static string. Not even "file '/foo/blah/ooops.log' not found", just "file not found".

    Just because you've seen poor C++ programs doesn't mean it has to be that way.

    It still annoys me pretty much every day, because I like exceptions, and I really dislike the complexity of code that has to deal with every possible error as it possibly happens. The overwhelming majority of what I write is error handling code. There's no such thing as "do steps 1,2,3, and 4, then make sure nothing went wrong". It's more like "do step one. Did the obvious thing go wrong? No, well how about the less obvious thing? No, well maybe it timed out? Oh, my gosh, it succeeded. Now, how can I write some obfuscated bullshit so that I can continue my chain of if-elseif clauses rather than going in another indent level?"

    you keep making these claims that are not true

    1636:

    @1581

    [" ... And in some farcical situations, “hospitals hired their own staff back as travel nurses and paid them higher rates,” Bettencourt said." ]

    Just the way the USA YAY fed government 'downsized' everything, and particularly all aspects of the military, hiring 'consultants and private agencies' to cost-cut, and thus costing all of us a lot more for everything with no oversight by or for the taxpayers, and no accountability for failure to deliver, rape, theft, criminal activity like drug and weapons running, corruption, murder, torture, etc. either.

    1637:

    Yes, I have seen those stories before. As I said, they all originate (and are published by) people who have an axe to grind against him. How many are entirely invented, how many are conflating Russian state possessions with his personal property, how many are based on the myth that he controls everything that happens in Russia, and how much other exaggeration there is, it's impossible to tell.

    I stand by what I said - you are, at best, viewing him through a western lens.

    1638:

    Just the way the USA YAY fed government 'downsized' everything, and particularly all aspects of the military, hiring 'consultants and private agencies' to cost-cut, and thus costing all of us a lot more for everything with no oversight by or for the taxpayers, and no accountability for failure to deliver, rape, theft, criminal activity like drug and weapons running, corruption, murder, torture, etc. either.

    Yes, yes. Now let's look at it from the grunts' side. Excuse me, the nurses. Nursing is a profession up their with garbage handling and military combat in terms of heavy lifting injuries and stress. So there's a good chance any nurse is going to get injured on the job, possibly by a violent patient or family member, but more often simply trying to move someone who's heavier than they are from one bed to another (there's a whole self defense for nurses course I can direct you to). There's also the stress of care, dealing with Covid, ad nauseum.

    While nursing salaries are pretty good, benefits like paid/medical/other time off accumulate rather slowly, as one might expect. It's just a salaried job like any other. So if a nurse is young, especially without a family or mortgage, there are a couple of choices. One is to get on a career-track job and slog it out in the wards. Then, if they get hurt or just sick of dealing with Covid, they'll transfer into an admin job or some specialty track that puts them away from direct Covid care (like transplant or cardiology), leaving a hole in the nursing staff dealing with the pandemic.

    The other track is that they can become traveling nurses. The pay is higher, because there aren't benefits like paid time off. However, if they're relatively young and healthy, this isn't as much a concern as if they're middle-aged, especially with children, a mortgage, and aging parents. Also, the money helps pay down college debt from getting the RN. And they get to travel, spending 4-6 months at a time in a place. A big benefit is that if they burn out dealing with Covid, they can take as long a break as they can afford to, they're not going to get fired.

    This is suboptimal for hospitals, because paying for traveling nurses really is more expensive. Also the travelers don't know the local systems, so it takes time to get them up to speed. That said, a number of nurses, especially younger ones, are doing a fairly cold-blooded calculation and becoming traveling nurses, because the benefits for staying on staff somewhere are less than they'd get traveling. And again, if they get sick of dealing with Covid, as travelers they can tailor their time off and recovery to meet their own needs. Since there's a shortage of nurses at the moment, there will almost certainly be jobs for them when they come back.

    It's not a great situation, but pandemics in general are not great situations. I wish there were ways to take the burden off the medical staff for dealing with this, but that requires things like mass vaccination and abiding with behavioral constraints that a good chunk of our populations simply won't do. So we end up paying more for care instead.

    1639:

    True. The push to make nurses get a bachelor's degree goes back to the seventies - someone I was good friends with for a while was at Jefferson in Philly, and was doing the BSc degree (while working triage in the ER at Jeff, a downtown Philly hospital....)

    1640:

    I think you're missing the point. By your standards, there are no billionaires on this planet. The key to being a billionaire isn't ownership, because property is regulated and taxed. Instead, the key is indirect control that is difficult to prove. That's a majority of what the global wealth management industry does.

    The simplest example is a trust. A trust is a relationship between the beneficiary and the trustee. The trustee takes care of the contents of the trust, while making sure the beneficiary gets the benefits allowed by the trust. The trust owns the property, but it is not in itself property.

    So let's say the beneficiary is a "billionaire." He may personally own a few bank accounts with a few thousand dollars in them. The trust (in this overly simplistic example) owns the billions. If someone sues the billionaire for half he's worth (say in a divorce case) and wins, the billionaire forfeits his personal wealth--a few thousand dollars. The litigants then demand that he pay the rest out of the trust. So he requests it from the trust, and the trustees refuse to pay. Per the terms of the trust, they are unable to cover legal claims against the beneficiary. Oh well.

    So when you look at the Panama papers in that Grauniad article I linked to, there's no direct tie saying Putin owns anything. People in his immediate circle, who were largely nobodies before he befriended them, own huge amounts that came from....somewhere, under fairly ludicrous circumstances. And apparently much of the traffic leads back to a Swiss law office that has Putin as a client.

    So while I have no idea what wealth Putin controls outside his role in the Russian government, I will say that the parts of his system that the press has legitimately uncovered make him look exactly like every other kleptocrat and billionaire in the world. How do you think they offshore their wealth, in a little tin box?

    1641:

    Then you should add the wealth of a lot of extremely dubious companies to that of the Conservative Party. The thing that makes me suspicious is the dearth of evidence from any sources that are not highly biassed, including corroborative evidence. Oh, yes, he probably has squirrelled away a few billion, but all of the evidence is that he does NOT do that in preference to doing his job, which is very unlike Trump and Bozo.

    Russia has a very different set of social history and traditions, as Kipling noted, but we in the west of today ignore.

    1642:

    Since the minimal level for "ultra-wealthy" is somewhere in the $60-100 million range (e.g. the minimum wealth managers will take on), then if Putin has "squirreled away a few billion," he's a kleptocrat. Administrative competence isn't relevant, because no one decided his skill was worth a few billion in compensation. He took it.

    As for doing his job, the key question is whether Russia's better off with him or not. What would those billions have gone to if his people didn't appropriate them? Health care? Decarbonization?

    I seem to recall, about a century ago, Russians tried to get rid of their wealthy overlords. They failed spectacularly, but I certainly don't blame them for trying, any more than I blame modern progressives for trying to destroy similar systems that are growing worldwide.

    So no, I don't give Russia a pass for having corruption and social inequality, any more than I give China or any other country similar passes. They all have equal traditions of people fighting for more equality, and those I'm far more willing to support those traditions instead.

    1643:

    There are other things that at least sometimes work. For instance, at the ends of my dialysis sessions, I ask the nurse working with me if they want me higher off the floor (sometimes they do), lower to the floor (less likely but it's an option), more sat upright.

    1644:

    Re: 'Instead, the key is indirect control that is difficult to prove.'

    Yes - because access to their 'fortune' can be easily severed by the State (i.e., Putin) according to at least one former Russian billionaire.

    The paper below identifies another 'force' at play - access to the West (esp. the UK and US) by Russian billionaires. Not just for investment but for residence and life style. This could be a potential political lever for other gov'ts to consider --- making things uncomfortable for the current crop of 'crony' billionaires. Probably wouldn't work though becuz I don't think Putin personally cares who he makes rich/poor.

    https://www.amacad.org/publication/russias-oligarchs-unlikely-force-change

    'According to The Economist’s crony capitalism index for 2016, billionaire wealth from the crony sectors in Russia is the highest in the world as a percentage of GDP (18 percent), followed by Malaysia (13 percent) and the Philippines (11 percent); it has also risen since 2014 (from 16 percent).14 Meanwhile, most of the unfortunate Russian billionaires who lost their billionaire status from 2006 to 2015 were not victims of the state, but rather of market conditions or of unscrupulous rivals.'

