Have you done a comedy at a longer length than short stories?

Set up a Xanatos Gambit?

Girl and her Dragon?

Meddling kids? (Arguably the crew in Dead Lies Dreaming fills this role, but they aren't really kids.)

A murder mystery with every character a reasonable suspect?

Where does Scratch Monkey fit in all this? It's not mentioned above, though it seems to be a book that exists, as I can see it on my shelf.

While you're allergic to Westerns, I'm going to rant about the underlying tropes anyway, because I think the main tradition of Westerns actually does ask an interesting question about how society is structured, specifically: how does society structure itself in the absence of strong, trustworthy state authority?

The answer to this question, for most classic Westerns, is "because individuals with strong moral compasses use wit and frequently force to make it so". Which, yes, this gets hoary and hokey and problematic real fast. "A good guy with a gun," mythmaking- fundamental to so many classic Westerns. But then you get films like The Ox-Bow Incident, or, as I like to call it, "Twelve Angry Cowboys" (it's even got Henry Fonda!), a courtroom drama on the frontier, tackling racism and mob justice.

This core question even permeates the more deconstructionist later Westerns, especially the Spaghetti Westerns, but they have a simpler answer: in the absence of strong, trustworthy state authority, society just structures itself around violence. And a lot of these films revel in that answer.

This is also what gives us the cross-pollination of Westerns and Noir- while A Fistful of Dollars is famously based off of the novel Red Harvest (and Yojimbo, itself an adaptation of Red Harvest), we can see that cross pollination even earlier in movies like A Bad Day at Black Rock, a Noir with Western tropes, once again, investigating how racism influences society, and how without a strong, trusted state authority, personality cults tend to replace them. (A Bad Day at Black Rock is more Noir than Western, and if one hasn't seen it, I'd recommend it- it's one of my favorite movies).

Drifting from here into Science Fiction, it's easy to see how this core question of Westerns influenced Heinlein and the early days of SciFi. Hell, arguably (very arguably), one could argue that the Foundation series is really a Western for people who are really passionate about spreadsheets.

So yes, I'd agree- it's not a good predictive model. Most of the answers Westerns propose to their core question are wrong; overly simplistic, needlessly violent, and absent any forward thinking. But it's still an interesting question, and one that works within a variety of framing devices.

Oh, and it's also just worth noting Pale Rider, the time Clint Eastwood accidentally made a movie with Marxist themes (miners who extract wealth from the Earth through labor are in conflict with capitalists who are industrializing mining, and the miners are the good guys specifically because of their labors).

I have to say I would love to see your take on Dark Academia/protagonist goes to magic school, I love the genre but it's ripe for a good kicking

Have you done a comedy at a longer length than short stories?

Sure! That's about half the Laundry Files.

Set up a Xanatos Gambit?

Aineko in Accelerando is wall-to-wall Xanatos Gambit, all the time.

Meddling kids? (Arguably the crew in Dead Lies Dreaming fills this role, but they aren't really kids.)

You haven't read Quantum of Nightmares, have you?

A murder mystery with every character a reasonable suspect?

Murder mysteries are booooooring.

It exists, but as I wrote it 1990-93 I don't pay it much attention. File under juvenilia.

You're focusing on the foregrounded plot elements of the western genre, and seem to be ignoring the horrendous racism and genocide going on in the background. That's kind of a deal-breaker for me. (I can cope with westerns where that stuff is the focus, or where the protagonists are explicitly de-privileged -- not white men with agency, but women and minorities trying to keep going around the edges.)

Several, but I doubt they are your scene, though you touch on them in some stories.

Upbeat stories. Trunk and Disorderly counts, but is a very specialised form. The same applies to humour, excluding the fair amount of incidental (usually dark) humour in your stories.

Pastoral SF, whether human, alien or alien ecology. 'Nuff said.

Ones with radically alternative evolutions, as primary 'plots' rather than through a mirror of humanity. That gives a LOT of scope for cultural assumptions, but is damn hard to do well.

There are lots of other forms of alternative society SF you could explore, though many of the above are fairly solidly in that category.

You haven't seen that mostly because I went to one of those second-tier British fee-paying schools that aped the first-tier posh public (read: expensive and private) schools like Eton and Harrow, and I hated it. I'm almost certainly somewhere on the ASD spectrum, and you couldn't design a better torture chamber for aspies than a British public school environment.

Don't get me started :-( While a story of yours about such things would be fully justified, if you are like me, writing it would be hell.

I've mentioned this before, but I went to a sibling school of the one Golding taught at, and was asked by a stupid adult what I thought of Lord of the Flies. My response was that it was FAR too naive and rose-tinted.

As a side note: I think the reason it took so long to get rogue 3D printers is that most of them don't have cloud connectivity. The most common models, even today, give you a choice between loading the file on an SD card and sending that file over USB.

That's sorta why I brought up The Ox-Bow Incident and A Bad Day at Black Rock, which both directly tackle racism, and I think the Ox-Bow Incident ends up being very interesting for it, because while yes, it's a white perspective on racism, our POV characters are outsiders who are afraid to intervene lest the mob turn on them.

It's also why I was pointing to the fundamental question, and less the setting- to me, what makes a western a western is that fundamental question, not cowboys and horses (with a heaping helping of of genocide). Hence including Black Rock (which takes place in the 50s).

It's difficult to discuss genocide in the context of Westerns, because Westerns themselves are so ahistorical that they never really were in a good place to grapple with it. They're not about a historical period, despite their pretensions, and trying to compare the mythology of Westerns with the bloody history at which they gesture runs into immediate trouble that dates back to the Dime Store fictionalizations of the 19th century.

Now, sure, there are plenty of Westerns that include Natives in various roles, especially as faceless antagonists (Stagecoach leaps to mind, which definitely doesn't age well).

I guess, in the end, I don't tend to see much difference between genre fiction- Western, Noir, and Sci-Fi are all thematically very similar, and given that there are specific works in the Western genre that I feel strongly about, I always want to lift at least those works back up into the public eye.

(Also, I have the worst time commenting here, as my session always times out)

(Future) Police Procedural?

I get that there are elements of this in the New Management but I suppose I'm thinking more of an exploration of what radical developments in police/crime procedure might look like if technology were no object...

The New Management is social commentary/satire rather than direct extrapolation. And if book 4 gets written, it'll be set in the dizzy far future of ... 2018, because the Laundry timeline asyptotically closed in on the Lovecraftian Singularity of May 2015.

The elite panic link is borked.

Yep, the Bambu printers involved in the incident are closed source hardware and software and heavily dependent on cloud connectivity. They are apparently quite good and fast and are selling reasonably well. Most printers are based on the work of Josef Prusa who runs his own company but releases the hardware and software designs as open source resulting in many variations of differing quality. There's a popular application by the name of OctoPrint, often bundled as an OS image called OctoPi ready to run on a Raspberry Pi if you can get one, for controlling 3d printers that has the potential to cause mayhem if any miscreants found a way in.

Yes but those are still Westerns, which are basically American Kitsch, and I am not interested in writing pastiches of American cultural touchstones. If I was going to go there, the equivalent would be a Kipling tribute (hint: I am not a fan of Kipling's imperialist ideology).

I would like to see your take on a "choose your own adventure" book and yes, I am serious.

How about straight-up military sci-fi? It does not need to be jingoistic or militaristic, it can be downright pacifistic; indeed in my opinion the best examples of the genre are exactly that or close to that anyway.

Not tropes, precisely, but I'll point out a couple of things to consider:

One is that cultural appropriation goes both ways. I get this because my Korean-born wife loves K-dramas and K-pop. Aside from the historical fantasies, to me these works look much like Korean appropriation of American material, to the point where Korean shows get remade by US companies (The Good Doctor, for instance), ColdPlay teams with BTS, and so forth. It's not white cultural imperialism (whites telling Koreans what to do), it's Koreans appropriating the American culture they've been intimate with for decades as a result of the Cold War.

Everyone swipes stuff, whether it's art or food. You produce a story with yokai from Japan, they produce manga and anime with blond straight-nosed. You eat tikka masala, they eat squid and corn pizza (not to mention Korean Army Stew). Appropriation goes both ways.

Another thing is that not everybody who has white ancestors identifies as white. Barack Obama, the Black President, had a white mother. But he's black. A fun example is in the linked article*, about increasing and increasingly respectful cooperation between Australian scientists and Australian Aborigines. It's a worthwhile article in itself, but look at the third photo. The light-skinned, pink-haired woman on the left is aboriginal, and she's far from alone. Many aboriginal and diasporic people have white ancestors as a result of imperialism, colonialism, and slavery. We tend to fetishize the "most genuine" people and their culture, but this in itself is a relic of imperialist ethnography. That's not who they are these days, and who they are these days sometimes gets lost in fantasy.

I guess my bottom line here is that tropes tend to stereotype, and this can become a bit of a blind spot.

• https://www.science.org/content/article/indigenous-people-shaped-australias-curious-geography-plants?

A "pilgrimage" with an "object" - but twisted ... ?
The protagonists(s) find they have been tricked & now have to work out how to get out of their pickle.

Or. alternatively, a pilgrimage or journey that of itself, turns out to be futile ( Rainbow's End, or "Foot of the Arch in ringworld for example } but leads to interesting conclusions, good/bad/indifferent - or all three.

A puzzle-set, or maze - though that tends towards RPG's & other games.

How about the not-too-deep past?
"Britain" between Cheddar Man & just before the coming of the Romans?
There were at least two major population-changes in that period & there is vast dispute as to how peaceful &/or violent those changes were.
Specifically NOT "the matter of Britain" unless you want to guy it unmercifully, of course. { And I DO NOT mean "Monty Python" either. }

For MilSF, see Singularity Sky.

One is that cultural appropriation goes both ways.

Yup!

Some years ago my wife and I were visiting a Japanese supermarket in London and she wanted to pick up some Manga. So we get to the books/periodicals/magazines department and she squints ... then points out that the Katakana caption on the Manga shelf is transliterated as "comic-su". (We call their comics manga, they call our manga comics.)

This may be covered by your in-progress stuff — but utopian SF. A Trek Federation / Banks Culture?

Also — while kinda covered by some of the Laundry/New Management books — a good old fashion heist is fun.

(I'm assuming that plague/pandemic style stories are just… not gonna be a thing considering :-)

Oh! Big arse Dumas style saga. You've done fun things with narrative voice a few times… you've done the 1800s thing… but playing with that voice/form might be fun.

Ada Palmer's Terra Ignota series, Brust's Khaavren Romances, that kinda thing.

Fair enough, I went to a Girls'(Public) Day School Trust which was similarly hard but at least I didn't have to live there

How about a classic high fantasy prophesied idiot with magic sword subversion?

PKD reality-slip. Often paranoid but not required.

Aquarian Age psychics. Julian May’s “Intervention” and similar ilk.

A warm, cozy story largely from a kid’s POV where it is clear terrible things they don’t understand are happening around them while assorted Machines Of Loving Grace shuttle them to safety. There is a happy ending.

A heist. Combine it with a Canterbury Tales collection of shorts exploring the backgrounds of the motley crew of esoteric specialties this intricate plan to steal a whole bunch of money requires.

Survival in a hostile environment. I’ve read and enjoyed so many pulpy books where the protagonist(s) must trek across an unindustrialized world, equipped only with their wits, whatever compact high-tech tools they have (solar powered ice-needle gun, umbrella-tent, etc), and their saucy banter. Half of Clayton’s Diadem books, the third of Daley’s Alacrity Fitzhughs… They always feel like they write themselves when they’re done well, which is probably an indication of quite the opposite.

Oh Hello It Turns Out The Fantasy Novel You Just Read 2/3 Of Is Actually SF

How about the not-too-deep past? "Britain" between Cheddar Man & just before the coming of the Romans?

No, please, NO! A Conan the Barbarian (with tentacles) would be bad enough (*), but I have never seen anything set in that milieu where the world-building grated significantly less. Oh, yes, THEORETICALLY, it could be done, but ....

It would be better to go the whole hog and write an Atlantis story.

(*) Loki save us, but I have just looked up Hyperborea and bloody Aleksandr Dugin pops up.

(Future) Police Procedural?

gestures gently at 'Rule 34' :-)

Covered by in-progress/New Management is wall=to-wall heist capers.

About that Western allergy...

I'll suggest a story line at the end, but the basic point is that the real 1870s west was an imperialist, genocidal hellscape (this was the era of settlement based on the notion that "the rain follows the plow") pasted on top of centuries of Spanish-Indian frontier wars (which gave rise to Plains Indian culture, incidentally). Many/most of the cowboys were young, poor, often immigrant or minority, uneducated, poorly paid, and with short life expectencies.

So if you ignore the tropes, it's right up your alley, from the Mississippi all the way to Hawai'i. You'd need to do research, though, and that might well make it cost ineffective.

Anyway, here's the prompt, to knock off two tropes in one story: cowboys, indians, and a werewolf. Anyway, basic laundryverse plot: a large predator progressively and spasmodically develops gorgonism, becoming more and more dangerous. It could be a wolf, a coyote, a feral dog, or set it in Gold Rush California and make it a mining camp-habituated grizzly bear. The setting is five days past the middle of nowhere, no one has anything bigger than a hand mirror, and the cowboys are too poorly educated to know what they're dealing with. And the boss wants them to wrangle cattle and keep costs down. For added drama, throw in Indians dealing with cultural genocide and also a gorgon.

Use, abuse, or lose the idea as you see fit.

Big arse Dumas style saga.

Impossible to sell as such these days. You can self-pub them as patreon or web serials, and you can slide them in under the radar -- the original Merchant Princes had potential to roll in that direction if I hadn't gotten bored/burned out/butted heads with my primary editor one time too many. But you can't go to a publisher and say "I got a great idea for a million word Dumas-style saga!" because they'll cut you off after two 100,000 word volumes if sales aren't building.

I hate high fantasy. (Comes of having grown up in a monarchy. Even in attenuated form, they suck.)

Nope. Just nope.

PKD reality-slip stuff is far too prone to veering into self-indulgence. I'll stick to the New Management folks exploring the dream roads, thanks.

Psychic powers are bunk, a side-effect of Descartes' dualism via the spiritualists -- it's usually got Christian eschatalogical assumptions baked in at a very low level and I'm having none of it.

Heists: see Dead Lies Dreaming, etc.

Cozy story from kid's POV: that's someone else's story, not mine.

Survival in a hostile environment turns out to be competence porn 2/3 of the time. Most of us would just curl up and die, and I'm at the stage in life where I find that far more relatable than actually lucking out.

SF in fantasy drag: that was the first third of a million words or so of the Merchant Princes.

Best option along those lines would be something set in Doggerland. Steve Baxter already went there. The setting has certain problems, modernism-wise, insofar as it predates writing systems (at least, any that have survived) and metallurgy -- it's neolithic at best.

Anyway, here's the prompt, to knock off two tropes in one story: cowboys, indians, and a werewolf.

Or I could, y'know, just re-read Crimson by Molly Tanzer. Which has a vampire instead of a werewolf, and is a deeply weird western (our protagonist is a trans-masc Chinese psychopomp from San Francisco: the rest of the cast is much stranger).

You've mentioned that you never cared for Narnia. Was there any fantastical fiction that your younger self did love and which your adult self could affectionately mock?

How about a classic high fantasy prophesied idiot with magic sword subversion?

From the viewpoint of the sword?

Probably crappy SF twist: the sword is an otherworldly artifact intended to kickstart/guide the primitives development, and is very frustrated that every time it manages to find a wielder they aren't interested in advancing technology and education, but just want to hoard the 'magic' and boss people around. The sword's creators, in an effort to avoid cultural contamination, programmed it so that it can't disobey a direct order from someone who has properly activated it.

Charlie
You were saying - about COVID? - um.
Yesterday, I was on a very crowded tube train, though it wasn't so when I got on it.
Quite.

Meanwhile - a very delicate subject.
You seem "very concerned" - you mention it several times - with TERF's?
Now, they may be wrong, indeed I strongly suspect that everyone, including me, of course, is wrong on some aspect of this subject/problem.
I also think it will take considerably more time to sort out.
I'm not the slightest bit bothered, provided people are content in their own skins ... which is the problem, of course ... many are not & exploration is being closed off, before all options are considered.
At the same time, I can understand why/how many actual, genuine feminists can get so worked up about it { I'm married to one } even if they may have been led up the garden path by other people with "other" agendas, shall we say?
- Like using an attack on Trans people as a wonderful excuse to trash Feminism & LGBTQ people simultaneously, perhaps?

Margaret Trauth
BIG Problem with Julia May's saga - it's rampantly christian all over the landscape.

Charlie @ 33
Umm ... the non-monarchies were no better, & often worse.
The Most Serene Republic of Venice for starters, or Rome from the Punic wars up until Gaius Julius came along, yes?

