martin089

martin089

  • Commented on Ask the Author
    Another one! 4) Sometimes around Rule 34, you said something to the effect that you don't believe in free will. Can you elaborate which concept(s) of free will you don't believe make sense, and which ones might? And what does...
  • Commented on Ask the Author
    Several questions! 1) Of the diverse utopian societies depicted in SF, is there one where'd you think "a society like this just might work (without magical tech)" and "I wanna live there?" 2) My feeling is that you write fantasy...
  • Commented on On the lack of cultural estrangement in SF
    Skipped the last 70ish comments, skimmes quite a few beforeso sorry if I'm redundant here. Three thoughts. To write about a different society you need to observe and think about society. I think an author who transplants, say 60ties suburbia...
  • Commented on On the lack of cultural estrangement in SF
    My guess why quite a few authors don't really bother to extrapolate social change: 1) You need to think a lot about society, and not everybody does that - sadly. 2) You will not only make assumptions that will be...
  • Commented on Let's put the future behind us
    (((Extensivly refering to Jared Diamond is another strange attractor round here. We should get him to take his knowledge of birds and islands and derive some bold, counterintuitive statements about the singularity. Nerdsplosion ensues))...
  • Commented on Let's put the future behind us
    Refugees is who lifeboats are for. I think you are talking about castles for practically feudal elite. Cosy catastrophy much? I think KSR got the whole 'lifeboat' argument right in the latter parts of the mars trilogy: There's so, so...
  • Commented on Let's put the future behind us
    Hmm. I wonder if the aspects that would make a space station a likely candidate for a police state would also apply in Siberia, or Greenland or Antarctica (just a few orders of magnitude les so, but still more than...
  • Commented on Let's put the future behind us
    Funny. Today, on my way back from work I was thinking about how crime might look like in panopticon space station. I arrived at a guy who breaks into a liquor store and drinks all he can before the police...
  • Commented on Leading question
    I'm thinking close to the wording of the original question: Where does the power come from? At first glance, I found scenarios depicted above like soviet Russia with extensive social networks enabling the subsistance of the people plausible. But Russia...
  • Commented on Metacommentary
    For some reason the first example that spring to my mind for the trope " is evil and must be stopped" are Banks' Idirans. Where the problem seems to be that they belive in manifest destiny among the stars, once...
  • Commented on Metacommentary
    Getting back to the guest posts and why the threads stay so much on topic ... I read most of Charlies posts as containing some question (like this one), while most guest posts I remember were pretty much closed essays....
  • Commented on Not a Manifesto
    About the "urban" in UF - I think the most urban-feeling fantasy to me were the Hoduns in Count Zero. This fusing of street smarts with magical thinking impressed me deeply. Someone asked about the real world impact of Rand....
  • Commented on Not a Manifesto
    Is magic a form of technology? Let's see how magic works in different fictional settings: Homers ancient greeks - magic, yes, but mostly powerful individuals. The whole thing feels magical because the stories are grand. Grimms Fairytales - no consistency...
  • Commented on Crib Sheet: Neptune's Brood
    Interstallar communication was a topic on this blog a while back: http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2011/12/tanenbaums-law-v-the-fermi-par.html Short version: sending a chunk of storage media may be a higher bandwidth communication than a laser. So for a different Freyaverse (the Leyaverse?) we could have three...
  • Commented on Crib Sheet: Neptune's Brood
    regarding the whole question of 'real' value etc - A few years back, I stumbled over the article "Once again, on fictios capital" by Loren Goldner (freely available) that went to great lengths to explain value that's seemingly disconnected from...
  • Commented on Crib Sheet: Neptune's Brood
    First of all, when I saw 'crib sheet neptunes brood' in my feed reader I thought "Now'S the time to ask! Did you run into a deadline, or what was up with the ending?" Second, back when Neptunes Brood was...
  • Commented on The Ferguson Question
    While the peelian prinicples seem sound, I think the most basic thing that makes a police a police is that it's (in theory) about crime and lawbreakers: Someone breaks a law, we find him and drag him to a court...
  • Commented on Message for GISHWHES participants
    I think the "commandment" not to harrass writers or others misses the point. It's not the issue if one asks politely or not. _The issue is that with many people asking, no matter how politely, the whole thing becomes a...
  • Commented on Competition Time!
    [Redacted]'s attempt to use a Hero trap based on Nablakovs Lolita to seduce underage women has, not surprisingly, led to [Redacted]'s arrest. All whom it may concern shall remember to never base geases on works featureing an unreliable narrator....
  • Commented on Competition Time!
    The Laundry does not discriminate against employees pursuing a BDSM lifestyle or using practices from the same, on the contrary the Laundry welcome s all activities that help our most valuable assets to deal with stress. However, we wish to...
  • Commented on The myth of heroism
    First, I also strongly recommend the cracked piece. Here's why: I think superhero is far from classical greek and similiar mythology (superpowered beeings do amoral things) and closer to knights tales - stories spun to teach those knights how to...
  • Commented on Generation Z
    Heteromeles, I'm interested in reading something like this and want to encourage you to finish this a little bit....
  • Commented on Why AIs Won't Ascend in the Blink of an Eye - Some Math
    I think the whole graph and the reasoning behind it is fundamentally flawed: On one axis, we have "time". But time itself says nothing, we should be looking at is beeing produced in this time, and suddenly we may be...
  • Commented on "The next big thing"
    What's the big thing now, or rather which things are big? I find it hard to extrapolate from my personal reading. I'd guess neuroscience (or rather neuro pop-science) is in, Zombies are on their way out or are allready yesteryears...
  • Commented on "The next big thing"
    Rereading my post, this so hopelessly 2011....
  • Commented on "The next big thing"
    You used to say "Look at what Bruce Stirling is doing, he's usually a few years ahead of everyone else." I give it a shot (Without knowing or understanding everything Bruce is doing): Boris is trying to fashion 3D-printed lingery...
  • Commented on Trust Me (I'm a kettle)
    Is this so? Can someone do the math on wether power is the main cost in computing? Come to think of it: Let's say a Rasp Pie costs 20€, and a kWh 20 €ct, then the Rasp Pie would have...
  • Commented on Trust Me (I'm a kettle)
    This. This is so true, sadly. Try to think about it another way: It takes more time to debunk myths than to create them, it takes more time to disprove slander than to spread it. And slander is, by definition,...
  • Commented on Trotskyite singularitarians for Monarchism! A political speculation.
    yes, the first ones. the MG/Gegenstandpunkt don't have any strategy at all, and are not relevant to the discussion here....
  • Commented on Trotskyite singularitarians for Monarchism! A political speculation.
    I don't know you guys, but I know a branch of leftist nutjobs over here in germany. Part of the nutkobbery are two beleifs: 1) enlightment is great, capitalism is a logical conlcusion iof enlightment and any rest od pre-capitalist...
Subscribe to feed Recent Actions from martin089

Following

Not following anyone

Specials

Merchandise

About This Page

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Search this blog

Propaganda