    Not really a fan of this site but the article does describe the playbook.

    https://www.forbes.com/sites/daviddawkins/2020/02/19/why-russias-one-time-richest-man-wont-see-a-penny-of-the-50-billion-putin-destroyed/?sh=a56437038408

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oleg_Deripaska

    And returning to COVID ... I just laughed when I read this Cdn TV news headline:

    https://globalnews.ca/news/8489384/france-emmanuel-macron-piss-off-unvaccinated-covid-19/

    1645:

    I guess it does make a kind of sense... most plentiful when it's there but also most variable. Odd that they can't just cope with the variation though.

    1646:

    Yeah... I prefer the older Volvos that were just straightforwardly built like tanks (but without the weight of a tank because they actually understood efficient structural design, unlike British manufacturers).

    Because if I hit a deer then I most certainly do not want the car to be transformed into a crumpled immobile wreck. I want at the very least for the engine to still be functional (so the radiator must have escaped injury) and the wheels to rotate properly and point in the right direction. Because otherwise I am stranded out in the middle of fucking nowhere with no way to get either myself or the car back home. (And if it's a Swedish winter night and I can't even have the heater working...)

    Of course the other thing I want is some means to prevent a ton of soggy meat crashing through the windscreen, but you never get anything like that on an actual car even if it is made in a country where that happens all the time. Either you'd need some sort of cowcatcher affair that started at roof level, or simply a vehicle that is much bigger than a car so the levels aren't so pathological.

    Fortunately in Britain you don't often get red deer (US elk) wandering across roads; it happens in parts of Scotland a bit (and they can overturn Land Rovers), but elsewhere there aren't all that many of them and there are more humans and the deer tend to be more concerned with keeping out of the way (they will still raid vegetable plots at night, but that's a bit different). Most deer collisions are with smaller species that are more comfortable living around humans (such as the northern area of Milton Keynes where muntjac vs. car is a slightly notoriously common event).

    1647:

    I think the chap I know who had the same happen to him was on a Suzuki too. Must be something about them...

    He got away with remarkably little damage to either himself or the bike. The deer was fucked though and he had to do something horrible like cutting its throat with a penknife to finish it off.

    1648:

    The unfortunate fawn looked like a rag after hitting the front spokes of a bike doing maybe 75 kph, launched into the handlebar and shattered a plexiglass fairing. I got road rash. Locals took me to their house to wash the gravel off and called the County patrol who helped me straighten the bent handlebar and gave me antibiotic cream and gauze over the road rash.

    1649:

    or simply a vehicle that is much bigger than a car so the levels aren't so pathological.

    In Australia kangaroos aren't limited by that silly "gravity" nonsense that burdens cows, deer, elk and so on. They have been known to go right through the windscreen of a truck.

    I've seen some pretty hardcore bull bars, some people run bars up along the front outside edge of the bonnet up to the roof rack and occasionally a centre bar down the windscreen. Not to mention the roof racks that just run forward and are supported by vertical posts from the front bumper.

    In NSW I'm pretty sure there's a ban on unnecessary bull bars in urban areas because they are awesome at killing pedestrians as well as other vermin.

    1650:

    In Australia kangaroos aren't limited by that silly "gravity" nonsense that burdens cows, deer, elk and so on. They have been known to go right through the windscreen of a truck.

    I think a small to mid sized car can drive the hood UNDER some of the elk I saw when driving up the California coast a while back. And I understand those in the upper midwest US and Canada are similarly sized.

    1651:

    By "elk" do you mean moose, or do you mean what we Americans call "elk"? In moose country, people worry about moose. They will go through the windshield/windscreen if hit head on unless the windshield/windscreen is quite high.
    "Alces alces is called a "moose" in North American English, but an "elk" in British English. The word "elk" in North American English refers to a completely different species of deer, Cervus canadensis, also called the wapiti."

    (I try to avoid hitting any animals when driving, though insects can be hard to avoid. This sometimes bothers passengers but so it goes.)

    1652:

    David L @ 1624:

    Next level up would be the Registered Nurse. This is a two or three year college level course, and more & more it seems like it's going towards a Bachelor Degree in Nursing.

    You're showing your age. [grin]

    Well ... if it keeps those damn kids off my lawn.

    It is a 4 year full degree program in the US and has been for a few decades. Our (LOCAL) Wake Tech Community College system is a mostly 2 year system. But for nursing is 4 years and was for a long time before my son flamed out with it over 10 years ago. (His temperament just wasn't suited to the type of things you had to learn. He does just fine now in another field.)

    When I first came to Raleigh, NC State University still had a 2 year nursing (RN) program run in cooperation with Rex Hospital. That was when Rex was located on the NW corner of Wade Ave & St. Mary's St.

    Plug 35.798123844935034, -78.65291886597386 into Google Maps, go to street view and look towards the west. That white building was the student nurses' dormitory.

    My Mom started LPN school while I was in Junior High. It was a program between Durham Tech & Watts Hospital. My mom worked as an EKG technician at Watts for about 10 years before going back to school to get her RN. That program was a joint venture between the new Durham County General Hospital and North Carolina Central University.

    The old Watts Hospital became the North Carolina School of Science and Mathematics in 1980.

    Too bad THEY didn't think of founding something like that 20 years earlier when it might have done me some good.

    1653:

    David's as American as I am. If he saw them on the California coast, he had his choice of a rare Tule Elk around Pt. Reyes or a fairly rare Roosevelt Elk up in the rain forest. I'd bet on the latter, but I've seen both.

    Regardless, we don't get wild Alces in California.

    1654:

    Poul-Henning Kamp @ 1625:

    "The Volvo sustained as much damage as the elk did, although the driver survived."

    Volvo pioneered the concept of "crumble-zones" in cars, exectly because a lot of swedish cars ran into elks.

    I saw the elk leap the fence and run out in front of the Volvo. What it looked like is the Volvo's front bumper clipped the elk somewhere near its ankles and the elk's body kind of lifted up and smashed down where the top of the windshield meets the roof. The Volvo definitely crumpled. But the elk and particularly the elk's rack didn't go through the windshield & I think that's what probably saved the driver's life.

    1655:

    Greg Tingey @ 1626: Deer
    Not "right here", but quite close to me, there is a large-ish forest - with deer ( That also wander across the local farmland )
    Like right here, in daylight - I've also seen a small herd, again in full daylight, half-way along the road the goes off in an ENE direction.
    ... PHK - beat me to it, about Elks!

    Oddly enough, Colorado Springs is one of the places in the U.S. where traffic circles (roundabouts) were introduced back in the 80s & 90s. That could easily BE up on Cheyenne Mountain (except for it not being on the side of a mountain) and the deer I was mentioning would have been as close to the road as the Miller & Carter sign the pedestrian is walking past.

    JBS
    PLEASE
    No quoting from the Big Bumper Fun Book of Bronze-Age Goatherders' Myths?

    By that time the Iron-Age would have been well established. And I believe it's good advice regardless of the source.

    1656:

    David's as American as I am. If he saw them on the California coast

    North of Eureka I think. We were driving up the PCH. The old narrow twisty one. Most likely in the Redwoods area. They were grazing in a meadow at a park pull off. Freaking big they were. I mean big.

    We drove north then turned right then up the Smith River through the tunnel into Oregon then to Crater Lake.

    1657:

    Bill Arnold @ 1651: By "elk" do you mean moose, or do you mean what we Americans call "elk"? In moose country, people worry about moose. They will go through the windshield/windscreen if hit head on unless the windshield/windscreen is quite high.
    "Alces alces is called a "moose" in North American English, but an "elk" in British English. The word "elk" in North American English refers to a completely different species of deer, Cervus canadensis, also called the wapiti."