I am working on Narnia: if the next New Management book gets the green light, it'll be Narnia vs. William Burroughs (much as Quantum of Nightmares was Mary Poppins vs. Sweeney Todd).

Or I could, y'know, just re-read Crimson Vermillion by Molly Tanzer. Which has a vampire instead of a werewolf, and is a deeply weird western (our protagonist is a trans-masc Chinese psychopomp from San Francisco: the rest of the cast is much stranger).

SP Somtow published Moon Dance (reimagining the Ghost Dance movement, but with werewolves as the dancers), so yeah, Cowboys and Werewolves has been done. Probably a lot.

I was just suggesting a way to help complete your trope/trophy cabinet with a couple more tropes.

Anyway, the one that would probably be the hardest for you to write is an unsubverted monomyth. There's always the danger that it would be picked up by Hollywood, filmed, and become the only work you're known for...

On a lighter note, ignoring werewolves in the Laundryverse, where are the ghouls? Immortality for anyone with a strong stomach and a morbid sense of humor. What's not to like?

Stories where the protagonists, and possibly the society they move, in are deeply non-human. Less human than PHANGs and the Laundryverse elves, that is. Especially if said protagonists initially seem pretty humanoid but the deep divergences emerge later in the story.

A haunted house story, perhaps? With all the trappings: isolated location, overconfident investigators, mysterious presence targeting one poor victim in particular, slowly eroding sanities, etc.

Or: OceanGate's made it obvious to everyone why deep sea colonization isn't happening anytime soon, but could be worth looking at "why bother" (although that might get into climate fiction), or how it maps to freedom of the seas.

Now, they may be wrong

Greg: Yellow Card warning.

Take TERF rhetoric and replace "gender" with "Jews" or "Blacks" and what you get is transparently easy to perceive as bigotry. These people are Nazi-adjacent shitbags and apologias for them will not be tolerated on this blog.

(Your big clue should be, well ... you remember all the classic photos of Nazi book burnings in Germany in 1933? Guess what they were burning? Their very first target was the Institut für Sexualwissenschaft, which at the time was the world's first establishment for sexology research -- and a leading centre of "research and treatment for various matters regarding gender and sexuality, including gay, transgender, and intersex topics." (wiki.)

It's Nazis all the way down (and you might want to be wary of accepting western white women's feminism as an authoritative fount of wisdom on womens' rights: it's quite possible to combine support for white women's rights with profound racism against women of colour and homophobia).

You're waiting for Ghost Engine, I see.

(The protags remain liminally human until the first sex scene ...)

Haunted house: see Dead Lies Dreaming.

Ocean colonization: see Neptune's Brood.

Not exactly a trope, but what about the self-help book, or something like a story hidden in a manual?

Exchange of letters, either love letters or some historical mystery?

Speaking about collages - cyberpunk (retro-classical), or John-Brunner-like mixtures of story with "found" material?

A functioning far future stl generation ship?

1: Re Hornblower In Spaaaacccceee - and your avoidance of it is vastly appreciated. Talking about my novels, I get happy smiles when I tell people I will never have Starships of the Line firing broadsides at each other.
2. I have FTL, and it does not involve time travel (for example, see the Alcubierre drive).
3. Cli-fi/grimdark/noblebrigt/hopepunk - I am far beyond fed up with "everything has to be "-punk", like every scandal "-gate". I declared a New Literary Movement months ago: Future Perfectable (I did not say perfect). Actually, Empire Games, Earth 3 fits that.... 4. Westerns. Um. Yeah. I am reminded of the ad Galaxy used to run, back in the day, "No Bat Durstans here". On the other hand, let me mention two tv westerns that are not on anyone's list: for one, Have Gun, Will Travel" - Paladin was a fixer. There were whole shows where he did not use his gun. And the other, yes, The Lone Ranger. I have the two VCR tape origin... and a) you see Tonto, played by an actual Native America, being subjected to racism by the bad guys, and b) the Ranger and Tonto are after bad white guys, not Native Americans.

Having said all that... as we all know, the Nazis got a lot of their idiotology from the US. How about outright racism/slavery?

Oh... have you dealt with classism - superpowered people becoming a class, and looking down at normals? The current one of Lost Boys is more powerful using less powerful.

Isn't it Vermillion?

Have we done "End of Civilisation -> Post-apocalyptic Wasteland"? I used to be quite keen on that genre but "The Road" may have cured me of it.

Also is "Revolutionaries in Spaaaace" a thing? Fighting the evil empire/federation/corporation? Might be more of a Ken thing though.

And finally, I believe there is a substantial body of extruded, fiction-like produce based on the Fundies' Rapture. Might be fun to fuck about with that and turn it inside-out.

Neptune's Brood deals with space opera, slower-than-light, economics, ponzi schemes, finance, water worlds, family feuds, Age of exploration, robots are people too, bildungsroman, fraud investigation, space pirates

also, alien space bats. I've wondered for a long time if you made a bet with Ken MacLeod (Learning the World).

Heteromeles, you should know perfectly well - Barack Obama is black... to America. But then you know how puny and recessive those Pure Aryan, er, White genes are - one great-grandparent being black makes you black, rather than one one white grand-parent making you white.

Oh, that's right - if it was that way, you couldn't breed your own new slaves.... (Why, yes, they should have killed the entire families of Southern slaveowners who owned more than five slaves, and given the slaves their lands.)

Did you catch The English when it aired earlier in the year? It ticked all those boxes.

I second that! I'd love to see what you'd do with the Rapture (tm)....

What about "the shady immortal group of heroes" tropes -- think Highlander, etc... For some reason this topic is hugely popular recently in comics (and movies based on comics) -- Old Guard, Eternals, BRZRKR, probably more? all of these are occasionally exciting, but don't make much sense, would be nice to have a fresh perspective. Considering popularity of the topic this might be a ticket to the big screen )

The Festival in Singularity Sky was based on the Edinburgh Fringe?

Having to live there is the crucial difference (as in orders of magnitude).

Graphic Novels and Superheroes - you should write your own "Watchmen" or "The Boys"

Charlie @ 44
I SAID it was a delicate subject - ok?
The replace - with jews or blacks or "wimmin" rhetoric is obvious { now } & I DID say that it was now clear that um "certain persons" appeared to be manipulating the subject, also yes?
I also suspect that those same "certain persons" who are certainly right/white-wing are actually hoping & manipulating well-disposed persons, such as your self ( & me for that matter ) will over-react, so that they can then condemn ALL of us - it's a divide-&-conquer move, which is one of their favourite tactics. See also Niemöller, yes?
I happen to think that "the boss", here is wrong ( As is everybody else, of course ) - but how do I persuade her?
If I even mention the subject, she goes off loudly, all over the landscape, so I'm not going there again.

whitroth
I'm with you ( & EC, for that matter ) that FTL IS possible, under tightly-constrained circumstances - mostly no "Curvature" to return to point-of-origin before you started.
You might get "back" mere microseconds after you "left" but still no paradox, or causality-breaking - thouigh that's an extreme case..

sergei_kara
Problem - even being a "shady" immortal can/does/maybe turn into a curse for the individual concerned.
Though I think we are far too-short-lived.
4 or 5 hundred would be a better bet - how long did the Dunedain live? 2-300 IIRC?

A couple of space opera sub-tropes you've nodded to but not much: Big Dumb Objects, yes Missile Gap, but that's all I can recall; Deep History, which you kind of do in Palimpsest but that's more about the time-travel-ness of it all, and Neptune's Brood and I guess Ghost Engine are about deep future rather than ancient astronauts. The tropes kind of meet one another in Empire Games in the shape of the fortress, but it's only a few thousand years old and a few hundred meters wide. What about properly big things made up of galaxies?

A couple of tropes spring to mind: Island in the Sea of Time (ISOT), where an area and everybody in it are switched with the same area in some previous time. The original S.M. Sterling Island in the Sea of time, Eric Flint et al's 1632-verse. I understand there's one web-published one where Margaret Thatcher's UK (!) gets sent back to the early 18th century. Probably many others.

The other trope that comes to mind is the simple "person unexpectedly goes back in time". L. Sprague de Camp's Lest Darkness Fall (when did the racism fairy get into that book?!?) is a good example of that one, although there are plenty others. Two recent-ish ones by Harry Turtledove: "We Haven't Got There Yet" - William Shakespeare watches a performance of Rosenkrantz and Guildenstern are Dead. In 1605. And "Hail! Hail!" The Marx brothers get involved in the 1826 Fredonian Rebellion.

Your own Disney "movie" set in a world where genetic uplifting has given us talking animals to be the sidekicks, AI has made furniture and "magic" mirrors sentient, unified field theory makes matter and space manipulation "wizardry" commonplace...

But everybody's mother is dead.

Tropes not used, not used by much of anybody tbh:

Silurian Hypothesis: intelligent species might have existed in the past, how would we know? today, what might be living e.g. as network in crust of earth/near hydrothermal vents? There are a LOT more microbes in the crust than most people realize.

Non-FTL Travel: personally, I think it likely (for SFnal values of "likely") that something like wormholes might exist/be possible for travel, but not FTL. What you'd save wouldn't be travel time but cost, energy expenditure. I don't think writers have really thought about what kind of societies might arise if people could spread from planet to planet asynchronously.

The Bad Guy wins (Dr. Doom in a Marvel series where he finally defeats all the heroes and rules mankind, Satan wins the Battle of Armeggedon and God is dead as in Blish's "Black Easter", Man in the High Castle, Mark Millar's "Wanted" comics, etc.)...

... and the Bad Guy is bored out of his mind.

How about a Zelazny-style gonzo techo-mythic epic?

A warm, cozy story largely from a kid’s POV where it is clear terrible things they don’t understand are happening around them while assorted Machines Of Loving Grace shuttle them to safety. There is a happy ending.

The subplot of Duke Felix Politkovsky in "Singularity Sky" is definitely not warm and cozy, but otherwise matches what you described

The Bad Guy has already won in the Laundry-verse (I imagine that by Dec 31, 2015, all countries have been taken over by some Elder God).

No sign of them getting bored, of course.

Phanariots and Janissaries.

Janissaries were the slave soldiers of the Ottoman Empire who became too powerful and actually ruled the empire under weak/incompetent Sultans.

Phanariots were a Greek minority in the Ottoman Empire that became prominent in the imperial capital of Constantinople as businessmen and diplomats, and the Greek Orthodox Church and the Ecumenical Patriarch rose to great power under the Sultan's protection and gained religious control over the entire Orthodox population of the empire.

So...

... Earth is conquered by an evil galactic empire that enslaves mankind and forces human to fight their wars and work their vast industrial/energy facilities. Humans eventually become the Phanariots and Janissaries of the galactic empire. Eventually ruling said galactic empire.

Partner with a great illustrator to bring us an authentic childrens' book published under the New Management.

"Specifically NOT "the matter of Britain" unless you want to guy it unmercifully, of course."

With that "unless" clause having the value "true", though, it could be bloody great.

Related subversions that spring to mind then include the Yankee forgetting the effect of calendar changes on the date of the eclipse, so everyone goes "ner ner ner" and entertainment ensues.

Or on a differently-related line, Susan Cooper's "The Dark is Rising" series could do with a rework. Repeated solving of questlets without danger by following to the letter the instructions given in the previous chapter; Merlin incognito as a main character; universe's underlying logic optimised for production of nasal chickens. Resembles the kind of programming language with so many fairy rules that it takes 20k of code in 35 different files to do "a + b". (Java). If you know it, I'm not sure whether you'd see it merely as a powerful emetic or as a collection of things that could be greatly improved with suitable refreaking.

Another one:

Owain Glyndwr: I can call spirits from the vasty deep.
Hotspur: Aye, you can call, but will they answer when you call them?
Spectral voice accompanied by smell of fish: Twll din pob Sais.

Another reason to avoid the cowboys and werewolves: if shapechangers are real, then by implication you'd have to do a fair bit of thinking of how to account for aboriginal beliefs such as the Navajo concept of skinwalkers without slipping into cultural appropriation or clumsy satire. There's interest in the clash of the Western and aboriginal belief systems and what that clash can tell us about ourselves.

How about an inversion of the Laundryverse in which the Lovecraftean creepies are actually the protagonists? Shouldn't be too hard to find human sins (racism, genocide, vulture capitalism) that paint us as the bad guys in the story and motivate the Lovecrafteans to step on us like the nasty bugs we are. My first thought is that playing it absolutely straight would be the best approach; otherwise, it would be too easy to end up with clumsy, heavy-handed social satire. I imagine you'd need a fifth-columnist narrator/protagonist wearing a human skinsuit to account for the minor problem that to write from a truly Lovecraftean perspective, you'd have to be bugfuck crazy.

To pick up on a previous suggestion about Utopia, how about combining that with your interest in economics? For example, a Chinese client has just completed a scholarly work on combining capitalism with communism based on many of the things that have happened in China since the great opening to the West under Deng in 1978. To do his argument a gross injustice by summarizing radically for concision, "capitalism sucks, communism sucks, but if we combine the best aspects of both, maybe we've got something with legs!" (Of course, there's the Churchill anecdote: "but what if you combined the worst aspects of both?") This borders on Cory Doctorow territory, so maybe work with him if you enjoyed the experience when you wrote Rapture of the Nerds?

Is it Henry, the mild-mannered janissary?

You haven’t really written a post apocalypse novel, though you’ve touched on apocalypses either in the distance past or alternate timelines.

Not exactly a trope, but what about the self-help book, or something like a story hidden in a manual?

That's a style, not a trope. Nothing to get my teeth into in this suggestion.

Exchange of letters, either love letters or some historical mystery?

Roman a clef doesn't sell well these days (notable exception: This is how you lose the time war).

cyberpunk (retro-classical), or John-Brunner-like mixtures of story with "found" material?

John was borrowing the collage style of John Dos Passos from such novels as USA. It's really hard to do well (you may however notice chunks of it in Accelerando).

A functioning far future stl generation ship?

Now, generation ship is one novel I haven't done: it's on my very tentative list of possible novels set in the same universe as Ghost Engine/Palimpsest (yes, GE is a variant of the Palimpsest time line in which the timegate is used as a stargate instead).

Having said all that... as we all know, the Nazis got a lot of their idiotology from the US. How about outright racism/slavery?

Slavery is a moral abomination (as much so as royalty, only in the opposite direction on the same scale) and I don't know how to add anything new to the discussion. Endlessly repeating "slavery bad" is a good way to bore readers who either already know this or don't want to know it. And while there are many other forms of slavery than the peculiarly race/caste based North American/Caribbean/Brazilian version (with varying extremes of evil associated), I don't particularly want to write about those, either. Nor do I want to write about racism (hint: human "races" don't really exist, they're social constructs much like Indian castes) although there's an element of it in the background of Ghost Engine.

"Baby Cthulhu"?

Trust me, you do not just get to "write graphic novels". It's an entirely different writing technique (scriptwriting vs. prose fiction) and plugs into an entirely different industry. It's also collaborative (the writer and primary artist are at least working as equals).

Superheroes/supervillains are something I've done repeatedly.

As it happens I had one plan for a novel centered around certain very long-lived people (who gave rise to the original European vampire legend), but it got overrun by events and parted out for other books, notably elements of The Rhesus Chart, Halting State, and Season of Skulls (implicitly). So I'm not going back there now.

Anyway, immortals are boring, fictionally, unless you're going to focus on the historical angle.

What about properly big things made up of galaxies?

If I ever write the other two-thirds of Palimpsest, that scale is definitely going to feature in it. (Spoiler: seems unlikely, there's a lot of work involved in making that book.)

You must be as old as I am to remember that Saturday morning cartoon.

The Bad Guy wins

Tell me you haven't read the later Laundry Files or any of the New Management books without telling me in so many words, why don't you?

Phanariots and Janissaries.

That one seems to be a work in progress by Walter Jon Williams in his Dread Empire series.

Re Brunner - it's not really a collage. Rather, it gives the reader the context of the world the PoV characters are living in and reacting to.

Yes, it's hard to get right... but it works really, really well for SF, and lets you completely avoid infodumps and "As you know, Bob". And I'm speaking from first-hand knowledge - my next novel, Becoming Terran (coming out later this year, hopefully) is exactly in that style. The "clippings" in my case are newsfeed reports.

How about an inversion of the Laundryverse in which the Lovecraftean creepies are actually the protagonists?

That's not an inversion! (By the end of The Labyrinth Index I think it's pretty clear that all the humans in the expedition Mhari led are either dead or no longer human; by the end of the last book in the Laundry Files series arc -- planned, not yet written -- there will be no Version 1.0 human staff left in the Laundry, although lots of them will remember having been human (like Bob).

This borders on Cory Doctorow territory, so maybe work with him if you enjoyed the experience when you wrote Rapture of the Nerds?

