
MickyFinn
Recent Actions
-
Commented on The Biggest Little SF Publisher you never heard of pulls on the jackboots
I'll read enough of what arrives in the voter packet to make up my mind on the actual work, but just judging from Michael Z Williamson's blog, I suspect that this isn't a case of Poe's Law. Anyone posting this...
-
Commented on The Biggest Little SF Publisher you never heard of pulls on the jackboots
Its far from certain that they're going to force reform of the nominations process. And yeah, if it happens, SP members may claim victory. Hell, I'm prepared to consider improvement to the voting process as a victory for all reasonable...
-
Commented on The Biggest Little SF Publisher you never heard of pulls on the jackboots
I think we should look for a fix that does not openly discriminate against them. Possibly some sort of fix which discriminates against nominations being dominated by slates? Maybe something like RAV? A fix which will, even in non-slate years,...
-
Commented on The Biggest Little SF Publisher you never heard of pulls on the jackboots
I think that's about as good as you can get. It will sound very bad to a lot of people. "They say it isn't corrupt because they made a rule to do it that way. They made the rule last...
-
Commented on The Biggest Little SF Publisher you never heard of pulls on the jackboots
How on earth did you get from "Reasonable Third Party" to "Fox News"?...
-
Commented on The Biggest Little SF Publisher you never heard of pulls on the jackboots
a) "The Hugo nominees were selected using Re-weighted Approval Voting, in accordance with the rules and regulations covering nominations" b) Hugo nomination statistics aren't released until after the ceremony. It is very likely that one of the 80 vote or...
-
Commented on The Biggest Little SF Publisher you never heard of pulls on the jackboots
LRon, I'll be voting for No Award before any of the puppy Slate nominees, because that is the best way I have of discouraging this sort of shenanigans. Hopefully, next year, people should see being placed on the slate of...