    The Elk I saw demolish the Volvo was a Wapiti.

    The deer I saw up on Cheyenne Mountain in Colorado Springs might have been Mule Deer. They didn't look quite like the deer I frequently see here in North Carolina.

    (I try to avoid hitting any animals when driving, though insects can be hard to avoid. This sometimes bothers passengers but so it goes.)

    I have gotten over the reflex to try to swerve to avoid squirrels. I won't deliberately run them down, but I'm not going to lose control and wreck my car trying to avoid them either.

    1658:

    Minor reminder about the "divided by a common language" thing... in Australia a truck is a heavy vehicle, and often a road train. What USAians call "trucks" we call "utes" (for "utility vehicle"). A giraffe would definitely go through the windscreen of even a large truck, but something as low as a moose would need a ladder with most trucks.

    We have camels and they are mostly just annoying to truck drivers. They're heavy enough to mess up even a solid bull bar if you hit one at speed... and they're arrogant enough to sit in the middle of the road and just look at you.

    We have small trucks, but generally the overlap between kangaroos and small trucks on faster roads is small. It's the "open road" areas, generally at dawn and dusk, that are fun times for animal-avoiders. Even a small (20-30kg) kangaroo can make a real mess of a car, and as far as road users go they're basically low flying rather than walking - they do 30ish kph and hit the ground every 5-10m or so. So they can cross the road quite unexpectedly if there's any cover at all.

    1659:

    Of course the other thing I want is some means to prevent a ton of soggy meat crashing through the windscreen

    Avoid moose.

    Deer will total your car. Moose are tall enough that your hood (bonnet) just hits their legs and the body comes through the windscreen.

    (Moose are members of the deer family, but in common parlance moose (and elk) are not called "deer" over here.)

    1660:

    I have gotten over the reflex to try to swerve to avoid squirrels. I won't deliberately run them down, but I'm not going to lose control and wreck my car trying to avoid them either.

    And one assumes you don't stop your car to help ducks?

    https://www.ctvnews.ca/canada/quebec-woman-who-stopped-on-highway-for-ducks-causing-fatal-crash-loses-appeal-1.3450013

    1661:

    Sounds harsh to convict for dangerous driving when they weren't in the car. Maybe criminal negligence at a stretch... (is there such thing as negligent parking?).

    I'm a motorcyclist and I take the motor cyclist's part by default, but really, riding into the back of a parked car, no matter where it's parked, seems like the responsibly of the controller of the moving vehicle rather than the stopped one.

    JBS: I think the Bumper Book of Bronze Age myths may have been written down in the iron age, but the myths were old then. Over 1000 years old? Dunno, but probably. These things stick around. There's some thought that changes to the black sea 7000 years ago (stone age) became myths that were incorporated into the BBBoBAGHM.

    1662:

    Here's some links, note very closely the Time / Date on them:

    One-Day $10 Billion Profit Erases Turkey Central Bank Losses

    Turkey’s central bank posted an extraordinary daily profit of around $10 billion on the final day of 2021, sparking questions on what caused this overnight boon that will trickle down to the nation’s Treasury.

    https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-01-04/single-day-10-billion-profit-erases-turkish-central-bank-losses

    Bloomberg, 4th Jan 2022

    Five world powers issue pledge to prevent nuclear war

    China, France, Russia, the UK and the US said that a nuclear war "cannot be won and must never be fought," quoting Ronald Reagan and Mikhail Gorbachev at what became the zenith of the nuclear arms race.

    https://www.dw.com/en/five-world-powers-issue-pledge-to-prevent-nuclear-war/a-60317989

    DW 3rd Jan 2022 (DW is basically The Telegraph circa 2002 in terms of scope: it's CIA / BND backed, but is at least intelligent about it).

    So, yes: if you read the deleted material, somehow Little Miss Insanity Pants managed to tell you exactly what TR was doing before it even hit the international markets, and 4 days before Bloomberg made it public.

    That, in market terms, is worth over $500,000 dollars.

    "Egregious shit in the middle"

    That's your collective unconcious we're processing. Fun fact: 100% we've shovelled more horse shit in our (current) life that you have. We're talking Tonnes.

    Oh, and that little "£5,000,000" PR campaign? You won't have noticed it much, Goog/Alphabet inc stomped it hard, the terms are " MASS PSYCHOSIS FORMATION" which is both predicatble and novel (in that: 100% of all such fields are mostly bollocks, entirely. Even the "hard" brain biochemistry is like... "We still do not understand how anesthesia works". With an added sting of Mr Stephen Christopher Yaxley-Lennon being bunged an extra £20k or so from the Canadian Shock Jocks (Ezra... is Jewish, he really is, and has IL backers, all in the Financial Details btw) to claim a firebomb and push his racial rape video.

    But we told them all before it launched, so who knows.

    Oh, and a little discussion that was had here over four years ago is now Live once more: Goblins, Rowling and "When Antisemitism isn't really antisemitism because Israel". No, really: fucking knocking it out of the park with the amount of self-immolation going on in that department.

    Anyhow: if you read the non-deleted stuff: someone told you the exact number of TR moves ... before it happened.

    ~

    That's worth a lot of magic beans.

    1663:

    That, in market terms, is worth over $500,000 dollars.

    $500,000,000 actually.

    You know, for those ones who don't do math so gud.

    ~

    So, very...very bored of Humans.

    1664:

    Tryptch.

    Fun Fact: in the Witcher DLC addon "Blood and Wine" there is a secret hidden Contract[0] involving a Golden Goose getting kidnapped and freeing her.

    https://witcher.fandom.com/wiki/Golden_egg

    Oh, and fun fact: one of the quotations above was not uttered by a Homo Sapien.

    Just sayin.

    The amount of shit and... we can ruin your Fantasies about Capitalism and Hard work and so on.

    100% Ruination.

    So. Our current bill is roughly ~$3.9 billion. That's "Money made for those traumatising and beating the shit out of the golden goose", but they're stupid as fuck, so ignore / delete it all.

    See?

    Nah. WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAR.

    ~~Dump the Sands of Eygpt on us and "break our spine / neck"? LOL, no - Rise immediately, grasp your pin-striped suit by the neck from behind and fry his Mind.

    "Little Boy"

    Yeah.

    That whole thing about "A Penis and Clitoris are essentially the same cells" really missed you, didn't it?

    Here's the rub: we're better at Capitalism than you are.[1] Better than your fucking Puppets like Elron, by a Country Mile.

    ~

    Now. Fuck off.

    [0] K. Starmmmar: "Cannot say "Respect"" - you know why? Because Truth has to be linked to it to use in a Contract these days. Brain froze, total melt-down.

    [1] Khazissssssstannnn LNG just flared up: oooops.

    1666:

    1662, 1663, 1664, 1665
    MORE babbling, along with a deliberate personal insult as a pathetic attempt at trolling. Not biting.

    1667:

    1658 - And in the UK we're just confusing. Depending on context a "truck" may be either an HGV or what Australians call a ute. We will also use "pick-up" of the same "ute" vehicle. To illustrate, this class would include a Holden Maloo and a Chevrolet El Camino, and if you can find an example a Skoda Felicia Fun.

    1661 - Well, in UK strict liability applies if you rear-end someone, unless there is some sort of evidence that they brake tested you (burnt out brake light bulbs for example).

    1662 - 1665 inc. Admin note, TL;DR.

    1668:

    That being California, if you saw a deer (and I assume you meant wapiti, not moose) big enough to drive a car under, I would deduce one of two things :-)

    1) Rogue genetic engineers, or

    2) You had been smoking something strong.

    1669:

    I assume he means the animals body will end up maybe going over your car after you drive through its legs. If you are lucky.

    It happens.

    1670:

    I'm a motorcyclist and I take the motor cyclist's part by default, but really, riding into the back of a parked car, no matter where it's parked, seems like the responsibly of the controller of the moving vehicle rather than the stopped one.

    From what I remember of the news when it happened, she stopped in the left (passing) lane of a highway, just over the crest of a hill (so the motorcyclists had very little time to react).