Ha Ha Nope! (Nothing wrong with Cory, but we both wrote 75% of that novel and it still hasn't earned out the single-author-novel-sized advance. There are easier ways to starve.)

I tell people I will never have Starships of the Line firing broadsides at each other.

What, you'll never run out the lasers before a space battle? :-)

You may not be the person to do it. But we badly need some fiction about 2123.

There are babies being born now who will see it. Being held by Great Grandmothers born in 1923.

I am not terribly keen on writing about near-futures in which my ongoing metabolic viability would be excluded.

I am also uninterested in writing wish-fulfillment fic dependent on prior genocides or great reset conspiracy theories being true. (Hint: go re-read The Iron Dream by Norman Spinrad and pay attention to how the worldbuilding in the Hitler novel was constructed.)

Administrative note:

My fingers ache from typing(!) and I am quitting this thread until tomorrow.

When I resume I will probably ignore suggestions that I've already answered (or something proximate to them), suggestions that focus on a style ("write me another gonzo 60s Roger Zelazny novel": spoiler, I'm not Roger Zelazny), or stuff I've already done ("write me a time patrol novel!" -- see Palimpsest, for the n'th time).

Nope. (:)

Lasers have issues as weapons in space. For one, spaceships need to shield against radiation. I tend to like hypersonic projectiles, no explosives needed.

Someone mentioned the Alien Space Bats - something involving them, the flying spaghetti monster and other weird silly ideas might be fun. Especially if you can bring royal reptoids into it...

Had the crazy insight the other day that a kid born today that made it to the age of 77 would see the 22nd century.

Re: Glasshouse - "memory shenanigans" are definitely a trope in themself. You did "X is a constructed intelligence with memories from whole cloth" (a la Deepness in the Sky) as a minor point in either Accelerando or Singularity Sky, IIRC, but I'd be interested in a Last-Thursdayist "everything we know about the world is wrong, and also it's much bigger than we thought".

That could well be an "emerge from the simulation into the layer that generated it" book, in which we find out that Our Heroes were being run on some hyperintelligent space penguin's equivalent of a dead badger.

Just read "Survival of the Richest" by Douglass Rushkoff.

How about an apocalyptic novel from the point of those tech billionaires hiding out in their New Zealand bunkers?

PKD reality-slip stuff is far too prone to veering into self-indulgence

Yeah, it's a really tough line to walk. I found it interesting to do once and I really don't ever want to do it again unless I come up with a really great new angle. Or something I want an excuse to really wallow in self-indulgence with.

Pretty much everything I've read from you is an invented-world story, what do you think about kicking back with some interesting corners of history until a Secret (Conspiratorial) History jumps out at you? Arguably there's some of this in the Laundry backstory but making it an explicitly historical piece could take you to the kind of places Tim Powers excels in going. You might also have kind of implicitly dismissed this sort of thing with the part in your post about steampunk, I dunno.

"Man was not meant to meddle"; an obvious one (probably too obvious given recenty history) might be an escaped disease, but we might also have trans-humanism, body modification, cyborg enhancements, what it means to be human.

I have never said that FTL is possible - merely that it does not necessarily imply a breach of causality, and that some aspects of quantum mechanics imply it.

Charlie [85] wrote: "That's not an inversion! (By the end of The Labyrinth Index I think it's pretty clear that all the humans in the expedition Mhari led are either dead or no longer human"

Apologies for the lack of clarity. I didn't mean to suggest you add this to the Laundryverse, but rather write something that stands alone. In the world as it is [sic], would Lovecraftean nasties have a plausible argument for exterminating us?

Charlie: "Ha Ha Nope! (Nothing wrong with Cory, but we both wrote 75% of that novel and it still hasn't earned out the single-author-novel-sized advance. There are easier ways to starve.)"

Fair enough. But the larger idea is interesting if you're willing to do the work to figure out the workings of the economics that would result from creating an unholy lovechild of capitalism and communism.

a Last-Thursdayist "everything we know about the world is wrong, and also it's much bigger than we thought"

That gets you into the Omphalos hypothesis real damn fast, and I don't want to go there.

(NB: Boltzmann Brains are, speculatively, a variant on the Omphalos hypothesis, minus the God bit. Which says something damning about people who believe uncritically in BBs as a literal possibility rather than a footnote in a cosmology textbook.)

How about an apocalyptic novel from the point of those tech billionaires hiding out in their New Zealand bunkers?

a) They're assholes. By definition.

b) That's a Cory Doctorow short story, not a Charlie Stross novel.

The only fantasy that isn't set in an feudal society that immediately comes to mind is the Commonweal series. Given the starting condition of low tech and some level of (non-theistic) magic what sort of society could work that isn't another kings and queens rehash?

"Man was not meant to meddle";

BTDT, frequently.

Nasty thought: co-write one with Paul Krugman?

Hang on! Boltzman brains are definitely a statistical possibility, at least given some interpretations of quantum mechanics or Hawking's black hole hairiness. Rather more implausible than a functioning Maxwell's demon, though :-)

I agree that such things make for extremely uninteresting SF, and worse science.

Not sure: my read on the Commonweal series is that there's a third of a million years of wizards/dark lords doing their thing before a particularly weird one (Laurel) tips the game board over, and the Commonweal is what results -- that the broader culture has been doing a drunkard's walk through the phase space of magical autocracy for so long that it's finally wandered into a weird local minimum where cooperation works and (the rest is plot and world-building).

Trying to top that without actually stealing from Graydon makes my head hurt, and I don't want to steal from Graydon in the first place.

No.

(He's not a fiction author and our priorities are too divergent for it to work.)

Revolt of the plebes in a Muskian planetary colony, or is that too close to a Heinlein pastiche? My favorite of the ideas is the Strossian generation ship.

Too close to Heinlein pastiche and highly unlikely (as Kim Stanley Robinson chillingly depicted in Red Mars, anyone with remote control over the atmosphere plant can kill any rebels stone dead just by raising the pO2 to 30-40% and waiting for a spark).

Heinlein stacked the deck scandalously in The Moon is a Harsh Mistress, by having the colony Big Computer develop intelligence and side with the rebels.

Charlie ...
@ 88 - The "Great Reset" conspiracy is plainly white-wing/Nazi bollocks, & it really surprises me that people are stupid enough to fall for it ..

I am not Roger Zelazny - nor is anyone else, unfortunately - that guy could WRITE!
Lord of Light / Amber / Creatures of Light & Darkness - & many more.
He was plainly driven, as I asked him once at a long-ago Worldcon about his writing & he replied that he had to - a case of the OGLAF-muse if ever I saw one.

@ 99
Alternative version of that { Emphatically NOT "Omphalos" } - JBS Haldane - the Universe is stranger than we can imagine..."

How about an apocalyptic novel from the point of those tech billionaires hiding out in their New Zealand bunkers?

Cory Doctorow did something like that in his novella "The Masque of the Red Death". Highly recommended, not for the optimism but for the schadenfreude.

https://craphound.com/podcast/2020/03/13/the-masque-of-the-red-death/

Free authorized audiobook version here:

https://archive.org/download/Cory_Doctorow_Podcast_332/Cory_Doctorow_Podcast_332_-_The_Masque_of_the_Red_Death.mp3

How about some romantic fantasy? You talk about how you're approaching 60 and you've been married for a long time now. You could channel some of that into "mature" romance in the sense of doing romantic fantasy that is about a more mature relationship than "teenagers in love". Instead of a romance about creating a relationship, you could do one about the strains trying to stay together over the long haul, but using many of the romantic fantasy tropes.

Instead of a romance about creating a relationship, you could do one about the strains trying to stay together over the long haul, but using many of the romantic fantasy tropes.

Tell me you haven't read the Laundry Files without saying (etc).

Just as sword and sorcery stories tend to be about the change over from a barter economy to a money economy, SF stories tend to be about the change over from a money economy to a credit economy. Samuel Delany 1987

Done that already.

How about a far-future story where somebody tries to be "elected" within a very different political system (not using the old-style manipulative or violent means)

Far-future optimistic climate-fiction? That one seems difficult to pull of plausibly. :-)

Yeah. That world is deeply weird as a consequence of the emergence of magic, and Graydon seriously soft-pedalled how weird in the first book. The dry discussion of Creek sex in book 5 really points up these people we've known for 4 books are not human (as does the revelation of Graul sexes, but we already knew that).

I'd suggest a Sci-Fi epic which fights the Great Man of History trope, with a focus on the reality that is the success of cooperation, and people doing "their bit" unrecognised... but "Rogue One" (IMHO one of the best Star Wars movies) has already done it, and the second "Knives Out" has stuck the boot into tech billionaires.

I'd love to see your take on YA fiction, but Cory Doctorow nailed that with his Little Brother series; mature romance, but LMB did wonderful things with "Gentleman Jole and the Red Queen". Pharmaceuticals for fun and profit, but "Breaking Bad".

How about a historical novel - the delights of transferring from the Machine-Gun Corps to the Royal Flying Corps, loosely based on your ancestor?

Pale Rider, the time Clint Eastwood accidentally made a movie with Marxist themes

Accidental?

Yes, he's got issues, but this is the actor who was persuaded to work with Sergio Leone because the first spaghetti western was described to him as "Yojimbo as a Western" (he was a film buff who watched a lot of arthouse cinema).

"The Outlaw Josey Wales" - women, natives, an entire section on how the first peoples were screwed over, and a plot which subverts most westerns of the era.

"Unforgiven" - local law enforcement as brutal and murderous, particularly against black Americans; poverty driving a farmer to crime...

Oh, wonderful. My semi regular reminder that William S. Burroughs was a remittance man living off the income of the Burroughs Adding Machine Company which eventually labored and brought forth the Stack Machine architecture, IMHO a very elegant and probably ultimately doomed design.

Callahan's Bar/Draco Tavern style stories? I've always liked the "aliens/time-travelers/faerie/etc find common ground over beers" vibe.

Large milSF sections in Glasshouse too

Can someone post the link to “A Bird in Hand?” My phone fu isn’t good enough.

Yes, Charlie contributed a SF bar story to Fables from the Fountain, and I think Tor still has it online somewhere. It’s worth hunting down. Hopefully someone links to it.

Fighting the Great Man….

I think Joan Slonczewski did an excellent job of that in A Door Into Ocean,, which is the antithesis of Dune in so many ways.

It would be fun to read a great author like Charlie give the ADIO treatment to some other Great Man story.

I thought Nicola Griffith's 'Hild' was excellently done. But not really sf.

I always thought Banks' Culture had hints of darkness in the corners that could be teased out by a good writer. Much as I'd love to see a Culture ship in orbit, I'd also love to see what a good author could do with the dark side of that worldbuilding. I know I certainly don't have the chops to do it.

It may be more of a Doctorow thing (i.e. Walkaways) but I have had a growing interest in near future sf that explores attempts to thrive in the context of a combined collapse or withdrawal of central authority and ongoing function of some but not all tech. Not apocalyptic wanking but functional 'this might work' stuff. That said it would make for a significant redirection in your writing styles/approaches.

"A heist. Combine it with a Canterbury Tales collection of shorts exploring the backgrounds of the motley crew of esoteric specialties this intricate plan to steal a whole bunch of money requires."

Something like Dan Simmon's Hyperion?

Something hopeful?

Agreed. Something, something, Callahan/Niven set in a bar.

Big Dumb Objects.

I don't have much else, but I'll keep thinking about it.

Re: Navajo ski walkers/ cowboys and werewolves.

I’ve got a strange library that includes entire books on kanaima and skinwalkers, as well as some Chumash lore on bear doctors. Artifacts of the latter two (wolf and bear skins) have never been collected, but the stories make it pretty clear they were modified skins basically puppeted from the inside by the human wearing them so that the skinwalker could walk on all fours, using crutches in the forelegs. The bear doctor skin even had some armor inside it.

So no, true shapeshifting was not required by the original stories.

Anyway, that’s why I proposed an animal suffering from gorgonism as the monster. There’s nothing at first to tell you how dangerous the animal is becoming, very much like a werewolf story.

Spy vs spy, but from the agency head perspective (spy-master vs spy-master), M sending out an endless supply of James Bonds and other operatives on missions, but we only see the end of mission debrief (if they make if back), and never leaving the office themselves (Angleton?). Politics, intelligence, counter-intelligence, fake ops to distract from real ones, fake ops to make other fake ops appear real, all taking place over decades, if not lifetimes. It would read like a George Smiley novel, not a Bond one; Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy would be a single plot line.

I’m thinking maybe…. Young Adult? Mid-future peri apocalyptic? The seed here isn’t a plot, but rather an underlying sentiment: people looking at whatever remains of our era and wonders “what the frack were they thinking?”

Think of it as an apology to our sucessors maybe?

Meanwhile ...
Real, documented, recorded racist prejudice & monstering - DJT's non-election of course.
So this is what we are up against.
And, going back to the original subject ( yes, I know ) "Mil-SF" & yet, 18 months ago, a general war broke out in Europe.
There are obvious very-near-future SFnal parts of this story - any others, any advances, in the literary sense?

Martin
Has anyone heard from LMB recently?
I do hope she isn't a covid-victim ( "long Covid" )

Sports? Are there any tropes involving sports? Or is this just a subtype of bildungsroman? It'd be a view into an alien mind, for the typical SF reader...well, for me. What are the cultural assumptions underlying sports, anyway?

Space station cottagecore?

Mining the asteroids for fun and profit? (that '60s optimism...)

How about an apocalyptic novel from the point of those tech billionaires hiding out in their New Zealand bunkers?

More interestingly: Some people want to do something useful with currently unused land, but there's a bunker full of asshole billionaires under it. Complications include: they'd probably resist being pulled out by Ordinary Folk; if they get out they'd try to reclaim stupid amounts of ownership and/or control, disrupting the current status quo; some people object to the idea of just paving over the bunkers (Oops, they're trapped forever. So sad. Oh, well. Fancy a beer later?).

How about an office drama among under-employed twentysomethings who are producing post-apocalypse "news" content that will keep billionaires in their underground bunkers while the rest of the world marches on without them?

Charlie, do you have any post-apocalyptic survival? It's en evergreen genre - Dies The Fire, Fallout, I Am Legend, Walking Dead, Last of Us... you don't have to put zombies in (mutants are required, however).

Also, alternate history! I know it's not in vogue (not counting the terrifying fascist-revanchist abomination which is the Russian-language popadanets genre), but maybe you could bring it back!

I have thought of several more, but of the sort you would not touch (nor would I want to read). However, you haven't done several of the tropes that were very common over a century back, but have gone out of fashion, and which might be plausible. They all have classic stories, both children and other.

Exploration in terra incognita, sometimes involving discovering things you did not want to find.

Treasure hunting. There are lots of variations of this.

Castaway stories. Again, with lots of variations.

"What about properly big things made up of galaxies?"

If you are going near Stapledon territory, you could consider something along the lines of Sirius and really piss off the evangelical right. Probably not good marketing though.

How about a far-future story where somebody tries

I think you've fundamentally misunderstood the meaning of "genre trope" that I'm looking into here.

No.

Time traveller/space traveller bar stories range between wall-to-wall twee sentimentality and grotesque self-indulgence.

I do not do twee, and I try to keep my solitary vices to myself.

(A Bird in Hand was specifically commissioned as a homage to a particular Arthur C. Clarke series that allowed him to indulge his vice of terrible science-based puns. So, an edge case.)

I always thought Banks' Culture had hints of darkness in the corners that could be teased out by a good writer.

Whaa—

Are you kidding me?!?

Go and re-read "Use of Weapons" then get back to me about the Chairmaker (and consider the implications of Special Circumstances being happy to employ Zakalwe ...)

Charlie, do you have any post-apocalyptic survival?

No, and I'm not interested in writing it (or reading it).

Also, alternate history!

You missed the entire million word long, nine book, Merchant Princes/Empire Games saga.

There's a chunk of exploring new worlds embedded in the Merchant Princes series. (Quite a lot, in fact. Paratime traveling zeppelins! Protocol for opening up a new time line when you're not sure the atmosphere is breathable! Five dimensional paratime fortresses and the vexing question of who the defenders were defending themselves against!)

really piss off the evangelical right. Probably not good marketing though

"Really piss off the evangelical right" is actually on my bucket list (hopefully Ghost Engine will help, but it's probably not pointed enough to get their attention).

Hot Earth Dreams - yes, well ....

Charlie @ 135
Plus by the same author: "Look to Windward", or even/particularly "Surface Detail" ...

Indeed, but it's not really the trope I was trying to describe. I am not sure that it's your scene, anyway.

I look forward to your step beyond werewolf porn into interspecies dalliance - I am also reminded of Memoires of a Spacewoman :-)

I wonder whether you've made a go of the straight storytelling thing, not necessarily with no genre (after all the argument goes that literary fiction is just another genre), but without the trappings of a genre. So recognisably contemporary humans engaged in recognisably contemporary human things. Maybe there's a dramatic disconcerting event that drives the story, but it notably doesn't involve eldritch horrors, aliens or elves. And rather than 10 minutes in the future, the setting looks a lot more like now.

TBF I think Halting State and Rule 34 are close to this... if only because they were 10 minutes in the future but that 10 minutes happened a few years ago now.

I guess I've half an eye on the Iain Banks without the M material. The early stuff overlapped strongly with horror or crime or something, but roll forward to something like The Steep Approach to Garbadale, and I'm not sure you can say that has a genre. I've no idea what sort of thing, if anything at all, in that sort of space would appeal to you to write. No idea what the market is either, except I'd buy it.

Callahan's Bar/Draco Tavern style stories? I've always liked the "aliens/time-travelers/faerie/etc find common ground over beers" vibe.

He's written a pub story. Check out Fables from the Fountain, a lovely homage to Arthur C Clarke's Tales from the White Hart.

http://www.newconpress.co.uk/info/book.asp?id=50&referer=Catalogue

Bar stories are a good medium for shaggy dog stories and throw-away ideas, but far too many are poor imitations of short stories. I may buy that book - it is a pity that the Jorkens collections are so expensive.

I vaguely remember reading on here once about a conjecture that the true golden age of the universe happened a few attomoments after inflation when entropy was really low, and that everything after was basically just the ashes of this.

I wonder about a post-apocalyptic story except where everything we've ever known is the epilogue. The true horror of the godlike beings beyond is not just that our existence is mostly irrelevant to their games, it's that their games are already long over and the only ones of them that are still around are at best waxing nostalgic for the time when the real party was happening.

Are these sorts of tropes Baxter territory?

A couple of Baxters Xeelee stories "The Quagma Datum" and "The We Who Sing" have that sort of premise.

Ofc in that universe the real "gods" are very much still around and wondering why the silly apes are wasting energy time attacking them all the time.

Something that lacked the "Humans are all worthless wretches" angle could cover the same ground while feeling very different. We really are rubbish in his stories.

I know it's not 300 comments yet, but...

We interrupt this thread to bring you news that Yellowknife (pop.22,000, located lat. 62.4540° N), capital of Canada's NW Territories has ordered a complete evacuation of all of its inhabitants in the face of advancing wildfires.

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/north/nwt-wildfire-emergency-update-august-16-1.6938756

The capital city of a Canadian province is being completely evacuated.

A city located in what was normally considered to be in an arctic region.

So much for fleeing to Canada when the lower latitudes get too hot.

Heteromeles [124] noted: "So no, true shapeshifting was not required by the original stories."

My point was that if you're using classic/traditional werewolves, shape-shifting is the sine qua non. You then have options: choose shape-shifting for skinwalkers (thereby doing lazy appropriation of actual aboriginal lore based on your longer description), or figure out a way to play the two tropes (western and aboriginal) against each other to see what the juxtaposition reveals.

I don't see "Sleeping King / King Asleep in Mountain" on the list, to date.

Although the identity and nature of the Sleeper in the Pyramid still remains to be seen.

I vaguely remember reading on here once about a conjecture that the true golden age of the universe happened a few attomoments after inflation when entropy was really low, and that everything after was basically just the ashes of this. I wonder about a post-apocalyptic story except where everything we've ever known is the epilogue.

Hell, I wrote that. Approximately, anyway; my story's gimmick was the main character bringing in memories of other lives, from other universes, and one of them was from a witness to the end of the Planck epoch. To them it was literally the end of the known universe, as parts of now faded away into an unreachable then and parts of here drifted away into distant there. The universe was shrinking, and it was being witnessed by everyone who had ever been.

A better writer might be able to do something more with the idea, but I can't even get a general idea of what it would look like as a piece of fiction.

How about something set in the 'Cloud Atlas" universe or something like it?

One of my favorite movies (though many consider it to be an acquired taste).

Premise: Transmigration of souls is a real ting with each of us being reincarnated. However we are tied to another soul who is literally a "soul mate" through eternity. And you always destined to find your other. Its gender fluid, switching male and female with some iterations, sometimes gay, different races and ethnicities, and in the far future one of the souls will be an android.

If you don't like literal soul migration try brain download into a fetus before the moment of death. The download is so perfect nobody can tell (or care) if the process is "cut and paste" or "copy and paste". One problem, there is already a developing mind in the fetus. Does it get snuffed by the new download, does it merge somehow, does it develop multiple personality disorders?

Saw an ABBA tribute band in concert recently.

Yes, I'm a grown man who is not afraid to say that he likes ABBA.

In fact, my kids love ABBA. Indeed, they love all of my Boomer music from the 50s to the 80s.

How about something like Station 11 (HBO miniseries and novel by Patrick Somerville), but with tribute bands and Elvis impersonators?.

A plague wipes out the remaining Boomers (an engineered virus like Herbert's "White Plague" which only killed females - government created it to get out of paying social security and pension to the massive Boomer demographic bulge and thus saving the economy from going bust) resulting in both some rejoicing and sad nostalgia.

Possible potential for comedy and critique of Boomer culture which will looks like it will continue to dominate long after we are gone.

Apparently, Evangelicals now worship Trump instead of Jesus.

https://www.newsweek.com/evangelicals-rejecting-jesus-teachings-liberal-talking-points-pastor-1818706

"Multiple pastors tell me, essentially, the same story about quoting the Sermon on the Mount, parenthetically, in their preaching—'turn the other cheek'—[and] to have someone come up after to say, 'Where did you get those liberal talking points?'" Moore said. "When the pastor would say, 'I'm literally quoting Jesus Christ' ... The response would be, 'Yes, but that doesn't work anymore. That's weak," he added.

So how about a future history of the First Church of Donald Trump, created by tele-evangelists after Trump is martyred (choking on a beany weany while eating in the prison mess hall). They have their own bible, rituals involving orange face make up, and a white nationalist creed. They have a special hatred of gays blaming them for the coming horrors of global warming (like those preachers who blamed Hurricane Katrina as God's just punishment on NOLA because of its tolerance of gays). The religion spreads not just in rural Red State America but overseas in right wing white nationalist countries like Hungary and Putin's Russia.

Look at how it evolves after its firmly established going from cult to mainline religion.

You could abandon the "mundane" SF thing long-enough to write something in a classic space-opera universe, complete with FTL, energy shields, sooper-dooper science, etc., including a Captain and /his/her/it's mighty ship! If you ever wanted to give certain tropes a mighty thwacking, this is how you do it!

Also, a Robin Hood type thing, in any genre, ending with the brutal death of the last billionaire.

Zakalwe being the Chairmaker was the big reveal in the final act however, and the Culture agents were surprised as well.

Obviously there was plenty of darkness around the edges, that's not really what I meant. I haven't had enough coffee this morning to really explain further just yet.

DP
The demented arsholes have been doing that since 2016 at least ... it's not going to get any better.
Mirrors the "Kremlin & Orthodox-Church know best" mentality of many Russians, I'm afraid, or the rabider Brexshiteers ...
It's called the Reality Gap

Though it's not new, there was a C19th iteration, carrying on - particularly on "sports" fields *SHUDDER called: - until at least 1970-ish, called Muscular Christainity

Technical correction: Northwest Territories is not a Canadian province, it is a Territory (variations in legal powers and responsibilities). It is also immense and consists mostly of boreal forest and tundra.

The evacuation of the entire city is definitely noteworthy. I hope everyone gets out alright, and even more I hope that the fire is controlled before it reaches the settlement. An old friend of mine is an ER doctor in Yellowknife, and knowing him he'll be among the last to evacuate (out of a sense of responsibility).

I'm an American.

You can't expect me to know anything about Canada. ;-)

I always thought Banks' Culture had hints of darkness in the corners that could be teased out by a good writer. Much as I'd love to see a Culture ship in orbit, I'd also love to see what a good author could do with the dark side of that worldbuilding. I know I certainly don't have the chops to do it.

I tried some time ago to re-read the Culture books. I managed to get through 'The Use of Weapons', but anything else has been just too dark and sad, except I did recently finish 'Inversions' and now I'm reading 'Surface Detail'.

So, yeah, there is darkness even in those, especially the weapon book, but some are more positive than others.

Um, er, there's millions of words on that against the Great Man theory of history: the late Eric Flint's 1632-verse.

"Not in vogue"? See my previous post. (ObDisclosure: my first published stories were in the Grantville Gazette, and I've just started a new one, following the character introduced in the last two....)

That's on your bucket list? Are you aware of https://www.cityweekly.net/utah/even-jesus-is-too-woke-for-the-maga-right/Content?oid=20336976

I'm not sure where he could go with those. In my first novel, 11,000 Years, you very, very indirectly come to know of a group of beings that survived at least one collapse/restart of the universe. I have no conceivable idea of what they're like, and strongly suggest that words like "boredom" are not merely irrelevant, but anything that's lasted that long has long gone past that concept.

Heteromeles @ 124:

Re: Navajo ski walkers

Hmmm? That might be interesting. 🙃

JPetherick @ 148:

I don't see "Sleeping King / King Asleep in Mountain" on the list, to date.

Although the identity and nature of the Sleeper in the Pyramid still remains to be seen.

Yeah, I know OGH is ready to move on from the Laundry Files, but I'd still be interested to know who "he" is and how he ended up sleeping there? Maybe a short story about origins?

Just got back from being one of that throng of tourists. Edinburgh was utterly delightful; the Fringe was appropriately fringe-y. And yes, 6 of the 8 of us picked up Covid.

But if you have the chance to go and have not yet done so, do: a delight (and both the hiking and the food were great also).

DP @ 151:

Saw an ABBA tribute band in concert recently.

Yes, I'm a grown man who is not afraid to say that he likes ABBA.

In fact, my kids love ABBA. Indeed, they love all of my Boomer music from the 50s to the 80s.

I like ABBA. I like a wide range of music from the 30s to the current day. Before the 30s there wasn't much fidelity in recordings, so I don't have any of that early music (converted to Mp3) to listen to. I do have much later versions of some early popular music (aka "Folk Music").

My playlists lean heavily on Rock 'n Roll from the period 1955 to 1985 or so, but there's A LOT of good music that came before and there's a lot of good music being made today and it's more accessible than ever. And there's a lot of good music in genres other than Rock 'n Roll.

I don't get out much for live music anymore. I hope I will again - both to attend concerts/shows and to make music with my friends - but Covid sure did fuck up a whole lot of shit ...

How about something like Station 11 (HBO miniseries and novel by Patrick Somerville), but with tribute bands and Elvis impersonators?.

A plague wipes out the remaining Boomers (an engineered virus like Herbert's "White Plague" which only killed females - government created it to get out of paying social security and pension to the massive Boomer demographic bulge and thus saving the economy from going bust) resulting in both some rejoicing and sad nostalgia.

That's what I love about this list, learning "new" things. I was aware Herbert had written that book, but I've never read it.

However, looking at the synopsis on Wikipedia, I realized it might be the reference for the computer game I like to play - ArmA3 Ravage mod. (The game DayZ is a spin off from an ArmA2 mod and Ravage is an ArmA3 iteration of similar theme).

In Ravage, the "white plague" (a "possibly" bio-engineered variant of the Cordyceps fungus) has killed 91% of the human population - killing the women outright and turning the men into zombies à la "The Walking Dead". You play as one of the survivors, who may or may not be immune to the "virus", so you gotta' be careful not to get infected.

Other modders have created a number of scenarios - some quite elaborate - using the Ravage mod. So, a fun way to kill time (and zombies) ...

Possible potential for comedy and critique of Boomer culture which will looks like it will continue to dominate long after we are gone.

Only fair since Boomer culture is an amalgamation of the preceding generations' culture + tech. I'm sure someday Gen-X, Gen-Z & Millennials (plus the kids being born today) will develop cultures of their own. I hope they will find something worth keeping from ours.

And that's as it should be (my not so humble opinion).

Greg Tingey @ 155:

DP
The demented arsholes have been doing that since 2016 at least ... it's not going to get any better.
Mirrors the "Kremlin & Orthodox-Church know best" mentality of many Russians, I'm afraid, or the rabider Brexshiteers ...
It's called the Reality Gap

Though it's not new, there was a C19th iteration, carrying on - particularly on "sports" fields *SHUDDER called: - until at least 1970-ish, called Muscular Christainity

Doesn't seem like that had the revanchist component of "owning the libs" though.

I wonder whether you've made a go of the straight storytelling thing ... without the trappings of a genre.

You're asking me to write mainstream/litfic.

Unfortunately I can't get paid to do that, because reasons (which boil down to business considerations of no interest to you).

And yes, 6 of the 8 of us picked up Covid.

Yeah, this is why I am doing zero fringe events this year and mostly avoiding pubs, too, and when I went shopping today I masked up on the tram (unlike about 95% of the folks also using it).

I do not need to get that virus again, especially as damage is cumulative and the UK government doesn't want to hand out vaccination booster shots any more (ack, spit -- although there's some hope of them at least allowing us to buy them next year).

Hmmm... will Feorag (sp?) still be doing a pub crawl next year Wed before Worldcon?

Glasshouse deals with war crimes, singularity, body modification, annoy the TERFs, murder investigation, space prison, oppressive milieu, and self-discovery. Also a John Varley "Eight Worlds" tribute novel, in which respect I think it is probably unique.

Taking us off topic, but I’d love a blog article expanding on this. It’s the one of your novels I’m still confused about what happened in the last quarter, and the one I find myself thinking about at random moments.

Personal theory remains that it was entirely a parody of The Sims and deeper analysis misses the point not supported by your subsequent blog comments to my deep sadness…

It occurs to me that the Merchant Princes multiverse can be used for paratime operas of any sort. Jaunt, rather than going interstellar.

You can do a Kaiju story with titanisaurs, have murder mysteries set at cross time conventions…. Tales of the paratime precursors… whatever.

I will only half-seriously suggest a Dragonball-style continually escalating shonen power fantasy, complete with multiple tournament arcs.

If Ghost Engine is the busted-singularity novel, I'm really looking forward to it. Just what we need in these days of "Open"AI and their ilk. Here's hoping a US publication contract is on the table sooner rather than later.

Some way above i saw “MilSF” and misread it as “MilfSF”; but I think one could argue that Heinlein covered that some time ago. Weber is kinda doing so as well since Honor has definitely become a character describable as older, desirable, and active.

I too like ABBA; did when they were first performing. In fact I took two girlfriends to see the ABBA movie. It was economically sensible since they were sisters so we all went together and I saved a ticket.

Writing advice... can’t really offer much there as it’s not my bailiwick. I will say that I’ve been really enjoying quite a lot of stories that emphatically do not feature people like me. I’ve always considered that the real value of SF is getting to inhabit someone not-me and learn. Female authors are providing a lot my reading in this quest. “The girl in red”, for example, or “The end of Men”.

Much as I like the trope of the hippy dropping out and encouraging others to leave their livelihoods and families to follow him around the country preaching love and good times for everyone, I think it's been done to death. At least Muhammed had the guts to step out of line and say "blessed are the bureaucrats, for without them we do not eat". Actually, run with that trope... vaguely like the Laundryverse, but the opposition is chill dudes who just want to live their lives, man. Channel a bit of Matt Johnson as your authorial soundtrack.

And surely you could mix in the trope of a group of friends working mediocre jobs in an office somewhere that everything costs far more than their jobs could possibly pay. Yes, it's all fun and exciting and isn't it interesting that a waitress can afford her own apartment in the middle of London? Per the Big Bang Theory fan idea, have her be a secret policeman there to monitor the activities of everyone else. And for a real boot to the eye of the people trying to sell your book, have her get pregnant to one of the other idiots and decide to raise the baby. Is "secret policeman gets activist pregnant" a trope or just a nightmare?

Re: Navajo skinwalkers.

If you want fiction about them, they showed up in at least three of Tony Hillerman.s mysteries.

If you want to read about people who mix psychopathic violence with shamanism, read Whitehead.s Dark Shamans, because he actually interviewed some practitioners. The problem with Navajo wolves is that there’s no proof they actually exist.

It's a tough one - Tchaikovsky is knocking off the weird tropes pretty frequently as well. Big Dumb Object is the most obvious, I liked his more recent one that riffed off Beowulf.

Was going to say Outside Context Problem, but destroying Leeds nicely covered that.

Biopunk, or other organic/inorganic development, possibly combined with adapting to a bad climate future. Maybe your take on the whole Last and First Men evolution developing over deep time, rather than just starting at the far end.

Possibly a Culture inversion, with overly paternalistic interfering aliens, the equivalent perhaps of William Tenn's The Liberation of Earth only with beauracracy instead of military.

John S
Mucular Christianity was particularly apparent on the spurts field & "owned" the libs by persistent bullying & petty torture of anyone showing the slightest interest in literature or the fine arts or anything "sensitive" - was rolled-up with hatred of the "queers" of course, though that was an excuse to cover for the ongoing power-play(s) Petty fascism in fact.