    Highway 30 is a dual-carriageway in Candiac, so restricted-access, high speed. It has a shoulder on both sides wide enough to pull onto (in emergencies) but she didn't do that — she stopped her car in the travelling lane. At the trial she argued that it was a logical thing to do, because she wanted to take the ducks home.

    The Court of Appeal determined that even if Czornobaj remains convinced she took steps to reduce the risk involved in parking her car in the left-hand lane of a highway the jury determined another reasonable person could have felt otherwise.

    All three of the judges who heard the appeal agreed on the decision. Czornobaj will probably have to begin serving her 90-day prison term soon. She was sentenced to serve her prison term on weekends. Czornobaj was not appealing the prison term itself but the fact that the judge who presided over her trial, Éliane Perrault, also issued an order that she not be allowed to have a drivers permit for ten years. The Court of Appeal decided that a 10-year prohibition from driving for Czornobaj compensates for the relatively low prison term she received and was therefore suited specifically to her case.

    https://montrealgazette.com/news/local-news/court-rejects-appeal-of-driver-in-deaths-of-two-people-after-she-stopped-to-help-ducks

    I wonder if the charge of dangerous driving was made specifically so the driving prohibition could be imposed, given her attitude of "I didn't make a wrong decision"?

    1671:

    I'm a motorcyclist and I take the motor cyclist's part by default, but really, riding into the back of a parked car, no matter where it's parked, seems like the responsibly of the controller of the moving vehicle rather than the stopped one.

    Not quite parked and in the US it's almost a lock to be your fault if you hit someone from the rear but ...

    My son was second in line at a stop light. Jeepish car ahead started forward with the green light. My son also started up. But a bit too close. Just as they cleared the intersection the jeepish thing slammed on the brakes and my son did also. But he still slid under the bumper of the jeep thus wreaking his entire front end, hood, and fenders.

    Then the jeepish thing just drove off. (Now you know why I say "jeepish".)

    While the police were writing it up they said normally my son would be at fault but when the other driver leaves the scene "you win!". So my son wasn't at fault.

    We still wonder just what was so wrong the other driver didn't want to deal with the cops. No license? BOLO? Drugs?

    1672:

    I did that, once, and I was on a bicycle! I didn't come off, the frame was a bit bent but I rode the bicycle for some years afterwards, and I broke the plastic rear bumper of the car. The driver did get out, but went away when I asked "Why did you do an emergency stop in the middle of the junction?" Cluelessness, not drugs. And, yes, I was too close :-)

    1673:

    Robert Prior @ 1660:

    I have gotten over the reflex to try to swerve to avoid squirrels. I won't deliberately run them down, but I'm not going to lose control and wreck my car trying to avoid them either.

    And one assumes you don't stop your car to help ducks?

    https://www.ctvnews.ca/canada/quebec-woman-who-stopped-on-highway-for-ducks-causing-fatal-crash-loses-appeal-1.3450013

    I might, but I'd be pulled COMPLETELY OFF THE ROAD; out of the traffic lanes.

    1674:

    gasdive (he, him, ia) @ 1661: JBS: I think the Bumper Book of Bronze Age myths may have been written down in the iron age, but the myths were old then. Over 1000 years old? Dunno, but probably. These things stick around. There's some thought that changes to the black sea 7000 years ago (stone age) became myths that were incorporated into the BBBoBAGHM.

    Maybe the first part, Volume 1, but the particular text quoted is from Volume 2 which was written MUCH LATER. Most likely uttered around 30 CE, transcribed into the story collection 50+ years later and accepted by the editors later still.

    1675:

    She stopped in the passing lane over the top of a hill?

    Why should she EVER HAVE A DRIVER'S LICENSE?

    Yes, I'm now infuriated.

    Early in the year before I met my late wife, she and kid were in a 12 car pileup. Some stupid fucking moron idiot woman came over the crest of a hill, and on the down side, her engine died. She stopped the car, in the left lane, go out, and she and her kid walked away as fast as possible, because she "knew there was going to be an accident".

    Not putting the hood up. Not putting on emergency blinkers.

    Speed limit 55mph. My late wife was the second car in the pileup - she did right, managing to keep the car straight as she bounced off the first car, but her car spun in the ricochet. My son had a number of plastic surgeries, due to the window coming in on his when the car behind hit, and his face was described by a doc as "ground meat". There were bits of glass still coming out of his skin six years later.

    So, yeah, take this duck-loving asshole's license away for LIFE.

    1676:

    Sounds harsh to convict for dangerous driving when they weren't in the car. Maybe criminal negligence at a stretch...

    Dangerous driving is federal, not provincial, in Canada and the first part of the relevant section of the Criminal Code of Canada is "a motor vehicle in a manner that is dangerous to the public"

    She was operating it when she decided to park the car in an unsafe place.

    So dangerous driving seem applicable.

    1677:

    In New Zealand, non-squeamish drivers swerve to hit (Australian, bovine-TB infected) possums as a service to the community.

    1678:

    Was thinking about Man's Rise... and I'm sorry you didn't read the whole thing, I'd really have liked to read your cmts.

    You do realize that he wasn't tracking any specific group in America and following them, he was taking specific tribes in specific areas and using them as examples of human societal development, suggesting that there were direct comparisons to groups in the Middle East, etc., right?

    1679:

    "What it looked like is the Volvo's front bumper clipped the elk somewhere near its ankles [...]"

    As I have understood it, that is precisely why elk are so dangerous to people in cars: Most of the mass is high enough over the ground, to clear the front/radiator of the car, and continue through the wind-shield at pretty much whatever speed the car was driving.

    1680:

    My understanding too, and the nearest I've ever come to a "wild moose" is a couple of red deer (Cervus elaphus) stags crossing the road in front of me in the dark, although to be fair they were about 100 yards past a "caution: red deer" road sign.

    1681:

    the motor pool of one of his units only had one working starter for a couple of dozen trucks

    Are you sure it was "one working starter" and not "one working battery"? AFAIK, if starter motor does not work, jump-starting won't do any good, since what they do is supply current to the starter motor.

    1682:

    It's quite good for showing that many of our standard tropes about the development of culture civilization were molded out of bovine excrement and other found materials for various and often imperialistic purposes. What they propose to replace the bullshit with has some holes and fertilizer spackling of its own, but still.

    I largely agree with these remarks. I suppose my take is that if you set about pulling out the epistemological rug from under a whole bunch of received truths and cultural prejudices, you're obliged to make at least a start on developing a plausible alternative version. Even if such an attempt is bound to have its own problems, it shows that the space needs to be contended and that it might take a while for a coherent version to emerge.

    I recently (as in maybe sometime in the last 5 years) read a couple of things by linguist Guy Deutscher, and found he spent an inordinate amount of time attempting to debunk some scholarly claims that did not strike me as critical to his own argument, and which came across as largely not things people making them actually held deeply but simply used as a rebuttal to imperialists, or other folk who just didn't need defending. It left me uncertain whether to see Deutscher as a crank, and discount his actual substantive arguments. I don't get anything like the same impression with Graeber, who does spend a lot of time demolishing existing claims and taken-for-granted positions. If anything it's the other way around: the critique is substantive with the alternative version being offered as a starting point. Not that I think anyone is calling Graeber a crank either.

    I'm also still ploughing through. I recently took a break from it to re-read Dead Lies Dreaming and for the same reason will most likely take another break shortly to read something else (ahem).

    1683:

    Be wary, be wary

    6 January

    Stupidity, MAGA and plot

    I see no reason Republican treason

    Should ever be forgot!

    - Jeff Bigler

    1684:

    Maybe originally "starter cables" should have been "tow ropes", and "jump start" was used in the common but inaccurate meaning of "tow start". So one truck wakes up and then manoeuvres about the place tugging the others into life. This would be more entertaining and a very military way of doing it.