Charlie @ 169
SOME London/City firms are being politely asked by some of their older-but-not-yet-65 employees if they can contribute to the ridiculois costs of paying for a vaccination.
We'll see how that plays out. - Contra to the tories ongoing drive to wreck/privatise the NHS of course.
See also: Vote tory for SHIT in the rivers

Mayhem
John Brunner did that one....

Probably: the Glasgow worldcon pub crawl is already being planned!

Yes, it's all fun and exciting and isn't it interesting that a waitress can afford her own apartment in the middle of London? Per the Big Bang Theory fan idea, have her be a secret policeman there to monitor the activities of everyone else.

I wrote a little thing where one of the characters had a government job somewhere in London, sitting at a desk pushing papers around and answering the phone, for some kind of nebulous "Intelligence Taskforce." I might have gotten away with it except that among the readers were at least two who actually wrote for Doctor Who spinoff media...

I am not a fan of Tchaikovsky. Tropes are merely a starting point, and what is built around them and the writing are both more important. Also, just adding tropes grates - they have to be properly integrated.

Personal theory remains that it was entirely a parody of The Sims

No, it started out with "what-if we take folks from a transhuman society who are post-gender and indeed post-death and post-standardized-body-plan and dump them into a version of the Stanford Prison Study where they're allocated to arbitrary genders and forced to abide by arbitrary behavioural norms?" ... all in the space of one beer with a pal on a rainy Tuesday afternoon.

Then it acquired another question: in a post-death setting, what do you do with immortal soldiers when the war is over?

Yers, and there may be another novel in that setting ... but not any time soon.

A lot of British spyfic and movies from the 1970s involve paper-shuffling and answering telephones rather than dangling from a rope over a web of laser beams to get at Ze Sekret Documents. Even TV shows like Callan had twenty minutes of bureaucratic meetings in an office and five minutes of action in each episode.Much of that might have been to save money in production though.

Postapocalyptic? Especially if the apocalypse is the kind I talked about a decade ago with Vernor Vinge: a civilization-wide catastrophe distinctive to a high-energy society. (But not nuclear war, please; too much of that has been done.)

The classic superman story is extinct, and rightly so, since the old "hopeful monsters" version of evolution has been abandoned. But perhaps genetic engineering could be used for something comparable.

Philosophers like the Churchlands have speculated about new understandings of the self growing out of more accurate models of cognition than the Cartesian res cogitans. What if cognitive science gives us innovations in self-awareness?

It happened a couple times in the real world, I think, in England. Also a book by Paul Theroux covers some of the same territory.

DP @ 152: So how about a future history of the First Church of Donald Trump

Heinlein did pretty much that in Revolt in 2100. Not to say that it can't be done again, better and longer of course.

I think one could argue that Heinlein covered that some time ago

thought he angled more towards youth for his protagonists' love interests

i remember when i was 16 the line "an explosive bullet hit between her lovely, little-girl breasts" from the moon is a harsh mistress struck me as excitingly transgressive

less so in hindsight tho

I wonder if something could be done with the noir hard-boiled private detective set in the future. Obviously you'd want to avoid a vanilla cyberpunk setting, but maybe the theocratic takeover of America has enabled an eastern hemisphere dominated by a Chinese hegemony in a world suffering from serious climate problems. Our protagonist is hired to track down a missing young woman. Who turns out to have been under pressure from someone in Vietnam, and who has some odd connections to the power system in Arizona that failed last year, letting several thousand Americans cook when their air conditioning went down. Not that you'd see that on the news channels or social media.

Is "secret policeman gets activist pregnant" a trope or just a nightmare?

That's actually reality -- it happened repeatedly in the 80s and 90s, hence the "spy cops" scandal.

If you want to turn the trope inside out, run it as "activist gets secret policewoman pregnant", then, on discovering his spouse's other life, gets totally conflicted between outing her for the good of the cause and/or blowing up his personal life (and never seeing his kid again).

But that's a gritty mainstream novel.

I may buy that book - it is a pity that the Jorkens collections are so expensive.

I got the ebook. No space on my bookshelves, and I can make it large type for when my eyes are tired. It was cheaper than a physical copy, especially when including shipping.

If expense is an issue, maybe persuade your local library to get it? That's been my tactic for a while.

A lot of British spyfic and movies from the 1970s involve paper-shuffling and answering telephones rather than dangling from a rope over a web of laser beams to get at Ze Sekret Documents.

Some day I'd love to see a spy-fi with an extended rant on the impossibility of doing the dangling-from-the-ceiling-tiles scene inside a portable SCIF (a TEMPEST-shielded shipping container with armed guards and metal detectors on the door).

The whole Mission: Impossible stunt thing is like depicting a jailbreak from a new-build Supermax prison as being similar to one from a late 19th century town jailhouse in the Old West.

I wonder if something could be done with the noir hard-boiled private detective set in the future.

Robert Sawyer's Red Planet Blues springs to mind. Very deliberately written as a homage to hard-boiled detectives, but also looks at the effects of technology on both crime and detection.

https://www.sfwriter.com/exrp.htm

in no particular order...

frustrations of a faltering interstellar alliance (the last days of the UFP from Star Trek and/or the failure of any of a dozen pan-galactic civilizations including Poul Anderson's Terran Empire)

temporal cold war rewriting the timeline (yes, that's a hijacking of ST:ENT story arc but still a concept with a lot on the bone to chew upon) including an attempt to prevent various genocides in C20 & C21, a struggle between fascist wannabes and the survivors of those genocides to decide whether the future is ethnically streamlined or multi-cultural or rolled back to the bad old days of 1830s slavery-imperialism-peasantry

Trump & Putin & Johnson as the clueless meatpuppets of an alien race seeking to xenoform Earth by way of deliberately abusive climate change (updated version of infamously awful 1960s series "Invaders") with humanity having covert support of a pan-galactic version of Green Peace sending the eqv of a handful of well-intended naive college interns to uplift the semi-savage hairless apes

set in 2091, struggles over unionizing of miners in deep space and control over asteroid mining... much mention of cyborgs and zero gee sex

behind the scenes of cable teevee foodie show set in 2047... haute cuisine version of 1970s Soylent Green... alternate food sourcing...

So far as story transferring goes, I still think moving the story of the Ikko-ikki rebellion from medieval Japan to the modern US or UK would work. Of course, reframing the Tai Ping rebellion in the US, with the main rebel being like Trump, would be better, but given global politics, I think the latter is probably a bad idea.

Probably too much work for Charlie, though

The classic superman story is extinct, and rightly so, since the old "hopeful monsters" version of evolution has been abandoned. But perhaps genetic engineering could be used for something comparable.

Can you elaborate on this? Because I have no idea what you are talking about.

Assume you may know this already, and it may not be net-worth-it depending on your risk calculus, but the US by policy explicitly does not limit access to COVID vaccines by citizenship, so if business does bring you stateside anyways at some point, you would be able to get vaccinated here.

Probably too much work for Charlie, though

Sounds like something Harry Turtledove might do. He's already done Stalin-in-America (Joe Steel) and Europe-as-a-fundamentalist-backwater (Through Darkest Europe). Not to mention the whole alternate-world-wars multi-series saga that put his daughters through university…

Can you elaborate on this? Because I have no idea what you are talking about.

Which part is unclear to you? The bit about hopeful monsters? The bit about genetic engineering?

For hopeful monsters, I'm referring to an idea of an early evolutionary biologist, Goldschmidt, who thought that evolution took place through macromutations that produced a radically different organism, all at once. The idea is sometimes mocked as the "let's found a new species, dear" theory. I'm pretty sure you can find a discussion of it somewhere in Stephen Jay Gould; it's sort of a spiritual precursor of his punctuated equilibrium idea, though punctuated equilibrium still takes multiple generations for species change. A lot of science fiction and comic books about superhumans seem to like the idea that they appear all at once through a single big mutation, but it really has serious problems as biology.

I'm not sure what to say about genetic engineering.

In terms of tropes, have you done anything with theme parks, circuses, or carnivals? I'm thinking anything from works like Dream Park (technologically enhanced LARPing) to the travelling show staffed by cryptids and any number of other genre permutations of these venues.

Or how about reality TV shows? There have been several successful superhero / reality TV combinations, but I'm not aware of any magical realism or urban fantasy variants.

In terms of tropes, have you done anything with theme parks, circuses, or carnivals?

No, and I'm not going to (those things hold zero personal appeal for me).

As for reality TV shows ... blech. (Although the New Management has plenty of scope for such ...)

Which part is unclear to you? The bit about hopeful monsters? The bit about genetic engineering?

The bit about hopeful monsters -- I had never seen this expression before. Thank you for the answer.

I suspected that once you explain what "hopeful monsters" are, the genetic engineering bit would become obvious, and it did.

There are six short books. They seem to be sold at a reasonable price now but, when I first looked, they were of the order of 40 pounds each.

What? You're not going to outdo the Hunger Games?

No, I haven't seen it, won't do so, and wouldn't buy such a book even by you. It would be just TOO depressing.

The Hunger Games was originally a pretty decent young adult novel. Then it turned out to be a runaway bestseller so her publishers chained her to a hot word processor to the tune of two bestselling (but not terribly good) sequels, and then Hollywood took over. The first book set a new benchmark for millennial/gen-Z dystopian fiction, if you can cope with a lachrymose/romantic happy ending bolted onto it (because apparently Kids Today can't cope with an ending even as grotesquely unpleasant as Narnia).

It is in turn a watered-down version of the Battle Royale trope (exploding collar bombs! Teenage headsplodey porn! Nobody escapes alive!) which I can live without, although it's pretty popular in movie terms (the entire Suicide Squad franchise seems to be an attempt to mix Battle Royale into the DC Supervillain universe).

If you want to see it done properly, re-watch The Dirty Dozen. (But don't expect me to rewrite it.)

In terms of tropes, have you done anything with theme parks, circuses, or carnivals? No, and I'm not going to (those things hold zero personal appeal for me).

And "Escape from Yokai Land" doesn't tick the "theme park" box?

I want you to know that I only went there under protest (it was my wife's birthday). And the core conceit of the novella was hers: "what if the Colour out of Space was Hello Kitty pink?"

I read the Hunger Games because my kids were enjoying them and I wanted something to talk about. By the time I got to the final book I was tired of waiting for the main character to have to actually make a difficult decision. At no point did she have to actually make one of the dozens of horrible choices she wrestled with through the entire series. The plot always, invariably, resolved the problem for her.

At the time I wrote it off to the demands of YA for a wide audience, but there exist plenty of excellent YA novels with more realism and more character development.

And you don’t think of yokai as Laundryverse shapeshifters? SMH…

Yes, I read and enjoyed that story. I’m just throwing elbows towards anyone who thinks that Larry Talbot Shall Be Ye Archetypal Werewolf, and Everyone Else’s Shapeshiters Shall Be Appropriated For This Trope.

Pfui, as one Nero Wolfe used to say. As we both know, it’s entirely possible for an artist to respectfully use some other culture’s creation while shaping it to one’s own universe.

lachrymose/romantic happy ending bolted onto it

I read "Hunger Games" when it first came out and never read it again, so I may be misremembering, but my recollection is that throughout the book Katniss Everdeen keeps missing Peeta's romantic overtures which are so obvious, it makes her look just stupid (or maybe completely asexual). And after Games are over, President Snow basically orders them to get married. None of which sounds exactly romantic or happy-ending. Well, maybe happy-ending for Peeta.

One of the standard tropes of SF is "science is easy"; individuals can make epochal discoveries, initial discovery to mass production is a matter of months, full comprehension of the consequences arrives with the discovery, all of the heady mix of early SF authors not fully comprehending aviation and quantum devices as those things went up the steep leg of the logistics curve and then massively overgeneralizing.

There's probably a novel in "what is actually wrong with our habitat's life support?" (it's tenths of percents right now, but the voyage (or the mortgage) has some time to run, and the implications are stark) via actual doing of science.

Not the easiest thing to write in the present cultural circumstances, admittedly.

The related trope is the correct iconoclast; their individual brilliance allows them to have a better understanding and be more effective than everyone conventional around them. The trick with this one would be writing it from the viewpoint of the iconoclast, making them sympathetic, and sufficiently subtly wrong that they stay sympathetic. Which seems like hard mode in tap shoes.

Charlie Stross in 205:

"chained her to a hot word processor"... OH! YOU BRUTES! forcing her to carry those heavy, heavy sacks of silver 'n gold to the bank upon her weary, weary back... definitely was her personal version of 'Peter Rabbit and brier patch'

hmmm... updated 'Peter Rabbit and brier patch'... tweaked critters trapped to endlessly cycle their scripted lines in a real flesh version of kiddie safe playgrounds scattered in multiple locales due to brutal corporate struggles over vacation bookings... why travel to Disneyworld (5000 km) if a scaled down version can be achieved with a customized playground in every high value neighborhood? 1000+ worldwide given there's enough rich families within 10 km with jaded parents and mass market intellectual property loving offspring... robotic-animal-cyborgs running off scripts deployed from corporate HQ via AGI-chatGPT-tailoring to regional languages and political bias of parents... this week it's Ninja Turtles™, next week it's My Little Pony™ and every Christmas™-Halloween™-local-festival-day™ it's whatever characters and songs and dialog causes children to drag their parents along to pay the admission...

yeah... that's a horror novel just waiting to gnaw at our eyeballs

Katniss Everdeen keeps missing Peeta's romantic overtures which are so obvious

That bit struck me as quite realistic. Kids grow that way inclined at different speeds and often unrelated to what their body is doing. Just because some seven year olds can get pregnant doesn't mean that all seven year olds are ready to get married and settle down.

Likewise an authoritarian in an authoritarian society saying "you two get married" ... history is full of that to the point where "marry for love" is something of a modern trope.

a novel in "what is actually wrong with our habitat's life support?"

One of the reasonably name authors has a generation ship written largely from a kid PoV where that's the big question. The stressed out parent is the chief trouble-shooter in a world/ship where balancing the ecology is multiple people's full time jobs. "you will eat more saly food, we have too much salt" being one minor issue mentioned.

(names? what do you mean "names"? I barely remember my own, you can't expect me to remember the name of someone whose book I read)

Kim Stanley Robinson, perhaps?

Anyway, there’s a deep issue here about what science fiction is.

If it’s fiction with science tropes, then “make science realistic” makes sense. If it’s fiction for scientists,, then why not give them some entertainment? I mean, science generally fails. Want to read about that? Or you want to giggle at unrealistic wish fulfillment.

While I agree that scientists aren’t often good writers, it’s worth pointing out that humanities types can badly miss things through their own educational lacunae.. This is where we get science fiction tropes getting codified and then taking on greater importance than the original science.

Charlie, given your background, one myths you can legitimately appropriate is Judaism. Here’s another idea to ignore:

The setting has a reasonably large Jewish population. Perhaps a fictional neighborhood in a UK city?

The Ark of the Covenant hides itself in the neighborhood. Perhaps it’s above a deli, so the smoke from sacrifices goes unnoticed? Whatever.

Reality becomes increasing mystical, Temple era Jewish the more active the Ark is and the closer you are to it. Golems work. Angels manifest and say “Please stop screaming, I just have a message for you.” Giants and unicorns slouch in the alleys. That sort of thing. And most people are, of course, Unobservant and therefore do not notice. But some people are Observant, and take advantage of the situation. The conflict between modern reality and the Ark can get interesting.

Anyway, want a plot? The Ark declares a Jubilee year, and reality plotzes all around it. And, I am telling you, it is a trying time.

Want bad guys? Throw in a bunch of vegan Dominionists, just to make YHWH plotz too.

Oy.

Moz
Why do you think that in a very high proportion of the arranged dynastic marriages in the Middle Ages, either or both partners also had lovers &/or mistresses?
We usually only hear of the men having affairs, but closer study shows that the women were, actually, not too far behind in that exercise ....
{ Start with Eleanor of Castile? Or Henry V's widow? Or, very likely Anne of Austria, or .....}

H
Unfortunately, one of the best scientist-&-SF-writers died of a Brain Tumour, some years back.

How about the trope where half the characters repeat whatever they're told back to the speaker, either as a question or as shocking new information?

"It's Tuesday"

"Did you know that it's Tuesday?"

"You obviously don't know what day it is, today is Tuesday"

Some day I'd love to see a spy-fi with an extended rant on the impossibility of doing the dangling-from-the-ceiling-tiles scene inside a portable SCIF (a TEMPEST-shielded shipping container with armed guards and metal detectors on the door).

Darn it, now you've gotten me imagining the Hollywood movie version of that, with full CIA-off-the-leash spy nonsense. The protagonists need the MacGuffin information and can't get it because of, well, everything you said. So they organize a big attack on the opposition camp; should it happen to actually take the site, great. But really it's a diversion to get everyone on the ground busy while the protagonists come in with a big cargo helicopter and steal the SCIF.

This plan is obviously completely bonkers. But then, reality includes the Glomar Explorer and Operation Ivy Bells and the thing in the Moscow embassy, so this sounds plausible enough for two hours of Hollywood explosion movie.

Actually, most epochal scientific discoveries ARE made by individuals or small groups of people, but (as you imply) it's a hell of a long way from those to actual use. It's not the science but the engineering that takes the effort and time, though a hell of a lot of what is called science is actually engineering.

I agree with you that the trope to which you refer grates.

The cargo helicopter would have to perform insane aerobatics to prevent the people still inside the container from standing up long enough to delete the data.

I'm referring to an idea of an early evolutionary biologist, Goldschmidt, who thought that evolution took place through macromutations that produced a radically different organism, all at once.

That model is, ah, not right. (Is that charitable enough?) Bizarrely, and illustrative of how biology is always more complex and crazy than anyone expects, I can think of two occasions where that happened, more or less.

The marbled crayfish is a new species, only noticed less than 30 years ago. At some point one individual crustacean got a mutation that allowed it to reproduce by parthenogenesis; it proceeded to do so with great fecundity. The EU has opinions about this and added it to their invasive species list.

Over in North America can be found the gray treefrog and also the Cope's gray treefrog; as you'd guess, they are gray frogs that like woodland habitats. If you can't tell any difference, don't worry about it; neither could frog biologists for a long time. In the field, about the only way to know is by sound, as they have slightly different mating calls. But genetic testing revealed that the former is tetraploid, unable to interbreed with the latter. Apparently at some point there was a single brood with the tetraploid mutation; with luck (and incest) they managed to establish a viable population.

The cargo helicopter would have to perform insane aerobatics to prevent the people still inside the container from standing up long enough to delete the data.

You have obviously given this more thought than a Hollywood executive would.

But imagine the dramatic scene where the clerk inside the SCIF frantically throws secret documents out into the sky, with secrets flying away in the breeze! (Whatever drops randomly onto the ground might be recovered by the enemy; anything that stays is certain to be examined.) Folders and loose pages flying everywhere! Frantic tearing at cabinets trying to pull out computers full of secrets! Struggles with secure encryption machines too securely bolted to the walls!

Yeah, we're definitely over-thinking this. :-)

One of the standard tropes of SF is "science is easy"

Yeah, because most SF authors aren't working scientists (and have no experience of such work). There are notable exceptions -- for example, Timescape by Gregory Benford -- but as it won the Nebula in 1980 it's a very 1970s-tinted vision of how to do science: subsequent updates are rare as actual working science tends to lack the dramatic element readers are looking for in their popular entertainment.

(I have played with the "lone mad scientist" trope, though, in The Annihilation Score -- the superhero/supervillain Laundry novel, in which we get to see that Mad Science in the 21st century actually takes a Mad Science Corporation (or similar scale organization) rather than a lone crazy. And again in the New Management, only Professor Skullface isn't a scientist so much as a demon-haunted inventor of gadgets ...)

I want you to know that I only went there under protest (it was my wife's birthday).

Well I enjoyed "Escape From Yokai Land" even if you didn't! Which probably says a lot more about me than it does about you. ;)

Anyway, on with the tropes...

If MilSF has to be a thing then "All Quiet on the Western Front ... in Spaaaceee" might be entertaining with a Strossian twist. There's also "Das Boot ... in Spaaacee" to think about. The similarities between a submarine and a space ship are all too obvious. Two sub commanders from WW2 make an interesting contrast: David Wanklyn VC (HMS Upholder): neurotic and tearing himself to pieces about the large Italian troop ship he sank. And Anthony Miers VC (HMS Torbay): martinet and war criminal. Obviously the first died, and the second survived WW2.

Still those ideas are not really tropes so much as plot ideas.

What I haven't seen is a SciFi Political Thriller -- though I haven't read the Merchant Princes Series yet (I'm leaving it for later).

First a bit of background. At Oxford I frequently attended parties where the Cream (Scum?) of The Union and the Oxford University Conservative Association were in attendance. William Hague, Michael Gove, Boris Johnson, David Cameron (who was actually at my College). What you become aware of is that their supreme skill is spouting bollocks -- however nonsensical -- and then having the skill and charisma to defend the position.

And charisma and unembarrassability are the key skills needed in almost any political situation.

One of the things people often forget is that there is no government position on anything -- because all of the politicians are forever arguing. We've seen it on the blog comments here: "NATO thinks this", or "The West thinks that". No! Jens Stoltenberg might think something, but Poland's Prime Minister, or Hungary's or Turkey's probably think something else. Not to mention Mr Trump and Mr Biden. I once read an anecdote (from Dayan, I think) that when he was young he thought that a kindly bearded old man was guiding the steps of Israel, but that he'd since learnt that instead it was a bunch of uncouth furiously arguing politicians. This is where conspiracy theories go wrong: conspiracies require a unity of purpose that is rare in small groups, but actually impossible in anything much larger than a dozen individuals.

And things don't get much better in an authoritarian society either. Persuasion works better over the long term than violence. Too many people falling out of windows, for example, forces political players to evaluate the assassination strategy.

As you can see, the Geas of the LaundryVerse pretty much rules out human politics; why persuade when you can command?

So, to pick out an idea from further up the page, if I was writing something about spies from the perspective of "M", I'd be highlighting the interactions "M" has with MI5 (now the Security Service or SS as I prefer to call them) who are continuously investigating my people for treason. Or Special Branch (part of the Met) who do day-to-day leg work (such as confiscating my desktop at the behest of the US Secret Service/NSA). Or very occasionally interacting with the SAS (Rory Stewart in Afghanistan as part of a Jedburgh team). Not to mention M's interactions with the Prime Minister and the supervisory politicians on JIC (Joint Intelligence Committee). I think that GCHQ is now independent of MI6, so there'll be interactions there. Finally, there are twelve people who act as "referers" who are there to provide an outside perspective and try to prevent institutional group think.

As you might guess, it wasn't only political wallies I ran into at Oxford.

As for Alien politics, well, I offer you Chimp Politics: "I am bigger than you, so do what I want or I hit you." Any similarity to Human Politics is purely coincidental, eh? ;)

Naah. It's pretty hard to miss a big-ass cargo helicopter hovering 20 metres up while specops types hook cargo cables up to the big box you're trying to work inside.

Most likely a prelude to stealing the SCIF would involve poking a hole in the air intake filters and saturating the interior with aerosolized carfentanyl. (Effectively a nerve gas for which there exists an effective injectable antidote -- used by Russian special forces during the Moscow theatre siege of 2002.)

Then you drive up in an army green low-loader with a crane and a bunch of guys in uniforms with forged papers and load the container on the back and drive off. (There aren't many choppers out there that can carry a 1TEU container: trucks on the other hand are ubiquitous and anonymous ...)

As for Alien politics, well, I offer you Chimp Politics: "I am bigger than you, so do what I want or I hit you." Any similarity to Human Politics is purely coincidental, eh? ;)

As outdated as Alpha Wolves, I'm afraid; there are "I am bigger than you" chimpanzee leaders, but apparently their careers are notably shorter than coalition-builders. (see Frans de Waal's early work for details.)

I'm sure someday Gen-X, Gen-Z & Millennials (plus the kids being born today) will develop cultures of their own.

Gee, thanks.

Actually, there are quite a lot of such examples, including a few that originated in the UK - I can't remember them, offhand, but Heteromeles might. The bigger problem is that Darwinian evolution requires that every stage be more advantageous than its predecessor (with minor statistical aberrations), and there are species where nobody has been able to think of a convincing path from the ancestor to the descendant species. Human bipedality is one such example. And it is those examples that fuelled the epochal evolution hypotheses, though modern research shows a lot more evidence. As far as I know, the sanest theories are that such changes happened in special circumstances, where there was little evolutionary pressure against otherwise detrimental changes - e.g. birds landing on an island free of other vertebrates.

https://www.nature.com/articles/news.2009.1134

What there is considerable evidence against is really huge changes, such as are needed for the mutant fantasy tropes.

"what is actually wrong with our habitat's life support?" (it's tenths of percents right now, but the voyage (or the mortgage) has some time to run, and the implications are stark) via actual doing of science.

Moz and Heteromeles have already identified Kim Stanley Robinson's Aurora as an example of this. ISTR that KSR described the challenges of keeping a generation ship from ecological destruction pretty well. Lots of unsexy things that had to be tracked and corrected, because not tracking / correcting them meant death, slow or fast.

Bonus points for the people doing this are the fifth generation of inhabitants of the generation ship. The people who went first were all supremely competent volunteers. Their descendants? Same mixture of competent and incompetent as we have here on Earth.

Charlie @ 224: [...] in which we get to see that Mad Science in the 21st century actually takes a Mad Science Corporation (or similar scale organization) rather than a lone crazy.

The real life example of this is Aum Shinrikyo, which was a large organisation with multi-million dollar funding and actual science PhDs amongst its true believers. Read the Wikipedia article and giggle at their farcical attempts at chemical and biological terror, before they finally got good enough to actually kill some people. At which point the hammer came down hard and they ceased to exist. Up to that point nobody had realised that there were any attacks happening:

In July 1993, cult members sprayed large amounts of liquid containing Bacillus anthracis spores from a cooling tower on the roof of Aum Shinrikyo's Tokyo headquarters. However, their plan to cause an anthrax epidemic failed. The attack resulted in a large number of complaints about bad odors but no infections.

Poisons and bio-warfare agents get highly diluted before they reach a significant number of people, even on a crowded subway. So you need thousands of times the LD50 per victim. Producing that much of a lethal agent without killing yourself is hard. Doing it without causing a noticeable spike in illnesses downwind of you is even harder. Ironically, if Aum had merely handed out handguns and told its followers to start shooting bystanders at 17:36 exactly they would have had a far higher body count.

I said @ 217 ... Unfortunately, one of the best scientist-&-SF-writers died of a Brain Tumour, some years back. - Charles Sheffield

Dave Lester
Oh dear: - "How true these words are - even today!" { Repeated quote for laughs, from the long-ago R4 series "The Navy Lark" by the utterly useless padre. }
Or, as I observed yesterday, in the pub, whilst discussing the inanities ( Or should that be Onanities? ) of Local misgovernment ... Never reach for a carrot, when you think that a stick will do

I assume you've read Kim Newman's 'Life's Lottery'? If not, do.

most SF authors aren't working scientists

You've mentioned Benford. From memory, also

• David Brin
  
• Peter Watts
  
• Fred Hoyle
  
• Poul Anderson
  
• Carl Sagan
  
• Isaac Asimov
  

All male, most not writing much (or any) fiction anymore. I'm making an effort to read more widely now, but don't really pay attention to authors' educational background anymore so can't remember the background of anyone I've read recently. Hell, I often struggle remembering the author's name now, which makes finding them again on my iPad (sorted by author name) tricky*. Mia culpa.

If we include engineers, there's a lot more. And a lot of the 'single scientist' plots are actually mostly engineering. Although I suspect that we should consider engineers separately — the thought processes for science and engineering are often very different.

S.L. Huang is a mathematician.

Robert Sawyer isn't a scientist, but he did a decent job of the physicists in Flashforward. (At least according to a physicist I chatted with at Perimeter Institute.) Too bad Hollywood decided that physicists are boring and switched the main character from physicist to FBI agent in the screen adaptation…

*One downside to switching to ebooks for fiction. My memory for books turns out to be very much like 'blue cover with some red, on the shelf this height and this far from the edge'. Which doesn't work for ebooks in the iPad, obviously.

Bonus points for the people doing this are the fifth generation of inhabitants of the generation ship. The people who went first were all supremely competent volunteers. Their descendants? Same mixture of competent and incompetent as we have here on Earth.

Poul Anderson did the reverse with Tales of the Flying Mountains. The interstellar voyagers had some competent volunteers, but most of the crew weren't. They figured the next generation would be basically normal despite what their parents were like, and designed the ship accordingly. (From memory, might have got the details wrong.)

Then you drive up in an army green low-loader with a crane and a bunch of guys in uniforms with forged papers...

Interestingly, one of the very few successful escapes from Alcatraz worked that way. One prisoner worked in the print shop, another worked in the mail room, and one day the warden received a letter regarding some pardons. The four listed inmates were collected by the guards and turned out on the mainland.

Pretty soon the penny dropped and three of them were collected again, but one was never found.

SS
Or, you could pretend to be dead & be buried at sea ...
Oops, that's The Count of Monte Cristo

Or, you could pretend to be dead & be buried at sea ...

He was dead and buried in space.

Or was he? Cue long search on the most probable trajectories by multiple parties, each of whom has something to prove.

The bigger problem is that Darwinian evolution requires that every stage be more advantageous than its predecessor (with minor statistical aberrations)

Not true: it just requires that each stage not be disadvantageous compared to the previous one -- and only under conditions prevailing at the time the change takes place (for as long as it takes to be passed on to descendants).

Evolution proceeds via a drunkard's walk through the space of possible mutations, with a filter that weeds out non-viable mutations. That's all.

In fact, disadvantageous mutations can also become universal, almost invariably the result of inbreeding. While it is more common that a neutral mutation becomes universal, it's still unlikely. You can increase the probabilities by assuming very small populations, but that makes the chance of extinction much higher. It's the difference between an undirected random walk and a directed one. Once upon a time, I could have given you the formulae off the top of my head, but no longer.

Anyway, a long chain of such things produces a resulting probability that, while not in Boltzman brains territory, is astronomically unlikely. That was my main point.

Your point about possibly temporary conditions is the key - characteristics can become universal remarkably quickly if there is even a small amount of selective pressure in favour of them.

Advantage is based on environmental conditions, as the non-avian dinosaurs discovered at the end of the Cretaceous. And it depends on relationships with other species, as cattle discovered, but aurochs did not. And a huge chunk of variation is selectively neutral. Then, on rare occasions, some previously random and neutral set of traits becomes selectively advantageous, which is why some species can take over with extraordinary rapidity. Urban weeds are an example of this. They got lucky to happen to have a set of traits that make it possible for them to proliferate in modern cities. Antibiotic resistance also can follow this pattern: it shows up in wild bacteria that have never been exposed to those antibiotics. The resistance was already there for some other reason.

Yes. That's essentially what I said! I was trying to explain why 'simple' mutations are common, and speciation is not a rare event, but why the fantasy trope of macromutations is so implausible. It all comes down to probabilities. As a mathematician, I believe in events that occur with a probability of 10^-100 - in all other contexts, I don't :-)

Actually, I don't think that it is rare that neutral traits become beneficial (or, for that matter, detrimental), but that's a debate for another day ....

Getting back to the original topic, has Charlie written a madcap comedy? (Sometimes called screwball comedy, I think.) Is that a trope or a genre? (I get confused about the difference.)

Maybe Trunk and Disorderly, although that doesn't seem to quite fit the sheer craziness I associate with madcaps.

Which reminds me: I haven't read the latest Jodi Taylor St. Mary's book yet. Something to look forward to…

Off topic, but of probable interest to a number of folks here…

There's currently a Kickstarter running for a graphic novel version of Good Omens, supported by Terry Pratchett's estate. Looks decent, but the shipping costs for non-UK addresses equal (or exceed) the cost of the book.

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/dunmanifestin/good-omens

Getting back to the original topic, has Charlie written a madcap comedy?

It's really hard to do screwball comedy at book length! There are outbreaks of it in my work (see the dinner party scene in The Nightmare Stacks, for example) but novels consisting purely of comedy ... no, not so much: don't think I can actually do that.

You've mentioned Benford. From memory, also

Alastair Reynolds is an astrophysicist, and cites Benford as his inspiration to write science fiction

»but novels consisting purely of comedy ... no, not so much: don't think I can actually do that.«

Comedy requires a solid background to be funny against, and of the top of my head I can't recall a single novel which has more than about 20-30% comedy.

The most obvious book Charlie hasn't written yet, is the one inspired by Twain's "Life on Mississippi" where he regales the reader with tall tales from his youth as a UNIX-wrangler.

I would buy it!

Perhaps a black comedy, sir? Or a farce?

I’ll admit, the title that keeps occurring to me is A Child’s Book of Nonsensical Prose, by Charles Stross and Peter Watts.

So Quantum of Nightmares wasn't enough of a black comedy for you?!?

Edward Lir?

Old Strossum's Book of Theoretical, Practical and Impractical Cats?

I don't know which trope it fits in, nor what plot could make sense, but I'm imagining something written from the point of view of the starship's cat, named Menhit, of course.

This is kind of close. Not a cat, but an uplifted capuchin monkey: https://www.amazon.com/Lovelock-Mayflower-Trilogy-Book-1/dp/031287751X

My thought was that OGH's cat Menhit is named after a war goddess, so this cat character would be more bloodthirsty than the crew expected when she came aboard.