    British Rail used to have a similar problem with the original steam-replacement-era DMUs. Maintenance of lead-acid batteries was something BR always seemed to have a problem with in general, and the starter batteries on those DMUs were undersized to begin with, so although they might start up all right in the summer, on a freezing winter morning with the battery and the cylinders cold and the lubricating oil viscous you'd be more likely than not to flatten the battery before anything useful happened. You would then have to shunt the DMU into the shed, or more likely heave out this bloody great heavy box with a huge transformer in it on the end of an extension cable, and give it most of the day to get some charge back in.

    Obviously this was no good when you needed it to operate a service, and you can't tow-start them, so they got into the habit of just never turning them off. You could always locate a DMU stabling point by the continuous gentle rumbling and rattling and the perpetual drifting haze of blue smoke. And of course one effect of repeatedly leaving them on tickover for hours on end was bore wash and contamination of lubricating oil with fuel, leading to low compression, so they got even harder to start, so you had even less choice about it...

    This even sometimes happened with full size locomotives, although not so much because those mostly had batteries specified by people who understood just how much starting the engine might need, whereas the DMU designers had apparently thought "it's a bus engine, so a bus battery will do" without due consideration for Railways Being Different. But it was one of the reasons fuel in the oil was a constant problem for BR all over. (DIY injector maintenance in despite of repeated advice from diesel specialists not to was another one, and that really does count as self-inflicted.)

    1685:

    I've been in a car where the kangaroo, albeit clipped by a glancing impact somewhere between the front of the car and the top of the windscreen, went right over the top of the car and landed in bushes a few metres behind where the driver managed to stop. There was no visible damage to the car. We had been travelling around 100km/h, maybe slowed to 80 something by the time of impact and there was definitely a loud thud. When I went to check on the kangaroo (a grey), it lunged at me angrily before hopping off down the road.

    OTOH I've been sitting near the front of a long-distance coach when a kangaroo bounced off the bull bars. I barely noticed the bump and the driver didn't even slow down. Big red too, 'bout the mass of an adult human.

    1686:

    Our country hit a million new cases - positive tests? -- today.

    Our city, one of the largest in the world has large portions of it at 50% infections -- positive tests.

    https://www1.nyc.gov/site/doh/covid/covid-19-data.page#maps

    So if peoples wonder why we're not out and about, there ya go. It's also frigid cold, with Maybe Snow for tomorrow, and then getting even colder for quite a few days.

    1687:

    "bull bars"

    Linguistic diversion, but in parts of Latin America and the southern border US, these are called "tumbaburros." From tumbar = knock over/down and burro = burro.

    1688:

    RvdH
    Do you want the full version, as per Cliffe Bonfire Society version of that?

    Remember, remember the Fifth of November, Gunpowder Treason and Plot, I know of no reason Why the Gunpowder Treason Should ever be forgot. Guy Fawkes, Guy Fawkes, t’was his intent To blow up the King and Parli’ment. Three-score barrels of powder below To prove old England’s overthrow; By God’s providence he was catch’d With a dark lantern and burning match. Holla boys, Holla boys, let the bells ring. Hollo boys, hollo boys, God save the King!

    .....

    1689:

    You may well be right! It was 30+ years ago that he told me the story, so lots of time for me to lose details.

    1690:

    Another variant, possibly relevant in this time of treason in the US:

    "Remember, remember the 10th of November1, and Sherman's March to the Sea. I can think of no reason the banner of treason should fly in the land of the free!"

    1 Sherman actually started his march on the 15th of November, but that doesn't scan as well.

    1691:

    Our country hit a million new cases - positive tests? -- today.

    NSW is using a positively Trumpian solution to that problem: we've capped PCR testing capacity at about 20,000/day and limited the supply of DIY tests. So officially we're at about 30,000 new cases yesterday... but no-one believes that. Even my "she'll be right" girlfriend was persuaded not to go camping with friends.

    Meanwhile someone I know who had a big family gathering over xmas managed to achieve ~20/30 attendees testing positive the week after.

    I am staying the fuck at home

    1692:

    Here's a couple more links:

    Right-wing Indians have their own app to manipulate Whatsapp and Twitter

    Social media operatives apparently affiliated to India’s ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) use a specialized app to hijack Twitter trends, harass critics, and spread propaganda through defunct Whatsapp accounts, according to a new investigation by The Wire, an Indian publication.

    https://qz.com/india/2110005/bjp-supporters-use-tek-fog-to-manipulate-whatsapp-and-twitter/

    Jan 6th 2022

    .@SpeakerPelosi introduces @Lin_Manuel who introduces other Hamilton cast members to sing "Dear Theodosia."

    https://twitter.com/cspan/status/1479161259618672648 - CSPAN, 6th Jan 2022

    Turkey’s State Gas Importer Races for Funding as Prices Surge

    Boru Hatlari ile Petrol Tasima AS, known as Botas, has been seeking a loan of around $2 billion to meet looming repayments, with some of the money owed to Russia’s Gazprom PJSC, according to people with knowledge of the matter.

    https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-01-06/turkey-s-state-gas-importer-races-for-funding-as-prices-surge - Jan 6th 2022

    ~

    Oh, and of course: How Tony Blair advised former Kazakh ruler after 2011 uprising

    https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/jan/06/how-tony-blair-advised-former-kazakh-ruler-after-2011-uprising 6th Jan 2022

    Ignore the Bitcoin attackers, this is all connected.

    Notes:

    1) grep, and search "fire up the wasapp". Yeah, only a couple of years late to "unveiling" the massive BJP stuff there

    2) Jan 6th wasn't a Revolution, it was a carefully manufactured PSYOP to get the Qanons and others back on the dual party train. Thus, the USA Democratic Party is using "Hamilton" which was massively popular pre-COVID19 to their base (and Metafilter LOVED them for it). This will fail, as it's no longer 2016 and everyone can see the cracks in the Pantomime and we're no longer fucking in Narnia, children.

    3) Kazakhstan (KZ) is all about pipelines, where they get their LNG from (LPG subsidies are a thing, yes, and derivived from oil extraction, but it's not about that, really - there's no shortage of it, it's costs being passed on) and who is paying whom to get jiggy with whom (MR TONY BLAIR).

    4) TR Lira is tanking (again) and there's serious moves (like, look up which MENA state offered a $10 bil "investment" in Oct 2021) - but, bottom line: you made a DRONE PLAY in a region the USA (and RU) consider "extremely sensitive" and so.... Curtains.

    5) The Bitminer thing is valid: 100% so, but not kinda for the reasons you're listing. Probably missing the bit where a lot of Organized Crime (of the non-Georgian Mafia kind, if you require a flash-Mind-fuck into just how much we might know about RU organized crime, which of them do Bar Mitzvah and which Oligarchs are in with various flavors) moved to KZ, not due to CN, but due to Molvdavania getting seriously nuked by both Interpol, SWIFT and Kremlin(due to various bank things and the amount of shit show raised by a petty $8 billion scam - just use HSBC or DB like everyone else does). The More You Know. But, yes: it's really not as simple as the Junket Press wants you to think. And yes: color revolutions, totes a thing, but that was 2019?2020? during a Drone War

    Want more?

    Kids: TL;DR

    We did Goblins 3+ years ago.

    ~We return you to the Retired People's Home.

    p.s.

    That Witcher Joke - a thing of beauty, if you know the material. It's only one of the top five games ever made, and it was made a while ago now, it's Art.

    1693:

    Ah, yes.

    Why do we bother mentioning Goblins? Well, apart from the obvious nuclear devastation being done to the credibility to absolutely anyone who posted anything about Murals[1] and their frantic attempts[2] to not look like total hypocrites (they're failing).

    Ah, yes.

    "Publisher of Harry Potter SLAMS accusations that JK Rowling is antisemitic"

    cough

    Is that the publisher who, if you want to get really honest, is happy to publish anti-LGTB+ stuff, and so on? Whose C level are... (and we've met them at parties), well: more than a little bit racist?

    Ho-Hum.

    ~

    Kids: don't burn your Minds out on this popcorn level stuff. If you want your Mind burnt out, try one of our Runs.

    Hey: We're still alive, still lucid, still seeing the Future and... Our Mind is not a Garden, it's a fucking Jungle.