Speaking of tropes, "temporarily embarrassed millionaire" anyone?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qGNFR7pgxDY Billy Bragg covers "Rich men earning north of a million"

"Spherical cats in a vacuum cleaner", surely? Which also makes the natural unit the Watts-Stross :) (joules per second per cat per square metre)

I'm still getting over XKCD's recent cartoon about the feline car wash. Look at that and tell me it's not a big cat in a box.

Haven't read any comments and not sure this is a trope.

But I'd really like someone to tackle this: solving societal problems (whether global, time/generational or interplanetary) without resorting to violence. So instead of shoot-em ups, we get some really interesting mind-bending problem solving. Not just exposés but some ideas about how to address what seems like an increase in acceptance of using physical violence.

The reason I mention this is because I recently read about the injuries/loss of life to-date in the Russia-Ukraine war - half a million and rising. My gut reaction: Violence is the ultimate in stupidity. (Why are you throwing people's lives away? You're only going to create more problems down the road for those affected - not just the ones who died/were injured but their families/friends as well.)

Ditto for antiquated economics: the GDP is purportedly by some right-ish pols the ultimate metric for measuring an economic winner. Not so if you look closely. Anyways, the $$$ is the other sword of the would-be oppressor. Not sure but from my POV, the concept of 'recycling' (circular economics) is newish in economics - at least in the headlines and could be popularized via fiction.

Charlie -

I think you do satire very well so I hope that you'll consider trashing the notion of 'heroes win by violence or by economic sleight of hand'.

Heteromeles @ 176:

Re: Navajo skinwalkers.

If you want fiction about them, they showed up in at least three of Tony Hillerman.s mysteries.

If you want to read about people who mix psychopathic violence with shamanism, read Whitehead.s Dark Shamans, because he actually interviewed some practitioners. The problem with Navajo wolves is that there’s no proof they actually exist.

Ha! You missed it. Not skinwalkers, SKI walkers ... Navajo SKI walkers like the Jamaican Bobsled Team

Upside-down smiley -> 🙃

Greg Tingey @ 178:

John S
Mucular Christianity was particularly apparent on the spurts field & "owned" the libs by persistent bullying & petty torture of anyone showing the slightest interest in literature or the fine arts or anything "sensitive" - was rolled-up with hatred of the "queers" of course, though that was an excuse to cover for the ongoing power-play(s) Petty fascism in fact.

I'm fairly familiar with it from first-hand encounters. In its 19th century origins it was NOT about "owning the libs" ... that has actually come within my lifetime, and in the later part of it at that.

The version of "Muscular Christianity" I encountered in the U.S. public schools** were not really in any way fascist, just "a healthy mind in a healthy body" taken to its illogical extreme.

U.S. public schools have a thing called "recess" which usually follows closely on to the lunch period when the students are taken out doors to "play" - mostly some kind of organized sport (kids can't be allowed to just run around whooping & hollering like kids, not durning school - it's got to EDGE-YOU-KATE you!) ... softball, soccer (football), basketball ... in which the class or classes is/are divided up into teams usually by the teacher having the two most popular boys take alternate picks.

Suffice it to say my abilities at sports were such I was never picked first for any team.

Petty fascism in that regard was just that, petty, childishly so. The kids I went to school with wouldn't have recognized REAL fascism if it had come up and bit them on the hind parts; for all that casual unthinking racism was pervasive then (unlike today when it's anything BUT unthinking).

OTOH, I did fairly well in music & art classes ... and folk dancing

** which are NOT the same as English Public Schools, being actually PUBLIC, everybody's kids can attend at taxpayer expense - English style Public Schools are private schools here in the U.S.)

Yes, you got me!

Howard NYC @ 212:

Charlie Stross in 205:

"chained her to a hot word processor"... OH! YOU BRUTES! forcing her to carry those heavy, heavy sacks of silver 'n gold to the bank upon her weary, weary back... definitely was her personal version of 'Peter Rabbit and brier patch'

IIRC, the brier patch was Br'er Rabbit, not Peter.

Perhaps some of your works already cover this, but a story about becoming or discovering you already are the Other? But in a joyous way instead of a horrifying way.

Not realy your style, but an example would be Katalepsis. I'm not sure that this trope inherently has the high concept or satire you usually go for.

Idk, just a fairly rare trope that I love. Probably has nothing to do with being trans and neurodivergent.

anonemouse @ 228:

I'm sure someday Gen-X, Gen-Z & Millennials (plus the kids being born today) will develop cultures of their own.

Gee, thanks.

You're welcome, but don't forget the other part: "I hope they will find something worth keeping from ours."

... or that I think it's not only inevitable, but desireable.

What DP characterized as "Boomer culture" didn't spring fully formed from the forehead of Elvis like Athena ... it was both an extension of & a reaction to the culture our parents raised us in shaped by the events of our times.

Just like our parents' culture extended & reacted to their parents' culture and the events that shaped our parents lives ... it's generations reacting like turtles all the way down.

Why should it be any different for y'all?

“What is happening to our young people? They disrespect their elders, they disobey their parents. They ignore the law. They riot in the streets inflamed with wild notions. Their morals are decaying. What is to become of them?”
     – Plato

“We live in a decaying age. Young people no longer respect their parents. They are rude and impatient. They frequently inhabit taverns and have no self control”
     Inscription on a 6,000 year old Egyptian tomb

I'm sure, if we could find them, there were contemporaneous complaints from young people about what old fuddy-duddys their nagging parents & elders were. For every "Kids today blah blah blah ..." there was (and IS) an equal and opposite "Parents just don't understand ..."

Just because I don't agree with some of the things they say & do doesn't make them wrong ... same as when I couldn't always agree with MY parents. I try to remember all the times I said, "I'm NOT going to be like that when I'm a grown up!"

IF I ever DO grow up ... 😏

Paul @ 238:

Or, you could pretend to be dead & be buried at sea ...

He was dead and buried in space.

Or was he? Cue long search on the most probable trajectories by multiple parties, each of whom has something to prove.

Bujold has a short story in the Vorkosigan Saga on that theme, Aftermaths

Charlie Stross in 238:

Another useful definition of -- or rather an insight into -- evolution is it less a matter of a species heading towards a destination as it is seeking to move away from a source of stress.

Living in deserts, mammals develop kidneys more effective at losing less water.

Variations in skin tone amongst our own species of hairless apes in response to excessive sunlight being just one example. There's likely a gazillion variants of skin tone, each having advantages and disadvantages in each of a zillion ecological niches.

Indeed, when considering species in dire straits (examples such Brittianius Toyious and Americus Republicus) will undergo frantic attempts at adapting to changes in their respective political ecologies. Though with outcomes ranging from moderately effective to outright self-destructive to toxic die-off.

Anybody writing that story absolutely must mention the traditional greeting of the Ski'ites, "Slalom alaikum".

Cats in space:
ONE name: - P. M. A. Linebarger { "Cordwainer Smith" }

Charlie, have you ever tried letting go of the sci-fi mindset while writing?

By which I mean, the deeply ingrained knowledge/belief that deep down, everything in the universe is governed by impartial and impersonal rules.

You can write fantasy with this mindset, and plenty authors do, but it leaks through. I think GRRM is the best example of a modern fantasy writer who is very good, but writes with sci-fi mindset, and as a result the magic feels out of place. Like he's consciously switching gears - "right, I'm going to invoke fantasy tropes now... and done, back to Romantic pseudohistorical fiction."

Not even going to mention Sanderson, who turns magic into a video game.

Compare and contrast, for example, LeGuin's Earthsea series. Oh, and all her sci-fi, which is written with a fantasy mindset.

Actually, it's the other way round. The original skin colour of our species was dark brown, and most gene pools retain it - it is the reaction to inadequate sunlight (i.e. vitamin D deficiency) that caused the flavism.

Elderly Cynic in 268:

oooooops... you caught me...

I'd been setting up that post for sake of mashing up soon-to-be-extinct parasitical species Britianius Toryious and Americus Republicus into a snark involving (dreaded) evolution and 'political ecology' and how they are refusing to be rational... I'm just chaffed raw reading about Greece burning, Hawaii burning, coral reefs cooking, Ukraine faltering and instead of fight fascism or fixing the world... we can only watch it all die in highest rez real time feeds on our handheld supercomputers... my attempts at distraction unsuccessful...

oh... another overlooked topic for OGH to consider! 'justice for all' after Gaia awakens and every critter on the planet is on the jury evaluating humanity's crimes...

warning : looks like you got hackernewed, and given the tone deafness of the few comments on zombies slave revolt I saw, you may have some moderation headache coming.

I’ll admit, the title that keeps occurring to me is A Child’s Book of Nonsensical Prose, by Charles Stross and Peter Watts.

A Stross/Watts collaboration would be interesting, especially considering Watts' optimistic outlook.

(Seriously, he considers himself an optimist. Angry, but optimistic.)

the brier patch was Br'er Rabbit, not Peter.

I assumed the mingling of two country's children's stories was intentional. Enid Blyton in the Old South…

I wonder if something could be done with the noir hard-boiled private detective set in the future.

Larry Niven’s “The Meddler” or Alastair Reynolds "The Prefect"

Who is Sanderson?

The eponymous Prefect is definitely hard-boiled, but unlike pretty much every other fictional hard-boiled detective, he relentlessly refuses to bend rules and sticks to the legal procedure -- despite many of his colleagues clamoring otherwise. And succeeds.

The Prefect is the very opposite of Dirty Harry.

Mole salamanders in North America have complex reproductive strategies that, for some species / species complexes, include hybridization and parthenogenesis. The parthenogenetic hybrids are always female and still require insemination, but don't actually use any of the spermatozoa, so they are in sperm competition with females of both parent species. Offspring usually have multiple copies of the mother's genome, but not always, increasing in subsequent generations.

You're asking me to let go of rationality. Sorry, my brain doesn't want to do that! Might as well ask me to believe in God.

You're asking me to let go of rationality. Sorry, my brain doesn't want to do that!

Possibly that was what was meant; but I took it to mean that perhaps the storyline should be more stochastic.

The problem with that sort of thing is that readers get pissed off by the random it just happenedness of it all.

It's one of the features of much literary fiction that things happen for a reason, but reality often does include a lot more "random shit" than narrative fiction would allow.

There is one trope I don't think you have hit: The Cassandra syndrome. Sometimes shows up as the village idiot who speaks the truth but nobody pays attention. For a near(ish) future story, have a LLM AI model actually telling/warning people about something, but since LLM AIs have been been found to be unreliable nobody pays attention....

Or a genuine strong AI, but since strong AIs tend to say things people don't want to hear nobody pays attention.

Actually, you can hang on to rationality, just with a set of natural laws that are entirely different from what we are accustomed to. It's DAMN hard to do build such a world, which is why it's rarely attempted, and even more rarely done successfully. I don't know if you would call it a trope or a meta-trope. It's much easier to adopt a variant of the fairytale myths of yore, though it's very boring the way that most authors also adopt a pseudo-mediaeval world.

The Laundryverse (and Missile Gap) goes some of the way there, but even that is our world with added magic. My guess is that it would double the time to write a novel, even if you could pull it off. I know that I can't, because I have had several seed ideas, and floundered fleshing them out (even ignoring the fact that I can't write readable fiction).

Actually, you can hang on to rationality, just with a set of natural laws that are entirely different from what we are accustomed to.

You need not invent your own world: our quantum reality is quite confusing enough for most of us to give up ;)

I must re-read Hannu Rajaniemi's Quantum Thief to see if there's anything I missed on a first reading that helps explain what's going on.

"Overly paternalistic interfering aliens" instantly brought to mind Jack Williamson's response to Asimov's Three Laws, The Humanoids.

Doing this in one post, this is not my blog: "Hopeful monsters"... Also in reply to @225 and persuasion: have you read my first novel, 11,000 Years? 256: also about persuasion, and less violence - that's my next novel, Becoming Terran, coming out hopefully later this year.

Vegan. Dominionists.
mark runs, screaming....

Ah, right. Charlie, have you ever seen Lindsay Anderson's O Lucky Man? Several things - he could stumble through the New Management coming out find (as the hero does, as long as he stays with the hippies, he's safe), then....

Just read about that in this morning's Guardian. Thanks very much for the link.

You may have missed the context. The genesis 1 dominion covenant specified that humans had dominion, and they had to be vegan. By genesis 6, YHWH is so sick of their wickedness that they want to destroy all of creation in a deluge and start over. But he likes Noah, so he lets the that ark survive and makes a second, non-dominion covenant with Noah and his descendants.

This isn’t harshing on veganism, it’s about Genesis.

Anyway, so if YHWH starts manifesting in a modern city via the Ark of the Covenant, and Observant people gain powers in step with following the Temple-era Laws, who better to play the antagonists than vegan dominionists? After all, they are following a covenant, just one that YHWH apparently hates.

Note that I’m suggesting this as a story setting, not asking anyone to believe in it. Figuring out what YHWH and the Ark are in the context of the story is the place to start, primarily because the story needs to be respectful of Jews and Judaism, whatever the author personally believes or practices.

"Enid Blyton in the Old South..."

ENID BLYTON??!!? Beatrix Potter, you uncultured foreign person :)

Enid Blyton in the Old South would be hideously unreadable, and I can't imagine Charlie wanting to write it for a Planck moment.

Still got the same problem, though, of being mindbendingly hard to make a setting with that you can actually tell a readable story in.

Dave Lester
I wouldn't bother if I were you.
I've read it twice & attemoted a third PLUS the next two: "Fractal Prince & "Causal Angel" & I haven't a clues.
I mean: - What's the fucking point of an unreadable book?
"Unreadable" in the sense that the words & sentences make sense, bu the integrated whole is NOT integrated & has zero adherence to any plot or cognition - from my p.o.v. at any rate.
Very annoying.

Actually, you can hang on to rationality, just with a set of natural laws that are entirely different from what we are accustomed to. It's DAMN hard to do build such a world, which is why it's rarely attempted, and even more rarely done successfully.

Richard Garfinkle managed in Celestial Matters. Ptolemaic astronomy and Aristotelian physics are valid scientific models, as is Chinese xi. Described as an alternate history but really more of an alternate science novel.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Celestial_Matters

Good enough for a read-once, at least.

Actually, Mark Twain was pretty close to Enid Blyton in the Old South :-)

There are others along such lines, but I was thinking more radically.

Brain fart. Thinking one, wrote the other, and didn't check.

I'm actually English — got the fancy birth certificate and everything. I think one reason I like SF was that all the children's books I read (mostly English) were clearly about another world, that was nothing like where I grew up. So SF was just another imaginary world, rather than totally outlandish…

Um no, Mark Twain was not Enid Blyton. Joel Chandler Harris, who collected and published the Br’er Rabbit stories, is rather closer to Blyton, I think. Twain was, among other things VP of the American Anti-Imperialist League…

I see what you mean as far as the adventuring and stuff goes, but their attitudes to the social order don't have much in common. Their sympathetic protagonists are from opposite ends of the social scale: Mark Twain chooses slaves and poor people just above the level of slaves, and excoriates their condition and the slave-owning classes, whereas Enid Blyton's main characters are people who in that time and place would be the slave-owning classes, and the further down the scale the minor characters are the less respect they get. Charlie would probably do very well at turning "Enid Blyton in the Old South" inside out and stabbing the fuck out of it, but I suspect he would much prefer not to even think about such a project.

I decided to post it in that form as a reference to one of Enid Blyton's favourite tropes ;)

Old South? These days, the story I wish more people would try is “Lincoln isn’t assassinared, the North wins The Reconstruction and…. cue science fiction or at least steampunk, with 21st century US racial politics in a 1900 world.

Perhaps riff on Twain, such as A Connecticut Yankee in Freetown Tara, or something like that.

Why? The GOP’s current playbook is straight out of the Anti-Reconstruction playbook of a century ago. If you want to bring the struggle into literature, why not attack the original?

She didn't just write the Peter Rabbit books, you know. Try the Famous Five or Secret Seven.

Brain fart due to exhaustion. As Pigeon says, but my point stands.

I haven't seen "I/We are the Last of My/Our Kind" as a trope mentioned or, as far as I can recall, in any of your books. Not post-apocalyptic in a general sense, as life in general goes on, just without this person/group.

As far as the Western tropes go, have you thought of suberting them? The original cowboys were black as a contrapoint to the White Supremecist/Settler Colonial narratives that are the norm. The Wind Done Gone instead of Gone With The Wind

Re TV shows, the New Management might be interested in some bread and circuses entertainment for the masses. How about that old TV show The Golden Shot with human targets?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Golden_Shot

The Grants were invited to see that play with the Lincolns, but US Grant was able to deal with his paperwork and head north that day.

If I ever went mad and tried to write the alternate history, that's the turning point; extra paperwork. The Grants are there, Lincoln lives, Wilkes-Booth is hanged with one hand, and the one shot Wilkes-Booth gets off goes through Mrs. Julia Grant's hat.

Can I steal that scenario?

My take on that is "Lincoln is not a lawyer, but an early economist, and can prove beyond the slightest shadow of any doubt that the South's economy is inferior to the North's. The civil war is avoided and slavery becomes a non-issue. (Yeah, I know human nature is against that kind of admission, but I think it would be a fun alternate history - in which Captain Kirk is played by James Earl Jones.)

Since Beatrix Potter, IIRC, got hounded out of biology for daring to publish the truth that lichens were composites of fungi and algae at a time when symbiosis was thought to be impossibly anti-Darwinian, confusing her with Blyton makes my head spin. Apology accepted though.

Hey, there’s a story: the antithesis of Guns of the South.

Elderly Cynic @ 268:

Actually, it's the other way round. The original skin colour of our species was dark brown, and most gene pools retain it - it is the reaction to inadequate sunlight (i.e. vitamin D deficiency) that caused the flavism.

Is it? I'd always read it was somewhere in the middle & both were adaptations?

Brandon Sanderson, a writer who created the most successful Kickstarter ever for BOOKS!

Oops, missed the comma after "ever". It's the most successful project on Kickstarter.

As far as the Western tropes go, have you thought of suberting them? The original cowboys were black as a contrapoint to the White Supremecist/Settler Colonial narratives that are the norm.

Black, Mexican, Indigenous… the original cowboys (in the Western sense) were Spanish. Gun control was common in Western towns (also eastern ones — ruled not unconstitutional, too) — the who gunfight at the OK Corral fracas was lawmen apprehending wild boys who thought they had a right to carry and shoot their guns in town. Fights between wagon train settlers and Indigenous people were rare and a minor cause of death; disease and starvation killed two orders of magnitude more settlers.

A number of 70s films did subvert the Hollywood Western narrative.

Lincoln is not a lawyer, but an early economist

Lincoln was interested in economics. He subscribed to the labour theory of value — you can bate Americans by quoting from his writing and, when they call you a stinking commie quoting Marx, reveal that you are actually quoting their revered president.

(Although many of those don't seem to revere him much, as he was on the wrong side of the late unpleasantness and encouraged overturning the natural order of society.)

Agreed on the cowboys. Anyway, they covered only the last three decades or so of a Great Game of empire in western North America that ran for at least 200 years before that.

I know it’s not Charlie’s thing, but someone could almost set a warped version of Kipling’s Kim in New Mexico in the early 1800s. Making fantasy out of it, with the area settled by all sorts of people (crypto Jews, Muslims….) trying to get away from the Spanish Reconquista? Yeah, that might be doable.

Actually, you can hang on to rationality, just with a set of natural laws that are entirely different from what we are accustomed to.

You need not invent your own world: our quantum reality is quite confusing enough for most of us to give up ;)

I must re-read Hannu Rajaniemi's Quantum Thief to see if there's anything I missed on a first reading that helps explain what's going on.

Don't confuse "Quantum Thief" Quantum mechanics with actual quantum mechanics. Some of his claims for the properties of entanglement are remote from actual quantum entanglement. Fun story. Bad physics.

it's past 300... oh goodie... something worthy of its own SF book, the vile underpinnings of the incel/fascist/rollback groups warrants closer attention... reading their rage posts about women's football and "Barbie" and so forth just makes me wonder how we can avoid triple-stacking these nut cases in prison cells in order to protect ourselves from them... the Tories clearly want to rollback the UK to the good ol' days Dickens made infamous... and the GOP hackers to rollback to when a handful of men had the power of dukes... oddly both are more-or-less point in the 1840s...

You're asking me to let go of rationality. Sorry, my brain doesn't want to do that! Might as well ask me to believe in God.

Not in real life. But there are different modes of writing. Take mystery, for example. Under the sci-fi mindset, a mystery is simply a veil covering something concrete, and there's always at least a possibility of uncovering it. Under fantasy mind-set, mystery can be a quality on its own.

Accidentally, this is why Lovecraftian Cosmic Horror doesn't work too well under a sci-fi mindset. It reduced the Old Ones to just exceptionally obnoxious aliens that can nonetheless be defeated with sufficient ingenuity. In a world of impartial rules, everyone is playing on the same board. Or as they say in TTRPGs, "if it has stats, you can kill it".

Actually, you can hang on to rationality, just with a set of natural laws that are entirely different from what we are accustomed to.

No, the sci-fi mindset only requires that the secondary world has impartial and impersonal rules, not that they be anything like the real world.

Hmm... I wonder now, is this the Modernisn vs Post-modernism thing again?

Charlie, are you a modernist author? ;-)

Ted Chiang makes a habit of it, although the short story format does make it easier to avoid tricky edge cases.

Graydon Saunders' books are an interesting comparison; he writes with a sci-fi mindset and sensibility - so his characters act like there are and/or try to discover universal natural laws - but the universes he writes are fantasy and therefore e.g. in the Commonweal books magic's immutable laws are immutable and different for each magician.

Spoeaking of tropes, how about raising a dead horse from the dead purely so you can thrash it some more?

Hard to tell whether the politician suggesting Aotearoa ask to become part of Australia is being satirical or making some kind of rhetorical point. Perhaps hoping that people in Australia will notice and start thinking about how Te Tiriti compares to The Voice. Article linked provides a decent summary of the situation in that area in order to arrive at the "you can't be serious" conclusion. Note that the point about the neo-thatcherites being the anti-Maori party is accurate, and they are unpopular as a result (they are also as close as we get to a terf party outside the lunatic fringe*. Consistent...ly wrong?).

https://theconversation.com/a-retiring-nz-mp-has-suggested-joining-australia-we-should-at-least-think-about-it-before-saying-no-211728

I've mentioned this before, but to be acceptable to most kiwis the Australians would have to guarantee Maori seats, and likely Aboriginal ones lest "ten thousand warriors on the streets of Auckland" (link to video quote from the movie Utu). I'm not sure how the actual vote would go, but I have a feeling you'd see an age skew worse than Reuplican support in the US. But as with that skew, still high levels of support amoung the older white folk for Maori. Australia... pretty racist, aye.

(* the upcoming election promises to have a glorious (gold) fringe featuring maritime law, maga hats and relgiously antivaxx stances. Making the thatcherite ACT party seem positively normal and mainstream by comparison. Sadly there's a real prospect of the religious right of the National Party + ACT ending up as the government, so there's potential for some scary moralising as well as the expected recession + tax cuts)

Don't confuse "Quantum Thief" Quantum mechanics with actual quantum mechanics. Some of his claims for the properties of entanglement are remote from actual quantum entanglement. Fun story. Bad physics.

Thanks Nick.

I thought it was just me being dense.

Howard NYC
The Tories clearly want to rollback the UK to the good ol' days Dickens made infamous... - FAR TOO LATE.
We are already there, back at the beginnning of the C19th with Prison Hulks, Transportation beyond the Seas & rivers full of shit.
Aren't we?
I would say about 1818, actually, or even 1788 - the latter date being the arrival of the "First Fleet" ....

A piece in the "indy" yesterday, unfortunately behind a paywall, but it indicated that several dangerous climate points have been passed, all this year.
Would help if someone could re-find-it ( I got there via "incognito", so don't have a record ...

the Tories clearly want to rollback the UK to the good ol' days Dickens made infamous... and the GOP hackers to rollback to when a handful of men had the power of dukes... oddly both are more-or-less point in the 1840s...

Let's take the 1840s as shorthand for a generational period spanning roughly 1820-1860, shall we?

It's no coincidence that the 1840s was a turbulent decade during the period when efficiency improvements in steam engines made powered machinery more effective than muscle power for most tasks -- rail most obviously, but also agriculture (with stationary engines in grain mills, also smaller mobile engines that could be moved to fields to provide power for ploughing, tilling, and harvesting appliances), shipping, and for spinning, weaving, and other aspects of cloth and clothing manufacturing: sewing machines were invented during this period (1790-1840) before emerging in recognizably modern form in the 1850s, much as bicycles did (from the 1780s hobby-horse through penny farthings of the 1870s-1890s, which were abruptly rendered obsolete by the modern Safety Bicycle in 1884-88).

Militarily ... the 1840s approximately match the end of the era of musketry and the arrival of breech-loading rifles which dominated the battlefields of the slaveowners' treasonous rebellion in North America: it matches the beginning of the age of the ironclads (HMS Warrior, the Royal Navy's first all-iron steam-powered frigate was ordered in 1859, as a reaction to the French navy's launch in 1850 of the Napoléon (ordered in 1847), the world's first steam-powered battleship (still wooden, with sails).

The 1840s also marked the start of a long slow emancipation for women (in the US and UK), who, as of 1840, had little more legal autonomy than they do in Afghanistan under Taliban rule today.

So it's no surprise that the 1820-1860 period saw the beginnings of sunset for social hierarchies dominated by the economic musclepower -- quite literally -- of large landowners with tenant farmers (or slaves, or serfs, depending on jurisdiction), and the rise of the urban industrial class.

And the Tories and American Republican elites represent the descendants of those landowners.

Not bad physics so much as physics based on speculative string theory. And note that Hannu did his PhD in string theory at Edinburgh around the time he was writing the Jean Le Flambeur trilogy.

Greg 323:

"unfortunately behind a paywall"

try this...

https://archive.ph/

With your restrictive definition of fantasy, you would include most works usually classed as such as science fiction.

As has been posted by several people here, many (perhaps most) readers find fantasy not rooted on a set of implicit rules rarely worth reading.

the vile underpinnings of the incel/fascist/rollback groups warrants closer attention... reading their rage posts about women's football and "Barbie" and so forth just makes me wonder how we can avoid triple-stacking these nut cases in prison cells

But why would we want to avoid that? Let them decide who's the most alpha and gets the top bunk in their (pink painted) abode…

Or we could take the Arpaio approach: stick them in camps in the desert with pink clothing. It can't be illegal, because their hero Trump pardoned the good sheriff for those work camps…

RE: '... hang on to rationality, just with a set of natural laws that are entirely different from what we are accustomed to'

A few questions - just curious, not sniping ... :)

a)When you say 'rationality' do you mean a forever-fixed, never-changing set of rules/laws or are you allowing for errors/mutations/chance/evolution?

b)I've been wondering how a fractal universe, i.e., same fundamental elements but in varying quantities/concentrations per iteration, would play out if/when two or three such fractal spin-offs came into contact again. Am wondering if changing the proportions of elements would also change the forces and potential interactions between/among fundamental elements. Sorta chicken-and-egg - which came first: the particles or the forces? To me, fractal also means eternal/infinite therefore even if you don't happen to see X, it doesn't mean it's not there. Potential for riffing on dark matter/energy. Very hand-wavy SF with an emphasis on the 'fiction'.

SF narrative POV -

The 'rational' narrative is typically told from one point of view and usually follows a linear timeline which makes for an easy read. Although less common, the multiple-POV narrative alternative is a really good approach for presenting and arguing an idea because the real world is a hodgepodge of diverse individuals/POVs. Based on my reader experience, for SF/F, a multiple-POV approach makes it faster and easier to present a new universe that feels robust and complex. A couple of my favorite stories where a key incident is experienced/told from multiple POVs: non-SF movie 'Twelve Angry Men' and The X-Files 'Jose Chung's From Outer Space'. (This is the episode with an alien behind bars smoking while repeating 'this can't be happening' - hilarious.)

Graydon @ 304: '... that's the turning point; extra paperwork.'

Yeah - or how admin/paperwork is responsible for triggering a tsunami of potential universes when umpteen Dept Administrators meet to decide what the best next step is. Missing from this next-step discussion are the entities that will be affected. (Excel spreadsheets/AIs don't have a 'human' computation function/symbol.)

Hmmm... How about the "space-aliens are already among us, with unknown, and possibly hostile intentions" trope?

I'm also a big fan of the Illuminatus trilogy. I'd love to see a good author do an 'updated' take on that, with all our modern conspiracies and cultural changes.

Something involving the bio-sciences might be fun too. Genetic manipulation as the singularity-ish central problem rather than computing.

Hmmm... How about the "space-aliens are already among us, with unknown, and possibly hostile intentions" trope?

Because unless they're microbial in scale, that's bullshit. It begs the question of the Fermi Paradox, for starters, and for seconds it implies a ridiculous degree of convergence in evolution, giving rise to terrestrial-compatible biochemistry, non-sessile animal life, and a bunch of other unlikelihoods before we even get as far as "can we talk to it?" never mind "can it hide among us?"

As for "Illuminatus!" style conspiracy-mongering, it was fun the first time around before the internet ruined the experience by turning the exotic shores of conspiracy theories into overpopulated package holiday destinations served by the budget 747s of usenet and the web.

When you've seen enough conspiracy theories they tend to converge on one variant or another of the Blood Libel, and when a bunch of your relatives were murdered by mobs who'd been bamboozled into believing that shit, it loses its appeal.

(On genetic engineering: if Ghost Engine ever comes out, that has some pointed subtexts ...)

I've got to ask... it's been bugging me ever since this post went up.

Am I misreading, Charlie, or are you really saying that you believe artificial general intelligence to be impossible? Sure, when I know that FTP is nothing more than wishful thinking on my part, and I agree with you on most other speculative points, but it's difficult to understand how AGI could be impossible.

Is there something magically special about the meat in our skulls? And even if this were so, why might we not manufacture that artificially?

I've read that passage a dozen times now trying to figure out if my brain malfunctioned and inverted the meaning, but I'm just not seeing it.

I mean a universe with a different set of consistent, logical rules from which everything else derives. There are a fair number of stories (often by physicists) that do that with the current laws and tweaked physical constants, according to the current speculative multiverse theory. But I am not referring to those, which are more SF than fantasy.

Consider, for example, where physics includes a sort of macro entanglement (like quantum but at a higher level), leading to the evolution of low-energy PSI abilities (i.e. ones that use the amount of energy produced by a cluster of brain cells). This could give a basis for mind reading and control, direct control of genetics and development, and physical magic (*). But, just as with technology, scientific development would be needed for more than the abilities learnt in prehistory, and people would vary in ability.

Describing an advanced society based on that rather than our technologies would be a consistent, rational fantasy, but developing such a world would be damn difficult.

(*) People with the requisite ability could make tinder by chewing fibrous plants, drying the result, and then using their mind. But person A's tinder would not work for person B, and not everybody would be equally good.

The problems about string theory are that it is really a speculative meta-theory, and that it hasn't delivered any explanations or predictions commensurate with its generality. While I agree with "show not tell", I feel that anything based on it needs a lot more time describing its world if it is to be comprehensible.

You're right about Illuminatus,* but on the subject of how aliens will look/behave I think it's most likely that Earth is near the center of the Bell curve in terms of how life evolves. That doesn't mean they'll be remotely humanoid, of course, but I'd imagine a combination of sessile and non-sessile forms fitting another planet's ecological niches is probably a given. I'm not sure wildly different is actually a disadvantage when it comes to 'hiding among us.' If we don't recognize them as being alive they're pretty well hidden. And why not intelligent microbe colonies? That would be an interesting explanation for sociopaths, among other things, so there's plenty of room here, I think.

If you're looking to grow as a writer grabbing a handful of ideas you don't like and wrestling with them is probably a good idea. If you're looking for a good niche to colonize then you need to find something you'd enjoy.

* Re Illuminatus, your idea of 'budget 747s of usenet and the web' would just be another wrinkle, but I still get why you might not want to write them.

Well, of course it's most likely to be near the center of a distribution. You get that pretty much by definition.

Anyone who has ever built a Monte Carlo model can tell you how likely you are to get a good answer with a sample size of 1 though...

I don't even want to think about the dimensionality of the space of evolved intelligence and how probabilities are distributed across it, but I'm willing to bet it's not a well behaved narrow bell curve centered on us.

You're right about the sample size of one, but Charlie isn't doing science. It's perfectly reasonable for a fiction writer to make the assumption that Earth is near the center of the "Bell Curve" for story purposes without feeling like she/he/they did something wrong.

Space colonization from the other side may be interesting, with earth as target and humanity seen by the benevolent conquistadores as noble savages.

Not sure if it can be pulled off without hitting all the cliches but when it does not focus on the military and high-level political topics it may be a fun "what if" read.

What happens when Europe (or one of the other rich and powerful societies in the 21st century) are on the receiving end of a future shock like the Aztec Empire when they first met horses, fire arms and christian preachers?

I am less interestend in the MilSF part with all the ammosexual kitsch and more on the cultural impact (what is the Coca Cola analogon the aliens bring? how does a cargo cult work in the internet age?), the initial setting shouldn't be a confrontational one; crossing light years only to plunder is .. stupid.