    When the Queen dies, well... all bets... are off.

    [1] Apologies to Jewdas: but do a grep - we said it wasn't then, and we were right. This is the fallout from this.... and boooooy is it gonna get good.

    [2] In many cases just flatly devolved into "Well, she's pro-Israel, so no big deal" which is a total repuduation of the concept of "Universal Rights"

    Yeah: if there weren't Things-Like-Us, that second bit is how badly you're getting played and how far ahead we're warping things.

    Sheldon and co planned years ahead, Kissinger does decades: We do fucking Centuries

    Music: Radiohead - Just https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oIFLtNYI3Ls

    1697:

    Cut this.

    JK Rowling made a billion pounds rehashing her pitiful understanding of mythology to tell middle class people that they were special, and servants were cool and the only evil people were actually those who revolted against the system. And people against slavery are weird.

    That's it.

    So, an entire generation raised on the mythology that there are "US" (the wizards) and "THEM" (the boring muggles) because: "They are educated enough to read a fucking book". It's a simple dualism, which you can then use to, well: all kinds of Sins.

    That's all it takes to make it: and her publishers, who, while you do not know this, but we do: not very nice people.

    ~

    That's it: it's indoctrination because, kids: when you're reading it in Brazil, you can be 100% purity sure there's no fucking indigenous wizards.

    Note: tweeting: "Yeah, Chief Crow Big Wings Dances with Elks is actually a wizard in Ravendorrf" .... is not a fucking defense of your shitty writing.

    1698:

    Holy shitballs Batman! A seagull post I can get behind!

    1699:

    absolutely anyone who posted anything about Murals

    our boy jezza was stitched up tbh

    though he did leave himself kind of open to it with that comment

    live and learn

    We do fucking Centuries

    normal for science fiction writers

    1700:

    Bugger "murals"
    Try Mosaics instead - Like this
    Or this

    1701:

    NSW is using a positively Trumpian solution to that problem: we've capped PCR testing capacity at about 20,000/day and limited the supply of DIY tests.

    Sounds like Ontario.

    Getting a rapid test is like the Hunger Games — long lineups, supplies running out, etc. PCR tests are limited to those in dire need. Schools infections are no longer being reported. Getting a picture of what's happening is suddenly a lot harder.

    We have an election in five months, so every choice Ford is making now has one eye on that — and his voter base includes all the anti-Covid nutters. (Not to mention his caucus, which has a statistically-improbable number of MPPs who are medically-exempt from the vaccine — who are deciding to leave politics for family reasons now that those exemptions must be verified by Public Health rather than just being taken at their word…)

    * Which screws up the official Covid contact app, as the only way to tell the app you tested positive is using a number you get after an official PCR test result, which now most positive cases will not be getting. (And the reason you can't just self-report is that when the app was released Covid deniers were planning on just telling the app they were positive to make the alerts useless, so it looks like there's no winning that one.)

    ** Shout-out to Durham Board which is still reporting school cases, independently of the province, so parents aren't guessing.

    1702:

    Bloody Markup.

    The first footnote refers to PCR tests being limited.

    The second refers to school infections. Which wasn't supposed to be italicized — I just forgot to escape the asterisks I was using for the footnotes.

    1703:

    Actually I've always disliked the absolute numbers. As they depend so much on just how many people are getting tested. The positivity rate, while not perfect gives a better, but no where near perfect, picture.

    In some states in the US the positivity rate has moved from low single digits to 50% (or more) in a few weeks.

    1704:

    Absolutely :-)

    The problem about getting actual population rates is that it has no immediate benefit except to help with planning, and (in most countries) TPTB regard anything that forces them to do that as undesirable. Facts should not be allowed to interfere with policy. The technical problems and cost of doing a random sample are significant but lost in the noise for a wealthy country.

    My graphs use positivity rates, as you would expect.

    1705:

    Yeah; more people are testing, so more asymptomatic cases (or false positives) are being detected. Statistics 101.

    1706:

    Some caution for those outside the US that Trumpism can transfer across borders.

    See this photo of a survey/poll of Canadians aired by the CBC TV where 27% of Conservative Party Canada voters think Trump won the 2020 election.

    https://i.redd.it/7pnud94uc5a81.jpg

    It probably won't take much for them to also question local election results.

    1707:

    They have always, always been with us. Those are the people in Alberta and elsewhere who, like clockwork, are outraged that the Conservatives have not won - because everyone they know identifies as a conservative.

    Aproximately 30% of any population are going to gravitate to authoritarians. It is up to the rest of us to ensure that they are fragmented, internally fighting and never, ever take power in any form.

    These are the people who, consciously or unconsciously, cannot wait to get fitted for a brown shirt. Not the leaders or the vanguard, just the followers who can't wait to strut around their little neighbourhood or town and wallow in reflected power.

    1708:

    Yeah; more people are testing, so more asymptomatic cases (or false positives) are being detected. Statistics 101.

    Note sure of your point.

    Most testing in the past was broadly people without symptoms. My wife and I just got our 6th PCR test. Never had any symptoms but in each case it was before we wanted to get with our kids or after we had to be near a larger group.

    And most people I know getting tested have never been positive or symptomatic.

    Why would more people getting tested bump up the positivity rate outside of the infection percentage being higher. I don't see it.

    1709:

    Or the version I saw,

    Remember, remember, Six days past December

    Can't remember what whoever it was posted, but the above works. I see no reason to ever forget this treason.

    1710:

    Rocketjps
    I'd have said 20% ... but that in times of "stress" - like right now (C-19) - more will buy a supposedly "simple & obvious ( & WRONG) answer.
    The real problem is what happens when they creep past the 33-36% mark - about the overall percentage of those who actually voted for Adolf in'33

    1711:

    GT 1710

    I'd say that there are probably 20% who are fascist by strong inclination. The next 10-20% are people who lean that way and will follow the prevailing winds. Sadly, the winds seem to be blowing rightward at the moment, and a lot of views that should be shunned are out in the open. The Overton window has moved such that actual extremist fascists are inside the rightward edge, which empowers a lot of people who just casually agree with a lot of their precepts to drift that way as well.

    I don't think it is a fait accompli, but the danger is real and growing.

    1712:

    You can replace "the 10th" with plain "15th", and still keep the same number of syllables and the same stress pattern. It's the difference in stress pattern in the next line, from "gunpowder" to "and Sherman's", where the failure to scan becomes significant.

    1713:

    Holy forking shirtballs!

    Wait, am I in The Good Place now?

    1714:

    In the US a few years back a survey of people old enough at the time to pay attention, about 1/3 of them thought Tricky Dick did not commit any crimes. It was all a witch hunt. Talk about tribal.

    1715:

    So you are suggesting that what we should be doing is going out and starting lots of competing right-wing parties, to split the RWA vote?

    We've seen one cycle of that with Reform, which split from the Progressive Conservatives and then rejoined as Alliance, then just Conservative — and dragged the whole Tory party to the right in the process. Alberta's UCP has gone through the same process.

    1716:

    about 1/3 of them thought Tricky Dick did not commit any crimes

    Including Tricky Dick. "When the President does it, that means that it is not illegal"

    Trump apparently feels the same way, as do his supporters.

    1717:

    That "window" may have gotten wider - or are you not seeing the actual self-proclaimed socialists in the US Congress, and let me assure you, from personal knowledge, that the DSA, as of three or four years ago, had grown by literally an order of magnitude, and it's still growing.

    1718:

    Trump apparently feels the same way

    To be honest he just doesn't give a damn. At all. His entire life is about how to ignore the rules and get away with it. From trivial to hugely legal issues. He is the libertarian taken to the ultimate extreme.

    1719:

    are you not seeing the actual self-proclaimed socialists in the US Congress

    They look pretty middle-of-the-road from up here, and probably the same from Europe. Certainly not very left-wing.

    The only reason Bernie and AOC look "socialist" in America is 'cause you folks are pretty far-right in your political spectrum.

    1720:

    I tend to the theory that Trump rejects all this intellectual wank and is purely "Make Trump Great (Again)", no further thought than that. Almost Australian in his "what can I get away with" approach to other people, their property and anything else that catches his eye.

    He cheats at golf FFS.

    1721:

    I think you're conflating Trump with Trump supporters. My relatives and others that are hard core Trump supporters want the federal government to go back to somewhere around 1821 or before. To them he is a means to an end. And they are somewhat delusional about the actual man himself.

    Trump just wants to do whatever he wants with no consequences to him. Screw others.

    1722:

    Per Wikipedia.

    "Libertarians seek to maximize autonomy and political freedom, emphasizing free association, freedom of choice, individualism and voluntary association."

    Is there such a think as a libertarian anarchist?

    PS: He cheats at EVERYTHING. Even if he doesn't need to. (I have this cousin...)

    1723:

    вядзьмак Zone Police:
    (Have all of that, except missed whatever was cut at 1665.)

    Good to see the qz.com link on "Tek Fog". BJP social media operatives/ops are really annoying.

    TR Lira is tanking (again) and there's serious moves...
    Recep Erdoğan is making mistakes. Good to see. (Looked at a few days of TR-related news feed and a sampling of the last month.) Inflation at that level is stressful for a society.

    They're not sending their best: yeah, they are: that is the best of them. That's how bad it is, and thus they have to degrade the entire Battlefield / Societal Structure to compete.
    That's a clarifying way to put it.

    Jan 6 had enthusiastic participation including planning from Republican operatives (e.g. Stone, Bannon, many others) and politicians (inc Trump, he thought deniably), and that's just the open stuff which had bad or no OPSEC. The antifa types avoided the event (word spread and everyone pretty much agreed), so the hoped-for mass street fights (chaos justifying Trump-gov action) did not happen. (And DC has strict gun laws.) Also, the US intel agencies (and FBI) are thoroughly contaminated with RW nuts.
    So ... mixed.

    BTW, finally read American Gods(Neil Gaiman, 2003). I was afraid I'd be annoyed, but no, good story, well told. Thanks for the recent nudges.

    1724:

    I think you had it right the first time. The anarchist position is usually that you can have a decent society without overarching coercive institutions like governments, and manage it through voluntary institutions like co-operatives and clubs. Leaving aside this "constitutionalist" thing which doesn't make sense outside a specific jurisdiction, libertarians have a difference position: that you must manage without any institutions other than raw power, and the society that emerges as a result is the only just one (because power is the only true motive). People who say they are libertarians often deny this, but the account they give is (usually) essentially a paraphrase, using words that have positive connotations for them. Many, perhaps most, offer a milder version of this, that some government is necessary because poor people can't look after themselves. I suppose this is their version of anarchists saying that some government is necessary because powerful people are fuckers. You can probably tell I'm more sympathetic to the anarchists?

    1725:

    David L
    TrumpBo Jon-Sun just wants to do whatever he wants with no consequences to him. Screw others.

    1726:

    Is there such a think as a libertarian anarchist?

    No, libertarianism split off from anarchism a long time ago, because the libertarians couldn't let go of the idea that they need an army and police to force their ideas on other people. And defend property rights, defined largely as "I've got mine". Or, as the anarchist cartoon put it "your ancestor won that in battle. Ok, we'll fight you for it".

    As noted by Damian, there are many strands to libertarianism, some indistinguishable from fascism and others more economic anarchists. But the key thing that distinguishes them from anarchists is an acceptance that consent of the population is impossible and therefore force is required.

    Some rude people say that that's because they want a very unequal society, and ain't no-one gunna consent to that. But I'm sure there's more to it. It's just I haven't met any genuinely poor libertarians, they're all either rich or the children of rich people. So it's hard to know whether they really are fighting not just for the right to enslave others or harvest their organs, but also for the right to be enslaved or have their bodies otherwise sold.

    1727:

    If it had been in the UK, he wouldn't have committed any crimes! My view was then (and now) that he was hammered because he didn't arrange a suitable excuse and didn't just treat it as SOP. Many other presidents have broken the law and got away with it, but they did the former and not the latter.

    Whether Trump will get away with his flagrant actions I can't say.

    1728:

    https://www.vice.com/en/article/y3v3ny/all-my-apes-gone-nft-theft-victims-beg-for-centralized-saviors

    less than one percent of users (institutional investors) account for 64 percent of Coinbase’s trading volume, and 10 percent of traders account for 85 percent of NFT transactions and trade 97 percent of all NFTs at least once.

    Ah, yes, the "decentralised" cryptowhatsit continues to evolve. And use more energy, and chips, but I'm sure it will all make sense eventually.

    I am really tempted to start making NFT's of Charlie's blog pages or something equally daft, just to see if I can sell them.

    1729:

    If the extra people being tested were ones with symptoms, that could happen. The positivity rate is very dependent on why people get tested.

    1730:

    On Libertarianism. Here is the story of what happened when libertarianism met reality. I've linked to this in previous threads, but it bears repeating (sorry).

    When you analyse Libertarianism against Socialism Classic you find that many of their ideas are actually the same. Both expect the State to fade away, to be replaced by good-hearted citizens naturally doing what is right, and depending on personal reputation as an enforcement mechanism where natural good-feeling fails. I could go on, but a detailed compare-and-contrast essay would not be very useful. The point is that both are equally unrealistic.

    I haven't heard a Libertarian explain away Grafton, but no doubt "yes, but it wasn't true libertarianism" will appear somewhere, along with "it would have worked if it weren't for all the nasty authoritarian socialists trying to destroy it".

    1731:

    He cheats at golf FFS.

    I read Commander in Cheat a few years ago. It was surprisingly interesting.

    https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2019/apr/02/donald-trump-golf-28-club-championships

    1732:

    If the extra people being tested were ones with symptoms, that could happen. The positivity rate is very dependent on why people get tested.

    That is basically the case here now. Home tests don't get reported, and PCR tests are being restricted to symptomatic people so…

    1733:

    When you analyse Libertarianism against Socialism Classic you find that many of their ideas are actually the same. Both expect the State to fade away, to be replaced by good-hearted citizens naturally doing what is right, and depending on personal reputation as an enforcement mechanism where natural good-feeling fails. I could go on, but a detailed compare-and-contrast essay would not be very useful. The point is that both are equally unrealistic.

    I haven't read a Libertarian Walks Into A Bear yet, but it seems to be about the story I'd expect.

    I'm with the native peoples: no one "naturally does what's right." They have to be taught, because human life's too complicated to intuit out. And personal reputation only goes so far. The more interesting thing is that I think Graeber and Co. are likely right when they point out that "anarchist" or "heterarchical" societies seem to work because a) they're relatively small, and generally b) everybody who can stand it spends a lot of time talking things over, much as we do here. It's a constant problem solving exercise, much as life anywhere else is.

    The other issue that generally gets ignored is what I'd call the 90% problem, which is that 10% of people do 90% of the work, and 90% of people do the other 10%. That's why it's so useful to have 90% of the people talking, as here. This problem seems to be endemic in every organization I've ever belonged to. And, so far as I know, it crops up in nonhuman groups like termite colonies. Making the big but (apparently) reasonable assumption that you're generally going to only have 10% of a group doing most of the organizing, teaching, and other hard stuff--if you're lucky--then things like communism, libertarianism, and socialism are going to be really hard to pull off. This is NOT an argument for authoritarian systems. You can certainly make a heterarchy work this way if you call the 10% elders, peace chiefs, and the like, and put them to work organizing the other 90% for sporadic but essential stuff. But 90% slackers seems to be a recurring limit that any political theorist needs to work around. And it also may explain why charismatic authoritarians can capture a group, at least temporarily, by rousing some part of the 90% to do shit for them.

    The sad part is how many organizers beat themselves into a bloody pulp trying to get more of the 90% to activate. It's even more sad when a scheme depends on activating the 90% to do the right thing. I can't be the only one who's had this experience...

    1734:

    If it had been in the UK, he wouldn't have committed any crimes!

    Seriously? He approved/directed others to commit law on the books criminal operations.

    The fibbing people could accept.

    1735:

    The positivity rate is very dependent on why people get tested.

    Yes. And I know it is a small sample compared to the area population but everyone I have to interact with and their families and close associates get tested on a somewhat regular basis. I'd say it's 100 people. I've had PCR tests 6 times. And now many of us are doing rapid tests now that they are available.

    What I'm saying is more people I know getting tested (100+) are doing it without symptoms. Just after something that makes them leery or before some of us gather. We may be an outlier but so far we push the positivity down.

    1736:

    So where do the self proclaimed smartest in the room fit in? Those who drop in and give out the Picard "Make It So" commands?

    1737:

    So where do the self proclaimed smartest in the room fit in? Those who drop in and give out the Picard "Make It So" commands?

    I can call spirits from the vasty deep. I can summon spirits from the deep ocean.

    Why, so can I, or so can any man, But will they come when you do call for them?

    1738:

    Re omicron,

    I was delighted a couple of weeks ago when a good friend I'd lost contact with got in touch after 10 years. He and his wife were well, missing travel (my first trip through Asia was with him and my mother who were work colleagues). He'd recently retired and was looking forward to doing more travel when this covid thing was over.

    Yesterday I was a bit down as I often am on my mother's birthday (she's been gone 12 years and I still miss her greatly). His message popped up on my screen which cheered me up at once.

    It wasn't him, it was his wife with the news that he'd died that morning. Covid 19.

    Australia is a total disaster area at the moment, but the news cycle is dominated by a tennis player who can't fill out a form correctly.

    It's just giganticly shit.

    1739:

    the news cycle is dominated by a tennis player who can't fill out a form correctly. -
    That's not just in Australia. The English Broadcasting Corporation even seem to think that we like him!!

    1740:

    If you're always the smartest person in the room, you're in the wrong room.

    1741:

    It's just giganticly shit.

    One of the deaths in Queensland this week was a fully vaccinated 30-year-old with no prior conditions, whose complication was myocarditis. The new CHO, who had recently advocated for "this is the right time to let it rip" was on as a talking head explaining that this is a rare complication that we're only seeing because of the number of cases. Well duh, fucker. Sadly the state (Labor) government seems to have segued from "do everything we can to keep people safe" to "be slightly less shit than the conservatives" as a strategy for the next election (not for a couple of years at state level as much as there is a federal one imminent).

    Meanwhile the quarantine hotel with the tennis player is full of refugees who have been in immigration detention for 10 years.

    1742:

    Robert van der Heide @ 1683:

    Be wary, be wary

    6 January

    Stupidity, MAGA and plot

    I see no reason Republican treason

    Should ever be forgot!

    - Jeff Bigler

    I'm stealin' that!

    1743:

    Depends on what version of "socialism classic".

    I was a Wobbly a couple of times, but moved back to what I consider more classic socialism, because you do need a government to, say, deal with the 2,000 scum a year ago.

    1744:

    ilya187 @ 1681: the motor pool of one of his units only had one working starter for a couple of dozen trucks

    Are you sure it was "one working starter" and not "one working battery"? AFAIK, if starter motor does not work, jump-starting won't do any good, since what they do is supply current to the starter motor.

    I can visualize the mechanics having to install the starter on one truck and after it's running having to remove that starter again to install it on another truck.

    It would be a real serious PITA and dangerous to mechanic's fingers, but it's just stupid enough it could work.

    1745:

    Robert Prior @ 1716:

    about 1/3 of them thought Tricky Dick did not commit any crimes

    Including Tricky Dick. "When the President does it, that means that it is not illegal"

    Trump apparently feels the same way, as do his supporters.

    The real difference is Tricky Dick didn't have half the Supreme Court and half the Senate agreeing with him.

    1746:

    @1722:

    ["My relatives and others that are hard core Trump supporters want the federal government to go back to somewhere around 1821 or before."]

    To the days when only white males with a certain amount of property and wealth were able to vote! Which means we could bring back slavery for anyone we can point to and say, 'of Other descent than white!" No public education, no public health, no libraries, no anything that's not privately owned. In fact, if you don't already own a company, a bank, a corporation, you can't start one. The days of wine and roses.

    1747:

    zephvark @ 1720: Trump isn't remotely Libertarian. They're strict Constitutionalists. Solipsistic anarchist, more like.

    Narcissistic Sociopathy.

    1748:

    And also the PM commentating at a cricket match saying "{Omicron} is taking wickets". Thanks for that lovely sporting analogy oh dear leader, I guess we all know which side you're on now. I can die happy knowing that the PM's team is winning.

    1749:

    I used to be utterly confused by people who were clearly on team virus.

    However I now have a working theory.

    The people who believe that there's a giant fairy in the sky that controls everything are team virus. I'll quote ABC news here as I think you can't be libellous if you are reporting what someone else said. They said about the new Premier that removed almost all of the covid restrictions and presided over the state that saw a 100 fold increase in covid infections over the last 6 weeks:

    As a child he attended the Roman Catholic school Redfield College in Dural.

    The school's chaplain is an Opus Dei priest.

    Opus Dei is recognised as part of the Catholic Church, and has historically been accused of secrecy, elitism and misogyny.

    But Mr Perrottet has never shied away from making his faith public.

    Last year he spoke about how his devout Catholic beliefs have had a fundamental influence on his work in politics.

    "I think having a Christian faith is part of who I am and inspires me to make a difference wherever I go," he said.

    The ABC carefully doesn't say that Dom is Opus Dei, and I'm obviously not saying that either.

    Team virus seem to think that they are protected. Generally by God, but God works through the vaccine, not having a menial face to face job and being able to take time off work to hide from the infected. A local religious school got the vaccine months ahead of everyone else via a private import. I don't think you or I could import our own drugs (not without the cover of night anyway) but they did it. God hates poor people. That's why he makes rapid antigen tests expensive, private hospitals expensive and reserves these things for rich people. Like Scotty from marketing.

    How good is the virus!

    1751:

    Could a mod please delete my second identical post. Not sure how that happened. Sorry

    1752:

    1750, 1751, 1755, 1756, 1757

    Moderators & Charlie - 1756(a) 1756(b) - especially the latter!

    1753:

    Yes. The details are complicated, but what JBS said in #1746 is relevant, though only part of the story.

    1754:

    Other parts being, I suspect, more vivid popular memories of WWII and fascism, as well as a strong external enemy in the USSR hence the need to differentiate America from what was portrayed as an autocracy.

    1755:

    I don't think so. Most of the USA differences date from the founding of the USA, and were an attempt to constrain any development of autocracy. The UK system is largely because the office of Prime Minister has inherited the powers of the Crown (think 18th century), compounded with the theoretical supremacy of Parliament (now meaning the Commons).

    1756:

    "Moderators & Charlie - 1756(a) 1756(b) - especially the latter!"
    Greg, you clearly do not know what those mean. That's tech talk, saying that the blog's content is mirrored elsewhere for various reasons. Probably the mirrors, if public facing, are blocking search engine indexers (through normal consensus means[1]).
    Heck, I keep a archive/mirror (trying to keep a light footprint), partly to keep track of things I've said here; this is easy to set up. (And the comment about Norns was in no way hostile to you.) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robots\_exclusion\_standard#About\_the\_standard

    1757:

    I was referring to the differences between Nixon and Trump, which seemed to be the comment you were referring to. (The one about half the Senate and Supreme Court.)

    1758:

    Bill Arnold
    Assuming your explanations are correct ( & I have no idea ) - then ... pass.

    1759:

    do you think spooks (or more likely algorithms) are attempting to glean profit from our ruminations (or maybe just the seagull's veiled stock tips)?

    i wish them luck

    Specials

    Merchandise

    About this Entry

    This page contains a single entry by Charlie Stross published on December 7, 2021 3:51 PM.

    Outage report was the previous entry in this blog.

    Quantum of Nightmares is the next entry in this blog.

    Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

    Search this blog

    Propaganda